noc18-hs37-lecture 20

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
Welcome back to the new understanding about the perspective.
I think we have to recall the previous things that we have discussed and in extension to
that let us try to understand Indian society further in those perspective that we have
discussed.
So, I think keeping previous deliberations in mind, let us try to have the further deliberations
so that it will enhance your further understanding about the Indian society.
So, I think when we try to speak about the Indian society, let us have these things in
mind.
Especially when we try to see Ambedkar's contribution, I think he had made many important
statements like one statement that has to be recalled and regained from Ambedkar is
a freedom of mind is the real freedom.
And he was more to be observed in terms of that the people have to overcome the resistance
which is part of the mind in that sense and such.
So, the freedom of the mind is to be seen as the ultimate freedom.
And a person whose mind is not free, though he may be having full of chains, but he may
be treated as a slave.
So, one should see that the person whose mind is not free should be seen as a bondage in
that sense as such.
And he says that in order to overcome this, we have to have the freedom of mind which
of course is the real proof of one's existence in the life.
Then we also try to see that he had also formulated in 1937, the independent labour party and
this independent labour party was again an important aspect of his life which we try
to see is going to be significant with regard to the presentation of the lower caste.
Now, this independent labour party which was having its presence in 1937 was basically
speaking about the contributions of what you can say the lower caste in terms of political
unity as a formation of a political party, he wanted to make that we have to have the
political front for fighting against the tyranny on them.
Then we also try to see that he has also made a very significant contribution with regard
to the women, especially his contribution which has been visible through the formation
of a Mahad Agadhi front which was basically a front led by the women in that sense which
he tried to call it as a Mahila Agadhi front, Mahila Agadhi front basically by the Mahad
women in that sense as such.
And the issue which he was raising up of course is that the women are also to be politically
empowered and that is how he is trying to make the upliftment and empowerment of the
women.
Apart from that he had a strong fight for what you can say talking about the evils which
are associated in and around the women's life, especially he was trying to have certain
amount of antagonism with regard to the tyranny which the Hinduism have on the women in general,
especially he was fighting against the Hindu code bill and for that he had a strong resistance
especially he wanted to work upon and transform the Hindu code bill which he says is a important
source of exploitation for the women in general.
And in that way he tries to have certain uncovers of these issues, then also it is not that
he simply wanted to put the things, he wanted to have an ideological statement, he also
wanted to make the things in action and especially not only in the case of polity, he also wanted
to have that there should be the contribution of the lower caste in the case of the nation
building, like he tried to work for the formation of the specific soldier team which he tried
to call it as the mahar regiment.
And this mahar regiment was a representation of the contribution of the lower caste in
the creation and in safeguarding the nation and the national interest.
So, that is how he is trying to put the people at the different fronts economically, politically
and also in terms of the nation building that is how he is trying to talk about the issue
of upliftment.
And his social philosophy which is basically been said to have enshrined the three important
issues, one of course happens to be the issue of liberty that is one, then you have the
equality and the third is the fraternity.
So, he was talking about these particular issues which are going to be relevant when
he is trying to speak about the social philosophy of enrichment and enlightenment that you have
to have an element of liberty, the freedom in that sense as such which has to be seen
in terms of the freedom of mind which we have discussed earlier.
Equality if we have to see, it has to be seen in terms of the brotherhood, in terms of the
relationship which has to be there between the different categories of the people.
And also the fraternity which has to be with the similar other groups with of whom we are
part.
So, virtually we have to see that we have to have certain amount of amalgamation, certain
amount of coming togetherness in that sense as such which has to be seen on all the fronts,
on the political fronts, on the economic fronts and also on the social fronts and that is
how he is trying to believe upon that we can have the formation of the new India.
And with regard to that freedom that we said, I think he has his own understanding about
what the democracy is.
He said that democracy is merely not a form of government, rather it is a primarily a
mode of associated living.
So, we try to speak about democracy in terms of not a political agenda, rather it has to
be seen in terms of an associated living that is living together.
And also to have conjoined, communicated, act or experiences in that sense that is another
important aspect that we have to see.
And ultimately the essence of the democracy, it lies in having the attitude of respect
and reverence to the fellow men.
