Bain Capital’s Kei Chua on China Market Opportunities

Finance Fortress
301 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 20, 2024
The real estate crisis has shaken up China’s $13 trillion credit market, but also created opportunities for investors that can be patient, Bain Capital’s partner Kei Chua says to Bloomberg TV’s Yvonne Man and David Ingles. While some international funds have pulled out of China in the wake of the property crisis, many foreign investors may come back once some corporate debt restructurings are completed. “We need to see some satisfactory resolution before foreign investors want to come back and refinance high yield,” he says. “The government are doing the right thing, but they are doing it in increments because again trying to avoid the moral hazard.”
All right, let's bring in our first speaker now.
Why not?
Kee Chua, partner for Special Situations Investment
in Greater China and North Asia at Bain Capital.
Kee, you've been sitting here for a while.
Thank you so much for joining us and kicking off the credit
forum here in Hong Kong.
First of all, it's an interesting title
that you have.
Maybe you can introduce what Special Situations, what
your coverage is.
Sure.
Special Situations, as Bain Capital defines it,
really means flexibility.
What we do is we create bespoke capital solutions that
specifically target and address the needs of our counterparties,
meaning we borrow in the capital structure.
We borrow between terms and conditions
that may be akin to debt, such as covenants, maturity
profiles, governance structures, and then also
trying structure for equity convexity.
So if we're right, we get some upside.
And what that means is that creates a really interesting
risk-reward profile for Bain as well as the counterparty
because then they're actually getting specific capital targeted
for the use that they need.
Right.
And just to clarify as well, partly for our audience,
this is mostly in private markets.
Do you dabble as well in public markets?
We're pretty flexible.
Bain Capital's Special Situations is Bain Capital's most flexible capital
globally.
So we can be in NPLs.
We can be in private markets.
We can be in public markets.
And throughout Asia-specific, we are investing.
And how busy have you been so far this year,
Key, given where we are in the credit cycle?
And where are we in this credit cycle?
We've been quite busy.
We think it's a really interesting time to invest in China specifically
as well as in the rest of Asia.
We don't have hard targets by countries
because we're a patent agent platform, which
means that we're allowed to ebb and flow between markets
that we think are interesting.
And we're still very focused on China.
China is one of our core markets, as you mentioned.
Right now, we think the economic situation in China is challenging.
But it's understandable.
When you have 20-plus years of above-average growth,
you're going to have some hiccups now and then.
And because we are long-term players, because we believe
in the capability of the government to actually work
through some of the issues in the marketplace,
we think that it's very attractive and that there
will be a return to normalcy and stabilization in China
in the near term.
Right.
At the center of that, speaking of special situations,
the property market is in a special situation at the moment.
Where do you think we are in that story?
Property is a really large term in China.
It represents approximately 25% of GDP, maybe more.
And the way we define it is there's very different asset classes.
If you think about traditional property, residential, commercial,
we're in an oversupply situation.
We're in a situation where developers, frankly,
have been investing heavily into land banks, buying land,
and trying to grow them without the requisite demand in place.
And that property model, we think, is broken.
And that ultimately led to what we saw in the high-yield markets,
because they've been borrowing heavily a lot of times
from offshore markets and then using that to buy land banks,
because they were valued off of the number of years of land
bank that they had, eight years, 10 years.
The more, the better.
And the flip side now, can they deliver on those properties?
What we need to see is the execution of that.
And that's why the government has been coming
in to actually take projects off the land,
sell off projects so that we can deliver those projects to the buyers locally.
And obviously, we talked about this downturn
entering to this new phase, where you're talking about wind-up orders.
You're talking about liquidation, possibly, on the table as well.
In some ways, I mean, are you thinking that this restructuring
is a year-long effort?
Is it going to take months, years?
How is this all going to play out?
The sheer scale of the problem is actually pretty large.
And there is no quick fix.
I think the government's afraid of its moral hazard
by just restructuring the developer.
And so their approach has been, how do we take individual projects?
How do we find the projects that are attractive and work through those?
And when you do that, it's execution.
It takes a year to two years to build out a project.
And so by going in and taking each of these projects,
it's going to be a multi-year process.
You've been investing in China for so long.
And I'm just wondering, in this current cycle in the property market,
I think early on, you said you noticed signs of maybe something
was about to go south.
What were those canary in the mines?
So our team, we've been coming in China for almost 20 years now.
And so we have a large footprint on the ground.
