Top 10 Irish Whiskeys for Advanced Whiskey Drinkers

Brandy Channel
12 followers
It's about damn time. Yeah, it's a long-awaited day. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, this is it's all Irish all day.
The top 10 whiskeys for advanced Irish whiskey drinkers. Yes, that's true. Now, here's my qualifier.
Yeah. That is that when you talk about advanced Irish whiskey, I'm not thinking the same way
I think advanced Irish or scotch whiskey. Yeah. Because what most people mean when they say advanced scotch is the more peaty,
aggressive, some of the rougher stuff, right? Sure. So it's really hard to find that kind of thing in Irish whiskey.
We asked our community of thousands of whiskey lovers, the whiskey tribe, the Magnificent Bastards. What are the most
complex,
nuanced, yes,
interesting Irish whiskeys. Doesn't have to be challenging. Right. What are the favorite ones in our community?
This has more to do with the complexity of the taste.
Yes.
And how you have to kind of understand what's going on in Irish whiskey to find out different layers. Yep. Yep. And we're gonna start.
We're gonna start with Conmar. Where's your hair for hugs?
No, this is a discovery video. Okay. People are gonna be finding this video and having no idea. Fine. Why I'm wearing a wig.
Fine. I do think we need something though. Okay. I do think we need something. We need to summon like an actual Irishman.
Oh. Because we're just a couple of asshats.
Speak for yourself. We don't know our asses from our elbows. I know both elbows and asses.
I think we need a legit Irishman. Okay. Who's
lived his life in Ireland amongst these glorious whiskeys. Is this just because you're worried about my pronunciation problems? It is embarrassing.
I have a certain standard of quality and accuracy. Yeah. That I try to maintain. That's what you're so famous for.
Professionalism. Professionalism. Right. Okay. So, Lee, we need to summon an Irishman. You ready? How do you summon an Irishman?
Oh, oh, I forgot. I forgot my mooch necklace. Dude.
We're have to we have to rely on your summoning powers. I don't even know. I've never summoned an Irishman before. Here we go.
See if you can do it.
What do you do? Oh, I know. I know. I know.
Of all the money that I've had.
It's the parting glass. That's how you summon an Irishman. I'm gonna help you out. This is embarrassing for you.
Okay. You do need to put on the hair for help. It's gonna give you that extra.
Can I take it off after we get the Irishman here? Just an extra little bit of power.
Okay. The extra little bit. My understanding was that if you're in Texas like Pee Wee Herman said and you go the stars at night
are big and bright everyone goes
deep in the heart and so on an Irishman you sing the parting glass. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, go get that f***ing thing.
And make sure people see the wax strip Daniel. Yeah, look at that wax. Oh, it's so cringy. This is disgusting.
Oh, I touched it again. Every time I try to adjust it, I touch the wax strip. Try again. I believe you could summon now.
Of all the money that I've had.
I am a rambling Irishman.
You were just magically in Ireland. I was on the flight home and suddenly this happened.
Come on up here Terry. Oh. Oh, Terry needs a glass. Terry doesn't need a glass. Terry's gonna make sure we pronounce things correctly.
And since that you were summoned with the hair for hobbits helm. Yeah. Do I have your permission to take off the hair for hobbits helm?
I like how you look at me.
Okay, Terry.
I don't know if we're friends anymore.
His only response was, eh, fair enough. As long as you're pouring the whiskey. Okay, first things first. We're gonna go for Connemara. Yeah.
Pronunciation? How do you say it Terry? I'll go Connemara. Connemara.
The thing with Irish whiskey is you want to get it over and done with as quick as possible.
Connemara. Yeah.
Not like Texans just draw it out.
Yeah, that's the problem. All Texans. Oh, I forgot the dance slate. Oh, yeah. I'm surprised you were able to be summoned without the dance slate.
Yeah, it's just a little extra flair.
So is this in any particular order this list? No, no, no. I sort of, yes,
I did them in a certain order, but. But not in the order that they were voted in in terms of. No. The most votes.
Okay. No, I kept them random for that. So no particular order. Yes. So Connemara. Yes. Is a Cooley distillery owned by Kilbagan.
Right. So. And that we're gonna keep minimum history to minimum and just go for tasting notes. Okay.
