noc19-me78-lec07

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 4, 2023
Mechanics of Vibratory conveying, Effect of Frequency, Track acceleration, Effect of track angle, Effect of coefficient of friction.
[Music]
[Music]
welcome back so I will like to remind
you that last time what we discussed is
the vibratory ball feeder and some
aspects of the bowel filter design so we
said that how the ball feeder works now
for the design basic thing is to design
the the inclination angle track
inclination angle and the vibration
angle these are the most important
things so we said that the vibration
angle is decided by the suspension
Springs and how the suspension Springs
hold the ball in the ball feeder so for
sliding up the track to occur as we said
because we have this this force diagram
so in this force diagram as you remember
we said that this is the total inertia
force which is MP mass of the part a 0 s
0 is the amplitude of vibration and the
Omega square Omega is the angular
frequency so this total inertia force
can be resolved into the two components
one component is along the track which
is MP a 0 Omega square and the cause
sigh ok sy is the angle between the
total inertia force and the line of the
track okay so in here the along the n
that is the normal force which is acting
on the part this will be similarly MP a
0 Omega square and the sine side alright
similarly we have the mass of the part
which is acting here as MP into G G is
the gravity and this MP g will be
resolved into two components along the n
component is the MP g and the cos theta
and along the f it is MP G sine theta so
if it is that in this case for sliding
up the track MP a 0 Omega square and the
cost side this component has to be
more because the part has to slide up
the track then the forces acting on the
other side and forces acting on the
other side will be F and the MGP and the
sine theta so therefore f plus MP G sine
theta this MP is zero Omega square cos
sy has to be more than that that's one
aspect of it now the F which is the
friction force because of the normal
force acting on the part this is mu s
into n we said n is the normal force and
the MU s is the static coefficient of
friction between the part and the track
so therefore this n we can substitute by
the MGP and the COS theta this component
minus this component which is mpa 0
Omega square and the sine side that is
what we have written here so n is
substituted by this and therefore the F
becomes this much all right so this
equation equation 1 this becomes that if
we put the value of F as this in this
case the equation one can be converted
to this form converted into this form
now from here if we simplify this will
be the condition is zero Omega square
upon G this has to be more than mu s cos
theta plus sine theta divided by cos I
plus mu s sine sign so this is the
condition for the part to slide up the
track that's one thing so similarly if
you resolve the components in the way
when the part is going down the track so
you will find out that this will be the
condition this will be very similar to
this only you can see that this sign is
- ok so this will be the condition for
the track - for the part - to move down
the track that means on the other side
well then we said that the operating
condition of the vibratory conveyor may
be expressed in terms of the normal
track acceleration and the normal track
acceleration we said as a 0 Omega square
sine sy because it is a normal Oh Meghan
square Omega once again is
the angular frequency and a zero is the
amplitude of vibration so this is the
normal track acceleration and the normal
acceleration due to gravity will be the
G cos theta all right
so therefore the N by G n becomes a zero
Omega square sine side divided by G cos
theta now if we substitute this in the
earlier equations then we will be
getting this so how it is getting let me
explain it to you we have this equation
a zero Omega square by G is more than
that that we are getting from here okay
this is the condition for the part to
move up alright and we have the N by GN
this is equal to this n by G n we got it
from here okay now if we substitute this
from here we find out that a zero Omega
square by G is equal to n by GN sine
saibai sorry cos theta by sine side okay
now we will come back to this and we'll
put this value here in this equation it
is zero Omega square by G we are
substituting by this alright and we are
getting that n by GN this has to be more
than this component so therefore and n
by G n this is the one that we said is
the not is the ratio dimensionless
normal track acceleration and this is
the way that I mean this is the
component by which we are defining the
performance of the ball fitter so n by G
n has to be more than mu s plus tan
theta divided by COTS I plus mu s this
is for the part to go up the track now
we have given an example that for MU is
equal to 0.8 and the inclination angle
is 3 degree and the vibration angle is
30 degree so you will be getting that
this is the equation alright and the
limiting condition for the forward
conveying Hawk to occur we are
rearranging this and we are getting this
so finally what we are saying is that
for small inclination angle track
inclination angle the tan psy has to be
more than the track inclination angle
