noc19-ee21 Lecture 31-Linear antenna-I

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Dec 3, 2023
Linear antenna, radiation resistance, current distribution, thin wire antenna, spherical coordinates, Maxwell's equations.
Hello and welcome to NPTEL MOOC on Electromagnetic Waves in Guided and Wireless Media.
We will continue our discussion of antennas.
I would like to just motivate this module by bringing up one of the results from the
last module, namely that of the radiation resistance.
Now recall that radiation resistance is how a circuit would look or how the circuit would
view the antenna as such, right, because the antenna is radiating power and that power
will be supplied by some source and the amount of power that is radiated would something
that the source would never get back, right.
So it is a power that is being lost, you know, as far as the source of the, you know, that
power is concerned.
So the voltage generator that you would have kept in order to feed the antenna.
As far as that voltage generator is concerned, this power that is lost or radiated by the
antenna is something that is lost from the perspective of the voltage generator, okay.
And that is the reason why we represent that power radiated by an equivalent resistance
and call that as radiation resistance, right.
So that resistance is how the voltage generator would look at an antenna.
So regardless of what antenna type that you consider, you can, of course with some approximations
that we have been, that we have not talked about, but there are lot of approximations
here, but you can with those approximations, you know, replace the antenna as far as the
circuit is concerned and then represent that one by a equivalent radiation resistance.
Now one of the things that you would like when you are using an antenna for transmitting
information from one point to, you know, another point, you know, by radiation would be to
maximize this amount of power that is being radiated.
So suppose I send in 1 watts of power from the voltage generator or the power generator,
transmit it through the antenna and if only like 1 milliwatt of the power is radiated,
then most of the power is either lost or rather most of the power is not being sufficiently
utilized in order to transmit information.
Yes, that power would be remaining within the source, but that is not what we want.
What we want is to maximize the radiation, that is, because unless I maximize the radiation,
then the receiving antenna cannot be kept at a very far distance.
We will see the relationship between the transmit antenna power or rather power density
and the receiving antenna and the distance between these 2 in order to get appreciable,
you know, signal at the receiving antenna later on, but it is kind of obvious from physical
intuition that if you only transfer a very small amount of power that is being fed to
the antenna and make it radiation, then that is not a very good antenna, right.
So what you want is a situation where the antenna radiation resistance should be larger,
right.
So one of the ways in which you can do this is what we are going to consider in this module
and we call this as a linear antenna.
Sometimes it is also called as a thin wire antenna or sometimes called as a linear wire
antenna and the length of this antenna will not be very small.
So in the case of a short elementary dipole that we considered, the length of that dipole
dz was considered to be very, very small compared with the wavelength.
Now we do not make that approximation and we will see that if the length is made appreciably
close to the wavelength of the wave that is being radiated by the antenna, then the radiation
resistance can be improved significantly, okay.
So with that in mind, let us look at what antenna that we are going to consider.
This is one of the more practical antennas, okay and this antenna is usually center fed,
meaning that the voltage generator that you have with appropriate, you know, internal
impedance would be connected via a transmission line to the antenna terminals, okay and then
connected to the antenna at the middle of this antenna terminals.
Of course, I have shown this gap to be very large, but in general, this gap would be very,
very small.
So a proper representation would have been something like this with the transmission
line connecting the antenna up here, okay.
The gap should be there, but the gap is considered to be very, very small, okay and we will put
some length here.
So if you consider this as the z equal to 0 point, then this fellow at the top portion
will be z equal to plus L and this one would be z equal to minus L and this is the antenna
part and this is the transmission line feed to the antenna and this of course is the voltage
generator that will be, you know, generating whatever the power that is necessary to feed
to the antenna, okay.
Of course, information will be residing in this voltage and it would be time varying
so that the current that the antenna would, you know, have, the antenna transmit, the
antenna current or the current on the antenna terminals will be dependent on what voltage
and transmission line feed that we are using, okay and because of this, you know, current
which is varying with respect to time, you will have this A field that is vector potential
and by calculating the vector potential, you can then calculate what would be the electric
field and the magnetic fields of this antenna as radiated away, right.