We have three offices in China.
And our team is there every day with local networks.
And what we saw was exactly the situation,
where developers were buying land, participating auctions,
reaching successive highs on a per-square-meter basis
as they were buying things.
And what we also saw was a lot of ghost towns.
We saw a lot of property that was built where there was no demand.
And if you look at the high-yield markets,
the high-yield markets was dominated by Chinese property developers
that was borrowing cheaply from overseas.
And so we largely stayed away from that.
We thought, this is a leveraged situation.
And if there's a hiccup in execution, if there's a hiccup in refinancing,
the Chinese local banks have set limits in terms of how they were
going to finance these properties.
So it became an offshore and an onshore market.
And therefore, we just thought, this is not going to end well.
And what among those early warning signs
you think either still exist in the market,
or even if they do exist, where you have enough information to at least
be actionable at this point in time?
I think the supply-demand situation is still a problem.
It's not just in residential.
It's also in office as well.
We monitor rents in all the major cities.
Rents have been declining as people have tried to fill the space.
So you're seeing vacancy rates as well as rents still being soft,
soft particularly compared to what we saw in 21 before the crisis happened.
I mean, the sticking point still remains that key hurdle, which
is the physical market needs to turn around.
When do you think that's going to bottom in some ways?
And once it does, can credit markets bounce back?
And does that solve the problem?
I don't know when it's going to bottom.
But I do think that where we'll see it is as more and more of the projects
get delivered and executed on.
I mean, there's still a lot of buyers that haven't received their properties
yet, people that have put deposits down, their life savings for several years.
I think we need to see some movement in the restructurings of some
of these developers, the 23 names.
There's quite a few of them that have been in the process
for over a year, year and a half.
We need to see some satisfactory resolutions
before foreign investors are willing to come back in and refinance high yield.
We need to see some clarity and stability in the policies around property.
I mean, the government's doing the right thing,
but they're doing it in increments because, again,
trying to avoid the moral hazard.
I think that's going to be an important litmus test as to when
the property market starts to come back.
That's a good point.
Timing this thing is incredibly difficult, if not impossible.
And what are, not just yourself, players like yourself in the industry,
what is sentiment like?
What do you think people are watching very closely before they actually
pull the trigger?
And are we close to that point where you actually
might see big transactions start to take place?
Luckily, in the private space, and particularly with big capital,
where we have long term capital, it's patient.
We can wait.
We don't have to be the first to run and take on the extra risk.
In fact, I explained how we make our investments.
We're actually very bespoke and tailored.
I think the general market sentiment is that property
has been a challenging sector.
A lot of property funds and property corporates
have actually pulled out of China, saying they're not
going to invest further into it.
We think that's short sighted.
We want to be in China long term.
We've invested in there.
We have a lot of infrastructure and networks.
And that allows us to keep our ear close to the ground.
It may not be specifically the whole sector,
but it could be interesting projects or interesting geographies.
Real estate is about location, location, location.
And that's how we are tackling the situation,
trying to figure out specific sectors.
And real estate, for example, outside of traditional real estate,
we've actually been very active.
We've been investing into the infrastructure that
supports economic growth and domestic consumption,
things like logistics, warehouses, manufacturing workshops, data
centers.
Those are growing at above average rates.
Those are very stable.
They're specialized, so you have locked in tenants.
And so there are different markets within real estate
that we still find quite interesting.
On the residential side, I think it's
going to take some time because it's pretty commodity.
And you need to have that long-term capital that's
available before you can start to build these out.
We ended the last segment on just really what the key sectors still
remain in terms of residential.
That's still fairly iffy at the moment.
Industrial might be somewhere you're looking.
How much have you guys invested in China, special sits,
for the last few years?
Special sits, we've invested almost $2 billion
over the past seven, eight years.
And then as being capital in China, it's
been over $5.5 billion since we entered almost 20 years ago.
Right, and sort of within special situations, $2 billion,
where are your current interests right now?
So special situations, we're actually industry agnostic.
But what we do like to do is identify sectors and opportunities
in the marketplace.
And historically, we've invested into non-performing loans,
for example.
But we've also invested into, as I said before,
the infrastructure for domestic consumption,
so logistics, warehousing space, manufacturing workshops.
These are highly specialized assets that
are needed to facilitate the flow of commerce in China.
And you're following the policy tailwinds in some ways, too.
We're following the policy tailwinds.
