Lecture 28

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Feb 23, 2024
if you notice in the earlier lecture we
have discussed about the locus how the
locus can be changed with the variation
of the system gain so we have
discussed the
graphical graphical represent
of
the
movement of the
poles of the closed
loop closed
loop control
system with
the
different
values of
the system
gain if you notice here what you have
done before uh we have done this
practice with the variation of the one
single
parameter so the root
Locus
what you have
done what I've
done with the various
of
one
single
parameter which is basically K which we
change the and how the lcus has been
drawn this is what we have looked at but
in practically this one single parameter
cannot specify all the performance of
the system so this
variation with this variation it
is not
possible
to
satisfy all the
performance
specifically
using a single
parameter so to solve this uh problem we
we need to come up with some different
kind of
compensation which can be added to the
control system to meet this performance
or the specification what the designer
has so we need to
apply we need to
consider we need to consider to
add some
form
of
compensation for
the control
system to meet
the
design
specifications and this compensation we
can add in form of electrical circuit
mechanical device or electromechanical
compensator
so the
compensator
maybe
electrical
circuit
or mechanical
device or
electromechanical
device devices to
improve
the system
performance and this compensator if you
look carefully this compensator
basically adding the poles or zeros to
the system in Feit forward or feedback
path so
basically the
compensator
as
a transfer
function
which
added which
adds
PS or
zeros
to
the
system so now before we ped to the
control system uh let's look how our
root Locus plot going to behave with the
addition of fals and zeros to the system
so before we
proceed let's
look the effect
of addition
of
Poes or
zeros to
the
system let's go with a simple
example then it will be clear how the
system going to be affected with the
addition of fours and zeros
example
construct a root
Locus for the trans of
function GS
HS equal to e by S into s + B1 so there
is no zeros in the system only there are
two FS one po at origin another po at
isal to minus P1
and
examine
examine how
the
locus going to
be
affected by
the addition of addition of the
following the following
to
the
original transer
function so let me go through this
following what are the addition we have
to do the first addition
is We'll add a simple
poll and we will see how it will be
affected the RO will be affected simple
F second case we
consider multiple
pole and third case we consider
simple
zero so we'll add this uh simple pole
multiple poles or simple zero to this
trans function this to function will act
so we'll see
solution if you look the original trans
function we have
Gs HS equal
to K
upon s into s + P1 and if
you if you see this Po's location in
our
is plan we have one pole is here and
another pole is here this is = to 0 and
is = to minus
P1 and if you go back to our concept of
ASM tootes the angle of ASM tootes
should be it is clear that there should
be all breakway point will be somewhere
here that is quite obvious what you have
done from the previous lectures this is
that should be breakway Point here and
this once the breakway happens the locus
will go to Infinity since there is no
zero in the system so it will go to the
Z
infinity and now let's look what angle
this Locus will depart from this
breakway point the angle
of angle
of ASM
tootes will be if you denote Pi so it
will be 2 Q +
1 N - n into
180° and since there is two poles we can
there will be two angles one is 90° and
270° so it is quite obvious the locus
will be will follow the ASM toote so
Locas will be something like
this
something like this so this is the
original trans of function how the locus
will be plotted for the origal transfer
function now let's look the the the case
first case if we add simple HS to the
system how the locus will be affected
let's
look now if we
add a simple
for
s + P2 for
example to
the GS
HS so now GS HS will
be K upon s into s + P2 and S + P1 so
this will the modified trans of
function and if you
plot uh these poles in s
plan if you place this PS we have one
pole at origin another pole is here
another PO is for example this is minus
P2 minus P1 and is = z for
example and this is the location of the
PO of the transer
function 1 by
is s +
P1 s + P2 right
and so if you notice here the angle of
ASM toote will
change so in this case there will
be uh three
angles and one Locust will we can
calculate the
angles is you look can calculate so
there should be breakway happens between
these two poles and Locus will be going
to like
