🔵 A Documentary by The Epoch Times, reveals the truth that has been hidden from the American people.👉 https://ept.ms/3cTR1zF
-
Certain Western media outlets are publishing content in line with propaganda from a tyrannical regime: the Chinese Communist Party. At the center of that problem is the New York Times—at least when it comes to a major human rights violation, committed against practitioners of the Falun Gong spiritual movement inside China.
A troubling agenda revealed certain Western media outlets are publishing content in line
with propaganda from a tyrannical regime, the Chinese Communist Party, at least when it comes
to a major human rights violation committed against practitioners of the Falun Gong spiritual
movement inside China. And at the center of that problem, really unfortunately, is the paper of
record, the New York Times. Why was this journalism so off the mark? And so here was the leadership
of the New York Times meeting with the leadership of the largest tyrannical communist regime on
earth. Watch our exclusive interview with Levi Browdy, Executive Director of the Falun Dafa
Information Center, this Saturday on NTD 11 a.m. Eastern Time. Welcome to China In Focus. I'm
Tiffany Meyer. Today we're going to talk about a new report from the Falun Dafa Information Center
regarding how the New York Times repeatedly failed to cover atrocities against the Falun
Gong spiritual movement and amplified the Chinese Communist Party's propaganda.
We have in our studio Levi Browdy, Executive Director of Falun Dafa Information Center.
Levi, thank you so much for joining us. Thank you for having me.
So in terms of this report, it's over 40 pages. Why publish it now?
So this year marks the 25th anniversary of the persecution of Falun Gong in China.
And so in addition to what we normally do, which is look at that persecution and try and expose it
to the world, we're also taking a look at those 25 years and looking at some of the more impactful
trends, some of the more disturbing lessons that we've learned in this persecution. And emerging
from this quarter century of persecution, one thing that's been very disturbing is the coverage
or lack thereof in the Western press of the Falun Gong human rights abuses in China. And at the
center of that problem, really unfortunately, is the paper of record, the New York Times.
And so we did a deep dive into their coverage, the kind of things they were looking at,
stuff they missed, because it played an enormous role in maligning Falun Gong really worldwide
and completely obscuring, sometimes completely missing, what was happening in China. And we
thought that that is not only an important thing for the Falun Gong community, but it's really
important beyond the Falun Gong community to look at what happened there. Why was this journalism
so off the mark, and what could we learn? On that note, why was it so off the mark? Did the
New York Times change the way they covered it, or what exactly was the root issue here?
Well, what we saw is the New York Times was pretty much off the mark from the very beginning. And in
fact, the first few years were among some of the more disturbing in terms of how they covered
Falun Gong, the way they framed Falun Gong. And we contrast that really with some of the work
of the other major media papers, particularly The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post.
So if you look at, for example, 1999 to 2002, which was the first three years of the persecution,
The Wall Street Journal was busy on a series of 10 articles that would win them the Pulitzer Prize
for exposing the persecution of Falun Gong. The Washington Post had a series of groundbreaking
articles where they were really the first ones that said, oh, you know, this persecution
is really coming from the top man in the Chinese Communist Party at that time,
Jiang Zemin. Or this persecution has torture as part of the mandate from Beijing. All that
was uncovered by The Washington Post. So while these two papers are generating this sort of
groundbreaking work, The New York Times coverage of Falun Gong, first of all, was taking the lead
from the CCP itself in terms of how to frame Falun Gong and how to talk about Falun Gong.
And worse yet, I mean, one of their, I would say, big events of those first few years is the publisher
of The New York Times flew to China and met with Jiang Zemin, the leader of the CCP at that time,
the man who had architected the persecution against Falun Gong, as The Washington Post had
disclosed a year earlier. And so here was the leadership of The New York Times meeting with
the leadership of the largest tyrannical communist regime on earth at a time when they were what many
scholars and some lawyers call engaged in the genocide against Falun Gong. So those first few
years were particularly disturbing if you look at what The New York Times is doing and not doing.
You mentioned, say, The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post and their critical coverage
of these human rights abuses happening inside China, especially against the Falun Gong.
