Here's Why Unhappiness Is As Important As Happiness | Dr.Loretta G. Breuning

Bay Area Innovators
541 followers
What is #happiness? Is unhappiness curable? Today we sit down with Dr.Loretta G. Breuning, who spent years on research on the origin and theories that revolve around happiness. She will talk about the reason of happiness from a #biological perspective, as well as the history and popular ideas of how to pursue happiness.
#bayareainnovators
Here's Why Unhappiness Is As Important As Happiness | Dr.Loretta G. Breuning
========
🔵 Sign up for our newsletter: https://bayareabeyond.com/
⭕️ Follow us on GAN JING WORLD: https://bit.ly/GJW_Bay
They're telling us that happiness is the natural normal state.
If you're unhappy, it's a disease that can be fixed by treatment.
It's attractive. I mean, who wouldn't like that idea
that some kind of treatment can take away my unhappiness?
So, but that's not the case.
I mean, I wish it was.
I was shocked to learn that these advocacy groups for mental health
are funded by the pharmaceutical companies
that produce the very medications that they're taking.
Academics and therapists must fit this model to avoid career suicide,
and the media tends to fit it
because pharmaceutical companies are one of the biggest advertisers.
Hello, everyone, and welcome to Bay Area Innovators.
I'm your host, Steve Esposito.
Our guest today is Dr. Loretta Browning.
Loretta is the founder of the Inner Mammal Institute
and Professor Emerita of Management at California State University, East Bay.
She's the author of several books, including Habits of a Happy Brain
and How I Escape Political Correctness and You Can Too.
Before teaching, she worked for the United Nations in Africa
and is a graduate of Cornell University.
Our topic today is unhappiness.
What makes us unhappy, how normal it is,
and how much it is of a cause or concern.
Loretta, welcome to our program.
Nice to be here.
Great to have you here.
So I'd like to talk about unhappiness in today's world.
Based on a CNBC report from October of last year,
there's a huge increase in American workers being more unhappy at work
and creating this loss of productivity in society,
that they count as $8.8 trillion lost because of people being unhappy.
And it's more towards the health industry that this happens.
Why is this happening?
So humans are unhappy a lot
because our brain naturally creates a lot of unhappiness.
It has an important function.
It alerts us when there's important information that we should be cautious about.
So if we are trained to define this natural unhappiness as a disorder,
then we need a lot of services.
So this is, to my opinion,
that we've been trained to define our natural unhappiness as a disorder
so that someone else has to fix it.
So unhappiness, the state of being unhappy,
is not necessarily a disease or an abnormal state.
You're saying it's more of a normal state?
It is a normal state.
Of course I know what the official professionals have to say about this.
But let me just add to what people have heard about that.
So in the state of nature,
our ancestors were constantly looking for food and water.
So imagine if you climb a mountain and you're looking for water on the other side,
and then there's no water.
So unhappy chemicals surge
because it's your brain's information
that you have not gotten a return on your investment of energy.
A simple way to say that is disappointment.
Every time you expect something and you get disappointed,
your unhappy chemicals turn on.
But that's just a natural, normal way for your brain
to know how to allocate your energy.
So how does this relate to what the medical industry is telling us these days?
They're telling us that happiness is the natural, normal state.
And if you're not happy, it's a disorder,
and treatment can fix it.
So there's so many problems with that.
One is to see your natural ups and downs as a disorder,
but the other is to expect someone else to fix it for you.
And that suggests that happiness is the natural, normal state,
and if you're unhappy, it's a disease that can be fixed by treatment.
And that's attractive.
I mean, who wouldn't like that idea
that some kind of treatment can take away my unhappiness?
So if you believe this message,
then it's very attractive to say,
yeah, sign me up.
But that's not the case.
Yeah, I mean, I wish it was.
I understand our brain is designed to seek happiness constantly.
So we're designed to be disappointed, really.
And the simple, again, explanation is that our ancestors
had to look for food all the time.
When they found food, they were happy.
But then the food was soon gone, and they had to look for more food.
So our brain is designed to seek, seek, seek.
And when you seek, you don't always get it.
So you have ups and downs, and that's just natural.
So if you're saddled with this expectation
that other people are getting happiness effortlessly,
then you think, oh, maybe I do have something wrong with me.
