Rep. Barkis discusses Washington's housing crisis on TVW's Inside Olympia | Feb. 1, 2024

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
1 Video View·Feb 2, 2024
Rep. Andrew Barkis, who is intently focused on fixing Washington's housing crisis, recently sat down with TVW's Austin Jenkins to discuss the issue.
Learn more about Rep. Barkis: representativeandrewbarkis.com
this week on inside Olympia housing is
one of the most pressing issues facing
Washington State there's not enough of
it it's expensive and much more will be
needed in the coming years so what
strategies is the state legislature
considering to grow the housing Supply
and address affordability on the program
Democratic state representative Emily
Alvarado Vice chair of the housing
Committee in the house and Andrew barcus
a republican member of that
committee
from the tvw studio it's inside Olympia
with host Austin
[Music]
Jenkins and welcome to inside Olympia it
is estimated that the state of
Washington will need a million more
housing units by 2044 and at least half
of those units will have to be
affordable for the lowest income
washingtonians so who will build that
housing what will it take to build that
much housing stock over 20 years and in
the meantime what actions can the state
legislature take to incentivize housing
density and take a bite out of the
existing housing shortage plus what can
be done about housing affordability and
Rising rents joining me now and for the
full hour this week to discuss one of
the most pressing challenges facing the
state are two members of the housing
Committee in the State House Democrat
Emily Alvarado is the vice chair of that
committee she's also the former director
of the city of Seattle's Housing Office
Republican Andrew barcus is a longtime
member of the housing committee who also
runs a property management company
welcome both ins Olympia good to see you
thanks for having us we have a full hour
to talk about this issue it is one of
the most pressing issues facing the
state it's also something that has uh
brought together Democrats and
Republicans to really work to try to
come up with some solutions you don't
always see eye to ey but are certainly
working together and at times finding
bipartison Solutions so let's start with
a couple of setting the table questions
um the first one is just how does the
work you each have done in your private
lives professional lives in this space
how is it influen ing the work you're
doing let me start with you
representative Alvarado as I said you
headed up the Seattle Housing Office you
now work for a nonprofit that does
housing work nationally how is that
informing your thinking about policy in
the in the state legislature yeah well
thank you so much for having us in this
important conversation um I've spent
most of my career working in housing and
it's clear to me for many years that we
don't have enough housing and that the
impact of that housing shortage
disproportionately impacts lower income
people so from my experience I know that
we need the market to produce more
housing overall but we also need
directed Investments that are going to
help produce housing that's affordable
to lower income people that won't ever
be provided by the market and we have to
take steps that are quick and immediate
to help people who are struggling with
affordability okay that's um same
question for you you come at this from a
different perhaps perspective but what
is that perspective and how is it
informing well I think there's good
commonality in the perspective I've been
in the property management business for
uh over almost 30 years it's hard to
believe uh in all in all aspects multif
family and single family and still have
a single family management company here
in thirston County um so I've housed
thousands and thousands of people I mean
our job is to provide that housing and
um you I've seen the changes in landlord
tenant law I've seen the constraints of
Supply I've seen the market go up and
down and when I became legislator in
2016 um immediately uh started to see
that there was policy moving forward in
this in this Arena and volunteered and
you know spoke out and said hey I I I
might know how to help in this Arena and
from that moment on uh just became one
of the subject experts uh worked uh
within our caucus and of course
bipartisan on a lot of policy around
landlord tenant and then of course in
the supply side issue working with uh
the stakeholders to to try to get at
that and um so bringing that uh private
sector bringing that industry
perspective uh to the policy
conversation I think has been very
informative and like representative
Alvarado with her perspective and the
different things you have to have both
of those when you're looking at the
thing in totality so uh always uh
beneficial to have people who actually
work within the space to uh to be uh
leaders in the policy discussions and
ultimately the legislation that comes
out of that one of the things that I I
especially going back to that statistic
about how many more units of housing the
state will need I'm struck by the the
fact that some problems that confront
policy makers you maybe couldn't predict
or wouldn't have been able to predict
but shouldn't we have predicted this
housing deficit because we are
constantly modeling our population
growth and it seems like we dug
ourselves a gigantic hole and getting
out of it I don't know how you will do
in 20 years but do you have any thoughts
on how we and and I will acknowledge
that almost every state in the country
is dealing with this the headlines from
state capitals across the country right
now are about housing housing
affordability lack of housing red States
blue States so we're not alone but
nonetheless how' this
happen yeah well we have um it's it's
multiple factors that have come together
to put us in as you said the deficit
that we have now um and a few things
have been in place one we've had very
restrictive zoning in our state and in
other states as well that really has
restricted the amount of homes that
we're able to build and the diversity of
homes that we're able to build um we
have created systems around permitting
that are well-intentioned um but often
have created barriers to being able to
get housing built quickly we have
financing gaps that are significant in
our communities we know that land is
expensive so that by the time you put
together uh the financing that's
necessary to build housing it's no
longer affordable and we need public
subsidy and public financing to come in
and we've seen quite frankly obstacles
to addressing all of those things we've
seen communities that haven't wanted to
change their zoning we've seen local uh
communities cities and counties who have
been unwilling to take action to free up
zoning we've seen systems that are built
that put barriers like permitting in
place and we have seen a complete lack
of sustain and dedicated investment in
affordable housing and that is a
critical piece to make sure that the
financing is in place to build the
affordable homes which you said half of
the homes that we need need to be
affordable and we have no dedicated
funding source in this state to fund
