Rules Committee Hearing on H.R. 3602

HouseRules
23 followers
Apr 18, 2024
a
color rules committee to order evening thank you for joining us
this evening destabilized our national security in that of our
the world has gotten more dangerous on his watch not less
indisputable House Republicans are committed to safeguarding
Partners from The Fallout of This president's keeping with
that commitment the rules committee will consider HR the
Border catastrophe Act President Biden has created in our
Southern border there have been more than
that are Southwest border in on two million
our country for context Jay Security under the Obama
Administration believed that a crisis we are will pass that
the Biden Administration we've illegal immigrant encounters and
our Southwest border did not need to happen and it did not
happen in a vacuum over 60 rash choices that
decisions to stop the Border while Construction in Mexico
program of President Trump how America's national
illegal immigrants are being released more than 20,000
Chinese Nationals far and at least
to an illegal immigrant admitted
but how many of his it entered our country the Biden
Administration all of us this
it continues to fuel retail theft rings to outright murder
us on our districts have dealt with but recently
her whole life ahead of her traveled here
Rule and dangerous Biden Administration has proven time
in defending our own borders of Duty House Republicans must
continue to step the bill before us today
measures it border wall
and ends transparency for the Department of
the Asylum process for Texas
of the financial and human costs that should be borne by the
open agenda Biden House Republicans
mail deliver on that obligation
McGovern for any remarks he wishes to
make I don't even know where to begin
everybody knows Democrats
or should I say the most right-wing members
a way in the house Tanked
that's just a fact but let me let me me let
this hard it is clear
that the house Republican leadership is absolutely
floundering
you know you all talk a lot about Joe Biden's leadership
give me a break
you're on your second leader this Congress and he's one bad
day away from losing his job instead of acting quickly and
decisively GOP leaders are scrambling
easy vote once again
will take to get their conference under control
I mean that's why we're here I mean flash for those who don't
remember hr2 already passed the house
it is already been sent to the Senate and it lost time
it only got 32 Republican votes and even if it did pass the
Senate
how this is supposed to show up
maggot members support for the foreign aid bills that we should
have dealt with
a while ago none of this makes any sense to me all complete
and colossal waste of but if we're being honest here Mr
chairman nothing
this majority has done has made any sense host Republicans are
an absolute train wreck
a total clown show the American people are watching our allies
around the world are watching and they are scratching their
heads and asking what the hell
to the Republican Party so I guess I have a question before
we get to we have
three Republican colleagues on this who have told the Press
they plan to vote against the rule for the National Security
Supplemental
Roy called this Billy watered down cover vote do they
plan to support a role for this bill and I would yield to
anyone on Republican side who will tell us how they're going
to on the rule
you know we again I'm just going by what's in the Press several
of
the members of this committee have said they're not going to
support this I I you know I you know I maybe they they talked
tough in front of the press and they decide not to
show up to the rules committee but I'm just wondering is is
this a complete waste of time where we are we
we expected to report a rule or does anybody can anybody
answer me whether or not they image a little yes
the chair prepared is prepared to vote for the rule in ours is
of Republican members to vote for the rule
we always should support our procedure emotions and and you
have they will
I think you need to ask them yourself well they're not here
they're hiding right now but any event I don't want to belabor at
this point but yeah well yeah
I yeah well in that I mean I I'm pointing out the
obvious here I mean is this is not this is not serious this is
not real
this is a complete waste of I apologize to the two gentlemen
who were coming here to testify we're going through this
exercise again and this is not
about border security this is about providing some people
cover
which apparently may not be enough but with that I yield
back the animal back here thanks a gently first comments without
objection any prepared statements that are witnesses
may have will be included in the record and I do want to welcome
our first panel representative Tom McClintock
from California I'm ranking member Jerry Nadler from New
York from the committee on judiciary representative Lincoln
talk I look forward to your testimony thank you Mr chairman
as you all know on inauguration day our border with secure
president
Trump's policies including the remaining in Mexico program
it slowed illegal immigration to a trickle border wall was
nearing completion with only construction gaps remaining to
be closed and Ice was actively enforcing court ordered
sending a strong signal around the world that illegal aliens
would end up right back where they started so they stop coming
