IITK NPTEL Structural Geology_Lecture 11: Complex Rheology [Prof. Santanu Misra]

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
hello everyone welcome back again to
this online structural geology course
under NPTEL and today we are at our
lecture number 11 and we are studying
rheology today we're at our part 2 of
rheology lecture in the last lecture
lecture 10 of rheology we learnt the
three basic the 3 end members of
rheology elastic rheology viscous
rheology and plastic rheology and today
we will learn combined or complex
geology so in this lecture will cover
rheology of rocks as combined viscous
and elastic materials so we will call it
viscoelastic rheology similarly we will
combine elastic and plastic that would
be elasto-plastic rheology will combine
viscous and plastic that would be your
visco plastic material and then in the
next lecture will cover some examples of
the applications of rheology in
structural geology tectonics and geo
dynamics so we start with first the
viscoelastic rheology but before that
let's have a look that what are the
different applications of this combined
rheology so in aquifers and reservoirs
so flow of groundwater and hydrocarbons
to understand their flow behavior flow
mechanisms it's important that we use a
complex rail as your combined geology
their magma flow in volcanic conduits
that also requires complex geology to
explain the flow mechanisms in geo
dynamics there is mantle convection
plate motions the deglaciation phenomena
all these are explained by complex
geology and if we come to the crustal
deformation
we generally see in the field the
ductile structures folding shear
localizations and also earthquakes which
are not ductile but these are all
explained by complex geology so you can
consider that almost all ductile
deformations and their flow processes in
Earth can be explained by by using the
complex rheology so the complex reality
are combined rheology basics is very
simple that we will see that elastic
plastic and viscous beat linear or
non-linear these are often found to be
too simple to model and explain the
deformation behavior of rocks under
certain conditions so it is important
that we combine these three types of
basic rheology in order to describe the
natural Rock deformation and the
combinations the possibility of these
combinations are many so as you can see
here I have added a spring and a dashpot
then I have Springs of two different
properties and then a dash board in two
different Springs two different - pots
so you can you can array them in
parallel and CDs and then again parallel
and series and so on so what we are
going to learn today is the very simple
combinations in parallel and also in
series particularly for viscoelastic
rheology
and then we will see how to explain or
what would be their stress-strain curve
or to their stress versus time strain
versus time curves and why these are
important for for understanding better
the deformation of rocks so we start
first with viscoelastic rheology in the
previous lecture we learnt that elastic
behavior is not time-dependent that
means it does not depend on time and we
also learnt if we consider viscous
reality then it is time dependent it is
strain rate dependent now if we have to
combine these to observe a
that one rheology elastic is time
independent and another rheology viscous
which is time dependent how can we
explain this in terms of or haqqani
apply this in our art systems now the
general observations that we have seen
from different type of long-term or
short-term measurements that crystalline
solids so many deforms it behave as a
viscous fluid in geological timescales
like 10 to the power 12 seconds or so on
but the mantle behaves as an elastic
solid on timescales ready when it is
very small so 1 to 10 to the power 4
seconds but it shows a viscous behavior
on timescales when it is very high tend
to go to 11 or 10 to the 17 seconds so
in general if we try to understand that
if the deformation is short timed then
the rocks respond as elastic manner but
if it is very long time then it responds
as viscous manner so this is a spot or
this is a range where we can apply the
viscoelastic rheology the combinations
of elasticity and viscosity we have
combined them together in different ways
and then we can apply this
viscoelasticity to explain the behavior
of the deformation and the materials
that do have the property that in short
timescales they behave elastically and
long timescales they behave in viscous
manner are known as viscoelastic
material so let's have a quick review of
what we have learnt for viscous and
elastic rheology we know that elastic
rheology is explained by a spring and
the stress-strain curve is like linear
something like that this is your stress
this is your strain and this is the
stress versus time and strain versus
time response this one and this one
where their viscosity is explained by
dashpot
and then here we generally explain it
stress versus strain rate curve and it
is like this for a linear viscous
material and this is your stress versus
time and strain versus time curve where
time is corresponding to stress and
strain now you can combine these two
rheology either in parallel or in series
when you combine them in parallel we see
a different behavior when you combine in
series we get a different behavior and
