Prof AT Jan24 Lec 15

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Feb 16, 2024
[Music]
in this lesson we'll introduce European
Union emion trading system and its
Evolution over the three phases of its
implementation we'll also discuss the
role of European Union emion trading
system in emission reduction objectives
each phase of euts implementation or
European Union emission trading system
implementation had certain objectives
related to carbon pricing and emission
reduction we discussed these in detail
we'll also discuss the key features of
euds across all the three phases of its
implementation and the carbon pricing
over these three phases next we discuss
the euts annual cycle pertaining to
monitoring and Reporting and
verification of emission allowances
we'll also discuss the methods of
allowance allocation namely free
allowance allocation through
benchmarking and grandfathering and
auction method of allowance allocation
we'll also discuss some of the important
advantages and disadvantages of these
methods in this video we'll introduce
the European Union emion trading system
or what we call as European Union
emission trading scheme its features and
its implementation over the four
phases to begin with the European Union
emission trading system or also referred
to as emission Trading scheme is a c and
rate system as we have noted earlier it
caps the total volume of greenhouse gas
emission from the responsible
installations for around 50% of the
overall European Union greenhouse gas
emissions so it covers around 50% of
emissions the system allows trading of
emission allowances so that the total
emissions of the installation stays
within the cap and the least cost
measures can be taken up to reduce
emissions in an efficient manner as we
have discussed in the previous videos
now therefore this U is a major tool of
European Union in its efforts to meet
emission reduction targets now and in
the future as
well the trading approach helps to
combat climate change in a coste
effective and economically efficient
manner as the first and one of the
largest emission trading system across
the world it is the largest and most
successful trading system for reducing
greenhouse gas greenhouse gas emissions
or what we call as ghg ghg greenhouse
gas
emissions it covers more than 11,000
installations in 31 countries European
countries the system was first
introduced in 2005 and has gone several
changes since then the implementation of
system has been divided into four phases
over time and these phases are as
follows first phase ran from 2005 to
2007 it was a three-year pilot phase
aimed to create infrastructure for the
free trade of carbon and establishing
its pricing
mechanism this phase was marked with
lower carbon prices as Supply exceeded
demand many times in the absence of
reliable emission data next phase phase
two ran from 2008 to 2012 in the
previous pilot Phase 1 it served to
create headways in recording verified
direct emissions data which proved very
useful for phase two using this
emissions data Regulators created an
emissions cap for various farms and
reduced the carbon allowance Supply
however 2008 Global financial crisis
resulted in dampened economic activities
leading to lower demand for carbon
allowances driving prices further down
next we have phase three which ran from
2013 to
2020 the over supply of carbon
allowances in phases one and two laid
the foundation of this phase which
mainly focused on regulating the excess
Supply this phase experienced an
increase in carbon prices on the back of
reforms such as backloading Market
stability reserve and annual reduction
of carbon allowance cap among others
this we'll discuss in more details in
subsequent discussions currently we are
in phase four which is from 2021 and
Beyond up till 2030 So currently we are
in phase four the fourth phase
introduced more and stringent policy
measures to reduce the carbon emissions
for example the allowance Supply cap
will at a higher rate of 2.22% every
year compared to 1.74% earlier so earli
it was 1.74% per year now it has been
increased to
2.22% this phase also focused on
providing funding mechanisms for low
carbon Innovations to help energy
intensive sectors in their transition to
low carbon
economy to summarize in this video we
introduced the European Union emion
trading system and we also discussed
some of its key features and its
Evolution across L fa for four phases we
noted that in initial phases the pilot
phase and phase two the scheme was
evolving and it has certain features
which adversely affected prices such as
over supply of allowances leading to
lower prices however from phase three
and now in phase four the scheme has
evolved and matured leading to more
efficient pricing which is linked to
carbon emissions in this video we
discussed the benefits of UTS cap and
trade
scheme we Tred to answer the question
why you chose a cap and trade structure
and also what are the direct explicit
benefits of this scheme to EU over short