It's one of the only peated Irish whiskeys. Oh. Now back in the day,
all whiskey in Ireland, as far as I know, was likely peated just like it was in Scotland.
Yeah. It was only in the more modern era that they started to do unpeated and a lot of that had to do with the
English taxing peated malt, or
taxing malt. Yeah. And then you had unmalted barley. It is interesting on the nose because there's so few peated Irish whiskeys.
I would smell that and think, oh, Scotch. It's a very different kind of peat, though, because it's such a clean, sweet, fruity. Yes, clean, sweet.
It still has all the characteristics of an Irish whiskey.
I don't suggest that that's a great entry into peated whiskey in general because it's just so clean and refreshing. I totally agree.
I've used, uh, yeah, it's a gateway. It's a gateway drug. No.
No, I still get all the classic Irish notes of the green apple.
Yeah. And the kind of light fruit notes and the buttery biscuit notes.
But then, it's almost like you're sitting in a field of flowers. And I read somebody said this, I thought, that's perfect.
It's almost like sitting in a field of flowers next to the sea and there's a little bit of a campfire smoke
drifting through the field. Lacy peat. It's like a peat with doilies.
All right, I'm taking this thing off. I think that is worthy of, because the Irishman's here now, an advanced Irish whiskey.
It's very complex. I think it is, too. It's nuanced.
And in terms of like a lighter end peat, but it doesn't, it's not weak. Right. It's still there.
It's just all the high, the high-end notes. So we're gonna move into
Ryder's Tears. Okay. Now, Ryder's Tears. This is so interesting. Is a product. That Ryder's Tears made the list.
It did. Actually, tealing made the list more than anything.
Okay. But there are a lot of different tealing products and Ryder's Tears is one of the Walsh.
It's actually, no, sorry, Ryder's Tears is not tealing. Ryder's Tears is Walsh, who makes
Ryder's Tears Irishman. Okay. And, wait, wait, did you just smell the water?
I was gonna see if it still had the peat smell. Oh, okay, fair enough.
Now, as you're pulling out the Ryder's Tears, the reason why this was very surprising to me. Mm-hmm.
Because I remember this being one of the earliest whiskeys we ever reviewed on this channel. Yeah. And I was
underwhelmed.
Hopefully my palate has advanced. Your palate's more advanced than mine. We'll see. We'll see. This bottle's donated by Brad Whittington, by the way.
Brad Whittington. Are we Magnificent Bastard? Nah, which, he paid, he helped donate to bring that into the Academy.
You remember, I know you too well, Brad. So, when we first found this bottle. You're too much of a bastard.
They didn't have any distribution in the U.S.
Right. And so, we actually had to buy a case of it from a shop in Dublin in order to get them to ship it over
to us. I wanted to. And it was $80 a bottle because of all the shipping and everything. Okay, so this being voted up the
Advanced Irish Whiskies list. Mm-hmm. And I remember this being specifically
simple. Yeah. In my earliest days of whiskey tasting. Now, this is a mix of pot still and single malt.
Okay. Right now, pot still,
meaning there's some unmalted barley in it, and usually single malt is, well, it could still be unmalted.
There are different styles. Single malt's more traditional. It's probably gonna be all malted barley.
What say you, Irishman? There's a little coffee in this for me, too, though. I'm getting a little coffee, but it's quite underwhelming, apart from that.
Yeah. You're wrong, tribe.
So sayeth the Irishman. No, I think it's the taste that brings out some of the character.
The nose is simple and pretty, but the taste brings out, like, a milk chocolate kind of note to me.
That's something I often find with Irish whiskies. Sometimes the nose is quite underwhelming and quite flat, and then you get into it,
and that's very rich, and it's kind of almost a surprise. Mm-hmm. I totally agree with that. So I'm getting that classic
buttered biscuit note. But the oak is showing up in the taste, too.
The honey. Which means there's a little age to this. Now, they don't tell you how. It's 40% though.
Mm-hmm. It's 40%. That number always leaves me concerned, but it could be best at 40%. We don't know.
Usually, is it, though? I don't know.
They have a redhead version where it's finished in sherry casks. Okay. And that's kind of interesting, too. So, an advanced palate.