What was The New York Times saying then if they even met with Jiang Zemin? What were they saying
when it came to Falun Gong? Well, a few things I would point out. One is a really disturbing
factual inaccuracy. And so in 1999, if you look at the coverage, including The New York Times,
everybody was saying there's 70 to 100 million people practicing Falun Gong in China, and they're
referencing a government survey, which had come up with those numbers. Shortly after the persecution
began, suddenly The New York Times, without explaining why the change or why it even
differs from their own reporting just a few months ago, changed that number to 2 million and said,
oh, there's only 2 million Falun Gong in China. In addition to that, they sometimes reference the
number 70 million, tens of millions, but then they change the source of that and say, oh,
that's just claims by Falun Gong that no one can really substantiate. So it's very disturbing
that they would not only get the facts wrong, they not only contradict their own reporting,
but then they try to spin what was the real number and give it to a completely different source.
So that's just one example of many, many examples where factual inaccuracies got into their reporting
and propagated out from there. It seems when we look at the coverage of Falun Gong by The New
York Times, often you see the terms evil or cult, which sounds very similar to what the Chinese
Communist Party calls it. What did you find out in terms of that and maybe why The New York Times
was towing that party line? So that was another disturbing aspect because yes, when the Chinese
regime started the persecution of Falun Gong, they weren't using that term. They didn't really
know what they were doing and they sort of stumbled into a public relations nightmare.
Months later after the persecution started, they realized, oh, we need to have an excuse to the
world. So the regime started using that term, the cult term. And of course, a lot of the media were
reporting on that, that they were using it. What's disturbing of what we found in The New York Times
is they seem to really internalize that idea. And so in some of their reports, they're not using
quotes or attributing it to the Chinese regime. They're saying it themselves in their own voice
as fact. And so that was one of the more disturbing things that we found is not only
were they following the CCP framing in terms of what is Falun Gong, what are the teachings,
what are the beliefs, but they were internalizing it. It appeared from their reporting.
So it sounds like, as you're mentioning, this is a pretty ominous start to The New York Times
coverage of Falun Gong. Has that changed since then in terms of their coverage?
Well, we looked at over almost 160 articles that came out for The New York Times from 1999 to the
present day. And what we saw was really three phases. There was that first period where that
was really disturbing in terms of how are they recovering it. Then there was a period from about
2003 all the way through to really up to 2016, 2017, where there's virtually no coverage. There
was one notable exception by a reporter there by the name of Andrew Jacobs, who did a quality piece
on what was happening in China. But besides his work, virtually nothing. And so this is sort of
this deafening silent time period. This third time period, I would say, with sort of the last six or
seven years, The New York Times really has taken a very hostile tone to the Falun Gong diaspora
around the world and affiliate organizations. They seem to be on the attack where they're not only
regurgitating the old CCP framing in terms of the character of Falun Gong and what we're doing,
but they've upped the ante a little bit. And it's gotten more hostile and more attuned to
kind of hot button issues in the West in terms of trying to convince, it seems, their readership
that there's something really wrong with Falun Gong and they're not to be trusted, as opposed to
there are still tens of millions of people in China being violently persecuted. And that's
really a real story. They take not only the old, the original CCP framing of Falun Gong,
but they're sort of attuning it to the Western world. I want to give you an example.
One of the recent New York Times pieces that was covering, I think some of the, it might have been
the Epoch Times, but they made a lot of reference to Falun Gong. And one of the references they
cited is that Falun Gong is racist because it prohibits interracial marriage. Now, this is
important because this is a propaganda talking point that this Beijing put out at about 2009,
2010. Notably, they only put this propaganda out in the West where they know that talking point
is a pertinent issue. It's not in the propaganda against Falun Gong domestically inside China.
Also notably, it's demonstrably false. If you go into any Falun Gong community here in the
United States, around the world, there's interracial marriage, interracial children.
It's completely a non-issue. It's totally fabricated. But the New York Times sought
to sort of cite that as they do other sort of unsubstantiated or demonstrably false things
to kind of paint an entire picture that Falun Gong is somehow strange and weird and extreme.