both of them have applications in in
structural geology or in geo dynamics in
general so let's first have a look the
first viscoelastic component that we
will be talking about is known as Kelvin
rheology sin Kelvin viscoelastic
behavior or Kelvin viscoelastic
materials the deformation process is
reversible right that's the first thing
to to get but the strain accumulation
recovery are extremely slow it's not
like elastic materials and this typical
rheology this Kelvin rheology is also
known as form of viscous or white
rheology now generally this Kelvin
rheology is explained or we model it
when we add spring and the dashpot that
means elastic and of his cos in parallel
arrangement what we see here that I have
spring and in parallel I have a dashpot
now the first statement that we made in
this slide the deformation process is
reversible you can clearly figure out if
we stay within the elastic domain of
this spring doesn't matter how far I
stretch this it has to come back to its
original position because there is the
spring so this response of viscous part
is important in determining that how
much time it would take to come back to
its position because when it comes back
to its position or when it responds this
way
it is not a function of the spring
anymore it is the function of how much
this fluid is allowing this this entire
system to come back to its original
position so both systems in in in this
case the spring and this viscous dashpot
they move simultaneously under stress
but the dashpot returns the extension of
the spring okay so when the stress is
released the spring will return to its
original position it will try to return
to its original position very quickly
but again the dashpot will return this
movement okay so therefore the
deformation is time dependent though the
entire deformation is recoverable so you
can again see this with the stress
versus time and strain I'm sorry
this is stress and strain versus time
plot the application of stress is very
similar that we have applied to our
elastic elements so we apply
instantaneous stress which is here to
here and then leave it for a while and
then release the stress instantaneously
and then it stays at zero but the strain
response is very interesting so when the
stress is zero this strain is zero at
the beginning but when we
instantaneously apply the stress now
because it has both spring and dashpot
in parallel the strain increase is
somehow non-linear even if the spring is
linear and the fluid here is a linear
viscous fluid because we are combining
them and once we release the stress
again the recovery is lawn linear and
time dependent so it comes back to its
original position in an asymptotic
manner and this part this release of
strain very slowly is known as viscous
relaxed
sation viscous relaxation has many
applications in structural geology and
GD and geo dynamics will not go into
that part but you just remember that
when you when you are dealing with this
kind of rheology kelvin rheology then
the release of strain after the load is
gone is is long linear and it's
extremely slow and it is known as
viscous relaxation so clearly I have the
equation for this spring known is Hookes
law and viscous is also known is is is
the flow of the Newtonian but because
they are parallel so the total
deformation would be following the
equation of parallel combinations of
elements so if I have to go with the
strain rate so I know that one by strain
rate should be equal to one by strain
rate of the elastic element which would
be added with the inverse of the strain
rate of the viscous element and if we
expand this equation or resolve this
equation then we simply get this
equation where your total stress is
equal to strain multiplied by the
elastic element and then viscosity
multiplied by strain rate of this
viscous element and this is how so this
is Young's modulus and this is viscosity
so this is how we explained the Kelvin
rheology where the strain is recoverable
or the entire deformation is reversible
but the entire process is extremely slow
what would happen if we add this elastic
and viscous elements instead of parallel
if we add them in series then what we
get is known as Maxwell rheology if we
so here we have the viscous element here
we have the elastic element and
are added in a series so a Maxwell
viscoelastic material accumulates strain
from the moment a stress is applied
because it is independently deforming it
can deform independently this spring the
deformation this spring does not depend
initially on the deformation of this
viscous element right so it deforms
immediately the moment of stress is
applied first elastically and then it
goes to gradually in viscous manner
so therefore for a short duration of
deformation this system works as an
elastic body but but later this goes to
a viscous manner so this short duration
of deformation in most of the cases is
recoverable because then it is
independent of the dashpot but the
spring then only plays the role however
for long term deformation the viscosity
component takes the lead
right because then viscous viscous
material starts flowing through the
porous spaces of this piston and then it
remains permanent and if it becomes
permanent then your deformation is
permanent and you cannot recover it or
in other way you can recover the