So, ultimately we try to see that democracy is not to be seen as having the political
character, rather it has to be seen in terms of the change in the mindset, change in the
common living and also an attitude of respect for others of the fellow workers with whom
we are putting up.
And he had, as I said that he has written and documented the Mooknayak that is one thing
and also Bhahishkarath Bharat that was another significant work which has been referred,
which of course has been written and been edited by him in a historical phase.
And we try to see that his constitutional arrangement which he tries to frame about,
it tries to represent the society in totality, especially when we try to see that democracy
which we try to see is part of the Indian society, it should not be seen as a top dressing,
rather it should have the real essential character in terms of the undemocratic practices.
So, in order to have the constitutional framework of democracy in a real sense, it has to be
documented and practiced in the real life, that of course should be the part and parcel
of the understanding of the Indian society.
And if you try to see that when he was talking about this issue of caste, especially one
of his famous statement which he tries to speak about is talking about the issue of
annihilation of caste, annihilation of caste and its enemies, annihilation of caste and
its enemies, that was an important slogan which has been raised by Ambedkar.
And this annihilation of caste, he was basically been charged by Marxian understanding that
is the annihilation of the class enemies.
So, he tries to see it and imbibe like he had Ambedkar, then Marx and Buddha, the combination
of the three, the work which he has tried to make out in that sense and he tries to
speak about the annihilation of caste and its enemies in that particular work.
And apart from that, he said that caste cannot be abolished by simple means, if we have to
abolish caste, it has to be abolished not simply by having the inter-caste dinners
coming together, rather it has to be abolished if we have the inter-caste marriages, because
endogamy is the source of exploitation and differences between the various caste groups.
So, if we have to end the caste system, I think we have to not simply eat together,
rather the inter-caste marriages if it is there, then it can result into a better outcome.
So, he was seeing that caste is basically seen as a state of the mind and one has to
really change the state of mind in order to improve upon the things and he see caste basically
as the disease of the mind, because it is so enforcing and also impressing upon and
also trying to make the people to act in that particular fashion and for that he was putting
that it is the Hindu religion, which is responsible for having these evils, which have been practiced
in the name of caste. And finally, when he was trying to move out
from Hinduism and adopt Buddhism, although he has a resistance, but he tries to give
an alternative path, because it was not simply saying, but also saying and doing and which
he tried to see in terms of a practitioner. And when he is trying to see that what we
have to do and what I have done as a important leader, I have been able to do what after
passing through the crushing miseries and the endless struggles all my life has faced,
basically fighting with the opponents. Opponents both the caste system, the contenders,
the political leaders in that sense, the parties in that sense and he said that I have
brought this Karwan, when it has to be seen today, means a sort of a journey, which he
has tracked and where he is trying to see that lots of hurdles, what he had faced. Ultimately,
he was in a position to overcome all these issues by his own effort and this is how we
have to see the transformation in the life. So, this is the message, which he wanted to
give to the people, not as a leader, but he wanted to say that these things are to
be seen in terms of the practices, which the people have to adopt at the different period
of time. And his final message, which he wanted to give and that was a sensible message and
that basically we try to see it in terms of an important trio, that is the educate, organize
and agitate.
So, this was a trio mantra, which he says is an important issue, if we have to fight
the battle of freedom. So, in order to have the fight or battle for freedom, we have to
have this particular issue of education, organization and agitation, which will be a supplementing
issue, when we try to see the transformation. And especially, he wanted to speak about not
only the caste system, he was also speaking about the Hinduism in that in a specific fashion,
like when he was trying to speak about the caste, he has gone through the understanding
the caste and one of his famous work, that he has written and documented is the Genesis
of Caste System. Now, in this whole work, he was talking about
various aspect in which the caste system has emerged through history and through this readings
only, he tries to build up the theory on the caste and also how we can have the possibilities,
which can make us away from the caste system. Now, that is one important work, where he
is speaking about this annihilation of the caste enemies in that sense as such, then
apart from that his contribution also lies in the very fact, that he tried to speak about
the revolution and counter revolution, that was another significant contribution, he also
has contributed towards the issue of economy in that sense as such, that of course is again
an important aspect, which has been reflected by Ambedkar.
