The election of George Washington was weirder than you think

Great United States of America
107 followers
The first U.S. presidential election in 1789 was very different from the way Americans do
presidential elections today. In 1789, there were no official candidates. There was no campaigning
for the office. There were no political parties, no nominating conventions, no primary elections.
The entire election season was very short, and the major issue of this election was the
Constitution itself. Whether the very system that they were using as the basis for the election,
whether they would keep the system. Okay, well you might be thinking,
why were they electing a president for the first time in 1789? Didn't they declare independence
in 1776? What were they doing for those 13 years? Well, they didn't have a president during those
13 years. It's important to remember that the United States of America was not originally
a single country. It was a collection of 13 separate countries. The 13 colonies that were
participating in the rebellion had each been separate from each other, distinct colonies,
with ties between themselves and Britain, but not really ties amongst themselves, between the
different colonies. So when the 13 colonies declared their independence, they did so not as a single
unified country, but as 13 separate countries in association with each other. What we would
call an international organization, in order to accomplish their common goal of freeing themselves
from British rule, there was only one branch of government, effectively, on the federal level,
which was the Continental Congress. Although to call it the federal level is a stretch,
because there wasn't a federal government, so to speak. Anything that the Continental Congress
decided to do had to be enforced by the states, and if a state did not want to enforce it,
they didn't have to. Some people, at the time, saw this as a problem, and they thought that the
states would be better off if they entered into a closer union with each other. This was mainly
for financial reasons, but I'm not going to get into that. So they held a constitutional convention
in Philadelphia in 1787, in which they drafted the constitution that we use today in the United
States. Now this new constitution was different from the way it had been before. So under the old
system, you had one branch of government, the Continental Congress. In this new system, there
were three branches of government. There was the legislative branch, the executive branch, and the
judicial branch. The legislative branch would consist of Congress, but now Congress would have
two separate houses. A house of representatives, which would represent the people directly,
and the senate, which would represent the states. And then the executive branch would be headed by
a president, and then under him would be everyone who is in charge of executing the laws passed by
Congress. And then the judicial branch was headed by the Supreme Court, and then there would be
various courts underneath the Supreme Court. So one of the questions that the framers of the
constitution had to answer was, how are they going to get the president chosen? Now one obvious
choice would be to have him chosen by Congress. That would essentially make it a parliamentary
system. Like in most English-speaking countries, there's a parliamentary system where parliament
decides who the prime minister is going to be, and the prime minister runs the government.
The framers of the constitution did not want to do that. And by framers, I mean the men who met
in Philadelphia in the summer of 1787 and drafted the constitution. They're called framers, the
framers. They didn't want to do that. They wanted to maintain a strict separation between the
executive branch and the legislative branch. So that was off the table. So how else could
they elect the president? Well, one option, which is the option I think most Americans today would
take for granted, was that the president would be elected directly by the voters. The framers
of the constitution also didn't like that idea. They thought that would be not practical to do
that, and also not wise. So the framers hit upon another system that was neither of those two
things. What they would have would be the famous electoral college. This body of individuals
who exist within the executive branch, so you don't have to worry about cross-contamination
with the legislative branch, and the electoral college's only job was every four years they
would elect the president. Now how do you choose the members of the electoral college?
Well, they just left that up to the states. However the states wanted to do that. If the state
legislature wanted to choose their electors, they could do that. If the state legislature wanted to
leave that up to the voters to decide, they could do that too. So the American presidential election
has two stages. First, you have to choose the electors, and then once the electors are chosen,
they choose the president. That's still the system that's used in the U.S. today,
and when Americans go to the polls in early November of an election year, they're voting
for electors. And then the electors meet, nowadays it's in the middle of December,
and they cast their votes for president, and that's the actual election of the president.
So what we call election day is actually the election of the electors. The Constitution
gives Congress the power to decide when each of those elections happens, when the electors are
elected and when the president is elected. Nowadays it's early November and mid-December.
