1 Video View·Jan 30, 2024
Taylor sits down with Dr. Hayden Evans of NIST and Sir Anthony Cheetham of UCSB/Cambridge/National University Singapore to talk about their research on carbon storing materials. Learn what special characteristics makes the materials they are researching well suited for CO2 capture.
Articles:
Perovskite-related ReO3-type structures
Aluminum formate, Al(HCOO)3: An earth-abundant, scalable, and highly selective material for CO2 capture
Noncryogenic Air Separation Using Aluminum Formate Al(HCOO)3 (ALF)
Exclusive Recognition of CO2 from Hydrocarbons by Aluminum Formate with Hydrogen-Confined Pore Cavities
Hydrogen Storage with Aluminum Formate, ALF: Experimental, Computational, and Technoeconomic Studies
This episode is sponsored by Cal Nano, learn more about their work and services by visiting their website.
This episode is sponsored by Materials Today, an Elsevier community dedicated to the creation and sharing of materials science knowledge and experience through their peer-reviewed journals, academic conferences, educational webinars, and more.
Thanks to Kolobyte and Alphabot for letting us use their music in the show!
If you have questions or feedback please send us emails at [email protected] or connect with us on social media: Instagram, Twitter.
Materialism Team: Taylor Sparks (co-creator,co-host), Andrew Falkowski (co-creator), Jared Duffy (production, marketing, and editing).
Keywords: CO2 Capture Sequestration Carbon Reducing MOF Formate
I would like to describe a field in
which little has been done but in which
an enormous amount can be done this
field is not quite the same as the
others in that it will tell us little of
fundamental physics but it will tell us
much about the strange phenomena that
occurred just below our perception in
contrast to the Natural philosophers of
the past the scientists of this field
delve into the recesses of Nature and
show how she works in her hiding places
their Quest is to understand and create
the imperceptible after all there is
plenty of room at the
bottom hello and welcome to the
materialism podcast an exploration of
the past present and future of Material
Science my name is Taylor Sparks and I
an associate professor of Material
Science and Engineering here at the
University of Utah in Salt Lake City and
I'm joined today by two co-hosts who are
going to help me learn all about the
world of absorbing CO2 right if we're
going to get serious about tackling uh
CO2 emissions one thing that we might
consider is how we could absorb those
and do something with them I have Hayden
Evans and Tony chetam and I'll let them
introduce themselves great so my name is
Hayden Evans uh I'm a research chemist
at the NIS Center for Neutron research
and I'm Tony cheum I'm a research
professor at UC Santa Barbara and I also
hold a visiting professorship at n Us in
Singapore fantastic well thank you I
don't know where in the world everybody
is we're from all over the place I'm
glad we found a time zone where we could
chat um hey I've known for a while and
he had reached out to me a while back
with some really cool new findings that
have been coming out of the work that
you've been doing together on aluminum
formate a material that I'd never heard
of before actually I'd never actually
heard of this one and yet it turns out
to have a lot of interesting properties
and some of those are going to be
relevant to some big challenges that we
face as a society namely CO2 emissions
so before we get started with aluminum
formate if some of our listeners were
like me and didn't know what that
material was what its structure was
maybe we should start there what is this
structure and why is that what is it
about the structure that makes it
compelling or interesting to
study so in general uh if we think about
this material and we know it's an
absorbent many different types of of
absorbents you can think of them as sort
of surfaces um but in particular the
types of compounds we like to to study
they're more like sponges so you can
imagine some kind of block of material
but it has these holes and channels that
sort of run through them aluminum format
is one of these types of absorbents it
is porous so it has places in its atomic
structure where other molecules can slip
inside of the Void spaces that have been
and defined in them and and more
generally we've been you know interested
in different types of absorbance
particularly the type of crystal
structure that aluminum formate has Tony
and I were particularly interested in
this for for many many years and I'm
sure Tony can sort of speak about his
general interest on formates in more
more specifically sort of this larger
crystal structure
class yeah if I pick it up there um I've
been interested in these abx3 perov
skites that have um typical example
might be dimethyl ammonium uh zinc
formates and they adopt the classical
abx3 perov skite structure uh but in
this case the formate acts as the Linker
compared with the classical in oranic
systems where you might have say oxide
as the Linker or halide as the Linker
and uh actually I started working on
these things in about
2007 in collaboration with the late
Sahari Coto who won the Nobel Prize for
discovering
ferin and uh We've Harry and I shared a
student Harry was at Florida State and I
was at UCSB we had a student called
prant Jane and prant worked most of his
time with me in Santa Barbara and he
inadvertently made Single crystals of
this dimethyl ammonium zinc formate
perovskite and it turned out that had
been made before but this started a
