Join my mailing list https://briankeating.com/list to win a real 4 billion year old meteorite! All .edu emails in the USA 🇺🇸 will WIN!
Does Penrose's model merely confirm the need for a God hypothesis? According to Stephen C. Meyer of the Discovery Institute, Penrose's phantom field is a purely mathematical entity that suddenly turns into physical matter, which is inconsistent with what we know physics does. Is there any other explanation for this than God? Find out in this clip of my conversation with Stephen!
Stephen C. Meyer is an advocate of intelligent design and helped found the Center for Science and Culture (CSC) of the Discovery Institute (DI), which is the main organization behind the intelligent design movement. Before joining the DI, Meyer was a professor at Whitworth College. Meyer is a senior fellow of the DI and director of the CSC.
Additional resources:
📢 Ownership of your health starts with AG1. Try AG1 and get a FREE 1-year supply of Vitamin D3K2 and 5 FREE AG1 Travel Packs with your first purchase 👉 https://drinkag1.com/impossible
if you permit these infinite Universe
cosmologies you also have this situation
where anything can happen for any reason
at all in some possible universe and it
ends up resulting in science destroying
consequences because you can't rely on
the uniformity of nature you can't make
predictions you can't make explanations
and you end up with bolman brains so um
I don't know if steinhardt agrees with
that but it's that's one of the problems
with those Destro exactly Steve it
destroys the testability it destroys the
meaning of the probabilistic measure
that you can assign and it's not even
clear what probability means in a
Multiverse you know what are the odds of
an event happening how do you define an
ensemble what is the notion of
philosophy here's an issue maybe Justin
for another time to discuss with Stephen
uh but what would if you have an
infinite number of universes um and not
only are the laws of nature have to be
finally tuned in the parameters the
speed of light the strength of gravity
but why not the laws of logic why not
the laws of mathematics could they vary
from Universe to Universe could modus
tolin could modus pins could all these
law laws vary from Universe to universe
but that's not Paul's objection um you
know a priori his objection is simply
that you can't make any predictions in a
Multiverse and anything you get could be
consistent with some other particular
set of laws or set of laws of physics or
laws of law so that's his objection uh
sir Roger Penrose has uh has has called
the fine-tuning issue and the and the
very low entropy State configuration
that Steven talks about in The Return of
the god hypothesis he calls that fantasy
and he calls and again he's one of The
Originators of of the singular theorems
with Steven Hawking the late great
Steven Hawking so these men not only
though the reason I want to point them
out is they don't only assil with slings
and arrows from the sidelines they have
constructed theories rival theories to
the inflationary universe that not only
solve the problems of cosmic structure
formation depicted on this uh on this
very uh very comly beach ball that I'm
holding up here very colorful uh but
they also they also um provide a test a
crisp test to falsify themselves in
other words they have a mechanism by
which they can be proven wrong whereas
we just established that the
inflationary Theory can not only not be
proven right it may not be able to be
proven wrong because not observing the
inflationary uh signatures is not
necessarily reputation of the Multiverse
or of the inflationary Theory itself so
both steinhardt and the Penrose Theory
have testable consequences and they
bothen to be related to the theory of
cosmic microwave background polarization
that is my team
specialty yeah I mean just briefly Steve
some commentary on those alternative
theories um and whether or not they have
an implic any any anything to say to the
the god hypothesis itself yeah I
certainly don't think they refute it um
in um penrose's model uh in fact both of
these these models involve they're
cyclical models where you get multiple
universes generating over time and uh
back in the
1980s when the oscillating Universe
which was a kind of precursor to these
ways of thinking was popular Alan Guth
showed that you know with whatever is
causing the expansion of the universe
the process of expansion is generating
disorder in entropy if you think of
blowing a lot of energy through a system
you're going to get a lot of disorder so
if you want to get another cycle out of
that you've got to find some way of
resetting the entropy to a lower level
but just making things more orderly
again so that you have more energy
available to do work and in both of
these new models this is still a problem
um in the Penrose model you have the
