Lecture : 13 Factors associated with galvanic corrosion: Case study 3

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
Welcome to the course Corrosion Failures and Analysis. We have lecture 13 and this will
be the concluding lecture on Galvanic Corrosion and next class onwards we will take up other
forms of corrosion. Now the course is Galvanic Corrosion.
Now we take up some case studies or examples. Some I will take up from different books on
area issues, area factor. The example what is given in the book written by Fontana and
Green which is corrosion engineering. So, these two plates we have rivets. So, this
is two plates which are copper. In another situation if I do only the top view. So, this
is copper plate and steel rivet and in this case this is copper rivet and steel plate.
Both of them as per the book data, both of them is dipped in sea water for 15 months
and this was basically referred to just follow the book by M. G. Fontana and N. D. Green.
The book name is corrosion engineering. So, this is if you see that book this is basically
taken from international nickel company fine. So, this entire thing I am projecting for
education purpose. Now in that case both are dipped in 15 months.
Now after some time after 15 months we would see that the part which is steel plate and
copper rivet that maintains strong joint in spite of corrosion because as we have seen
that from the mixed potential theory that corrosion of cathode anode cannot be prevented
at all, but corrosion of cathode also cannot be stopped completely. So, here this copper
rivet would also corrode, but very small corrosion small amount of corrosion, but here and the
steel of course, and the steel corrosion would be filled around this zone around this zone.
So, other part would also get corroded, but the rust formation would be more around this
area. Now it will maintain its strong joint, but on the in the case of copper plate and
steel rivet we will see that the joint has loosened up and it has lost strength also
lost and second observation is the steel rivet is seriously corroded. This is typical example
of unfavorable area factor unfavorable area ratio and in the sea water as per the galvanic
series copper stays on top of steel and here the oxidation reaction is.
So, now oxidation would be F minus 2 e equal to F e plus 2 and in case of this is anode
and if it is copper. So, the oxidation the cathodic reaction would be this is cathode
it will be O 2 2 H 2 O plus 4 e equal to 4 O H minus. Now since in this case area of
steel is less than area of copper plate the unfavorable area factor would copper area
unfavorable area factor will be experienced. So, here large cathode and small anode. So,
anode will corrode heavily and finally, the strength will be lost the joint strength will
be lost, but here copper area is less than steel area. So, anode area is more than cathode area.
So, hence the corrosion of steel will be spreaded over entire joint area and surrounding
and that would lead to maintenance of the joint. So, this is an example of typical example
of large cathode and small anode and large anode and small cathode.
Now another example let me cite from my own experience. So, if I see this typical example.
So, this is two pictures I have taken the house wise I stay where I stay the roof top
where there are pillars concrete pillars and inside that pillars we have inserted the they
have inserted the while making this particular structure they inserted those pipelines into
the pillars and then they have painted outside they have painted.
Now interesting part is you could see that pillar the top part where there is the pipeline
is there that pipeline around that pipeline the concrete is heavily broken and this breaking
happens there are two factors one is corrosion rust as from by the observation. So, observation
it is very clear that this particular pipeline. So, let me analyze this particular failure.