to medium-term as well as on long
term to answer this question by you
chose a cap and trates structure you
chose this as the best means of meeting
the ghg or greenhouse gas emission
reduction Target at least overall cost
to participants and the economy as a
whole it allows us set of environmental
outcomes to be achieved at the lowest
cost a traditional command and control
approach May mandate a standard limit
for installation but provides little
flexibility to companies as to where or
how emission reduction objectives would
be made a taxation regime does not
guarantee that these greenhouse gas
emissions or reduction targets will be
achieved in a multinational system
agreement that kind or custom that would
be required across all
countries on the right price for the
carbon it is also very difficult to
determine the right price of carbon to
obtain the cut in
emissions without under or over charging
companies or installations so it offers
a sort of flexibility which plays a very
important
role that is the trading allows
companies in the system to determine
what the least cost option is for them
to to meet a fixed cap the carbon price
is then set by the market or in a
market-based mechanism through trading
and based on a wide range of factors the
flexibility of cap and trade combined
with other key benefits played a very
important role in the choice of cap and
trade structure let us now discuss some
of the explicit benefits of this scheme
let us now highlight some of the
explicit benefits of the cap and trade
scheme to begin with we have certainty
about quantity that is GM emissions
trading directly limits the greenhouse
gas emissions by setting a systemwide
cap that is designed to ensure
compliance with the relevant
commitment that is there is certainty
about the maximum quantity of greenhouse
gas emissions for the period of time
over which system caps are set this is
relevant for supporting the eu's
international objectives and obligations
and achieving environmental goals next
we have cost Effectiveness trading
reveals the the carbon price to meet the
desired Target the flexibility that
trading brings means that all firms face
the same carbon price and ensures that
emissions are cut where it cost least to
do so next we have revenues if
greenhouse gas emission allowances are
auctioned this creates a source of
revenue for
governments at least 50% of which is
expected to be used to fund measures to
tackle climate change in the EU and
other memb
States lastly we have minimizing risk to
member State budgets the European Union
emission trading system provides
certainty to emission reduction from
installations responsible for around 50%
of U
emissions this reduces the risk that
member state will need to purchase
additional International emission units
to meet their International commitments
under the Cotto
protocol to summarize this video we
discussed four explicit benefits and the
flexibility that is available because of
this cap and trade based trading scheme
to EU and that is why it chose this cap
and Trace based scheme these benefits
included certainty about the quantity
related to the targeted emission
reductions its cost Effectiveness its
auxiliary Revenue potential and also
minimizing risk to member State budgets
for meeting their International
commitments in a series of next few
videos we'll discuss the evolution of
UTS in a phase-wise man starting from
phase
one eets was set up in 2005 it is the
world's first International emission
trading system and now currently it is
in fourth phase running from 2021 to
2030 let us start by discussing the
history of
UBS the Kyoto Protocol of the UN
framework convention for climate change
that is unfccc was agreed upon in
1997 and it set the legally Bing
greenhouse gas reduction targets or what
we call as caps for 37 industrialized
countries for the first commitment
period which runs from 2008 to
2012 this led to the need for policy
instruments to meet the Kyo commitments
in March 2000 the European commission
presented a green paper on greenhouse
gas emissions trading within the
European
Union with the first ideas on the
designs of UTS represent in this paper
this paper served as a basis for
numerous stakeholder discussions that
help shape the UTS in the first phases
this led to the adoption of UTS
directive in 2003 and introduction of
UTS in
2005 the Caps or the targets on
allowances was set at National level
through what we call as National
allocation
plans the first phase of UTS from 2005
to 2007 was was considered as a pilot
phase this phase was used to test price
formation in the carbon market and to
establish the necessary infrastructure
for monitoring reporting and
verification of emissions what we call
as Mr RV M for monitoring R for
reporting and V for verification the cap
in this phase was largely based on
estimates as there was no reliable
emission data
available in this phase it was a
three-year kind of pilot for what we
call as by learning by
doing to prepare for phase two when the