And so they've taken the cult narrative that was domestic in China from 20 years ago,
and they've updated it. And they seem to have weaponized it to try and go against Falun Gong
and Falun Gong related initiatives here in the United States and around the world.
Why is the Falun Gong such a thorn in the side, if you will, to Beijing to the point that they're
trying to get their propaganda into the biggest media in America?
Well, if you look, Falun Gong really is a third rail issue in China. And there are a couple reasons
for that that have evolved. For the first few years, it was the third rail issue because the
top man in the country, Jiang Zemin, who was the chairman of the Communist Party,
personally mandated it. This is what the Washington Post uncovered early on. And so
it's very clear that anybody who cares about their political career or even their business
is going to toe that party line. So that's why Falun Gong was really the third rail issue for
the first few years. But over time, Falun Gong inside China has developed a massive grassroots
network that is peacefully yet determinately exposing the CCP to their neighbors, their
friends, and everybody. So it's become this tremendously potent voice for exposing the CCP
crimes to the people of China. The Falun Gong diaspora is a similar story. If you look at the
Falun Gong projects and initiatives and affiliate organizations around the world, they represent
a huge voice in warning the world, not just about the persecution that we have faced,
faced in China, but the threat of the CCP globally. So I think now Falun Gong remains
a third rail issue because in the CCP's mind, it's an existential threat. It's one of the
strongest voices, one of the most visible actors on the world stage exposing their dirty laundry,
and that's something they don't want to see. So it really is a third rail issue. And then the
question becomes, well, if it's a third rail issue for the CCP, why does it seem to be somewhat
of that for the New York Times? There's a convergence there of goals that I think is
very troubling. So you mentioned earlier with the New York Times head traveling over and meeting
Jiang Zemin right in the midst of this persecution, the Epoch Times article dives into the
vested interests of the New York Times, whether that's money or setting up more bureaus inside
China as a potential reason why we're seeing that. But switching gears a little bit right now,
if you look at a lot of headlines, the Uyghurs or the ethnic minority group are dominating
headlines. What have you found in terms of how the New York Times covers the Uyghurs
compared to, say, the Falun Gong? We get that question a lot and actually we delve into that
into some length in the report, because if you look at, let's just look at three different groups
in China that we know are being horrifically persecuted, Falun Gong, Uyghurs and Tibetans.
Well, if you look at Uyghurs and Tibetans, they get a significant amount of coverage in China
from the New York Times. So clearly it looks like New York Times is dedicated to exposing human
rights abuses in China. But with Falun Gong, it's very, very different. It's treated as a third
rail issue for the New York Times as well. So why is that? Well, there's a few things that we point
out in the report. One is there tends to be, or there seems to be, a pattern of secular bias at
the New York Times. Whereas Uyghurs and Tibetans are ethnic minorities, Falun Gong really is only
defined as a faith group. So that's one picture. And I think the other thing we have to look at
is, again, from the CCP's perspective, exposing the human rights abuses of the Uyghurs and Tibetans
is annoyance. They obviously don't want that, but it doesn't represent a significant threat. Whereas
Falun Gong is the Chinese people. You can't separate Falun Gong. I mean, 70 to 100 million
people among the Han Chinese throughout China. And so it's really a third rail issue for them.
And so anybody who's interested in keeping in good graces with the Chinese government,
with not getting kicked out of the country, or at least maintaining some sort of access,
because I know a lot of the media over the years, they get kicked out. They'd be invited back in.
It's a back and forth. Anybody who's interested in trying to maintain some access to China
has to stay away from the Falun Gong issue. And that must be coming into play.
And just to give you an example of what that looks like, if you looked over the last,
I think it was, we looked at the last 14 years in the coverage of Uyghurs and Falun Gong,
there are 27 op-eds in the New York Times about Uyghurs. I think seven or 10 of those were penned
by Uyghurs themselves. For the last 25 years, there's not been a single op-ed in the New York
Times by a Falun Gong practitioner. Wow. And given these 25 years,
what was the conclusion of your 40 plus page report?
The conclusion is it's undeniable there is a Falun Gong exception within the New York Times.