whole thread of work which uh lasted
nearly a decade when we discovered that
they were ferroelectrics they could be
multi heroics and some so
on now in this particular system the
cavities are occupied by the dthy
ammonium but uh when Hayden and I were
researching this article on the systems
with the remium trioxide structure which
is a perovskite with no aat in the
cavities we came across aluminum
formate um and it had been known for a
very long time but the crystal structure
had been determined by a Chinese group
and there was something really
intriguing about it which is that when
they did the crystal structure they
discovered that there was CO2 in the
cavity in the asight
cavity and uh so in fact the title of
the paper that they wrote suggested that
the CO2 was necessary to template the
formation of this structure oh is that
true has that held born out to be true
that's well it's probably true yes it's
probably true because though people have
made uh including ourselves a number of
analoges of aluminum formate synthesiz
them say with iron or with manganese or
with gallium and so on it's always got
CO2 in the cavity oh interesting some of
our listeners might be familiar with the
Prov skite structure um it probably s it
in their introductory course um now
normally if you take like abx3 you've
got two different cations and in the
structure it's it's what's so great
about it is that it accommodates big and
little right because you have a smaller
cavity right six coordinate and you get
the larger 12 coordinate one but in this
rium oxide type structure it's
interesting in that you only have one of
those catons right it because the
tungsten for example and some of these
other materials can become six plus it
can actually electrostatically balance
out the six minus coming from the
oxygens and so it occupies quite happily
the smaller space right something six
plus is going to be really small but
then you got these big cavities and I so
that's where the CO2 is going is in the
larger
cavities yeah because the uh bridging
formates are much larger than say oxygen
in aro3 itself you get quite a large
cavity and and so the Chinese Group
found that in the crystal structure
there was CO2 in the cavity when you
made it and so we had two thoughts and
this was work that we initially did in
Singapore with a postto um called denes
mangi who worked with me first of all uh
could we remove the
CO2 without collapsing the
structure and if we did that could we
would the resulting material be uh
genuinely porous and could we reabsorb
the CO2 into it one of the particular
interesting details about this Chinese
work is that you could tell based on how
they had written this paper that they
were interested in removing the CO2 as
well because they could appreciate that
they this was a very interesting crystal
structure
however we from what we can infer from
their the manuscript and you never know
how people write manuscripts are like oh
I meant to do this I meant to do that
like you never know exactly if you're
getting the the the the true story or
you're getting the written story but our
perspective on it is that potentially
that they were particularly interested
in the iron compound and when you try to
remove the CO2 from the iron formate
structure it doesn't work it doesn't
work or it's very hard to do and they
gave like a crys graphic argument they
were like the hydrogen bonds of how the
CO2 fits inside the cavity they're just
too strong and anything smaller than
iron obviously they wouldn't have any
success with doing it but that's just
not that's just not the case that the
aluminum one is actually able to have
the CO2 removed much easier I can't say
we've tried any of the other analoges
just as aggressively because aluminum
formate was you know the cheapest and
and easiest to make and well behaved why
would you why would you start playing
with indium gallium yeah right well I'm
curious for our listeners that have
never even considered molecules floating
into an otherwise mostly inorganic sort
of structure and absorbing it like a
sponge how do you actually get that
stuff out because uh yeah I'm not
actually totally for myself I assume
that you could just reduce the pressure
and maybe some of it would de gas I
assume you could maybe try and heat it
up maybe you could flush it out with a
smaller molecule and my are there other
approaches that I'm not thinking of well
in this particular case the easiest way
of doing it is to heat it up and the CO2
comes out so that's what we did with the
asade material which contains CO2 anyway
we gently heated it up and we studied
the heating quite carefully and on until
we found that we could have a set of
conditions where we could remove the CO2
whilst pre preserving the crystal
structure and so we did in situ x-ray
powder defraction as a function of
temperature and you can basically watch
the CO2 coming out and it's repeatable
you can do this over and over and it
doesn't destabilize it over time right
so then once you've done that the CO2
will go back in uh it's got fantastic
affinity for CO2 because as Hayden
mentioned the CO2 hydrogen bonds in the
cavity to the hydrogen atoms of the
formate Linker per so you have hydrogen
bondings between the formate hydrogens
and the oxygens of the
CO2 and it kind of
exquisitly um constructed so that this
is more or less a perfect fit and that's
why the people thought it was templating
the structure and and indeed it probably
was uh so um and you once you've
activated it and then you can uh