eets would need to function effectively
to help EU meet its Q2 targets let us
discuss some of the key features of
phase one phase one covered only CO2
emissions from power generators and
energy intensive
Industries also almost all laces were
given to businesses for
free we'll discuss some of these
Concepts later as well the penalty for
non-compliance was €40 per ton of carbon
emission now this phase one it succeeded
in establishing a price for carbon a
reliable price for carbon also it
established free trade in emission
allowances across EU through this U ETS
scheme and also it provided for the much
needed infrastructure to monitor report
and verify emissions from the businesses
covered
however in the absence of reliable
emission data in Phase One caps were set
on the basis of estimates only as a
result the total amount of
allowances issued exceeded the emissions
and therefore it resulted in over Supply
which significantly exceeded the demand
for permits and then in 2000 the prices
of allowances fell to zero because of
this precise issue because phase one
allowances could not be banked for use
in phase two we'll discuss the concept
of banking later as well but essentially
it meant carry forwarding of current
allowances in the subsequent phases in
the absence of banking all such over
supply of allowances became worthless
and prices fell to zero as you can see
here in this diagram we were able to set
up some kind of price around €0 which
though was fluctuating but stabilizing
but suddenly because of the over Supply
there was a sharp fall it felt in this
around 20066 April it fell to 10 and
then again it fell to zero this was in
2007 this sharp fall to zero reflected
that over supply of these emission
permits as compared to the emission so
Supply exceeded demand Supply far
exceeded the demand because there were
more us while demand was less this
demand was established based on the
verified emissions data that was made
public and subsequently prices
fell to summarize in this video we
introduced The Evolution of U scheme in
the phase one we noted some of its key
features and some of its achievements
what it established we also noted some
of the problems in this phase related to
pricing particularly the over supply of
permits as compared to the demand
leading to Sharp price fall in this
video we'll discuss the evolution of
eets in its phase two the second phase
of UTS ran from
2018 to
2012 the same period as the first
commitment period under Pho protocol
from 2008 businesses could also use
emission reduction units generated under
joint implementation that is ji to
fulfill their obligations under euts
this made the euts the largest source of
demand for CDM which is clean
development mechanism and ji emission
reduction units we'll discuss these
concept related to CDM clean development
mechanism and ji joint implementation in
subsequent videos towards the end of
phase two the scope of UTS was expanded
Ed by including Aviation as
well let us discuss some of the key
features of this phase two first and
foremost this phase two coincided with
the first commitment period of Cotto
protocol where the countries in the euts
had concrete emission reduction targets
to meet second the lower cap on
allowances was available that is
somewhat around 6.5% lower as compared
to
2005 and also new countries joined
including three particular L
Iceland lanstein and Norway so three
countries
joined also nitrous oxide emissions from
the production of nitric acid included
by a number of
countries next the proportion of
reallocation fell slightly to around
90% several countries started holding
auctions which also acted as source of
Revenue the penalty for non-compliance
was increased to 100 euro per 10 and
then businesses were allowed to buy
International credits totaling around
1.4 billion tons of CO2
equivalent another important feature was
that Union registry replaced National
Registries and the European Union
transaction log replaced the community
independent transaction
log the aviation sector was brought into
the UTS on 1st January 2012 although
application for flights to went from
non-european countries was suspended for
2012 importantly because now verified
annual emissions data on the pilot phase
was not available the cap on allowances
was reduced in phase two based on actual
emissions however in 2008 economic
crisis the crisis led to emission
reductions that were far greater than
expected and this led to a large surplus
of allowances and excess credits which
weighed heavily on the carbon price
through phase two resulting in slight
slightly slight decrease in prices in
2008 to summarize in this video we
introduced the evolution of phase 2 from
2008 to 12 which fell around the same
time as first commitment of CTO protocol
we noted that the eut scheme expanded
with number of changes and improvements
during this phase however still some
concerns remained particularly driven by
the 2008 economic crisis in this video
we'll discuss the evolution of UTS
around its phases three and four