affordable housing and it's interesting
you say that because as somebody who
covered the state legislature in the
state for almost 20 years I always heard
about the Housing Trust Fund I always
heard about putting more money into it
and what it would build and so just as a
by way of a brief followup given that
commitment and given the fact we have
that was it just not enough too little
too late what why wasn't the Housing
Trust Fund our our path to building that
affordable housing yeah absolutely the
Housing Trust Fund is the state's most
effective tool at funding affordable
housing and it has been very effective
you see right now though that it's
oversubscribed there is more opportunity
to build housing including housing
that's supporting people exiting
homelessness low wage work workers
people with disabilities across the
state in Rural and suburban and urban
communities that quite frankly does not
have the available funding from the
state to be able to move forward we can
make immediate progress with resources
the other piece is that the Housing
Trust Fund falls under the capital
budget and it takes an annual fight to
get the kind of resource that's
dedicated as part of that Housing Trust
Fund what we're looking for this year is
a bill the affordable homes act which
would establish a dedicated resource so
that communities can plan developers can
buy land and build a pipeline and we can
have assurance that we can build the
affordable homes we need know that the
money will be there exactly okay so same
question how did we get to a million
household or a million unit deficit in a
state that has you know the office of
financial management is putting out
population projections annually and we
have the census numbers this is where
we're going to agree and disagree right
so that'll make it interesting yeah it
should and you know um the Housing Trust
Fund is but one tool and I think if you
remember when I was on your program last
time with represent bitman we were
talking about midal housing I think the
stat was around 40,000 we've only built
around 40,000 units in the entirety of
the existence of that program we're not
going to build our way out of this
problem and a million homes using the
Housing Trust Fund it serves a purpose
within a certain Arena but it is
extremely expensive to build any type of
unit in the state of Washington that's
part of our problem when we talk about
removing the barriers even for Housing
Trust Fund money into those type of
programs and projects and and and
low-income housing or whatever it might
be you have to go back several years I
mean in our state I I would argue that
you know I think we've been Our Own
Worst Enemy in so many ways we we have
to look at the priorities that are uh
important to the state in the last 12
years what has been our priority the
climate environment Etc housing is part
of that but there are other priorities
that outweigh even the housing
conversation uh it was only the last
couple years that housing really Rose to
the Forefront that we started to have
these talks about zoning and and the
different things so through the process
through legislation through the
government uh a lot of that has
attributed to the barriers and the
problems we also have to look back at at
in in the most recent history the the
crash right so before we had the big
housing crash which encompassed
financial which encompassed lending laws
which encompassed all these different
things we were building at a incredible
clip um Builders were doing all sorts of
stuff now you look at the way that they
were financed and it was a house of
cards in so many ways and when it
crashed it crashed hard um we've never
picked up that momentum we have a
tendency when those things happen we
regulate we regulated financing and
government and loans and and all sorts
of so we just kept adding on to that so
it made it even more uh cumbersome to
have to go through that process so it's
slowly coming back but not at the pace
that it was beforehand but in the same
breath in Washington state and one of
the things we debate we debated
yesterday during committee is still the
growth management act it still has to do
with where we build how we build the ug
Outside Inside and and I think that it
has created so many uh barriers um that
it still makes it difficult to develop
yes we've done things in zoning density
we have to do so much more um when you
talk to people right now uh which I do
in the development Community they're
here today we're talking about different
things and you ask them how long will it
take to bring units to Market if I was
to you know do this how long
and when you hear two three four years
you know um you know even in the most
perfect scenario within the ug all the
different things it's too long so you
know it it's not going to be through the
Housing Trust Fund although that is a
tool it is going to be through
incentivizing it is going to be through
reform it is going to be through a more
holistic look at the growth management
act and all these things in concert have
to come together to to break that down
well and then this gets to another
bigger picture question which is is the
there does anybody have a plan to close
that million unit Gap and if half of
those units do need to be affordable and
if the Housing Trust Fund even if it
wants to be The Little Engine That Could
doesn't have the capacity to do all that
what are some other ways you could get
that kind of housing outside of the
Housing Trust Fund so that's sort of two
it is two questions maybe we start the
with the first is there a plan on on
paper yet to close the million unit Gap
well um I think there are lots of plans
at lots of different levels in part um
you know GMA requires a comprehensive
planning process that builds for local
communities to have a plan of how
they're going to reach their housing
targets and that was spelled out in
House Bill 1220 which really provided
Direction and Clarity on what local
communities need to do now we need to
make sure that they're accountable to
doing that and it is going to take a lot
of tools to get us the units we need the
number one thing we need for those
affordable homes though is resource and
as I mentioned there is currently no
dedicated fund Source there is a bill
this session which would create a sirar
charge on the sale of high cost
properties above $3 million that would
be a dedicated fund Source specifically
for the Housing Trust Fund but for the
other homes that we need in our
community we really have to empower the
market to be able to do that and we need
to take steps to empower the market to
do that through many things that I
believe we agree on one we need to
unleash zoning we have to get rid of
restrictive zoning and allow in
particular for more dense housing that's
located near Transit there's a bill this
session to help increase density by
transit while ensuring that some of
those homes are affordable for lowincome
people we have to address permitting
barriers and cost drivers that are
driving up the cost of housing including
in the private Market um and and take
those on as well and we need to partner
between the state and local community
ities to work together on it it is a
