上帝指揮的戰役,D-DAY,神秘巧合致德軍慘敗,超自己然力量,盟軍開闢第二戰場。| D-DAY | 諾曼第 | 加萊 | 英吉利海峽 | 經典戰役 |

火力施密特
41粉絲
12 次觀看·2024年2月29日
諾曼第登陸戰並不是人類可以控制的戰爭,關鍵時刻總有什麼力量控制著整場戰役,最終勝負與雙方的實力無關。
If you could go back to the past with your current memories you might try to reconcile with your first love or buy NVIDIA stock to achieve financial freedom
But there is one thing even if given a god's-eye view you could never accomplish nor could you do it better than it was done at the time and that is the D-Day invasion
Don't rush to disagree the Fire Force knows everyone is very familiar with this war the first half of this episode will give a general overview of the Normandy campaign the defense and the forces involved in the landing
In this phase everyone can put themselves in the role of the commander and try to see if they can help the Allied forces land successfully
Keep in mind that perspective can transcend but technological transcendence is absolutely impossible
Some say the D-Day invasion was not a war of humans or that it was not a war humans could control
At every critical moment it seemed as though some force was controlling the entire battle the final outcome of the D-Day invasion seemed to be a predetermined conclusion unrelated to the strength of either side
Is that really the case Let's first briefly review the background
In 1939 after the outbreak of World War II Germany quickly occupied Poland Denmark and Norway then launched a lightning attack on the Netherlands Belgium Luxembourg and France
In June 1940 the German army achieved a major victory in the Battle of France which Hitler called the most famous battle in history forcing the British and French armies to withdraw in large numbers from Dunkirk
Saying it was a retreat strictly speaking it should be called a rout to speed up the withdrawal the allied forces left behind their equipment some soldiers even fled barefoot with only one pair of underpants
The German army thus naturally controlled almost the entire Western European continent
In June 1941 Germany invaded the Soviet Union and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin urged the Western Allies to open a second front in Western Europe aiming to relieve pressure on the Soviet Union
In June 1932 the German army reached Stalingrad and the Soviet Union once again asked Britain for assistance prompting Britain to send the Commandos and the Canadian 2nd Infantry Division totaling more than 6 000 troops to aid the Soviet Union
In the following six months the Allied forces finally managed to take their revenge delivering heavy blows to the German and Japanese armies in the battles of Stalingrad Midway and El Alamein
However overall these victories were still not enough to completely shake the entire fascism the Soviet forces on the Eastern Front still faced immense pressure from 3 million German troops
In May 1943 the Anglo-American Washington Conference made a decision that seems almost perfect by today's standards
The decision was that the Allies would land in Europe in May 1944 opening a second front and encircling the German forces from both sides
In December 1943 General Eisenhower was appointed as the Supreme Allied Commander which meant that the invasion of the European continent was officially put on the agenda
This was the beginning of the bloodiest and most tragic landing operation in human history - Operation Overlord
The background of the D-Day invasion is covered now let's look at the German deployment in Normandy
First get a basic understanding of the terrain of Normandy
From the mouth of the Orne River to the eastern coast of the Cotentin Peninsula the beaches in order are Sword Beach Juno Beach Gold Beach Omaha Beach and Utah Beach
Among them Zhunuo Beach is a dune area about 9.6 kilometers wide with a sandy steep slope of nearly 10 meters in height behind it
Although Omaha Beach is 6.4 kilometers long most of it is lined with cliffs over 30 meters high leaving only about 200 meters of usable landing space
Although the Yushan Beach consists mostly of low dunes the Germans had already deployed heavy fire bunkers along the 5-kilometer coastline
From the above terrain features landing at any beach is not promising
Next let's look at the German defensive forces deployment
The Western Front had two German army groups consisting of four armies with 58 divisions 33 coastal defense divisions 15 infantry divisions 8 armored divisions 2 light divisions plus two armored divisions under Hitler's direct command totaling approximately 800 000 troops
The B Group Army was stationed in the Normandy region of northern France consisting of the 15th and 7th Armies with a total of 39 divisions
The first to land at Gold Beach and Sword Beach were the 716th Infantry Division the first to land at Omaha Beach was the battle-hardened 352nd Infantry Division and the first to land at the Cotentin Peninsula were the 31st Regiment the 709th Infantry Division the 243rd Infantry Division as well as the 91st Airborne Division and the 6th Parachute Regiment
