The xBloom Review: Is Great Filter Coffee Easy Now?

About Coffee in life
92 followers
72 Video Views·Dec 21, 2023
Today we're going to review this. It's the X-Bloom Coffee Brewer.
Something new and unusual because it's both a beater cup filter coffee machine,
but also a pod machine, which is something you don't see every day.
It's a little bit unusual in its design.
The whole idea behind this is to kind of make a promise.
Is to say, you, you there, do you love delicious filter coffee?
Do you find the process of brewing it annoying and kind of irksome?
Do you find the whole idea of dialing in a recipe
eye-rollingly irritating rather than kind of fun?
If that's you, this is who they're trying to reach.
They're saying this machine is going to take all the pain away,
make life easy and make you kind of perfect, well-brewed filter coffee each and every time.
How will it do that? That's the question.
And ultimately, will it do that? Will it deliver on its promise?
That's what we're here to discuss.
To explain how this whole thing works, we should really start with the pods.
Which are these.
Now, this is quite a large pod and inside of here will be maybe 15 to 16 grams of coffee,
depending on which roaster has put coffee inside this thing.
Now, when you peel open the pod, a satisfying sound, you'll find inside coffee beans.
And those coffee beans are sitting inside a very neatly folded coffee filter paper.
Because this pod is not just for storing the coffee,
this pod is a brewing cone and brewing filter paper.
All in one.
Now, the magic of this happens when you touch the pod to the top of the machine.
Because at the base of this pod is an RFID chip that has just told the coffee machine
what the coffee is and it's communicated a recipe to it as well.
On the front of the machine, you can see a kind of visual representation of that.
It's showing you firstly, grind size.
So how finely or how coarsely it should grind the coffee.
Then the brew temperature and how hot the water should be.
And finally, the kind of ratio of coffee to water.
At this point, we pour the beans in.
We put this thing in the little tray, the little holder.
Make sure it's level, that is important.
And then if we push go, it's going to grind coffee and start to brew.
Now, as it's brewing, you can hear it's pretty loud.
You can hear both a little gurgling of the water heater going on,
but you can also hear quite a loud little PC fan that's sitting inside the body here,
keeping anything steamy away from the precious electronics.
And then you can hear that, a little jiggle,
a little agitation of the grounds at the end of the bloom phase.
Something actually I'm kind of into generally.
I like a little swirl of a V60, sometimes a stir if that suits you better.
Here, it's doing a little side to side jiggle.
At this point, after a period of bloom, it will begin to pour the water.
And how it pours the water is another way that it's being unusual,
clever and a little bit interesting.
As you watch this brew, you can see that the stream of water is moving around on the coffee bed,
and it's doing that in a very clever way.
There's no mechanical piece here, nothing's rotating.
Instead, right at the exit of the spout are four, I suppose, conductors.
And by passing a charge through them, you'll have a kind of electrostatic pull on the water.
So as you sort of vary the charge around the conductors,
you can vary the pull on the water that sort of changes its direction.
And without doing anything mechanical, you can move a stream of water around.
Now, because the fan is genuinely pretty noisy,
I'm just going to wait until it stops brewing to talk to you about the coffee that it brews
and some more about this particular pod.
So the brew is now done, and it seems important to point out that there's one big difference
between this and other pod machines that make filter coffee that you might have seen,
and that's speed.
This brews in a similar way to someone who's brewing a pour over,
which means that the brew process takes minutes, not seconds.
If you've used things like K-Cups or Nespresso Virtua pods or other kind of pod systems,
they tend to prioritize very rapid brewing.
Now, there's no real noticeable warm-up time here.
Once you turn it on and put a pot in and start brewing, it goes pretty much straight away.
So it's quick, but the brewing process is relatively slow.
This brew is obviously a little bit too hot for me to taste properly right now,
but it is a good opportunity to talk about the pod.
Now, this will probably drip on the table, but never mind.
This pod...
Now, the pod itself merits some discussion.
Most people are very anti-pod machines because they see pods as contributing to waste.
Be it an aluminium pod, be it a different kind of pod,
people are generally anti-pod from a waste perspective.
XBloom's approach has been to make this thing fully compostable,
which is broadly good with the exception, of course, of the RFID chip at the bottom.
