Masters of the Air –Why so many bombs in Episode 7? - Fact Checking the March 8, 1944 Mission

The Globe Quest
3 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 16, 2024
In Masters of the air episode 7, the 100th bomb group is sent to lead the 13th combat wing in attacking the VKF ball bearing works near Berlin. The video will address the accuracy of the clip. In particular did the episode narration match reality. My of the the channels views expressed concern too many bombs are released. This along with other items will be addressed. In short, the episode would need a few changes to match the post mission tactical mission documentation.
in this masters of the air episode 7
clip Rosy's bomber is attacking the vkf
ball bearing Works Factory near Berlin
the intent of this video is to address
the historical accuracy of the bombing
events as portrayed in this episode this
video is in part due to channel viewer
comments mostly regarding the scene
showing too many bombs dropped as an
unrealistic narrative all of the footage
shown is part of a 3-minute clip
publicly released on YouTube by the
Apple TV channel a summary Narrative of
the March 88th 1944 mission is shown on
this page from a Declassified eth Air
Force Narrative of operations key points
of the document are three bombardment
divisions were sent representing some 10
combat Wings dispatched to attack the
vkf ball bearing Works 470 bombers
attacked the plant 66 dispatch b7s made
up the 13th combat Wing the 100th Bomb
Group was chosen to lead the 13th combat
Wing since the 100th was to lead the
entire 66 plane wing it was issued a
special PFF
B17 a PFF bomber is also called a
Pathfinder bomber the PFF B17 was
brought in to lead the wing because of
its blind bombing radar system and
specially trained crew its ball turret
was replaced by an h2x radar a radar
operator station was added in the Radio
Room the h2x radar set is also called a
Mickey set and the radar crewman was
called the Mickey operator the advantage
of the path Pathfinder is that they do
all the navigation and bombing for the
entire Wing the Pathfinder can bomb
through clouds by targeting the aim
Point by radar if they arrive at the
Target and visual conditions exist they
will still be responsible for siding the
target for the entire Wing visually by
using the Norton bombsite alone bombing
by visual targeting is always more
accurate than by radar the Pathfinders
Bombadier will be the only bomber
sighing on the target the Pathfinder's
first bomb out of the bomb bay will be a
smoke bomb the other plane watch the
lead plane during the bomb run when the
lead plane drops his bombs the other
planes will drop their bombs none of the
other 65 bombadiers in the wing will be
using the Norton bomb s sites the other
65 planes bombadiers will be downgraded
to a toggle ear just releasing their
bombs when the lead plane releases his
bombs the 13th combat Wing looks
something like this the 100th Bomb Group
is represented by 15 bombers in
formation Colonel Bennett's Wing lead
Pathfinder is here Rosy's plane is here
in the high Squad
the position of the bombers within the
group is based on the Tactical mission
report the PFF lead is highlighted here
Rosie's plane is here on the right in
the high Squadron the 100th group does
not contain a low Squadron the 95th Bomb
Group is in the wings High position and
the 390th bomb group is in the wings low
position three Wings make up the third
bombardment group the 45th is leading
the bombardment group the 13th and the
trailing fourth it was the 45th that was
getting hammered in the episode and miss
a turn ah I can't get a shot at him
they're taking up the 45th I have green
green flares from Colonel Bennett ship
noted in the log that the 45th Wing
missed the turn for the IP we are under
Colonel Bennett's command turning with
him to the Target over the target was
attacked while the planes were ination
as discussed on this 100th Bomb Group
postm Mission narrative the bombs were
dropped by Pathfinder Q this page is
rosenthal's postm Mission interrogation
form from the March 8th Mission the
position of Rosie's plane in the
formation is circled here the formation
is marked with The annotation dropped on
lead visual primary Rosie like the other
planes within the wing all dropped their
bombs when the PFF lead dropped their
bombs this page from the postm mission
PFF lead ship statistical flak form
outlines of parameters of the bomb run
the bombs were released at an altitude
of 22,000 ft the plane was on a heading
of
240° the straight and level bomb run
duration equated to 60 seconds and the
bombs were released at 2:37 p.m. Target
visibility was good and unlimited this
is why the bombs were released visually
by the PFF plan's Norton bomb site the
radar was not needed a handwritten note
indicates the Mickey operator was
helpful through the entire trip this
clip shows Rosie's Bombadier taking
control of the plane siding the target
with the Norton bomb site and releasing
the bombs the clip does not reflect how