deformation of the spring but you cannot
recover the deformation of this dashpot
so the total deformation therefore is
not coming back to its original position
once you release the stress so the
deformation is not totally recoverable
and this is the physical model of
Maxwell rheology where you can arrange
it a spring and a dashpot in series now
once we do it in series the equation is
very straight forward so total shear
strain rate is the sum of the total
strain rate of elastic and thus total
total strain rate of viscous components
and if we expand this equation or
resolve this equation then it takes this
little complex shape
and here again we have Sigma and time
and here we have again strain and time
curve and what we see here let me
explain it I should do it before that we
have zero stress no strain then
instantaneously I apply the stress the
strain increases instantaneously because
of this elastic element so this
deformation is essentially because of
the spring this one and then I add the
viscous part when I keep it for quite a
long time
so then viscous strain increases slowly
now when I release this stress
instantaneously the elastic part
released but the viscous train stays it
does not come back to its original
position but again this happens very
very slowly
however in linear manner so this is
viscoelastic rheology and we learnt that
we have Maxwell rheology and we have
Kelvin rheology Maxwell rheology when we
add viscosity and elasticity in series
and Kelvin rheology when you add
viscosity and elasticity in parallel
let's talk about another one which is
elasto-plastic rheology the last two
plastic materials as you can guess from
this name that it combines elastic
material elastic element and plastic
element right so it considers
recoverable elastic strain from the
elastic element but non recoverable
strain from the plastic element so
therefore the total deformation is not
recoverable the permanent deformation as
I talked is plastic but it does not
begin until the yield stress is reached
release of stress recovers the elastic
component of the total deformation and
physical model we can in a simple way we
can see it when we add them in series
here I have this spring block I'm sorry
here I have this spring block and then I
have the friction block here and if I
pull it the spring in the spring slowly
expands because of the force I'm
applying and when this spring also X
gives the load to this pulling load to
this friction block and when this
friction is overcome by by this force
pull force pulling force then this
friction block starts moving and when
the stress is released then this spring
comes back to its original position but
not the friction block so we can have an
idea from of this behavior from stress
versus time and strain versus time curve
so here when the stress we apply there
is no stress there is no strain then I
slowly pull this spring so I increase
the stress strain is also increased
linearly the way I increase the stress
but then when I start moving this spring
so this I'm sorry this is your elastic
Sigma Y is your yield stress then this
friction block starts moving and if I
release the stress then the elastic
strain I recovered come I I can recover
the elastic strain and then the plastic
strain continues so this strain is
equivalent to the strain this is your
plastic strain which you cannot recover
this model has significant applications
or it is in a simpler form we apply it
mostly to predict the or or understand
the behavior of the earthquakes and we
will see it later
so now we will see what is viscoplastic
rheology as you can understand it has
viscous element and plastic element and
in this case the viscoplastic materials
display the linear viscous behavior only
above yield stress of a plastic material
now viscoplastic materials are also
known as Bingham materials or being
hompless ticks and a typical
viscoplastic rheology is generally shown
by the parallel arrangements of friction
block and dashpot which is shown here so
what is happening in this case if I add
the if I try to understand these to
illustrate plots this is Sigma versus
time and strain versus time so in this
stress is zero strain is zero and then I
start slowly applying the load once I am
applying this load interestingly I
cannot move the dashpot
till I reach the yield of this friction
block right so there would be no
deformation there would be no strain
even if there is some sort of stress and
when I reach the yield stress then I
instantaneously move this spring block
and then stress goes this way and then I
leave this stress so in the entire time
the strain continue continues increasing
but doesn't matter if I release the
stress the strain remains permanent
because of the friction block and also
the viscous element so I repeat the
viscoelastic materials display linear
viscous behavior after the ill stress or
only above the yield stress of a when
when you are dealing with a visco
plastic material so therefore if I don't
look at this part
this behavior is essentially a behavior
of linear viscous rheology now we'll see
three examples of where and how in
large-scale processes we apply this
complex are combined rheology the first
one we take over is earthquake mechanics
now we know how earthquakes do happen
right that most of the earthquakes do
happen along plate boundaries or to be