So, what are the observation? Observation is concrete is severely cracked and second
is wherever crack happen huge rust has formed. So, there are some pillars where the crack
has just opened up for example, in this case the crack has just opened up, but still you
could see there is a huge amount of rust here also huge amount of rust. So, these are two
observations now let us see why this crack has formed. So, there are two reasons one
is which could be minor let me tell you which could be minor. So, that is expansion and
contraction of steel. Since the environment is heavy environment
day time the temperature can shoot up to 40 degree Celsius and the night time it will
bring back to around 25-30 degree Celsius. So, there could be change in expansion and
contraction. So, that would lead to a kind of stress generation in the concrete, but
the second part and that might lead to a failure of that particular concrete, but the second
part which is leading to a kind of galvanic effect corrosion. Now, let us analyze why
the galvanic effect now if you see that outside is painted and the paint cannot is not kind
of a impervious thing there are pores and it can also have mechanical damage over the
years it does not happen 1 month 2 months it will happen after 1 year or. So, those
cracks or the breaking of paints there we expose and in fact, the entire paint segments
are impervious and there we have moisture there we have moisture as well as oxygen and
that would lead to oxygen. Now, the part which is inside that would also have moisture shift
in moisture and oxygen inside this part and this part we have also moisture and oxygen,
but here if you see since it is covered the partial pressure of oxygen and here partial
pressure of oxygen. So, this factor would be if we say this is
out would be greater than P O 2 in. So, this lead to concentration cell. So, this would
become cathode and this would become now since this cathode area is the exposed area
of the pipe. So, it is a huge area. So, the huge number of this reaction would take place
this reaction would take place. So, now, in order to meet that electron that electron
should be provided by the anode area. So, that anode area is here where we have Fe minus
2 e Fe Fe plus 2 and then Fe plus 2 would again convert to Fe plus 3 and it might go
to Fe 2 O 3 H 2 O. So, this is hydrated ferric oxide or you can simply write. So, we have
shown that previously that we can have O 2 plus H 2 O plus Fe 2 it becomes Fe OH whole
2 you can make 2 ok. So, this is the reaction ok. So, let us see oxygen 2 oxygen 4 fine
that the balance is maintained. So, then again Fe OH whole 2 plus oxygen plus H 2 O
it can go to Fe OH whole 3 and that time I can make it would be I make it 2 here half.
So, oxygen is 3. So, we can make 2. So, this 6 2 2 I think this is balanced hydrogen is
4 plus 2 6 it is balanced. So, this phase or this phase that would form because there
are always little bit of oxygen going in though it is partial pressure is not 0. So, this
phases are forming inside of it ok. So, this is inside the rust is forming outside
also rust is forming it is not that rust is not forming that is very clear if you see
this area this area. So, though there are little rust that has formed for example, if
you see here it is just opening up just opening up ok, but in fact, the entire paint will
be impervious. So, that would allow, but even if that mechanical failure mechanical
breakage of that paint does not happen still you will have those reactions.
So, now interestingly now we know that which one is cathode and which one is anode. Now
the unfavorable area array factor comes in why because if you see the entire pipe. So,
almost about close to 10 feet or I think 20 feet pipe is outside this concrete and
inside may be hardly 1 feet pipe is inside the concrete. So, now, inside that 1 feet
area 1 feet distance that much area is actually exposed to the are becoming that much area
is becoming anode the rest 20 feet area 20 feet length area equivalent area is actually
cathode. So, the large cathode and small anode and leading to huge galvanic corrosion
inside inside pipe means the pipe which is inside the concrete structure.
Now why it fails now interestingly if we compare the density of this rust and the density of
iron the density of rust is lower than the density of iron. So, the iron is actually
going to rust. So, there is the rust phase is forming since the rust phase has a lower
density it has a higher specific volume and since that volume is entrapped into the concrete
structure that would lead to a hoop stress on the concrete structure. And because of
that hoop stress if we have a concrete like this let us say this is the pipe this is the
pipe and around that we have concrete. So, the hoop stress is basically it is leading
to this kind of failure would happen there will be splitting of concrete and this splitting
of concrete is very much visible. So, there is a tensile stress because the
rust less volume the higher specific volume rust is actually pushing the concrete from
inside to outside and that is what from top it is actually splitting. So, that is what
the failure happens. So, the now question is how do we prevent this that prevention
part I will discuss, but I will leave it to you to think about it what could be the preventive
part because this is not there in any book this is my photographs I have taken this photograph
and I am explaining this is the explanation what is true here, but now you have to you
have to suggest how we would prevent it ok. So, the only thing is I can give you the give
you the hint is somehow you have to avoid this differential aeration cell or concentration
aeration cell in order to avoid that because it is exposed to environment you cannot take
oxygen out you cannot take moisture out the only way you can do it somehow you have to
take oxygen inside take moisture inside still corrosion would happen, but it will not happen
the way it has happened because of the unfavorable area factor ok.
So, I am just giving you the hint you take it up and then find out a reason. So, this
is open ended reason I have. So, you have to tell me what could be the reason you can
write to me in that in the YouTube video you can write what could be the reason fine. So,
this is one example I just wanted to share with you this is also typical galvanic corrosion.