In addition the 711th Infantry Division of the 15th Army was stationed east of the Orne River along with the renowned 2nd Panzer Division and the 12th SS Panzer Division
These two units equipped with Tiger and Panther tanks were hidden in the woods 25 miles southeast of Caen waiting for Hitler's orders
That is the general deployment of the defending forces on the Normandy beaches Next let's take a look at the defensive structures
We'll keep this brief
Almost becoming a fortress within a fortress all the Normandy beaches had become a barrier within the entire Atlantic Wall deployment several months before the landings
Rugged Czech hedgehogs steel multi-angled pyramids field logs Belgian gates anti-tank obstacles and devil's cube concrete cones are scattered along the beach mostly positioned at the waterline between high and low tide
In addition there are densely packed landmines and sea mines connected to these anti-invasion devices totaling approximately 8 million
Behind the barrier was a layer upon layer of barbed wire followed by 15 641 German bunkers and 799 reinforced concrete strongpoints each gun positioned to dominate the beach from a commanding height
Most importantly the gunports of these bunkers did not face the beach directly but were angled a design that greatly reduced the likelihood of the gunners being injured by the attacking force's concentrated fire
In addition the Germans had extended numerous pipes directly from the oil depot to the flamethrowers in their trenches creating a dense network that could be considered a pillar system
In addition positioned on the defensive line the Germans had prepared a large number of remote-controlled tanks which would recklessly charge onto the battlefield and explode once the attacking forces entered the shallow area each carrying half a ton of explosives
By this point some comrades might be eager to say these measures only prevent infantry landings I'll use an airborne force
Indeed paratrooping was indeed a good method but Rommel had obviously thought of this as well To prevent scattered troops and mechanized infantry Rommel had filled the low-lying areas behind the bunkers with seawater making the entire peninsula almost completely isolated from Normandy
At this point as the defending force the Germans could either encircle the invading paratroopers by flooding the few roads and bridges or use these roads to supply the front line As for the high altitude areas where water could not be stored they simply drove in dense rows of stakes and between the stakes they placed an unobtrusive half-trigger fuse the specific function of which the combat forces would not elaborate on
We'll leave it at that for the defense side feel free to add any missing points in the comment section
From the technological standpoint of that time the Fire Force believed this line of defense had very few flaws almost perfect
Here you can also take a little break and imagine if you were the Allied commander at that time how would you direct the troops in this landing operation
Let's get back to the topic now let's take a look at how the Allied forces actually fought
Landing operations are generally divided into two phases: the planning phase and the implementation phase
First let's talk about the planning phase Everyone should look at this map the closest landing point across the English Channel should be Calais not Normandy
Some say that Eisenhower's decision to take the long route was based on the element of surprise a view that the Fire Army agrees with but there were two other important influencing factors
We previously outlined the defensive measures of the German forces in Normandy which were actually just the standard defense and not nearly as heavily fortified as Calais
BBC launched an initiative as early as 1932 to collect photographs and postcards of the European coastline from Norway to the southwest of France from its audience
Now everyone knows that the purpose of this activity is to gather intelligence and help the Allies find the most suitable landing site
Soon after the announcement the British War Office received millions of photographs which along with aerial reconnaissance intelligence indicated that the place would be more defensible than Normandy in the future
Post-war data shows that the German forces stationed in the Calais area were about twice as strong as the Normandy defenses so Eisenhower wasn't unwilling to attack Calais strictly speaking he was afraid to
Regardless the D-Day invasion was already decided upon by the Allies but making the plan too early could also create a problem if the German commanders had learned in advance that the Allies would land in Normandy they would have shifted their defensive focus making Normandy even more difficult to attack
Unless the Allies could maintain absolute secrecy during the planning phase and furthermore interfere with the German's judgment
