Prof AT Jan24 Lec 14

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Feb 16, 2024
[Music]
in this lesson we start the discussion
with the introduction to climate
change and climate Finance next we
discuss the concept of carbon pricing
and its role in greenhouse gas emissions
we also discussed the concept of
abatement cost next we discuss the two
very important
direct pricing mechanisms these are
emission trading systems and carbon
taxes we compare and contrast these two
direct carbon pricing mechanisms next we
introduced the concept of emission
trading systems and its role in climate
change mitigation with the help of a
simple illustrative
example in this video we'll introduce
the subject of climate change and role
of climate Finance in mitigating it let
us first try and answer the question
what is climate change so climate change
refers to long-term shifts in
temperatures and weather patterns such
shifts can be natural for example large
volcanic eruptions but in the current
scenario human activities have become
the main driver of climate change mainly
due to burning of fossil fuels like coal
oil and gas and therefore emission of
greenhouse
gases now in the modern day climate
change has become a significant Global
Challenge and therefore governments and
international agencies are focusing on
the projects and policy instruments that
can take the global economy towards the
path of lowc carbon emission and
decelerate the pace of climate change
risk in this regard un United Nations
framework convention on climate change
that is unfccc has provided the basis
for international climate
negotiations including Landmark
agreements such as the Kyoto Protocol in
1997 and Paris agreement of 2015 the
convention has been ratified by 197
States who have committed to act on
climate change to reduce their
greenhouse gas emissions and regularly
report on their
progress in this backdrop climate
Finance has emerged as a very important
area that is study of approaches and
policies that facilitate and attract
investment towards green and renewable
Technologies by capturing the scarcity
of environment
and
therefore putting a cost or Premier on
emission of harmful Gases such as
greenhouse gas
emissions for example governments are
focusing on the policies such as pricing
carbon emissions through emission
trading schemes and also taxation on
emissions and other approaches such as
reducing fuel subsidies improving
regulations and so on for reducing these
carbon globally there are Market
approaches such as emission trading
schemes green bonds and also taxation
based approaches that allow Nations to
reduce carbon emissions to the targeted
level with least economic cost and in an
efficient manner and hence such
approaches are preferred over other
approaches this new area of climate
Finance is officially recognized by
unfccc and this novel area of climate
Finance is defined by unfccc as the
local National or transnational
financing br from public private and
alternative sources of financing that
seeks to support mitigation and
adaptation actions that will address the
issue of climate change in this backdrop
in this regards carbon pricing more
specifically emission trading schemes
have emerged an important Market based
instrument and policy tool for climate
protection and climate change
mitigation to summarize this video we
discussed what is climate change and in
this this backdrop how climate Finance
facilitates mitigation of climate change
by inviting investments into green and
renewable Technologies and thus
reflecting the scarcity of environment
or the cost to polluting the environment
and putting a premier on the same in
this video we'll discuss the concept of
carbon pricing and its role in
mitigation of climate change we'll also
discuss the direct and indirect ways of
pricing
carbon more precisely we'll try to
answer the following questions what is
the price of carbon or carbon pricing
what is the role of abatement cost in
climate change mitigation and what are
the direct and indirect ways to price
the
carbon economically any resource that is
scarse and has some utility will be
naturally priced by the market in a more
organic manner in a similar manner
carbon pricing aims to capture the
scarcity of the capacity of environment
to absorb greenhouse gases emissions of
greenhouse gases and polluting activity
before reaching hazardous levels which
can affect the humankind and
society and thus it requires pricing
carbon in an efficient manner which
captures this environmental scarcity and
incorporates it in society's investment
and consumption decision more
efficiently and thus carbon pricing
helps internalize the external cost of
polluting activity such as greenhouse
gas
emissions by incorporating this cost of
carbon into production and consumption
decisions this carbon pricing or put it
more specifically the cost of carbon
because it goes as a cost into various
industrial production and consumption
decisions should in principle represent
the abatement cost needed to meet meet
climate change mitigation related
objectives or sort of represent the
societal cost or the cost born by
Society because of these polluting
activities such as greenhouse gas
emissions there's a broad landscape of
carbon pricing instrument which ranges