this and there should be another Locus
will be going this
direction like
this it means what is the takeway from
this addition of
PS we can write here very interesting
here so it means the root
Locus
will
bend
into
the right
half
plane so it it it means
which
limits the range
of the range of the range of
k for
the for the system for the
system will be
stable but in the previous case if you
notice here in the previous case here
for any values of K the locus is always
on the left hand side the system is
stable but in the second case if we add
a pole to the system so we have limits
on the D of K so system is going to be
less stable for we can't take any values
for K so that's why system going to be
there be different part one is stable
region and is the unstable region for
the different values of K
now let's look at another
condition if we add another pole what
will happen the second part multiple
poles if you add another pole for
example let's
assume
at a pole is = to minus
P3
to GS
HS what will happen so in this case our
trans function will be GS HS equal to
can
write one
upon aent into s + P1 s +
P2 s +
P3 and if you place this PS in s plan
you'll have so this is my S equal Z this
is for
example let's assume this is s = to
minus P3 for example and this is s = to
minus
P2 and this is equal to minus P1 for
example so it is quite obvious there
will be Locus in between and this is
also there Locus in between these poles
and in between these poles there will be
breakway somewhere here and there will
be angle of there will be some mean the
some Locus will be like this and there
will be another Locus something will be
like this so if you can do this
experiment if you take some example with
some numerical values of P1 P2 P3 you'll
have look at something like this so what
is the takeway from this
part the
addition
of another
F
adds another
Branch the that goes
to that that goes to 0
Infinity
but the
system can still
unstable
if
the system
gain
K
exceeds
H so in this case again the system will
be unstable if you if you increase the K
after this part the imag axis so in this
case also there's a limits on K on which
the system will be St
now let's look how we can get the root
Locus plot for the addition of the zero
before we proceed to the addition of the
zero let's a note
here
interpretation for the a
analysis the root
Locus
plot
Bend
towards right of
plan with
the addition
of
pole to
thef open loop transer function
hence the
addition
of of a simple
po tends
to
destabilize
the close
Lo control
system this is very very important part
this part how if you add the PS to the
system system will be it will be tend to
the
destabilization so this is very very
important part now how let's look how
the root Locus will be look like if you
add zeros to the
system we consider the original system
original system we have
GS
HS = to K upon h s +
P1 and let's add to this transer
function a simple
zero let's add a
simple
zero is = to Z1 for example
and the trans function will be GS
HS K into
s minus Z1
Z1 and S into s +
P1 and if
you locate this PS and zeros in s plan
we'll have here we
have there is another pole let's
consider P equal to
minus
P1 and we are adding a zero
here is = to minus
G1 and if you no this there will be
breakway between
this two
poles and breaking will happen here this
is quite sure now the root
Locus it will be breakway somewhere in
between this
point
and it will go like
this so it means if we add zero to the
system it will system will be more
stabiliz for any values of K the locus
always in the left hand
side and if you take another case if you
add a zero inut in between these
poles let's consider another
case this is for example s equal to Z if
we add
a if we add a Zer
here s = minus C1 and if you have P here
s = minus
P1 so in this
case for the locus from this pole will
end here and Locus from this pole isalus
4 will go like
this so in both the cases in this case
and in this case Locus actually stays in
the always in the left hand side it is
not going to the right of plane so we
can conclude from this part we can write
here with the addition of the addition
of the addition
of
zeros to the
system the root
Locus
root
Locus
plot to bendt
further
into the left
hand left
hand
plan so hence we can write by
adding a zero
to the
system system in the open loop
system the system the closed loop
system will
be more
stable than
the
original
close Lo
system so what is the takeway from this
lecture is if you add zero to the system
system will be more stabilized and if
you add P to the system system will be
will be t to the destabilization mode
and based on this
motivation we'll be in the next lecture
we'll be discussing the concept of
compensator to the system how the
compensator going to add different
stability criteria to the original
system thank
you