So if I was going to compost this, I would need to, from the bottom here,
remove this little RFID chip.
That would obviously need to be disposed of separately to the rest of this pod.
Now, a quick note on composting.
It doesn't feel as neat and clean and simple as I wish it was,
and that's not an indictment on compostable things.
That's an indictment on composting services where most people live.
Where this studio is, for example, if I put this into my food waste to be composted,
it, along with any other packaging, will be removed
because they can't tell what's compostable and what's not,
so it all gets taken out.
If I try and put it into my garden waste, again, destined for compost,
that will also have any packaging removed and taken out.
So for me here, the best thing to do would be to put the ground coffee into my food waste,
but this pod, regardless of its biodegradability,
is going to end up in landfill in many parts of the world.
As I said, I'm not criticizing them for that decision.
I just think it's important to talk about, you know, compostable stuff
and how it actually figures into our lives and our waste disposal systems,
and I wish composting was kind of better.
The RFID chip is... it's a point of conflict for me.
I understand that they're chasing convenience for the end user,
and actually this is a very convenient technology.
It's a very quick and neat way to communicate enough information
to have a recipe be transferred over or information about the coffee be transferred over.
I think about what the alternatives could be.
It would either be something like image recognition,
where either you're going to take a photo of the pod with your phone,
or this would have a camera, but I really don't want cameras and smart devices in my kitchen,
or you could do something like the Nespresso Virtuo system
that uses a barcode in the brew chamber and it scans that,
but this doesn't really feel like a place where I want a barcode scanner hanging out.
So I struggle with it.
I understand why they've made the choice.
I just feel like this has to be excess cost and excess waste in a system,
and I would hope for a better solution in the future than this.
This definitely makes me feel a little uncomfortable,
despite how well it works and how seamless it makes the whole process.
Ultimately, I think it will be one of the biggest points of pushback
from the broader coffee community to this machine and this particular system.
Now, this tasting glass that I will drink from soon,
once this is cooled just a little bit more,
did come with the coffee machine.
It was included in the kind of Kickstarter package.
In addition to that, I got 32 of the pods from four different roasters.
That was good. Most of those are now gone.
Drunk a lot of them.
I also got this, which was quite nice as a little sort of solution to a problem.
This is some third wave water.
I've got five sachets there that would make up five gallons.
This is minerals that you would add to distilled water
in order to have the right minerality for brewing delicious coffee,
because it's one of the variables that has this massive impact
on cup quality, on how delicious the coffee is,
that's actually really hard to control.
So they're trying to set people up for success from the beginning,
which I appreciate.
And the one other thing that came with it,
which we'll have to talk about a little bit more
because it needs a bit more discussion,
is this, which is designed to be a kind of reusable pod
to allow you to use any coffee that you want to use.
That I think is a good thing.
They're obviously, you know, sensitive to the idea
that people don't want to feel locked into a system.
You know, it's one of the criticisms of pod systems
is that you can only buy the coffee in the pods.
You can't brew the coffee that you want to brew.
They've said, no, no, no.
If you put in, let's say, a Kalita 155 paper filter,
you can, you know, tap this on top, build out a recipe,
and you can brew whatever coffee you want to brew.
And to explain that a little bit more,
I should probably show you the app that comes with this,
because I do like the fact that I don't have to use an app to make coffee.
I don't have to get my phone out of my pocket in the morning.
I don't have to suffer dealing with technology.
I can go, bip, pour, brew, and have coffee.
That seems kind.
But the app lets you do quite a lot.
If this brew wasn't to my liking, I could make a change to it,
or I can build a recipe for a coffee that XBloom don't know about.
So I'm in the app, and at the start of it,
you can sort of browse some of the roasters
that they're working with.
I will say they're working with a selection of great roasters
who buy and roast great coffee, which is good.
I'm pro that.
At the top, you can see the machine.
I can tap into the machine.
Now, to explain things, if I put a pod on top,
you'll see that it detects the pod,
and I can actually tap into that.
Now, in a situation where I may want to tweak a pod's recipe,
well, I can do that very easily.
The first page is quick edit, and you'll see if I tap that,
then I can just move these sliders around.
Obviously, the smaller the number on the grind size,
the finer the grind.
