This discussion is hot on the internet right now. Will being Chinese ever be considered cool?
Let's talk about yes or no and also why everybody keeps asking this question
You are asking the wrong question about whether or not you will ever be cool
You should be worried about shifting a unipolar world to do also school
We got to talk about it Andrew. There is a reddit post titled and this is from a male perspective this time
We covered one from a female perspective. Will China slash Chinese ever be able to lose the negative stereotypes?
He goes on to say that people hate being Chinese
Even Chinese Americans of varying generations seem to hate being Chinese everything from the traditional culture
Modern culture to everything we know about the negative stereotypes
China does not have an upper hand with soft power with things like fashion pop music TV shows right now
the biggest Chinese products exported overseas are text products and everything else Chinese is considered either a cheaper knockoff version or
Antiquated cultural products such as gua sha or TCM long story short Andrew
He basically says that Korea and Japan have their variety of things that are considered cool
Whereas a lot of Chinese Americans feel a disconnect with China because when they were growing up
They had nothing cool except what old-school things
Confucianism filial piety or who or who music that's hilarious. He said or who music he goes
So what my question is will China or Chinese ever be able to lose the negative?
Stereotypes or will it just take several generations for people to see China just as normal people Wow
This is a crazy question. We've talked about this before in different ways
But I guess the question is yeah
Will being Chinese ever be considered cool and anybody who's cool that is Chinese?
What is it because they don't act or look Chinese, right?
But anyways, David, I guess I haven't I have my quick answer before we get into our our comment section
But why do people keep posting this question? Why is this such a burning question for so many Chinese in the West?
You're saying because there's so many articles that have been written about it
There's so many posts on a variety of platforms that have been written about it. It is because
Chinese culture compared to Japanese Korean and even in some ways like
Vietnamese or Filipino, even though the Southeast Asian countries are a different situation
Like they just don't seem very adaptive to the West. That's the easiest way I can put it
It seems like Chinese things they tend to be so centered in things that were created in China
That those things seem very outmoded
Outdated esoteric and on the downside and just woefully uncool in 2023, right now
Is it uncool to be Asian because those things are very?
Truly Asian or it's just that those things are still outdated like is Japan
Being more Asian than China is or Chinese culture
You don't I mean like I guess I guess that you're saying because for example Japan and Korea
They maintain a lot of the bowing that went away a hundreds of years ago in China, right?
But they both seem like they have a better grasp of Western at least pop culture
No, no, no
It seems like Japan in a weird way and especially Japan is both more in tune with its ancient side and in tune with the modern
world
Simultaneously, but I think you could even make some arguments about that. They still use coins on the Tokyo subway
There's some throwback things. I guess nobody's perfect. But I guess David do you have an answer? Yes or no?
Will it ever be cool to be considered Chinese? Listen guys, we're gonna get to the bottom of it
I think the answer is extremely complicated. So make sure you like subscribe and turning your notifications
However, you know what could make Chinese things cool or is a cool Chinese thing
Maybe you cannot shift this type of like global narrative
Realistically, this is trying to take the best parts of a Western finishing oil in a Chinese mala chili oil
Smaller check it out. Very delicious
Tons of chefs and foodies like it. Um as far as I've been alive Andrew being Chinese was never considered cool
Whoa, uh, I'm not saying Bruce Lee didn't have a little
Blip for his time. There's no Chinese. I mean, there's a lot of as far as the 80s and 90s go
You know, it was all Japan. Japan was already cool. Obviously the last 15 years Korea has been hyper cool
Japan's like still cool, but cooled off a little bit. So, uh of the last, you know my life 30 years
It's never been cool. Okay. So what do you what do you think for the future? Will it ever be cool?