phase three running from 2013 to 20 the
third phase of the UTS was shared by the
lessons learned from the previous two
phases Phase 1 and two and in particular
significant efforts were taken to
improve the harmonization of scheme
across the EU following a review of UTS
agreed upon in
2008 in phases 1 and two running from
2005 so phase one ran from 2005 to 7 and
phase two ran from 2008 to 12 which was
the first commitment period free
allowances were allocated according to
member State specific National
allocation plans or what we call as naps
during the first phase of U the process
of preparing these naps was found to be
timec consuming complex and not
sufficiently transparent and
harmonized therefore the European
commission emphasized the need to make
phase two nap simpler and more
transparent and more harmonized and
therefore from third trading period
onward which began in
2013 up till 2020 naps are no longer
used instead allocation is determined
through common rules agreed directly at
EU level and member states were required
to prepare an allocation plan now which
is known as National implementation
measures or nms national implementation
measures
document the third phase which is
running from 2030 to 20 it coincides
with the Kyoto Protocol second
commitment period as agreed in Doha in
December
2012 the EU is one of the jurisdictions
that has committed to a Target under the
second commitment period and the UTS
will be key in achieving that Target
nonetheless the UTS is defined by EU
legislation and operates independently
of the actions of other countries under
the unfccc United
Nations
framework and underlining the commitment
of the EU to tackle climate change the
UTS does not have an end date and
continues Beyond phase three and
currently is running in Phase 4 so the
reform of the ETS framework in phase
three changed the system considerably
from phases 1 and two and let us discuss
some of the key features of
this to begin
with a single EU wide cap on emissions
was put in place of the previous system
of national caps
second auctioning as the default method
for allocating allowances was chosen
instead of free
allocation harmonized allocation rules
were applied to the allowances still
given away for free more sectors and
guesses were
included 3 million allowances set aside
for new interest reserved to fund the
deployment of innovative Renewable
Energy Technologies and carbon capture
and storage through the N300 program
N300
program in phase three of UTS which is
running from 2013 to 2020 the union wide
cap European Union wide cap for
stationary installations decreased each
year by a linear factor of
1.74% the 2013 cap was set on the basis
of the average total quantity of Alles
issued annually in 2008 to
12 coming to phase four some of the key
features for phase four were as follows
the laan Supply cap was supposed to
reduce at a higher rate of 2.22% each
year as compared to 1.74% earlier as of
2021 emissions from UK installations
previously covered by UTS are no longer
considered in the cap the initial volume
of Neer at the start of phase 4 amounted
to 331 million Alles this included
unallocated allowances from phase three
and 200 million allowances from the
market stability Reserve MSR we'll
discuss this MSR Concept in subsequent
discussions unlimited banking has been
allowed since 2008 but borrowing is not
allowed explicitly however implicit
borrowing within trading periods is
allowed which is the use of allowances
allocated in the current year for
compliance in the previous year as of
2020 eets and the Swiss ETS are linked
which means that allowances issued in
one system can be surrendered for
emissions generated in either of the two
systems the linking agreement between
the EU and Switzerland sets out the
conditions and requirements under which
the two systems are linked a direct link
was created between the Registries of
both the systems which allowed regulated
entities to transfer allowances from one
account in one system to another account
in the system these transfers are
planned generally taking place twice a
month to summarize this video we noted
that U scheme which was implemented
earlier in phases 1 and two considerably
improved in phases three and four in
particular the number and amount of
installations and gases that were
covered that improved substantially
moreover the scheme became more
efficient and seamless across different
member nations as policies were
streamlined and also the targets that
were supposed to achieved within a given
time frame they were accelerated in this
video we'll discuss the evolution of UDS
in particular we'll focus on the price
and volume and trading volume Dynamics
at European Union emission trading
system to begin with in the back of
robust fundamentals the market and
emission allowances developed very
strongly from the beginning in Phase One
the trading volumes Rose
from
321 million allowances to 1.1 billion
allowances in 2006 and 2.1 billion Alles
in 2007 so to
1.1 to 2.1 according to the world bank's
