Lecture 14

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Feb 2, 2024
[Music]
a very good morning good afternoon and
good evening to all the students at
whichever time you are hearing this
lecture uh this is the multicriteria
decision making Muk and P series course
and and my good name is raghunandan s
Gupta from the IM department at I kpur
so as you know this is a 60 lecture
series which is spread over 12 weeks and
each week we have five lectures each
lecture being for half an hour so we are
in the third week and doing the course
so the broad outline we are covering
which is a broad
umbrella which is about the mcdm
definitions Concepts utility function
Safety First principles stochastic
dominance and this is the 14th lecture
which we will
do so the coverage would be would be
even though planned accordingly uh as
the notes slides are uploaded you'll
understand what is the exact coverage so
we'll
plan to cover the concepts of the last
example of utility function then what is
the concept of certainty equivalent
geometric mean methods and why geometric
mean methods are used safety first
principle what are the three rules there
are many rules we'll only discuss three
the concept of stochastic dominance
first order second order and the general
hyperbolic absolute dision function and
how it leads to all the initial set of
or examples of utility functions we have
discussed three we have discussed in the
last class and one we'll discuss today
so today's portion would be the last
utility function the simple one on
quadratic exponential and power we have
already discussed so the last one is
logarithmic utility
function and the logarithm U function is
given by Ln of w so NEP and log and let
us uh check the the this is sorry this
is my mistake this should
be r r
Prime so this uh we will consider a a
prime r r Prime and see the graphs
according as we have done for the other
set of
um util
functions so U Prime which is based on
the first property would be 1 by
W this is d d Ln of w by DW and U Prime
would be equal to minus 1 by
w² so if I want to find out a I'll use
use a different color so in order to
make it much
more readable and
differentiable so a is given by - U
Prime by U Prime which is equal
to minus of 1 by
W minus minus becomes plus so divided by
1 by
w² so this
becomes
W uh by w² by
W and
uh this would become uh let me check
whether 1 by W this is - 1 by
w² so okay U Prime would this would be
w² and this is 1 by
w
so when I
consider so this is w² and there in the
numerators you
have W this is with a plus sign so the
final value becomes 1 by W so when I
differentiate and find out a prime it is
-1 by w² as given
here so w is positive obviously W square
is positive so it has a decreasing
absolute risk Aion Factor considering
the negative sign so now let us come to
R which is relative risk aversion
property I'll remove the portion which
is marked in green which was the
calculation done for related to a and a
prime so you use the blue
color so as usual we need to find out r
r is minus
W into U Prime by U Prime is equal to -
w u Prime was
already 1 by w² so with the plus minus
minus becomes plus and this is U Prime
is 1 by
W so this
becomes W from from the denominator goes
up and in the numerator of w it is 1 so
R
Prime differentiation of a constant is
zero so it is zero here and is a
constant relative risk conversion
property so just so we have derived it
understood it I'll re erase this blue
portion and also the red portion which
was related to U Prime and U
Prime so only thing which
I want to make you note this second
bullet point is basically R Prime So
based on
that I need to
draw so the logarithmic U function first
case is
basically the
fact that this is Ln of w logarithmic U
function given as
here and we are plotting the following
you're plotting W along the
x-axis and
u a prime R Prime along the Y
AIS and the corresponding a prime and RP
Prime are even though drawn but it will
become much more clear when we go to the
next set of diagrams so a prime looks
linear but it's not a prime is marked
here similarly R Prime which we develop
uh derived is also marked here so now we
will go to the separate figures for u a
prime and R
Prime so this is also the first
figure where we plot W along the x-axis
only U along the Y AIS this is the
logarithmic utility
function this the shape is exactly the
same what we have seen in the last
diagram logarithmic U function versus
W and the
corresponding a
prime is this even though it was a
straight line but actually it's is this
because it is if you remember it was
given by minus1 by W and the negative
signs are here so this is basically d a
w DW which is a prime for the
logarithmic util
function versus W which is being plotted
Just for information even though it's a
repetition please bear with me we are
plotting W along the x-axis and a prime
along the Y
AIS the last figure is
basically given as
dwdw which is basically r Prime we
plotting it for the log2 function versus
W which is the
wealth and as usual we plot W along the
xaxis r Prime W along the y axis and if
you
remember in this in the derivation we
did derive that the fact that R Prime R
was a constant was one so hence R Prime
was basically zero and if you see this
graph it is a straight line with the
value of zero zero being
here so we have uh considered in the
last class three different util
functions quadratic
exponential and uh Power and this class
which is the 14th lecture we have
considered the last example of
logarithmic U functions there are other
util functions also we'll cover one more
which is the general one hyperbolic
absolute risk Aion Factor
Hara now all these things we are
discussing about util function actually
in practical sense won't make much
sense so that was the background but
what we need in order to understand the
concept of util function is known as the
concept of certainty value which I'm
marking or certainty equivalent so the
actual value of expected utility is of
no use expect when except when we are
comparing with other alternative so
there are many Alternatives and we want
to compare them so expected value is
