What are some ways to connect with your Chinese heritage when you feel very, very distant from it?
Yeah, it's quite simple. You just study for six to seven years to become fluent in the
Chinese language and delay your dopamine and oxytocin release.
No, I'll never be Chinese then!
We gotta talk about this thread. It's titled,
I'm half Chinese and I want to feel more connected to my culture.
But I think there's a lot of good takeaways for people who are even full or zero percent.
It's from Cherry Toad 39.
Andrew, she says her dad is Chinese American.
He's ABC. He's second gen.
Her mom is half black and half white.
So she's a quarter black, a quarter white.
She said she ended up looking Filipino.
Everybody thinks she's Filipino.
She is in college right now, so she's still quite young.
She went to her South Asian Indian boyfriend's Hindu Diwali celebration
and started just saying, man, it was super fun.
And it made me longing and envious in a melancholic way
to feel connected to my culture like that.
And I just don't know if I'm going to get accepted in the East Asian looking community.
Does anybody have any suggestions
or what to do to implement part of my culture into my life?
All right, everybody, we're going to try to help her and help everybody out there.
Obviously, we're two people who have created a lot of,
I guess you would say, Asian or Chinese or Chinese American content over the years.
So let's see if we can help.
Please hit that like button and check out other episodes of the Hop Hop Boys.
But real quick, a way to connect back.
Well, check out Smala Sauce.
It is a Chinese and Italian inspired chili oil.
Check it out, Smala Sauce.
Hey, man, from Sichuan to Sicily, I think it could help.
I mean, honestly, I guess what is she really asking here?
I think that in a way, humans are just always looking for identity, right?
Like this is a like there's so many scientific studies on it.
Humans are like tribal animals and they're looking for a tribe.
But not everybody necessarily makes it their ethnicity.
But it's one of the easiest things to do,
because that's the way the world treats you.
That's what you feel about yourself, right?
Right, right.
And I think her having the desire is already part of it.
That's a big step, because I mean, some people could easily be like,
well, I'm half Chinese, I'm mixed heritage, but it doesn't really matter.
And my dad doesn't really care about the culture.
She can lean into the white culture, the black culture,
because she's a quarter white and a quarter black.
Or she can just be in this general mainstream mixed culture, which is fine, too.
There's nothing wrong with that.
Yeah, but the fact that she does want to lean into the Chinese culture and experience it,
that's good.
That means there's a desire there and there's something to work with.
To me, I would say whether or however difficult you try to define being Chinese is,
because I think there's an argument to say that figuring out what it means to be Chinese
is more difficult than another Asian, perhaps that's arguable.
I would honestly, I'm not going to mince words.
It's for sure more complicated.
I think outside of having a general Middle Eastern identity,
and that's a whole different beast on its own,
I think being Chinese is the most complex singular group.
Because I think that India is also really large, Andrew, but it's also very demarked.
I guess like what tribe of Indian you are and how you're supposed to be if you're that tribe.
I think being Chinese is very, it can be very murky.
It's kind of open-ended and specific at the same time.
But anyways, what I'm going to say is that there's different tiers of leaning into your culture.
Now, I understand that she may not be because her grandparents have passed on
or her dad who's Chinese is not really into being Chinese.
So-
Yeah, like, you know, growing up, I didn't really think it was fun.
It didn't really make me like have an American type of Western childhood.
She said she wore shoes inside the house.
Whoa.
But anyways, there's different tiers.
I think top tier to the bottom tier to the easiest tier of like,
just watching memes and YouTube and sharing memes with your friends
about being Chinese and all the Asian memes.
But what if she doesn't even have enough information
or knowledge base to enjoy the memes?
Because there are like a ton of meme accounts on Instagram nowadays.
And it's interesting when people don't follow them.
You guys got to follow them.
I'll pop some of them up here.
But like, you're saying that she should just subscribe anyway.
Well, I think just watching general Asian-American content
to a lot of Asian-American content,
it does stem from some Chinese culture as well, right?
And then also second tier is just like,
then you take a language course and you put yourself around Chinese people.
You try to order at the restaurant and stuff like that.