that afternoon President Biden reversed all of these successful
policies the first of more than 60 actions he
subsequently taken to undermine our immigration laws and open
our border and the results been the largest illegal Mass
migration in history since
that day the Biden Administration is released at
least million
illegal aliens into US communities these illegal aliens
have broken our laws to enter this country and while the
border patrols been overwhelmed another one point eight million
known godways have illegally entered as well now that's a
total population
of six and a half million illegal aliens in less than
three years that's a population larger than the entire state of
Missouri our 18th largest state with eight congressional
districts and just three years
that's been devastating a schools have been overwhelmed as
classrooms are packed with non English speaking students
hospitals have been forced
to shift millions of dollars of care from Americans to illegals
in Yuma
Americans are now very often sent to Tucson for maternity
care because the local beds are now taken by illegals the social
safety net
been shredded by the deliberated mission of millions of
impoverished illegals demanding free food clothing shelter the
number of terrorist suspects the border patrol is encountered his
ballooned exponentially and law
enforcement officials are warning that among the 1.8
million God always mostly single military-aged men
is likely a dangerous fifth column which could soon launch
devastating attacks within our borders
fentanyl brought in through the open border is killing hundreds
of Americans every day Democrats Sanctuary policies they're
hamstring the attempts to deport criminal illegal aliens and
worst of all the admission of UNT 12,000 vicious gang members
on the planet are now producing a terrible
butcher's bill of murders and assaults on Federal
judge described the Democrats policies quoted kin to posting a
flashing come in
we're open sign at the southern border and quote
hr3602 the end of the catastrophe Act would restore
the successful Trump
policies and remove the rewards and incentives the Democrats
have used to entice
people to violate our nation's sovereignty division a includes
Provisions in the homeland security committee's
jurisdiction that helps secure our border for instance it
includes Provisions to require border wall Construction to
increase number of border patrol agents and provide them bonus
pay and to deploy additional technology to the Border
division Provisions in the jurisdiction of the and Foreign
Affairs committee a
title one reforms the Asylum process to deter fraudulent
Asylum
claims from Aliens including economic migrants and assures
that aliens granted Asylum are truly being persecuted by their
government Article 2 ends the Biden
administration's Catch and Release policies by clarifying
that the DHS secretary must remove
or detain illegal aliens who arrive at the border or place
them in remain in Mexico type programs there are no other
options the aliens cannot be
paroled or otherwise released into the us is the Biden
Administration is doing
unless an Immigration Court grants the alien Asylum or some
other immigration benefit title 3 directs the of State to
renegotiate successful Trump policies
Asylum Cooperative agreements and their remain in Mexico
program with his diplomatic counterparts title four
fixes the disastrous florist settlement the rewards illegal
aliens who render by children deposes family units to avoid
detention instead it keeps legitimate
families together as they await adjudication to their Asylum
claims and detention or in Mexico
title five requires an unaccompanied child be
immediately and safely return to their home as we already do for
unaccompanied children from Mexico and Canada rather than
have them traffic to abandoned and exploited in our country
which is the administration's current policy
if a child shows
up it's your door you've got moral obligation to them safely
home not drop them off at a sweatshop or somewhere even
worse our eventually doing that right now and it is morally
reprehensible a title six
applies the same penalties for Visa overstays as we currently
to overstay a Visa title seven ends the circumvent immigration
law parole is inherently based on individual
by category isn't parole passed by Congress in a nation that
respects the rule of law but it hasn't 8 creates two Grant
programs the first to construct or improve border barriers and
Border technology for money spent on law enforcement
activities related to The Border the
resurrect respect for US immigration laws and
sure thanks to gentlemen from New York is chairman Burgess
ranking member McGovern thank you for the if at first you
don't succeed try again again the majority is bringing forward
a cruel piece of legislation
my Republican colleagues continued to show solutions to
tough issues this know this as it has brought up and
a mere 32 votes that's about this legit what this legislation
provisions of this bill serve as no one would be able to
of Entry or if they had we previously offered a variety
requirements and unaccompanied children
a year old codifying the vital
over given that
slim margins it is unclear that Republicans can even pass hr2
in this entirety today does not even include all of
worried was a big government program that would wreck our
economy in mind going on here
