noc18-me60 Lec05

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
Shape Memory Effect (SME), One-way SME, Pseudoelasticity, Two-way SME, Applications of Shape Memory Alloy
[Music]
[Music]
good morning everybody welcome to the
final lecture of module 1 on this MOOC
course smart materials and intelligent
system design in the last particular you
know lecture we have talked about active
smart polymers and also I have touched
the issues on classifications of
electroactive polymers which is a
special group and all this active smart
polymer and their if you remember we
have mostly focus on AI PMC's ionic
polymer matrix composite
now the reason behind developing these
kinds of you know active polymeric
systems was I was telling that the
inspiration was from the muscles okay
so that you can get a large deformation
in the system however also we have noted
down that in polymers even though you
can get large deformation you are not
going to get large force out of the
system so this kind of active polymers
will give you large deformation but it
will give you low blocking force now
already I have once told you about this
concept of free strain and blocking
force if you remember that if we
consider this you know as a strain
versus force strain versus force of an
actuator then when it is freely
straining at that point it is actually
the maximum point you know the maximum
strain that you can get from the system
and on the other hand this is the point
which we call it as the blocking force
where the strain is zero but you are
getting maximum force by stopping the
actuator to deform at all so that
actuator will be giving you the force
now these force naturally depends on the
you know one of the parameters is the
modulus of elasticity so because these
polymers are having low elastic modulus
so they will be giving us low
blocking force now that is where we will
see today that if we use not these
polymers but a metallic alloys for
example nickel titanium alloys mostly
used then you will see that this modulus
of elasticity will be much higher and as
a result the blocking force will be much
higher
but of course somewhere there is a
compromise that the free strain for such
cases will be lower so those are the
group of materials that I will be
discussing today and that is you know
given a common name which is called
shape-memory alloys what I will be
talking about is what is shape memory
effect first of all and then the
metallic alloys that show such shape
memory effect will also talk about a
couple of interesting properties like
one way shape memory effect pseudo
elasticity and two way shaped memory
effect and finally I will show you some
applications of this shape memory alloy
actuators so let's begin with that what
is this shape memory effect now many of
you might have seen this movie for
example Terminator 2 which actually you
know amplifies the situation where the
robot even if you melt it down the
moment it is getting cooled it actually
gets back its original shape so that is
too much of a science fiction but indeed
material certain materials it is found
that they can actually remember their
you know parent state shape and that is
that happens particularly for certain
group of metallic alloys okay so this
parent state is generally with respect
to high temperature and whatever you do
with this metallic alloy at the low
temperature the moment you take it back
to the high temperature it will get back
to the parent ship because it can
recover the large deformations that are
imparted at a low temperature and
we will see later on that it actually
happens because of a very regular
crystal structure most of the times it
is a body-centered BCC structure that it
actually attains at a high temperature
this recovery streams imparted to the
material at a lower temperature and
which is you know actually later on
regained by heating this entire
phenomena is actually called the
shape-memory effect so we will see that
how you know step-by-step we can carry
out the deformation and then recovery of
the material the effect was first
observed in gold cadmium alloy in 1932
but gold cadmium is a very expensive
alloy so you cannot use it for
day-to-day applications neither it shows
very large amount of this shape memory
effect it was found out later on that
there are three candidates the two
ternary alloys copper zinc and aluminium
and copper aluminum nickel they show
this effect and also one binary alloy
that is nickel titanium they also very
interestingly so this effect of
shape-memory you know in it and once
again these things are discovered
particularly the nickel titanium so on
at the novel Ordnance Laboratory of USA
and hence whenever we say this product
it we actually refer it as nitinol that
in oil part is the novel ordnance
laboratory abbreviation that is added
with it now what is the competitive
advantage of SMA why should we go for
this new material if you look at it that
from the you know actuation stress point
of view piezoelectric material was
having only about 0.001 mega Newton
meter per kg you know specific actuation
stress that means per unit weight in
that same tone if you actually check
with the human muscle is slightly better
means about five times better than pzt
however this SMA is actually several
orders of magnitude higher so with the
same weight you can get much larger
actuation stress from the SMA so which
means it is a you know it is possibly a
much higher level something like you
know hundred times more powerful than
you know these other materials so that's
how you know you can have a very good
use of such materials in applications
like robotic well in terms of the strain
also if you look at it piezoelectric
material shows very very small strain
human muscle relatively shows a larger
strain but SMA shows a strain of around
0.1 so it is not very high in terms of
strain at that point one also is maximum
we call it as you know thousand parts
per million okay
ten thousand parts per million but this
is maximum generally what we get is
something or the range of three to five
thousand three to five thousand ppm so
actuation strain is not as I as a human
muscle but certainly it is higher than
piezoelectric material now when we are