partnership between the public sector
the private sector and the nonprofit
sector to solve for this problem and
housing is a very local issue as well so
the state has a role but it's also the
domain of the cities and the counties so
so so there's three kind of examples of
legislation that's moving possible
solutions where is their alignment and
where do you where if you were the chair
and had the votes where would you go in
in a different direction um it sounds
great I mean it sounds like we're doing
all we are but it's so incremental and
it's still pick and choose we're still
picking and choosing how much permit
reform we're willing to do and how much
zoning and where we're going to put it
and you know there's still those
arguments there's still those
constraints when it comes to GMA and I
would say there's still a lot of
resistance to doing these different
things would you repeal the GMA if you
were I don't think we'll ever repeal the
G I think it's a it's a question that
comes up all the time and no but I think
we need to reform it Austin it was never
meant to static it has uh many tenants
we added another one and a goal of
climate to it so we've added more pieces
that now have to be followed when we're
looking to plan I think we're doing too
much planning too many studies we we
have a tendency to do that a lot we we
did a ruckles house study here not too
long ago uh had some good
recommendations for GMA but it wasn't
really a clear we must do this and even
if we get a clear we must do this the
legislature has a tendency not to do
that I mean we'll we'll we we'll pick
and choose this dedicated source is a
tax I mean it's a re tax let's call it
what it is it's it's it's it's there's a
lot of opposition to it we have we're
not going to tax our way out of this
we've funded uh through many many years
uh the Housing Trust Fund we've done the
dock recording fee we've done so many
different things within the contents of
our state taxation system to do this so
what what is the opposition to taxing
homes selling for three million and
above at a higher rate for this purpose
it's a it's a you know again we're we're
we're saying that we're going to solve
this by taxing a certain segment of our
Marketplace we have the highest reat in
the country a couple years ago we broke
that down we we we they had a graduated
re so that it would be effective in
certain things uh and now we want to hit
it again we're going to we're going to
do another taxation you look at that and
you say well it's gosh 3 million is a
lot but you have to look at other
properties that fit within that realm
right and what it will do and how that
affects it so do we need another
dedicated Source that's Up For Debate we
can we can talk about if we if we think
taxation is a way to get us out of this
I believe that we actually need to focus
on the regulatory side not necessarily
pouring more money into the Housing
Trust Fund we have done that we have
been doing that um and I don't know if
that's the best way to do that we we
look at property tax we might have even
a broader conversation on tax reform as
a whole I think we've been trying to do
that for a couple years but there is a
lot of resistance on both sides of it
around Taxation and and what works best
I will talk about you know we need to do
property tax in sales T we need to do
everything we can to do what we can to
incentivize the private sector and
Austin no matter how we look at this
there still is what I would call a war
against or a you know opposition that is
against a private sector developer it it
it seems to be when we're looking at
this we will not do it in this sector we
will do it in this sector and so we have
to somehow find a way that we can do
that it took years to get the multif
family housing tax exemption put forth
we're trying to expand that into other
Arenas it is challenging to say the
least and we we're trying to do that to
get more people to use it so it is more
friendly to the private sector to
encourage that yeah so just to jump in I
do think that we need incentives and we
need Partnerships and we need to find
Opportunities to remove unnecessary
regulations to help support the market
in creating more housing but there is no
evidence and there is no analysis that
there's an alternative way to create
housing that's affordable to the lowest
income households in our community of
which we need 50% of the million homes
need to be affordable to Folks at 50%
Ami and Below we can't use incentives
and the market alone to achieve that it
will take subsidy it will take
investment and we're going to need to
raise revenue to do that and how I would
just say a I mean subsid I agree
incentives yes all those different
things not going to tax our way and and
by pouring money in one thing I get it
it it feeds this one other side but but
again you know if you look at a proforma
if you look at we we've talked about
this uh uh you know then Congressman HEC
now our lieutenant governor we talked
about this it's called a proforma we
looked at what it takes to build
something and in our state we have to
lower those costs 20 to 25% to get at
that if you ask somebody that's say can
you build me a a $250,000 home they're
going to laugh in your faith no we can't
there's no way to do that and within the
last couple years data and data will
show you as we've looked at we keep
adding different things that are adding
to the cost of building housing it's
going the opposite way to make
affordability well what is your thought
representative Alvarado on the just the
cost per unit piece like shouldn't we be
able to say that if half of those units
need to be affordable to the lowest
income that we should be able to say how
much it would cost to build or at least
within a
range per unit and and then how long it
would take and how long then it takes to
get what we need in terms of the housing
stock like it seems like it should be
pretty simple but has anybody figured
out that math and said here's a
reasonable price here's how many units
we need and here's how fast we can get
it done yeah well we know how much it
costs to build housing um and we know
what the cost drivers of that housing
are and I think where representative
barcus and I agree is trying to reduce
some of those cost
um as I said earlier permitting is C
it's unnecessary things like Park
requirements and other NE unnecessary
requirements Drive the cost and we have
to do everything possible to tackle that
and in some cases even when you do that
the math still doesn't work to create an
affordable home and it'll take an
additional partnership and investment
from the public to make those happen I
don't disagree but also time is a factor
awesome time is money so when you look
at the cost and and the reason why it
takes so long at the local government
level or at any level is again let's go
back to the planning let's talk about
the comprehensive plans let's talk about
GMA let's talk about critical areas
let's talk about environmental
regulations Geo you name it you add all
these things on and I go in to get a
permit to build something and I have to
secure my financing which is a
challenging to say the least in this
market as as always and then I have to
