Everything you need to know about 401k loans, hardship withdrawals, and distributions. Do you need to take a loan out of your 401k plan? Make sure you understand exactly how your plan works before pulling the trigger.
School of Personal Finance is an Investment Advisor registered with the State(s) of New York. All views, expressions, and opinions included in this communication are subject to change. This communication is not intended as an offer or solicitation to buy, hold or sell any financial instrument or investment advisory services. Any information provided has been obtained from sources considered reliable, but we do not guarantee the accuracy, or the completeness of, any description of securities, markets or developments mentioned. We may, from time to time, have a position in the securities mentioned and may execute transactions that may not be consistent with this communication's conclusions. Please contact us at 914-299-3843 if there is any change in your financial situation, needs, goals or objectives, or if you wish to initiate any restrictions on the management of the account or modify existing restrictions. Additionally, we recommend you compare any account reports from SPF with the account statements from your Custodian. Please notify us if you do not receive statements from your Custodian on at least a quarterly basis. Our current disclosure brochure, Form ADV Part 2, is available for your review upon request, and on our website, www.schoolofpersonalfinance.com. This disclosure brochure, or a summary of material changes made, is also provided to our clients on an annual basis.
hey what's up everyone and welcome to
the school of personal finance so now
this is the third video in the
everything you need to know about 401K
plans Series in this video we are going
to talk about taking loans from your
401k taking hardship with your alls and
also just taking distributions trying to
withdraw money from your 401k plan if
you haven't seen the first two videos we
talked all about if you should
contribute how much you should
contribute all about asset allocation
picking the right funds in the 401K so
make sure to go back and watch those
videos as well I hope you find this one
helpful let's get to it if this your
first time here my name is Rich
McCormack I'm a certified financial
planner I've been a financial adviser
for over 20 years and this channel is
all about teaching you personal finance
and how to become great with money if
you enjoy these topics please hit that
subscribe button and go check out School
of personal finance.com all right so we
are going to talk about loans hardship
with your RS and taking distributions
from your employer sponsored retirement
accounts so now this goes for 401ks
403bs 457 plans and where we're going to
start start is that each employer plan
is different so you have to make sure to
check with your employer to see what the
rules are surrounding these different
types of options that you might have no
plan is the same so some plans might
offer hardship withdrawals or loans
while other plans might not so you
really need to contact your HR
department or whoever is The Record
Keeper for your 401k or 403v plan and
understand exactly how it works before
you take any action all right so let's
start with loans and I'm going to keep
saying for 41k but I also mean 403b and
457 plan as well but let's start with
the pros and cons of taking out a loan
and how it works so now when you take a
loan out of your 401k plan the maximum
that you could take out is going to be
the lesser of $50,000 or half of your
account balance let's just do a very
quick example if you have $80,000 in
your 401k and you want to take out as
much as possible in the form of a loan
then the max you'll be able to take out
is 50% of that account value which is is
$440,000 right so the lesser of 50,000
or half of your balance if you had
$500,000 in your 401k then the maximum
you could take out would be that $50,000
right you can't take $200,000 out they
put a cap on it at $50,000 but you can't
take any more than 50% of your vested
account balance and there's no credit
check your credit score doesn't matter
if you have bad credit you're not going
to get denied for a loan from your 401k
because you're borrowing your own money
it's typically just an application and
then you have to wait a little while for
your 401k provider to actually process
the loan and a lot of times there are
some small fees that you want to know
about they might have an application fee
they might have an annual fee to service
alone so you want to look into that as
well and now the typical repayment
period is between 1 and 5 years and you
could choose whatever repayment period
you want now if the loan is for the
purchase of your primary residence then
many plans will allow you to extend that
repayment period 15 years 20 years all
the way up to 30 years so you want to
check with your plan to see how that
works I actually took out a 401k loan
when I bought my house back in 2011 we
built our house and I needed the funds
to continue building the house and I was
able to take out a 401k loan over a
15-year period I just had to send them a
contract basically showing them that I
was using it for my primary residence