from direct to indirect ways of pricing
carbon the idea behind direct pricing of
carbon is to attach or add a pricing
component to a given product or activity
that is directly proportional to the
greenhouse gas emission or polluting
activity generated by that product and
activity for example direct carbon taxes
or emission trading schemes the two most
common instruments are these carbon
direct carbon taxes and emission trading
systems indirect carbon pricing schemes
or policies include fuel excise taxes
and fossile fuel subsidies these are not
directly linked or represent
the amount of polluting activity such as
emissions from a given product or
activity in its pricing
component finally let us discuss the
abatement cost concept the abatement
cost is simply the cost of an
intervention that will reduce greenhouse
gas emissions by one ton for example an
individual replacing a gas boiler with a
heat pump will reduce their greenhouse
gas emissions but they will also have to
pay for the installation of the heat
pump and the electricity needed to run
it but they will also save money by no
longer purchasing the gas so essentially
if you divide the total additional cost
what is the additional cost here the
investment into the instrument plus also
the difference in additional operating
cost minus saving in operating
cost by the avoided
emissions then you'll have the batement
cost so essentially if you divide the
total additional cost that you are
incurring by the avoided emissions you
have sort of what you call this per ton
of carbon not emitted whatever is the
dollar cost so essentially this pattern
of carbon not emitted the dollar cost is
called abatement
cost to summarize this video we
discussed what is the carbon pricing and
why it is needed to efficiently price
the carbon that is if carbon is priced
efficiently that it captures the
scarcity of environment in its ability
to absorb emissions and greenhouse gas
emissions and polluting activity before
reaching hazardous levels that are
harmful to society and Mankind we need
to price the carbon efficiently we also
discussed what are the direct and
indirect base to price carbon and it
seems that the direct base to price
carbon are more efficient from
environment perspective lastly we also
discussed the abatement cost concept
which is essentially the total dollar
investment or cost cost per turn of
carbon not emitted or per turn of saving
in carbon emissions whatever is the
dollar cost investment required is
called the batment cost in this video
we'll discuss two very important
components of direct carbon pricing that
is emission trading schemes which is a
cap and trade based system and direct
carbon
taxes we'll also discuss the revenue
mechanisms from these carbon direct
carbon pricing
instruments more specifically we'll try
to answer the question what is an
emission trading scheme and how it works
how carbon taxation works as direct
instrument of climate change mitigation
and what kind of revenues are generated
from these direct carbon pricing
mechanisms to put it simply an emission
trading scheme or what we call as
ETS is a cap and trade based system
which caps the total or aggregate level
of greenhouse and other emissions such
as sulfur Dio side so SO2 emissions in a
region and then subsequently the
aggregate emissions are divided and
distributed towards the installations or
industrial installations Plant Man
manufacturing
units in the form of right to emit what
we call as emission allowances these
emission allowances essentially provide
them with the right to
emit now those installations that are
more environment friendly and operate
based on green environment friendly
Technologies they have naturally low
emissions so they are in surplus of
these allowances in terms of these
allowances and then those installations
that are more intensive in their
emissions that are more heavy users of
these emissions because their emissions
are
larger they are always demanding these
emissions so essentially those
Industries with low emissions they sell
their extra emissions to those with
large emitters who are in demand so thus
creating a supply and demand for these
emission allowances an emission trading
scheme or ets establishes a market price
for carbon or what we call as these
greous gas emissions which is a more
Market oriented or Market driven price
discovery of carbon the idea behind
getting the cap at the overall aggregate
level is to ensure that required
emission reduction targets are met and
at the aggregate level the emitters at
the aggregate level they have their
emissions in the pre-allocated carbon
budget so the initial budget that was
set at the beginning the aggregate
emissions which are essentially nothing
but the overall sum of all the
individual emitters should remain within
the budget that was initially set and
therefore everything is aligned to the
Target that is set for the
scheme in contrast carbon tax directly
sets a price on carbon by defining a
explicit direct tax rate on the emission
activities such as emission of
greenhouse gases or to put it
more
clearly a price on the carbon content of
fossile
fuels in this way it is different from
from an emission trading scheme that
emission trading scheme is linked to a
certain emission reduction Target the