Well, you know, over the weekend,
I read your book, and I'm going to put it right here,
Why You're Unhappy.
Tell us more about the book, what you cover in the book,
what makes the person happy or unhappy,
and just what your experience is through writing it.
Sure.
So the subtitle, Why You're Unhappy, Biology vs. Politics.
So politics is a natural human process
where we try to get support from others
by telling people what they want to hear.
So we all want to hear that happiness is the natural, normal state.
And this is sort of where we are now,
is that we like politicians who say they're going to make us happy.
We like professional services that promise to make us happy.
We like medical services that promise to make us happy.
And maybe we need to ask a little more questions about that
and to question the very underlying model
that we should be happy all the time or that we can be easily.
Tell us more about the politics of being unhappy.
You wrote about it in the book.
What are the politics of being unhappy?
Sure.
So as I said, politics is telling people what they want to hear to get support.
So most of our information about our brain and our emotions
comes from medicine, academia, therapists, and the media.
So I talk about the politics of medicine, the politics of therapy,
the politics of academia, and the politics of the media.
In each of these, we get reinforcement of this paradigm
that says happiness is the natural, normal state,
and unhappiness is a disorder.
So that's why we all believe it,
because all of our information sources are telling us that.
Tell us more.
Why is unhappiness treated as a disease?
Many people have heard about the Sacklers,
and this bit of history is very useful.
Today, they're in the news because of the drug called oxycodone.
But long before that, almost a century ago,
the first Sackler created the idea
that a medication could relieve bad feelings.
And he put his life into first researching that drug
and then marketing that drug.
So even if we could say that he started with good intentions,
the marketing techniques he created are not only with us today,
but they're really dominating our reality.
Because doctors have drugs,
not only what they're relentlessly marketing to doctors,
and even when doctors may have good ethics and good intentions,
they are actively shamed.
Like a doctor who doesn't accept this idea
of making everyone happy with the latest treatment,
they shame them.
And so it's hard for professionals to resist this onslaught.
Tell us a bit about the model,
the model used for determining either unhappiness.
And there's always questions on models,
if they are correct or not.
In this case, how is the model being determined,
and how correct do you think it is?
So let's start at the end and the beginning.
So the end, many people have heard of the DSM-5,
which is like the latest way of determining a person having a clinical disorder.
Now, in real life, if you get quote-unquote diagnosed,
then you get a prescription,
and you can get treatment as a covered benefit.
So this is highly desirable in today's world,
and that's what's driving a lot of this.
And especially when you think other people are happy all the time,
other people are getting free treatment,
so I want it too.
Or maybe other people's kids are getting benefit from getting a diagnosis,
so people want it too.
So that's the modern, like, driving this disease model.
But now I told you about the researchers were looking for treatment that they could sell,
but let's look at the very distant roots of this.
It's a hilarious story, really.
So it really goes back about 250 years ago,
when Jean-Jacques Rousseau told us that happiness is the natural state,
and gave us this illusion that we all have,
that if you lived on a tropical island, you'd be just effortlessly happy all the time.
Where did Rousseau get the idea that nature was effortlessly happy?
That was politics, too.
He was just selling a popular idea.
What happened is, it's hard to believe this,
but I looked it up and I really researched this.
So at a certain point in the late 1700s,
British ships sailed into the harbor,
sailed to shore in Tahiti.
There was no harbor yet.
The first British ships to land in Tahiti,
the first French ship to land in Tahiti.
Naked girls literally rode their canoes out
to greet the sailors up close and personal.
And so this was shocking to people,
and the news spread around the world like wildfire.
And people said to themselves,
how could this be? What is causing this?
It was like a new information.
And Rousseau concocted the idea that this is the natural state,
and we'd be enjoying this all the time
if it weren't for that our civilization
has deprived us of happiness and ruined everything.
And that idea was so popular
that it just dug deeper and deeper and deeper
into all of our institutions of learning.
And the actual reason for the girls to greet the sailors was?
Was that they were compensated, to put it in a polite way,
and that their fathers and brothers
wanted the compensation for themselves.
And to get a little more specific,
is they did not have metal.
So metal was the compensation, nails.