take that risk to know how long is it
going to take there's no certainty in
that so yes those reforms that come into
place if if you knew what you needed to
do and could Bank on that you know that
helps immediately remove some of those
those bur is there a specific
environmental regulation that you
think goes too far that you could give
an example of that you would say roll
that back we don't need it critical
areas in some aspects critical areas are
so important to protect our environment
and I we we have to have those right but
when and we've seen this just recently
too when when um you'll start to go
beyond you we'll say we'll put the
Protections in to make sure they're
there and then it's not enough it's
about trees it's about this it's about
buffer zones about all these different
things here in thirston County we've
dealt with how many years now 13 years
12 years of pocket gopher you know as
part of the critical area the endangered
spotted butterfly monarch you know all
the different things that have have have
prevented development prevented growth
within the urban growth area within
these plans right and so I think that
you have to start finding that
balance we're not I'm not we're not
going to say pave it over spraw it out
we don't care about the environment
we're washingtonians we care about the
environment we want to protect the
beautiful state we live in but there has
to be reason within that and when you
have groups that are so entrenched that
that it's just they will not move off of
any of that it gets into these different
things and no matter what we do
legislatively unless we change that
we're not going to we're not going to
move beyond that and we're still going
to have these problems moving forward
and if you you asked earlier you know
how do we do this yeah it's taken us 10
15 20 years to get into this problem
statement it's going to take a while to
get out of it but it's going to have to
take some radical changes you know of
what we've done so I want to touch on
that a little bit which is the time and
how long it's going to take us to get
out of
that we're in and that's exactly why I
proposed House Bill
2114 which looks at stabilizing renters
who are experiencing excessive rent
increases now and this is the 3% per
year cap it's it's a 5% cap in the bill
and again representative barcus and I
agree that longterm we must have Supply
to address our housing shortage but we
also know that it does take time and
that we have constituents across the
state who are really struggling with the
impacts of excessive rent increases and
what that means on their daily lives
there are older adults who are making
really tough choices about whether to
pay rent or other life Necessities we
see working families who are fighting
for wage increases and then rent is
outpacing that so a key part of our
housing strategy has to also be steps to
stabilize
so that they can live um with stability
in our community and this is obviously a
major priority of majority Democrats
this year to do some sort of rent
stabilization bill um and well we made
the pivot so we'll stick with it I guess
we are yes we'll stick with it um why
not it's if 5% is more than well it may
not be more than inflation let's hope
it's more than inflation this year maybe
next year um but why not try to at least
Benchmark uh rental increases to uh some
predictable uh year-over-year in it's
not the solution I I mean I appreciate
representative Alvarado's passion in
this space and I would say that I have
equal passion in it uh because I know it
I see it firsthand I'm I'm I'm doing it
as she is I'm working to House people uh
and dealing with all the things that
come into play um I'm sure we will
unpack this more but we can talk about
what we've been through over the last
several years we've had that
conversation on the show the eviction
moratorium the rent control was in place
at that point in time and I would say
there are other solutions that we can
get at because what you just indicated
was we are in a phase in the market
where this is a problem we're hoping to
get we're working to get the supply
we're working to address this but this
is a big policy this is something that
has not been done in other states where
it has it's had critical impacts but
it's not rent control in the classic
sense you can call it what you know call
it what you want stabilization rent
control sure it's not in the classic
sense and even that's fraught because of
course the argument will be well you
know once somebody moves out you can
raise their rent so guess what's going
to happen in the marketplace people are
going to raise their rent incredibly
high are we going to stabilize rents
when after a year the people move out
and they come back up so this percentage
we we just don't see this in any other
aspect of what we do in our marketplace
where we are capping what's doing we're
affecting the market to do that there
are other ways to do this and this is
where we disagree right this is where we
are trying to figure out some
commonality and I will get into more
you know what we should be doing to
solve this let's do that let's pause
there because I want to hear what you
would do if if you could just a response
to this idea that this is sort of this
this government coming in and kind of
creating this artificial cap on a
private
Marketplace yeah I mean I think what it
is it is a reasonable regulation that's
intended to ensure that there are not
excessive rent increases it still allows
landlords to raise the rent it still
allows them to to reset the rent when
there's vacancy but what it does is
provide some predictability and
stability for tenants um I'm a homeowner
I have a 30-year fixed mortgage and I
benefit from the government having come
in and help to back a 30-year fixed
mortgage so that I have some
predictability and stability and there
are a million renter households across
Washington State who have no idea what
their rent will be and and this is
really about providing some of that
stability and it does not come at the
expense of also doing Supply this is
both and we will increase Supply so that
we can continue to help hopefully
overall reduce costs in the market but
this is a tool for renters who are
hurting right now what would you do
differently what what would be your
first of all I wouldn't mess with the
market in this manner I mean it's it's
it we keep talking about that this is
you know a million I would I would say
that that it does not affect the
entirety of the rental Spectrum right
this affects a portion of the rental yes
there are people who are rent burden
there are people who need help and we
should help those that is a role as a
function of government that we help
those most in need that's where the
incentive Pro that's where the voucher
programs come in that's we should well
we we've there's two bills there's a
Democrat bill there's a Republican bill
these are vouchers we call Bridging the
Gap we're looking at creating something
where uh people have the ability to
access a voucher that goes to the tenant
that uh helps bridge that gap for a
period time up to a certain level so the
rent goes up they have some certain
things uh that they need say they're