And then the third tier is obviously, you know, you actually travel back to China.
But I'm saying for her, it's she's probably got to start more at the beginning
of just getting into Chinese content and being in Chinese spaces
and being at Chinese New Year events and stuff like that.
I think that if I was her, I would just shortcut it.
I would learn to say three things in Cantonese or Mandarin,
go to my nearest, you know, basically Chinese restaurant, speak it to the waiter.
Be super insistent.
Even if they come at you in English, English, English,
you make sure you only want to order Hap To Ha in Canto.
And once you get that confirmation where the waiter's like,
yeah, yeah, yeah, Hap To Ha.
Oh, wow, wow, wow.
Chinese so good.
That's going to be positive reinforcement.
It's going to be like, ping, dopamine up, serotonin up.
I have an identity.
Yes.
Use the waiters as Chinese class.
Yeah.
What do you want to order?
I want.
Can I get the Xing Chao Chao Mai Fun?
Oh, wow.
You speak Chinese.
Oh, OK, good.
Right, right, right.
It's going to be a great ping at that point.
I just think that, you know, that that's the best way I could say it,
because a lot of people, I think when they're asking this question,
they want it, but they don't.
They just want to go to a Diwali like festival.
Here's the truth.
Chinese, it ain't like Indian culture.
Daisy culture releases more oxytocin.
Yes.
In a physical like methodology than Chinese.
Yes, yes.
They dance.
If you're thinking about like a Chinese dance club, those are hard to find.
Well, it's going to be like ballroom dancing.
Right, right, right.
But there is a lot of like Indian dances.
So I think when she's comparing it to India, I think that it's tough because already we have
to be like, OK, you got to compare it to other East Asia.
Right.
She probably got the henna tattoos on her hand.
And she did all this and put the paint face paint.
I was like, yeah, go find it.
It looks fun.
You're not going to find it.
So but that's it ain't so just be born.
It's not as colorful as Diwali in like South Asia.
That's because you guys just don't know about the ancient.
Where in China are you throwing paint on each other?
Yeah.
Because I think that people are like, oh, yeah, but we have a you can go to Shen Yun
or something like that, obviously, you know, whatever that is.
But it's like it's like when you participate in a Diwali festival or a Indian wedding,
it's more like you are part of Shen Yun, like one of the acrobats,
like you're not like just spectating.
Anyway, let's get in the comments section.
Somebody said somebody recommended that I immediately watch Joy Watch,
Quiz Lady and Past Lives.
And someone said, yes, Past Lives is Korean-American,
but it's still very relevant to the Asian-American experience.
Joy Ride was also about a Korean girl, but I guess she was playing Chinese in the movie, right?
Do you think that this is more at the level of what she really realistically should watch?
No, this is like hyper-Americanized.
This is like the super base level.
I think you can consume Chinese or Asian-American content,
such as some of our videos, things Asian parents do.
Our stuff is more cultural than even everything everywhere all at once, right?
Yeah, I mean, either way, just consuming material
that is written by Chinese-Americans or Chinese people,
whether you watch Disney's ABC series, American Born Chinese, or you watch all these,
you can find something that relates to you.
The thing about being Chinese is that,
although maybe Chinese culture is kind of hard to sum up,
there's a lot of Chinese people and a lot of Chinese culture, so you can't miss it.
There is no excuse in saying, well, I can't find any.
I can't meet any Chinese people.
That's not the struggle in being Chinese.
It's just not hyper-organized with an easy pop cultural in, though.
You know what I'm saying?
Yeah.
It's not like set up that way.
It's like, because some people are going to be like,
oh yeah, Chinese culture is the ancient society or the poems
that were written in a pagoda in Hangzhou.
I think for her, if they're American and already only half Chinese,
they just got to think about what other Chinese-Americans do.
Watch Joy Ride.
Don't, don't.
It's not about becoming a Chinese person from China, okay?
Listen, I get it.
The international kids or the fobs and the immigrants.
You're saying that she's not going to become Zhuge Liang.
No, you don't.
Like, don't.
Just listen to your Chinese-American friends that you know.