And so many nails were spent in this particular way
that the ships practically fell apart.
And that's partly how the word spread so quickly,
is that ship captains would tell each other
to load extra nails,
because even though you try to hold the sailors back,
they're going to steal the nails,
and the ships are going to fall apart.
This is just history.
It's hilarious.
But to think that this is how this folklore spread,
that all life would be effortless.
What's more important is to know how miserable we would be
if we lived on a tropical island,
because we would worry that the next storm
is going to destroy our crops,
and we'll have no food for a year,
and our children will starve,
and we'll hear them cry,
and we won't be able to give them anything.
So I think this is a more realistic view
of the life of our ancestors.
That's very interesting.
So Rousseau's view is that
originally everyone is happy, everything is happy,
but society makes people unhappy.
Yes.
Did he go any further than that?
Well, here's the thing.
I have to tell you how he put this into practice.
It's shocking.
I mean, I found it so shocking
that it's upsetting to even say it.
So he had five out-of-wedlock children with his housekeeper,
and he brought every one of them to an orphanage at birth
because he didn't want his children
to be raised by a housekeeper.
And so despite his lofty theories
that were popular and made him
an important intellectual figure,
he was not living in any way
that we would see as natural and healthy.
Wow. That's amazing.
And Karl Marx, I think, went further with this idea
that society is the problem.
Can you talk to us about it?
Sure.
So let's think Karl Marx is born
after Rousseau's theory has been around for about 50 years.
So he's born into this world where it is...
Was Rousseau's theory accepted at the time,
or it was just a fringe kind of theory?
You know what?
Like everything that's popular,
it grows and it competes
because the competing theory, of course,
is that life is hard and you have to work hard to stay alive.
So that's not very popular.
So on the one hand,
like maybe religious institutions
were not big embracers of Rousseau's theory,
but slowly, slowly you could see
how each generation would be tempted
and even lured by this idea.
To put it in like the parlance of my generation,
the 70s, like, you know,
just strip off your clothes and live on a tropical island
and you'll be happy every minute.
So...
So yeah, going back to Marx, did he take it further?
Yeah.
So Marx is born into this world
where slowly over time,
the cool people have more widely accepted this idea
that nature is effortlessly happy
and our society has ruined everything.
And Marx then adds on this idea of,
but we can get our happiness back
by making a better society.
Then we'll all be happy.
We shouldn't allow this society to rob our happiness.
We could create this perfect society
where we'll go back to this natural state
of everyone being effortlessly happy all the time.
And thus was born communism,
which most people don't know,
but slowly over time in the late 1800s and early 1900s,
it grew and grew to the point where by the 1920s,
it was sort of like the norm of the intellectual world,
like anybody who was anybody was a communist.
And then when the Depression came,
it became like an ethical thing,
like I care about other people,
so you must be a communist.
Speaking of that, you also talk about Freud in your book.
And I wonder, what did you learn from him?
Yeah, this is so fascinating.
This is the second book in which I wrote about Freud.
So imagine now Freud coming along some years after Marx
into this world where people are believing
that nature is happy and civilization
is the cause of all of our unhappiness.
But Freud did something that I truly admire.
He was looking into the physiological roots
of how is it that we create this unhappiness physically.
And that's sort of my jumping off point
because I was raised in a very unhappy environment
and my mother had theories about why she was unhappy.
And in my little kid brain, I sort of questioned her theories,
especially like if my mother said she was unhappy because of me
and my little kid brain thought,
I'm not really sure that I was a cause of her unhappiness.
So I think at a young age, I sort of had an awareness
that our verbal explanations of our unhappiness
are not the whole story.
And that's what Freud said.
Now Freud went astray in so many ways,
but at least we can thank him for saying,
you know what, our verbal explanations of our unhappiness
are not the whole story.
And that's where I came in with studying animal brain
which creates and manages the chemicals
that cause our unhappiness
and animals don't have this verbal brain
that philosophizes and makes up stories.
And so I learned that our verbal brain and our animal brain
are not well attached, let's say,
and our verbal brain does not control our body.
Our animal brain controls our body
and our verbal brain is just sort of trying to influence it
the way a rider tries to influence a horse.
In your book, you mentioned the four chemicals
that affect the happiness of a person.