annual carbon market reports in fact the
European Union emission trading system
remained the main driver of the
international carbon markets during
phase two for example in 2010 European
Union allowances accounted for almost
85% of the value of the total Global
carbon market trading volumes jumped
from 3.1 billion in 2008 to 6.3 billion
in 2009 a phenomenal jump in 2012 7.9
billion Alles were traded which wor
56 billion
euros in fact the D daily trading
volumes exceeded 70 million in mid of
2011 indicating very strong liquidity
and trading activity in the
market however this period was also
characterized by certain price dynamics
that is interesting to note during the
early phases phases 1 and two they were
characterized by the over supply of
carbon allowances and this led to the
expectation that demand is less while
Supply is more and therefore lobal lower
carbon price as we can see here in Phase
1 and two in fact previously price also
fell too close to zero as we discussed
earlier but around by the end of phase
two it was hovering around
$20 now gradually as market dynamics was
understood and Market Regulators
understood how prices were working they
tried to resolve this problem of over
Supply and certain mechanisms such as
backloading of carbon allowance auctions
as well as introduction of MSR led to
expectations that in future the supply
will not exceed the demand and therefore
there was a strong recovery happening
there onwards this recovery was
predominantly in anticipation of lot of
reforms such as this backloading of
allowances Market stability reserve and
various other
reforms particularly as you can see when
MSR Market stability Reserve was
introduced to address this problem of
War supply of carbon allowances there
was a very strong
recovery however around this period
around 2020 because of covid there was a
sharp
fall because it was expected due to
crisis economic activity and economic
growth would be lower and therefore
demand of these allowances would be
lower while given the supply because
Supply was well planned in advance there
will be more Supply so prices fell but
again after covid period was over there
was a strong
recovery and also there were certain
reforms which are visible in the form of
this
very strong rise in the prices although
here there was this was the period of
Russia Ukraine war and tumultuous
economic activity in the Euro region so
because of this there's increase in
volatility and shpall here but in
general the expectation are that once
these geop political crisis situations
will stabilize prices will again see a
steady recovery and low volatility
periods characterized by good Market
quality now let us summarize what has
happened in Phase 1 to 4 in a more
structured manner first it is phase one
which ran from 2005 to 2007 this phase
one was a three-year pilot phase it was
a pilot phase test phase which aimed at
creating an infrastructure for free
trade of carbon and establishing its
pricing mechanism this this particular
phase was also marked with lower carbon
prices as Supply exceeded the demand in
the absence of reliable MSE
data next we come to phase 2 P2 which
ran from 2008 to 12 the pilot Phase 1
served to create headways in recording
verified direct emissions data which
proved to be useful in phase two using
emissions data Regulators created an
emission cap for various farms and
reduced the carbon allowances Supply
although 2008 Global financial crisis
resulted in lower and dampened economic
activities leading to lower demand for
carbon allowances driving the prices
down next we come to phase
three that ran from 2013 to
2020 in this period in this particular
phase three the over supply of
allowances in Phase 1 and two late the
foundation of this particular phase a
lot of learning happened which mainly
focused on regulating the excess Supply
so this phase experienced an increase in
carbon prices with these
reforms on the back of reforms such as
backloading Market stability reserve and
annual reduction of carbon allowance cap
and so on so this led to a robust
recovery of prices lastly we have phase
four which ran and currently running it
is starts from 2021 and will go up till
2030 this fourth phase in use more
stringent policy measures to reduce the
carbon emission for example the
allowance of Supply cap will reduce at a
higher rate at
2.22% every year as compared to 1.7%
earlier this phase also focused on
providing funding mechanisms for low
carbon Innovations to help energy
intensive sectors in their transition to
low carbon
economy so overall we can say the EVS
scheme started with its robust
fundamental though initial period there
was certain hiccups but now as we move
ahead in the four we move in the fourth
phase the prices and trading activity
has to a great extent achieved their
objectives the prices are linked to
economic activity and they reflect the
scarcity of environment its ability the
environment's ability to absorb
greenhouse gases which is nicely and