months saying that hr-2 was the only to secure the Border even
though they then
aggression Republicans even
to McConnell could not
Republicans said it out loud too saying they don't want to quote
do
to damn much to help a Democrat unquote folding to the
bill
page text of the bill was released speaker Johnson
declared the beat the bill Dead on Arrival in the house with the
rest of the Republican conference quickly
falling in line Republicans showed clearly what Democrats
have been saying over and over
version of hr-2 is being sent to the floor to give Republicans
cover
to vote for necessary aid for our allies Ukraine Israel and
Taiwan the speaker is
so desperate to convince his most extreme members to allow a
vote on this Aid that we are now here at an emergency Rules
meeting to debate a bill mere minutes after the text was
released so much for regular order if this political theater
and show vote of hr2 was what they need to pass vital Aid to
Ukraine Israel and Taiwan and fine
let's not pretend we accomplishing anything here
today
as representative Marjorie Taylor green said earlier today
we have already passed hr2 this is a waste of our time I yield
back
chair thanks again I want to thank both our Witnesses just a
couple of questions Mr McClintock can you
just revisit again the the grant Provisions that are included
in the language of the bill we have before the rules committee
tonight well I can
can't really elaborate on what you've already pointed out
that provides Grant programs for those communities have been the
most impacted by the federal government's
abrogation of its responsibility to maintain a secure border and
this is this is the responsibility of the
federal government and we do deal is very acutely in in Texas
because of the significant amount of dollars that have gone
forward under Governor Abbott's operation Lone Star program but
frankly this shouldn't be
necessary when we're at a of Texas in in January
of the Del Rio sector border patrol Chief said look
I am standing in front of an open fire hydrant with a bucket
I don't need more buckets I need somebody to turn off the hydrant
and that's what this admitted that's what Donald Trump
accomplished that's what this Administration is undone and now
it's not just the people of
the border states that are affected
because now we know as we've said states are now border
states and this is flooding into every community straining
resources and of flooding our with with everything from
Criminal aliens defense
and that was a pretty statement that was made last January I was
I was in the room as well not more buckets police during the
water off and we can can deal with the problem
look I don't know how it has gotten from
a border security discussion to an immigration
reform discussion but we need to secure the Border and that's
what this bill does and I
thank you for bringing it Forward tonight though yield to
the ranking member for your questions he may have I don't
have any questions this is not a serious effort tonight we've
been we've done already we know what the Sun is going to do I
mean and and my three colleagues who I know
many some discontent about what's going on here I mean we
can
end this hearing quicker I mean I I
if the three you vote no one this rule where then we're done
when
we so I don't see the point of questioning these guys on any of
this stuff but
let me I mean I don't Mr Roy I think you said call this a water
down dangerous Cover Vote I mean you to along with this are you
going to vote for this and I
want to add difference the chairman I want to follow the
proceedings of the chairman wants to set for the
hearing I think I'm pretty well public publicly not in favor of
direction that we're here but but I want to I wanted defer to
the chairman Mr Massey you could have vote for this or
I'll take my time when it's
yielded to me I mean I mean Norman you go to vote for this
no okay so I mean like if the three these
guys vote no we're not even going to get this other
committee so this is this is a waste of time
but I I have anything to add I just want to get the heck out of
here
this is General Neil back are you back here thanks
John from Pennsylvania's recognize famous chairman I
appreciate I want to thank both gentlemen for coming in here
tonight but for the sake of time I'm going to yield back
gentleman yields back to the from Pennsylvania
to live yields back the gentleman from Kentucky is
recognized
uh Mr McClintock when you first see the final text of this bill
was handed to me as I walked in was handed to you as who you
walked in
okay I yield back gentleman yields back
getting from Colorado I will say actually let me amend that
I actually I saw it as hr2 with the exception of the the fact
that hr2 included
to be why we've taken that out of the bill I don't understand
either
and the addition of the grant programs to meet
the needs of the local border communities but we you know
it's not as if this is some sort of new text this is what we
debated and passed
last year
and by the way just to correct the record my understanding is
the first Senate vote on hr2 was 46 yay votes
Rand Paul opposed it to Republican Senators weren't
there without
and and Rand Paul said he would support it without a verify so
we saw the Senators are there we should be up to about
40 and and Rand Paul votes for it that's 49 votes I'm not ready
to give
up on the Senate yet although the American people may be