basically ranked from the highest to the
lowest and we make the decisions
accordingly so another important concept
which will make much better sense when
we want to analyze util function is the
certainty equivalent and we use the
symbol
C to denote the certainty equalent so
this is the amount of certain amount of
wealth which is under consider the disc
free concept why dis free I'll come to
that that has the utility level exactly
equal to this expected value which we
want to find out for some
UW so I denote the UW as in red color so
you want to find out some equivalent C
such that the corresponding expected
value of C would be equal to the
expected value of U
based on the fact that the certainty
equivalent is being considered under the
risk-free concept so what does it mean
actually it means the following and
which I will Mark in
yellow which
means the expected
value of the certainty
equivalent and it is under risk free so
expected value of the certainty
equivalent
which is marked here this one this
portion should be exactly equal to the
expected value of
the utility which has non- deterministic
outcomes so let me draw the diagram it
will be there also later on but let me
make it clear so I'll use blue color for
the certainty value and red color for
the
utility so certainty doesn't have any
risk which means the probability is one
so you will basically have
C which when utilize will give you the
concept of u c which is the utility
based on C and is expected
value of e of
u c is a fixed value would be equal to
utility of C multiplied by the
probability of C which as we know is one
because it is another risk-free
case so the value would be UC into 1
because this
probability which you have this portion
I'm marking in green has a value of
one like you're tossing a coin both
sides are heads so the probability of
getting a head is
one now this value of UC which you find
out should be exactly be equal to the
expected value of the utility which I
said I'll mark in
Red so the
utility is given by
UW so it's corresponding expected value
I'll denote by E of
UW would be equal to
UW multiplied by this is the
multiplication
sign of
probability of
UW so both are being balanced so on the
left hand side you have the certainty
value whose utility is UC multiplied by
1 because it's a
sure case and the right hand side you
have the utility and it expected value
is found out by multiplying the
corresponding utility with this
corresponding probability we'll see that
in a problem so if I draw the diagram
I'll continue using this slide erase the
writings which I have done and draw the
diagram uh the blue one for the
certainty part and the red one for the
utilities certainty part means utility
function in both the cases are the same
but certainty means with the probability
of one so let me erase
it so the certain value I used blue so
I'll continue using blue
so you
have
C which gives
you
U probability is
one so the expected
value comes out as we know
is e of
UC which you already done that would be
equivalent I'll use the the equivalent
sign with the
black and on the right hand side I'll
use the red color in order to
denote the
utility which has different outcomes so
consider there are three
outcomes outcome one outcome two outcome
three so here the wealth is
W1 corresponding utility is
uw1
for the next arm I'll write the
probabilities consider wealth is W2
corresponding utility is U
W2 and third arm is wealth
three and the corresponding utility is U
W3 now the util function in both the
cases are same now how they are
equivalent because if I have
probabilities P1 for the first arm P2
for the second arm P3 for the third arm
then the corresponding expected value of
this utility on the right hand side
which is red in color would be given I
donate down in the top would
be U W1 multiplied this is the star is
the multiplication sign into
P1 plus u
W2 then multiplication of
P2 plus u
3 multiplied by
P3 so what is this value this value as
we know is expected value of utility
W and equivalent sence has been placed
in the sense that this expected value
and this expected
value are
same so that's why the equal equivalent
signs so you need given util function
you need to find out the value of C so
how is the value of C
useful so suppose that we have a
decision process with a set of outcomes
as I showed you three outcomes the
probabilities are given which is P1 P2
P3 for the example and the corresponding
utility values are also given uw1 uw2 u3
so in case we want to compare this
decision process we first find its
certainty value and if you want to
compare with C other utility decisions
we'll compare just the certainty values
for two different
decisions as it will be much easier for
us to compare because we will have a
value and we can find them to find the
exact form of the util function for a
person the certainty value is also
useful and the person may not be clear
about the form of U function but you can
basically ask him or her some questions
based on the certainty concept and then
at at least understand what his or her
utility function would be so there are
two important facts ranking comparing
and also to find out what type of U
function a person has so let us do a
simple problem so those were the
equations now let us do a very simple
problem
suppose
you face two
options so option one which I'll mark in
green is this under option one you toss
a coin and if a head comes you win tail
10 Rupees while if a tail appears you
win
zero so half of probabilties
outcomes and under option two you get an
amount of M fixed there's no change that
means you're consider tossing a coin and
where both are heads and head comes
probability one you get M so I'll mark
this this case of option two with blue
color so green for the tossing the coin
where head and tail are different half
and half and for option two it is
blue and consider for this case case the
utility function is quadratic in nature
as given which I marked wus
0.04 w s so the quadratic U function
which you have already
considered now for the first option the
corresponding expected value of the
utility would be given by
this so when I put the value of 10 for