divided by static coefficient of
friction
and sigh one second is the vibration
angle so meaning that if we know this
equation alright if we know this
inequality in that case if we know this
inequality in that case we can find out
that what should be the track
inclination angle for example given mu s
and the vibration angle what should be
the vibration angle if we have a track
inclination angle and the static
coefficient of friction this is the
advantage of deriving this equation as
we call this as the mechanics of
vibratory conveying okay now here for
sufficiently large vibration amplitude
the part will leave the track and hop
forward during each cycle what we were
saying is that it's the part which is
going along the track for sufficient
conveying velocity we have to have the
part to leave the track okay part has to
leave the track and hop hop like a frog
alright so that is that for that we need
require a large vibration amplitudes
now the condition for this to occur that
means when the part will live that means
the N has the normal force n has to be
equal to 0 this normal force when the
normal force is 0 the part is ready to
live it's not leaving yet it is ready to
leave all right so for n is equal to 0
from the figure you can find out that n
this will be this value minus this ok so
that's what we are saying that n is
equal to MP G cos theta minus MP a 0
Omega square and the sine side so when
this is equal to 0 the it is the
limiting condition for the part to leave
the track and the part will leave the
track when this is more than that okay
so if we do that if we rearrange this so
a 0 Omega square upon G this will be
more than cos theta divided by sine Sai
or from here you can say that n by GN
has to be more than 1
this is an important derivation because
this says that when the normal
dimensionless normal track acceleration
which is n by G n this has to be more
than 1 then only the part will leave the
track so for sufficient conveying
velocity we have to have the normal
track acceleration more than 1 this is
the condition here now let's discuss the
effect of frequency now the result of
the theoretical work says that the mean
conveying velocity VM is inversely
proportional to the vibration frequency
F now what do you call it as a mean
conveying velocity that means this is
the speed of the part along the track of
the vibratory bowel fitter and the track
is inclined one second and this is going
spirally along the inside wall of the
ball fitter so we need the large
conveying velocity because we need the
parts to be to be transmitted to the
exit of the ball feeder at a faster rate
so for mean conveying velocity VM this
is proportional to frequency this has
been found out theoretically and this
does mean that this is F into VM is
equal to constant means that the high
conveying velocity for high conveying
velocity so therefore we need the high
feed rates high conveying velocity means
the high feed rates it is desirable to
use as low frequency as possible because
F into VM is constant so if you are
increasing the VM so to make them
constant F has to be sufficiently low as
low as possible however since that track
acceleration must be kept constant this
result means a corresponding increase in
that track amplitude meaning we are
decreasing the frequency because we want
to increase the VM and F into VM have to
remain constant product of F into VM has
to remain constant so therefore one
option is to increase the track
amplitude this is the the conclusion of
the effect of vibration effect of sorry
effect of frequency that since F into VM
is constant so for higher
value of the conveying velocity VM we
have to use as low frequency as possible
and that does mean that we have to
increase the amplitude of track
amplitude of vibration next let's see
the effect of the track acceleration all
right track acceleration we mean that a
n by GN which is the normal track
acceleration I would like to remind you
that normal track acceleration is the
one which resides or defines the
performance of the ball fitter
now for the part to hop we said that n
by GN has to be more than one all right
at first now what is happening is as if
you see the curve this is actually the
experimental curve and this has been
this curve has been taken for angle of
inclination zero Degree for a flat track
and for the static coefficient of
friction as this is some I mean let's
say this is nyet near one ok now this
has been taken for the different
vibration angle 20 degree 40 degree and
60 degree and when we are increasing the
normal track acceleration as we can see
that F into VM which is in the in the y
axis that is the conveying velocity this
conveying velocity is increasing alright
in all these cases for any value of the
vibration angle whether it is 20 degree
or 40 degree or 60 degree with the
increase in the N by G n the conveying
velocity increases that is the first
conclusion that we can make from the
experimental curve which is shown here
now the second conclusion is that when
we are increasing let's say beyond one
point seven okay these curves are
actually saturating in the sense it's
actually not increasing anymore as the
increasing and order we are seeing for
the other values of the normal track