Can you please go over them briefly
and explain what each one does?
Sure. I call them the happy chemicals,
dopamine, serotonin, oxytocin, and endorphin.
So I wrote my first book about them 12 years ago.
And since then, this has become very popular
and a lot of people are talking about it,
but they're not talking about it
from the animal brain perspective.
They're talking about it from the popular perspective,
which people want to hear, which is not at all what I said,
which is the idea that you could have these happy chemicals
all the time and you could, you know,
take a hot bath and have your serotonin.
But what I explain in my books is that
our happy chemicals evolve to reward survival behavior.
So each of them is released in a very specific situation
where in the world of our primal ancestors,
that chemical motivates a step towards survival.
So dopamine motivates a step to meet your needs.
So if you think there's food on the other side of the mountain,
but you're exhausted and hungry,
but dopamine is released because,
oh, I'm so close, I'm so close.
And that's the feeling we all love,
whether you're doing some really difficult work
or whether you're playing a stupid video game.
It's that same like dopamine, physical excitement.
But once you've got it, it drops.
Exactly. And that's why unhappiness is part of life
because the happy chemicals are only meant to be released
in short spurts and they're not going to just go on all the time.
And that's true for everyone. So it's not a disorder.
And they have a purpose because you need to get food or,
you know, no matter if it's in ancient times or now,
you still need to get food.
Exactly. You still need to take action to meet your survival needs.
Now in the modern world, we can meet our survival needs
with so much less physical effort that we have all this extra energy
and we use it to meet social needs.
And that's why the other two chemicals reward us for meeting social needs.
And that's why we drive ourselves crazy over this stupid social minutia
because we have too much energy left over
after we meet our need for food and water and firewood.
So the social needs, oxytocin and serotonin,
they're two different social needs.
One is I want to be in a group.
And the other is I don't want to be at the bottom rank of the group.
I want to rise in the group.
So oxytocin is the good feeling that I have the protection of a herd.
And serotonin is the good feeling that I have the respect
and the recognition and importance in the eyes of others.
And the fourth one?
The fourth one is endorphin, which is the body's natural opioid.
It's triggered by real physical pain and it's not designed to be on all the time.
It's only designed to turn on.
You're injured.
And so the idea of injuring yourself to trigger endorphin would be crazy
because our body evolved to survive, not to hurt our survival.
And so that's why I'm very focused on the fact that we're designed to seek the other chemicals,
but we're designed to have endorphin for emergencies only.
Injured or very tired or in an almost like a life or death situation, right?
Or specifically for injury?
So injured, but that includes if you're starving,
your stomach contracts and that's a kind of pain.
Crying releases a little.
Deep laughter triggers muscles that don't get used very often.
So that triggers a little, which is why laughing feels good.
And they say that like moving, you get a little bit.
And so if you get up and move often, it's good.
But to accept that a little bit is enough, but people want to chase this high.
And there's this culture of I need this high.
And so then they have to do more and more to trigger a lot of endorphin.
And that's why I'm always so cautious on this subject.
This is very important.
I mean, I experienced this going hiking or running in the mountains.
You feel like, wow, I've done 10 miles, but now I start feeling good.
So I'm going to do more to chase, like you said, to chase this feeling.
And that could be dangerous.
I didn't know that.
Absolutely.
And the sad thing is that it's true with the other chemicals too.
So the fact is that our brain is designed to habituate to everything.
So if I walk into a coffee shop and it's like, oh, that smell is heaven,
but I habituate to it in a couple of minutes, and then I'm not in heaven anymore.
So it's the same with all of the happy chemicals.
And that's why even if I'm prescribed a medication, I'm going to habituate to it.
And that's why I'll need more and more of it.
Habituate means getting used to it.
Getting used to it.
Yeah.
And then it doesn't trigger the response that you're looking for.
And so you seek and seek, and you do things that may harm you to try to get more.
So these medications function the same way.
They provide a little bit of stimulant, and then you fall back into a depressed state, right?
I won't say a depressed state because that has like legal and medical connotations.
So I would say that you fall back into a dissatisfied state where you may go back to your doctor
and say, I want something more, and then your doctor is sort of like legally
and professionally responsible for giving you more and more.