On the nose, you're right. They're not gonna pick out anything amazing.
Yep. I'm just getting the classic butter and the honey and maybe, you said, like, a coffee note or something?
Maybe a little chocolate. There's a little something in there. Now, we'll tell you that Jim Murray, remember the guy?
A little chocolate, what? Maybe a little chocolate and almond?
Yeah, yeah, the same thing. Milk chocolate and almonds. Almonds, all right. Yeah, yeah.
So, um,
remember Jim Murray, the guy who writes the whiskey Bible? Yeah. And who rated Crown Royal best in the world at one point?
He said, this is one of those hundred whiskeys to try before you die.
Yeah, it's not a bad whiskey. He felt very strongly about it. I'm looking for complexity, though. Yeah. And I think there's some complexity.
I think there's some complexity. There's multiple things going on. You think you're too complex for this? I think complexity on the taste,
but not so much on the nose. Yes, I agree. I am so much of an exotic creature that
it's just, it's just not enough for my palate. We're doing a tin Irish whiskey blend here, but we're dumping.
Yeah, you got a plane to catch. Yeah. All right, so
Dunville PX. This is a Northern Ireland. This is Belfast Distillery. Actually, it's Ekinville.
Yeah, yeah. So Ekinville Distillery, Northern Ireland. They're doing a ten-year-old single malt Irish whiskey
that's finished and Pedro Menes cask. So it's a pork cask finished Irish whiskey.
I think there's actually a sourced whiskey. It is a sourced whiskey. And I think, I think they're also getting it from Cooley.
But I am, I could not figure that out. So I've done it. I did a lot of looking up things. Did you say Sherry?
Yeah, Pedro Menes. Yeah. And man, you can smell it immediately. It has that,
what's weird to me is when you get Irish whiskey mixed with some of the wine cask finished,
yeah, you get this weird medicinal note that shows up that doesn't normally show up. And it's almost like cleaning products.
It does, no, it does combine. Yeah, in that,
it's not unpleasant. But to me, you know when you go into a restroom and they have the fake,
like,
mountain breeze stuff spraying into the air to make the bathroom not smell like s**t.
It's like, it's like you did that with Sherry, where you wanted a Sherry flavor,
but it's, it's mixed with cleaning products to get the air clean. Now, of the few that we've tried, how many of you had
just off the shelf in Ireland? None. None so far.
Okay. Now, is that because it just never looked interesting or because we actually have a better selection?
Well, both. Yeah? I would tend to gravitate toward more interesting scotches first.
I picked a few bottles of Irish up, but tend to be the big heavy hitters. Yeah, yeah. You know that Ireland,
there's often times it's easier to get rare Irish whiskey in America than it is in Ireland.
They, which is interesting because at one point, in order to try to help the economy and make it Irish first,
they actually placed a huge tax burden on
exported Irish whiskey. And what that did was it left all this room for scotch to just take over the world. Yeah.
And now they're trying to fix that, I think.
That, if you like sherry,
that's gonna not leave you hanging.
Oh, that lingers. Yeah. That is all of the shiny grain spirit mixed with the sweet fruit finish.
It's like a fruit roll-up. That slight waxy taste to a fruit roll-up. I could buy that. Yeah. And, uh, a little bit of the
strawberries, like the artificial strawberry. Yeah, that's what I mean. All these artificial notes, that's what I'm getting.
I think it's coming from grain whiskey, which makes me think that,
and I couldn't find this, but it makes me think that they're not using pot still.
Yeah, I don't know. I'm not getting a savory butter from that. I mean, it is a single malt.
It has that pepperness of a high-grain whiskey. Yeah. Yeah.
But they're calling it a single malt.
But usually the grain whiskey means they just ran it through column stills instead of pot stills.
It's a lot easier to get your hands on. Okay. Because you can make a lot more of it faster.
So I'm wondering if that is, even though it's single malt, I'm wondering if it's a column still.
Now, we're in the street is actually, when Ecclesville starts producing whiskey, this brand's gonna die. So,
we're picking up. All right, it's 46. Oh, interesting. Okay.
46%. And, and because we have an Irishman here, he can tell us the word on the street. The word on the street. In Ireland.