pricing of carbon is more linked to an
emission reduction Target whereas in the
carbon tax
the pricing of carbon is more linked to
the output or volume of emission
generated it is not essentially linked
to a pre- desired level of emission
reduction outcome and therefore in a
carbon taxation regime there's no
guarantee that the targets that are set
the budget of carbon that is allocated
will be necessarily met while in general
in short to Med medium to longterm an
emission trading scheme ensures that the
desired carbon reduction outcomes are
met also for an emission trading scheme
the carbon
revenues for through mechanisms such as
auction revenues are a function of
carbon price the emission cover and
other design features such as the method
of allow and location such as auctioning
and the availability of
reates if we look at the numbers in the
chart here compared to the year
2021 the global revenue from carbon
taxes and Tion trading schemes increased
by around 10 billion in year
2022 moreover revenues from carbon taxes
and emission trading schemes do by 10%
in 2022 reaching almost USD 95 billion
globally out of which 69% correspond to
emission trading scheme and relatively
less amount of 31% was ascribed to
carbon
taxes to summarize this video we
discussed two schemes of direct carbon
pricing that is emission trading scheme
and carbon taxation we noted that EDS or
emission trading scheme is different
from the carbon taxation in the sense
that ETS price to price carbon based on
certain emission reduction objective
while the objective of carbon taxation
or the modor opend of T carbon taxation
in direct carbon pricing is to link it
to some kind of activity emission
activity or level of
emissions lastly we also noted that
emission trading schemes have been found
to be more successful these are called
cap and trade based trading schemes
which set an overall budget or Target
for emission reduction they have been
found to be more
successful as the revenues from these
emission trading schemes have grown
exponentially and much higher as
compared to carbon taxation related
revenues which have stagnated and are
more gradual in their increase in the
last few years while ETS based revenues
such as auctions revenues from ETS
auctions have exponentially grown in the
previous video we discussed the concept
of carbon pricing we noted that carbon
pricing aims to make emitting carbon
dioxide and other greenhouse gases more
expensive and ensures that market actors
take account of the true cost of
emissions when making commercial
decisions businesses and households are
expected to incentivize to change their
production and consumption Behavior
promoting lower emission outcomes firms
and businesses are expected to seek to
minimize the cost associated with carbon
price by investing in the most cost
effective abatement Solutions at the
same time consumers will substitute
lower emission products as these gain a
relative cost advantage through these
processes over time low emission
producers will gain market share over
High emission
producers thus carbon pricing is
expected to play a critical role in
decarbonizing the economy lastly we also
noted two key instruments of carbon
pricing that is carbon taxes and
emission trading system systems in this
video we'll provide a contrasting
discussion between these two instruments
and their implications for carbon
pricing and the objectives related to
climate change
mitigation recall that in the context of
carbon taxes we said that these taxes
set a fixed price per unit of emissions
to help internalize the cost of
emissions and provide incentives for
carbon emission reductions in the
context of emission trading systems or
emission trading schemes that is ETS we
said that an ETS imposes a cap on the
total emissions in one or more sectors
of the economy the regulator issues a
number of tradable allowances what we
call as emission allowances not
exceeding the level of this aggregate
cap each allowance typically corresponds
to one ton of emissions and entities
covered by the emission trading system
are then allowed to trade these
allowances resulting in a market for the
allowances this type of emission Trading
scheme or emission trading system is
also called a cap and Trace based system
or
scheme a very important difference
between ETS and carbon taxes is that in
ETS prices
are not very certain there is
uncertainty in prices as they are Dem by
driven by demand and Supply so prices
are volatile we noted a very important
theoretical difference between such ETS
and carbon taxes is that in the the case
of ETS the level of emission reduction
is more certain because the cap which is
set in the ETS it dictates the total
emissions in the covered sectors however
like I said earlier in ETS the price is
not fixed and it is De determined by the
demand and supply of allowances in
contrast to carbon taxes the prices are
rather fixed because it is a certain
added component of the emission total
amount of emission and therefore the
prices that is imposed is certain and
different taxes the tax rate can be
adjusted periodically to achieve the
desired price level however this is not
so certain in the case of ETS where
there is some kind of price
uncertainty in the case of carbon taxes
it is difficult to estimate the emission