very speaks very specific in the
convergent plate boundaries where
oceanic plate goes down we look at the
continental plate and here is an
illustration where this oceanic block is
continues to subduct
under this continental crust and we know
earthquake happens somewhere here what
we call Benioff zone at some depth so at
this place there is a significant amount
of friction so there is some sort of
resistance now when this block is
continuously pushing to go down because
of this resistance it cannot move
immediately if there is no creep
happening now in such a setting at this
region this plate is accumulating a
significant amount of elastic strain at
one point of time when you accumulate
this elastic strain it releases very
suddenly in a very similar way we have
seen in our friction block right so you
work on the yield stress and then it
starts moving instantaneously so when
this strain here elastic strain here is
released it released in forms of
catastrophic orco seismic event and
therefore we have an earthquake now this
we can very simply model using this
elasto-plastic rheology i I just remind
you that actual process of earthquake or
micro physics of the earthquake is
extremely complex and it's not Allah is
advised to explain it using this model
but this is the simplest way you can
explain the earthquake mechanics in real
logical context so what we see here I am
trying to provide I have tried to
provide here an illustration so what we
are considering that this spring and the
friction block together form the elastic
plate the pool I am applying to this
spring is the plate velocity and this
frictional interface is your contact
between continental plate and oceanic
plate so at T one things are very stable
now the plate velocity has been applied
to this spring so spring is slowly
expanding as you can see and when we
overcome this frictional resistance here
this block suddenly moves to its forward
it moves forward suddenly and that
happens at t5 and when this sudden move
happens you have a release of energy and
this is an earthquake interestingly when
that happens it actually shrinks the
spring back to its original position so
I have this spring here and I have this
spring here so I have accumulated the
strain but my elastic element comes back
to its original position not the plastic
element but plate velocity continues so
the same thing do happen Here I am again
stretching the spring again stretching
this spring again stretching the spring
and again when I reach the
elastic this this friction of this block
then this block suddenly moves forward
and produce another earthquake and so on
so I have one earthquake here I have
second earthquake here and in a similar
way I have third earth quake here with
accumulation of more strain and it is
happening in a zigzag manner like it
takes time to accumulate the strain then
suddenly it releases then again it takes
time to accumulate this strain suddenly
it releases and so on this is very
similar of what I call earthquake
recurrence that in a place if you are an
earthquake then it comes back in time
that could be in hundred years two
hundred years or several million years
it depends on the frictional resistance
it depends on many other parameter the
composition the fluid content and so on
we are not going to that part but this
behavior of an elasto-plastic body is
excellent to understand or to primarily
first-order understanding of an
earthquake phenomena so you can see that
you have doing elastic loading in the
stress and then at t5 you have a stress
drop because it brings comes comes back
then you have again elastic loading you
have stress drop you did each stress
drop is characterized by an earthquake
so this is a very simple model but one
can understand the earthquake mechanics
using a very simple combined
elastoplastic rheology
let us have a second example and this
example is from 2002 dinelli earthquake
the magnitude was seven point nine it
was a huge earthquake but it happened
you know dinelli's is in US or the
northern part of us in Alaska no one
died but it was a devastating earthquake
close to 50 60 billion was was a damage
that happened in this earthquake because
of mini-me
landslides so this diagram here on the
left side shows the displacement of this
earthquake the maximum displacement so
this is where this the line of the sleep
so you had this magnitude of I'm sorry
this is your magnitude of maximum sleep
that happened in this earthquake which
is pretty high in terms of this
earthquake that happened on the surface
because this was a very shallow
earthquake it was if I remember
correctly 1213 kilometers depth it
happened from the surface now what is
interesting of this earthquake now if I
have an earthquake the earthquake is not
an isolated process because the top part
of the plate is also attached to the
mantle below which we have learnt is
somehow viscous so when you have this
huge displacement of several kilometers
of these plates then mantle also gets
affected by these deformation so
instantaneous deformation of this grasp
that produced an earthquake also provide
an instantaneous deformation in the
mantle and this is what is shown in this
diagram so this is a Koh seismic stress
change what we see here that this is
this yellow then sorry orange then
yellow then green these are your stress