And with regard to the formation of the Indian society in terms of a important entity, he
says that there are to have the different levels of reforms and he talks about the reforms
at the three levels, the first level in that sense of course, is that you have to have
the social, you have to have the economic and then you have to have the political. So,
he was talking about the reforms, that has to take place at the three fronts, the social
economic and the political, social in terms of the fraternity, that is the sense of brotherhood
between of relationships between the different categories of people.
In the economic, his major concern was to move away from the division of labour, which
was in prescribed and that division of labour has to be abolished, rather anybody has can
adopt any source of occupation. So, it should not be caste based occupation rather of course,
occupation of choice, that is having based on certain skills, which the person has, he
can have his own way of generating and creating the occupations.
And in the front of political, he was trying to see it in terms of the representation,
that is the representation, which is going to be meaningful in terms of the political
aspect as such, that is the way, in which he tries to see, that all these things will
lead to the transformation of the Hindu social order. So, if you want to overcome the Hindu
social order, if you want to go for the specific understanding about the changeover of the
Hindu society, definitely we have to work on these three lines, then we can have a better
understanding about the Indian society. And apart from that, another significant issue,
which one has to raise about Ambedkar, apart from his tyranny over the caste, he has also
tried to work upon along with certain other categories of people, like as we shared, that
he has tried to formulate a political party, he tried to put the women's in the open
front, basically in the public sphere, he also had tried to abolish the notion of untouchability,
which he has tried to prove through the Mahatang Satyagraha.
So, these are the various aspects, which Ambedkar has touched upon and it basically tries to
represent the Indian society in a new way. Now, apart from Ambedkar, as I said, that
another prominent name, which we can say is relevant to the understanding of the Dalit
perspective is Gayle Oumwet. And Gayle Oumwet, if you try to see, she was basically an American
born Indian scholar, a socialist and also a human right activist. And Oumwet has been
involved in the Dalit and the anti-caste movement, especially the fight over the environmental
issues, the farmers and the women's movement. So, in that way, of course, Gayle Oumwet's
contribution has to be very significant in terms of the revolutionary changes, which
she tried to bring about in the upliftment of the Dalit. And Oumwet was basically trying
to put his position as a part of, what you can say, fighting against the Hindutva agenda,
where she was basically trying to have overpowered the discrimination, which is associated with
the caste system. So, that was the significant areas on which
Gayle Oumwet has focused upon. And it was basically, she was part of this Dalit activities
forum in 2001 at the world conference of fighting against the racism. And there she was talking
about the issue of biologically inferior and socially dangerous categories of people,
which is more dangerous even than the race. So, Oumwet's assertion was that there should
be a cultural revolt in the colonial society and the non-Brahmin movement in the western
India, that was one significant contribution or the message, which she wanted to make.
Then she also had worked on reinventing the revolution, that is a new social movement
in India. She has also worked upon gender and technology, the emerging Asian visions,
then also Dalits and the democratic revolutions and also the Dalit vision. I think Dalit vision
appears to be a meaningful work, which tries to narrate upon the Dalit perspective in a
specific fashion. And this Dalit vision, which has been an outcome of the collection of certain
writings, which she tried to focus upon. If you try to just have a glance to the work,
which has been put by Gayle Oumwet in the Dalit vision and if you go by the title itself,
I think many things are there, which are basically, been talked about by Gayle Oumwet in a specific
fashion. Like, she was speaking about the two great
traditions of India and also the construction of Hinduism, that is the two great traditions
with regard to the Aryans, the Davidians and also how the Hinduism has started emerging
in terms of a sort of a modification. Then it was also that apart from Hinduism, she
was also talking about before Hinduism, that is the Buddhist vision, how the Buddhist has
tried to work upon the understanding of the Hindu society, the Indian society. And another
important thing, which has been pointed in another work, in another chapter of course,
is that before Hinduism, that is the devotional vision of Bhakti, where of course, she is
trying to narrate the contribution of Kabir, Tukaram and many other people, who tried to
work upon the evils, the social evils associated with the Hinduism through the various devotional
Bhakti activities and that also has transformed the life of the lower caste.