And then you get more side effects.
So then you get more medications for the side effects.
And it's very hard to drop from these medications.
That causes new side effects.
And people are not informed about all of this to the degree that they need to be
once they start going down this road.
Can that lead to drug abuse or drug use to extend these feelings or these experiences?
Yes, it can.
And of course, drug use has so many different causes.
But to me, the core cause is this belief that you should be up all the time
rather than saying, oh, every time I'm up, there's going to be a down.
If I try to artificially boost my up, then the down's going to be even bigger
and I'm going to be even less skilled at managing it.
So the skill of managing my ups and downs is what matters.
I think one thing you explain well in your book is how if you're always in a state,
in a complacent state, like, quote, happy state, then you're not really careful.
You're not careful.
In ancient times, again, you have to be aware that someone may attack you
or a lion may eat you.
But even now, if I feel I'm complacent, something is going to happen.
Something is going to hunker me.
My kid is going to do something.
You can't be in the complacent state, right?
Otherwise, you're not going to be alert of what needs to happen.
Well, people use the word complacent in different ways.
So I'm not saying that you should be on guard all the time
because that can lead to anxiety, and then people feel anxiety.
They get diagnosed.
They look for medication.
So what I talk about is first we need awareness of threat,
but our brain is inclined to be so hyper-aware of threat
that the minute your happy spurt is over,
you rush back into your thoughts about threat.
Something's going to go wrong with my job.
Something's going to go wrong with my kid.
And the reason we rush back into that is because the biggest neural pathways
in our brain is where the electricity in your brain flows,
and threats are what create the biggest pathways in your brain
because that's our natural alert and self-protection mechanism.
So what we need is the skill of steering away.
Like the minute you have a free moment,
if you start worrying to say, oh, I'm flowing into a big pathway,
it's just a pathway, it's not a real threat,
and I can redirect the flow of my energy into something else,
but you can only do that if you create the something else.
So what is the something else?
If you make it a quest for a high the way teenagers learn to do,
then you can have bad consequences in the long run.
So instead, I call it neutral.
So maybe this is what you're probably thinking of with complacent,
is if you think that a neutral gear, like a car, it's not zooming forward,
it's not pulling back, but I'm in neutral.
And the good thing about being neutral is that then your brain is receptive
to all information, whereas when I'm in a high,
I'm only looking for good information, and when I'm down,
I'm only looking for bad information, just because that's how the brain works.
In part three of your book, you talk about solutions to this,
so please talk to us more about how people can achieve a state where,
like you said, they're in a neutral state versus them being up and down all the time.
So we are all relying on neural pathways that we built in our childhood
because they're so well-developed, because that's what the child brain does.
So we all just repeat ourselves.
If you want to build a new pathway, it's work.
If you think of, like, what effort it would take to dig a new road,
it's such hard work that you would just use the road that's already there.
So first you have to take the willingness to build that new road.
Then you have to design the new road so that you're not just digging everywhere,
but you're focusing your effort on the new road.
So the design comes from understanding the happy chemicals
and what are the healthy ways of triggering them by knowing the job they do in nature.
Then what's going to get me to dig that road toward the happy chemical that I've planned?
And I talk about giving yourself treats in the same way that animals get treats
in order to repeat a behavior and learn a new trick.
And treats have a bad image in today's world,
but really treats are what motivate a mammal,
and we can motivate ourselves to do something new
by giving ourselves small rewards for small steps.
Anything else as far as solutions or as far as addressing this unhappiness
that supposedly exists in society?
So the solution starts first, I think, with self-acceptance.
That to say, rather than saying,
I have a disease and someone else needs to cure me,
or to say my unhappiness is society's fault,
is to say that my brain is creating natural unhappiness.
So if I want to be happier, it's a skill that I can learn.
And everyone since the beginning of time has been challenged to have to learn this skill.
And it takes a lot of effort,
but I'm so lucky that I have the time and energy to learn this new skill.
So that's the first thing.
And then the second thing is, it's so tempting to want to fix other people,
as much as you want someone to fix you,
but then you want to fix the other person.
You think, they're making me unhappy, so if I fix them.
But the bottom line is that you really can't control someone else's brain,
so you have to commit to, like, how can I be happy,
given the fact that the world is what it is?
