NEPA for Congressionally Directed Projects

U.S. Department of Energy
60 followers
Feb 29, 2024
This presentation was specifically delivered to Congressionally Directed Statutory Projects (CDSP) recipients. This webinar recording provides a brief overview of the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and Section 106 of National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), with a focus on historic preservation programmatic agreements. Additional information is shared on the NEPA review process, Contracting Officer approval, and reporting requirements.
uh everybody this is Jay nawani pretty
soon I'm going to turn it over to April
and then she will M see the rest of the
things and uh she didn't know that by
the way so hi my name is April your turn
see I got so excited my name is April
mongrain I the technical manager for the
CDP program and I'm just going to read
this statement this team's call is being
recorded and may be posted on Doe's
website or us used internally if you do
not wish to have your voice recorded
please do not speak during the call if
you do not wish to have your image
recorded please turn off your camera or
participate by phone if you speak during
the call or use a video connection you
are presumed consent to recording and
use of your voice or
image
thanks okay uh April can we take a quick
uh Second and do introduction from our
and um it's a large group uh I don't
want to take that much time to do the
introduction around the hor but if you
can just put your name your email
address and who you work for in a chat
we will have all that recorded and that
will be uh that's your virtual
introduction okay um I will do that in
just a moment April mongrain I am the
technical manager for the CDP program
and I will um put that all in the chat
so you will have contact information the
team consists of Jay nathwani he is the
PO and our newest member of the team
which is Charles I'm gonna mess up his
last name Charles want to introduce
yourself okay um we will introduce
Charles
later so I will put all the information
um Diana from NEPA has graciously um
agreed to uh do a webinar on NEPA and
shipo and we will um send it over to
Diana Jay you're on mute thank you
before we turn it over to a wonderful
subject that you all love uh that's
called NEPA uh I want to provide a one
more disclaimer that he if you have not
started any work on this project please
do not please please do not if you have
to I mean if it's really that please
contact Co right away and tell us what
you have started or what you plan to do
uh I just wanted to read this and make
sure everybody knows that until Co has
approved the documents you should not be
working or costing any money let's put
it this way so with that Diana take it a
bit all right thank you Jay thank you
for the inside um info on how I can give
myself a pay raise as well I appreciate
that um so um I am Diana heider I am the
NEPA specialist and that is the National
Environmental Policy Act um and um I am
working with Jay and April on uh all of
these uh projects I'm going to share my
screen right now
so uh if someone can just just let me
know okay we can see it perfect okay
very good so uh this is uh a specific
training for the congressionally
directed spending projects um this is
intended to be uh an overview um of NEPA
and the historic preservation act as is
it applies to your um uh uh your
projects um it's not going to be a deep
dive into any environmental regulations
or anything but really kind of more of
an awareness for you all of what to
expect in terms of processes and and
requirements as we go um please let me
know uh or speak up if you have
questions um as I am going through this
um PowerPoint um I certainly know that
um it's sometimes hard to hold your
question if you have a specific question
on a point that I'm discussing U but
there will also be time to um ask your
questions at the end so we'll go ahead
and dive in here um the agenda is uh
first we are going to cover the National
Environmental Policy Act NEPA I will do
my best to uh not speak in acronyms but
I know I slip so um I will try to spell
things out as much as POS
possible um uh as um and we're also
going to speak about a section 106 of
the National Historic preservation act
um your statement of project objectives
or the soo along with an Excel
spreadsheet that some of you folks may
have been requested to also fill out by
April and J uh that really gets into the
specifics of your proposed project um
and then I'll also touch on our project
management center or the PMC and this is
our online system for doing um our EnV
environmental reviews or NEPA reviews um
we will also discuss the Contracting
officer approval what that looks like
and what that means to you as well as
finishing up with some reporting as it
relates to NEPA and historic
preservation so the National
Environmental Policy Act uh came around
in
1969 and is the national Charter for
protection of the environment um it does
require um Federal agency to evaluate
and understand potential environmental
impacts of projects um and when we in
doe talk about um our NEPA process we're
really looking at that in terms of an
umbrella of many processes so under the
uh NEPA process we evaluate and look at
National Historic preservation act
Endangered Species Act and others so
just so that you know it is an umbrella