reabsorb CO2 you can by taking the
temperature down and then passing CO2
over it and so on and then you can do
that
indefinitely absorb and desol I would
say just H you know as you as you
pointed out Taylor many many of your
listeners may not appreciate sort of the
the field of absorbance or the kind of
terminology we may use sort of in
passing here but you can imagine you can
imagine absorbent having these sort of
cavities and when you make these things
whether it's something like a zealite
which may many people might encounter
you know dayto day you know whether it
be sort of kitty litter or you know
other kind of you know uh kind of
situations where you have these
materials made out of silicon dioxide
that are absorbing um in that instance
sort of water but any of these sort of
generally these
absorbents they may be synthesized or
made and they might have something
sitting inside those cavities or maybe
they generally are pulling stuff from
the air when they're made but the
general term used in this field is
something called activation right you're
activating your porous material so that
there's nothing inside and then it's
ready to suck up something um whatever
you know the chemist or or or the person
using it chooses to to put into it right
and so these General steps of activation
are like uh you know Tony sort of
described so heating reduce pressure or
like you said introducing some kind of
molecule to flush it out right so you
could pass gas like nitrogen or or you
know that's a comical way to say that
you can you can pass gas over it like
nitrogen or helium or something like
that or if you're dealing with some some
of these other absorbents where they may
be made with these really um tricky
solvents they might have something like
these very heavy solvents like dimethyl
formid that has like a boiling you know
point of about 160 Celsius something
nasty like that it's up there and so
generally what they'll do is they'll
wash it with methanol and methanol has
like a boiling point of 60 right so
they'll swap out that one solvent for
another and then they'll blast it with
heat and and reduce pressure and then
you can create an open space again so
generally speaking when it comes to
these sort of you know I'm not a
catalysis person I'm not like an
absorption person but I'm kind of
interested in this but what I do know
from catalysis is that that interaction
it's not just like the volume right it's
not just like the size the channel was
the right size for it it was that
interaction and in catalysis it's kind
of the same thing right you want it to
interact but not too strong you want it
to form a like there's a there's a sweet
spot in terms of the bonding is it the
same thing with all of your active
absorption materials where there has to
be that level of chemical Affinity
otherwise it won't actually stay in the
structure I think yeah oh Tony you want
to go ahead yeah I'll go ahead on this
uh if the absorption is too
strong uh then you have difficulty
getting the absorb molecule
out and so as you said earlier you want
to be able to say heat it up remove the
stuff and then reabsorb but if it's
absorbed too strongly then you you know
it becomes expensive to take it to quite
high temperatures to get the molecules
out so uh in this particular case the
heat of absorption is more or less
perfect for a file absorption and
desorption if the heat of absorption is
too small then the molecules don't want
to go in and so the capacity is not as
good so okay we hit a sweet spot I think
with Al hence why you got the great
paper we saw this in science advances
this was in November of last year so um
hot on the tales of that I imagine that
now you're wondering what else can it
absorb but another question I must have
is like okay what if you were to modify
this structure slightly either via
doping or you know something else to try
and can you make it can you tune it
chemically to interact with other
species or to do something else I
imagine these are the types of questions
that you've been following up with this
so I think that the beauty of aluminum
formate is that you know opposed to some
of these other types of absorbents which
have um what are what are referred to as
undercoordinated metal center so as Tony
was sort of describing the sort of heat
of absorption right when you have a a a
metal sensor that might like to form six
bonds say but then given the charge and
sort of the kind of local environment
and whatever crystal structure you've
put this in maybe you can have something
not attached to one of those bonds and
so it has sort of this open area where
certain molecules can plug in uh
electrically or sort of like to hover
next to sort of these open orbitals that
might have like a very strong kind of uh
interaction with whatever gas molecule
have and you can think about maybe
switching the metals or changing the
local environments maybe you can change
sort of the intensity of how strong
comes in however in the case of Al there
is no open exposed metal center it is a
it is a cage that is defined in a very
specific way and so the interactions
that we're dealing with when we put
certain types of gas molecules in are
the kind of interactions you're getting
with the hydrogen's from the formate
sort of a hydrogen bonding interaction
or just generally sort of you know
Vander walls kind of associations as
they go hug up against the walls of the
cavity and so if you think about in some
sense um some absorption onto a surface
maybe it's just some kind of you know
potential on some surface in the case of