And the biggest thing about the world is that our brain naturally,
we want to be special,
because that's when we get that little drip of serotonin.
And there are 8 billion other people in the world that want to be special as much as me.
And this is just a reality that we all live with.
And so again, it's the self-acceptance and the small steps
and getting it where you can and then giving yourself a treat
when you redirect your flow away from the negative toward the positive.
You touched on this before,
but why do people do not question the disease model enough, or at all?
Yeah, why do we not question the disease model?
Because we're told that it's the science.
And all through the book, I capitalize the, capital T, capital H, capital E,
because we can all hear this and our mind is like, they say,
well, it's the science, which implies that if you don't agree with this,
you're a stupid idiot, because science says this
and only stupid idiots criticize the science.
But the reality I learned from my husband, who's a scientist,
he said, science is a discussion.
So if they tell you that you're not allowed to discuss it,
then they're not doing science.
So anyone who says, it's the science,
they're really selling you a service.
They're selling you their service, and they're not acknowledging
that people who do the science are debating and discussing
and having all kinds of evidence, and some of the evidence is ignored
because pharma isn't funding it, the media is not reporting it,
academic psychologists can get canceled if they acknowledge it,
and therapists will see their patients quit
if you tell people what they don't want to hear.
And I think you mentioned in your book also that researchers will be ashamed
if they come up with an opposite theory.
Yeah, you're shamed, even called a hater,
because identity groups have formed around various disease labels,
because people say, well, it's not my fault, it's my disorder,
and that puts them in the one-up position, which sparks your serotonin,
it gives you an identity group, which sparks your oxytocin,
it gives you a solution, which sparks your dopamine.
So people like having this diagnosis,
and then they accuse you of being a hater,
and hating and harassing even people with the disorder
if you even question the data around all their beliefs.
And so I was shocked to learn
that these advocacy groups for mental health
are funded by the pharmaceutical companies
that produce the very medications that they're taking.
I was just very amazed to learn that.
You wrote an article before about this culture of,
it's never my fault, it's either society's fault
or it's someone else's fault for what I may be doing wrong.
Is that related to Rousseau and Marx,
or where is this theory coming from?
Well, I think the core is like,
when you feel like something is your fault,
it's both a good feeling and a bad feeling.
So the bad part of it, when you feel like it's your fault,
is like, I'm going to get criticized, I have to fix it.
The good side of it, you think,
maybe someone else will rescue me because it's not my fault.
But then there's the bad side, which is,
if I say it's not my fault, then I'm powerless.
I can't do anything about it.
I have to just wait for people to fix me.
So I would really rather it be my fault
so that I know that I can take action and do something about it.
But that view, unfortunately, is not popular
because we've already sold people the idea
that nothing is your fault,
and apparently it's easier to sell therapy and psychology
and services and media if you tell people it's not their fault.
And blaming others.
And it's easier to get votes
if you tell people it's not your fault and blame others.
And so all the people we get our information from,
they want to tell us what we want to hear,
and so they're telling us things are not our fault.
And we may like to hear that in the short run,
but in the long run it makes us feel like powerless victims
and distracts us from the valuable path
of investing our energy in building our own skills.
Any final thoughts on how Americans can be happier?
Final thoughts about how Americans can be happier.
Well, in the conclusion of the book,
I talk about the dream of creating a perfect society.
And I just hear this everywhere,
that everybody thinks if we only create this perfect society,
then we'll all be happy.
And the reason I'm not happy now is because society has gone wrong.
So many people are repeating that,
but everybody believes it,
and they're not doing what they can for themselves.
So how can we create this perfect society?
They say, well, we have to create perfect people.
How are we going to create perfect people?
Because they see that that hasn't happened.
Well, we have to have perfect parenting.
So how are we going to create perfect parenting?
Well, we have to have perfect parenting classes.
So in my book I explain why it's just not a very realistic thing.
So we're just much better off understanding
that society will not be perfect, parenting will not be perfect,
and our own neurochemistry will not be perfect,
but we can build the skill of redirecting our brain
so that whenever we feel bad, we can steer it.
Aurora, thank you so much for your time.
I appreciate being on our program.
Thank you so much.
Thanks for the great questions.