for many other
projects or programs I'm
sorry okay is there a
question uh if you're not asking
question please M mute yourself uh
please thank you thank you
J okay so what is the first step to a
NEPA
review um
lot of information here so it really
starts with um getting your statement of
project objectives as well as the Excel
spreadsheet if directed to by April and
J
um uh nailed down so what we're really
looking for is a specific list of of
possible activities and and that may
include um maximum sizes as appropriate
um
so we see often times um broad terms
like deep energy retrofits or Energy
Efficiency um retrofits home
electrification weatherization um and
depending on different parts of the
country this can really have different
meanings so um if you're looking at
let's say renewable energy measures um
does that mean that you're looking at
roof mounted solar fova taic systems up
to 10 kilowatts that is really the level
of detail that we're looking at
um uh Energy Efficiency upgrades could
be replacing um furnaces and hot water
heaters um that are appropriately sized
um with higher efficiency units um some
projects specify that they're looking at
Energy Star level appliances um
weatherization measures it could mean
cleaning and tuning and repairing HVAC
systems um we also want uh to know if
activities are being focused on single
family homes multif family homes or even
commercial
buildings um and if you can specify when
a fuel change is being proposed such as
if you're paying to switch out gas
furnaces uh to electric heat
pumps um and certainly we want to know
if there's a possibility of any
activities that could occur on tribal
lands or tribal properties um and if
ground disturbance is going to be
required for your produ project
um perhaps you're looking at
um solar installations that could be on
rooftops or perhaps ground mounted
systems those types of situations um so
we really want to try to get all
possible activities um that does include
Kare I know that's a question I often
get and so a comprehensive list of all
these possible activities will allow um
you all the greatest flexibility so uh I
um I know I've spoken to one or two um
applicants and um you know oftentimes uh
there are programs that are starting
with almost like a um a shopping list of
possible activities
they have this list they may not know
where all of these activities are going
to be implemented but there they've or
are they they are working on developing
this comprehensive list and I stress
that because um the way that that we are
able to structure our
review it could be something where these
activities are being considered um at
any of these possible locations so we
don't necessarily need the addresses of
where you're looking at implementing
these activities um but we do need to
know what all activities you're
considering um and I say that with a
little bit of an aster um I believe that
to be the case based on some of the
initial information I've seen I have not
reviewed complete um project
applications yet but from what I've seen
broadly um these appear to be a lot of
smaller scale
renewable um or Energy Efficiency type
projects or even the weatherization
um so that is the strategy that we're
hoping to
take um and we certainly want to include
administrative Education and Training
activities so just assume NEPA applies
to everything that's a good rule of
thumb um when you're sharing information
with
us um so here and I hope yes sir before
you go to the second page uh from your
previous Slide Can you discuss a little
bit more about the ground
disturbance um actually I'm going to get
into that here in the next slide thank
you yep you bet so um this um for those
of you that have been requested to um
provide additional detail um in an Excel
spreadsheet this is just a sample and um
I apologize I know this is small print
um but I will touch on some of the
highlights of it so um and these are all
just examples um that I have seen in
other projects but perhaps you're you're
considering starting with a training and
education component um so you're looking
at doing Outreach in um uh public
meetings at say City Hall rec centers or
something of that nature to um share
information and to get residents signed
up for your program um and you may have
be sharing printed material as well so
you're not looking at you know any sort
of building modifications or ground
disturbance but you may have to develop
and print U materials for distribution
at the meetings um the next phase of
your program could be something where
once you have this list of of residents
um that are interested you may be
looking at going out and doing um
building assessments and energy audits
um where you work with local contractors
um to do these assessments and even um
do a solar sight assessment to determine
you know if homes have the proper um
orientation for um a solar system to be
installed um then based on these
assessments um perhaps um one of the
things that that uh this a home is
determined eligible for is um um a solar
fto vaic system
so um you may not know the size on each
structure but you know that the maximum
size will not exceed 10 kilowatt on any
of these single family homes so again
that's one of those um maximum sizes
that we need for the um for the uh the
equipment um and
um The Next Step may be um in in stating