talking about shaping effects there are
two different types of shaping effects
one is called one way shape memory
effect and another is called two way
effect in fact it is the one way effect
which is more you know related to the
material property and to a effect is
something that comes through the
training of the material so in the one
way effect what happens is that material
remembers the shape only at its parent
state and that parent state we will be
referring it as austenite phase which is
a high temperature phase but in the to
affect the material will remember its
shape both at austenite phase that is
high temperature phase as well as at low
temperature phase that is martensite
phase so austenite phase is high
temperature and low temperature is
martensite phase and the material will
remember
both the ships if it happens if you give
proper training then only you will see
the to effect how do we manufacture such
SMA where's wait you can see that the
basic composition is very simple nickel
and titanium but in order to have this
crystal structure which will allow the
twining it is to be very very pure so
you know and also you have to do it at a
high temperature mixing nickel and
titanium so generally we use vacuum arc
melting or induction melting process and
we have to take this in vacuum so that
you know we can take care of impurities
you can reduce it to a minimum oxides to
a minimum so at very high temperature in
vacuum we melt nickel and titanium mix
it together and then we get the ingot
which we later on draw into mostly where
forms but today it is also available in
thin strips and people are also talking
about porous SMS which has some
advantage in terms of quick temperature
dissipation we were talking about the
parent phase or the austenite phase and
the martensite phase and each phase has
its own typical crystal structure at the
austenite phase that is at the
high-energy phase high temperature phase
also there the crystal structure will be
body centered cubic or BCC structure and
it is a cubic crystal structure as you
can see that in this unit cell the all
these are of same size so it is
perfectly cubic you know structure now
the moment I actually reduce the
temperature then this changes to face
centered cubic system and so you know
from the body centered the crystal
structure becomes face centered cubic
and further many times it actually
changes from cubic system to rhombic
systems you know in terms of the crystal
shape what
example now so these are the two so bcc
at high temperature phase or austenite
phase and FCC at low temperature phase
or martensite phase we have to keep in
our mind now let us see at the low
temperature phase how it would behave
well if I reduce the temperature from
BCC to FCC we generally do not see an
appreciable change in terms of the
original shape or the size of the system
why is it that we don't see it is
because that even though it goes from
BCC to FCC but the crystals very nicely
create a fold you can see a fold here
you can see a fold here a fold here so
these folds actually take care of that
you know expansion that could have
happened in the or contractions that
could have happened in the system so
that is why there is no shape change
that you will see if you cool a system
from austenite phase to martensite phase
and this particular martensite phase is
called twinned martensite phase now so
when we are applying stress so so far we
are only applying temperature to bring
it down to join martensite phase so
let's say at low temperature we are
somewhere here where we are at that wine
martensite phase and now I am increasing
the stress as I am increasing the stress
there is a Sigma stress critical beyond
which this twine martensite state will
actually this poles will vanish the
crystals will layer these layers will
start to actually slide each crystal
layer will slide and then you are going
to get this kind of a rhombic shape so
this is your D joint martensite phase so
here Sigma SC are starting of the twine
martensite phase and then Sigma F SIA
that is finishing stress at which
complete you know
- whining has taken place so you are -
you know even though this looks like you
know plastic deformation but this is
essentially crystal twining that is
taking place in the system now once it
is in the fully de twin shape so it is
here again if I increase the stress it
will be a again like a elastic so region
okay so the same way and finally once
the stress is beyond a certain level
there will be the onset of slips and
then the plastic deformation and the
failure will take place in the system so
the initial large deformation that you
will see is not because of plastic
deformation but because of these twining
you know de twining - twining this
transformation that is happening in the
system so twining 2d twining or
determining - twine so that is what is
the low-temperature stress-strain
behavior in the system when you are only
in the martensite regime now what
happens if I look at it with respect to
temperature well if you take a sample at
a very low temperature let us say we
expect it to be here somewhere
at a completely martensite phase and
what martensite face if there is no
other stress etcetera then it is
supposed to be at the twinned martensite
phase as I am increasing the temperature
gradually okay so we will come to a
point which is called austenite start so
so far it is at the twine martensite
state and also this is having FCC
structure as we have already discussed
at s what will happen that some of these
crystals will start to get transformed
to BCC structure so now this FCC to BCC
transformation is happening but not
fully only some crystals as I am
increasing the heat further somewhere at
AF I get full transformation to
austenite so
all VCC I'll be getting at this stage
all VCC so that is you know everything
has been transformed from FCC to BCC
austenite finish I go to the parent
shape of the system what happens if I
again cool the system so this is 100%
austenite if I cool it again at a
particular temperature M is the BCC will
start to get transformed to FCC so now
BCC will start to get transformed not
all of them but just start the process
