this altercation between this British
musician and this Chinese TV station is
causing a viral debate about Freedom now
let's see who was right and who was
wrong all right so Brendan Kavanagh is a
street piano player there are people
that are about to shoot like I believe a
Chinese New Year promo for British CCTV
they're waiting to use the piano and
then just something goes wrong the whole
Japanese team I think she's nice she got
hello can you dance can you do a dance
but we're in a free country mate in
communist China now you know oh I'm
sorry this is reist now we have no we're
not in communist China we're in
country that's fine we're not talking
about two race this is not a racist
issue please don't call us we're not in
China this is the moment that you're
trying to reach your hand touch her
without her permission I don't want to
touch him at all that's good stay away
don't touch her don't
touch well there we go so we've got a
few people from China telling us that
we're not allowed to film listen boom
man this has 10 million views on Brendan
Kavanagh Channel this has been widely
sort of disseminated and went viral on
the internet and it seems like such a
trivial thing to go viral Andrew but
there's probably something much deeper
underneath it oh let me tell you this
there's a lot of emotions involved and a
lot of people are chiming in because uh
this guy Brandon wants to make it about
Freedom he's like it's a free country
it's a free country and then the Chinese
people they're probably not handling it
right either anyways guys we're going to
break it down so please hit that like
button check out other episodes of the
hot pop Boys by the way smalla sauce is
officially sold out on the website thank
you so much for ordering um you know
ultimately I think that the Chinese
people were wrong but I think there's a
lot more to this and there's a lot more
to the internet reaction I think it's
pretty simple to see that the Chinese
people even though they want to film
their you know Chinese New Year promo
for CCTV or whatever I'm not saying they
all work for the TV station I think it's
a colle ction of people like they should
have just picked another piano you know
what I mean cuz they're waiting for
Brendan Kavanaugh to finish busking
which is like street performing and this
is what Brendan Kavanagh does on his
channel he streams himself he is a bit
of a Troll he's been in altercations
with like other people playing the piano
um he's also had great interactions with
other people playing the piano but
apparently they're like y we are from a
Chinese TV station and you cannot like
film our we have like image right
basically people are like no you don't
no you don't it's not communist China
and then it just turns into a huge thing
about people saying that these Chinese
people are trying to enforce Chinese law
on British soil even though I kind of
don't fully think that that's the case
here even though I could see why people
perceive it that way right so you're
saying overall the Chinese people it was
it should the responsibility falls on
them to have handled this situation
better yeah they didn't handle it right
and now it kind of like looks bad not
maybe on all Chinese people but it
definitely like let
a Del or almost like built Dam of
criticism that people felt like they
couldn't say it it let it all out here's
where I think the Chinese people have a
point and I'm just going to defend them
on this point if they don't want their
faces in a video that you are going to
use to make money it is true it is your
obligation and being on the internet we
know this having a YouTube channel we
know this that if someone wants their
face removed or blurred you have an
obligation to blur or remove their face
or not film them that is your obligation
as a content creator it's true if
someone tells you hey can you stop
filming
me that is against their they're not
giving you permission to film them
that's true so that's their point so I
think that's number one that goes for
the Chinese people I think that's fair
because we've had people who said hey
can you blur my face I ended up in the
back of this video and we did it because
that's the right thing he do live stream
though so it makes it a little bit more
complicated but but I don't care just
because you're live streaming it does
not give you an excuse to film everybody
now with that said and this guy Brandon
is a troll himself he's a sharp guy and
he's very smart right no he gets in
constant uh battles verbal altercations
on his channel he's upholding the uh the
the English the Mastery of the English
language right and debate uh so he has a
point though in saying like well my
point is like why are the Chinese people
in the back of the shot why don't they
just move why don't they just move away
from the camera well yeah cuz we are
waiting to use the p no they can wait
for the p but just stay out of the angle
and if they continue to film them
against their will then they need to say
hey you're harassing me you can't film
me now it's true you can film in public
but again filming in public if someone
does not want to be filmed and they know
they're being filmed you have an
obligation to not film them with that
said everybody could have handled this
situation differently this guy Brandon
is clearly a troll himself so he kind of
made it a little racial or a little
nationalistic he did not try to
deescalate he's trying to put on a show
so to me these are two people on the
opposite ends of the spectrum and