Al you have a cage that's defined by
these multiple surfaces right so it's
the it's the combination of all these
different sort of Attraction uh
attractive forces that you can have with
the molecule so to your question can you
make Chemical modifications yes you can
but what you're changing in some sense
and this is as Tony will will confirm is
that we at first we didn't quite
understand why aluminum formate behaved
the way it did we we're genuinely
confused by how something so simple can
present so many interesting uh
properties in the case of our first
paper which was the discrimination from
CO2 and nitrogen right nitrogen and
carbon dioxide are very close together
in sort of size or at least you know
kinetic what they call Kinetic diameter
how easy it is for something to sort of
um you know pass through uh or it's
approximated sort of size okay
um why it does that is actually
intimately linked to the specific
crystal structure of aluminum format so
when you change part of the crystal
structure you can actually change how
certain gases come in and out and so we
didn't really demonstrate this in the
CO2 paper but in the followup paper as
you were saying We examined that oxygen
can also go into aluminum formate but if
you change the crystal structure by
incorporating something like iron to
replace the aluminum just a bit you know
about half um a little shy of half of of
the aluminum switched out with iron that
you can actually change and distort the
crystal structure in such a way that its
discriminating properties for certain
gas molecules uh starts to fade and so
but you can so that means that certain
gases might be able to rush inside the
crystal structure much faster than they
would have been if you had just normal
aluminum instead of aluminum iron
combination oh killer so you're if I
could chip in please yeah if I could
chip chip in on that uh when you dope
with iron and C up to about 50% you
actually change both the thermodynamics
of the absorption but you also change
the
kinetics and so uh we found that it was
particularly attractive for enhancing
the uh kinetics of the adsor of oxygen
as long as we got the doping level just
right um so it would absorb oxygen and
and not
nitrogen um and of course the first
paper that you mentioned was all about
the fact that nitrogen wouldn't go
in and so we thought well nitrogen's
just a bit too big so that gave us the
idea that maybe oxygen which is smaller
would go in and then we could take
oxygen from the
air as a air separation process which is
extremely important um as we saw during
the pandemic when there were shortages
of medical oxygen so we were actually
able to absorb oxygen leaving the
nitrogen behind in and uh enhance the
efficiency of doing that by doping with
iron so I have a couple questions first
off when you well first I'm surprised
you can dope it so much like but that's
kind of the point of a lot of these Prof
skes is just how tolerant they are to
they're not these are not line compounds
right these are very accommodating
structures because there's different
size spots to put things and uh there's
just a lot of flexibility in the
structure as well so you can go up to
50% I assume you can go even further
like how how flexible are these
structures in terms of doping and that's
my first question and the second one
you're you're messing with the the
cation uh the the metal that's
surrounded by the oxygen but what about
the formate itself have have you doped
the formate Linker as well have you
tried exchanging things there as
well uh not in the AL structure uh we
have we have actually in some of the
earlier work that Hayden mentioned
earlier we tried making hyper
phosphite analoges of of these uh
formates tried and succeeded we
succeeded yes we did this well I was
working at Cambridge we did this we made
perovskite analoges of the uh formates
using um hyper
phosphite and in part of that work we
also did mixtures of formate and Hyper
phosphite uh which uh you know gave us
uh substitution just as you were
thinking when you do that with the
aluminum formate it's and we've not
spent spent a lot of time on this we've
made the pure hyper phosphite analogs of
the aluminum formate we've not spent a
lot of time on making the uh doped
systems because we believe that the
additional hydrogens on the hyper
phosphate are going to fill the cavity
and so it's going to reduce the capacity
so that's even though it would be
interesting and we'll get round to doing
it at some point it's not high priority
at the moment okay
so so far we have this interesting
material it seems to be templated by CO2
when you when it first forms but because
of this sort of sweet spot and bonding
you can pull it out put it in you do
this repeatably um it clearly has some
Affinity to other types of gas molecules
and that's probably tunable based off of
how we can mess with the structure a
little bit what else can it do what
can't it do what have you run into
limitations with
it I I mean yeah it has limitations but
funny enough those limitations turn out
to be good right it has limitations in
nitrogen discrimination which is great
because it means we can separate
nitrogen from all these other gases
additionally it also has limitations um
in in absorbing hydrocarbons and so as
we we sort of mentioned here this work
on aluminum formate is not just Tony and
I it is involving denesh but more
generally uh myself Tony and our many
collaborators at the National University
of Singapore that Tony intro introduced
us to specifically Dan Xiao and pi canpa