So that is where we would like to go.
So in the elementary short dipole or the short dipole that we consider, the elementary dipole
that we considered, we were particularly not worried about the current distribution on
the antenna terminals, right because we had this antenna itself to be very, very small
compared to the wavelength, we took the current to be constant over the entire antenna terminal.
So you had this antenna which was fed but then, you know, the current over which we
had considered to, was considered to be constant, so no matter at what point on the antenna
that you took, the current was essentially the same.
You could make this approximation because the length of the antenna was very, very small
compared to wavelength but now the situation is not like that.
The situation is that you have your length, the total length of the antenna is 2L as per
what we have considered here is actually comparable to wavelength of the fields that it is radiating.
So because of that, you cannot simply make the antenna current to be a constant.
So then that leaves us one big question, what is the current distribution, okay?
What is the current distribution on the antenna?
Now unfortunately for us, there is no specific answer because this problem is so difficult
that we have so far not been able to calculate or determine the exact current distribution
on the antenna terminals.
If you make this into an even more practical antenna and instead of assuming them to be
thin wires, you assume them to have some finite thickness because any material that you construct
will actually have, a copper wire will have some amount of finite thickness and the copper
will also not be a perfect conductor, there will be some losses in that one and if you
consider that more practical scenario, then finding the current distribution is almost
impossible.
In fact, it has not been possible for us to determine what the current distribution is.
So unlike that elementary dipole discussion, where we straight away started with J and
then we wrote down A and then we found out E and H, of course with lot of tedious mathematics,
that procedure unfortunately breaks down unless we make some approximations to the current
distribution.
In practice, what we do is we use lot of numerical techniques to obtain a better approximation
okay of the current distribution on the antenna terminal.
Why this current distribution is very difficult to determine which is one of the central problems
in antenna theory is something that you will have to learn in a different course on antennas
itself.
But for now, you can kind of motivate yourself to see that this particular antenna that we
have you know considered can be thought of as being you know starting off with a simple
tapered transmission line and eventually flaring up over right.
So you can think of this antenna as being starting off with a straight transmission
line and then as you start bending the 2 wires of the transmission line at different angles
and eventually reach 90 degree bend, then that would be the antenna that you would obtain
which we have called as a linear antenna right, a linear or a thin wire antenna.
And we know that because there is an open circuit at the ends right, the current distribution
has to be in such a way that you will have, so of course it has to depends on the length
that you have.
So for example, if the flaring length happens to be say lambda by 4 here and lambda by 4,
then this situation is actually originally corresponding to a transmission line whose
length here is about lambda by 4 right and that is what we have taken this length and
then bend it in this particular fashion.
So on an open circuit and you connect this transmission line, what would be the current
distribution?
The current distribution would be something like or the voltage distribution let us say.
The voltage distribution will be maximum at the open circuit right.
So in open circuit, yes it would be maximum and over lambda by 4, it would have reached
a minimum right.
So this would be the voltage distribution.
The current distribution of course would be minimum at the gap, but then it would reach
the maximum.
So this could be the current distribution right.
So this is the current distribution that you have considered.
So essentially if you think of now the 2 wires being bent and imagine that the length is
about lambda by 4 and lambda by 4, then the current distribution could be well approximated
in this particular manner okay.
So it could be, now if instead of lambda by 4, you make it lambda by 2, then what happens?
Then you should actually consider the fact that the current distribution would look something
like this.
So is this the correct answer?
Not really, but this is a very good approximation.
So as the length of the antenna increases, you will actually see minima maxima, but this
motivation which we have done it from the transmission line theory is only a motivation
okay.
Because it has been found that the current distribution is not exactly a cosinusoidal
distribution, but in some cases may even take a triangular distribution okay and you can
even in some very low approximation consider it to be a step or a pulse like approximation
okay or a square wave kind of an approximation.
But for analytical purposes, we either consider it to be a you know triangular wave or we
consider it to be a cosinusoidal waveform okay and we will assume that is the scenario
over here.
