noc18-mm11 Lec 16-History of Dislocations

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
So, now we move on from point defects to dislocation.
We move on from 0D to 1D defects, but it does not mean that we will forget our friend point
defects.
We will come back to it because dislocation at many a places interacts with point defects
and many of the phenomena that we know are present because of the interaction of dislocation
with these point defects, particularly if you remember or if you have been exposed to
mechanical metallurgy, then you would know of the phenomena in yield point behavior.
So that is some phenomena that takes place because of the interaction of dislocation
with point defects.
So we will come back to it every once in a while, but now our focus would be dislocations.
So let us start with dislocations.
So the first thing that you should be aware of when we are talking about dislocation is
a brief history of how the concept of dislocations were developed.
So the first thing or the most important thing you should realize is that dislocations were
formulated and their properties developed in terms of elastic and plastic properties
were understood long before they were even seen first time directly.
So people were able to realize that there is something called defects inside a crystal
even before they had long before even they had seen it.
So how was that possible?
So that is what we will look at briefly.
So there is a long history on how dislocations were developed.
There were several people involved or several people contributed in steps, but most important
of those were Orovan, Poliani and Taylor.
We will come to them, but before that who has contributed and what have they contributed
we will see in a short note.
So there were Larmor, Darwin and Button.
These were somewhere in the late 19th century.
What did they contribute?
They were the first to introduce something called a strain figures which we can now relate
to the concept that we know of dislocation and strain that arises because of that.
Later on, Wengerton he suggested that dislocations are necessary meaning this concept of dislocations.
Remember that we people have not seen dislocations yet.
He said that dislocations are necessary.
So that time people were not aware why or how the deformation takes place.
They just know or observe the phenomena that deformation is taking place and they are hypothesizing
several things.
So someone suggested Larmor, Darwin suggested strain figures, Wengerton suggested dislocations
and he also suggested that dislocations are necessary if strains are to be bound.
If you do not consider what he meant was that if you do not consider a dislocation
like structure then the strains can become infinite which we know is not possible.
Then Tempe in early 20th century he introduced to the field or to the concept stress fields.
Then Volterra came and remember all of them were not using the term dislocations.
For example, Volterra used the term distortion which meant both dislocation and disclination.
We will talk about what are dislocation and disclination, but what we are talking about
now as dislocation was not like I said was not known to them.
So they were talking in different terms, but most likely they were referring to these concepts
and Volterra described elastic properties based on this model which is a very famous
Volterra model.
He described the elastic properties.
Then Loeb in 1920 he theorized for the first time something like a theory he put together
for dislocations.
From this stage there were several more improvement where lot of people contributed.
For example, later dislocations were distinguished from disclinations.
So far people were and you will see what is the difference we will talk about Volterra
model, but so far whenever people talked about these defects as line defects they were including
both dislocation and disclination.
So at this stage somewhere between 1920 to 1934 dislocation and disclination were distinguished.
Then came the contribution of White, Prandtl, Taylor, Kamaguchi somewhere around 1930s.
They came up with series of defects or theorized series of defects to explain discrepancy between
theoretical actual strength and the observed strength.
So they came up with series of defects.
So they will soon see what do we mean by weakening of crystal, but people observed this phenomena
weakening of crystal or basically much lower strength than what is theoretically expected
and they were trying to explain it and this is the first time they put together a series
of defects which would be able to explain this weakness in the crystals.
So they theorized series of defects to explain discrepancy between theoretical strength and
observed strength.
Next came the most important of all these where the theory was finally put in a much
more formal way and which actually became the genesis of theory of dislocations.
So this was proposed by Orovan and Pogliani in 1934.
So they initiated the theory of dislocation theory of slip.
So slip that occurs because of presence of dislocation and this was able to explain weakening
of crystal.
On the other hand in the same year Taylor came up with another model similar to this
what we know which says that why the micro cracks the shear micro cracks can lead to
strain hardening.
So you see this is kind of a contradictory work contradictory results, but the origin
is same that is the nature of dislocations.
So Orovan and Pogliani they are talking about dislocation to understand why the crystals
are weaker than what they should be.
On the other hand Taylor has theorized or used dislocation to explain why they should
be deformed material should have higher strength.
So this is a kind of a contradictory and very interesting phase of dislocations which led
to the discovery of or the understanding of theory of dislocations.
So this was the origin and later on Orovan has also contributed in models of dislocation
multiplication and Taylor has contributed to plasticity models.
So this is the brief history of dislocations that one should be aware of how they were
discovered.
Now let us yeah so this is the model, but one thing that I missed here is that when
was it first observed.
So in 1934 it is still as a theory and when is it actually observed Hirsch and Bollman
in the year 1956 that is when first time that direct observation of dislocation was done
in TM.
So you can see that until 1956 people did not know that this there is something exist
like really exist like dislocation, but just based on the external nature external observation
they were able to theorize such a perfect theory for dislocations.