Let me come out of there, though, and show you get creative,
which I suppose if you're building out a recipe on your own,
you might want to look at this.
Here, you can see a little bit more information,
and as you watched that pod before,
you see it did sort of multiple pours
rather than one continuous pour,
and you can edit each of those continuous pours.
So here, there's quite a lot of little pours
in this particular recipe.
I can sort of swipe across and see them,
and I can change the volume of each pour.
It's brew temperature.
I can change the pattern with which the spout dispenses water.
I can do a little vibration before or after,
and I can also change my beverage size
and my grind size at the top.
Let's just say I want to take that,
oh, just a touch finer.
There we go.
Now, when I save that,
I can save that as a brand new profile,
which is interesting.
Now, if I wanted to,
I could even turn this profile into the default
for this particular pod,
which means that whenever I use that pod
without getting my phone out,
it would use my profile and not the one
that's kind of baked into it,
which is nice if you feel like
you know more than the machine
or you want it to brew differently
than how it wants to brew.
And this is something I've definitely thought
quite a lot about,
but I'll tell you about that in a little bit.
Overall, I think a well-built app,
pretty easy to use.
That's kind of all good.
I'm not really going to complain about that at all.
We're not done talking about this though.
We'll come back to this,
but I do need to now taste some coffee
and talk about how that has been.
That is a pretty well-brewed cup of coffee.
I would say it's not a particularly flawed cup of coffee,
but at the same time,
I would say that it is not reaching
the absolute full potential of the coffee.
And I think there's a couple of different reasons for that.
One of those is kind of wrapped up
in a philosophical discussion.
Let me take you back to my first experiences
with this machine.
When we got it out of the box
and we started brewing with it,
the coffee it produced was extremely disappointing.
It was extremely underextracted.
If you know a little bit about extraction science,
that'll make sense.
Basically, when you grind coffee,
about 30% of it is soluble,
but you don't want all 30%.
Typically, people are looking for somewhere
between 20 and 23% of the coffee
to be extracted into the cup below.
If you get less than that,
the brew is not only weak,
but not really balanced and sweet.
And that's what we were getting.
We were getting kind of 17% extractions,
weak underextracted brews.
The grind was too coarse.
At that point, you're like, wait, wait, wait.
The whole promise of this machine
is that you just put the pot on top,
pour the coffee in.
It takes care of everything.
How could this be wrong?
And the issue was ultimately
one of a grind calibration.
Now, having spoken to XBloom,
they're very confident in how they calibrate these at factory.
But I definitely had an issue with this machine
that was relatively easy to resolve.
Inside the app, there's a setting to go to for the grinder,
and you can run an auto calibrate function
to kind of recalibrate everything.
And that has definitely improved the coffee
that this thing is brewing.
Now extractions are more like 19, 19 and a half percent.
That's the kind of range where
I don't know if I am struggling
with the roaster's interpretation of the coffee
or the machine's delivery
of the roaster's brew method, right?
Like the roaster chose the grind setting,
the roaster chose the brew temperature
and the ratio and the pause
and all of that stuff.
Were they aiming for 19 and a half percent in the cup?
Or is my grind still a fraction course?
I don't know.
I don't know the answer to that.
It's not a bad cup,
but I know it could be a better cup.
And that leaves me a little bit
kind of confused and conflicted.
It could be it's doing exactly what the roaster wanted
and they prefer that kind of lighter extraction
that not kind of,
they don't want to get into the 20s.
They don't want to go higher.
They prefer this and that's not wrong.
If that's what they like,
that's what they like.
There's no right and wrong in coffee.
It's kind of annoying.
I wish there was a right and wrong.
I wish there was a,
this is doing exactly right or it's not.
But it's brewing pretty good coffee.
But if I had this,
I would definitely be in and tweaking the recipes,
certainly from a grind size
for most of the pods that I've brewed.
Not by a lot.
I think originally I would say
the original grind setting was out
by like six or seven steps on the grinder.
Now I might adjust one or two.
So it's definitely improved.
But as an experience that promises maximum ease,
I'm not sure that's entirely what I was delivered.
These things happen.
This is a Kickstarter.
I paid $400 for it,
not $800, which is the list price.
And the nature of backing a Kickstarter says,
you are getting a discount
because you are taking a gamble.