We will of course not write this as lambda by 4, we will keep it slightly general and
say that this is L and L, but then we assume that the current to be cosinusoidal okay.
So since we took this as the z axis, rather because this is the source coordinates, we
need to actually put a prime onto these coordinates which is correct.
So the distribution has to be maximum at the center and then it has to be minima at these
two points okay.
So with that, let us write down the expression for the current distribution.
So I of z prime which is how the current would be you know on this particular antenna that
would be equal to some I0 which is the maximum of the current times sin k L minus z prime
magnitude okay.
So I will tell you the reason why I am writing this as L minus z prime magnitude and then
I have sin of k L okay.
So at z prime equal to 0 which is at the feed point of the antenna, the current would actually
be equal to I0 and at z prime is equal to 0, you have sin k L by sin k L yeah the current
will be I0 and then it will go to 0 at the edges okay.
Of course k is in this particular case 2 pi by lambda and the actual result will depend
on L and lambda ratio as well okay.
So for one of the, so I should have probably considered this to be a lambda by 2 antenna
so that is why I have put this cosinusoidal distribution or a sinusoidal distribution
but this is the distribution that we are going to assume okay.
So at z prime is equal to 0, you have an antenna current of I0 which then goes to 0 at the
two edges.
But please understand that this is only an approximation, this is not the true current
distribution and true current distribution is a very complicated topic and there are
no solutions for the true current distribution or the exact current distribution okay.
With this current distribution that is a well approximated current distribution that we
have assumed, we can now proceed to the next steps.
Now I will minimize the mathematics here, I will leave most of it as an exercise for
you to figure it out but I will give you the expression for the electric field and tell
you couple of approximations that we are going to make because those approximations are necessary
to obtain tractable analytical expressions otherwise the mathematics becomes very tedious
and will be very difficult for us to you know look at that one okay.
I mean look at that in this short course okay.
So I know the current distribution to be given as z prime, the procedure next will be the
same.
The A field, the vector potential will actually be around I mean will be something like z
prime Az that is to say it has only the z component okay and we know the expression
for Az right, Az is given by mu 0 by 4 pi integrated the current distribution.
So you had this j dot ds or j ds but now this is a linear antenna so there is no area
here so it becomes instead of j times dv prime sorry that is the volume, now it simply becomes
current times dz prime okay and divided by r minus r prime, these are of course the observation
and the source point and you have a phase factor that would also multiply.
This is the retarded potential part that you are looking at and this is what you have the
expression for.
Now we know that this is the antenna that we are considering, this is the feed line
of the antenna.
So the source coordinate is moving along z prime but then the observation point that
I have which you know if I take this as the origin of the coordinates, this would be the
distance from the observation I mean from the origin to the observation point which
we will call as point P and at any point on the source the current is of course Iz prime
at this junction so which is at a length of dz prime.
This would be the radial distance r, r is the distance between the observation point
and the source point right.
So this is the observation point, source point and of course we are working still with the
spherical coordinates okay.
Now I have because I have defined this capital R as this magnitude that is this particular
line okay, this is the line that I am considering, I can simplify the expressions over here okay.
So first I will substitute the expression for I of z prime which is the current distribution
that we have assumed and that would be I0 by sin kL and then you have sin of kL minus
z prime okay.
The magnitude of z prime because z prime can go from minus L to plus L covering the entire
antenna region okay and along with this one there is a denominator r and then you have
e power minus jk r okay.
So this integrated over the source element from z prime which is from minus L to plus
L.
This if you perform this, this is what you are going to get.
Of course you can also see that there is some amount of symmetry into this problem in the
sense that as you move around the antenna if you leave out the gap part, if you move
around the antenna you will see that the current distribution would remain the same
right.
So if this is the antenna and you move the current distribution would remain the same.
So there is a phi invariance in this particular problem.
So moving along the azimuthal will not really change the distribution and that symmetry
is built into this problem because az is now function only of capital R okay.
Even then the problem is rather not simple to solve.
So we will have to make couple of approximations and this approximation is something that you
may have seen earlier in the dipole scenario okay but it is worthwhile to make that approximation.