I think that it's got a chance in another 20 30 years
Potentially, but I don't think that people should hold their breath. I do think they're probably all better off
Redefining what they think is cool. Not necessarily redefining what they think is cool, but finding the significance in the impact cool
Because uh, I mean, it's just a very large and confusing country, right Andrew as somebody who like yourself
You were the youngest child in a Chinese family
Probably the most Americanized you might even have a different perception of it because I'm more I'm born deep in it
You know what? I mean? My first language was Chinese. Uh, you're born a little bit outside of it, but came back into it
Yeah, I mean, I think the short answer is uh
No, I don't think it will ever be perceived as cool
And here's why I say specifically the word perceived as cool because I think there will be many cool things to come out of China
Cool things on a Western level still whether it's clothes gadgets even characters. There's gonna be some cool movies
There's some cool icons. We have Bruce Lee Jackie Chan, but I jelly these guys are cool
and some of the new games coming out Genshin impact, but a cool game, but if you made me say on a a
Average level of how the average person views it. No, it won't be cool. And here's the reason why it's because China is such a big
And complicated country and in the Western ideas
It is so hard to put it on a good or bad scale people in the West
We want to talk about China as it is it good or bad it's China good or bad is it good or bad is
It good or bad in it to be honest. It's complex. That's what it is
It's both got some great things about it
And it is a extremely powerful country and it's right up there with America as far as leaders in the world that are gonna impact
The rest of the world but a lot of people don't want to admit that a lot of people don't want to look to China
For any sort of leadership because China has certain flaws about the country that we don't like so you're saying America is the all-good
Superpower China's the 50-50 superpower, but probably more on the downside in Russia is the all-bad superpower
But they kind of look white and I like the girl so that kind of makes me feel a little bit
You know torn about it because I like Trump and Trump likes Putin
Yeah, so if I had to put it on the big countries
I'd put America is viewed as good very good and then India is kind of like in a neutral zone
China is
Slightly negative and then Russia is considered very negative. So that's how it's I think it's gonna stay in that order
For a long time, right? And those are your four essentially major superpowers
Complex identities and complex issues are very hard for the average person to understand. I'm not gonna lie
Like I'm not saying people are stupid
I'm just saying that it is very hard to balance these things and a lot of people are not giving to give it enough
Empathy and thought to realize that it's just good and bad, right?
And there's people who even enter could be smart at their job
But not dedicate a lot of brainpower to thinking about this aspect of life
So they they can have blind spots where they're like hyper. They're not a hyper simplistic person
But their view on China could be hyper simplistic. Yeah, but I do think the image will get better
I'll say this. I think it's gonna get better. I don't know if it's ever gonna be on cool level like Japan cool
I don't know. That's pretty cool, right? I think here's one thing and you could look at this stuff
That's coming up Andrew. The EVs are coming up
I don't know if they'll ever let the EVs in America due to the geopolitical beef
The EVs are considered some of the top rated in the world Andrew the one plus open was considered the top foldable phone of
2023
Andrew I believe the verge gave the Osmo pocket 3 gadget of the year. That's DJI, right?
You can film Netflix. You can film Hollywood movies on this DJI 4d camera now Shanghai Tang, you know
They're starting to do some stuff with the denim
Chutton signs, you know, I'm not saying they look that great
You know, I just think at the end of the day
You know any great tech that comes out of China is gonna be perceived to be you used as some type of
Surveillance or hacking weapon against America, right? That's just how it's gonna be perceived. Maybe they do use some technology
Well to hack America and maybe they don't like I I don't know but it's possible
But I'm just saying that's how it's perceived. Right? Right, right. That is the perception
Somebody said it is largely because China's pop culture lacks emotional artistic or any sort of sex appeal
Yeah, I mean, I think that that's the one aspect I see and we're gonna get into the comment section Andrew
I think whether it's a modern-day repression or even a historical repression back to the dynastic days
There is something very old-school about the way Chinese
Process their oxytocin the way they have an oxytocin pool inside of the chest and the pipelines that lead to the oxytocin
Expression there is something that is very stifled about that
And I think that that is probably the most overlooked aspect
You guys will read more about it in my book later because I just might be too much to get into into a you know
Into a video. Anyway, let's get in the comment section
Somebody said it's actually been getting a lot better over the past two years a lot of video games such as Genshin Impact
Have Chinese themes. There's other ones. There's a new Sun Wukong video game coming out. Everybody's shopping our team
Good Ali Express she n she n is from China. So I guess he's like, well, what do you mean?
