is Barbie perpetuating Asian stereotypes
with their new violinist and Panda
veterinarian Barbie actor Daniel Woo is
speaking up about it so let's make sense
of it all you know looking after the
legendary Sha of course is prestigious
but I will prefer my daughter be a
highly paid neurosurgeon plus why is she
sewing so much arm when she is playing
violin is too sexual we got to talk
about this because Andrew Danel Wu came
out against these you can be anything
Asian Barbie dolls one is a panda vet
one is a violinist professionally looks
like and he said listen I'm all for
diversity but you can be anything Asian
Barbie that's a violinist or a panda
doctor that's more like you can be
anything your Asian parents want you to
be either somewh at non-asian at Barbie
F this up with stereotypes or the person
who created these is Asian but they're
carrying on generational trauma and
guess what Andrew a lot of the internet
agreed with them but a lot of them
disagreed with him so we're going to
break it down so make sure you like
subscribe and turnning your
notifications but you know what people
cannot disagree with SMA sauce is
delicious just check it out we're almost
sold out smalla sauce.com get yours now
Andrew this article reads the
controversy raises broader questions
about the significance of accurate
representation in children's toys it may
limit the diverse interests and career
choices within the Asian Community due
to the doll portrayal some people say
wait wait wait wait wait wait wait
they're trying to portray Asian people
accurately or do they want to inspire
Asians to be anything because there's
accurate which is following the numbers
of Asians that are going into these
careers and then there's also let's
break the mold which is to inspire Asian
women to be anything they want okay so
this is where it gets super confusing
guys most Panda vets globally are Asian
women because most pandas come are all
pandas come from China and most of the
caretakers in China not all of them
there's guys too are Chinese women but
here's the thing the panda vets in
America at the San Diego Zoo
specifically are mostly white women so
are they encouraging Asian-American
women to take the jobs at the San Diego
Zoo or were they basing this off of
scientist in Panda scrubs in China and
let me tell you this guys I looked up
Panda vets in China and none of them are
dressed like that this has to be the
most inacurate Barbie of all time just
for a vet like cuz first of all there
are no Panda vets that are dressed like
nurses they're all dressed in these
things these blue scrubs like suits
right yeah they have all the coverings
this is how they're all dressed in
America and in in in China they all wear
the blue scrub coverings with the mask
and the hat so they don't even look like
but the violinist probably more looks
like that to be honest showing the arms
like that though is too sexual what kind
of violinist well is this a female Asian
violinist with a fan base it's just all
white guys all right but we got to go
through other Barbies before we judge
the Asian Barbies we have to look at
other ethnicity Barbies and see if they
are stereotypical as well right from the
you can be anything collection
specifically this is a
specific collection so so now we'll
we'll be able to cross reference it with
some of the black Barbies and the
perceived Latino Barbies to see if they
seem stereotypical okay all right you
can be anything Barbie you got some
curvy Barbies nowadays you have a a
black Barbie who's a tennis star Naomi
Osaka vus Williams golf there are black
women who excel at tennis but but
obviously are they trying to say that
there should be more because it is true
the overall sport of tennis even though
some of the best female tennis players
are black right now is not that black
all right David you have a curvy tan
what looks to be a curvy Latino news
reporter Okay so there is a lot of
famous Latina news anchors but they
might not be that curvy cuz all the ones
that I see on Univision are just baddies
Cur curvy blonde white Dr Barbie this is
this is is a real one is this that I
mean I think there's curvy white doctors
well I don't think there's that many
blond bleached blonde women in GP
medical programs right now so I it's
going against the stats this looks to be
a black rhythmic gymnast Barbie makes
sense Simone biles is that is that
stereotypical because it's based or
inspired by a real Olympian gold
medalist see that's what I'm saying are
they going by the macro stats or are
they just basing this off like a famous
person who defied the odds right but I
will say this of all the Barbie dolls a
lot of these Barbie dolls are dressed
exactly like how they would be during
that job except this Panda vet there are
no Panda vets on the entire internet
that are dressed like this that's almost
like more how a dentist would dress if
to celebrate the some Panda having this
whole Panda set up with the panda going
down the slide with the bamboo slide is
stereotypical I will say this this Panda
vet is kind of stereotypical the
violinist not that stere stereotypical
in my opinion I got zero problem with
that but the Panda one is like OD Panda
there's no Panda vets that saying it's
not rooted in reality where the other