Somebody said a more deep cut one.
And by the way, she's a female.
So it's not like, oh yeah, you need to watch Warrior and all these,
you know, the Kung Fu, Jackie Chan stuff.
It could be a little bit, you know, that's for guys.
Somebody said check out Three Body Problem on YouTube.
Netflix is remaking it.
And that was actually a gray market book from China.
Three Body Problem.
Yeah, I think maybe, yeah.
I mean, there's like a lot of lists of movies
that you could just watch in a lot of content.
We'll just pop up some of them.
Like, I mean, I feel like that's like a starter pack
or that's like a, yeah, a starter kit.
Right.
And you're saying if you just enjoy some of those or you listen,
you just, I always say just celebrate Chinese New Year
while listening to the Higher Brothers song, Gong Xi Nian.
But then like Gong Xi Nian, Gong Xi Nian Fa Cai.
I was like, why not?
There's just something that's from the American culture,
but with Chinese culture.
No, I think you can listen to Chinese rap.
And if you like Chinese rap, then that's a still start.
Anything is a start at this point.
Somebody said begin learning Chinese.
Read about Chinese history and culture from non-bias,
but non-biased or non-Western sources.
Move to China.
At least start visiting.
Start consuming Chinese media.
Learn to cook Chinese food.
Learn about where your Chinese parents come from in China,
probably Guangdong.
Somebody said pay attention to deep culture,
not just surface culture.
Look for a Chinese boyfriend
of all these other things fall apart.
All right.
First of all, this would work, but this is, it's just.
This is not wrong, but this is like way just like,
this is too much.
Like it's not applicable advice.
I guarantee you the guy who wrote this is born in China.
I just feel like that's like a person from Asia
that wrote that.
Somebody said, what about getting Chinese friends?
And my whole thing about this is like,
not all Chinese Americans
that are actually full-blooded Chinese,
actually not all of them even know anything
outside of what they were born into.
Yeah, that's why I think the easiest thing you do
is look up memes and share them
with the Chinese people that you know
and see what they say,
because then you're gonna know
how much that person is into it.
Sometimes when you're just passively friends with people,
you don't actually know how deep in their culture they are.
And then you get them talking and then you're like,
whoa, you know all this about Chinese culture
and Chinese history,
and you thought about it this much.
And they're like, yeah, you know,
I do this on the side, blah, blah, blah.
But you know, in our friend group,
I don't really talk about it
because it doesn't seem like anybody else wants to talk.
Are you referring Andrew to possibly
some of the provincial stereotype memes?
No, I mean, it doesn't even have to be that deep cut.
I just think of just-
Chinese American creators, art content,
CantoMando, or like there's a bunch of Chinese-
You're not even talking about the China, China content.
No, no, no, no.
I'm not even talking about the Chinese material.
I mean, I think that is a step above,
you know, to appreciate Chinese art and products from China.
But that's like, that's actually, I think,
beyond where this person needs to start.
Yeah, right, right, right.
She needs to even identify who is the right person.
Yeah, even identify who of your friends
is even into being Asian.
Yeah, somebody said,
why don't you spark up a discussion with your dad?
Maybe even he doesn't like Chinese culture
because he felt like it led to his childhood
being unjoyful or not fun or isolated.
He at least liked Chinese food, right?
Do you think that's true?
Like, even if the-
Because Andrew, it's true.
A lot of people got issues
with stereotypical Chinese upbringings.
But even Americanized Chinese food is fire.
All right, first step, first step.
If you're watching this,
first OP was Strawberry Toad, whatever the name is.
Cherry Toad, yeah.
Cherry Toad.
Tell your dad to go to a Chinese restaurant.
Like, take the family out to a Chinese restaurant,
an authentic one.
Google, Yelp it, right?
What's the most authentic Chinese restaurant
within my city?
You guys go there.
Go to the Chinatown, if there's a Chinatown nearby.
Just go and experience that together as a family.
And then you can talk to your dad about it there
and bring it up.
I think that's an easy place to do it.
Or just see how your dad reacts.
I mean, just enjoying food together as a family
is literally the first step.