and so Dan Xiao took the lead um on some
aspect of work showing how Al can be
used with hydrocarbons and that was
mostly because we our our first paper on
the co on the CO2 Discovery was just it
was held in review for a very long time
and so we were just doing work we had
other things to do as it sat in the
reviewer's hands so we just kept working
right and we realized it could do lots
and lots of things so Dan Xiao showed
that it absorbs CO2
but it does not absorb pretty much any
hydrocarbon and then the one of specific
interest or the just the two would be of
specific interest for multiple different
um applications would be methane so
methane is just a little too big to fit
inside of aluminum formates but you can
imagine it's still fairly close to CO2
right it's it's it's in the ballpark I
mean it's a it's I don't actually don't
know the kinetic diameter of methane do
you know that off yeah it's
significantly higher than CO2 yeah and
are these things found together in in
drilling like where where do you find
these things together where you'd want
to separate them oh well you in two
areas both of which are of great
interest one is in um some of the
natural well uh natural gas Fields uh so
for example in New Zealand there are
natural gas fields that are rich in
CO2 and um there's another one I'm aware
of in Botswana huge natural gas field
that's got a lot of CO2 so taking CO2
out of the natural gas is very
attractive because you you don't want to
be using natural gas say as a fuel if
it's already got a lot of CO2 in it sure
because it reduces the efficiency of the
fuel so that's uh one area the other
area where you find natural gas with CO2
or methane is natural gas Acca is in
these uh
biotechnology digestion systems you know
for taking food waste or agricultural
waste and and then you break them down
and generate
biogas and biogas has a lot of CO2 in it
and so I think that this is a really
sweet spot for using Alf uh because the
question is what are you going to do
about the
CO2 um so that you can use the method
yeah there's another opportunity a
colleague of mine here does CO2
injection to stimulate Wells so if
you're if you're drilling for oil and
gas for example and you have two places
where you could access the well if you
inject a whole bunch of CO2 it can
actually pressure it up out the other
side but you're poisoning your your your
product in some cases with that CO2 but
now you've got a way to clean it up
again which is pretty slick right that
would work for that as well yeah so the
the thing we haven't talked about yet
but is really what makes this material
critically important is it's cost um
aluminum obviously second third most
abundant element on the planet right
it's going to be very cheap and form it
is easy to make so this is going to be
an inexpensive option um because it'd be
one thing to say we can make this custom
designer zeolite or whatever that's
going to have this perfect Civ size to
do just what you want but if it's crazy
expensive you're not going to use this
I'm assuming that aluminum format is
going to be on the cheap
side it is is about as cheap as you can
probably make something dirt yeah I mean
I like like to say this thing is is dirt
because I mean in some sense it really
is and I I remember when we first sort
of published I mean we know it's cheap
because you can just look up the prices
you can go on I mean the great great
sorcer of chemicals which is Alibaba you
can go check how much if you want for
like a ton of either formic acid and
aluminum hydroxide and they're on the
ballpark of about a dollar per kilogram
each or you can think $1,000 dollar per
metric ton for each of one of those two
reagents so there there is some that's
just the reagents right so the reagent
cost is cheap one of the additional
aspects of making aluminum formate is
that it's just those two things and you
heat them and there are some you know
minor parts of the synthesis but as you
were sort of saying right zeolites if
you make those they're made a silica but
they their synthesis can be kind of
tricky sometime and they might even take
weeks sometimes to crystallize them out
or many of the up until this point metal
organic Frameworks these other very
large class uh of absorbance that have
have these under generally have these
underexposed metal centers um and
aluminum formate technically and we
would like to say is the simplest metal
organic framework but many when many
people think of metal organic Frameworks
they're thinking of these very large
designer organic compounds and the
metals right the reagent cost for some
of those things you know they could be
$100 per kilogram on a good day right
and that depends on some of the metals
if you're using whether it's like nickel
copper you know they could the price
goes up and that doesn't even include
the compli of the synthesis right so one
of the major parts about why aluminate
alumin aluminum form is so interesting
or what we call Al right is because it
is so cheap and like that makes it
interesting in its own right but the
thing is that aluminum formate or Alf
you know the activated form can do these
really really challenging gas
separations so you not only have
something that's even if it was
expensive it's pretty well performing
but the fact that it's so simple makes
this thing quite quite significant uh We
Believe scientifically industrially and
potentially for the
world can I ask like how do you actually
make this stuff you know synthesis
always gets overlooked and I think