About how to deceive the Germans Allied commander Eisenhower put in a lot of effort first he sent the US's top general Patton to the Allied base across from Calais to command a non-existent force
This unit is the fictional First Army Group which includes the fictional 69th 18th 21st and 135th Airborne Divisions not only having ashes but even their numbers were not spared saying there are no troops is not accurate some non-combat personnel such as actors singers pastors performing artists and so on anyone who is free must wear military uniforms and just walk around when they have nothing to do
This is how the personnel of the First US Army Group were composed having the troops they also needed weapons Hollywood's prop makers created a large number of fake airports fake airplanes fake tanks fake warehouses and more creating a convincing illusion that the Allies would land at Calais this operation was called Operation Fortitude
In addition to Patton there was another person in the Allied camp who had the capability to command the Allied frontline forces during the landing operations which was the world-renowned British general Montgomery He was secretly kept across the English Channel from Normandy meticulously preparing for the major battle
At the time both sides' intelligence capabilities were not to be underestimated and if Montgomery remained hidden for a long time it would certainly raise Hitler's suspicions To solve this problem Eisenhower specifically chose the Australian actor Cliff Richard to play Montgomery
This man's face was already very similar to Montgomery's and after putting on the general's uniform it was almost impossible to tell any difference
The only difference between them was that James liked to drink alcohol while Montgomery didn't touch a drop Once James got so drunk he almost blew his cover
However after General Jia was severely beaten by Zhen's attendant such incidents never occurred again and it wasn't until the Mongol military records were declassified after the war that people learned about this episode
Just playing the role wasn't enough the fake Montgomery was even sent to the North African battlefield to command operations meaning to tell the Germans that the British war god wasn't here the only big gun here was Patton across the English Channel this was the operation known as the "Tongue of Bronze "
All of these were smoke screens used by the Mongol forces to deceive the Germans part of the security operation including several sub-plans such as the Double Cross Operation the Zeppelin Operation and the Copper Tongue Operation
Due to time constraints we won't go into detail here In addition to tactical preparation material preparation is also very important
In 1943 the Mongolian navy achieved a complete victory in anti-submarine convoy operations in the Atlantic and the UK began transporting large quantities of supplies from its homeland totaling approximately 5.3 million tons
By the time of the war the entire United Kingdom had become a vast military camp with every airport and port crowded with aircraft and ships in addition to nearly 3 million troops from 11 countries
Among them the landing craft were all equipped with multiple rocket launchers to fill the gap in naval gunfire and firepower after the troops landed
To quickly break through the German minefields British tank expert Major General Hobbs developed a new type of special tank and formed a special armored unit to suppress German firepower clear paths remove mines spray fire to clear obstacles and carry out a series of pioneering tasks before the engineers landed
Supplies are ready the remaining task is the port The port falls under engineering and cannot be accomplished in a single day How can we have a port available for our transport ships to continuously dock as soon as the troops arrive on the other side
Six months before June 6 1944 British Rear Admiral Tannatt was given the daunting task of overseeing the massive project of the artificial harbors known as Mulberry A and Mulberry B an undertaking that required four years of Britain's full industrial capacity
The artificial harbor consists of numerous abandoned old ships and 146 hollow concrete caissons each 61 meters long with eight different sizes set according to the depth of the seawater where they were sunk
1772 tons of minimum displacement 6044 tons of maximum displacement
The caisson contains ship compartments two anti-aircraft guns buoyancy tanks for surfacing and sea valves for submerging allowing it to surface or submerge to the designated location within ten minutes
The specific procedure is that once the Allied landing forces begin the landing the tugs will pull these caissons to a position five and a half meters deep one nautical mile off the shore then lower them one by one and connect them forming a breakwater that is 9000 meters long providing protection and convenience for the construction of a series of Allied supply facilities