now the typical interest rate on the
401K loan is going to be around prime
plus 1% so we're close to 10% right now
on these types of loans but again each
plan is different so you have to check
to see what your plan charges in
interest now when you repay the loan
it's going to come from payroll
deduction they're going to deduct the
payments directly out of your paycheck
so your paycheck is going to get reduced
and then the interest that you are
charged that goes back into your account
so you are repaying yourself all right
so this is another Pro with taking a
loan from your 401k you're not paying
the bank interest you're borrowing your
own money it's like you're acting as
your own bank so you are paying yourself
back that interest amount so now the
things we went over so far they all make
it sound pretty nice to take out a 401k
loan right the process is pretty
painless you're paying yourself back
it's a pretty easy way to get your hands
on money and odds are your 401k is
probably the largest asset that you
might have right now so to be able to
borrow money from it and take care of
other things it sounds pretty appealing
and once I go through the negatives I'll
give you my overall opinion as I already
shared I did take a 401k loan out in my
own life so everybody does have a
different opinion and it really depends
who you're listening to so I'll share
mine as well but now let's go into some
of the downsides some of the negatives
to taking out a loan in your 401k all
right so the first one of probably the
biggest one is that when you take a loan
you're taking the money out of the
Investments you're taking it out of the
market so that you could go ahead and go
use it so there's an opportunity cost
for that now if you could time it right
and you take out a loan at the top of
the market and the market goes down for
the next 5 years then in hindsight that
would have been the good thing but over
time markets tend to grow all right so
as your money is out of the market you
are missing out on the growth of that
401K money so this could end up costing
you big time over a long term especially
if you take out a loan over a 15year
period for the purchase of a primary
residence then that's a long time that
that money is out of the market and
you're only putting it back in through
your payroll deduction another thing
that you need to check with your
employer about is if they'll allow you
to continue to contribute when you have
a loan outstanding in my experience most
plans still allow you to contribute to
that 401k plan but that's a big deal if
you can't contribute anymore and you're
missing out on an employer match then in
my mind that makes it much worse taking
out a loan against your 401k so you want
to be able to you want to make sure that
you're still able to contribute to that
401k even though you have a loan
outstanding on it so now defaulting on a
loan it gets very ugly from there so you
do have to make sure that you are able
to pay it back if it's through payroll
deduction then you don't really have a
choice right but if you get build
separately or however it works you just
need to make sure that you keep up with
those loan payments because if you do
default then it becomes a distribution
where you're going to owe ordinary
income tax on that amount and also if
you are younger than 59 and a half you
will have a 10% penalty on that
distribution as well so you could get
smacked upside the head with a really
large tax bill just because you weren't
able to make those loan payments and OD
are if you couldn't make the loan
payments then you probably don't have
that money to pay those taxes so you
could really put yourself in a tough
situation if you don't keep up your end
of the bargain with that loan agreement
now another thing that you really want
to understand is what happens if you
leave your employer all right so you
need to check with your plan if you get
fired if you decide to leave your job
change careers or whatever and you have
a loan house standing that loan it could
become a distribution where again you
would have to pay ordinary income taxes
and the 10% penalty if you're younger
than 59 the half some providers they do
allow you to continue to leave your 401k
there and continue paying that loan back
even though you're not employed there
anymore but you need to check with the
plan another thing to keep in mind is
that you can't take a loan from an old
employer so if you have an old 401k
that's hanging out there then you can't
take a loan against it what you might be
able to do is take that old 401K and
roll it into your new 401k plan and then
take a loan against it but you can't
take it from that Old plan once you
leave that employer so do I think it's a
good idea to take a loan out of a
401k and my answer like with most things
is it really depends on your situation
so if you're taking a loan out for a
purchase of a home and you need it for
the down payment right then again
depending on where you're at financially
I don't think it's a terrible move you
just have to go in eyes wide open and
understand that your paycheck is going
to be reduced so not only you going to
have this mortgage payment now but your
paycheck is also going to be reduced and
if you change jobs if something happens