I don't know like no a lot of people also on Instagram when they make it fun of something
They're like yo, that's when you get like Michael Jordan from team. Oh, yeah. Yeah
So it's kind of like both a joke, but also everybody buys it too. So it's like it's this real weird thing
It's kind of like fast food where everybody partakes in it, but then they kind of still look down on it
You know what? I mean, right? It's weird just like tick-tock, right?
They're like everybody, you know, everybody's like gosh, you cannot find anything good on tick-tock because tick-tock is owned by doing in
But then it's like everybody's on
Still watching tick-tock
Somebody said, you know
It really comes down to the Chinese government for getting rid of soft power getting rid of the freedom needed to create soft power
Xi Jinping is really setting back China's image back to the Mao era
China was improving a lot when Hu Jintao was in power because he was less strict
It's true Hu Jintao was probably less strict than Xi Jinping
So a lot of other people said, you know, it'll probably happen, but it's gonna take 30 20 or 30 years
And somebody said yeah, we'll probably find China will be cool around the same time. We discover a true cure for male pattern baldness
That's funny. Um, somebody said this Korean guy said, you know guys I understand what you're saying internally within Asians
You're right. It probably goes like Korea Japan and then way way way below China in terms of coolness
But he goes I found that non Asians don't really understand the difference
So what anybody is feeling about China being uncool is an internal Asian thing
Do you agree or disagree with that that like people this is like an internal Asian?
Like I got a tier B tier C tier ranking versus like an external thing
Yeah, I do think on the external even those non Asians who are into Asian culture and can kind of tell the difference I
Think that they may still show even more empathy
Towards China's image and find the coolness in it even more
Than other Asians do yeah, it's possible agree with that. I would agree with that because they're not like tapped into. Yeah
They're also not like yeah, they're not part of the rankings like they don't care somebody said who cares about teenage pop culture
That's silly versus actually being able to shape ships the geopolitics of the world
Basically, this is that classic argument from like defensive Chinese guys being like y'all who cares about soft power hard power is more important
Yeah, I mean you could definitely obviously in the big scheme of things. I think most people agree that hard power is
More important right like Jamaica's got a lot of soft power
But I think we're just the reason why people ask this question all the time is because there's a lot of Chinese in the West
Who are just frustrated and they're wondering when they can potentially benefit or they feel like they're slightly
Suffering from the overall image of China right because they cannot benefit from the hard power here
In fact that that hard power competitiveness can only hurt them and then the lack of soft power
Exports or desire for China soft power also hurts them right so it's also in a weird way
Living in the West both aspects hurt you like let's say China
Has the most power in the world or whatever it takes over the world
But then like people don't like it, then they're still gonna view China as negative even if China is like the most powerful
It'll be a backlash against exact rankings. Oh, you know I guess it's a tough
It's a tough one guy somebody said the short answer is no sad to say but with the current negative stereotypes rising power of China
Which is challenging the u.s.. And lack of social awareness this definitely will not happen in anybody's lifetime
Yeah, I mean this house this guy said the thing is I don't need people to like being Chinese to enjoy being Chinese myself
Maybe start off with that, huh, they only love you if you're not a threat to them
Do you want to be a pet to them or do you want to be a tiger but a tiger?
That's hated essentially if people hate being Chinese. They need to wake up
Don't wait for white people to validate your culture Wow that's a strong statement. I understand
I think the truth is you have to just find the aspects of Chinese culture that you actually think are important and significant and cool
And there are a lot to choose from so you can pick and choose
But maybe you don't have to take on everything right right and you don't have to like look at everything like it's a very
intellectual place to be though to be able to balance it out and still like literally just see it for what it is or as
Best as a human can because all humans are subject to bias
Somebody said they laughed when China was weak now, they say they're we're evil when China is strong
Yeah, man stuff. Yeah. Um, this is more on a base micro level Andrew. This guy said I'm South Asian
It reminds me of a close female friend who said she hates being Chinese because the language sounds funny
The food is spicy or not appreciated amongst Americans unless it's Americanized and she learned to speak Japanese and considers Japan superior
Andrew this is a pretty common thing
We ran into in church a lot of kids wanted to be Japanese growing up then later on in church a lot of kids not
All obviously there's a very there's a variance some kids really wanted to be Korean. Nobody really wanted to be Chinese
Why it's important like if you want to support
Chinese products that you think make it Chinese culture look better or at least look more adaptive
It's important that you support you don't have to support everything
But you have to find the things or the personalities that you support if you feel like
There are good representation if you think
If you think it's Eileen goo or the phone bros or right?