the bombs were actually released the
clip should show the Bombadier watching
the 13th swings PFF lead ships smoke
bomb drop and toggle release his bombs
when he observes the PFF plane smoke
bomb this would have been a great
audience teaching moment showing the
changing bombing tactics as the war
progressed such a missed opportunity the
bomb load out is listed on this 100th
bombardment group's operational
statistics report The Columns are the
plane's pilot Squadron aircraft tail
number bomb Loadout crew casualties and
planes battle damage Rosy's plane is in
this role all of the 100s B7 bomb
loadouts were 30 100lb class
incendiaries and 10 100lb class general
purpose bombs each plane dropped 40
bombs one of the b7s Bombay racks is
highlighted in this image from the
planes Bombay the four B7 Bombay racks
can hold up to 42 bombs this page
outlines the type and quantity of bombs
to carry during the mission since m17s
were not available the bombers were
loaded with 10 m30 100lb class general
purpose bombs and 30 m 47 incendiary
bombs the intervalometer will be set at
200 ft this load out is consistent with
the type of bombs expected for the
destruction of a light industrial
Factory as shown on this page from a
1944 Army Air Forces board document
titled joint Army Navy committee on
bombs and fuses for high altitude attack
on light industrial Factory an alternate
bomb load consists of 100lb general
purpose bombs mixed with m47 incendiary
bombs incendiary are Force multipliers
the effects of incendiary bombs on
factories is shown on this page from in
October 1943 chief of air staff
intelligence report titled Japan
incendiary attack data the British
studied the damaging effects of bombs on
Industrial plants and found that
incendiaries were five times more
damaging than high explosives on a per
ton basis incendiaries were found to be
7 to 21 times more damaging than high
explosive bombs when attacking Japanese
urban areas as discussed in the channel
previous videos a cutaway of the m30
100lb class general purpose bomb is
shown on this page from a 1947 us
explosive ordinance document the bomb
weighs 115 lb and is filled with 57 lbs
of TNT m47 incendiaries were used by b29
Pathfinders in the firebombing campaign
on Japanese urban areas they have great
Appliance Fire Starting capabilities and
are used for Target marking
characteristics of the m47 incendiary
bomb are shown on this page from a 1945
National research Council document
titled weapons data fire impact
explosion each bomb weighs 72 lbs and
are filled with 40 lbs of Napal each
Palm liberates 69,000 BTUs of heat this
image shows m47s ready to be loaded on a
B17 this page outlines the effects of an
m47 static burst from a 1946 National
research defense Council document titled
fire Warfare incendiaries and
flamethrowers the Napal covers a radi of
75 ft from the bomb's detonation 50
Globs of Napal will still be burning 10
minutes after detonation this chart
outlines the ballistic parameters of the
m47 the m47s time of flight from a
22,000 altitude drop equates to 43.3
seconds a single bombers incendiary
strike pattern should look like this The
Expelled napom flaming discharge will
extend to a diameter of 150 ft the
spacing of each of the 30 incendiary
bomb strikes match the anomer setting of
200 ft the bomb should strike along a
straight line each bomb will strike 43.3
seconds from release the total length of
the 30 incendiary bomb strike line
equates to 1.1 mies since 44 bombers
dropped on the Pathfinder and if they
all carried the same bomb load out we
should see a string of 44 and 47s
clustered around the Target or
1,320 m47 strikes that's 8,2 50 gallons
of Napal although the series has
embellished some scenes like the fighter
escort quantities they are under
representing the number of bombs
released I counted 27 bomb releases per
B17 they should be dropping 40 bombs
also to get the proper 200 foot bomb
strike distance the bombs need to be
released every. 53 seconds in this clip
they are released every 009 seconds they
are being released 5.9 times too fast
the bomb strike spacing will be 34 ft
and instead of 200 ft the release speed
in this clip has been slowed down to
match the inom setting of 200 ft in
summary bomb targeting was done by the
wing Pathfinder all other bombers in the
wing would just toggle release their
planes 40 bombs no fiddling with the
Norton bomb site the number of bombs
released is underrepresented 27 bombs
were released and it should have been 40
the bombs were released too fast they
should have slowed down by a factor of
5.9 again Apple had 16 technical
consultants and historians on staff to
get the details correct not sure why any
of these issues were not addressed any
one of them could have raised their hand
and said let's show 40 bombs released to
match the actual load out and slow down
the releases to match the intervalometer
settings if you've enjoyed these masters
of the air factchecking videos please
consider engaging by liking Andor
commenting