In this first election in 1789, the election of electors happened on January 7th,
and then the electors would meet and choose the president on February 4th, 1789. So election day
in 1789 was January 7th. That was what we would call election day. Now some online sources will
say that this particular presidential election happened over two years, 1788-89. It's not quite
true. The election was January 7th, 1789. It was just in 1789. Where that's kind of true is in two
states, in New Hampshire and Massachusetts. They actually had a two-stage process for choosing
their electors. They would have voters essentially nominate who they would want to have as electors,
and then the state legislature would choose from a list that the voters sent up to the legislature.
So in both New Hampshire and Massachusetts, the voters went to the polls. Polls isn't the right
word. The voters went to their town meetings and voted for who they'd like to be elector,
and then those names went to the state legislature. And on January 7th, the state
legislature picked from among those that list. But in the other states that participated in the
election, it was just January 7th, 1789. Now there were 11 states that participated in the election
of 1789. Rhode Island and North Carolina had rejected the Constitution and therefore were
technically not part of the United States and not participating in the election.
In five of the states, the state legislatures chose the electors. In four of the states,
the electors were chosen directly by the voters. And then in two other states, they had a hybrid
system. Now let's take a minute and look at the states that did direct elections, because they did
it differently in the different states. In Pennsylvania and Delaware, they had statewide
elections. Meaning in Pennsylvania, wherever you were in the state, if you were voting in the
election, you voted for 10 names. And then the top 10 vote getters statewide would become elector.
Delaware did the same thing, but they had three electors. So wherever you were statewide,
you voted for three names. In Maryland, it was also statewide. Everybody wrote down eight names
because Maryland got eight electors. But Maryland had a rule where five of the names had to come
from the western shore and three of the names from the eastern shore. Virginia did it a little
bit differently because the Virginia legislature actually created electoral districts. Virginia got
12 electoral votes, and so the legislature divided the state up into 12 electoral districts. Each one
would elect one elector. And these were distinct from the 10 congressional districts that Virginia
had. Virginia was the only state to do it this way. So looking at the different states and the way
they did it, that reflects the politics of the different states. So Pennsylvania, for example,
the Pennsylvania legislature was dominated by Federalists, meaning people who were pro-Constitution.
Support for the Constitution tended to be stronger in the cities, so they thought by making it a
statewide ballot, it would make it more likely for Federalists to be elected as elector. The Virginia
legislature was dominated by Anti-Federalists, people who were opposed to the new Constitution.
And they wanted to improve the rural vote, and so they drew districts to make it more likely
that rural people would be elected as electors, and rural people were more likely to be opposed
to the Constitution. And this touches on the big issue of the presidential election that year,
which was the Constitution itself, whether the Constitution was even a good idea.
It was extremely controversial in a way that I think most Americans today probably don't
really realize. There were a lot of people who were opposed to the Constitution at the time,
and the passage of the Constitution was quite controversial in several states. Some Americans
felt like the Constitution was a betrayal of the goals of the Revolutionary War. They felt like
they had traded one tyranny for another. They'd gotten rid of the tyranny of the British Parliament
and the British monarchy, and they now were instituting a new tyranny of a new Federal
system. A lot of Americans, especially in rural areas and out in the western areas, were afraid
that this new Federal system would be opposed to their own interests, that the Federal government
would be dominated by commercial interests from the port cities, and would make policy decisions
that would financially benefit the big port cities and disadvantage rural areas. In fact,
this controversy between those who favor the Constitution and those who are opposed to it
ended up making it so that New York could not participate in the presidential election at all,
because the New York legislature was divided. The upper house, the Senate, was majority
Federalist. The lower house, the Assembly, was majority Anti-Federalist. So the Senate,
which was 10 to 8 in favor of the Constitution, wanted each house of the legislature to choose
four of New York's eight electors. The Senate would choose four, and the Assembly would choose four,
and that way four of New York's eight electors would be pro-Constitution.
The Anti-Federalists wanted the legislature to decide on the electors as a whole. So each
member of the legislature would get one vote. They would have one slate of eight.
Essentially, they would choose them in a joint session of the two houses. What that would mean
practically is that all eight of New York's electors would be anti-Constitution. So the
Assembly would pass a bill saying, this is how we're going to choose our electors. It would go
to the Senate. The Senate would say, no, we're not going to do it that way. They would pass their own
bill that would go back to the Assembly, and the Assembly would turn it down. It went to
conference committee. They argued over it. Couldn't come to a resolution. This went on for weeks.