reductions or how much emission
reduction objectives can be met through
the tax rate exante and therefore making
it hard to align the emission Target
with the tax rate objective
in the context of ETS this cap provides
certainty on the upper limit of
emissions for the ETS which enables it
its alignment to a certain policy Target
depending upon the Target or budget that
has been set at the beginning of the
period for overall emissions between the
two systems which is carbon tax and ETS
ETS has been found to be more cost
effective this is so because ETS allows
for trading of permits between and
across enti
thus it allows for economic efficiency
between sectors how because the entity
which is more cost efficient in
mitigating emissions can do the same and
then sell the excess permits to The
Entity Which is less efficient in
mitigating the emissions and meet its
Target in contrast a taxation based
regime does not allow trading and there
across sectors of economy and therefore
it does not allow the benefits of
economic efficiency
gains effectively it imposes a fixed tax
between all the entities across all the
entities whether they are efficient in
mitigating the emission or not and
therefore they are uniformly taxed and
it this kind of Taxation regime does not
recognize the differentiation or the
different abilities of entities to
mitigate the
emissions
while an efficient system an emission
trading system is more complex to
implement because it requires additional
infrastructure in setting up a secondary
market for trading of
allowances the regulator in this case
needs to set up a market micr structure
and Market design that should result in
efficient price discovery which links
the carbon emission related
objectives with the carbon pricing
any inefficient pricing system or any
system which results in inefficient
price Discovery may have very adverse
consequences for such emission reduction
objectives and the entire objective of
the scheme in general in contrast
setting a carbon tax system is very
simple because already we have set up
different kind of Taxation regimes in
economy moreover the objectives related
to monitoring reporting and verification
which is very detailed and complicated
in the case of ETS is not as much
detailed and complicated and complex in
the case of carbon tax system in fact
one can rely on existing system of
different tax variants to
implement carbon taxation regime across
a broad range of sectors not much
analysis and scrutiny and due diligence
is needed as it is required in the case
of pts where particularly a very large
due diligence requires across sectors
depending upon the needs and
requirements and emission character
istics of different
sectors moreover another very important
difference between the two regimes is
the price predictability in case of ETS
price predictability is very difficult
because the price is determined by the
market forces of supply and demand and
therefore it depends on the economic
conditions and the amount of economic
activity happening in the economy and
therefore the prices are volatile they
change in the case of carbon taxation
regime because of the fixed nature of
Taxation the prices are less volatile
and more predictable because one can set
a predefined tax taxation structure
which provides some kind of stability to
the price signal to make a more informed
investment Decisions by different
entities covered in the scheme to
summarize in this video we compared and
contrasted the carbon Taxation and
emission trading systems on four broad
parameters including certainty of
emission levels and emission related
objectives cost Effectiveness ease of
administration and price predictability
we noted that while ETS is more
efficient in terms of ensuring emission
related objectives and efficiency gains
of economic activity Visa V Mitigation
Of emission reduction objectives and
cost Effectiveness it is difficult in
terms of administration and price
predictability that is prices can be
predictable and not very certain and
design of Market to achieve pricing
efficiency in the ETS is difficult as
compared to much easier Administration
and price predictability in the carbon
taxation regimes previously we noted
that carbon pricing instruments help
Channel economic activities toward a
lowc carbon future in this backdrop we
noted that the attractiveness of an
emission trading scheme or emission
trading system is simple it sets a limit
on total emissions while providing
incentives for mitigation to be achieved
at the lowest possible cost
in this video we'll try to understand
the functioning of an emission trading
system that is
ETS please note that under an ETS the
government imposes a limit or cap on the
total emissions in one or more sectors
of the economy and issues a number of
tradeable allowances not exceeding this
level of cap each allowance typically
corresponds to one ton of emission the
regulated entities in an ETS are
required to surrender one for every 10
of emissions for which they are
accountable entities that hold
additional allowances after surrendering
the allowances needed for compliance can
sell them or Bank them for future use
entities that require additional
allowances may buy them in the open
market also please note that placing a