And the issue that I had was minor and easily resolved.
So I'm not out to sort of dam XBloom for this issue
because it's been fixed and the coffee is much better.
But it has wrapped me into this weird philosophical conundrum
where I don't know how the coffee's supposed to taste,
which is kind of weird.
Now there is one other issue I want to talk about
that is not to do with the grinder,
but is to do with how it sort of delivers water
and how the kind of pouring thing works.
If you get nerdy about pouring water onto coffee,
which unfortunately has happened to me,
you'll know that if you have a stream of water
fall into the kind of coffee brewing liquid,
then that's a good thing
because the sort of energy of the water falling
is translated and it will agitate the bed underneath.
If you pour slowly enough
that the pour breaks up into droplets,
what you see is actually that energy
becomes sort of dissipated.
And as the droplet hits,
the energy kind of goes sideways but not down.
Like it doesn't seem to churn the coffee
underneath the same way.
Here, the water breaks before it hits the coffee bed.
And so I think it's doing less agitation
that I would say is desirable.
To double check my theory,
I did separately have the machine grind some coffee
that I brewed with a pouring kettle
and it's not the most scientific of tests,
but in those comparisons,
I preferred the pouring kettle each and every time.
I just preferred that additional level of agitation.
It just felt like the coffee was a little sweeter.
I've got a little bit more out of it.
I wish the stream did not break
before it hit the bed of the coffee.
Let's talk about the price of the pods.
You buy them directly from Xbloom
and they have a couple of different price points.
In my money, in the British sterling,
32 pods costs £39 or £26,
which is I think around £1.20 per pod or 80 pence a pod.
At 80 pence a pod,
you're closer to specialty pod kind of prices,
even though most specialty pods
contain five or six grams of coffee
rather than 15 or 16 grams of coffee.
At £1.20, that is much more expensive.
I'm not saying that coffee should be cheaper.
I'm not saying that at all.
I'm just saying it is relatively expensive per cup.
Now, this unit is a 110 volt unit.
This is not built for Europe.
They have not launched in Europe.
They are launching May 25th, I think,
in North America, so US and Canada.
220 volt is coming later.
I'm obviously running this on a beefy transformer
underneath here to make sure we're all safe and sound.
Now, you can argue, coming back to this,
that you don't have to use their pods.
You get the reusable pod with this.
But this is suddenly comparable
to kind of going back to having a V60
and a grinder and a pouring kettle yourself
and going back to doing the work of dialing in,
of deciding how to pour,
deciding how hot your water should be.
You know, you still have to go and build a recipe for this.
And so this is kind of interesting to me
because it's very nice to have it.
It's nice not to have people feel like they're locked in,
but actually the lock-in still happens
from a workflow and convenience perspective.
I don't think people who buy this machine
are gonna be using this all that much.
Lovely if a friend gives you a bag of coffee
to try and play with and you're like,
oh, I can brew that,
but it'll be a bit of work, a bit of decision-making.
I feel like this machine appeals to people
who don't want to do the work and the decision-making.
So it's a kind of weird one for me,
but I think it's a very good thing that they've done it
and I'm pro them shipping this.
I think that's a good thing.
While we're on the topic of good things,
I would say that the grinder inside this is a good grinder.
It's a conical bird grinder.
It does, I think, a very good job.
I like the cups that it's capable of producing.
So from that point of view,
you're getting a pretty good grinder inside this.
I'm not sure it's at the level of something
like the Ode Gen 2,
which I think probably makes better tasting coffee,
but it's not that far away.
Like it's still making tasty, sweet, clean cups.
There's not too much mess.
There's a little bit of mess around the grinder.
This plate here comes off.
There'll be a little bit of coffee inside
and on the underside.
Different coffees seem to have different static quantities.
It's a little bit messy,
but not horrifically messy by any stretch.
If you look under the grinder,
you'll see a little kind of paperclip thing.
That's doing a little declumping distribution work
from the bottom of the grinder.
Obviously the coffee's coming into here
and being spread between the four holes
to distribute it evenly into the filter paper,
into the pod,
which is pretty good.
It does have these four little mounds
that you see in the pod
and I wish I could kind of get in there
and shake it level before the brew starts,
but that's not really what they want you to do.