See I am considering a particular point here at you know with a width of dz prime at a
height of z prime correct and then I also am going to consider you know similar point
which is at a distance of minus z prime from the origin but with a patch length of dz prime
itself that is the width is dz prime itself and now I am looking at the observation point
P here okay.
Now technically when I consider the point at z prime and dz prime width the R value
the capital R that I have considered let me call this as R plus okay and similarly I will
call this fellow as R minus okay and whatever that is from the origin to the observation
point of course is your distance R okay.
So I have 3 lengths and you obviously know that R plus or you can obviously see that
R plus is kind of larger compared to the small r and small r is smaller compared to sorry
R plus is smaller compared to small r and r is smaller to R minus meaning that R plus
is less than R which is less than R minus okay but imagine that my distance to the antenna
is so large that this entire antenna would essentially you know appear to me as a single
point.
Then what happens is that these lines which kind of converge at point P can instead be
considered to be 3 parallel lines okay they are 3 parallel lines of course because one
of them is at z prime dz prime the other one is at z prime equal to 0 and the other one
is at z minus z prime the lengths of these will be slightly different and if you move
the point P the distance as well as the orientation of these points move right.
So if this is your antenna point so let us say this is the R and as you move the point
P the orientation will change the orientation with respect to z axis which we will call
as angle theta will change okay so calling this as angle theta which is the angle between
the observation point P the radial line between the origin and the observation point P plus
this z prime dz prime patch that we have considered then if you approximate these 3 lines R plus
R minus and small r by 3 parallel lines you get you can simplify the analysis and what
you get is something like this.
So let us first write down the small r case and of course this will work only when you
have the point observation point P to be very very far away from the antenna so that the
antenna would essentially look like a point to you okay. Now I am going to assume that
this is you know parallel line and I am going to assume that this is also parallel line.
Now what is the relationship between these 3 lines? See if you look at R plus and small
r the only extra length that you have is this one right so this is the extra length that
you have. What is this extra length? I know that this is at a distance of z prime I know
that this length I mean you do not really need to know that length because you know
what is this theta and if you want to find out what is this extra length right so what
about cos theta? Cos theta will be this adjacent side whatever the length that you want to
find out so we will call that as say delta itself okay so delta divided by this would
be the hypotenuse right so that would be z prime.
So this will give you delta of z prime cos theta okay and therefore you can write R plus
as small r which is this length radial line minus z prime cos theta and similarly you
can convince yourself that R minus which is this fellow can be written as R plus z prime
cos theta okay so I can write in this particular manner so I am going to get this as R minus
z prime cos theta and R plus z prime cos theta okay. Now what is the use of this? See the
integral was actually going from minus L to plus L correct so all these integrals were
going from minus L to plus L now I can break this integral from 0 to L and then one integral
from minus L to 0 okay and in this integral I will have only the distances R plus involved
and in the second integral I will have the distances R minus involved but both essentially
look kind of symmetric and I can convert this integral from 0 minus L to 0 to 0 to L and
then rewrite the expressions for finding a z as I mean I will split the integrals of
course I 0 by sin k L is constant so I can pull this out so I have sin k L here and then
this integral is from 0 to L d z prime notice here that I still have z dependence in the
form of the current distribution so I do not have to now write magnitude z because this
is basically z prime positive only right and most importantly in the denominator this is
the source point that we have right and the source point is basically R minus z prime
cos theta e power minus j k R minus z prime cos theta okay.