And so we are avoiding certain sectors
that have policy headwinds.
But overall, we do like industrial.
We do like consumption and consumer.
And our team is constantly identifying
interesting industries that have strong cash flows, that
have stable cash flows and are growing,
and also the ability for us to really structure.
Because remember, we have the ability to be very bespoke.
And so we can come in and structure payment-in-kind type
securities.
We can structure back-end data equity convertibility.
So companies that don't necessarily
qualify for plain vanilla bank financing,
we can come in and create something
that really solves their problems and their needs.
And particularly in the real estate space,
it's actually required quite a bit of capital over the years.
And in situations like this market,
where they don't have ready access to capital,
it's a great opportunity for us to come in
and create bespoke solutions for them
and fill that gap in the market.
Right.
I'd talk a little bit more about that,
because that's quite topical as, I guess,
in many ways, the official push, or the push from officials
is really to try and get the money where
the money is needed, right?
And there's quite a big gap between the official banking
system, where you are with shadow financing players
like yourself.
So yeah, what are you guys busy with and studying at the moment?
So we're actually pretty comfortable
that the government has the right policies and execution
capability to remedy the situation.
So you just discussed the LPR.
They have quite a bit of policy room
in terms of cutting the LPR, cutting the reserve requirement
ratios, to create more liquidity in the system.
However, there's never enough liquidity in China,
because they're trying to grow, and there's
a lot of export-oriented business,
and there's a lot of capital needed.
And so our ability to come in and really provide
that capital at a much-needed juncture in the market
is actually really strong.
We made two new investments in Q4 in China,
pretty substantial check sizes, and we continue
to see interesting opportunities.
OK.
Do you want to talk more about that, or the check
sizes, or the transactions?
OK.
No, no.
OK.
No, I was actually going to ask a follow-up on,
you know, you talked about the LPR, right?
They've taken rates down substantially in China.
And I'm wondering, from your perspective,
has that brought down the cost of capital for clients
enough, in your view?
Well, generally, the people that we're dealing with
are not doing standard secured loans, mortgages.
And so it may be at 2%, 3%, but if you can get that capital,
you're not going to be talking to someone like me, right?
We're coming in and basically creating
bespoke solutions for them.
It's not necessarily going to be secured.
Again, private credit is pretty broad.
It could be senior secured direct lending,
like mortgages and secured.
Or it could be mezzanine and sub-debt,
or even convertible equity link-type securities.
Generally, we play in the latter half,
where we are looking for more alternative investment-type
returns and the ability to actually create equity
convexity when we're correct.
And so those that can have access
to standard senior secured lending
are more of the investment-grade side.
So do you expect deal flows to pick up,
especially in the distressed asset space?
Deal flow is definitely picking up.
In these types of markets, there's a lot of dislocation.
There's a lot of distressed assets.
There's a lot of mispriced assets.
Non-performing loans, or specifically
assets with debt against them that need to be restructured
and need capital to come in, are pretty interesting for us.
And if you have the local presence, the local team,
the capability, and the track record, and long-term capital,
you can create some really interesting
risk-reward situations for yourself.
Sounds like it's expensive to be your client.
No, no, so I was having a look at the high yield,
the Bloomberg high yield index coming in.
So we peaked at 32%.
I think we're now close to about 14%,
which might be just about some of the rates
you're alluding to there.
I guess my question is, when you look
at the offshore bond market, because a lot of that
also has to do with how things have frozen up in some ways
here, how long do you think before the offshore bond
space heals?
Is that a good way to put it?
I think investors are looking for a few things.
First of all, some more transparency
in terms of what's going on in the real estate sector.
We need to see some more restructurings taking place,
coming to fruition.
We need to see some more concrete data about economics,
what's happening in the environment.
We need some clarity in terms of government policies.
There's actually quite a bit of positive policy support,
monetary, fiscal policy, but that's trickling in
because of that moral hazard question.
And finally, we need to see some recovery
in the capital markets.
The geopolitical situation isn't helping things
because high-yield investors are generally
from the Western world.
And they've been burned.
They've been burned when their Evergrande bonds go from $0.100
to $0.02, $0.01 and 1.5.
I think people need to see those resolve themselves.
Then they'll have more capital to deploy back
into the marketplace.
So I think it's a multi-year issue, multi-year solution.
The bonds that they invested into
were structurally subordinated, had weak covenants.
And I think we're going to have to see a reset of that
if any new money comes back into the marketplace.