Barbie you can be anything are rooted in
an actual look at this curvy white
blonde Barbie that's a referee that
looks like how a referee is
dressed so I just think there's some
inaccuracy so you're in agreement with
Daniel wuu an extent for sure I'm
focusing on this Panda one because all
right so let's let's look at the modern
Asian Barbies by the way guys listen who
else is going to do this research for
you everybody else is just going to
react emotionally on the internet um we
have pasta Barbie over here I've got a
panda Asian girl gymnast a panda Asian
girl political candidate that's pretty
interesting could be based off Michelle
woo in Boston interes and then we've got
uh Asian-American Soccer Star Panda girl
however it's interesting because I
pulled some ones from the previous years
Andrew the panda pasta Chef used to be
way hotter looking uh you know look more
like you know bad
super this is like the criticism the
Barbie used to get right they made
everything look like the Badd version
stick skinny well stick skinny too like
the hot Instagram of model version of
everything and then uh they had nurse
and then they had uh Barbie vet which I
ain't never seen a vet look like that
but you know anyway Andrew real quick
what are your quick thoughts because it
seemed like a lot of people were like oh
my gosh Daniel boo so right and other
people were like man Asians are being
way too sensitive but it seems like you
are at least partial agreement that this
somebody messed up some sort of design
here right I just think the Panda one is
too OD Panda everything else was done
with class and taste all these other
Barbies make sense the clothing's on
point I thought they actually did a good
job with some of these Barbies You could
argue some of them are stereotypical or
not I think that there's always an
argument that something is stereotypical
to an extent okay but the pant you
didn't need the bamboo slide they don't
that that that I don't know if those
things exist they chined it out yeah
they chinked it out with the panda all
over print and like obviously P look at
all these people holding the pandas
these are all from Google images from
China and from America Pand you do have
the receipts you have the proof people
who work with pandas don't look like
that but anyways David let's get into
the comment section I all right so do
you think Asia made this or not I
actually don't think an Asia made this I
don't think so I think I think I think
it's a white person's depiction of a
panda vet from a movie all right so here
I pulled some comments from Yahoo news
someone said why are we letting foreign
Nationals dictate how an American line
of toys goes huh well Daniel wo is an
ABC by the way he just got famous in
Asia yeah he's not a foreign National
he's a actually American someone said
what so you would have a problem with a
substenance farmer with a conical hat
huh what about if it was gisha girl
Barbie or maybe if this Asian Barbie
worked out a massage parlor doing some
illegal things or or what else what or
doing someone's laundry would you like
that so these were the uh funny but
racist comments from Yahoo news but I
guess is it is it true that because it
was a doctor and a professional musician
we shouldn't complain or is there still
room to complain because they were so
stereotypical even though those are good
job it wasn't like a professional Asian
female guitarist which would have been
breaking the mold it was a violinist
which is a very stereotypical classical
instrument that a lot of Asians make
their Asian daughters grow up learning
right that's what that's why was stere I
would say this David I would like to see
a female Asian golfer Barbie how about
that cuz there there's a lot of legit
Asian female golfers in the world so
that wouldn't have been stereotypical
but would have that been stereotypical
because the top 20 rankings of female
golfers are so
Asian listen is it accurate or
stereotypical and sometimes those things
cross over sometimes those things cross
over is having a black gymnast accurate
or stereotypical because there are
actual black gymnasts that are amazing
it is true they didn't have like a black
female WNBA player which is more would
more stereotypical yeah if you had a
black basketball player Barbie well see
that's why he's confusing anyway Andrew
and that's where there was some even
arguing amongst Asians this girl said I
was reading this and I used to be a
professional violinist and I was an
exmed student I would have loved these
Barbies growing up but then now
everybody's saying in the comment
section that it's too stereotypical I
don't know how to feel about myself now
right I do think that there's some sense
like we don't want to shy away from
these good careers even if the good
careers are stereotypical stem careers
string I guess it's tough because
there's always that thing where Asians
get made fun of for being just stem
robots and being so good at stem stem
stem but then the truth is we do value
stem and stem is good for the world and
you need stem Majors but maybe Asians
don't only have to be stem Majors right
so when the Barbies reconfirm that stem
pathway
then I guess it's too stereotypical
right I I that's why it's listen I
believe there are valid arguments on