um it could be the solar panels could be
located on the the roof they could be on
the side of the house or they could be
in the backyard of the home
so some of the possible scenarios of
that are that you may have a home an
older home with deferred maintenance
that um is going to require some
structural reinforcement to the roof you
may have to have um replaced some
shingles prior to the installation oop
did mean to do that I apologize um so
those are some of the building
modifications that you can um enter into
this column um and then under the
possible ground disturbing activities so
this is where you want to specify you
may be installing up to 10 kilowatts of
of a solar system in the backyard of
homes um you again you don't know uh
which homes this is going to occur but
this is something that you are
considering um and in the next column
under additional
notes um
you I'm
sorry okay um thought there may have
been a question there so um so again you
know if you are looking in a specific
neighborhood perhaps you know that this
is an older neighborhood uh you know
that uh uh homes are going to be 45
years or older make note of that this
will help in in terms of clarifying um
all the the broad possible scope of the
project um then um the last item on here
is is window replacement again Energy
Efficiency improvements could include
that um you're going to replace existing
windows with more energy efficient ones
um and again you know that these homes
are probably going to be homes that are
45 years or
older these are just some examples of of
of what you um might be anticipating uh
in your program that's the kind of
detail that we're looking
for so taking that information um again
in the uh meeting invite for um this
webinar uh there were two documents the
first one was a word version of our
environmental questionnaire one um we
call that also the eq1 as well as the
eq1 submission guide so we're going to
dig into that
now so once uh Jay and April have said
you're good to go you've um we approve
your statement of project objectives um
you've completed um the Excel
spreadsheet with all of the information
we've asked you to
um you can start the NEPA process then
you're going to take that word version
of the environmental questionnaire the
first attachment and you're going to
fill that out the word document trust me
this is going to save you headaches um
you're going to fill out that document
then you're going to look at the eq1
submission guide the second attachment
this is going to give you a step-by-step
process of completing your registration
in the project management
center so once you've completed that
you're going to take your word document
and and take your answers and cut and
paste them into the online version of
the environmental questionnaire one um
our system has a lot of security
requirements it will time out on you
after 15 minutes if you do not hit save
this is why I encourage everyone it
doesn't matter matter what program
you're working on um but I encourage
everyone to fill out the word document
um so that you are not having situations
of delays in um the system timing out
and it not saving uh data that you've
entered um this really is a much easier
approach um I do want to highlight that
you want to select Jay athwani as your
project officer um when you're entering
this in the system um and then the
system will also prompt you to upload
your statement of project objectives and
this is where we're also going to want
you to upload um your Excel spreadsheet
of specific um activities in your
project
um once you have hit the submit button
you've gone through all of the steps and
you've uploaded everything you are going
to send a quick email to Jay and April
and say hey I've submitted my
environmental questionnaire one with all
of the attachments um this just allows
us a checks and balance we've had some
situations where perhaps the wrong
project officer was selected and um
information went out into the ether and
um this just allows us to know what you
have submitted um or when you have
submitted it and when we need to start
looking for
it so once the uh NEPA
as well as all the other reviews are
completed because there's going to be
reviews for your budget and all those
other documents um you're going to
receive notification in fedconnect and
this signifies that the Contracting
officer has approved the project so it's
critical that you don't begin the
project until you receive the FED
connect
notification if um and we know this has
happened but if you have started your
project
please notify April and J um right away
um there's some other steps that we have
to take so um if by chance you've
already started the project before
you've received your fed connect
notification that your project is
approved um that needs to be um shared
with Jay and April right away so that we
can address
it um but assuming that that has not
happened um all the reviews are
completed and you've received your fed
connect
notification uh the next step is that uh
it's you're going to want to review all
of your documents this includes um your
NEPA determination which is your
attachment six in your documents um and
you want to ensure that you understand
all of the restrictions and requirements
in um that
document I'm going to highlight a couple
of those excuse me um so um some