What is your... All right, we're moving on, and we're moving on to
Dingle.
Did you pronounce that correctly? Close enough.
Close enough? Wait, how can you mispronounce Dingle? When you get to that region of Ireland, the accents become very odd.
Anyway, okay. Dingle, yeah. How would you pronounce it? I'd say Dingle. Okay, see? Again, get over done with.
Don't give yourself... It's less opportunity to get it wrong. Exactly, when you just like, put it out there quickly and walk away.
All right. Yeah, no, I'm all for that. All right. So here we go. Now, this one I'm kind of excited about.
This is also, I really love the bottle shape on this. Yeah.
This is batch two from the Dingle whiskey distillery, and that means this was one where they married together
sherry
and bourbon cask finishes, and the sherry, they did both Pedro Menes and Olorosa.
Okay. So two different kinds of sherry finishes and a bourbon cask finish. Interesting. All in one single malt Irish release.
That is a beefy looking bottle. Isn't it? I dig it.
I dig that. I'm getting much more of a caramel on the nose of this than I typically do. Oh man, this is musty.
Yes. Yeah, this is like farm, barnyard musty. That is interesting.
Wow. So I'm not getting the classic.
No, this is nothing like the buttery biscuit. Anything we've tried so far. That is interesting. I'm getting a honey now.
This goes caramel, goes honey. This is definitely sweet. This makes me think of a farm.
Yeah, like harvested grain and barnyard animal and... Dusty caramel and honey.
I haven't tasted it yet. I'm just going off the smell still. I don't know. I'm all up in it.
I'm still getting citrus on the taste, but it's like lemon. Not the bitterness though. No, there's no bitterness.
It is zest. Yeah, a little lemon zest and then heavy vanilla.
But the nose is totally different. The mustiness in the nose doesn't show up in the taste at all.
Yeah. No, I really like it.
You said there's bourbon influence? There's a bourbon... You can definitely tell there's some old bourbon. That's the vanilla.
Yeah, so when you get heavy vanillas in scotch or an Irish whiskey, you're getting bourbon cask.
Yeah, you can tell that's been around the block in a few different...
Wow, that really lingers. It has multiple things going on there. It's a sweet whiskey, definitely.
Quite oily too. Yeah, this is maybe my favorite so far. Yeah, no, this has been...
Have I had this before? Have we ever done this? No, I was afraid... This was one of the ones I was afraid I couldn't get.
And it showed up on the list, but it was mostly from people not in America.
And so I was like, I never even heard of that one. I had to look it up and then our friends brought us a bottle
from their trip to Ireland.
And so I was able to do the video. We are on to what I'm kind of excited about.
Tealing took the cake for the most references on the list in general. Okay, this is one of my favorites too.
Yeah, and Tealing the Stealer. Now, they were young enough that most tealing you're trying right now is sourced.
But they are starting to do stuff. Yeah, so
Tealing
is sort of like High West where they specialize in sourcing and doing interesting finishes or finding special casks and doing things with them.
And so there are actually
two
tealings in our list. So this is what we do. And we're going to do one of them right now. This is what we do.
We need to go through the 30 tealings.
What time is it? Yeah, we're good. Dude, take a look at that. Yeah, you could
knock out a donkey with that thing. Yeah, this is quite a special bottling, isn't it?
It is. This is the revival
15-year-old tealing. Okay, but you're saying even if people don't get this tealing.
Tealing, just the general. Just tealing in general. Okay, that actually. Now, this is finished in Muscat bottles.
Muscat barrels. It's a dessert wine. Okay.
All right, sure. Well, it's actually a grape, but. Again, it's very delicate. It is. Yeah.
You get the sense that. I'm starting to find light milky coffee in a lot of Irish whiskeys these days.
Milk, like coffee with a lot of cream. Yeah. Oh, I can see that. Right?
So, you know. So that it's more cream than coffee. The candies, the coffee candies we get. Yeah. Tritoria Lucina.
Yes, that's what I was thinking. Yeah.
All right, very sweet. More vanilla with a hint of coffee. Yep. No, there's some kind of.
Oh, okay. So the taste
is
way more subtle than the nose. The nose has rich complexity. The taste is nice and sweet and round.