both sides somebody said well what about
a Asian accountant or a real estate
Barbie that'd be more realistic that's
funny but I think the Asian accountant
one that other people would have said
that was more problematic too right yeah
I mean David would an Asian Professor
Barbie have been
stereotypical man a foreign adjunct ta
for sure that like it's like here's how
to pronounce my last name call me PM
that an
Asian female Barbie that's a
mathematician would have been kind of
stereotypical I guess um Andrew there
was a bunch of comments from various
Asians I won't read them all but
essentially they're like can we stop
being triggered at everything what like
if I it was a Barbie with a big bowl of
fur and I always eat F all the time why
why and then of course people got but
there was a bunch of arguments somebody
said let's not Asians become the next
soft and easily offended group and uh
people just went back and forth I
couldn't even copy and paste the whole
thread because it went on for like 20
arguments I mean David what's your
overall take on all this listen Barbie
honestly in macro does this really
matter I don't think it's that big of a
deal but I think Daniel woo does have a
point he has a point but I don't think I
agree on that extent so I guess what is
your take I think it's fair to call uh
have Mattel explain its process behind
creating the bamboo slide and just being
like you know what I mean like I just
want to know did it get approved by
somebody Asian maybe that person is
whitewashed maybe they're not
whitewashed who approved it and what's
the thinking behind having an inaccurate
Panda vet costume but is it the biggest
deal ever I think people want to show
their dissatisfaction but Mattel seems
like a good an easy target right because
there's other ways to explain your
dissatisfaction with how we're
stereotyped in society and how we're
treated as like weaker physical people
that's why for example Asian stores get
robbed more often or Asians get run up
on a lot but nobody really wants to talk
about that aspect because that seems too
difficult yeah so discuss
stereotypes in reference to dolls but
how much do dolls really impact Society
probably pretty nominally if at all
here's the point is that Barbie is
trying to make an effort to break the
mold because their whole message behind
you can be anything is you can be
anything you don't have to be what your
parents want you don't have to be what
society says you should be able to be uh
a black female guitarist or a black
female mathematician or an Asian uh
pastry chef oh why don't they show like
a Asian a white girl at a walk that
would be something where i' be like yeah
you could be an old Chinese Chef as a
white woman if you want blond Chinese
Chef actually never even seen that
before I never seen a blonde person let
alone a blonde woman in front of a fiery
walk how come they don't have a blonde
girl rapper like Barbie like that would
because I know a lot of like white girls
who want to do that well you see it on
Instagram right now or like uh yeah
so I just think that they would take
extra creative liberties with the Asian
Panda vet Barbie like it just that's so
stereotypical of Mattel to be like hey
let's we got to do something with pandas
and like a veterinarian all right well
let's put pandas all over her outfit and
then have little pandas sliding down a
bamboo slide and that is going to be
like accurate but I'm saying everything
else was done accurate so I guess that's
my whole point to show you I will I
fully agree with Daniel shout out to
Daniel who was a friend of ours there is
a complete lack of care around Asian
imagery yes they do not care they think
that just they're they're not going to
double check it with anybody they're
going to double check it with the white
whitewash coworker maybe she was adopted
or something going be like yeah I don't
know we made a triple Asian why not
throw some dragon tattoos on her I don't
know but but let's have the black WNBA
player Barbie why not let's just go for
it you know what I'm saying right but I
guess that's why I'm saying but anyways
I'm not mad I'm not really mad cuz I
can't let Barbie dolls like affect how I
feel but I will I'll I'll agree with
Daniel like that that one was OD it's
there's not the care around the Asian
identity that other identities receive
bar Barbie does not treat the Asian
identity with much tacked is what I'm
saying I would agree with that for I
don't think they hate Asian people I
just don't think they take it with much
tack I don't know about the generational
trauma part that I I probably disagree
with that part but anyways guys you guys
let us know in the comments down below
um how stereotypical is this Panda vet
Barbie considering no Panda vets in the
entire world actually look like this uh
but yeah let me know if that even
matters to you or it doesn't or maybe we
shouldn't give an f what Barbie does
because who cares they're fake bar
because you're still centering Barbie
when you care about Barbie but you could
also argue that Barbie is hyper
Americana and is reflective of the
American like landscape or
mindscape I think we talked about Barbie
quite a lot today all right everybody
let us know in the comments down below
and until next time we out
peace