So, now let us coming back to our lecture. So, I have just given two examples there are
several such examples you can go to book written by Jaki Ahmed even in the book corrosion engineering
by Fontana and Green there is a typical problem in Fontana and Green which is the pipeline
this tank corrosion that tank corrosion also you can look at fine once you have understood
this you should be able to understand that also. So, now let us come to what are the
protection mechanisms prevention. So, first is choice of metals and alloys when somebody
chooses those metals and alloys for a many structure preparation they should be close
by in galvanic series. So, the galvanic effect will be less there will be uniform corrosion
which is fine because I can design my I can give over protection or little bit of extra
thickness if it is a uniform corrosion. So, no problem in that, but if it is a galvanic
corrosion the part which is hidden would get corroded this is important aspect the part
which is hidden gets corroded during galvanic corrosion this is typical example what I have
shown that roof concrete corrosion the part which was inside the concrete was getting
corroded. So, now this is important aspect the hidden part corrodes in case of galvanic
corrosion. So, now if you notice in your household let us say you have a pin or nail a nail is a nail
let us say is fitted to wooden stuff and if it is staying there for long time let us say more
than 5 6 years or more than that and if it is exposed to environment interesting part is you
will see that on top of it rust will be there rust will be there if we try to take it out you will
see it will break open and if it is wooden if you can take it out very carefully you will say that
the inside part which has gone inside would corrode heavily same logic outside is getting
oxygen H2O inside also it is not possible to avoid oxygen access or moisture access,
but the oxygen and moisture would be very low. So, oxygen inside less and here it is more again
concentration cell. So, this concentration is basically cell is basically same as what we had
in case of rain water example. So, outside we will have this reaction inside in oxygen partial
pressure is less this reaction would happen sometimes you might see that the those particular
wooden stuff where the nail is there it might you might see some cracks over there that cracks is
coming again because the same reason if it is a hardwood that crack formation would be very
much evident because the rust is again having higher specific volume and that would lead to
a kind of pushing stress and that particular stress would lead to a crack of the splitting
crack of the wooden stuff ok. So, this is. So, that is what whenever you try to see if
there is a galvanic effect you try to look at the hidden part because this is hidden in case
of concrete case this was the pipe was hidden the hidden part experiences galvanic corrosion
because it is always the collapse and the outside or head of the screw or the pin or the nail is
actually cathode and inside is. Now, there could be one is paint and the while painting one should
paint cathode part leaving anode part. So, this is also important I think it needs explanation ok.
So, we will take it up. So, we can also spend little time in your next lecture for the on
the protection part. So, this part I will discuss in the next lecture ok. So, the why we are saying
cathode part needs to be painted rather than anode part if you see that the painting is not
possible over the entire area please paint cathode part not you can leave the anode part open ok.
So, that will actually prevent corrosion effect then we have insulation. Insulation
means somehow you insulate cathode and anode part. So, that the galvanic contact is prevented
galvanic contact is prevented. So, then also you will have lot of advantage there could be issues
like if you can take out oxygen moisture. So, those can be considered as corrosive or chlorine
ion which is actually acting against the passivation. So, this corrosive if you remove
you can prevent corrosion galvanic corrosion like the example what I just we have what I
have narrated that in case of packing of CRG cold roll grain oriented steel sheet it is it
is evacuated the pack is evacuated. So, that moisture and oxygen is less the corrosion effect
would be less. Then there are things like beta coating beta coating and there could be examples
of inhibitors. So, this coatings and inhibitors will explain later. So, inhibitor is basically
inorganic or organic substance which do not take part in actual corrosion event, but it actually
leads to prevent some of the corrosion steps. So, that way it protects coating of course,
it avoids contact of metal and the corrosives ok. So, these are the some of the important aspects
of prevention. And in our next lecture what I will do I will try to explain this part that
why the painting of cathode area is important rather than painting of anode area ok.
So, till then let us stop here we will continue our discussion in next lecture. Next lecture I
will start with some typical examples and then I will move to some other corrosion forms. Let
us stop here. Thank you.