Right.
This guy said,
I think it's really important to even know
just what part of China your family's from.
It's really big and really, really diverse country.
And someone from Sichuan is gonna speak a different language
and eat completely different from somebody from Guangdong
to the point where it can feel like
they almost have nothing in common culturally.
So having a convo with your dad about family history is key
because he's the only one who will know those details
about your heritage.
And then maybe instead of trying to learn
the entire China history,
which actually I have gone on a journey to do.
And I'll tell you this,
it does take years of work,
but you just learn like that city or that province
or that immigration wave that your family stems from.
I think that's a not a bad place to start
because it gives you a focus and a starting point.
But I wouldn't say that nowadays,
you think all Chinese people don't have a thread in common.
I mean, obviously with me.
No, I think nowadays China in a way,
it's almost like more shared culture than they ever have.
But I would say a lot of grandparents in China,
they struggle to relate to each other.
I think finding out specifically
where your Chinese roots are from
gives you a sense of identity.
At least, you know, like, oh, I'm not just vaguely Chinese.
I will tell you this.
If you identify as vaguely Chinese,
it's a little bit difficult.
But don't you think,
and this is a whole different way
to feel some sense of humanistic identity.
She could just identify as Pan-Asian
because I feel like even a lot of full Chinese Americans
only identify as Pan-Asian.
Because it's easier too
because there's such a Chinese diaspora,
to be honest,
don't get offended guys,
but just like,
it's probably the one country in Asia
that is in every other country.
Well, the type of people, yes.
Or the cultural, ancient cultural influence,
the Sinosphere or whatever.
I would say before you even become Pan-Asian though
and you reach that level,
I feel like you still need to know where you're from.
I think so.
Because that gives you an identity.
But from that,
like what she knows that her parents,
her grandparents are from Guangzhou
or like Taishan or Shanghai, Zhejiang, whatever, right?
Then she knows,
okay, my parents, my grandparents are that,
but I identify with other all types of Asians.
Right, right, right.
It's almost like I identify as the Bellagio Pan Global Buffet,
but I know what part that I brought to the Bellagio.
It's in the Bellagio.
It is in the Bellagio,
even though it serves all different types of Asians.
This person said something really interesting.
Yeah.
Well, the thing is you can pick Asian American culture,
but Asian American have no culture.
For example,
Latins have salsa music, dance.
K-pop is just some version of American pop music.
A true Chinese culture is like
So basically,
yeah, that is like what you will have to learn
to be the true Chinese.
What do you think of this ancient argument?
This is a Chinese-ass argument.
They have a point.
They have a point that Asian American culture
is still forming, right?
I would say-
Some people think it's just bobas
and being wholesome.
Yeah, maybe Asian Americans don't particularly have
a style of dance that they do.
That's fine,
but they have food.
Asian American food is legit.
I think that's a legit thing that is recognizable now,
but-
You're talking about the fusion or the-
Boba even,
like, you know, to be honest,
the way we drink boba,
it is like,
even though it comes from Taiwan,
it's like kind of,
like the way we do it in America is a little different.
You don't think that Asian,
like Jabbawockeez is Asian American culture
or like Cabo Modern and all this-
No, I think that's part of it,
because what is Latin American culture?
What do you mean?
Of course, Latinos in Latin America have their culture,
but what is Latino American culture?
That's why any dash American people
have to take from the motherland.
You're talking about hyphenated second gens, right?
Hyphenated second generation immigrants
still have to take a lot of notes
and culture from the motherland.
That makes sense though.
But I would say that Asian Americans,
they mostly take food,
but not as much the styles of dress or dance.
Yeah, I don't know what Asian American,
like clothing necessarily looks like.
Yeah, it's more just like American clothing
made by Asians or with Asian imagery on it.
Yeah, somebody was just saying,
like, don't put too much pressure on yourself.
Maybe just join the CSA at school
because she's at college.
Do all the other things too.
I think joining CSA is just helpful
in putting yourself around Chinese people.
It's not a Chinese class though,
so they're not going to be talking about it.