very efficiently captured in the carbon
pricing so the prices in a way we can
say has become efficient and attain its
objective and given the trading volumes
are so large it almost account for more
than 85% of the global carbon Market
Dynamics so it's a very important and
more successful carbon Market UTS as we
have understood in this video we'll
introduce UTS compliance
cycle this compliance cycle runs for the
entire calendar year from January to
December and it employs three very
important steps of monitoring reporting
and verification that we are going to
explore in more
detail to begin with this UTS compliance
cycle starts with the calendar year in
1st of
January which is is the start of
monitoring for the period of current
year next date important date is 28th
February
where the allowances are received in
these can be free
allowances when the installations
receive these few Alles for the current
year emissions often the installations
borrow these allowances for previous
year's emissions for meeting previous
year's amission targets they often use
them as borrowing so that this 20th
February alls received also help in that
on 31st of
March they are submitting the verified
emissions report to competent Authority
for the previous year and also the
entries of verified emission data in the
registry so the verified emission data
is entered
and emission reports are submitted
verified emission reports are
submitted on 30th
April allowances are
surrendered for the previous year so
depending upon the the emission levels
in the previous year the laces are
submitted in fact The Operators
installations they are requested by
their competent authorities to submit
these verified emission reports of the
previous year as early as 28th February
which is this next on 30th June by
June they are supposed to submit their
Improvement or non-conformity report so
if there is any non-conformity that
report is to be submitted corresponding
to the previous year by to competent
Authority
by the third quarter verifier is
expected to start the verification
process for the current year so the
current year verification starts by
third quarter and by December end it is
expected to prepare the annual emission
report for the current year so by
December the entire process of
continuous monitoring plus
trading and the verification takes place
through the entire year if there are any
changes that also continuously takes
place if there any changes to then
approval is is needed in the current
monitoring plan through the year so that
those changes needs to be incorporated
but this continuous monitoring reporting
and verification process runs like this
and this entire
process ends on 31st
December and the all the entire data of
monitoring and any changes are submitted
to the competent Authority so the entire
process has three very important
components monitoring reporting and
verification of the
data this along on with all the
associated process is known as ETS
compliance cycle as we discussed the
entire cycle of monitoring reporting and
verification let us discuss the three
components of this process individually
so first we have
monitoring this is the process of
gathering data that is used to determine
emissions produced or save it can be
based on Direct emissions monitoring or
calculation methods that derive
emissions from other parameters such as
fuel use
then we have
reporting reporting is the mechanism and
infrastructure by which the regulated
entity provides emissions information to
the regulator this can emply a range of
possible tools from use of templates to
electronic reporting systems and web
interfaces in fact more sophisticated
reporting system can include workflow
management for more holistic fation of
engagements between regulators verifiers
and operators during the entire this
entire compliance cycle
and lastly we have verification process
as part of verification process it is it
requires thirdparty checking of correct
application of the monitoring method and
accuracy of the reported emissions
verifiers will be independent from
operators and should be accredited to
carry out their work in accordance with
the established standards and protocols
so to conclude this mrv or monitoring
reporting verification system it is at
the core of ETS this mrv system is at
the core of emission trading system as
it is essential to assure the
environmental Integrity of the system it
is the means by which participants
determine their emissions and the number
of allowances that they must surrender
so this mrv or monitoring reporting
verification system underpins the demand
for allowance in the market and robust
mrv systems build confidence in the
market that emission reductions are real
and
accurate to summarize this video we
introduced the concept of mrv which is
monitoring reporting and verification as
an integral part of UTS compliance cycle
we also discussed how over the entire
calendar year from January to December
the UTS compliance cycle runs with
different
[Music]
[Music]
steps
[Music]