where you might have to come up with
that payment and satisfy it or else it's
going to be a distribution then that's a
big risk so I think it really depends on
how much you need how long you're able
to take the loan for and what happens if
you do change jobs or if you get fired
God forbid all right so now if you're
taking out a loan to pay off credit card
debt then I think it's a good thing to
pay off 30% interest credit cards using
a 401k loan that might be at 8 or 9%
where you're paying yourself back the
money but if you run up the credit cards
again now you just took away one of your
lifelines right this 401k loan I look at
it as like a backup to the backup of my
emergency fund only in a worst case
situation do I really want to tap into
that and if you use it to pay off bad
debt High interest rate debt but you
don't change your behavior then you
could really bury yourself but if you
have a real emergency in life if you
have medical bills if something comes up
then having that Lifeline there I do
think that it's a good thing I don't
think that it's terrible I'm not in the
camp of never take a loan from your 401k
but you have to understand that it
really could put a damper on your
retirement right because you're taking
that money out of your account it's not
growing and you're missing out on that
and if they your plan doesn't let you
continue contributing then it makes it
much worse in my opinion all right so
now let's look at hardship withdrawals
so now the IRS defines a hardship
withdrawal as money that you need to
take out to satisfy an immediate and
heavy Financial need and there are seven
different circumstances deemed by the
IRS to be considered an immediate and
heavy Financial need so I'm just going
to go ahead and read them off to you
very quickly so the first one is medical
expenses for the employee the spouse or
their dependents the second one is the
cost to purchase a primary residence the
third one is tuition or related
educational expenses for the employee
the spouse or their dependents the
fourth are payments to prevent eviction
or foreclosure on a mortgage the fifth
one is going to be for burial costs for
your spouse or dependent the sixth is
repair of damage to the employees
primary residence and the seventh is
expenses and losses that are the result
of a FEMA declared disaster now the
amount of the hardship It could only
satisfy that immediate need you cannot
take out anything above that all right
it can include the taxes that you will
have to pay because of this hardship
withdrawal so with hardship withdrawals
you do have to get approved you do have
to send in documentation proving that
you have an actual hardship all right
and the HR department they have to go
through the process of approving it and
then sending you out the money now when
you receive the money you are not able
to put it back into your 401k plan like
you are with a loan so the loan should
always be the first option if you don't
have the option of taking out a loan
then that's where the hardship
withdrawal will come into play but once
you take that money out you can no
longer put it back in and you are going
to have to pay ordinary income tax on
that hardship withdrawal now in some
cases you might also owe a 10% penalty
it's going to depend on what you are
using that hardship withdrawal for all
right and then let's wrap this up by
talking about just taking distributions
from your 401k plan all right so now the
magic age for taking withdrawals or
distributions from your 401k is 595 once
you reach 59 A5 you could take a
distribution without the 10% penalty
right you're still going to owe ordinary
income tax on those distributions unless
you have Roth money if you have Roth
401k money or Roth 403b money then that
those distributions will come out
tax-free as long as you follow the rules
for the Roth distributions but now there
is one rule that many people people are
not aware of which is called the 55 and
retired rule where if you retire at age
55 or older you are allowed to take
distributions from your 401k plan or
your 403b plan without that 10% penalty
you're still going to owe ordinary
income taxes again unless it's a WTH but
you will not owe that 10% penalty so for
people who decide to retire at age 56
they could start taking 401K withdrawals
and not be subject to that 10% penalty
now another type of distribution is
what's called an inservice distribution
so let's say for example you work at a
company that offers inservice
distributions then even though you're
still working there you might be able to
take your 401k balance and do a rollover
to an IRA if you'd like to some people
like to move it from a 401k to an IRA
because they have more control over the
expenses the investment options they can
move it to a place like Schwab or
Fidelity or Vanguard and control how
much it cost them to invest in different
funds and have many more funds that are
available to them so that's called an
inservice distribution all right
everyone that is it for this one I hope
that you found that helpful please make
sure to hit that like button if you
enjoyed it subscribe to the channel if
you are not subscribed already go check
out school ofpersonal finance.com and I
will see you again in the next one
thanks