Rep. Greg Cheney shares his strong concerns about SHB 1104's proposed deferred prosecution criteria

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
1 Video View·Feb 29, 2024
In a recent House floor debate, Rep. Greg Cheney expressed his strong concerns about SHB 1104, focusing on eligibility and criteria for deferred prosecutions. Cheney noted that, under this bill, individuals could potentially reach their tshird DUI conviction before facing any jail time.
fur the
remarks the good member from the 18th
legislative district representative
Cheney well thank you Mr Speaker and
good evening I have some grave concerns
about this bill and I'd like to share
with you uh before I get to those
concerns about the way the current DUI
Law works in the state so Mr Speaker
when you're charged with the firsttime
DUI often the BAC we find statistically
is around a 007
to100 uh slightly above or slightly
below the 08 uh BAC cut off uh Mr
Speaker when you're convicted of a DUI
all convictions including first
convictions on DUI are already required
to do alcohol treatment the difference
between that treatment and a deferred
prosecution uh program is the length of
weeks under a firsttime DUI conviction
you merely go to treatment for the
number of weeks that the treatment
counselor says you should go under a
deferred prosecution however you are
required to do 26 weeks of
treatment now the other key component
between a deferred prosecution program
and a first time DUI offense is on a
first time du DUI offense you are
required to do jail under a deferred
prosecution you are
not so Mr Speaker the reason why and
there I heard the word it was there was
a pervers incentive to hold a deferred
prosecution for a second DUI charge it's
not a perverse incentive at all instead
what you're doing is you're doing jail
on the 1 with as many weeks of treatment
as the counselor will require instead by
using a deferred prosecution on a first
and creating now a second you could be
on your third DUI before you ever have
to step foot in a jail to me that is
fundamentally wrong and that is the
perverse incentive in this issue so Mr
Speaker the other problem here that is a
that I haven't heard anyone discuss is
that we currently have a tremendous
Workforce shortage in the alcohol and
treatment AB uh substance abuse space so
if we are now going to require
mandatorily on a first and second DUI
everybody to go into 26 weeks of
treatment regardless of whether or not
they need 26 weeks of treatment because
this bill takes away that discretion
from the counselor to determine that
where is the workforce going to come
from in order to make this program work
as designed Mr Speaker there isn't the
workforce I urge you to vote no on this
bill put people in jail so they feel the
sting of a first time DUI and don't get
a
second