At that time constructing these structures required 600 000 tons of concrete and 3 100 tons of steel and to complete the project the UK invested nearly 30 000 workers including as many as 500 officers
The entire project was completed successfully in June 1944 which is also one of the main reasons why the D-Day invasion took place in June
Just like the preparation of supplies and information the above-mentioned material preparations are only a small part of the many preparation plans the other military forces' firepower will not be introduced one by one
We are now entering the implementation phase of the landing station
On April 28 1944 638 American soldiers and sailors were conducting a landing rehearsal along the southern coast of Devon in England
Code name Tiger but no one expected the Germans to play outside the rules they directly sent torpedo boats to attack the US military during exercises resulting in all personnel involved in the exercises being killed
This explains why both archers had expectations in their hearts knowing that I would attack at any moment and that you knew I would attack you The archer duel thus officially entered a feverish phase
On the morning of June 6 1944 the Allied 21st Army Group commanded by General Montgomery launched a formal attack on Normandy
The army group includes the U S First Army the British Second Army and the Canadian First Army with more than 150 000 troops
The landing plan consists of three steps first the U S 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions will parachute near Saint-Mere-Eglise to control the right flank of the landing area
The 1st Infantry Division's 16th Regiment and the 29th Infantry Division's 116th Regiment landed on Omaha Beach the 4th Infantry Division landed on Utah Beach and the British 6th Airborne Division landed around Ranville in the northeastern part of Caen
After these forces successfully secured the left flank of the landing area the 3rd Infantry Division landed at Sword Beach the 50th Infantry Division and the 7th Armored Division landed at Gold Beach and finally the Canadian 3rd Infantry Division landed at Juno Beach
Next let's look at the actual battle situation
Before June 6 1944 the Allied forces had already used heavy bombers to conduct raids on key production targets deep within German territory
On the evening of June 5th approaching midnight Allied forces stationed balloons on ships heading to Calais successfully deceiving the German coastal radar while thousands of bombers and attack aircraft launched an aerial assault on the Cotentin Peninsula bombing key targets such as roads bridges railways and tunnels leading to the beachhead
At 16 minutes past midnight on June 6 the British 6th Airborne Division was dropped on the left flank of the landing area with the objective of capturing bridges near the Pegasus Bridge to prevent German armored units from reaching the coast for support
Here we highlight a key point which will be explained in detail later
In contrast the U S 82nd and 101st Airborne Divisions faced additional difficulties as they lacked experienced pilots and encountered complex ground conditions causing the troops to be scattered in various locations some paratroopers even landed in the sea or in low-lying areas deliberately flooded by the Germans and many drowned in the emergency waters due to the heavy and complicated equipment
Let's take a look at the situation on the beach
After landing on the eastern side of Sword Beach the British forces quickly broke through the German light infantry fire and successfully met with the scattered airborne troops that had landed inland by midday
The British forces that landed at Baojian Tan on the western side faced strong resistance from the German 21st Panzer Division and failed to meet up with the Canadian forces at Juno Beach in time
The Canadian First Army and the Third Infantry Division were responsible for capturing Juno Beach where the German forces consisted of a regiment primarily composed of Russians and Persians with low morale and poor combat effectiveness
But despite this due to the well-organized German defenses the Allied landing craft loss rate still reached 80% with losses generally occurring when unloading personnel on the return trip
In addition to the loss of landing craft the Juno Beach was experiencing high tide causing Allied soldiers to drown immediately after disembarking due to the weight of their equipment and even those who managed to land were subjected to heavy fire from German bunkers
The first wave responsible for capturing Gold Beach was the British 30th Corps' 50th Infantry Division and the second wave was the only armored division that participated in the beach landing the British 7th Armoured Division
This armored division was renowned having defeated Lumer in North Africa Because of the late landing time and the destruction of several key German strongpoints by naval gunfire before the landing the British amphibious tanks were successfully landed on Gold Beach by the landing ships