So I'm not sure I'm going to recommend
you try and do that.
But overall, I don't really have much
in the way of complaints about the grinder,
but I do still have some other complaints, I'm afraid.
Firstly, probably the biggest one for me
that's kind of confusing.
Well, it's tied to the dimensions.
Now this machine is very tall
and for some people, too tall.
If you're trying to operate this
underneath some kitchen cabinets,
this may be a little bit too high.
It is a very tall machine
and they've chosen to go very tall,
not very wide and a little bit deep,
but not really very deep.
As a result of that,
the water tank is very small.
It's very small.
It is at its maximum capacity, 700 milliliters.
That means that you can brew two cups out of this
before you need to refill it.
Not three, just the two.
A typical cup is going to be around 250 mils.
So it's not like a 750 mil tank
where you might squeeze three cups out.
It's two with a bit left over.
There are environments where I could see
this machine working like an office,
but then if you have to refill
the water tank every two cups,
suddenly I feel like the office
would be constantly complaining
about the coffee machine
that you constantly have to fill up.
And if it's, you know,
you and someone else at home
making coffee in the morning,
every day you're filling the tank.
If you want to brew two or three cups a day,
you're filling the tank.
It just feels like they could have
made the machine a little bit deeper,
a tiny little bit wider,
and given a substantially larger water tank to it
that wouldn't have been as frustrating
for most people
when it comes to the kind of refilling
piece of this thing.
It just feels slightly anti
the whole high convenience,
easy experience that the rest of the machine
is trying to offer.
In terms of other nitpicks,
the display on the front,
I kind of don't get it, really.
When you put a pot on top
and you see the recipe come up,
that isn't really information I can read.
At best, it's just telling me
that a recipe has been communicated,
but I can't really see,
you know, any numbers here.
It's just a rough representation.
In addition,
I feel like a little bit of a lie,
at the top of the brew temps here,
it says 99 degrees Celsius.
This thing can run its water heater at 99 Celsius,
but it can only produce water at 95 Celsius
from the dispense.
It just seems a little bit odd
to tell me one thing,
but actually in the app and other places,
offer me a different number.
And so in conclusion,
I find myself a little bit impressed
and a little bit disappointed by the XBloom,
but ultimately kind of hopeful.
There are challenges
that I hope they can fix and overcome.
The RFID chip as one,
the sort of breaking up of the stream as another.
It's doing a high convenience thing
and it's doing a reasonable job.
I just wish it was doing a slightly better job
on the extraction.
I wish the extractions were just a little bit higher
so that I was still confident
that that's exactly how the roaster wanted that coffee.
And I definitely, definitely, definitely
don't have a calibration issue still.
I still worry that this grinder is set
one or two steps coarser than it should be,
despite me running the calibration on it.
But I can't know that
because I don't know
what the roaster was trying to achieve.
You get my frustration here, right?
Like you understand that kind of gray area
is to someone like me, maddening.
But it's brewing good coffee.
And if it gets more people drinking great coffee
and buying good coffee from good roasters,
that I think is probably a good thing.
Not everyone wants to go through the rigmarole
of darling in a grinder,
doing all that stuff themselves.
They like the fact that you can get a grinder
and a kettle and a robot in between them.
The price of list price, which is $800,
which they're now selling on their website for,
is definitely a challenging price.
That's a lot more than a good grinder and a kettle.
That, you know, the cost of the convenience,
the cost of the robot in between is pretty high.
Having paid $400 for it,
I feel pretty good about that value.
But if I was paying 800,
that is, to me, a tougher sell.
But now I want to hear from you.
I think they've shipped about a thousand of these,
a bit more now.
I think they raised about half a million on Kickstarter.
So these are out there in the wild.
People are using them every day.
How are you getting on with it?
Have you had good brews?
Have you been impressed?
Have you had, like me,
some issues with the grinder calibration?
Or did it brew perfectly straight out of the box?
Are you disappointed?
Are you surprised?
Are you delighted?
If you have one of these,
I really want to hear from you down in the comments below.
And if you're considering it,
well, what aspect of this didn't we cover enough?
Drop a question,
and I'll try and answer it wherever I can.
But for now,
I will say thank you so much for watching,
and I hope you have a great day.