the utility function which is 10 minus
0.04 into 10 squ into half because
that's the probability that's the first
arm so this is the first arm this is the
second arm here you have 10 you have
zero probabilities are
half and
half and the second arm the value is 0
so it's 0 - 0.04 into 0 S into half and
the value comes out to be
three expected value for the utility
with two
arms now the for the second
option the
expected utility is given by because the
probability is
one so this is one and the utility is
given because the value is M so M - 0.04
into m² when you put it in the equation
this becomes a quadratic
equation so you
equate this utility
function which is M - 0.04 into
m² is equal to
3 equate them and based on a simple
quadratic equation you find it and the
value of C comes out to be C is
3.49 which is the certainty value for
the you for for the
case based on which you had option
one which means
technically that if the person has a
quadratic function of this form W - 0.04
w² and on one table you
keep a coin unbiased if a head comes
it's 10 Rupees given to him or her and
if a tail comes he or she doesn't get
any amount of money and on the right on
the
table there is
3.49 rupees
given so if the person wants to decide
he will try to basically decide the
expected value of the utility based on
the fact that the
value is 3.49 so in case if he chooses
that then in some way you can say the
person is indifferent we'll discuss that
later on and if the person wants to take
the gamble which means he's willing to
take take the risk why the risk concept
is coming I'll come to that and if he
wants to take the certainty value which
means he doesn't want to take the risk
he is a risk hater or risk avoider
why in the case if he takes the Campbell
he is willing to take the risk is
because there are two arms one is 10 and
one is zero so he or she thinks that
with the chance of half he or she may
get 10 which is more than
3.49 and if you remember the example
which you have done for the fair gamble
so we are increasing the stake and for
the example which was 2,000 2 lakhs 20
lakh X and so on and so forth and other
arm being zero and for the fixed value
fixed value in the sense probability is
one the value was either one 1,000
corresponding to
2,000 then 1 lakh corresponding to 2
lakh 2 lakh and zero so there are two
arms another was 10 lakhs for the for
probability one and the other side it
was 20 lakhs and0 so there
it was basically being balanced and if
you remember we use the util function as
W so whatever the value was we
multiplied it by its corresponding
values so certainty value will give you
in a sense that how you will balance
your
decision now let us go back to the
Venture Capital
example uh the consider a venture
capitalist is considering of investing
in an investment this is the second
example where the falling amounts are
there which is 10 lakhs 5 lakhs 1 lakhs
with probabilities
of
244 which means the sum of the
probabilities is one so there are three
arms so let me use the red color first
arm it's 10 lakhs I'm using the word L
for
laks with a probability of
02 the second n 5 LH
with probability
of4 third um one lakh with probability
of4 so the sum is one you can find it
out now it says the you are using the
par
utility so par
utility if is the case then the
corresponding expected value would be
calculated by this so 10 lakhs to the^
half that's the utility multiplied by 2
is the probability so this is the first
arm the second arm is value is 5 lakhs 5
lakhs to the^ half into point4 which is
basically the second
arm and the third arm was basically 1
lakh to the^ half which is the utility
multiplied by probability point4 which
is the third
arm if I find out the expected value the
value comes up to
609 which I just
circled now consider the certainty value
C the symbol which I said so obviously
the util function is also same so the
corresponding utility for the certainty
value which should math 609 is like this
so I'll use a different color so the
certainty value c c to the^ half into 1
is basically the value of expected value
of the certainty value that that should
be equal to what that should be equal
to
609 so when I find out the value of C
the C comes out to be 609 squ which is 3
lakh
7,881 which means for the utility
function half the certainty value for
this decision where there are three
outcomes 10 lakhs 5 lakhs 1 lakhs with
probabilities of 2. 4.4 and the U
function being w^ half which is the
power U function here power U function
means that gamma value is half C value
is one and c and Gamma if you remember
were less than equal to
one so this value would 3 lakh
7,881 we just balance
it now considering the discussion of
certainty equivalent on the gamble I'll
discuss few important points a risk of
person with select an equivalent
certainty event rather than the
gamble so if he wants to avoid risk he
will go for the sure event not the
gamble a risk neutral person will be
indifferent to both of them and for the
case when person is seeking the risk he
or she will select the gamble rather
than the certainty event and then
highlight mention this point which I've
already mentioned few minutes
back that for the risk aers person he is
thinking on the downside risk so if you
consider the last example of the last to
last example where there was an outcome
of 10 and zero the person he or she if
he or she is a risk ofse person is only
concentrating on the value of zero even
though in actuality the expected value
should be used to
balance while the risk neutral person is
thinking of so-called the expected value
for both the cases certainty values sh
event and the Gamble and the risk
seeking person is concentrating thinking
that what if the chance of the head
comes he or she gets
10 it's not that zero won't come with
the probability of half it will come
both for the risk of person and risk
seeking but the risk- seeking person is
concentrating on the value of
10 so with this I will end this 14th
lecture and continue discussing about
util functions in the later class thank
you very much and have a nice
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
day