accumulation immediately after the
earthquake and then the second
illustration shows same place after two
years and we can clearly see that at
least visualize I am NOT going into the
detail but if you are interested you can
read this paper free little 2006 I think
2006 a they have two papers on this so
what you can see here
that the just if I consider this
affected area or affected depth has
reduced from the co seismic time to next
two years and this third is showing the
change of stress that means if you
subtract from these two this and this
clearly indicates that we are recovering
the stress and this is an excellent
example of Maxwell rheology that when
you have instant instant deformation
like then the spring takes the lead but
in long term the dashboard comes into
the picture to recover or not recover
the strain and so on so this is an
excellent application of viscoelastic
rheology in explaining earthquake
processes in earth particularly the
mantle deformation during the earthquake
the last example that I would like to
give is related to deglaciation
and rebound due to deglaciation now you
we know that most of this lands that the
continents are under the threat of the
sea level rise but there is one place in
the world where sea level is going down
now this is very interesting and this is
a very important geodynamic problem that
people had to solve and it has been
solved again by the study of complex
geology or combined rheology so that
land is rising sea level is lowering
down it's the only phenomena that is
being seen in in scandinavian part so
it's Norway and other places Finland
Norway and these places but however the
observation suggests that the sea level
rise phenomena is also there so with
respect to the center of the art if we
measure the sea level
and times then sea-level is certainly
rising in this region but interestingly
the rise of the land is faster so
therefore the relative rise of land we
can see there now what we see let's have
a first look in this image at the core
of this area so this is the Scandinavian
countries and this contours that we see
here these are your land uplifts so at
the core the land uplifts with a rate of
nine millimetre per year and then it
slowly reduces to zero almost when you
reach the sea now this is explained by a
combined rheology this behavior that why
land is rising up in this region and why
also the maximum rise is at the core of
this area so these four diagrams
actually very very simply describe how
this can happen so when we have a very
standard setting we have see we have
crossed and below that we have mantle so
these parties you can consider this is
your thick continental crust you have
thin oceanic crust above which you have
the sea and then below you have mantle
everything is rest and everything is in
peace but art is a dynamic system so
probably during some sort of cooling
edge cooling time the sea level dropped
because it contributed to the formation
of place here in this region now this
glacier which is this blue area is heavy
ice so ice is loading the continental
crust and therefore it is deforming
elastic way the continental crust so it
is going down now
it continues the glaciation and then the
size or volume of the glacier increased
therefore weight also increased and the
continental crust deformed further now
when it deform further elastically of
course it has to display
the mantle below so the mantle Bulow's
very slowly move away from this place
because it has to accommodate the
sinking elastically sinking continental
crust now till this part it is fine we
had glaciers in Finland and Norway very
good but later when the deglaciation
started the sea-level rise
happened because the water from the
glacier goes down comes back to the sea
so the elastic deformation that we had
in the continental crust is now
recovering the strain so it's coming
back to its original position and the
mantle is also coming back to recover to
fill up the gap so this is exactly what
is happening that during due to
deglaciation this continental crust is
coming back or pushing up and this is
happening mostly because the
deglaciation also the push from the
mantle below and this is also an
excellent example of using combined
rheology in explaining the rebound
due to deglaciation in scandinavian
places we are almost at the end of the
lecture and of this reality and i would
like to show you the one of the first
slides where we have cited some of the
everyday use of rheology examples like
the ballpoint pens then why do you have
to shake the bottles of tomato ketchup
or running on a beach is harder than
running on roads and so on
now I request you to review all these
questions or all these facts and I'm
sure you can now answer them or you can
now understand the processes of all
these mechanisms in terms of rheology so
I repeat whatever we do most of the
things where we have some sort of forces
required to move
the best way to explain is using the
three basic realities or combinations of
them so if this I finished this lecture
but we are not done with rheology we
will have a short lecture to understand
that what are the influences of the
different external parameters in
governing the flow or strength of the
rock so we are going to learn it in the
next lecture thank you very much
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