But the taste doesn't. The moment it hits you, it's really light and bright and then it just
unfolds and becomes like much more buttery and savory. Yeah. Mostly buttery and savory. Yeah.
Yeah, some whiskeys you'll take a sip and the very first moment, the very first flavor is it's just that, you know,
throughout the entire thing. This,
it's switching it up. It's unfolding, then it's just drifting down. It's got an earthy aftertaste. You're left with, yeah, speaking of the finish,
you say earthy? Earthy. And by earthy, I don't mean dirt. I mean like vegetation and. Okay. Green earth. But not,
but not shying away from the sweetness. Right. Yeah.
After having a taste. Not better. I'm starting to get like a butter toast on the nose as well. Yeah. Moving on because there's too many good things.
You can finish that. It's fine.
Okay, so. A lot of slurred words. Glendola? Huh? Glendola?
Glendola?
I would. With a K sound on the end or just nothing? Yeah.
Ah, okay, because in Scotch that wouldn't be right. So, Glendalough? Yeah. All right, Glendalough.
Thank goodness Terry is here. All right.
You're gonna have to shut it all down. Yeah. This is the porter cask finish.
They worked with the Five Lamps Brewery in Dublin. They remind me what porter is? It's a beer. Oh, yeah. Dart beer.
So, porter. Porter just to be the stronger form of a stout. Yeah. Before like the working mouth.
The working mouth had a porter. Good blue collar beer. Yeah, yeah. Okay.
Now they put it in bourbon casks for six years and then they moved it to porter barrels for another year.
So it's seven years old with a full year. I am. In porter casks. I still
am surprised at how the Scotches and Irish whiskeys,
how light they are after over a decade. Well, you know, the temperature is so much more moderate. Right. And the used barrels
we were having. I am.
Have you seen me?
We were having a lot of Texas whiskeys over the weekend.
And these things are like three years old. And they look dark as coffee. Yeah. Yeah.
Way darker than this. Now this one,
this one's rich on the nose. This is maybe of all of them the most dark rich for me.
Dark rich. Okay. Yeah, it doesn't taste like the light floral Irish.
It tastes a little darker. Within the context of Irish though. Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's still Irish. Dark for Irish.
There's no question. This is Irish whiskey, but it headed towards plums instead of towards the lighter fruits. Okay.
Oh, oh, I like that. Is that a spearmint finish? Yeah, it is. It's minty. It's a minty. It's like a that's good though.
But it's like a chocolate mint. Yes.
Yeah.
Weird finish for an Irish whiskey. See none of these are anything like what people think of when they're like, I'll take a Jameson.
Or I'll take a, you know, fill in the blank. That is interesting.
I've had a few stout finishing Porter finished whiskey, but I've never had that, you know, like a freshly poured pint.
Yeah, that sort of smell that toasted sort of barley. Yeah. It really leaps out. Oh, I really love that. That is nice.
So the Jameson did a stout edition, but all it served to do was make it even creamier. Yeah.
This one, the Porter edition, which is wonderful. I actually keep the Jameson stout at my house as just a go-to.
It's and I absolutely enjoy it. It's a really nice background whiskey. We talk about hero whiskeys.
We talk about background whiskeys, but this is a Porter cask. This is not background. No, this is a feature whiskey. All of it.
There's like a jam or jelly in there. I can't quite piece which version it is. It's like plum or something in that region.
Maybe even blackberry. Yes, because blackberry has the spiky notes to it.
Man, our people have not led us astray on this video.
Okay, we're on to Redbreast. Oh, you son of a bitch. Let's stout sherry cask finished.
Yeah, this got voted in. Where's your glass? So,
jeez.
She can't be trusted, this guy.
What is your opinion of Redbreast? Because here in the States, it's wildly popular. Yeah. Amongst whiskey drinkers.
And my opinion is it's super, super popular because if you like the iconic
Irish whiskey
buttered biscuit. But rich, not grain thin like Jameson. Yeah, like a shortbread cookie that's really deep and savory.
That has it for days and just Redbreast in general.
Oh, I love Redbreast. It is like the step up from any sort of baseline Jameson or Bushmills. Redbreast is the first stop.
