Rules Committee Hearing H.R. 529, H.R. 7888 , H. Res. 1112, H. Res. 1117 Part 2

HouseRules
23 followers
Apr 12, 2024
there are also not growing up about things
a colic committee on rules to order
this is a temporary gavel so I can break it if it necessary
before we begin tonight I want to thank ranking member McGovern
your
comments the other we're not lost on me I've had the pleasure
of serving on
this committee since 2013 which I realized is not as long as you
but I'm certainly grateful for the confidence and speaker
Johnson has demonstrated in asking me to take on this
this new opportunity
in a very much agree with the sentiments that were expressed
in our last meeting about how this committee has operated and
I want to know Mr McGovern and members yes it's my intention to
continue the spirit that Mr Cole had had established in the
tradition that has served us so well
I do want to rank welcome our newest member Mr Scott
as a member of the agriculture armed services and intelligence
committees
his perspectives are going to be important for this committee and
on a personal note I would also
I used to sit between two Georgians on this committee
several years ago and George has always bring of a valuable
perspective to the rules committee
and purpose of
our meeting tonight is earlier this week the rules committee
met and took testimony on four measures these are hr5
the extending limits of the United States Customs Waters Act
house resolution
11 12 denouncing a bite administration's immigration
policies house resolution 117 opposing efforts to place one
side of pressure on Israel with respect to Gaza
nhr 788 the reforming intelligence and securing
America Act
a measure to extend and reform title 7 of the foreign
intelligence surveillance Act to lower it out rule governing
debate for all four of these measures of now
like to turn to our ranking member and recognize him for any
comments he wishes to make
well thank you Mr chairman and let me just briefly say
congratulations on your on your new role and I look forward to
working with you to keep the traditions and customs of this
committee moving forward and continue to make sure that the
rules committee does our best to model decency
and decorum not not just where I colleagues in Congress but for
the American people as well we've served on this committee
for a while together and
have a great for the gentleman and I know we'll have a good
working relationship I also
as well want to welcome Mr Scott to the committee as our newest
member we have served on the agriculture committee together
for a long and I look forward to
continuing our spirited debates up here in the rules committee
so having said all of that let me just
say that I I can't believe what's happening you know
from our second rules committee meeting of the week
and it's the fourth time let me repeat the fourth time a bill
to reauthorize fisa has come before our committee I mean me a
break the American people
want Effective Government what my Republican friends are giving
them quite frankly
is a circus this is be this is the most ineffective incompetent
majority I think in American history full stop it has
been nearly an entire year an entire year almost says anything
that we
have done in the rules committee has gone to president's desk the
last it did happen
it was with Democratic votes Republicans have tried and
failed to pass their own rules seven times this Congress seven
times this house
has been at a standstill because of their infighting before this
Congress it had been
20 years since a rule failed it's been 50 years
half a century since we've seen this many rules go down and
Republicans have done it seven times one or two three
times Maybe that's just incompetence but seven seven is
a disaster
seven is paralysis it means it means weeks and weeks of sitting
around
doing nothing because Republicans can't get their
house in order and do their job and do the job that they were
sent here to do 19 Republicans voted against
a republican rule yesterday 19 including the member
that managed debate on the role I don't ever happened in the
history of the committee I mean
genuinely shocking to me this member voted for the rule in
committee
but then voted against it on the floor now I've heard of I was
forward forward before I was against it but but this is not
the rules
majority turn the keys over to someone who wanted to the car
during debate I think he even pretty close to telling the rest
of
the conference to vote no on the rule now I'm not actually I'm
not I'm actually
sure Mr story was aware of the power they entrusted him with as
manager of the rule he could have offered an amendment to the
rule on the floor to do whatever the hell he wanted to do
including rewrite the bill entirely and it might have
passed
can they pick to send to the floor to represent their
position the speaker's position couldn't even be trusted to do
no wonder are we can't get anything done
I mean this is crazy I've never seen anything like this in my