Whoever it may be for your own reasons
You should figure out a reason to support it. Yeah, I know that you know, we're talking about hard power soft power geopolitics versus cool power
Those things are completely separate, you know
Like for example, Andrew we had this Filipino friend and his grandfather's name was Chino
But I remember he always tried to tell me that his Asiatic side was Japanese and I always went
Hey, bro
Did you know that if you were part Japanese and that's why your eyes look like that
It probably came from something really horrible happening. Whereas if you're actually just part Chinese, it's just gonna come through a happy marriage
But he was just so locked into what was cool
I think later once he got older he kind of accepted it
But uh, like we said people care about this cool ranking right like because we're sort of saying even though you can look beyond
Like being an American satellite state or not at the end of the day if you're living in the u.s
None of that stuff matters, right? Yeah
So anyway, somebody said for those hoping and wishing China gets buddy-buddy with the u.s. Forget it. It'll never happen
Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I don't know. Yeah, probably not for another 20 30 years. It's gonna
Who knows though in the 20-30 years China's gonna be under different leadership America's gonna be under different leadership
Hopefully, it's more chill. I'm still optimistic about it, but but cautiously optimistic
Somebody said so a Japanese American has to hang their hat on anime game consoles and Hello Kitty
Like what about all the ancient stuff? Is that stuff matter too?
And then but I guess Japan and or they also got the samurai stuff, too
So they got they got the ancient stuff and the modern stuff
They just got a whole they just got an era from 1925 to like 1945. That's bad
Um, somebody said as a Filipino, I see the true game from a bird's eye and I applaud China
Basically for for challenging the West
That's good. That's good. No, that's good. That's showing I guess
Yeah, I guess it's showing appreciation right but we're living in the West
So obviously it depends on like how much we're supposed to be bought into the Anglo sphere or Anglo dominance or whatever
Somebody says it has to do with the scalability of bad news
China is the biggest country in the world
China and India are the biggest countries in the world and they have a lot of good middle and horrible things happening
So anytime the Western news wants to dip into the horrible news pool
It is a gigantic pool of news this I think is a very very true comment that remember this comment
I remember this comment
These countries are anywhere from three to four times the size of America
I always say if you times the America by four, you know
How many people would die of drunk driving accidents drug overdoses gun violence?
Like literally shooting each other not cops shooting bad guys
like literally people shooting the other people how many people would die of like
Being obese like if those statistics times four think about it in America would be ridiculous numbers
So every country has as bad or good
But yes, it is true that if you want to find something bad about China, it's not hard to find it, right?
It's not right just because it's so big right? There's a lot of terrible stories coming out of India to Russia
What do I see on tik-tok of like what only guys want to raise bears or fight each other?
Large countries Brazil Mexico. I mean, it's lots of terrible stuff going on endless
Yeah
I do think in a weird way and this is like a whole nother video in a weird way like the white people who are
Really into geopolitics tend to be like upper-class
They're not gonna count a lot of the bad things in America because they're like, oh that didn't happen amongst our tribe
But that's a whole nother issue
Somebody said they actually did demonize Japan in the late 80s and early 90s, too
But everybody forgot because America created the Plaza Accords dropped the Japanese economy
Japan was no longer competitive with the u.s. But when it was getting close Andrew
There was a bunch of Time magazine articles making Japan look bad, too
Like there was an article from I believe what is this?