willing to do that in 202 days
I'm not if he was
answered and that's the question but I would just ask that we
proceed with
the hearing forth with to spare the staff if we know the with
the outcome is gonna be so I yield
gentleman heals back get them from South Carolina
there's no questions generally from New Mexico
given the nature of this hearing
I will also ask no questions and look forward to our final vote
gently yields back gentleman from Texas I want to thank the
for coming here
I want to associate myself with the question Mr Massey asked
I'll ask one other question
that's relevant to that point which is the the
gentleman said he didn't see the text other than the fact we knew
is hr2 without he verify before he came in here there's a
provision in an amendment that would be made in order if the
role were to advance
the deals with States
and do you when did the gentleman see that Amendment
with respect to Stage being paid back that is brand new
the rest the world and and that that language
to the best of my has not gone through committee it's brand new
it's not a bill that's been introduced it's all just brand
new language yes this house is turned upside down since Robin
ostler died so
the only thing I'll add to that because I feel compelled to do
it is that as a as a representative of the Texas that
Amendment as I understand it we literally just got it
is designed to I think
provides some reimbursement mechanism to Border States I
support that concept
and I'm on the record supporting that concept of stage taking on
the chin particularly Texas
Texas spent something like 12 billion dollars and and Counting
so but to the best of my understanding it's like at about
9 billion that's out of
the covid slush fund of the Commerce fund about six billion
of which is prospective based on grants I haven't had any chance
to review what that looks like billion that could be but I have
no idea how that would apply and how it would apply to Texas
versus other States something that we should have a hearing on
decide I support the concept and the policy this is not the way
we should be doing business and I believe this is a part of a
larger effort to push something through for very political
expedient purposes that I'm on record disagreeing with as we
the speaker of the house has been on record saying that we
need border security before we deal with Ukraine just non-stops
since last November we are abandoning that approach I
oppose it and I this rule as part of that entire effort with
that I yield back the chairman actually gentleman gentleman
yields back because gentle lady from Minnesota which seek
recognition and the gentleman from Georgia's recognized
chairman I'm not sure if this is my first real roles committee
meeting I don't think the other two were real meetings that were
but
I listened the other I get you Mr Governor you now voting with
Roy on rules I don't know how he's gonna vote
I tell us I don't know how he's gonna vote I mean you know
I'll listen I'll listen to you the other day long and hard
about about something and then I'm watches you voted
the same way on that one I think I'm right
I mean I'm a little confused as the Broken Clock can be right
twice a day so
it can be right but let me tell you what's wrong you're correct
about another thing from Massachusetts
and let me tell you what's right let me tell you what's wrong
legal immigration is an asset to this country people who come
here legally and through the system or an asset as a country
who come here are liability to the country and the the of
illegal immigration that the Democratic Party supports the
people it's most unfair to is the people who come here legally
who want to experience the American dream and so I don't
understand
if if 8 million is not enough to come here illegally in the last
four years how much is enough I mean
is what is the number that the party thinks is enough illegal
immigration and we're watching them yeah are you Mr government
what's the number that the Democratic party
thinks is enough illegal immigration you miss
characterizing the position Democratic party and I would say
that in the United States Senate Democrats came together with
Republicans on a pretty immigration bill that well you
know what I mean I you could disagree with the Conservative
Republican Senators who supported it but the bottom line
is please don't don't miss characterize
the position we are here today to rehash an old bill right with
some changes on it we know why we're here we're here because
you're trying to figure whether you get some votes on the
Ukraine package and so that's why we're here and I'm just say
you could bring whatever you want to bring to the floor
you're in charge I'm just simply saying if you're not gonna bring
it to the floor let's not be labor this evening that's all
right yield my time back to the chair I would just tell you
that legal immigration is an asset to the United States of
America in illegal immigration is a liability to the United
States of America and I do understand how anybody can think
that that is not a true statement well if I could just
point out if you're going to
tolerate illegal immigration there's no point to Legal
immigration fair enough I yield here thanks our Witnesses this
panel is
was that objection the committee
stands in recessed subject College chair do we know we're
coming back
we will communicate down information