that's a shame but how do you make this
stuff is this like a super high
temperature thing what do you do is it
is it high pressure Tony no you you uh
it's done
hydrothermally uh in an autoclave
typically at about say 120 de C and the
beauty of it is that you only need two
starting materials
you use say aluminum hydroxide and
formic acid and the formic acid is a
liquid you use concentrated formic acid
it's a liquid and so it acts as both a
reactant and the
solvent and the one of the things that
we've looked at quite carefully is the
uh question of where does the CO2 come
from that gets trapped in the cavity
when you make it I assume it's a
decomposition of the formate or
something so it's to do with the
decomposition of the formate so you have
to have excess formic acid when you make
it and but you just need those two
things hydrothermal in a small aut clave
or a large autter clave at about 100 to
130 degrees C and um what sort of
pressures is that generating because I
know right you boil things and that
generates a lot of internal pressure
what are we talking about is this is
this like really extreme or not so bad
no no it's quite it it's could be quite
low uh you know sort
of maybe 10 or 20 atmospheres or
something like that but depends upon the
filling factor of the autoclave sure if
you have a small yeah okay so if you if
you have small amount of liquid and
large dead volume then the pressure will
be higher there's also as Tony well Tony
hasn't said yet you can make it in the
autoclave but in terms of scaling up you
can make this thing in round bottom
flask no pressure outside of atmospheric
pressure no ner gas you heat formic acid
and aluminum hydroxide
together for two days at 100 C and
you'll you'll get the clean compound at
the end oh killer so I mean you I know
you sent one more paper about hydrogen
storage so we'll get to that but I just
got to know like is this being
commercialized like what's happening
with this this is a cheap material that
does what you want it to do is there a
company being formed around
this uh so far we not formed a company
around it because we we we felt like a a
kind of dog with four or five
bones and so the the challenge that
we're looking at at the moment is how to
scale up the
synthesis and so yeah I mean Tony's Tony
said this right I mean we there uh
intellectual property has been been
protected on the CO2 capture and the
oxygen purification and the hydrocarbon
purification and then also now the the
the hydrogen aspect of the hydrogen
storage has been protected as well right
so there's intellectual property that's
been protected uh in multiple instances
so there's no one company however if we
were to view this from the perspective
of uh non- capitalists I think we can
all believe that the work we we're doing
here may actually do some real
good somebody might get rich off of it
but I know for a fact that somebody
might get much cleaner oxygen cheaper
oxygen right cheaper oxygen sources
clean up our fuel sources mitigate the
amount of CO2 we're putting out into the
atmosphere um and then you know at the
other side I mean that's the coin that
the two sides of the coin for aluminum
forming right it sucks up CO2 you can
choose to capture it from burning fossil
fuels or you can choose it to clean up
your fossil fuels that I don't you're
more than likely will end up burning
right so it's it's it's and then
probably you use elf to capture the co
that you used it right yeah have you
actually tested on flu gas to see if it
actually works under the conditions that
a see like a cold fired plant would
have no we haven't because though that
was the first uh Target that we set out
to explore and that was in the science
advancers paper we've we've we've done
simulated conditions I see um but the
the challenge with the flu gas Taylor is
that flu gas is both hot and
wet oh so water is going to complicate
it isn't it so the water complicates it
yes and under hot wet conditions you
find the Achilles heel of
Al so we've we've been focusing on these
other applications where uh water is not
going to be a challenge because either
you can you'd have a dry gas stream or
you're not at higher temperatures and so
on perpetually this proves to be the
problem for these large scale CO2
capture right okay so if we imagine we
have a fuel plant right and you're going
to try and capture the CO2 using
something that's going to take a lot of
money and more than likely all you're
doing is you're capturing CO2 right so
how does anything get done in the world
generally is somebody's doing it for a
profit or there profit or there's going
to be a subsidy from the government to
do it for the greater good in in some
perspective right so there's no perfect
material I think is sort of the the
general feeling on specifically CO2
capture right you either have something
that's hyp expensive but it can resist
many of these sort of intense conditions
high humidity socks and knocks you know
capturing CO2 and discriminating against
nitrogen at these higher temperatures
which all of those things combined is
really challenging and then you have to
factor in you actually have to do this
right so it's going to cost money every
fuel plant is producing something like
20,000 tons of CO2 every day there's 300
of those in the United States not
including the rest of the world so you
have to think about this absolutely
massive like mindboggling problem of
capturing CO2 and if you actually want
to do it you have to scale something up
and it's got to be relatively affordable
to do it right so our argument with