acceleration now what happens here is
that when the N by G n is more that
means the part is hopping more and more
okay
now if it is going beyond one
it starts hopping and more than one up
to let's say 1.7 it is hopping more and
more initially when it is let's say just
crossed one it is hopping and coming
back to the track and the impact
velocity is not very high but beyond one
point seven of the N by GN value it goes
up so much hops high and then impact
velocity will be accordingly higher and
by landing on the track of the ball
fitter it actually topples it becomes
erratic okay so therefore the conveying
velocity does not increase anymore so
this is the this is the conclusion that
we can say that we have to limit the N
by GN to up to a certain value beyond
which the part will be unstable here it
is written the part starts to hop as n
by GN more than one that we have seen
earlier at first the velocity of impact
as the parts land on the track is small
but as the track acceleration is
increased the impact velocity also
increases until at some critical value
the parts start to bounce now what we
say as the critical value it also
depends on the mass of the part it
depends on the track it depends on the
material of the part and the track
material so depending on all those
factors this this can be somewhere
between 1.6 1.7 up to 2 it has been seen
in the practice so these are the
critical values depending on type of the
part depending on the type of the track
depending on the bow fitter that you are
using overall okay this is the effect of
track acceleration so once again summing
up increasing that and the normal track
acceleration increases the conveying
velocity up to a certain level after
that it is unstable okay next is the
effect of vibration angle so let's see
what happens as the vibration angle is
increases here it is x axis is the
vibration angle y axis is the conveying
velocity F into VM by the way conveying
velocity is given in Hertz
inch per second so
is an American system because the data
given by the American authors so
therefore it is in spy system in India
of course it will be centimeter or meter
per second so this is the the the
frequency F it is in the Hertz and inch
per second or centimeters per second and
meter per second is the VM so F into VM
this is in the y axis and x axis has the
vibration angle so for different values
of static coefficient of friction
starting from 0.2 to 0.6 you can see
that as the vibration angle is
increasing the conveying velocity is
increasing and after that it is actually
decreasing okay for 0.6 for 0.4 as well
as 1.2 it is well now it can be
explained by the same phenomena as we
have seen earlier for example for this
case that as the frequencies increase as
the vibration angle is increasing so
this n by GN increases and it is
actually getting the impact well in
higher impact velocity velocity zone so
therefore the F into VM conveying
velocity decreases so therefore these
curves also show that there is there is
an optimum vibration angle for a given
condition for example if we have the MU
is equal to 0.6 this static coefficient
of friction is 0.6 in that case the
maximum conveying velocity can be
obtained somewhere around 10 degree of
the vibration angle C for example if we
have the 0.4 for example then this
maximum velocity could be somewhere
around 30 degree or 30-something degree
so this is how we can actually
experimentally find out the curves and
we can find out what would be the
optimum value of the vibration angle so
that we can accordingly design the
suspension Springs and we can
accordingly select the electromagnet for
the ball fitter now these curves are
made for a track and inclination angle
of 4 degree and the normal track
acceleration as that
1.2 okay next let's say effect of track
angle okay so this is the track
inclination angle in the x-axis and
y-axis as always its output so this is
the conveying velocity in Hertz inch per
second it is given and the curves these
are experimental curves taken for the
vibration angle of 20 degree and the
static coefficient of friction as point
two okay and for different values of
normal track acceleration starting from
from 0.5 0.7 point 9 and so on up to 1.5
we have seen the effect of the track
inclination angle as we are increasing
the track inclination angle what
happened happens to the conveying
velocity find one thing here in these
curves that this is the zero conveying
velocity above that there is a positive
conveying velocity below that the
conveying velocity is negative there is
no conveying velocity upwards it's
coming back so therefore let's see what
happens for a very small track angle
let's say somewhere up to this for
maximum of track in clear so maximum of
N by G n is equal to one point five we
have the positive F into VM positive
conveying velocity but see here what
happens is one thing you can actually
conclude from these curves that for the
lower track angle that is zero degree
the conveying velocity is maximum this
is one conclusion that can be drawn from
here second conclusion is that for the
as the track angle is increasing to the
higher level let's say maximum of five
and above there is no conveying velocity
which is positive and all the other
conveying velocity will be below zero