Then January 7th came, and they were deadlocked. So midnight, January 7th,
they still hadn't chosen their electors. That was it. So they did not have electors. The same
gridlock meant that New York had no senators, because it was up to the state legislature to
choose senators. So it took them until I think the summer of 1789 to finally decide who their
senators were going to be. A similar thing actually happened in New Hampshire, because New Hampshire's
legislature was also divided in a similar way. But in that case, the anti-Federalists in the lower
house of the New Hampshire legislature gave in and agreed to the Senate's terms. So New Hampshire did,
and it was very close to midnight when they made that compromise, so New Hampshire did end up
participating in the election. Now this business of whether an elector was pro-Constitution or
anti-Constitution, what was that about? The Constitution ended up getting approved in these
11 states, but there were a lot of people who were uncomfortable with it, and so what they hoped they
could do was get a second convention. That's what they wanted to have. They wanted to get a second
constitutional convention that would draft a different constitution that would be more acceptable
to the anti-Federalists. Barring that, they could at the very least get elected to positions within
the federal government and then undermine the federal system from within, and thereby prevent
the full weight of the federal government from coming into force, perhaps make people disillusioned
with the federal system, and provoke them to agree to a new constitutional convention. Another thing
was if you get anti-Federalists elected to Congress, at the very least they could be clamoring
to get amendments. Now when the Constitution was approved in the various states, the pro-Constitution
people promised, which seems a little bit shady in retrospect, honestly, but they said, oh go ahead
and approve the Constitution now, we promise we'll adopt amendments later. So people were voting for
the Constitution with the promise in the future, it wasn't really binding, but with this
understanding that in the future amendments will be adopted, which ended up happening.
That was the Bill of Rights, which came into effect in 1791. But that was the idea of electing
anti-Constitution electors. They were hoping that if you get enough anti-Federalists as electors,
then they could cause problems for the presidential election. Everybody knew that
George Washington was going to become president. They knew that actually back in 1787, when they were
drafting the Constitution. George Washington was one of the Virginia's delegates, and he was
actually sitting there in the room while they're all talking about the president, and it was kind
of an open secret that they're creating this office, and George Washington's going to be the
guy they're going to put in that office first. So the Federalists were afraid that anti-Federalist
electors might mess up the election. And how would they do that? The framers of the Constitution
created the system where the electors would vote for two people for president, rather than one
person. And then the person who got the most votes would become president, and the person who got the
second most votes would be vice president. And the weakness of this system became apparent immediately,
because the way it's supposed to work is George Washington will get the most votes,
and then John Adams will get the second most votes. Then you get president, vice president. Great!
But what if George Washington does not get the most votes? What if he gets the second most votes?
What if some anti-Federalist electors decide not to vote for George Washington?
Maybe they vote for Adams, and then some other candidate, just some throwaway name.
They could potentially throw the election to Adams, making John Adams the first president,
and George Washington the vice president. Now the problem with that is Adams was not as popular as
Washington, especially in the South. And so that could reduce the goodwill that the general public
had for the federal government, right? And so that would help to undermine the federal government,
and therefore achieve the ends that the anti-Constitution people had. That was something
that the Federalists were afraid could happen. Or alternatively, another possibility would be if
there were enough anti-Federalist electors, they could get George Washington elected president,
and then an anti-Federalist elected vice president. Now among the anti-Federalists,
there were a few names, but I think the most common name that was bandied about at the time
was George Clinton. If you were an anti-Federalist elector, it was expected that you would end up
voting for Clinton. Maybe Washington Clinton, or maybe Adams Clinton. You know, you could do that.
So just to give you an example of a possible thing that could play out, the Federalist electors could
vote for Washington and Adams, and then the anti-Federalist electors could vote for Adams
and Clinton. And so then Adams ends up getting the most votes, Washington comes in second,
Clinton comes in third, that makes Adams the president, Washington the vice president.