aluminum formate is that it's so cheap
and it is so effective that more than
likely you can get away with a dry step
in it and then this probably becomes the
what we argue is one of the most logical
ways to tackle this kind of problem
because outside of that many of these
other competing absorbance
you know they're like about an order of
magnitude more expensive and then some
of them might also suffer from water
instability as well right so then you
still have the same problem still have
the same problem so the last paper that
we haven't gotten to yet is hydrogen
absorption right so hydrogen's a lot
smaller than and CO2 how are you getting
that to go in there why because up till
now we've been taking the size argument
and the bonding argument so why is it
able to also pick up hydrogen tell us
about that so yeah so I I'll go ahead
and take this and so this work is is is
kind of departs from many of the other
sort of earlier discoveries right and so
this was done by myself and Tanner and
Craig Brown at the N Center for Neutron
research and then we sort of built a
much bigger picture with our our many
collaborators but the initial Discovery
was done done at n and so we were
interested particularly because we
aluminum format if um any of your
viewers go and find sort of what the
crystal structure looks like since it's
going to feel a little abstract even
post it in the episode art so take a
look on the podcast wherever you're
listening you'll see the picture of it
great so you'll see the crystal
structure and you'll see that it has um
sort of a small cavity so we understand
how gases go into certain types of
materials we know an approximation of
how easy or how you know the target size
of some of these gases that's referred
to as a kinetic diameter and so we know
that hydrogen is a little smaller than
most of these gases right and so we were
interested like we had a good hunch that
it would go in but we didn't know what
it would do and is a general feeling on
sort of hydrogen absorbance hydrogen
storage is very challenging and the
reason for that is that hydrogen is very
small it hasn't got a lot of Mass to it
it doesn't have a lot of polarizability
right it doesn't have it can't you sort
of can't move the SLO the electrons
around because there's only two in them
and then generally if you're trying to
store hydrogen you either cool it down
aggressively right really really cold
temperatures or you use high pressures
and you force it into something or you
do a combination of the two of those
things right and so the Perpetual you
know achill or the perpetual that sort
of hydrogen storage or hydrogen
technology sort of faces is how do you
move this thing around without wasting
too much energy storing it places right
and that's I mean that you know that's
one part of the problem right think
about all the many aspects of a fossil
fuel economy storing the fossil fuels
moving the fossil fuels burning the
fossil fuels dealing that has like a a
massive economy sort of connected to it
and the hydrogen economy is just only
now being generated right one of those
problems is what do we do when we store
the the hydrogen whether in a car or in
a big you know box somewhere in a field
to be used for for grid storage right
and so we took a look at whether or not
aluminum formate absorbed hydrogen and
what we found is that it does and it
absorbs hydrogen um at these strangely
intermediate temperatures right and so
we sort of alluded to some of these
aspects about aluminum formate that it's
a it's a balance between thermodynamics
and kinetics and some of these gases are
being limited as to how fast they can
permeate into the material uh and
whether or not they want to hang out in
in an aluminum formate at all right and
so what we found is that hydrogen both
moves very quick through the material uh
at at certain temperatures at these
elevated temperatures because it's so
small but also because of the sort of
very small cavity what is referred to as
like an ultra microporus cavity right so
these sort of the the windows into
aluminum formate about 10 angstroms or
anything sub 10 anstrom are about five
or six wide but the the cavity itself is
very small so so as I was sort of Des uh
describing earlier you have these sort
of six surfaces and there's two types of
cavities inside of aluminum formate the
hydrogen itself finds a reasonably good
home inside the material and what that
translates to is that you have a
intermediate temperature of storage
about 120 Kelvin 160 Kelvin right so
we're above liquid nitrogen that's a
major selling point right that you don't
have to go down to these liquid helium
temperatures to store hydrogen
but because aluminum formate is so dense
that the amount of hydrogen you actually
get into it is not these massive numbers
right and so people might look at it if
you're looking at the straight metrics
of some of these materials you might go
oh it doesn't absorb all this
gas whatever m per yeah right but
because aluminum formate is so cheap you
need to normalize it based on dollar and
at that point you realize that aluminum
formate serves as an incredibly useful
vehicle for grid storage because you
don't spend a lot of
money making all this material you put
it in a big box somewhere and then you
just blast in some hydrogen and then you
can lock it in there you don't have to
heat it up that much to get it out you
know about another 50 degrees and you
can start to play with um you know
releasing the hydrogen but because it is
so cheap you end up with these really
