noc20-ce19-lec19

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
Welcome back. So, in previous lecture where we discussed mostly about the seismic waves
and why seismic wave understanding is important for the hazard, seismic hazard in particular.
So, we looked on different type of seismic waves, body wave, surface wave and their direction
of propagation and their behavior. And of course, we also discussed about the velocities
and whether the seismic waves in particular body waves will be able to travel through
different mediums and how they will behave. And also we at the end we have we had some
discussion on the frequency of the seismic waves and their implications toward the amplification
of the earth surface depending on the geology of the particular site of interest.
Now, there is another significant topic which we would like to you to have understanding
is related to the interplate, intraplate and stable continental region earthquakes. So,
we practically in India we see mostly the interplate and the intraplate earthquake and
also to some extent what we the region which has been classified as a stable continental
region also exist. So, we have all three in total. So, if you just look at the physiographic
divisions of India, then what we have is broadly we can divide into three. So, we have
the extra peninsular area, then we have the endogangetic plains and then we have peninsular
shield area. Now, before 2000 this Lathur earthquake and
this area whole area was been considered as an most stable region, but this was proven
wrong after experiencing the 19 if I am not wrong this was 1993 Lathur earthquake or Killari
earthquake. So, peninsular region of India Indian plate was considered to be seismically
safe. So, this whole area that what we comprise of mainly the the cratonic rocks was considered
to be the most safest one excluding this power portion of Kutch, because we had a couple
of earthquakes in this regions which were damaging and also those earthquakes resulted
into a drastic changes in geomorphology. So, landscape changes was evident during those
earthquake. So, with this understanding the recent large
earthquakes in this region have proven the statement wrong and that was after magnitude
6.2 Killari earthquake or Lathur earthquake and 6.6 Koyna earthquake. Of course, the Koyna
earthquake was your reservoir induced seismicity related to the reservoir induced seismicity,
but this earthquake that is in Lathur or Killari earthquake in 1993 is considered to be because
of the ongoing deformation. Apart from this event several damaging shocks have hit this
region in historical and ancient time. So, when they looked at the scientific groups
looked at the historical data, then they found that this was not the only earthquake that
is the Killari earthquake which shook the region in this area, but there were many more
shocks or the earthquakes and which were recorded during ancient time.
And then another one was 1997 Jabalpur earthquake which took place somewhere in this region
that is in Madhya Pradesh area which again has alarmed that the area which was considered
to be the most stable is not no more to be considered as unstable and that also was one
of the reason which was incorporated and when the seismic zonation map.
So, with this part which we discussed in the previous one also. So, there is a correction
here this about the Lathur Killari earthquake 1993 instead of 1992, but rest has been filled
and again as I told in the previous lecture also that this map was published in 2000.
So, we do not have the inclusion of the earthquakes which have occurred like 2004 along this one
and we do not have the inclusion of 2005 earthquake Muzaffarabad Kashmir earthquake and then two
more earthquakes in this region and that was about 7.5 that is in Nepal 2015.
So, interplate interplate and SCR earthquake. So, if you look into the detail some very
simple classification that numerous earthquake occurs along the edge of the plate boundaries
between the two plates and those are termed as interplate earthquakes. So, mainly such
boundaries if we take then we have mostly along the mid oceanic spreading centers, then
we have along the subduction zones and we along the transform zones. So, these are all
the earthquakes which are aligned or concentrated along the this type of plate boundaries are
termed as interplate earthquakes. For example, earthquake associated with Himalayan
seismic belt and even you can consider this along the subduction zone that is Sumatra
Andaman subduction zone. So, these are all considered to be the earthquakes which are
occurring in intra interplate region. Earthquakes which occur within the continents or oceanic
plates are termed as intraplate earthquake. So, any earthquake which occurs within the
plate away from the plate boundaries are termed as intraplate earthquakes.
Now, earthquake occurring in more stable region or in the older portion of the continents similar
to what we were talking about the shield areas the peninsular area, then those type of earthquakes
are considered to be or categorized the earthquakes occurring in stable continental regions. So,
example is your 1993 Latur or Killari earthquake and 2001 Hoche earthquake. Now, here for us the
the portion which we should emphasize upon is not the interplate and the intraplate earthquake
the recurrence interval along in this region mainly. So, in case of if you remember that we
we had we discussed about the deformation rate of deformation the convergence rate between the
Indian plate and the point in Eurasian plate that is in Tibet that the convergence is almost like
50 millimeter or so and out of that 50 millimeter hardly 5 millimeter has been consumed by the rest
of the plate where is 20 to 21 millimeter is taken up by the other the collision zone which
is marked between the the Indo-Gangetic plane and the Himalayas. So, the recurrence interval in the
intraplate case is at the order of hundreds of years and as I have been emphasizing in a few
of my lectures not this recurrence interval in in Himalaya is around 500 to 600 years or almost
700 years. Now, about the ACR earthquake many they may recur only over thousands of years. So,
the recurrence interval is much larger and this can be directly compared with the the convergence
rate that what we are having the difference along the that is along the Himalayas we are
have across the Himalaya we are having around 20 to 21 millimeter and rest of the plate is
having around hardly 5 millimeter. So, the recurrence increases or recurrence is much
larger as compared to what we see in the intraplate earthquake and the in ACR it will be more than
like thousands of years ok. Now, due to lack of preparation to face an earthquake damage due to
such earthquake are generally very very high and this is in case ACR earthquakes because they the
time interval between the two earthquakes large magnitude earthquakes will be more than like
thousand years and this I would like to emphasize here that our studies from the Gujarat region
revealed that the recurrence interval along the active fault in Kach is more than 2000 years.