life
and here's some advice find out if your manager
supports the rule before you send him or her to the floor
manage the rule
and to waste all of our time to bring this rule to the floor and
let it fail
I mean does the whips office need to have an arithmetic
arithmetic teacher brought in and some testimony on this bill
three different times and instead
of running this place like professionals Republicans wasted
our time and for what they barely
changed the bill I mean it would be laughable if this wasn't the
United States House of Representatives and now we are
here for a fourth time so it would be funny if
it weren't turning the world's greatest deliberative body into
a circus but they are
all they care is silly sensors sham impeachments and partisan
brinkmanship and this is not what the American people want
and come November I believe is going to be
a reckoning around here anyone with two eyes and a brain can
understand what's going on
Republicans cannot govern
and voters across the country are going to walk into the
voting booth and ask themselves do they want the adults in
charge or not and accordingly and with that Mr chairman I
yield back my time
here thanks to gentlemen for his for his comments the chair will
now be in receipt of emotion from the gentleman from Kentucky
Mr Messi Mr chair
I moved the committee Grant HR
7888 the reforming intelligence and securing America Act a
structured rule
the rule waves All Points of order against consideration of
the bill the rule provides one hour of General debate
equally divided among and controlled by the chair in the
ranking minority member of the committee on the Judiciary or
the respective designees and the chair and the ranking
minority member of the permanent select committee on intelligence
or the respective designees the rule provides that an amendment
in the nature of a substitute consisting of the text of the
118-27 Shelby considered as adopted in the bill as amended
Shelby considered as read the rule waves All Points of order
order only those amendments printed in the rules committee
report each Amendment may be offered only in the order
printed in the report maybe offered only by a member
designated in the report Shelby considered as red Shelby
debatable for the time specified in the report equally divided
and controlled by the proponent and an opponent shall not be
subject to an amendment engine of the question the rule waves
All Points of order against the Amendments printed in the rules
committee report the rule provides one motion to recommit
the rule further provides for consideration of hr529 the
extending limits of US Customs Waters act under a closed rule
the rural waves All Points of order against consideration of
the bill the rule provides that the amendment and the nature of
substitute recommended by the committee on ways and means now
bill as amended Shelby considered as read the rule
waste all points of water against Provisions in the bill
as amended the rule provides one hour of General debate equally
divided and controlled by the chair and ranking minority
member the committee on Ways and Means or the respect of
designees the rule provides one motion to recommit the rule
further provides for consideration of H res one two
denouncing the Biden administration's immigration
policies under closed rule the rule provides that upon adoption
of this resolution it shall be an order without intervention of
any point of order to consider h-rez 1112 the rule provides
that the resolution shall be considered as read the rule
provides one hour of General debate equally divided and
controlled by the chair and ranking minority member of the
on the Judiciary or the respective designees the rule
further provides for consideration of H res 1117
opposing efforts to place one side of pressure on Israel with
respect to Gaza under a closed rule that upon adoption of this
resolution it shall be in order without intervention of any
point of order to consider hres 1117 who will provide that the
resolution shall be considered
as read finally the rule provides one hour of General
debate equally divided and controlled by chair and ranking
minority member the committee on Foreign Affairs or the
respective designees thank you very much the briefly recognize
myself to talk about the changes
made hr7888 in the rules committee print
the rules committee print changes the reauthorization
period from five years to two years
it also strikes the sunset provision contained in section
19c
as members may remember from our discussion on Tuesday
there were some confusion as to whether this section would
affectuate a permanent
reauthorization of section 702 as it now stands in current law
to a limbicuity the rules committee print strikes
the provision altogether is there any discussion or
Amendment to the Mr chairman it's gentleman from Texas
yeah I mean take a couple minutes to respond to the
ranking member
the fact the matter is nobody in real America gives two