they're clashing right now so that's my
point um well yeah I mean and it's true
the Chinese they handled it badly they
have bad communication skills they
should have just paid him off they
should have given him like 400 bucks or
I don't even know whatever four 300
pound if it's a public piano then
there's no like booking or reservations
for it right right and my other thing is
this like listen man if you are going to
film something that's so Chinese with
the Chinese flag everywhere out in
public do you not understand that you
are going to get some stairs and you're
going to get some people who are going
to maybe yell at you maybe talk crap
maybe make fun of you I I don't think
they would even have done this in
America but in I think in Britain it may
not have the same contentious
relationship in Times Square New York
David and you got all these Chinese
flags and you got all you don't think
people are going to jump behind you and
do little like funny things and photob
bomb you you don't think that's going to
happen you have to understand that's
going to happen right so so that's just
being clueless on their part no no no
these people were certainly like
clueless they probably are like
particularly patriotic you know what I
mean it's just like I America something
even worse would have happened probably
like maybe yeah but this British guy's
kind of an he's kind of a dick
no he is he's known for like anybody
who's like being like Oh my God like
he's a great defender of Freedom this
man is a Troll he's been known for
getting a lot of views trolling a
variety of people do not get this
Twisted this guy Brandon is not a true
gentleman okay he is a a British troll
right right but he is making a point I
just think it's interesting that all the
things you know ever since Andrew the
British were taking a
Chinese would you like to go get a
Chinese tonight and then I'm like this
incident came out of here man anyway
let's just get into the comments section
Andrew somebody said like I said the guy
in The Piano guy is ultimately right but
he's still a complete tool basically
people were like yeah I Get It
ultimately I probably have to side with
him but let's be honest this guy is has
bad behavior himself but do you think
his YouTube video should get taken down
yeah it should because they can claim
copyright on the imagery not because
they can't get filmed but because he's
using their likeness to make money yeah
he's trolling them to make a bunch of
money off the AdSense guys I am a
content creator we've been making
YouTube and social media videos for
years and I will tell you this if
somebody does not want to be in our
video we have an OP obligation to to cut
them out or blur them but the part that
they were wrong the Chinese tourists or
whatever you want to call them some
people are calling them spies whatever
you want to say they're when they're
like we have image right we have image
right that's not fully true because they
might have the image right for the
non-disclosure agreement with like UK
CCTV or whatever there I don't know what
like Channel they're working for that
may be but that doesn't necessarily
extend to his production but the fact
that he's mon iing on it does change the
legal equation a little bit yeah yeah
yeah um so he's kind of wrong he's a
little a little wrong he is actually a
little bit wrong because he's monetizing
off of it um I'll say this when it just
kind of turned into a lot of Chinese
bashing though because a lot of people
are sick of what they're hearing in the
news they're calling whether it's you
know whether it's China bashing or CCP
bashing or whatever it like sort of I
feel like sometimes these like more
trivial simplistic incidents they open
up for a lot of like like I said the
floodgates to open for how people really
been feeling yeah but I I think here's
the thing even for like westernized
Chinese or Chinese Americans or Chinese
of the diaspora I think for speaking for
myself it's like I don't
fully feel for obviously I would never
want this altercation to get worse but
at the same time I can't really fully
side with these people with the Chinese
TV station cuz I'm like I would never do
that like that's not me with the flags
trying to do something ridiculous like I
would be able to handle myself better I
would never do that like I'm not
representing you know China right now
like I I love Chinese culture I'm proud
of being Chinese and I'm proud of the
Chinese culture and in the diaspora but
I cannot I'm not like representing the
government you know so I'm like right
these people were a little bit trying to
rep I'm not not saying that they were
but it sure seemed like they were
representing the government yeah so I I
guess what I'm saying is like if you're
going to do something that's considered
a bold move in public you have to
understand just as him playing the piano
he's ready for some altercations as well
a lot of people were talking about it
was just miscommunication and obviously
uh Brendan kavenaugh he's way better at
communicating his point of view than the
Chinese were communicating their point
the Chinese have their point about not
wanting to be filmed they probably
should have moved away from the camera
first
but yeah they they they did tell him
they didn't want to be filmed it's true
right right right um somebody he says
when in Rome do as the Romans do and
then a lot of people were basically
pointing out that like they feel like
this was everybody's chance to air their
grievances with Chinese tourists where