You may think that we have not really simplified the problem because z prime is present in
the denominator z prime is present in the numerator luckily for us if the overall length
L is very very small compared to the radial distance from the observation point then this
z prime cos theta maximum value that it can have is L and L is very small compared to
R so in the denominator it does not really matter if I take this as R minus z prime cos
theta or I will just take it as small r okay so one of the approximation that I make is
the approximation in the denominator therefore I can you know or rather I will rewrite in
the same equation here so I can neglect this z prime cos theta because you know that is
very small compared to R okay. Can I do the same thing in the numerator unfortunately
no why because z prime whose maximum value will be L is actually comparable to the wavelength
lambda correct see you have k which is equal to 2 pi by lambda that gets multiplied to
z prime cos theta the maximum value of this one will be 2 pi by lambda times L and I cannot
neglect this because L is approximately lambda or in the range of lambda so that you have
a 2 pi I mean the factors are large in the numerator therefore in the numerator I cannot
neglect this okay so this is an important approximation and with these two approximations
your problem is kind of solved now because of course I have written only for 0 to L on
this side you have to write down similarly for the other one also so you will have instead
of e power minus jk R minus z prime cos theta you will have e power minus jk R plus you
know z prime cos theta so you can do that or you can just write down only over 1 L and
then write down the other part as well well I will complete the next step and after that
I will leave it as an exercise for you.
So at this step what I am interested is to write down this way I will move this R outside
the integral I can do that because R is not dependent on z and then I have sin k L this
is just a normalizing factor and now look at this exponential I can write the exponential
by splitting it I have e power minus jk R and I have e power jk z prime cos theta retain
this pull this outside the integral so you have e power minus jk R and integral of 0
to L dz prime the sinusoidal current distribution times this e power jk z prime cos theta right
so you have e power jk z prime cos theta integrated over this and this is what you are going to
get for the first integral.
Now there will be another integral which would be from minus L to 0 and you can use your
standard change of variables out there or you know interchange the orders and then get
a minus sign plus sign and then you can rewrite that expression I mean write down that expression
as well and we will call some of these as constants what you can do is you will have
that other integral from minus L to 0 with appropriately k L plus z prime remember that
L z prime is now negative here and then you will get e power minus jk z prime cos theta
integrated over d theta so you can reverse this order of you know variables from minus
L to 0 to 0 to L and add it to the same integral and then you can you know get a simplified
expression and integrate the whole thing and I will leave this as an exercise to you it
is just about 2-3 steps to show this one as mu 0 I 0 divided by 2 pi sin k L multiplied
by e power minus jk R divided by k R and you have cos k L cos theta minus cos k L divided
by sin square theta so this is the expression for a z that you get and from this you can
find out what would be h okay h is del cross a and e is basically obtained from h by writing
it as del cross h divided by j omega epsilon 0 these are of course Maxwell's equations
sorry b was actually equal to del cross a so b is basically mu 0 h so therefore h is
basically del cross a divided by mu 0 okay so you can find out the curl of this a z in
the spherical coordinate systems again the expressions will be slightly you know tedious
not difficult but it will be tedious requires you to write down the curl in the spherical
coordinates which normally we do not do but when you do all of that that is when you carry
out the calculation subsequent steps you can see that h will still be oriented along the
phi direction and it would be function only of R and theta no dependence on phi luckily
but it will be the direction will be phi but the component itself will be independent of
phi okay so this will be you can show this it would be ji0 divided by 2 pi sin kl and
then you have e power minus jk R by R and then you have cos of kl cos theta sorry this
is not sin square theta this is basically just sin theta okay so this is sin theta and
then you have kl cos theta minus cos kl divided by sin theta in the phi direction okay and
the electric field can be shown to be function of R and theta but this would be you know
in terms of its magnitude it would be eta times h phi and it would be oriented along
the theta direction okay now because h and e are both I mean h and e are oriented along
phi and theta e cross h will be theta cross phi and because theta cross phi will be along
the R direction okay so you can show that the power will be radiating in the R direction
which is or the radial direction which is what you want from an antenna okay so these
expressions I agree that are I know I have not derived it but the derivation itself would
take about half a module so rather than that I have given you the basic you know approximation
steps that you needed to make and once you have made those approximations which are very
valid because of the reasons that I have told you in the module you can go ahead and find
out the magnetic field component h as well as the electric field component.
Now what is remaining you have to find out what is the average power that is being radiated
by this antenna which of course will be calculated first by forming the pointing vector okay
and then you will have to find out the directivity and most importantly find out what would be
the radiation resistance of this antenna okay we will do all of this in the next module
thank you very much.