universe expanding for a long time and
out of a very old Universe you get U uh
a new universe arising and he posits a
field called he which he calls the
Phantom field that he alleges is capable
of making that crossover from our sort
of the dying MERS of our universe to a
new one but it has almost Godlike
properties and another one of his
colleagues at Oxford um Julian Barber
has commented on this and said there's
no this type of field has no analog in
any known physics because it operates
only in a particular time and in a
particular space and it has the ability
to reset entropy and it has the ability
to initiate a dramatic change of state
um in other words it sounds more like a
mind than a physical field and so it's a
interesting proposal and I'm I'm really
always open to evaluating and looking at
new such proposals and it may end up
being testable as Brian says but the the
um the mechanism that he proposes at
this point is somewhat is more than
speculative and it has these properties
that are contrary to our uniform and
repeated experience of physics itself we
don't know physical processes that can
spontaneously at just the right time and
just the right place reduce entropy
increase order and generate whole new
change changes of state and the
steinhardt model also has this same
difficulty a different he has the the
new universes arising at more at the
beginning of the after a big crunch and
he also requires a a univer an entoy
setting uh resetting mechanism and he
acknowledges that that it would involve
novel um interactions between the
different physical Fields so it's at
this point there's not a lot of
specificity there so I'm not sure it's
yet testable but it's
Sol whether it's the kind of
inflationary model or a kind of you know
mathematical model or one of these other
models for you none of them seem to be
able to escape the need for some sort of
information uh and you know to to make
it work pen interesting the Penrose
model has exactly the same character as
these Quantum cosmological models in the
sense that his his Phantom field is a
purely mathematical entity that suddenly
transforms into a physical entity
without explanation so you go from again
from math to matter and I think that's
inconsistent with what we know physics
does math is a conceptual reality so his
his it's interesting to me that the the
the kind of mechanism that he ends up
inventing to make that crossover has
Godlike properties and it it can reduce
entropy it's immaterial initially it
operates only at a particular time in a
particular place and it can generate a
change of state at that time and place
as as a mind could do by making a choice
so to me it's it's kind of interesting I
mean it might be it's certainly worth
exploring but it seems to me to kind of
reinforce the need for a god hypothesis
because of the causal profile he's
painting of the necessary The Entity
that he posits which would be necessary
to explain a new universe arising has
attributes that are more like agency
than like
matter Qui quick response Brian and then
we'll go to a break and we'll we'll try
and fit in something on fine-tuning as
well but yeah go for it
yeah I I I I tend to agree with Steve
the the only uh slight you know kind of
uh tweak to it is I would say that they
might not be um philosophically or
mathematically fully fleshed out but
they're currently falsifiable in other
words uh we can currently or imminently
with tools like my colleagues and I are
building on the high okama desert at
17,000 ft above sea level the Simons
Observatory funded by the Simons
Foundation we if we observe the
so-called twisting curling
pattern of microwave polarization that I
describe in losing the Nobel Prize is B
mode polarization that will be the death
nail uh for Paul steinhardt's model and
he candidly admits that uh that would
invalidate and uh eviscerate his model
so although the underpinnings of it uh
are not fully fleshed out of of course
you have to look at the sociology of
science it's a sociological field uh
even if you know some argue that
sociology is not a science but there's
still a sociology within science and and
there's a a tremendous amount of energy
that goes into Fields like string theory
and inflation and very little that goes
into Alternatives uh so uh so it's
remarkable how much uh he is extracted
from this incipit you know theory of him
and and very few others like Neil turo
and an Eis uh but almost very few others
have really picked up that mantle and
yet we can perhaps prove it wrong within
a few years uh with tech tools and
technology that my colleagues uh are
building currently and then and will be
deploying that's fascinating so and
Bully for the experimentalists in this
that actually hold feet to the fire with
some of these theories and say do they
work or not yeah that's
great