they feel like they don't really like
assimilate well into wherever they're
going around the world and then of
course this turned into the talk of like
you know the Japanese are much better
mannered than the Chinese the Chinese
they seem to go everywhere and they have
no tact um I do think that Chinese
people because they're like several
decades economically behind in
development they're struggling to
there's there's going to be more Rocky
incidents you know when they're like
going abroad yeah yeah for sure I mean
that that that is fair to say um
somebody said they not wanting to be
filmed and them causing a scene that
goes Super viral is beautifully ironic
um people were talking about that guy
who was a drama queen he's like don't
touch her don't touch
her what about that part uh I don't know
listen I'm not gonna break down every
single interaction that happened every
word exchange I just that part was a
little
cringey yeah again I think it's people
Chinese people not handling things the
way uh like with so much tact you know
like I understand that I think some of
those Chinese people had been living in
Britain for decades probably because
they were like oh I'm British but they
were probably Chinese
born I I would have expected them to
handle things a little better yeah for
sure for sure really bad uh
communication skills to be honest
somebody said I'm proud to be Chinese
what these people did in this video does
not define the rest of us I feel like
this CL aration is somewhat necessary
actually most people and on the local
Chinese internet in China are also
supporting ultimately Brendan Kavanagh
more so yeah like even people in China
are like oh gosh what are these people
doing making us look bad yeah yeah I my
only thing is that when they tell him
they don't want to be filmed he should
in post after the stream is up be
blurring their faces right yeah um
basically people were just saying you
know
uh they were the going against the
British police cuz the British police
woman was kind of like you can't say
that Brendan you can't say that when
he's like we're not in China we not in
China no that's that's true you're not
in China yeah that's a fact yeah he is
also saying it to troll too and
antagonized to get more views so
ultimately Andrew what do you think man
Andrew this guy went on Piers Morgan and
that got 2 million views the original
video which I believe will get taken
down due to likeness copyright on
YouTube YouTube's rules will got like 12
million views we're talking about
something that is such a silly incident
we're talking about usage of a donated
piano from Elton John inside of a train
station that is technically owned by
like a bunch of different companies that
invested in it or whatever but I'm just
saying like what are we even talking
about we're talking about the usage of a
piano but somehow this crazy incident
got like the most millions of
views that you could think of any like
Chinese Western interaction in a long
time
um I don't know I think it's just that
some people identify with brandan and
that no they're using it as a like
symbolic way to express how they feel
how about this how about this on the
positive side I think some Chinese
people are watching this and learning
from this hopefully like don't do this
well handle it differently because
listen if you're in a western country
and you're all Chinese flagged out
and you're in public going to do
something you have to know that's
considered a bold move right you know
I'm not saying you deserve any sort of
like uh uh aggressiveness or you don't
deserve any of it I'm just saying
realistically it might come right are
you talking about also like maybe people
like holding up the uh the flags for
xiin ping when he was there for the the
SF Global Summit yeah like listen
like listen I if you stand bold on what
you believe in I respect that but also
you have to understand that there's
going to be some static there's going to
be some tension there's going to be some
people there's tension right now there's
people who feel some type of way so
you're going to look be perceived as an
agitator right and you better be able to
handle it it was almost like he
perceived them as they were trolling
Britain and then obviously he himself as
a busker he's naturally kind of a troll
on his channel and then you just got you
it was like they were unintentionally
trolling cuz they were just so naive and
just like yeah we have to film The TR
like video yeah well that's like me
wearing a t-shirt around like going to
Texas and wearing a a t-shirt that says
America's number or wearing the Detroit
Jersey to SF Stadium yeah you're just
wearing the other team's Jersey in their
home City you're not going to get like
when we went to Boston and I was wearing
Brooklyn Net stuff wear Yankee stuff
dude yeah it's crazy dude so you just
understand you're wearing the other
team's Jersey right but I don't think
they understood that and they handled it
poorly like I said I don't think this
guy Brendan Kavanaugh is a great guy
either yeah I don't think he came in
with the most Angel like intentions
let's be honest guys but anyways let us
know in the comments down below what you
think you know I just hope everybody
learns from this situation and again you
just have to know what situation you're
walking into man that's all yeah hey
guys let us know what you think of the
comments section below a lot of people
asked us to talk about this incident
until next time with to hop H boys we
out
peace