and as I reduce the temperature further
it will reach a point when martensite
finish will come and it will complete
this and it will be completely
martensite and it will be having
completely FCC structure so that is a
temperature dependent behavior now look
at it that when this is happening this M
s and M F they are not actually coming
at the same point neither s and F so
there is a hysteresis that is always
present in the system
now that hysteresis you know is
something which we will see later on
that in terms of stress we can actually
exploit it as pseudo elasticity in terms
of temperature this hysteresis for an
actuator is not very good the narrower
it is the better is the system now let
us look into the one way shape memory
effect just once again because it is
little bit complex so let us see that I
have taken a beam here and I am bending
the beam Here I am giving a deformation
bending the beam and this is at its
original shape that is at austenite high
temperature now I am simply cooling this
system what will happen I told you that
there will be no change of shape so if I
cool it there will be no change of safe
length is still the same which means
here also in the bent case there is no
change of shape but only it will get
converted from austenite to twined
martensite phase
now if I apply load so I am deforming I
am applying load and then if I apply the
load what will happen is that there will
be a change of shape that will happen to
the system and that means this you know
twine martensite is going in the
martensite face in the deterrent shape
now again if I heat it up beyond a
certain austenite finish of course
beyond austenite finish we will get 100%
recovery so you will get back the
original shape just like this ship in
this case also you get back the original
shape just like this okay so that is the
one way shape memory effect and how
people got excited about it it's
phenomenal that you know they first
thought of NASA that let us make an
antenna out of the shape memory alloy
wears and then let us you know at the
martensite stage know temperature stage
you know
let us deform it because that the
martensite stage you can deform it okay
so you squeeze it
that whole antenna you can make it at
the austenite phase and then you squeeze
it and you can make a small roll out of
it now the moment you deploy it in the
space you increase the temperature it
goes to austenite phase and you get the
full antenna back so that was how you
know first applications were actually
and resized of this one way shape memory
effect now what if so far we have not
done two things together what if I do
both the things together temperature and
stress okay so there are three
parameters here in this system stress
and temperature and strain okay let us
say we start from a situation one okay
and where you know this whole thing is
supposed to get the twine martensite
phase I am increasing the load so d
twining is happening and I will be
reaching to if I increase the load
further the material would have failed
but I don't want to do it I am reducing
the load now if I reduce the load it
will not actually get back to its
original shape because they are
this determining - twining you know that
load release will only bring it back to
the partial the elastic part of the
recovery then I heat it up as I heat it
up it actually goes to 0.4 and here full
recovery has taken place full recovery
of the ship and then if I cool it up
then what will happen it will go back to
its you know martensite state that is
here we should say that the twined
martensite state here and that would not
mean there will be any more change of
strain strain is zero okay but only that
it will get converted from the austenite
to the twined martensite phase so that
is the whole diagram we have to keep in
our mind now there is something which is
called pseudo elasticity now the way the
whole thing happens is that in the
austenite phase that is at the high
temperature phase if without changing
the temperature if I only apply stress
then what happens is that this austenite
phase can get converted to the d2 ID
martensite phase and this procedure okay
so you know directly that means you know
you are not coming to twine martensite
phase but directly between austenite to
Detroit martensite phase transformation
this has lot of hysteresis in it and
that is why this you know elasticity
that means it is not perfectly elastic
but it is because of a stress induced
phase transformation and neither it is
plastic so that is why it is pseudo
elastic and this involves large
hysteresis and that is used for
structural damping due to large
hysteresis in the in this particular
transformation process so that is pseudo
elasticity which we will show later on
that can be used in structural damping
in fact this is what is the stress
induced transformation diagram you can
see that you are at the austenite phase
increasing this stress
and it is going to directly to the
divine martensite phase so here this
determining is complete de twined
martensite phase there is no change of
temperature remember and then as I am
reducing the load okay I will come back
to the austenite state here and this
process has a full hysteresis that you
can see now what if I do not take it to
complete design martensite phase that is
possible in this case it will be partial
pseudo elasticity as you can see that
you are going partially and coming back
and there will be some amount of
recovery strain that will be there in
the system so complete pseudo elasticity
will bring it can bring it back to the
zero strain condition but partial pseudo
elasticity will have some amount of
remnant strain in the system now what
are the commercial applications of this
you know effect well the first effect
actually came from you know one of the
aircraft applications in biracial
corporation and this is known as cryocon
so what they have done in this case is
that this is used for joining tubes in
aerospace systems so initially the shape
will be oval ring of SMA and that will
be set at the martensite phase oval ring
okay and then you can easily join the
two system at that shape let us say you
design it in that manner and this is
happening when it is cryo cooled which