So, the memory of human memory is very short and if the earthquake is not recurred in a
shorter period then we lack in preparation because we consider that this area is quite
stable and no earthquake has been experienced or recorded from this region. So, identifying
potential faults and assessing seismic hazard of ACR region is very challenging task.
So, again this can be this point can be justified based on that if you are having
the larger recurrence interval. So, the landform which was been formed or modified because of the
tectonic activity that is what we call the rupture may get eroded and will not be well
preserved on the surface hence it makes and difficult task. So, to identify such weak zones
or the manifestation of the ongoing deformation. So, for example, it is comparatively easy to
identify the tectonically active landforms in Himalayas as compared to what we do study in
Kach region because the recurrence is so high that the features are not getting preserved on
the surface because of the erosion. So, how much we know about the intraplate seismicity?
In recent years destructive earthquakes have struck some regions which were previously
considered as inactive or relatively stable. So, example is not only from Gujarat or Maharashtra,
but even from the areas like Canada and and and Australia. So, these are the two events which
occurred in an what we consider as in stable continental regions from India. So, Killari
Lathur earthquake and Bhuj earthquake with magnitude 7.6 and Killari was 6.4.
Now, the strain developed at the plate boundary is more and and very little within the plate
region. So, what we we had discussion that we have the if we consider this as an Indian plate here
and then along the the plate boundary across this one it was around 20 millimeter per year and rest
of the portion which was consuming this was around 5 millimeter and that was out of the
complete what we were looking at 50 millimeter per year. So, of course, out of this half has
been getting consumed by along way within the the Indian plate portion and rest goes with the the
area in the Tibetan side or China side. So, so, if you just keep this in mind that is your
5 millimeter and you have 20 millimeter, then the the strain which is going to develop in this
particular region the strain will be much much higher. So, higher strain along the Himalayas
where is the this region will have low strain. Now, this has direct implication with the with
the recurrence interval. So, in in the area with the higher strain will have shorter recurrence
and the areas with the low strain will have longer recurrence. So, this you can remember
and this will help you in understanding that what will be the scenario of occurrence of
earthquake in this two region. So, this is Himalaya and rest of the area. So,
the strain developed at the plate boundary is more and very little within the plate region. Hence,
making the areas with relatively low seismic strain. So, this region will be a low seismic
strain region that is your the rest of the the Indian plate. So, of course, we know little about
the the earthquake occurrence in the the stable continental regions because the recurrence is
very large and the earthquake signatures which are been preserved on the surface are very meager
and that is some difficult task. But we have different methods to to look at the the signatures
that is in the in the secondary effect like liquefaction and all that and that we will discuss
later on. So, we know very little about the seismicity of such regions because the recurrence
interval of the intraplate SCR earthquake is very very large. No studies of active faults,
but I would say that now we can say that few studies have been carried out from this regions
mainly the SCR or intraplate region in particularly in in the area where we had 7.6 earthquake. So,
very few studies have been carried out because the hazard in terms of is not alarming in in
in very short time. Hence, we keep avoiding this. So, these are the regions of less priority.
So, seismic zoning if at all done are only based of on an incomplete historical seismic records
or the catalog and scare records of instrumental seismicity during last decades. So, this again
and was the case and the lesson which we learn from Bhuj earthquake that we were not at all
prepared for this event as well as this event in the SCR region or the intraplate region and that
is because of the very long recurrence interval and no active fault studies were been carried out.
So, we never had an complete understanding of what how the tectonic deformation will eventually
result into the future earthquakes and also the incomplete historical records in that those
region. Only from Bhuj area what we had was the 2018-19 earthquake and another was 1956. So,
this were the two only earthquakes which were the damaging earthquakes from this region what
is been classified as intraplate and seismic stable continental regions.
One of the causes for severe damage by earthquake in SCR region which we discussed
in the previous slide is that very long recurrence interval one and then another
one was not the preservation of such tectonically generated features like
false scarps and displaced landforms are very meager because they will be eroded very fast
because the time interval is very large between the two events. So, usually major earthquake in
SCR region can result into a widespread damage because the attenuation this is another very
significant reason for that because the seismic energy in the plate interiors from such earthquake
is relatively low. So, if the energy is not getting attenuated in such regions then they
will result into the more damage in the region. Therefore, even moderate earthquakes that is
moderate magnitude earthquakes as experienced in the case of 1993 Killary or Lathur earthquake
may be extremely dangerous and we of course, we knew that more than 9000 lives were been people
were got killed during the Lathur earthquake and within very moderate magnitude and magnitude was
6.2 only and the reason is because the attenuation of the seismic energy in the in the such regions
by such earthquake is relatively low. So, it never get attenuated very fast.