Yeah, you want it to be like classic, but also super just. There's always a richness to Redbreast. Yes. Yes.
That's what it is. It has a wow factor with the richness. Now for me,
the sherry cask finish just puts a little bit of jam on the biscuit.
Yeah, just a little bit of a sugary jam. Oh, come on.
I just need to sit down. This is 9 to 12 years old. We're going to pause on this. We're just going to sit down.
Finish the bottle. Just appreciate this moment. Oh man, that's all jam. That is all jam all day.
You get your biscuit. You do. And then you get the butter and then you get the jam on the butter.
Yeah, but it's very, it's like someone went a little extra heavy with the jam.
Yeah, right. Like this is not a poor household. Yeah. They can, they can afford extra jam.
Savory, rich butter. I remember growing up poor. You grew up poor. Growing up poor is a thing where
like I was in, uh, I moved to California. I got a roommate and we were making eggs and he poured
a, like a cup full of half and half into the scrambled egg pan. And I was like, what are you
doing? That's disgusting. He's like, no, it makes fluffier, richer eggs. And I'm like, that's, who
puts milk in a, in eggs? And then I tried them. I was like, Oh, Oh, how did I only just now hear
about this? And then I asked my mom and she was like, we couldn't afford to pour our milk into
our eggs. We had to have the milk separate. We were, uh, we were milk rich. Yeah. You were milk.
And then it was the same thing with jam. It's like you get buttered toast and really you get
margarine cause it was cheaper. You know, like I can't like country crock and then you get jam,
but all you get is like one knife of jam and you better make that spread across the whole slice
cause you weren't getting any more. And on the knife, it's like, there's a left. You're going
back. That's right. You just lick the knife. But this is like, no, this was from a wealthy family
was just had jam for days. This is 46%. Now I think, uh, your, your, your, your whiskey friends,
they're ready to step it up from a lot of entry level whiskey. If you think they're prepared to
jump up 6% in the alcohol, this is going to unlock a whole nother level of flavors. Start
them with a classic red and rest 12 and then introduce them to what happens to Irish whiskey
when Sherry is involved. Yeah. Oh, sorry. We're getting a little bit more interesting. Are you
ready? We got three more this video. We're just trying. I'm just trying to deliver you guys.
Just trying to deliver as promised. Wait, wait, wait. Now it's like a red breast is my love
language. Green spot is my Irish love language. Yeah. Yeah. Cause it reminds me of being a kid
on South Padre Island on the beach in the Gulf of Mexico. Now they're very different whiskies too.
No, very different. So that's the dump glass, which goes to show how Irish whiskey sometimes
gets a rep for being relatively simple and straightforward. Uh, when it turns, when it goes
to like the spectrum of flavors that are possible, Scotch has a wide range of things. I still think
that's true. Yes. Scotch has a wide range bourbon. It's a narrower, narrower. I think bourbon and
Irish are similar. They're very similar, but I think Irish whiskey may have a little bit of an
edge. Very similar in terms of the spectrum, the variety of what's possible. But I think Irish may
have a bit more variety that's possible. And I don't think there's a better comparison from the
ends of that spectrum than red breast on one side, green spot on the other. Yes, I agree. And so in
green spot, you've got Middleton making, who also makes red breast by the way. You've got Middleton
making green spot for Mitchell and Sons is dates back to the early 1800s, which is a merchant.
They were just sourcing things and bottling and they were creating flavor profiles. They have
different spots of blue, yellow, red. To me, green spot has, this is the most complex because I've
been able to discover, you're still there. I've been able to discover weird things in this one.
So saltwater, coconut, and the same buttered biscuit. You really get butter biscuit on this?
I do, but it's way behind the coconut and saltwater. This one to me, I always recommend,
this one I always recommend as a go-to starter whiskey because I think the flavor is so clean
cut. Oh yeah. I always get like unripe banana, red berries, brown sugar, and cream. That's my...
Man, when you said red berries, you know what just popped in my head? Cap'n Berry Crunch cereal.
That kind of like sweetened cereal red. No, the unripe banana nailed it for me just now. I have
never heard that with this until now. And now that you said it, I can't unsmell it.