cap on allowances and establishing a
market to trade them generates a uniform
allowance price which is also called the
carbon price
the this price incentivizes businesses
to reduce the emissions from their
operations if the cost of reducing
emissions is lower than this
price this price reflects the stringency
of the cap for example a more stringent
cap means fewer allowances are issued
all Z being equal this results in higher
prices and
therefore a stronger incentive for
businesses to avoid the carbon price by
reducing their emissions in this manner
the allowance price acts as a signal
that favors lower emission goods and
services setting the cap in advance
provides a long-term Market signal so
that partments can plan and invest
accordingly in
advance in this backdrop we note that an
emission ETS or a cap and trade program
is managed by a governing jurisdiction
or regulatory body that sets a limit or
cap on the total level of covered
greenhouse gas emissions including CO2
or equivalent tons of CO2
the allowances to emit are distributed
to the liable or covered
entities that must redeem allowances for
every emitted T of CO2 or carbon with
the possibility to buy additional aanes
or sell the unused
ones as the liable entities consider the
cost of their emissions within their
production processes and the possibility
to buy or sell allowances a market for
CO2 emerges which leads to supply and
demand forces
this sets the price on co2 that then
acts as a reduction incentive for all
the liable
entities thus this price influences
decisions both in the short-term
management of existing assets and in the
long-term direction of Investments and
the idea is to facilitate and promote
investment into green on Renewable
Energy
Technologies lastly an ETS as opposed to
a tax is a quantity based policy that is
it offers certainty over environmental
outcome which is the cap set in the
policy but also it leaves to the market
that is trading activity across Market
participants and generating Supply
demand forces to set the price of the
carbon to summarize this video we noted
that an emission trading scheme or
emission trading system is a cap and R
based program where an overall Target
based on the emission reduction
objectives is set by the regulat
regulatory body subsequently this
overall cap is distributed amongst the
covered installations and
the installations with Surplus are the
supplying ones and those with falling
short are demanding ones this supply and
demand forces they meet in the market
and trade the permits amongst each other
thus through the supply and demand
forces the carbon price naturally
emerges emerges organically and a fair
Discovery fair price Discovery and
efficient price Discovery occurs which
provides a price to carbon which is
market-based and and captures the
scarcity of environment and also is
aligned to the emission reduction
objectives of the overall scheme in this
video we'll try to understand the
functioning of UTS with the help of a
simple example UTS or European Union
emission trading scheme is a cap and
trade based system which works by
capping the overall GG emissions of all
participants in the
system the European Union emission
trading scheme or euds legislation
creates allowances which are essentially
rights to emit greenhouse gas emissions
equivalent to global warming potential
of 1
ton equivalent of CO2 or
carbon the level of cap here determines
the number of allowances available in
the whole system the cap is designed to
decrease annually from 2013 reducing the
number of allowances available to
businesses covered by UTS by 1.74% % per
year this allows companies to slowly
adjust and set their expectations to
meet the target which is increasingly
ambitious and overall Target for
emission
reductions each year a bulk of
allowances are
auctioned and a small proportion of
allowances are also given to the
participants for free particularly in
the sectors where there is a
considerable potential risk if they pay
the full cost of pollution allowances
they need
that production and also pollution could
shift to countries with less ambitious
emission reduction
action at the end of the year the
participants must return an allowance
for every ton of carbon or CO2
equivalent emission they make during
that year if a participant has
insufficient amount of allowances then
they must either take measures to reduce
their emissions or buy more allowances
from the market or through auction from
Market I mean trading from from such U
ETS trading scheme they can trade among
those who have Surplus allowances they
can buy from them let us look at the
simple example of factory installation A
and B who are emitters in this example
Factory B does not have enough free
allowances to cover its emissions so it
can either comply with the cap by buying
allowances from Factory a or from the
auction
itself if a parent emission of
greenhouse gases exceed the free
allowances they were given at the start
of the year then they can buy allowances
from the auctions from or from other
participants in their scheme trading
scheme in through the
market who would be these participants
these are the participants who have
reduced their emissions and therefore
they have Surplus allowances
participants can also decide to bank
allow so if you have Surplus allowances