Now let us move on to what we have been calling as weakening of crystal.
So we know that there were 2 different aspects which led to the understanding or theory of
dislocation.
One was the weakening of crystal and the other was strengthening of the material because
of dislocation.
So what is the weakening, what is the theory that we are talking about which is weakening
of crystals.
So assume that you are in the era of 1930s where people have not observed dislocation,
but what you know is that materials deform at certain strength or basically you know
the yield point of the material.
Now you would think how is this phenomena occurring atomistically.
So one of the models that people said that should lead to deformation is let us say you
have crystals like this.
So now if you are applying some shearing on to this then or some kind of tension or stress
on to it then for the deformation to occur atoms must move relative to each other and
that relative motion would mean that one plane should move with respect to the other plane.
Therefore if you are applying at some local level this layer of atom would move to the
right this with respect to this or this layer of atom would move to the left and you will
have final structure like this.
This is just a very, very small strain associated with this movement, but several such movement
would lead to the overall large deformation that is the theory and therefore if you look
at it this will become we can call this as b some vector b.
Now let us look at how this stress and energy should look like.
Over here if you look at the energy then this is low energy state and this is low energy
state and in between these two there would be a high energy state.
So this energy plot if you want to plot it should look like.
So most likely this is representing when the atoms, so let us say we are talking about
a and b which becomes a and b over here.
So this is a, this is b and over here this is a, this is b and in between somewhere you
will have configuration where the energy is highest a sitting just over b.
So this is the transition mode over here and if you take a derivative of this you will
get the stress that is acting on to it and you will get some relation like this.
So what you can see here is that somewhere over here you have zero stress not somewhere,
but the region where you have a and b in the lowest energy position you have zero stress
required when the a and b are again in the final position then you again you have zero
stress required.
Somewhere over here there is zero stress, but it does not mean it is stable position
if you just push it a little bit then negative stress is required or it will automatically
come down to this position this is what this implies, this plot implies.
Now here if you look at, so this is tau which is the shear stress and therefore this amplitude
would be called tau max.
So this tau which has a sinusoidal relation can be written like tau max sin 2 pi x by
b.
For small x this can be it reduces to tau equal to tau max 2 pi x by b.
So this is if this is a very small quantity we can say this tau is equal to tau max 2
pi x b or this is only when x is much less than b, but we also know that the usual relation
which is tau is approximately equal to g which is the modulus times the strain.
And therefore when you compare this what we see is that tau max is equal to g by 2 pi.
So the shear strength of the material that is what you would need if you want deformation
because you must apply at least this much of stress for the atom to move and if you
apply continuously this kind of stress then the atoms can keep moving.
So this tau max is related to g by 2 pi and you must have this relation shows that this
minimum stress that is required for deformation to keep occurring this should be equal to
tau should be equal to g by 2 pi.
Now what is the actually the case this is where what will be called as the theoretical
strength and g by 2 pi can be approximated as g by 10 taking into account some other
factors we have missed.
So now let us look at what is really the observed case let us talk about steel what is the theoretical
what is the observed.
If you look at the g by 2 pi then the theoretical strength should be 8 Giga Pascal if we talk
about even something like copper then its strength should be 4.5 Giga Pascal.
Now do you know what is the actual observed strength of these materials for steel it is
somewhere of the order of 400 Mega Pascal and we consider it to be a very strong material.
Copper is not so strong it is of the order of 70 Mega Pascal.
What do we see we see that the actual or observed strength is much lower than what we would
assume or what we will theoretically calculate assuming that dislocation or deformation takes
place slip of the planes.
So certainly this is not the way slip is taking place and something else is aiding into that
and what is it that is aiding into that.
So plastic deformation proceeds atomic step by step meaning we will show it in a minute.
So now if we will come back to our more descriptive model of dislocation but for now let us say
this is a crystal now you can imagine that this is a dislocation which is it is a defect
because this plane is not going all the way to the end this plane terminates inside it
in a perfect crystal this plane should not go all the way to the other end and this is
a line because we are looking at 2D if you go 3D then this is a line.
So this is a 1D defect and this is a defect that is first for sure.
Now what how can this actually move it can move in steps.
So if you apply stress on the from left to right on the top side and on the bottom side
from right to left then what will happen.
So what do we see here that this dislocation in steps has moved from here to the next plane
to the last plane and this is the phenomena that leads to the deformation and you can
see that you do not need to shear whole plane only one line one line of plane one line of
defects is being broken and being moved and therefore that the energy required which we
much much the not the energy but the stress required would be much smaller.
In fact even this model will have more as we will develop more understanding even in
these line defects you develop steps which are called kinks and jogs.
So those kinks and jogs are what lead to the movement of this whole dislocation.
So the real stress required is even much even further lower than what we know.
So the plastic deformation proceeds atomic step by step by generation and movement of
dislocation.