Yeah. Good starter whiskey. Nice work. Not necessarily for the price point though,
because this is like, I don't know, the 80s, 90s? No, no, no, no, no, no, no. Green,
yellow is in the 80s, 90s. Green spots in the 40s to 60s, depending on which shop you find it in.
I'm taking a white spot. It's like a hundred bucks for me to get the white one.
Well, just keep telling yourself that.
All right. We're about to get real. Are you ready? We're going to do Middleton,
Very Rare next. So we just went, this is a Middleton distillery. Oh, we need a little...
Well done, green spot. Well done. Well done.
Middleton, you know that glass is going to taste amazing.
Middleton makes a lot of whiskey. So there was a point in Irish whiskey history
where the combination of multiple things happened. Economic collapse, the famine,
and prohibition in the US all combined over a decade or so to just wipe out the Irish whiskey.
At one point, there were hundreds of Irish whiskey distilleries. And by the time it
collapsed, it ended up in one, which was the Irish Distillers Limited Company,
who owned all production in all of Ireland. And including, they bought out Bushmills even at one
point, who was a holdout for a little while. And so Middleton has become the distillery that
produces, it's sort of like MGP. When you go to the shelf and you see all of these bourbons,
and like a third of them are MGP sourced whiskeys. Middleton is that for Ireland,
which is you go to the Irish whiskey shelf and you see Hellcat Maggie and all these
different Clontarf, and then you're like, oh, it's all Middleton.
Now, the good news is that's changing. Ireland is under a whiskey boom right now.
So was that Middleton actually just voted up as, hey, Middleton is huge,
but that's the one that you want to go to? Yes. Middleton Very Rare was voted up,
Very Rare. Or the Berry Crockett, but I chose the Very Rare of those two. So Berry Crockett was the
head distiller who chooses what goes into the Middleton Very Rare. Now, it's actually in the
town, Middleton, which is obviously where the distillery's name comes from. This is between 12
and 20 years old, depending on the barrels. They blend them together to get, and they're hand
selected by Crockett. All right. I'm starting to get a buttery note. This is, and then this is
conjecture. It's a grainy, buttery note for me. Yeah, this is conjecture. But I would say Middleton
Very Rare is probably one of the most expensive Irish whiskeys consistently on the market.
If you had to pick the priciest Irish whiskey on a consistent basis, as opposed to the Unicorns,
it's going to be Middleton Very Rare. It's Ireland's Johnny Walker Blue. It's that pure,
gifting whiskey. That was such a perfect analogy. Yes, that's exactly what it is.
Okay. Now it's, because I was about to ask, this is 40%, and you usually don't see, it is,
you usually don't see a lot of fanfare, a lot of love for the 40%, but in the context of a
Johnny Walker, it's like, oh, it's just wildly popular, and there's not a lot to hate about it.
To me, this is just, it's drinkable. The more I live in the nose, the more that classic butter
note is just getting... To me, this is the quintessential character of Irish whiskey.
No flair, no fanfare, no extra little tendrils being pushed out. It's just...
It's quite a normal whiskey, but held for a little longer, because you get those sort of
dusty, woody notes, and a little hint of smoke from the barrel. This is the spirit of all Irish whiskey
at its finest. Okay, I would say. With no weird variances. If you like what's going on in this
bottle, then a bottle of Redbreast, you will adore taking this, and then just amping up the volume.
Yeah, I totally agree. Now, yeah, to me, this should be just the ambassador of Irish whiskey,
of classic Irish whiskey. Right here. That's it.
How do you... Give us an Irish curse. Yeah, what's an Irish curse?
You can't put them on the show. Yeah, we have cork noises.
How long can you make it? Are your parents watching?
30 seconds? No, I don't know.
Anyone who met me here heard them, so...
Oh, so is that everything? No, we got one more.
From Teeling. Oh, you're gonna be excited about this one, and we go out on this one. Are you ready?
Sure. How are we doing so far, Irishman? I think we're doing okay so far.
Yeah? Just okay?
Just okay so far. Oh, come on.
No, no, you're gonna want to... You know what? F*** this. Let's get three new glasses.
Because this, from Pegene Riley, was a gift. Pegene Riley?
Pegene Riley. Should I bastard her?
Oh, no. She already has been. But, I mean, feel free.