language that you're going to want to
look for it's going to be in all of your
NEPA
determinations um and I should clarify
the NEPA determination is our internal
document that um uh documents our review
of your project so that is a um a
document that spells out this is the
project that you're proposing these are
the restrictions and the requirements so
that is um our review of your project um
in that document you're going to see
language that says that you're required
to adhere to the requirements of your
State's historic um preservation
programmatic
agreement so these programmatic
agreements um offer a streamlined
process for complying with Doe's
responsibilities under section 106 of
the National Historic preservation act
um I am going to try here to shift over
to another
screen
um give me just a
moment while we are waiting for Diana to
switch over uh I wanted to remind you
that if you have any questions please
type it in in the chat section raise
your hand uh interrupt us don't hold
back
um more question we get better we know
that we have done a good job in
communicating your concern so thank you
over to you Diana great thank you um and
and just to clarify as well this
PowerPoint presentation will be shared
with you afterwards so just know you're
going to get this with all of the links
so don't be concerned about that um but
this is the link that I was sharing and
um this is a doe website that has you're
not sharing sorry you're not sharing
your
screen thank you for saying that Jay
I'll try that
again okay can you see it
now I'm sorry jay can you see my screen
now yeah okay yes all right great okay
so um as I was saying this is the link
to the historic preservation um web page
um I just wanted to show this to you
really quickly so you can know what it
looks like um there's an intro where it
provides context and it explains um some
of the history of these programmatic
agreements they came about after um doe
received a significant funding Under The
Recovery Act um and so most of these um
programmatic agreements um started
around 2010 so there are older
agreements
um uh but all of the states are listed
here every state has a programmatic
agreement so um this also includes any
amendments that you may have had to your
State's agreement um and um and it also
shows the expiration dates so um in 2020
we did a big effort to extend all of
them um some expired 2025 some 2030 but
the they are all
here
um going to I live in Colorado so I'm
going to click on
Colorado um you want to to be sure to
look at these amendments too because
Colorado does have some additional
language in theirs
um these were template agreements
between the department of
energy the um State historic
preservation office and every state and
um most
territories um and and programs
um these programs um there's we've had a
legal determination that these um
programmatic agreements apply
um to um to these congressionally
directed projects so they are included
in it um but it's very important that
you spend some time familiarizing
yourself with this
um there's a lot of
nuance to the different states some
State historic preservation offices
wanted tailoring uh language to be
tailored to their state or they wanted
uh to have have it more restrictive less
restrictive there's there's a lot of
nuances to this but I just want to
highlight a couple of things here um
like in the state of
Colorado um right here um under uh B it
talks about undertakings involving
properties greater than 50 years old so
every one of these programmatic
agreements Define historic property in
terms of age so
if you are looking at working on a
building that is 30 years
old this doesn't apply if you are doing
um only activities that are above ground
on a structure it's not in a historic
district none of that it's just less
than 50 years old this doesn't apply but
it's important to look at your
programmatic agreement because some of
the shippos the state historic
preservation offices
designated um that the threshold was 45
years so again there's some differences
between states um we'll just keep
scrolling down
here and at the end of this agreement
you're going to find
appendices and what these appendices do
is list
activities that your state historic
preservation office has agreed
um that they don't have the potential to
cause effects on historic properties so
if you are these are a list these are
lists of activities again another Aster
they have restrictions um but these are
activities that are exempt from historic
preservation review even when they're on
historic properties um you may find that
your
program is proposing activities that
perhaps are not on the Exempted list um
in appendix A or B um traditionally it's
a little awkward the way it's broken out
appendix a is specific um it's called
for the weatherization assistance
program um don't worry about that um
these programs have all changed names
and and expanded and uh in a
reorganization at Department of energy
but the weatherization assistance
program traditionally in the past was
focused on otherization activities um
another appendix is State energy program
and
eecbg these programs have
traditionally um been more Energy
Efficiency and renewable energy type
projects with perhaps um a little bit of
weatherization if your proposed activity
is under either one of these appendices
it is exempt it doesn't matter which one