It's undeniable that there is a significant effort to distort the beliefs, the practices
of the Falun Gong faith community. It is undeniable that there is a lack of coverage of
horrible human rights abuses over 25 years, even as the major human rights groups, even our U.S.
Department of State every year is documenting human rights abuses against Falun Gong.
So this is a catastrophic failure of international reporting on the New York Times.
So the question is why? Now, that's not something we necessarily can answer. We're not in the back
rooms of the New York Times. We don't understand all their dealings. We're not privy to that.
But I think it's important to understand the demonstrable trend, not just for the Falun Gong
community, but we rely on the New York Times and other papers to inform us about important
things of the world. And if they're getting this story that wrong on Falun Gong, what might
they else be getting wrong? And I think it's important for people to realize that, to recognize,
OK, we need an answer to this question, because if we can't answer why the New York Times has
done this to Falun Gong, how can we trust anything else that they report?
Kind of in a hypothetical, what would have happened if the New York Times from the very
beginning was critical of the regime when it comes to the persecution of the Falun Gong?
It's a great question and a tough question to answer. We know from our human rights work on
the ground for the last 25 years that attention works. When policemen that are holding practitioners,
perhaps torturing them in a labor camp or a prison camp, when their crimes are exposed to
the world, they get scared. They stop. Sometimes people are released. We know that works.
So if more attention had been paid to this persecution, to not only reveal the persecution,
but to sympathize with the victims, not paint them as some strange unworthy victims,
but to let the readers understand what is really the life of a Falun Gong practitioner inside China
and the threat they live in, the real examples we've seen of people being, their persecution
lessened, the torturing stopped, sometimes being let out of prison, that could have been magnified.
Who knows how many times, tens of times, hundreds of times, had the New York Times really brought
to bear the full credibility and platform that they had to expose what's going on with Falun Gong
in China. And I think it's almost impossible to measure that, but it is obvious it would have been
significant in terms of saving an unlimited, or in terms of saving an enormous amount of suffering
and perhaps even lives, not just for the people that are there, but for generations.
We did see instead the New York Times even saying that some of these practitioners said they had a
better life in prison than back home, which would make people here in the West be like,
you know, maybe it's not so bad. So that does sound like it would have been very different.
Taking a step back here, what are you hoping the outcome will be, following this report or,
you know, anything? Well, I mean, just to speak personally for a second, I mean,
the New York Times, perhaps like millions of families around America, that was a staple
of our family home. It was always on the dining room table growing up. And so that has always been
an important reference for my family, for my community. So it is enormously disappointing and
sad to see what has happened to Falun Gong. I think the most important thing now, or the thing
we're hoping for, is we learn from this. I mean, if I was at the New York Times and this study came
out, I hope there's some soul searching. You know, again, we can't say why that they're doing this,
but the facts that the results that they achieve are in line with the goals of the largest,
most tyrannical communist regime on earth should give the New York Times pause. What happened here?
What is going on that that is what we're achieving? I hope it engenders some sort of soul
searching and some change at the New York Times and other papers that might be suffering from
the same kind of problem, looking at their operations, looking at what they're doing,
look at the spirit of what they're trying to achieve as the fourth estate and saying,
we have a problem, let's fix it. And what would be your message to those people who are finding
out now through this report or through this interview that, oh, the New York Times covered
the Falun Gong wrong since the beginning. Where can they go if they want to learn about the Falun Gong?
Well, the first thing I would do is send them to our website. So the Falun Dafa Information
Center website is faluninfo.net, which is F-A-L-U-N-info.net. There you're going to find
enormous amount of documentaries on the persecution, on what Falun Gong is.
You're going to find reports. You know, again, we get every single day, we get a dozen reports
from people inside China, all over China, documenting exactly what's happening in their
neighborhood, in a prison camp down the road. We're getting that, we're analyzing it, we're
publishing that. So I would go to that website and that's where you're going to get the real
story of what's happening to Falun Gong, certainly in China and around the world.
What an insightful conversation with Levi Browdy, Executive Director of Falun Dafa
Information Center. Thank you for joining us for this special report.
Please join me for China In Focus right here on NTD News. See you soon.