But this is a... Well, now you've ruined it.
Like, there was good momentum. We were diving into this.
No, we're gonna end with this. Magnificent bachelorette.
Well, if you really want to. No, we're gonna end with the memory
of her father in whom this was purchased. Oh, yeah. All right.
But this is a 25-year-old Teeling release. Damn.
Good on you, Pegene Riley. A memory of your father.
It has an almost barrel musty note. Musty? I'm getting, like, a...
First thing, it was peach. Yes! Peach tea! Absolutely!
Peach tea. Peach tea. You're right.
It really is peach tea. Yes.
Because it has that slight bitterness that tea will give.
Wow. This is alcoholic peach tea. Yeah?
This is bottle 175. I'm trying to find something else.
Now, bottle 175 of 250 bottles, cask 10505, bottled on July 13, 2015.
Okay, I'm overwhelming my nose right now. Wow!
So, what was the thing where, if you're trying to reset your...
Your elbow. Your personal skin.
Right. That your nose is zero.
Not coffee beans. That's bullsh**.
It smells like hard man.
You see what it's like? You see what I deal with here?
I don't know how you do it. Yeah, it's a crucible.
Oh, well, now I'm getting some more lighter fruit notes in there.
Lighter fruit notes. It goes peach tea...
The tea was a good note. When you said tea...
And pear. That brings out all the black tea notes.
Yeah. Peach tea and pear.
So, here's what I want to say about Irish whiskey.
I'll help you. Get in there.
I think... Get in there.
Just dive in.
Irish whiskey is one of the most underrated categories.
Bourbon people love it, and they get it.
But Irish whiskey, I think, doesn't get its fair share in its ability in nuance and subtlety.
Yes, and I think that's just it.
Whereas with scotch, the spectrum is obvious.
And we love scotch. We love scotch.
But you don't have to go hunting.
But it's the more advanced drinker that's going to be able to pick out a lot of these notes
that for a lot of people will just kind of fly past them.
Irish whiskey makes you work for it.
Yeah, it'll just fly past them as friendly and kind of sweet
and almost like a shortbread cookie type of vibe going on there.
There's a lot of nuance. There's a lot of complexity.
But you have to be able to pick those flavors out.
So, if somebody is starting to get into whiskey,
how should they go down that path of being able to identify those flavors?
Because I know for a lot of people, it's like,
man, I don't know if I'm even equipped to be able to...
It's just practice.
And I think you were right when you said that the right entryway into scotch
is going to be Red Breast 12, or into Irish whiskey is Red Breast 12,
and then followed by Green Spot.
Because they're two totally different sides of the spectrum.
Yeah.
Right? And unlike scotch, which is what was in my head, it's not obvious.
Oh, peat. Oh, butterscotch. Oh, saltwater.
My understanding is to be able to pick out those notes, those flavors, it's practice.
Just to get the context.
Practice and repetition.
Practice and repetition, but also the willingness to just have a flash of a memory of an experience
come into your head and be willing to say it.
Because so many people, they're intimidated.
Like, well, I'm smelling something that's kind of like a peach tea,
but I don't know if that's right.
You know what you do?
So you shut up and they don't say anything.
Drink Irish whiskey with friends.
That's the way Irish whiskey was meant to be consumed.
With non-judgmental friends.
Yes, friends who are willing to say what they think they smell.
Yes.
And then you go in and look for it.
And the thing about smelling and tasting is it's very subjective.
There's not a right or wrong answer per se.
And that's what the Whiskey Tribe is all about.
Whiskey snobbery.
It's kind of like, yeah, you're not really going to get invited into the community.
Man, that's good.
But magnificent bastards who believe that the best whiskey is what?
The whiskey you like to drink the way you like to drink it.
Yes.
If you want to join us in the Whiskey Tribe, check out whiskeytribe.com.
This has been the top 10 advanced whiskeys for whiskey drinkers
that have been butt smuggled by Terry Dillon.
And on that note, if you fight, may you fight for a friend.
If you steal, may you steal lovers heart.
And if you drink, may you drink with us.
Hey, thanks for hanging out with us in the Whiskey Vault.
Don't forget to throw in a like, hit that subscribe button on the bottom right,
and drop a question or comment down below.