it is um but this is where you want to
review this make sure you're familiar
with this if your activity is not listed
here you are going to want to um you're
going to be required to consult with
your state historic preservation
office I wanted to make a comment a lot
of the CDP uh projects may fall under uh
SCP and ecbg type of activity those are
like lighting projects or uh um
so once again in this case if you don't
know just ask us tell us that hey which
one should I take uh and which one
should I apply for it thank you right
absolutely
um okay I'm going to switch back here so
give me just a
moment
um
and I lost my where I was on this I
apologize so when your activity once
again you are not sharing now sh up
thank
youuh so if your activity is not listed
as an Exempted activity in the
programmatic agreement it allows you to
consult directly with your state
historic preservation office
so get CAU up here I apologize it keeps
flopping backwards um and um so again
determine if the activities are Exempted
from review in the appendices if they're
not or even if you're not clear um there
some language is not
clear I'll be honest with you um you're
going to want to contact your state his
preservation office if you need
clarification on specific language of
your programmatic agreement um I have
included here a link this is a directory
of all um State historic preservation
offices it's going to show you um their
websites and contact information um it's
important to note um historic resources
can be above or below ground so don't um
don't think of this as just um your um
some your concern is about buildings
that are 45 or 50 years or older there
could be resources below ground
depending on where you are working so if
you are having ground disturbance that
could trigger a historic preservation
review with your state historic
preservation office if it's not Exempted
so just want to raise your awareness to
that
um if you are I should say when you are
contacting your state historic
preservation office you want to notify
them that you're operating under Doe's
historic preservation programmatic
agreements um it informs the office that
these are federally funded projects um
which has a different set of
requirements and it also alerts them to
the agreement itself um you know we've
seen a lot of of um staff turnover at
these State historic preservation
offices so it just um makes it much
easier if you provide that information
UPF
front um additional language to look for
in the NEPA determination
um some projects may have language that
says that activities must be documented
such as in AA log um
this will not apply to everybody so um
but if it if you do see this language um
a NEPA log is a document that provides
evidence that you have reviewed and
complied with the restrictions of your
NEPA
determination um this is generally
required um for ground disturb for some
and not all but um for some ground
disturbing
activities so
um if you see this language uh in your
NEPA determination we're going to be
reaching out to you we're going to
provide you a sample along with
instructions and um this is a quarterly
reporting requirement that you're going
to have um again um I from some of the
initial projects I've seen so far I'm
not seeing where that's necessarily
going to be a requirement for a lot but
I want folks to be aware that that this
could be a
possibility so
um NEPA historic preservation all of
your reporting requirements that you're
going to have for your um award are
going to be outlined in the federal
assistance reporting checklist we
affectionately call that the farc which
is a fun acronym um and again this is
also going to be in your award documents
so some things to work out look for from
our perspective for anpa is there is an
annual report that everyone will be
required um for your historic
preservation programmatic agreement um
this is basically a report on your use
of this agreement um it asks you to
document and to count the number of
categories of Exempted activities that
you utilize the PA and and if you had to
consult to document that as well so uh
you are going to see in your reporting
checklist um this designation that this
is required is going to include a link
to the report I encourage you to look at
that um it's so that you are aware of
what that reporting requirement is going
to be it's um it is submitted at the end
of the fiscal year so it's going to be
um the end of August that you'll be
required to submit that um and it's good
to know so you can be tracking that
throughout the year Diana there's a
question okay go right
ahead hi Diana um what does ground
disturbance
constitute oh you got me with that one
that is um a question that you need to
present to your state historic
preservation
office um the template language again
again not every programmatic agreement
is going to have the same language but
many of the programmatic agreements say
that anything above minimal ground
disturbance is going to require
consultation with your state historic
preservation
office minimal is not defined in the
programmatic agreements so um and I can
I can tell you that um I've had this
conversation with multiple State
historic preservation offices and um
nearly all of them have a different
definition so that is um very much one
of those situations where you are going