$200 short $300 short $400 short where
they can do that it's an immediate like
we said immediate fix to that funding
source one looks at a sales tax one
looks at appropriation we want to make
it a a priority in the government that
we have a lot of money in our in our
State Surplus and our state coffers that
we could look at doing this but we have
never focused
into helping tenants in that manner by
creating these voucher programs instead
we want to manipulate the market by
doing a cap on rent uh overall but
there's many other things in this bill
Austin that are not just about a
percentage that we're doing a rent a lot
of other things I got to go to break but
let me just hear why not go for
something like a voucher per well I I
should say I absolutely support rental
assistance and I think we do need more
rental assistance in our community we
have a lot of people who the math
doesn't work for their household budget
to be able to afford rent I think there
are two challenges with the rental
assistance uh proposed that are on the
table one is that as we talked about we
need more resources right uh spending
money on rent assistance is a spending
of public taxpayer dollars um and um
I'll continue to absolutely and I'll
continue to Advocate to Bringing more
resources to the table so that we can
spend on these important purposes the
second piece is that under these bills
The Government Can Be subsidizing rent
for individuals who after after a
landlord receives that rent payment they
can turn around immediately after and
raise the rent meaning that we continue
to be chasing the market with those rent
subsidies I believe that rental
assistance would pair really nicely with
a rent stabilization program and policy
so that we can have predictability in
the housing market and then also help
provide some subsidy to households who
are in need very briefly then I need a
break all sounds great but you know you
can't do it unless you collaborate
unless you're willing to get together in
all parties and that has never happened
in this space when it comes to landlord
ten law it's adversarial it's not like
we did in the supply side there has been
no conversations nobody's sitting around
talking about merging uh subsidies with
stabilization with everything else so
we'll get to that in the next segment
I'm sure but there's a lot more that we
can go into that could in fact help
people today I really look forward to
collaborating on this issue okay let's
take a quick break when we return we
continue our conversation at times spicy
conversation about the housing chall
Alles facing the state of Washington and
efforts underway in the current legisl
to address the Gap back after
this it will dwarf Katrina it'll be
absolutely the largest thing that we
will have had to have dealt with in our
country we know the clock is
ticking and welcome back to inside
Olympia our Focus this week is on
Washington's housing crisis and what the
legislature is doing to address it
joining me once again our state
representatives Emily alar
and Andrew barcus and let me just before
we move on because there's a lot more to
talk about just ask this question about
sort of a grand bargain
around uh you know vouchers rent uh
assistance and stabilization why isn't
there sort of a blending of these two
ideas in some sort of grand bargain well
I look forward to that conversation
again I think both are critical tools
and I'd love to see both of them working
together what part of the conversation
needs to be an acknowledgement that we
do need some reasonable regulations to
make sure that there aren't excessive
rent increases in our community so um
you can't do that unless there's
willingness and collaboration I think
the reason we were so successful the
last couple years especially
representative baitman and I and others
uh is because we worked in the interim
we worked outside of the legislature and
then while we were there we worked
consistently to have to everybody had to
give and and I always call it 70% policy
right it's like it's not 100%
policy unfortunately one on one side
with the low-income housing folks it's
it is 100% And and there's there's very
little give in the in the region you
cannot have um in my experience over
almost nine the nine sessions doing this
right that does that doesn't happen and
it's very frustrating right when you
look at the Grand bargain you look at
the votes we have 40 they have 58 in the
house um if they had all the votes we
wouldn't even be talking about this they
just would do it but but there's
probably not all the votes there because
it is a controversial policy in a lot of
ways but let's go back to last year
middle housing it was the same way
Austin they did not have the majority
and both Chambers did not have the votes
to pass middle housing it was the
Republican caucus it was myself it was
working collaboratively to bring those
votes along to pass that policy never
would have happened if we wouldn't have
all sat together that's not happening in
this space this space this space
unfortunately has been so advisal for so
long tenant versus landlord you know 46
pieces of legislation Last 5 Years
Austin all targeted at landlords 46
pieces of legislation 15 passed and
signed in a law of those two had
bipartisan support only two so it tells
you there's a history and I'm trying to
break that I introduced a bill this year
to do a task force I think we need to
look at it holistically do you see an
opportunity to we didn't even hear that
bill this year I I think there's always
an opportunity to collaborate and I
think process really does matter rent
stabilization has been a bill that's
been before the legislature for many
years now and I think this bill builds
upon things that we've learned
throughout the process unfortunately
there isn't people who are coming to the
table to talk about how we can make a
rent stabilization policy that works for
other um members for primarily
Republican members and I I I look
forward to hearing feedback on what that
policy would look like but the key thing
is is that we have an urgent situation
right now 40% of my constituents are
renters and they need some relief and
building on three years of introducing
this bill we need to have some action
now so that people in our communities
feel actual relief from the sing Single
greatest cost in a household budget
which is housing agree but I may if I
may okay
almost 40% in the entire State rent in
some way but if we don't start talking
about the landlords that are providing
the housing that are part of the supply
issue we're missing half the equation of
this whole thing without housing
providers you don't have tenants you
have to have that commonality again 46
pieces of legislation again this year
another eight pieces focused at tenant
protections not landlords not in the in
the sense of that and people are are
shedding they're getting out of the
business it has become burdensome and
we're not looking at both sides of this
equation when it comes to that well let
let me it's it's problematic in that
aspect let me pivot back to
supply and I think I can connect a
thread here that there there is a way we
have been doing business for a long time