1987 how Japan picks America's brain
Basically about how like they're stealing u.s. Technology and innovating. Yeah, and yeah, Japan used to take intellectual property. I'm sure
Everybody I think that I
Think the main difference is that when you met Japanese Americans or Japanese people in the West you didn't get that feeling
No, even if the Japanese government is responsible over, you know last century for some pretty terrible things
When you met a Japanese person, it almost made you feel like they didn't do anything
Yeah, in fact, the only guy to ever be killed for quote-unquote being Japanese was a Chinese guy Vincent Chin
Yeah, so I'm saying
Every time you met China Japanese people at the teriyaki shop at the Japanese market when you seen them
when you just met the international school students when you
Obviously if you watch like hentai and all that stuff like you know V
Yeah, JV that it just it just warmed you up to it, right?
Right, right and that goes to our final point
Somebody said listen guys all aspects matter even at the height of u.s. Japan economic war in the early
1990s
Half of America was still really pro-japan because they were obsessed with Kurosawa movies Sony Walkman's ninjas and samurais
so this is where the soft power comes into play where it's like
Even when there's an economic rival if there is some soft power culture that the other rival loves it can soften the hatred
Yo, man, Jap, Japan was kind of like that toxic
Cool boyfriend that u.s. Dated or a BG. Yeah, but then became better
But then you forgot about their toxic past but because they're just so good to you now
It's like a hot bipolar girl, dude
People love hot bipolar girls, even though generally it's cuz she loves you now because the girl loves you now
So you're cool with it and you're willing to forgo like not really think about her past, but she did some crazy toxic stuff
Well, she's gonna turn and if it ever goes downside, she's gonna turn your life upside down
Anyway guys, let's just get into the takeaways. Like I said, these are a lot of comments. They're not necessarily my thoughts
We're just responding to them. I'll say this for the effective lifetime of the person asking the question Andrew
I'm assuming it's a Chinese guy who is looking to date Eastern European women
Like like all the Korean guys are doing right now for probably not for another 20 30 years
So it doesn't so it will happen but not for their effective to see the narrative change. I think it's gonna be tough
You know, I think that I'll say this
I think the people who can make Chinese culture seem cool and seem palpable are gonna be rewarded
you know people who can come up with the products the people who can explain the culture the people who take after Bruce Lee and
in being
Philosophical in a Chinese way, but being able to deliver it in a Western way. I think those are really important roles
But I think you just got focus on yourself and make you know
It's gonna be after interaction over interaction if everybody that was Chinese that everybody met was sweet and warm and nice
Not and I'm not saying you have to be that I'm just saying if that was that if everybody got a pleasant interaction
Or a cool interaction with a Chinese person. It would change their perception
But because that's not how we're necessarily raised. So yeah. No, I think that there's twofold
Listen, there's a lot of factors that the teenage cool side and or that's obsessed with soft power
They will never understand and the super geopolitical side
Basically saying it because China is challenging Anglo-saxon hegemony over the past 400 500 years Ray Dalio, etc, etc
They're changing in nations
They're there both sides are missing up an aspect
both sides are looking at it in a lopsided sense because I do think that the
The oxytocin piping is probably like an issue that you know Chinese need to take a look at I do think TCM is
Outdated you're great at one point for preventative medicine. I do think it's outdated now. So I'm gonna end with this last comment
I read this somebody said this from a Chinese person, by the way
He said people can start making a new Chinese identity instead of clinging on to the old ones
And he was talking about how like yeah
Like maybe we do need to look at TCM companies and be like they're not putting enough into R&D
Clearly showing that it's not real or Wing Chun masters that are making a bunch of them
I'm not just singling out Wing Chun
But I'm just saying Shaolin masters that are making X an X amount of money teaching people things
But then when they get into combat, they're losing to Muay Thai fighters or Sancho or Sanda fighters
I do think that there needs to be a little bit more accountability
Yes, because just because you created a full-fledged culture that was completely outside of the Western world
Thousands of years ago. It doesn't mean that you got to hold on to it forever, right?
You know the West Andrew they mix and match a lot of stuff from the east to especially when it comes to MMA
Why can't the east just mix and match back to the West?
Anyway, guys, let us know what you think of the comment section below very deep questions
Like I said some of this stuff belongs in a book and perhaps I might be working on one
Let us know what you think in the comment section below. We encourage the debate
Keep it civil until next time with a hot bar boys. We out. Peace