But as expected they will still face the same fire suppression as at Nausauer Beach forcing them to lie low under the eyes of the Germans
We previously introduced that Omaha Beach is 6.4 kilometers long with much of the coastline consisting of cliffs over thirty meters high making the terrain very defensible
The landing operation here was carried out by the US Army's 9th Army but the Allied forces due to incorrect intelligence believed that the German defending force here consisted of only a single regiment
In fact Lumer had already moved the entire 352nd Infantry Division a key unit of the German army to Normandy three months earlier with the division's main regiment stationed at Omaha Beach
The results were obvious with the Allied casualties alone reaching 2 500 on the day and the landing operation almost completely failing
The other beaches were to be captured by the 4th Infantry Division of the US 7th Army so let's highlight this point as we will have some questions to share later
Here the subsequent process will not be elaborated further let's briefly analyze the nodes for everyone
Although the Tonga operation of the 101st and 82nd Airborne Divisions started with a poor drop it was an early attempt at using Pathfinders in military history
Sergeant Ib in the 1st Company 506th Regiment 101st Division led by Winsted launched an attack on a German 105mm artillery position at the Brockton Estate an action later recorded in West Point's textbooks
A private from the 7th Parachute Battalion 6th Airborne Division Sidney Cornell was inserted into the game "Call of Duty: Vanguard" during the Normandy campaign and the in-game character is named Arthur Kingsley
At the time of the landing the Rangers fought fiercely at Omaha Beach destroying the 155mm artillery positions that threatened Omaha and Utah beaches an action that is recorded in the history of the 75th Ranger Regiment and will be reenacted in a commemorative event at Omaha Beach
On D-Day naval vessels provided fire support to the shore with destroyers and minesweepers being hit directly by German coastal artillery because they were so close but this was also the most effective way to support the infantry on the beach so these destroyers engaged the German coastal artillery at very close range which was a dangerous maneuver primarily aimed at protecting the infantry on the beach
In addition the Sang Shen artificial reef project played an extremely important role as soon as the assault troops landed on the beach these caissons sank onto the Normandy beaches forming an artificial breakwater Under the protection of this artificial breakwater the Allies successfully established a series of support facilities thereby launching the Cobra operation the major offensive into the Cotentin Especially after the port of Cherbourg was completely destroyed by the Germans the role of Sang Shen became even more significant and it was used until the port of Cherbourg was put into operation
From the final outcome the D-Day invasion was the bloodiest and most costly war in the history of the US military with the Allied forces deploying over 7 000 landing ships which transported 156 000 troops and 10 000 tanks to the Normandy beaches on June 6th alone and on that day as many as 4 400 Allied soldiers died with over 9 000 injured or missing and the exact number of casualties remains unknown estimated between 4 000 and 9 000
Of course from today's perspective the outcome of the battle has little significance but when we carefully review the entire situation we find that this campaign was full of coincidences and even more puzzling is that all these coincidences naturally favored the Allies
For example the first focus of our neutralization was to prevent the German armored forces from reaching the coast for support but the problem was whether this single airborne division could hold back the German armored division and the 12th SS Panzer Division The answer was obviously no
However the scales of fate had already begun to tip these two hidden forces which only obeyed the Führer failed to receive Hitler's orders at the critical moment remaining unmoved despite the efforts of other commanders to deploy them for if these two units had been activated it would have been as futile for an Allied paratrooper division to try to stop them as it would be to eat a man's words
So the question arises why didn't these two German elite units move The answer is simple: at the most critical moment of the German defense Hitler was still asleep to be precise he was oversleeping and what was even more infuriating was that no one dared to wake him up As a result the Germans lost the most critical few hours to hold on to Normandy
This is the first focus of our plan and like the first and fourth accidents of the Normandy campaign this accident was called an unexpected event that influenced the entire course of the Normandy campaign