when it comes to housing and there's
these sort of built-in relationships
landlord tenant that you talked about
and then there's the kinds of housing we
build and I know that you were trying to
incentivize some new you know accessory
dwelling units and lot splitting and
building density around Transit but I
wonder if if the thinking is out of the
box enough could you get much more
radical and and where my head goes is
that if you drive south uh from Olympia
into Lewis County and go south of um
cellia and even chahalis there's a
little development off to the left of
what looks like single wide trailers
except they're actually stick Built
Homes with a little parking pad and
there's like 15 or 20 of them and
they're very cute and it's like the only
place I've ever seen any like that it
doesn't look like temporary housing it
doesn't look like uh a tiny village it
looks like something they might work for
for a single person even a couple maybe
a small family why don't we have
more little postage stamp communities
like that for instance why are we not
why are we still building stick built
and not looking for creative ways to
build would love to take this yeah no I
I think I think that uh manufactured and
mod module housing has a real opper is
an opportunity for us um and I think uh
a lot of the Technologies continue to
change and adapt they're they're not as
proven at scale but certainly we need to
be looking at more opportunities to
supplement and complement stick built
housing with manufactured and modular
and Factory built housing it's an
opportunity especially with so many
people who are without homes right now
because we talking about people who
can't afford but we're also talking
about people absolutely but I would
argue that those are more strategies
that we need they're additional
strategies they are not a substitute for
some of the other things so this is
about taking multiple approaches to and
what I was asking is are are we
considering all of the options the whole
we are but we're not doing it though I
mean we still have prohibitions where it
come where you can site manufactured
housing um we don't have anybody
building manufactured housing in
Washington state we used to have three
factories in Washington state one was
actually loaded located not too far from
where those little houses are in Louis
County I grew up in chahalis uh I
actually sold manufactured housing way
way back and moduline used to be the
Builder of that they're gone uh the
closest manufacturers in Oregon um we
tried yesterday to talk about maybe
it'll go through executive today but uh
you know where do we site these homes
most communities don't want them there
and so there's been these different
things about I don't want this in my
backyard we don't the manufactured
housing stigmatism it's wrong I I
started working with some groups to try
to encourage the building of those uh
whether manufactured housing tiny Homes
modular homes uh container homes I mean
there's a company in Tacoma trying to
build uh they actually build apartment
buildings out of modular type of things
everything has to be looked at but
again within the state of Washington you
have to ask yourself why if there's all
these great ideas why aren't we doing it
and it and it probably comes down to
regulatory environment cost of doing
business cost of all these other things
um I will say I was just down at Ocean
Shores again this weekend and I tell you
it's one of the most eclectic
communities to drive around when you
look at it I mean talk about diversity
and zoning and types of you'll see
single family multif family little tiny
duplexes next to a big house on the
beach I mean all this stuff it should be
a plot of that Community for what
they're doing and and it's a good
example looks great but they're they're
they're meeting that Mark I don't know
how they're doing it I need to talk to
them see see how they're building those
things down there but but you know if if
there was a way Austin that we could get
past it even in yesterday's
hearing people from the OWN their own
associations that talk about these
communities are prohibitive of any type
of of expansion of existing Parks
outside of the ug where people have come
in and say look we could add another 20
or 30 homes we need to do more to
encourage that I would love to see that
develop up here two things first of all
absolutely agree that we have to remove
barriers to citing housing types in all
communities we see it's extraordinarily
difficult to site Supportive Housing
emergency shelter and even affordable
housing that we know we need in many
communities there is a bill this session
to try to push on cities and collaborate
with cities to help make sure that
sighting happens more easily we also
need more housing types something that
we definitely agree on and there are a
lot of bills this session that are
looking to be creative about housing
types there's a bill by representative
Gregerson to create more co-housing
types that I know is co-sponsored by
representative baras there's a bill by
representative Wallen to help convert
unused vacant commerciales into housing
there is a bill to look at new financing
opportunities through the the state
Housing Finance commission the workforce
housing accelerator that's a bill funded
by uh that's a bill sponsored by
representative levit so we are pushing
on types of housing ways to finance
housing and making sure that local
communities let us put the housing in
place that we so desperately need one of
the other criticisms that you often hear
from Republicans is that Democrats on
the sort of environmental Side Of The
Ledger or driving up cost by doing
things like wanting to not connect to
Natural Gas anymore requiring uh you
know building codes that are that are
more efficient over the long run things
that perhaps pencil out over 20 30 year
50 years of the life cycle of the home
but do add costs in the short term
absolutely how do you you know as a
majority Democrat address that piece as
you're working on this housing crisis
and then you've got colleagues over here
who are saying no more natural gas yeah
absolutely I mean these are for me this
is the kind of issue where we can find a
both end I believe we can both provide
and support environmental sustainability
and also solve our housing crisis and
there are some um regulations that are
cost drivers in housing but there's a
number of untapped opportunities that
really could help solve both our
environmental and climate challenges and
our housing challenges namely adding
more density in urban areas density by
transit there there's a a a bill this
session by rep Reed to create um more
dense housing by transit that's
something that's both good for the
environment and good for housing um and
and on the cost drivers there are things
that long-term will save us costs and
are worth it for our environment but is
there anything you can do in the short
term to offset that yeah in the short
term there are a lot of things that we
could do to offset costs and that's why
I'm uh particularly passionate about
permitting because as representative
barus said permitting is a not only a
cost but it's a time and time is money
in development um there are things like