means it is fully at the martensite
phase now you remove that cryogenic
condition so it will go back to its
memorized safe and we memorize save is
actually a circular you know ring okay
so the moment that happens then there is
a tightening because it is squeezing
inside the human joints the system so as
a result you know you can fit it at the
cryogenic condition and get a complete
beautiful connectivity between the
system that was the first effect using
one way a semi
now one way SME remembers only warship
that is the high temperature ship but if
you actually you know reduce the
temperature then this memory gets erased
however if you do it in a cyclic manner
then what will happen that is what we
call the training then it will remember
both the high and the low temperature
shape and that is in some applications
very much useful that you get both high
as well as the low temperature ship say
for example you have this as the
original shape when temperature is less
than martensite finish you are
plastically deforming the system okay so
you are in that bend shape now you are
heating it up but only partially you are
recovering okay so you are coming back
to the austenite phase and then from
this stage if I cool it temperature is
now less than MF okay I am getting this
particular shape and I have to repeat in
this cycle continuously if I do it then
it will be trained and in that case
where whenever every time you will
actually you know cool it you will get
this shape so not only you will get the
austenite shape but also you will get
the martensite shape every time and that
is what is the two way shape nori effect
that you will get in the system now
there are lot of applications of these
for example the two AFS can be used for
control of aerodynamic surfaces so that
you can vent it in a manner that it goes
from one shape to another shape so you
can use it for flapping of wings for
example then you can use it for as micro
coils for vibration isolation you can
use this system grasping by robotic
fingers people have tried it
space exploration like a rock splitting
nitinol filters deployment of solar
array hinges there are many such space
applications that are thought of by
using this effect some of the very
specific effect that we are doing in lab
Tereza for example we have two series of
SMA where's one below and one you know
one top one below of a cantilever beam
and then by actuating each one of them
so like you know if you consider that
this one you just have time versus
current you pass it in a manner that it
is like this so at a repeated cycle you
are doing it and so this is I 1 let us
say for this one I 1 and let us say for
this one current is i2 so if I plot I 2
versus T I just do it just the reverse
manner that means like this so by
repeatedly you know periodically heating
up the top and the bottom you can
actually generate if you look at time
versus displacement of any particular
point let us say I am trying to plot the
X the displacement of this point I would
be actually getting this kind of a
deflection in the system so that's how
you can generate vibration in a system
people have used to eat for the Chevron
using SMA actuators by bowing and what
they have done is that if you look at it
that this part is actually jagged okay
so at the you know beginning when you
are the taking off is happening at that
time this part is jagged and as the heat
increases so this jaggedness actually
helps in terms of attenuation okay so
the sound will be much less this you
will see in Dreamliner all Dreamliner's
if you look at it you will see that this
technology is there now as the
temperature is increasing the aircraft
is going at the you know high altitude
you do not the sound doesn't matter
anymore and this that temperature will
make it actually flat so this will
become flatter so that you get more oil
efficiency from the system so that's how
this particular system is very cleverly
designed there you you know there is
also another example of amplified a semi
actuator to further amplify so let us
say this is the
to me you know at this core and as you
are shortening it is like these two
points where you are getting a
mechanical amplification of the system
by using archetype of a mechanism so
thus you can actually further amplify
the deformation one last use that I want
to talk about is actually so far I have
only talked about SME based actuators
but now I want to just show one last
slide on a cinema sensor so in this case
what you can do is that that suppose you
have a micro switch team and you have
SMA where's okay and you have a system
which is actually having two such micro
switches as you can see a and B and you
have to point touching two parts of the
conductive strips now if this system
rotates what happens that there are
certain times when the these two stylus
will be over two of these conductive
strips so whenever they will be at the
two conductive strips there will be
current which will be flowing and as the
current will be flowing then you will be
getting the heating here and this switch
that we have here that switch will be
actually pressed so that means the
current will be flowing on the next
moment if one of them goes here that
means the current is not there so it
will once again lift up so you will be
able to see this kind of a you know
current flowing and again no current
current flowing no current situation now
if you have two such switches with a
phase lag between them then there is a
phase difference that you are getting
between two adjacent switches so by
measuring this phase delay you should be
able to say that how fast the angular
rotation Omega is taking place in this
disk and by integrating that you should
be also able to say how much of angular
deformation has taken place so this can
be used for sensing of you know angular
sensing by using SMA so briefly I have
told you that what is the shape memory
effect I have told you about
- Maury effects one way to way and
pseudo elasticity and I have talked
about the shape memory actuators and
shape memory based sensors in this
particular overview in the next lecture
I will talk about introduction to
composites thank you
[Music]
[Music]