But there is going to be people in CSA
that do know more about Chinese culture,
so that's a good way to meet friends
who are interested in Chinese culture.
I think taking a language class-
But even in a CSA, it's pretty variable, right?
Some people are like,
hey guys, can we study like Qin Shi Huang
and how he united the kingdoms?
And then other people are just like,
Boba night, like dumpling making.
Yeah.
Which is not wrong either way.
It's just like different.
But I think that's fine.
I think that ultimately just being in a space
where other people are interested
in Chinese culture is important.
So whether that's taking a language class
or joining CSA, I think that's super legit.
Somebody just said,
be comfortable in your own skin
and the sum of all the cultural influences
that made you who you are.
But obviously, if you're missing
some of those cultural influences,
go and seek them out.
Go and seek out food.
You know, just know that food can be remixed
just like you can be remixed.
You know how like people
have like westernized certain dishes.
Even the Neurozhuangbing
is a westernized version
of a literally a Shandong
like green onion wrap without the beef.
I don't agree that just because your family
didn't raise you with a lot of Chinese culture
that you can't lean back into it
and become more Chinese as you get older.
I think that that's, it's still possible.
It requires some work,
but it's not like saying,
because what if someone grew up
in a culture that they didn't like?
They never wanted to be that.
Then what?
You're telling somebody
that they're stuck with that,
that they have to be that no matter what.
Right. You can download Xiaohongshu too
and like really take a look
at what's happening in modern China.
Like I said, I do not think that like,
it's not going to be like being,
in my opinion, daisy people.
Oftentimes it's an ethno-religious group
because it's heavily tied with a religion.
I think that Korean and Japanese people,
they are, those countries
and their histories are way more homogenous,
you know, and so it's easier to understand.
I think China is like super layered.
It's been conquered by foreign powers
multiple times, like Mongolians, Manchurians,
even internally within Han people.
It's like very unclear
what the movement pattern was
and stuff like that.
So I think that even full Chinese Americans
struggle with this question, right?
Yeah, all the time.
I think identity is difficult
and it just requires-
Especially when you're from a more complex,
heavily layered identity, right?
Just requires a lot of conversations too.
Yeah, I mean, anyway, guys,
I think at the end of the day,
there's no real right or wrong answer.
I agree with everybody who wrote different things.
I think everything would work,
but at the end of the day,
Andrew, for Cherry Toad,
it's depending on what she's going to execute on, right?
Yeah.
And how those projects that she executes on
ultimately digest or marinate within herself.
Dude, I mean, there's just a lot of opportunity out there
and don't be overwhelmed by it.
Just start small, start consuming the media,
meet some Chinese people,
have some initial conversations.
There's a lot of content out there.
Luckily that Chinese is the largest country in the world.
One of the oldest,
longest standing civilizations in the world.
Tons of content, tons of restaurants.
The opportunity is there.
Yeah, it's just, I will say this.
I will admittedly,
because China's modern culture is lagging,
I would say arguably two decades behind South Korea's
and maybe like four decades or three decades behind Japan's.
It does make it more difficult
because there's not that immediate,
like, you know what I'm saying?
Like hyper appealing into it.
Yeah, I mean, I think that there is no like,
it's tough to find like just a Chinese party
that you're going to love.
Or what about just doing Wushu
or doing Wing Chun with your friends?
It's like, nah, it's not, I'm just kidding.
Nah, yeah, if you're into that.
Just watch Zhang Zilei or Song Yadong or Zhang Weiming.
Just keep it moving because that does not exist.
Go to a Higher Brothers concert
when they come to the,
Chinese rappers are starting to do concerts in the US.
That's true.
Yeah, anyway, guys,
let us know what you guys think in the comment section below.
No real right or wrong answers on this one, to be honest.
I think it's just like ultimately
a lot of these things are applicable to anybody though.
I think an outside person trying to learn,
a half person trying to find their identity
or even a full person who didn't really do
a lot of additional research
beyond the life they were born into.
So anyway, guys,
let us know what you think in the comment section below.
Until next time, we're the Hot Bob Boys.
Check out SmileySauce at smileysauce.com.
Until next time, we out.
Peace.