parking requirements that's something
that if we eliminate parking required
parking minimums that's good for the
environment and good for housing about
subsidizing the cost of
these heat pumps or the higher cost
insulation or whatever it is may I yeah
uh what's a subsidy a subsid is a tax ta
it's a shift it's you have to take the
money from somewhere Austin so I mean
we're seeing that all around so my other
role is ranking on Transportation so
we're trying to balance this out you
know we've talked about the climate
commitment act we've talked about the
money coming in and where's that going
to go so we can say well look you you
know we're going to help you out by
helping you with a heat pump and but
that money comes I mean if we're talking
about where the priority of where we put
in this money we put it in rental
subsidies we put it in subsidies so that
I can put solar on my roof natural gas
if we don't have natural gas we have no
dry kiled wood we have no concrete
building materials we have I mean
everything that it takes to actually
build the homes and products we need gas
to do that and right now I don't think
there's a substitute for that within the
context so so I think this is a great
example of where you know we have one
side that is really wanting to to ramp
us into a a climate goals that are set
by our governor been no secret that's
his priority and as a consequence they
do have consequence on the other side
and the cost drivers that are part of
that so you know whether it's taking
natural gas out a building whether it's
building codes that require different
environmental whether it's uh wooi codes
which are about the wildlife Urban
interface codes of what type of type of
Windows we have to use or architecture
all those are cost drivers all those are
going to increase the cost of building
homes in Washington state so you have to
temper that out I think you can find
balance I mean I think we have found
balance within the climate and some of
these different things but it does not
detract from the point that we continue
in the legislature to add on more things
whether it's for climate or something
else we're doing that I would also say
that we do have a number of incentives
that we've supported over the years and
have looked at several bills this
session to expand tax exemptions to help
cover the cost of development in part to
offset cost that exists but also to
provide more affordable housing and one
last thing though I want also say too is
because I just popped in you know when
we talk about density and we talk about
all these things these are very pisound
Centric words right these are things
that we have really focused transitor
development you're not going to see an
Elby or or or Eatonville right you're
going to see this in Tacoma or whatever
and that's all good it's it's one of the
things but when we look at the housing
crisis it is not just exclusive to the
pesan region it is the entirety of the
state so policy must reflect that well
let's stick with density though for a
moment because I do want to I mean
probably the most closely watched bill
because it's a carryover from last year
is the transit the density around
Transit uh it there are issues obviously
local government has its concerns and
there's also the you know what's the
right me you know the 10% of units need
to be affordable piece uh housing
Advocates say that's not enough the
developers say it might be too much to
incentivize them to build you've got the
concern about gentrifying neighborhoods
and pushing existing residents out where
do you see that particular proposal
ending up in this short session what's
your I'm not going to speculate where it
ends up it did make it out of the
housing committee um and uh supported
that obviously there are a lot of dials
in that bill and conversations that can
continue to be had but I think the
fundamentals are this we need more
density by transit that's an imperative
two we need to make sure that as we
build more housing a portion of that
housing is Affordable to not only the
most Transit dependent people who are
low-income folks but also essential
working people who we need as part of
all communities and three that we're
engaging with the cities to help support
necess infrastructure Investments as we
continue to grow that's the thrust of
the bill it's the spirit of the bill and
I hope that we can move it forward and
is there bipartisan support for like
where fault lines um and we're trying um
you know it was interesting the product
I started working on that um years ago
uh in the transportation room both Cher
F and I did and um we had a product last
year that was more incentive based um
came out of the Senate came over to the
house and turned into a different
product that product has those
affordability indexes in there and I
think that's where it really kind of
went sideways within the context of
developer versus affordable low income
whatever um and where that sits is there
there are proposals being put forth but
again it's it's pretty rigid in what is
wanted so if you're rigid in what you
want and some of these things come in
and are added to it and they're not cons
it's not going to move it's not going to
get that support that it needs do you um
I don't I don't see it moving this year
I I think that I I think there's too
many pieces still as as representative
Alvarado said I think there's too many
pieces left there but but there I mean
there are so many agreements we we do
all those things she said density
Transit all those things you did pass
legislation last year correct me if I'm
wrong to uh to expand density or to
increase density in urban areas by by uh
having to do with lot size right or the
use of lots allowing four plexes mid
abely so that was your was a big one
right so that got through is the transit
sorry that term wasn't coming to me uh
how could I have forgotten so if middle
housing passed how does the the transit
density compare it didn't have a
affordability index it didn't have a 10%
that says you but the in terms of pieces
of the puzzle to get us towards a
solution where does Transit density fit
like as compared to Middle housing in
terms of the importance you would put
upon it as a policy well there there
were some pieces in there in in the
middle housing about you know about
closeness proximity too yes as related
to as related to parking and as related
to these different things but and that
and and then and there was some
affordability on how you know how many
units you know depending on where
they're built and would give you extra
units but do you see it as again I would
say we need all types of density we have
to have dense housing by transit and
quite frankly we see some communities
including the city of Seattle where I
represent part of the city that is
taking advantage and looking forward to
building more dense communities by
transit we also need four plexes and six
plexes in uh in neighborhoods so that
people have an opportunity to buy their
first starter home and live near the
schools where they want to send their
kids to schools and we need accessory
dwelling units and we were able to uh
pass legislation last session to help