rats rear ends about whether or not
votes on a roll main role goes down to
the floor and then votes on a roll nobody in America cares to
see the
continued perpetuation of what this body this Congress has been
doing to the American people for Generations
racking up 34 and a half trillion dollars of debt
endangering the American people wide open borders and all of the
that this Congress has been doing endlessly when
the American people here us talk about oh you know and what we're
doing
here in the they care what they want is for their civil
liberties to be what is do not have a government spying on so
I make no apologies for trying to work with the majority to
move a bill to the floor
through this committee get it down to the floor have a debate
on the floor and manage the rule representing
multiple views of the conference with respect to the concerns
about what is in that bill and including members of the other
side of the aisle who have
very real concerns because he had a bipartisan bill passed out
the Judiciary Committee 35 to 2
that was not put down as the base pit base text what we were
trying to move that bill through the perspective of going to the
floor to me was important
but when it was that fingers were being
put on the scale to stop the ability to have a warn Amendment
get a free and clear debate
so that the warrant could protect the civil liberties the
American people yeah
I didn't think the rule should move forward and the fact is the
most American people don't care about those procedures they want
to see the result so no
apology there's nothing written in the Bible there's nothing
written in the there's nothing Sacrament about
how this place is supposed to operate because what has been
doing in this body for far too long is not working it's just
not no matter who's
in charge no matter who's in the majority because this isn't
about shirts and
the American people are sick of shirts and this is about
questioning the regime in this town that wants to decide
through the intelligence community
that there's no way to do this stuff and that you can't
question
it that's what happened on the floor yesterday so now we're
trying to bring forward legislation that responds to
that with a shorter
time period so that we can see results of what happened so we
can see if the reforms that were
promised to work will actually work so they don't them in
process for five years so I'm not gonna apologize at all for
taking steps to guarantee that we have
two years instead of five years to protect the civil liberties
of Americans because it's not about shirts and skins it's
about the American people are you mr chair
gentleman from yeah that's right nice I said a gentleman Texas
I'm not asking him to apologize
I would just making a comment I think the American people do
care that
this Congress seems incapable of getting anything done at
all as I said at my outset nearly 10 months
before this committee which all consequential legislation goes
through
as reported a bill to the floor that has actually become law I
mean
I don't know maybe send you here to do nothing but
my constituents sent me here to actually help solve problems to
get things done I don't disagree
that there's there there issues regarding the feasibility and I
don't know how
you would I don't know how whether we would have voted the
same way on on some of these amendments I certainly support
the warrant Amendment but that's not the point we're just wasting
time and and you know to sit through
this is the fourth hearing to bring a bill to the floor and
have
a go down to me seems like a colossal waste of time so I I'm
asking the gentleman from apology I mean
the I don't know why the gentleman wanted to be on this
committee if he's not going to try to help move legislation the
floor but that's the decision that you're your leadership has
made but you know
I General can do whatever the heck he wants I would just
making an observation and apparently I got under his skin
but what that Mr chairman I yield back and have no further
coming thank you gentlemen
is there any other Amendment or discussion if not question
is on the motion from the gentleman from Kentucky all
those in favor taking five by saying hi
I always no no any of the chair of the have it the question is
agreed to
as for recorder vote recorded most is requested the clerk will
call the roll Mr Russian dollar hi Mr Russian dollar hi Mrs fish
Rock let's I Mr Massey
hi Mr Massey I Mr Norman Mr Roy Mr Roy
I Mrs Houchin Mrs Houchin I Mr Langworthy Mr Langworthy I Mr
Scott
Mr Scott I Mr McGovern no Mr McGovern no Miss Scanlon
Miss Scanlon no Mr news no
Miss Ledger Fernandez Mr Fernandez no Mr chairman chair
vote side Mr chairman
Hi Well Kirk will report the total aa's four days
in the eyes have it the motion is agreed to accordingly Mr
Massey
will be for the majority and Mr Goose for the minority
good choice
without objections the committee is adjourned of chair does want
to thank everyone
for their patience during this time
