[Music]
brought to you by the every dooll app
start budgeting for free today I'm on B
step two um getting ready to liquidate
my after tax investment account clean
out my savings besides the uh $1,000
baby emergency fund to attack some
personal loans my question to you is um
would it be worth it to uh take a loan
out of my 401k just to clear out all the
person loans uh since the interest on
the 401K loan is essentially paid to
myself
yeah
no um how much debt do you
have uh personal loans about 22,000 and
then student loans about 30,000 okay and
how much are all these after tax
Investments going to create when you
liquidate
them uh only about 6,000 and another six
or seven in savings
okay so brings your debt down to 40 do
that from from 52 yeah so you got 40,000
in debt what's your household
income uh right around 155 before tax
good okay all right the problem with a
401k loan is several fold one is yes you
do pay yourself back the interest but
you
unplug that portion of the investment
from the mutual funds that would have
been earning you 12 this year maybe even
more percent so maybe you would have
made 15 but you paid yourself five
instead uh bad idea number one number
two when you leave the company and you
will leave the company uh when you die
when you get a better job or when they
fire you you will leave the company okay
uh and if that loan is still in place at
that time it's becomes due in full if
you do not pay it off in 60 days it's
considered an early withdrawal with all
the taxes and penalties so that is
leaves you very very vulnerable it's a
really bad
loan um and so and you still got $40,000
to pay off regardless of what we do
making 155 what you ought to do in what
like a
year yes if I will yeah if you do if you
get on beans and rice rice and beans and
you tear into it it sounds like you've
studied our stuff and you're doing you
know you're cleaning out everything you
$1,000 you're going to stop adding to
the 401K yes I would do that uh but we
never tell people to borrow on a 401K
ever I don't even offer the borrowing
option to our team couldn't do it if you
wanted to here which is good stop people
from not available just not available
just cuz I'm not going to participate in
you doing something stupid it's that
simple so um the uh but no I I that's
the problems with it is you you're going
to get you you just leave yourself very
very vulnerable as opposed to a regular
loan so to speak I mean if you went and
got just another loan at the bank for
40,000 and paid off and cleaned them up
but you've got one big loan Instead at
5% you know that would be okay because
you don't have all these other problems
you didn't unplug an investment that
might have made you 12 or 15 and you
didn't leave yourself open to penalties
and taxes in the event you leave that
particular position so um because other
I mean pretend somebody came along
offered you double income you got to
think about not taking that CU you got
these golden handcuffs that you've
created yeah that's that's what people
do they oh I I was going to take that
better job but then I had borrowed them
my 41 and I was going to get
hammered so yeah that that's what you
don't want to do Gordon so but this has
gone in less than a year I mean if you
make 155 after taxes let's call it you
know 110 you can live off 60 and pay off
50 in a year and so it's gone yeah it's
a $4,000 and you're probably going to
add to your income and you're probably
going to find some other stuff to sell
maybe it's 14 months maybe it's 15
months maybe it's 9 months I don't know
but it's somewhere in that range it's
not a not not a fiveyear issue and I
wouldn't put all of this other stuff at
risk for that and so no I've never told
anybody to do that and folks it's a good
idea just aside from Gordon's question
let's just sidebar a second
George the thing that we have figured
out at Ramsey that a lot of people in
the financial world are now
acknowledging because we've made such a
big footprint in the space but but most
of the people when I was growing up in
the financial world we thought all this
was a math problem it's all about the
math well hey the interest is higher
here why wouldn't I do this with lower
interest all I got to do is fix the math
and I'm going to be okay and what I've
discovered in 35 years of doing this is
it's not a math problem it's a me
problem it's 80% personal finances 80%
behavior and
20% head knowledge now why does that
matter well if you fix the math and you
don't fix the Behavior you're going to
be right back in the soup that's why
debt con solidation doesn't work that's
why we call it a con because you move
all your debt from one place over to
another into one big Loan in this case
he's using a 401k to do it now in his
case it doesn't apply because he is
actually changing he's he has changed
what he's doing he's cleaning out these
savings accounts he's thinking about
this he's doing a budget you can hear
Gordon's really focused right so this is
not this is this particular part of the
discussion does not apply to Gordon okay
cuz I think he's beyond that he's
willing to make the a lot of people that
have called me over the years that want
to do a debt consolidation loan I want
to move my debt over here first thing is
the out out of the abundance of the
heart the mouth speaks the Bible says
and they say I paid off my debt with the
debt consolidation no you didn't you
moved it you put it in the drunk drawer
you didn't pay it off but what that
tells me is is you took the pressure off
of yourself and it's now
okay cuzz I paid it off no you didn't
you moved it and you still got the
problem in your
mirror this person is still not handling
money this person is still spending
money like they're in Congress they're
not on a written plan this person in the
mirror is still impulsive this person in
the mirror is still not working with
their spouse they're still not thinking
longterm they're still doing a bunch of
other stupid stuff and so the debts
going to grow back and we know from the
debt consolidation industry that 88% of
you that's nine out of 10 that take out
a debt consolidation loan your debt
grows back after you move it so you end
up with twice as much debt because you
don't change the behaviors habits
character issues that cause that in the
first place yeah and these are these are
all shortcuts at the end of the day and
it feels like you did something when you
take a shortcut but the problem is like
you said you're going to be right back
where you started when people do these
401K loans or the Helo or whatever the
move is they actually end up in the same
place they were a year from now yeah cuz
the same person and you've got to
transform if you want to see different
results yeah and so you know same thing
happens with your marriage okay how many
times you know somebody and I know
people because I'm again you go through
enough life you see this but I know
people who um are in a marriage and they
have a certain set of behavior problems
in their
relationship they get divorced and go
marry a new person with the exact same
set of issues and they didn't fix their
own ISS issues so they D they just do it
again because they thought that they
thought the problem was that person and
it wasn't it was the issues that were
not addressed the core things that were
not addressed and so yeah you the
problem is you take you with you when
you do all this stuff and me too I'm the
same thing so the the beautiful thing
that happened when Sharon and I went
broke was we didn't have a choice we had
to change we didn't have any food
electricity was cut off we had to change
we had to address the Ridiculousness of
our decision-making paradigms our our
ridiculous set of assumptions our stupid
intellectualizing uh rationalizing
ridiculous Financial concepts with my
intellect that absolutely caused me to
lose everything cuz I'm an idiot you
know I had to face all that I didn't
have a choice you ran out of shortcuts
there was no I was everything was gone I
just left with this mirror you know and
I'm stuck with me and I'm like God you
you are a problem and that but the
beautiful thing about something that
dramatic and traumatic is you you you
come away from it changeed you don't
have a choice when you guys are just
kind of everything's okay and nothing's
smacking the crap out of you to get your
attention you don't have to face it and
so our job here is to keep you from
having those extreme experiences instead
letting you choose to face it rather
than all your choices are taken away
yeah be the preventative medicine that's
how this whole thing Works guys that's
why this Ramsey stuff works is we have
figured out P the guy in your mirror the
gal in your mirror is the problem that's
the bad news the good news is they're
the solution create your free every
dollar budget today the simplest way to
budget for your life