So, earthquake hazard and risk usually what we consider is then earthquake hazard is anything
associated with an earthquake that may affect the normal activities of the people. This includes
surface faulting, ground shaking, landslide, liquefaction, tectonic deformation and tsunami.
Tsunamis are of course, and landslides and what we call the surface shaking liquefaction these
are all associated secondary features or secondary phenomena which will be always
experienced during the earthquake. Then earthquake risk of course, it comes not earthquakes never
kill people by building do and this is because of the poor construction even have maximum building
damage and people that are expected to be hurt. So, the risk part will be based on that. So,
what will be the number of buildings which will be which are vulnerable to the earthquake shaking,
ground shaking and how many people the population is likely to be getting affected
or hurt or killed during an particular earthquake. Of course, the if you talk in terms of the groups
or the research groups who are talking about the geotechnical aspect, then the definition
usually slightly varies, but they talk in terms of that what is the potential and the probability
of earthquake at a particular given location. So, but as a geologist if we consider then for
us this is the difference between the major difference between or the fundamental difference
between the earthquake hazard and risk. But in geotechnical part we take into
consideration the source of the earthquake, then what will what is the magnitude of the
earthquake expected earthquake, probability of that earthquake that is again the recurrence
interval and the geology of the site of interest where it is located. So, this all parameters will
talk about the deterministic seismic hazard and probabilistic seismic hazard. We are not
going to get into the detail of that about the probability concise the deterministic,
but I will try if I can give you some slides on that at later stage.
Now, measuring earthquake as we have we started with the understanding of seismic waves and in
the frequency of seismic wave and inter plate and intra plate earthquakes and the high strain
area low strain area and the recurrence interval. So, the measuring earthquake is another important
aspect to we should know before we get into the details of the methodology of paleo seismology,
how we are going to carry out and how we are going to identify the related tectonically
of developed landforms. Now, measuring earthquake is usually done based on the intensity one where
the intensity is the presentation of effects ground shaking and damage of an earthquake at
a particular place based on the observation of the affected area. This information is presented
by iso seismic lines along with the Roman letter numbers which is termed as intensity scale and it
can range from 1 to 12. Whereas, the magnitude is it represents the amount of seismic energy
released by an earthquake. It is measured on the basis of the arrival time of PNS wave and the
largest amplitude of the seismic waves ok. So, in other than the PNS wave seismologist
also uses the surface waves to calculate the magnitude and the magnitudes are usually
represented by the numbers that is 1 2 3 and etcetera on the magnitude whereas,
the intensity is been done is been done on the modified Mercalli scale. So, this is the major
difference between the intensity and the magnitude. So, in earlier time when before
the invent of the instruments measuring the magnitude and earthquake of measuring the
earthquake mainly. So, intensity was very important and the, but still even though we
have the instruments installed and they are recording the earthquakes occurrence of the
earthquakes. We do the analysis or we do the we keep collecting the observations after any
earthquake that is based on the damage pattern and the deformation in that particular area and
prepare the intensity map which are known as iso seismic maps. Now, if you go back into the history
of the seismograph. So, it takes you as back as almost like 2000 years ago. So, the first seismograph
was invented about 2000 years ago by Chinese astronomer and mathematician Chang Hing. He
called this device as an earthquake weathercock. Now, this is based on a very simple physics,
that it is when the it has like total 8 dragons are mounted around the vase with the bronze ball
in its mouth. So, you have the dragon and it had like 8 dragons which are we can see only 4 and 4
are in the back side. So, all this dragons 8 dragons are holding a bronze ball in their mouths.
So, whenever there is the there was an even a slight earthquake earth tremor ok, a mechanism
inside the. So, what you have is one is the dragons here 8 dragons and respectively you
have torts with open mouth which are also aligned and sitting exactly below the open
mouth of the dragon here ok. So, even with the small tremor mechanism inside the seismograph
would open the mouth of one of one dragon and the bronze ball would fall into the open mouth
of the torts. So, you have this making enough noise to alert someone that earthquake had just
happened. So, this was even with this even it was possible to tell that from which direction
the earthquake came that is the seismic wave games and by seeing which dragons mouth was
empty ok. So, this was the earthquake weathercock which was invented way back in 2000 years ago by
Chinese astronomer and mathematician. Now, if we look at the chronology because
as we discussed in one of the lecture that with more data and what we learn from different
earthquakes we keep improving our methodology and we keep improving the methods which helped
in interpretations and all that. So, the intensity scale as well as the magnitude scale kept on
revised revising based on the input of the data and whatever the what lesson we learn from and
respective earthquakes ok. So, anyway what we can do is I will stop here and we will start with the
the chronology of the intensity and the magnitude scales in the next lecture. Thank you so much.
.