Next is the second one the Allied forces captured Jewish Beach which was assigned to the US forces but when the US landing craft first landed it deviated 1800 meters to the south and did not land at the designated location
However this mix-up made the Jewish Beach the beach with the least losses among the five beaches of the battle
The original landing site was defended by a battalion and two artillery companies while this wrong landing site had only a single company
After discovering the vulnerability General "Little" Roosevelt the commander of the Fourth Division modified the landing markers and the US forces began landing here at 6:30 am completely overwhelming the defending Germans by 10 am with total casualties only 197 less than one tenth of the estimated losses
This is our second point and also the second accident of the D-Day invasion there are still a third and fourth accidents and the artillery unit decided not to hold back and said it all
For a long time before deciding June 6 as D-Day the English Channel had been sunny so the Supreme Command arbitrarily chose a day as the D-Day for the battle and established a combat weather committee composed of meteorologists
On May 29 the Weather Committee for the Battle remained optimistic about the weather in early June believing the landing plan could proceed normally However an unexpected change occurred once June arrived the sky turned gloomy casting a shadow over Operation Overlord
By 9:30 PM on June 3rd the weather showed no signs of improvement and the high pressure over the Azores became unstable with three low-pressure systems moving from Scotland across the Atlantic towards Newfoundland meaning strong winds would occur in the English Channel for the next week
At that time whether the previous bombardment plan or the airborne plan would turn into a blur of gunfire delaying by a day would risk a ten-point deduction However if the plan is carried out under such weather conditions the effectiveness of the strike cannot be guaranteed and may not even reach half of the results achieved during the rehearsal period
After weighing the options Eisenhower decided to delay the first day Just then the Weather Committee reached a new conclusion based on the cloud formations stating that the English Channel would experience a brief period of improved weather before the cold air and low-pressure cloud mass arrived and that day was June 6th
This is the third coincidence if this coincidence is a result of scientific derivation its consequences would be unbearable for the German army As we have introduced earlier the German commander stationed in Normandy Rommel known as the Desert Fox on the evening of June 5th observed the weather and believed the Allies could not launch an invasion under such conditions so he secretly went home without informing anyone
What was he doing when he went home Everyone probably knows that at the time when the German army in Normandy most needed a commander the Desert Fox was celebrating his fiftieth birthday with his wife and even personally gave her a pair of shoes as a birthday gift
On the morning of June 6 when the Allies launched a large-scale invasion the "wife-lover" Rommel was still in Germany this was the fourth chance that influenced the entire course of the war and together with the first chance they are considered the two main factors influencing the Normandy defense
The military believes that you might achieve the comprehensive approach and seamless tactical coordination that Eisenhower demonstrated but the four elements of chance we mentioned above are not within human control In other words it's not something you can solve just by working hard it requires sufficient luck
At that time none of Hitler's subordinates dared to wake him up so Rommel chose to abandon his post to avoid being scolded by Hitler The sudden change in weather and the American's accidental hit were all coincidental factors that were tipping the scales in favor of the Allied forces The Allied attack on the German defenses in Normandy these coincidences could have all potentially rewritten history
After the Normandy campaign the US military conducted multiple simulations and the results were surprisingly consistent with the Allied Normandy landing success rate being only 30 percent and if all chance factors were excluded the success rate would suddenly drop to 10 percent It is precisely because of this that many people say the Normandy landing was an unrepeatable war winning was the result but Yang Xiao winning again would be even harder than climbing to heaven
So saying that the D-Day invasion was a war beyond human control is relatively accurate Since we couldn't influence it isn't it also acceptable to call it a natural contest of time and space
Alright the more we talk the more surreal it gets Does anyone have a surefire strategy to win in one move If so feel free to leave your thoughts in the comments section and let's discuss and exchange ideas together
This concludes today's program I'm Huoli Jun see you next time