So somewhere you will also get generation of dislocation in case there are not sufficient
and even if it is sufficient for larger deformation you may need larger number of deformation
larger number of dislocations and therefore generation has to take place and generation
and movement of dislocation is what leads to plastic deformation overall of the material.
So now what we will look at what we have looked at is the weakening of the crystal.
Next we will look at the work hardening of crystal.
So we said that so we said that there are two different and contradictory phenomena
which led to the understanding of dislocation one was the weakening of the crystal that
we have explained and now we also explained how the presence of dislocation can explain
that why the observed strength is lower than theoretical strength.
Now we will see that why the presence of this no not why actually at this stage we
will just show what do we mean by work hardening of crystal.
So let us say you have annealed sample.
So somewhere the dislocation if we draw the dislocation density versus strength at this
stage we will not be able to understand why but we will just understand what this means
we will come back to the why in later stages.
So this is the let us say the annealed sample what do we mean by annealed sample one which
has very minimal amount of dislocation density and how do we do that basically we put it
at high temperature so that whatever stresses are there they get relieved and when the stresses
get relieved it means that the dislocations have annihilated and you have strain free
crystals.
So annealed polycrystalline sample or material they have but that does not mean that they
have zero dislocation that is something you must understand that dislocations although
not thermodynamically stable defect like point defect they are always present in a material
and even in a annealed crystal strain free crystals you will have dislocations of the
order of 10 to the power 14 per meter square.
Now what is the anomaly over here anomaly is that if you keep increasing the dislocation
density then it is observed that the strength increases.
So your strength for example if you do rolling, if you do forging, if you do severe plaster
deformation in all these cases dislocation density is increasing and concomitant with
that simultaneous to that strength of the material increases.
So this is your work hardened material as the name suggests it is hardened meaning it
has higher hardness higher strength and over here you will have dislocation density something
10 to the power 16 to 10 to the power 17 depending on what kind of or how much deformation has
been given.
So this is what we mean when we say work hardening of crystal.
However, now let us also include our earlier understanding which is the weakening of crystal.
Now if the dislocation density were very, very small somewhere like this over here which
is almost what is called as defect free whiskers or dislocation free whiskers.
Then from our earlier part we know that now the deformation has to take place by slipping
of the whole plane and therefore the strength is now so much, much, much higher.
In fact even higher than work hardened samples.
So this is another you can say anomaly or the part of the same understanding where when
we said that weakening of the crystal as well as work hardening of the crystal both of them
led to understanding of dislocation.
So this is the weakening of the crystal meaning when you have defect free whiskers you have
very high strength, but in unusual annealed material where the defect densities of the
order of 10 to the power 14 per meter square strength is lower.
And again if you go beyond this then again it starts to gain strength, but this particular
strength is much, much higher this is orders of magnitude higher than these and these.
And similarly if you keep increasing the dislocation it drops very sharply, but still it will have
a continuous distribution and you will have a strength versus dislocation density plot
something like this.
Now to further expand our understanding on to the density of dislocations let us understand
what happens to lithium fluoride crystals.
Now in lithium fluoride initially there may be the density of mobile dislocation what
is called as mobile because these are the ones that will contribute to hardening.
They are very small.
So if you take a very high density or sorry high purity lithium fluoride crystal you will
get strength something like this.
So this is okay let me just so here we have shear strain and then we have shear stress.
So if you are talking about a very high purity crystal when the dislocation density is very
small then shear strength would be very high and it will be like this, but once you have
started deforming then the dislocation density starts to increase and therefore the shear
stress drops.
Now if you take a material with a little lesser quality meaning it has to begin with some
dislocation density then it will show a little less increase in the strength in the beginning
and very soon it will start to add dislocations and it will drop like this and if you take
even poorer quality dislocation poor quality lithium fluoride crystals it will start to
deform at a much lower shear stress and at a much lower strain and dislocation would
get start to generated and it will drop as expected because now the dislocation density
starts to increase.
So here what we have is so when you go in this direction improving quality of crystals
when we say improving quality what we mean is lower density of dislocations.
So this is again something that helps us understand what is the phenomena that is taking place
over here.
So now we have understood the basic history of dislocation and the 2 contradicting aspects
that led to this discovery.
Now let us move on to begin our understanding for this dislocation, but like I said one
of the other things that people were always relating dislocations with was disclination.
So what we will look at next is the model of the Volterra model which describes dislocations
and disclinations.
Now when in the Volterra model what is done is basically we you take a hollow tube of
material.
So it is probably somewhere from inside a crystal and you assume that the crystal is
broken along this line or it is cut along this line.
So this is a hollow tube.
So this is in this particular model we take a hollow tube with a cut on up to the edge.
Now you can realize that there are 2 faces to this.
How you deform the 2 faces it will lead to either dislocation or disclination.
If the 2 faces are just being translated then you get dislocations and if you are giving
some kind of angular opening to it then it leads to disclination.
So with this basic definition or basic understanding of dislocation and disclination with respect
to Volterra model I will leave it here and we will pick up from this point in the next
lecture.