which is that means backwards this is
negative now from here there is one more
thing which is very important that the
parts will be going from the below to
thee and it will be riding above the
track above the track so on the ground
well the track angle is zero and for the
mechanical design of the track we have
to give some angle because it has to be
inclined so normally it is actually 3 to
4 degree the design that is the track
angle inclination track inclination
angle
so therefore what happens is that at the
ground level the velocity the conveying
velocity will be maximum because here
the curve shows that at a zero Degree
that is the from the track angle is zero
which is flat the conveying velocity is
maximum but when the parts will be
riding above the ground level above the
flat that is the incline level there the
track inclination angle increases and
therefore the parts behind those parts
which have gone up the parts which are
located at the ground level at a zero
degree inclination angle they will
actually push the parts above that you
understand what I said
there is a pushing effect from the parts
which are which are at the ground level
because there the track inclination
angle is zero degree they will push
those parts will push the parts above
and sometimes it may actually jam if the
track is filled up with the parts the
parts at the ground level can actually
push and they it can a jam at the exit
or in between on the tracks if there are
some orienting devices that we'll
discuss later on those orienting devices
can be jammed by the parts which are
pushing which are at the flat level of
the of the track here it is I'll read
this the highest velocities are always
achieved when the track angle is 0
degree from here it can be seen as the 0
degree the tracking the maximum F into
VM could be achieved the mechanical
design of bowel feeder necessitates a
positive track angle of 3 to 4 degrees
because the track is the inclined as I
said in order to raise the parts to the
ball outlet
therefore the parts located at the
bottom having zero degree track angle
will push the other parts on the track
where the
angle is more than zero and this may
create the jamming at the outlet or
jamming at the orienting devices as I
said so this is a very important
phenomena because we have to find out
that how these drag angles could be
designed from this concept point of view
let's say what is the effect of the
coefficient of friction so overall if I
say if I don't even look at the
experimental curves we can say that if
the coefficient of friction overall is
increasing between the track and the
part the conveying velocity will be
higher that is one conclusion that we
can make okay because it's a rougher
surface so there will be less sleep it's
not smooth and if the track is very
smooth then the part can slip and the F
into VM can decrease let's see what
happens experimentally here we have the
coefficient of friction in the x axis we
start from point two and it goes up to
one coefficient static coefficient of
friction and in the y axis we have the
definite ovm conveying velocity in hertz
inch per second and we have taken zero
50 100 150 up to 250 of positive
conveying velocity so these curves
experimentally again have been taken for
a zero Degree of track inclination angle
and twenty degree of the vibration angle
so these curves have been taken for
different values of the normal track
acceleration starting from 0.5 0.7 0.9
up to 1.5 all right so first thing that
we can see is that as the coefficient of
friction is increasing the conveying
velocity increases so this is a normal
thing because it is the less smoother is
the track and it can facilitate the
parts to go up if the coefficient of
friction is increase increased now for
practical values of track acceleration
and increase in coefficient of friction
leads to an increase in the conveying
velocity that's one thing hence
increasing of static coefficient of
friction by coating the track with
robber is justified coating can also
reduce the noise level due to the motion
of the parts see as I said the parts are
moving not just sliding over the track
minded it's actually hopping and landing
on the on the on the track again but at
the same time it is going you know
forward so therefore because of that
impact velocity there is a noise okay
and to reduce the noise also you can
track the you can coat the track with
the rubber is doing two things one is
that increase increasing the coefficient
of friction and therefore the conveying
velocity increases but it is up to a
certain level as you can see of course
the coefficient of friction cannot go
beyond 1 so therefore up to 1 you can
see that the conveying velocity is
increasing for all values of the normal
track acceleration starting from 0.5 to
1.5 okay now another thing that you have
to consider that whether you are you
will be coating the track with the
rubber or not that also depends on what
kind of material you are using
combination of material you are using
for the track and the part so depending
on that you can you can actually decide
from the experience that what kind of
coating will be required the rest of the
things we'll discuss in the next class
thank you very much
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