provide for two adus on a lot and also
this there are some bills moving forward
to look at how we um uh Empower more
adus in more communities so it's going
to take all of these strategies where
are we with lot splitting which is your
passion it there's a good possibility
it's dead dead it passed again first day
session it was it was a beautiful nod to
the work that we had done to run that
bill the first day and to pass it 94 to4
uh it's in it's in the Senate right now
it's in the committee uh there have been
negotiations we we took that bill last
year and and I think we ran out of time
really it was what it was and it was it
there were so many pieces of policy
trying to get them all to a line and I
think that one kind of fell out on there
so we we spent the interim working with
the stakeholders the cities and others
uh to to answer the questions and we
came back and the bill that we ran they
pulled right back up was was last year's
Bill and and when it went to the Senate
with the whole intent was to um to work
it over and put the substitute on top of
it that has been worked at a high level
but a meeting that was H happened last
week with what I thought was going to be
presenting these Solutions was met with
a lot of resistance uh what is the
argument against
it pick one I mean cities cities will
argue against creating again too much
density uh allowing for too much stuff
um the chair of the committee will argue
that it impacts her community in a
certain way and uh we're going to impact
trees and critical spaces and and and
you know you just keep piling on if the
longer these bills sit and do this
you'll find a reason to to vote against
it right and so so at the end of that
meeting even though we had what was
thought to be an agreed upon thing
between the stakeholders what was really
told was that they felt from the
majority that there there was just a lot
of resistance to it didn't know if it
would be moving we'll see I I have not
heard if it's moving out of that
committee I don't want to lose we just
have a few minutes left I don't want to
lose sight of the unhoused population in
this state thousands and thousands of
people without a home they've been
pushed out as the prices have gone up
they've been pushed down and out and it
goes back again to this thinking
creatively and I've asked the governor
this over the years like where is the
Marshall Plan for homelessness in the
state of Washington the way that people
are
living exposed to the elements in
dangerous locations are we not capable
of building a lot of emergency housing
very quickly and saying we're capable
and we're GNA get this done thank you
for that question I mean I'll start by
saying we know that homelessness is a
housing problem and we need housing
that's affordable especially to people
with the lowest income and people who
might need additional support a lot of
complex issues a lot of complex issues
but we need housing that's affordable to
folks and there are a couple of
challenges that are bottlenecking our
ability to create housing that's
affordable to the lowest income people
in our community one I mentioned that
the Housing Trust Fund has projects that
have applied to it to build permanent
support of housing in Olympia and
Aberdine that are sitting unfunded
because we don't have enough resource
two we know that local communities are
putting up obstacles to the sighting of
permanent Supportive Housing and
emergency housing in their communities
there's a bill as I mentioned to help
push cities to really help site the
solution to homelessness which is
housing and then three I'd say that we
know that the more people we help to
move off of the streets there are more
and more people who are moving into
homelessness and part of the reason
they're moving into homelessness is
because they have outof control rents
that continue to go up and we have to
address the facts that people are being
priced out into homelessness by
implementing policies like rent
stabilization now good sway um you know
the problem is that we we have to also
look at the the drugs the drug addiction
the drug addiction Mental Health crisis
that we see Astin um you know for far
too long we keep saying that uh you know
landlords eviction cause homelessness
this causes homelessness this causes we
we see that and there is we do have this
tremendous problem and I agree I we've
had this conversation I've had the
conversation with the governor why don't
we have a Marshall Plan you know I dare
I say I met with him and I said why why
don't we treat this in the same way that
we treated covid as a crisis why aren't
we implementing you know immediate
shelter setups why aren't we doing you
know bringing people off the street so
you know he has his RightWay initiative
but to to the point that represent
alverado on these other types of housing
you can't just take people out of a tent
city on Slater Kenny replace it with a
bunch of rocks and stick them in a hotel
in Lacy because it's problematic and
what we're finding is the people I'm
talking to from the mayor to other
people there are it's it is there is
more drug activity going on and crime
and everything else within that we're
not solving the problem literally 100
units I mean they they they have so much
methus going on I talked to one council
member that toured it and and they the
the city manager is coming to talk to me
about it we have to have more robust
Services we have to look at this where
everybody stands and treat all aspects
of homelessness um in some form of plan
like that so you know we can build all
these we can buy hotels we can put
people in there but unless we're helping
solve the problems well and so we have a
minute left and I'll just mention that
we didn't get to Workforce but that but
that is a whole other issue it has it's
an issue in a hold up for building it's
an issue isue in terms of Staffing the
kinds of supports that you're talking
about that these individuals would need
it's just a ripple effect it's affecting
the healthcare the mental health
industry so many elements and parts of
the economy right now a final thought 20
seconds each of sort of where you want
to leave us especially considering it's
a it's a short session but that this is
an ongoing conversation some partisan
agreement and some some bipartisanship
and some disagreement but uh
representative Alvarado well I I I'll
just close by saying that I think our
housing crisis is totally solvable and
um I look forward to us continuing to
take steps to do the three key things
that we need to do one build more
housing in the market and reduce
barriers to building housing in the
market two getting more resources so
that we can invest in affordable housing
that's not provided by the market and
three stabilizing renters and homeowners
now so that they can have safe uh lives
in our community can you do it in 5
seconds thanks yeah that works um thank
you uh collaboration I I I just hope
that we can build on the the
collaboration we have because we're not
doing it in in multiple areas and so uh
we'll see where it goes okay
representatives sparkus and Alvarado
thank you so much apprciate thank you
for watching inside Olympia and we'll
see you again next
[Music]
week