impressive metrics for how much it
actually costs to store the hen at these
intermediate temperatures and lower
pressures again because aluminum formate
is so dense you don't need you well you
can't even get to sort of the advantages
of going to these higher pressures but
because of the sort of you know kinetics
and thermodynamics that you're working
within this sub20 bar range of hydrogen
which means not only is it very treap
cheap and very effective for grid
storage but it also pairs incredibly
well with fuel cells which are
generating about five to or set to you
know be used about a five to 10 bar
range right and there's not many
materials that they found that absorb
hydrogen at lower pressures and at these
moderate sort of temperatures and then
it's also so cheap right so what we've
Illustrated in our manuscript is both
the science and Technical aspect of how
the material absorbs hydrogen but also
we've done something that many other
people don't do is that we we decided to
put up instead of shut up and we showed
the money argument of what this actually
means if you were to try and
commercialize this what is the cost how
does this compare and we found that at
this point aluminum format is at least
the only metal organic framework we sort
of see if we can expand that out to sort
of absorbance that is cost competitive
with compressed hydrogen of about 350
bar so about a fraction of the the
pressure range so so cool well today's
episode we'll wrap it up because it's
going a little bit long but we have five
excellent papers that will be in the
show notes a nature of view materials
whether they talk about proov skes in
general and the all the wonderful things
that that structure can do for us then
the first paper insights advances where
they kickoff Discovery and then three
Jack papers in a row so congratulations
guys this is nice work you've done and
it sounds like we're just getting
started I am sure we're going to see
more from this material and variance
thereof so this really slick anything
that you want to tell us before we
part oh there's one thing just to
crystallize it out Taylor I wanted to
just
underline actually Al though it's an
excellent absorbent the only molecules
that it will
absorb uh aside from uh say the uh noble
gases the small noble gases are
CO2 oxygen and
hydrogen so if you really wanted a
system that would uh hit each of those
three targets and won't absorb anything
else at all then I mean this is a
miraculous system for the energy
transition so cool well thank you both
for joining me anything else Aiden no no
I was just going to say more generally I
I think that the the what this work kind
of shows is that um I had a PhD adviser
in grad school who is Fred Wood he's a
very famous chemist and he was always
reiterating the constant concept which
was keep it simple stupid right keep it
simple you don't have to O over engineer
something you don't have to spend a lot
of money especially if you're trying to
do something in the real world cost cost
comes down to pretty much the the bottom
line right CU you have to do it in the
real world so looking for these big
problem Solutions with readily made
available things is not only you know
Pie in the Sky it is pretty much
Essential to the as we move forward with
the this new future energy economy that
we're trying to seek out okay guys this
was a total pleasure this episode is
sponsored by California Nano
Technologies or Cal Nano if you've
listen to the podcast you know that we
are big fans of them we've done a couple
episodes with them and I as a professor
have used their services multiple times
over the course of my career they have
some really great Services they've
helped us with spark plasma centering at
an extremely large scale way bigger than
what you're thinking they can make some
huge components I've always had great
success with them they turn out high
density Quality Parts two order and
pretty quick turnaround um and they also
have some other capabilities including
cryo Milling check out our episode on
that we think that they're an awesome
company and we're proud to stand by them
as a sponsor of the show The materialism
podcast is also sponsored by materials
today visit material today.com to stay
up to date on the latest happenings in
the material science field and read some
fantastic articles they have
published you can head over to el.com to
find out more about their journals books
conferences and related
programs okay thank you for listening to
this episode it was super fun to have
you along uh and as always we would love
to hear feedback from you so check us
out on Instagram we are at the ATM
materialism. podcast handle or or you
can send us an email materialism.
podcast gmail.com and if you want to do
me a huge favor I would love it if you
gave us a review we are tantalizingly
close to stealing that number one spot
in the chemistry category nothing would
make me happier than to have a material
science podcast in the number one spot
of our chemistry homies so hope make
this happen a review share it with some
bues that would just be Super Rad um as
always we're grateful to the people that
make the music for this that's alphabot
and kaby they make some cool stuff check
them out and we'll see you next
time the adventures of fire electricity
magnetism iron lead glass silk cotton
the makers of tools the captors of
lightning the architect the engineer the
musician are all beneficiaries of the
materials of this world and are bound
only by their imaginations in
manipulating those
materials