The Battle of Germantown in October 1777 was Washington’s second defeat in a month, and it caused many to question his leadership. While an American loss, the battle did prove that the Colonial troops were much better trained than earlier in the American Revolution. Please keep watching, subscribe, and check out our playlist below. #historyteacher#americanhistory#americanrevolution#apush
After General Washington's debacle at Brandywine, British General William Howe was able to capture
Philadelphia in September 1777. After my victorious run through Philly, I moved my
troops out to Germantown, about 7 miles north of the city. Howe' s camp was poorly defended
so I had to act quickly. I planned to attack the enemy troops at Germantown with 8,000 men
from the Continental Army and 3,000 militiamen. Washington planned to attack the British from 4
different directions at dawn on October 4, 1777. One general would attack with the main force,
another would attack the British flank, and the last would attack the British rear. General John
Sullivan would attack with the main force while General Nathanael Greene attacked on the flank.
We love the General but sometimes his battle plans were a bit lofty and hard to execute in practice.
Coordinating separate assaults from far-removed positions was high risk. We started off early,
around 5am. I was hoping for a surprise attack, but it wasn't meant to be. Due to darkness and
heavy fog, communications quickly broke down between my men and two of our columns were behind
schedule. We weren't able to advance and lost the element of surprise. Washington's troops, heading
down the central road in Germantown, arrived at their designated meeting place and thought
the other Continental troops were also in place. Washington didn't understand that Greene's men and
militia, led by General Smallwood, were lost in the darkness and fog. Unaware of Greene's delays,
Washington gave orders for Sullivan to attack. Sullivan's troops surprised Howe's advanced guard
and forced it back towards Germantown in confusion as a dense fog blanketed the battlefield. Although
it wasn't a complete surprise, we still were shocked that there was such a large colonial
force. Fortunately, one of my officers Colonel Musgrave was able to take shelter along with 100
of his men in a large stone house called Cliveden and attack the Americans from that fortified
position. At that point in time, it seemed like the Americans had the upper hand, especially when
American General John Sullivan simply bypassed the roughly 100 men in the house and keep pushing
forward toward the British center. We couldn't leave the house behind us as it would expose
our rear flank so we returned to Cliveden house to capture it. It had over 100 British soldiers
defending it. Unfortunately, that is when it all started to fall apart! At the front, Sullivan and
Wayne's men were exerting heavy pressure on the British center though they were running low on
ammo. Then Greene's men finally arrived on the field and became disoriented by the fog. Howe's
flanks were left untouched and intact. Oh brother, we were in a real mess. We were low on ammo so
we had to slow down our firing. Amid all the fog and chaos, some of our troops were firing on each
other. Others thought they were being encircled by the enemy and withdrew. On the far right flank,
the Pennsylvanians militiamen held a Hessian column in place but did little more. On the
opposite end of the field, over a 1000 militiamen from New Jersey and Maryland arrived too late to
participate in any major fighting. Oh this was perfect for us. I used this opportunity
to counterattack and tipped the scales back in Britain's favor. It was a disaster. Another group
of my men was able to take on the British so that the separated division wasn't routed. However,
yet another unit got lost in the fog, mistook the separated division for the British Regulars,
and began firing before they both fled the field. We ended up chasing Washington back
several miles. Oh what a sight! Well actually, thanks to the onset of darkness, the Americans
were able to retreat in a more orderly fashion, but it had been a British victory during the
five-hour battle. Approximately 700 colonial men were killed and wounded as well as 400 captured.
The British only suffered around 500 casualties or men missing. People began to doubt my leadership
because of Brandywine and now this. I can't blame them. I should have done better. Although it was
clearly a British victory, the Continental Army was beginning to impress other European
nations with their determination to win the war. Despite the defeat at Germantown it still boosted
American morale and self-confidence as they believed the defeat was the result of bad luck,
not bad tactics. Honestly, it was even a surprise to me because I thought I had beaten those pesky
colonials, and here they come again launching an attack. Who knows what they'll do next?