to want to reach out to your state
historic preservation office um present
and have a conversation with them early
um I encourage that if you are looking
at Ground disturbing activities
especially um let them know these are
the types of activities we're
considering
um our programmatic agreement says this
does this constitute more than minimal
ground disturbance um because they're
the ones that are going to have to
interpret that for
you okay thanks yeah you
bet um okay so uh again uh you may also
um have a requirement um a quarterly
reporting requirement in the form of a
Nea log so um
this is all going to be spelled out to
you in your documents again just want to
give you that heads up um so
um I suspect as you're as you continue
on through this process you're going to
have more projects or more questions
about your project um feel free to reach
out to um Jay and April they're going to
coordinate with me so that we can answer
your questions um and
this uh slide also has our NEPA and
historic preservation training website
uh link this is a generic um website for
all of the state and Community energy
programs um it will'll get more detailed
into uh uh anpa overview as well as
historic preservation and you're going
to find in your uh NEPA determination a
requirement that you also look at this
training website and review the
Powerpoints on um NEPA and historic
preservations so um it's a great
resource um not just for the training
but um if if you have additional
questions I think you may find some of
your questions answered there as well um
and that is my presentation so we have
uh more time for
questions thank you Diana this was very
useful even I learned today what is
minimum minimum is really not
minimum
uh so this is good um it just shows us
that uh all of us are diverse we think
differently and it's good to always ask
a
question
absolutely so um I'm hoping that all of
you love this presentation
uh we are not asking you to take more of
this presentation but this is definitely
the one the start
and don't hesitate to ask question
please please I mean you guys are quiet
I mean what's wrong uh do I have to buy
you coffee uh I can order
donut if that
helps ail can you kind of give us some
uh do you have a joke or can you kind of
oh is going to tell us a joke okay Eric
I I was just gonna say I love donuts but
it's kind of hard to get through the
computer screen I just wanted to say
thank you um I think why you're not
getting questions is you're answering a
whole bunch of them that we had talked
about internally here at SMUD and you
know I've been on several of these do
doe grants over the last 23 years at
SMUD and I have to say this is the most
clear I've been at this point about what
we need to do and the steps I know we're
going to have a separate call with you
about specifics on our project but this
this is awesome no I'm serious it's it's
super duper helpful thank you thank you
we appreciate that you've made my day my
week thank you for
that and and my paycheck you know now I
can justify it Kim I'll double down I'm
from smed as well and um I think it
helped us too there's probably some
missing information that in our
spreadsheet we're like oh wait the
Outreach component the education
component you know we were very focused
on the the measures that we were trying
to do so I I do think it gives us some
better guidelines of where to
go yeah only thing I regret that we
didn't do this three months ago I wish
we should have done it earlier but I got
that message next year in future we will
plan to do this much sooner um
absolutely but this is our you got
you've got a great model I mean I I
would have loved to have it sooner too
but you got a great model that I think
your point would avoid a lot of
headaches will help us to spin up very
quickly once we get everything pulled
together so hold on to this for next
year absolutely we definitely plan to do
that I don't have any jokes Jay but you
know I I appreciate everybody's time and
attention and all the questions and
anytime that you need help we're here
okay so do you want to tell us what they
need to do
next um so if you have not had a phone
call about Soo with April or I please
reach out both us okay because I I I'm
one of those old guy who is very slow I
I need to have a two sticks around and a
c of Home me wobble through my we uh so
if I forget about you I didn't mean it
just tell us that hey we didn't talk to
you we need to finalize our soos so we
can get the money and we can do NEPA and
then we can get the contractors's
approval to get money rolling please do
that bother me I have no problem uh
April doesn't like to be bothered but
keep her there
first okay that's not true and actually
I have a couple of calls that I need to
schedule right now just so we know with
Albuquerque and with
SMUD okay so please reach out to us once
again any questions or any question you
have about the indirect cost
anything uh please ask us and we will
try to process your award as we get
things done please bear with us uh we
can't do all of them in one day you know
that uh uh but we will try to process
them as fast and as quick as we can uh
with that if you don't have any more
questions um then I would say thank you
and and uh looking forward to working
with you absolutely yes thank you all
okay byee apprciate it you bye
bye you can stop recording
now