Just as one example of many possible permutations of this. So the point is,
the system that was written into the Constitution was a bad system. Having the electors vote for two
names and not designate which one they wanted to be president, which one they wanted to be vice
president, was a flaw. And people at the time recognized that as a flaw. So remember there are
two stages of electing the president. First you get the electors, and then the electors choose
the president. So the electors were going to meet and choose the president on February 4th.
In the run-up to that electoral college vote, some political figures in the country
were trying to organize a system where they would make sure that Adams didn't get as many votes as
Washington. And the most prominent figure in this movement was Alexander Hamilton. He was
writing a ton of letters to different people. He was not the only one involved with this. There
were a few others also who were writing letters to different states, writing to the different
electors saying, make sure you don't vote Washington Adams. Make sure there are some guys,
you know, there who are going to vote for somebody besides Adams. So if you look at the results of
the 1789 election, you look at the electoral college votes, it looks like, you know, everybody
voted for Washington, and then a bunch of people voted for Adams, and then there were a bunch of
small vote totals for other people. A lot of those votes were deliberate throwaway votes where they
would have voted for Adams, but deliberately chose not to vote for Adams because they were trying to
mitigate against a potential anti-federalist scheme. In Connecticut, they had seven electors,
five of them voted for Washington and Adams, two of them voted for Washington and Huntington.
The votes for Huntington were going to go to Adams. They voted for Huntington as part of
the scheme that Hamilton was organizing. In Pennsylvania, again, those two that voted for
Hancock would have voted for Adams. In Maryland, there were eight electoral votes. Two of the
electors could not actually make it to the election. The electoral college meets on a
state-by-state basis, so the electors in each state come together. In Maryland, the eight
electors were supposed to meet in Annapolis to do their voting. Two of the electors couldn't make
it. One of them was sick. He had gout and therefore couldn't travel. The other one was
unable to because of ice that blocked. I think he had to cross either the Chesapeake Bay or a river,
and it was filled with ice, and so he wasn't able to make it to Annapolis. Only six electors in
Maryland participated. All six of them voted Washington and Harrison. Harrison was chief
justice of the Maryland general court. He was not a national figure. They voted for him purely
as part of Hamilton's scheme to make sure that Washington came in first and Adams came in second.
They would have voted for Adams otherwise. Now, not all of these votes were like that. In some
of the states, the electors really were voting for someone besides Adams because they didn't
want Adams. They wanted somebody else instead. I think the votes for John Jay were like that. I
think the votes for John Jay were legitimately for John Jay. I mean, I did a lot of reading about
this, but I couldn't figure out exactly for every single state what the motivations were of the
electors. But if I were to guess, and this is based on incomplete research of the election,
I think the election would have looked more like this if there hadn't been so much strategic voting.
Now, this setup of the way the electors would vote for president, you know, voting for two
names and not distinguishing which one you wanted to be president and which one vice president,
this continued to be a problem in every presidential election after this until they fixed
it. And they finally fixed it in the 12th amendment where they said that electors will say
which one they're voting for president and which one they're voting for vice president.
The election results really hurt John Adams. I mean, he didn't have any expectation of being
elected president. He, like everyone else, expected Washington to get the most electoral votes, but
he didn't expect to get as few electoral votes as he got. And he felt kind of devastated by that.
It's kind of sad because it didn't have to happen that way. They didn't have to worry that the
Anti-Federalists would pull off a scheme because they didn't. All the fears about Anti-Federalist
shenanigans came to nothing. Washington easily got all 69 electoral votes and Adams wasn't going to
get more than him. You know, like there were enough people voting for Hancock and John Jay
and Rutledge to prevent Adams from tying with Washington. So it's kind of sad how that worked
out. But anyway, those are the election results. George Washington was elected president. John
Adams was elected vice president. They both traveled to New York which was the first seat
of the federal government and were sworn in in the spring of 1789 to begin their first terms
respectively. I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on this election. If you're an American,
do you think it'd be better or worse to have our elections the way they were back in 1789?
If you're not an American, how much better do you think your system is compared to
the original American system of 1789? I do plan on doing a follow-up video on the next
presidential election, 1792, when George Washington was re-elected.
So stick around for that. Thanks for watching!