you can Bank it for future years this
has also been allowed
now now these allowances have value
because they their supply is limited or
capped and this demand from them
particularly from those parti spent whom
the cost of making reductions are higher
than other participants so in this
manner it allows the effort to be
redistributed across participants so
that emission reduction takes place in
areas where it costs less which is the
gain in efficiency this is good for the
business and economy and thus complies
ensured through the penalty and
enforcement structure significant fines
are imposed if a plant manufacturing
installation or a company fails to
comply by surrending sufficient
alliances in time this penalty set at
100 euro per ton equivalent of CO2
emission and it rises with inflation
from
2013 in addition Farms face an
obligation to surrender the allowances
owed and thus the cap or what we call as
the target environmental Target is
maintained in an efficient
manner so now let's summarize our
understanding we said that carbon
allowances are traded in primary and
secondary
Market
Regulators which is the regulatory body
which is in this case can be thought of
as
EU they typically auction or
distribute for free these allowances to
the regulatory entities through primary
markets to comply with their emission
limits once regulated companies are
alloted this allowance they can trade it
in secondary Market in line their
emission requirements they can use they
can make use of both spot and derivative
contracts such as Futures options and
swaps now let's look at this simple
visualization here this regulatory body
issues allowances to forms A and
B these allowances will be used by A and
B to set off their emissions in a given
year however it is possible that one of
these installation is in Surplus while
the other one is falling short for
example
this one because it has less pollution
it is in Surplus while this has excess
emission so it is falling short for its
allowances now the installation a let's
say it may find cheaper to improve its
technology this installation a might
find cheaper to improve its technology
and through these technical enhancements
it can decrease its emission level so it
can have lower emission and thus ending
up with Surplus allowances in contrast
installation
B might find it difficult or costlier to
improve the technology and thus while
installation a ends up in Surplus B ends
up in Falling short of its allowance
requirement corresponding to the
respective emission levels now these two
and more installations will meet in the
designated Marketplace so they will meet
in the secondary Marketplace and the
ones with Surplus will sell and benefit
from the revenues while those falling
short will buy these allowances this
Market or emission trading scheme also
has intermediaries which are essentially
liquidity providers who will Who would
have probably bought these allowances
during auctions and are willing to buy
and sell these allowances in this
secondary Market to ensure continuous
Market making and smooth functioning of
this emission trading scheme so they are
sort of market makers you can call them
Brokers or broker dealers or liquidity
providers or market makers overall this
mechanism leads to efficiency gains that
is those installations that are better
place to reduce emissions through
technological advancements and those
installations that find it difficult
they simply pay for it in open market to
buy lances and thus in turn supporting
it in the market to summarize in simple
terms climate change refers to man-made
long-term shifts in temperature and
weather patterns that have adverse
consequences on the life on
Earth in this backdrop financing of
projects that support mitigation of
climate change is referred to as climate
Finance in this backdrop carbon pricing
plays a very important role in
quantifying these adverse effects of
greenhouse gas Emissions on the
environment another very important
concept is abatement cost which is the
cost of intervention to reduce per ton
carbon equivalent of greenhouse gas
emissions in this backdrop two direct
pricing mechanisms have emerged to link
carbon with economic activity and the
emission of greenhouse gases first is
carbon taxes where resulting carbon
price is known exante depending upon the
level of taxes however in case of car
taxes the emission reduction objectives
are not well anchored in contrast
emission trading is more Market oriented
approach that provides more control and
Clarity on emission reduction objectives
however the carbon prices resulting from
emission trading systems are uncertain
and volatile depending upon the market
quality parameters such as liquidity and
volatility emission trading systems are
generally cap and trade based systems
which employ a cap on overall emissions
then allowances equalent to this cap are
distributed amongst the permitted
installations these installations have
to provide allowances equivalent to
their emissions at the end of each
operational year those installations
that have excess allowances can sell
those falling short can buy in an
emission trading scheme including
instruments such as direct Market or OTC
based
[Music]
trades
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