Then another work, where she is trying to focus upon Jyotiva Phule, that is Hinduism
and the Brahminical exploitation, that was another work. Then on the issue of patriarchy,
because Hinduism also was been seen as a symbol of patriarchy and in that, it was basically,
the contribution of Ramabai and Tarabai, which has been significantly rated by Gayle Oumwet.
Then she was also speaking about the Dalit radicals of 1920s, that was been there during
the Aryan context and also discussing about the contribution of Ambedkar in terms of the
revolution and the counter revolution. So, these are significant works, which Gayle
Oumwet was trying to highlight and at the end, if you try to see in the later phase
of this book of the Dalit vision, we try to find out that Periyar and the National Quotient,
that is the Hinduism as the Delhi rule, because we try to see that Hinduism was been regulated
and controlled by the Delhi rule. So, the question of the South, that is Periyar, how
he was trying to work upon the sort of anti-Brahminical move in the South has also been taken up by
Gayle Oumwet. And then talking about the contemporary issues
of contemporary relevance, especially the Dalit Panthers, which were fighting against
the feudal backwardness and also the logic of Dalit politics, which has emerged in the
contemporary India. And especially, she is trying to focus upon the rise of the Bhaujan
Samajwad party and this Bhaujan Samajwad party basically, starting with the Kalsiram's
contribution, how he tried to build up and how that can be seen as an important revolution
in making the history in a new way. Now, the important thing is that, these aspects
if you try to see, I think all of them are depicting the understanding of the Indian
society in one way or the other, but they are trying to see the Indian society in a
very specific mode, that is on the one hand, you have the tyranny of the caste, in one
you have the tyranny of Hinduism, on the other work we try to see, there is a tyranny of
the patriarchy, the patriarchal values, which are associated with the caste system and Hinduism
in that sense as such. Then, on the other, we also try to see that,
there is a cause for the centralization of the Delhi in terms of the rule, that is another
important issue, which has to be debated out. And then, we try to see that, how we have
the formation of the regional and the local parties in the different parts of the country,
especially we have the emergence of BSP or we have the contribution as Dalit Panthers,
which are seen as the revolutionary and the radical masses on the political lines.
So, I think if you try to see these contributions, then I think we have to really see that, the
Dalit vision which I have shared earlier in terms of a perspective, it has to be evolved
in a very different lines, in a sense that, then Dalit is not simply, the Dalit perspective
should not be limited to the Hinduism alone or to the Brahminic hegemony. Rather, it has
to be seen in many other fronts and that has to be visible through many forces and it has
to be seen in terms of incorporations, which tries to rework upon the understanding of
the Indian society, their contribution, the contribution of the lower caste in the making
of India. And in that way, if you try to see this connect,
then somewhere we try to see that, the Dalit perspective goes along with the subaltern
perspective. In a sense that, the subaltern perspective tries to rework on or rewrite
on the Indian history and also trying to have the voices of the voiceless. And here, we
have the Dalit perspective, which is also trying to have the representation of the assertion
and also the transformation of the Indian society in a specific way.
So, the, we can say to some extent that, Dalit perspective can be seen as part of the so
called subaltern school, the subaltern perspective. And in that way, we can see that, there is
certain amount of assertion, the amount of commonality, which is there between the Dalit
and the subaltern perspective. But again, we have to see that, subaltern
perspective does not encompass many things, which have been talked about, when we try
to speak about the Dalit perspective in totality, especially the Dalit region, which has been
talked about by Gale Omwen and many other works in that sense as such, where we do not
find many shades of subaltern in terms of the writing of the history. So, I think, we
have to see them differently in terms of its, what you can say, the approach in terms
of a specific strategy for working and fighting against the various issues in that sense as
such. And the Dalit perspective basically, has a
meaning, when it is to be seen in terms of having certain amount of revolutionary character.
Because subaltern sometimes can be seen more in terms of a discourse or a debate, but Dalit
perspective sometimes has to be seen more in terms of radicalism in that sense as such.
Something which is going to bring about the transformation, as has been discussed by Ambedkar
and Gale Omwen in the different works. So, we can see that, these contributions, which
are been raised through this Dalit perspective, can have a meaningful effect, especially when
we try to uncover the Indian society in a new way.
I think, the caste system that we talked about, either it is Ambedkar's contribution in
terms of the genesis of the caste system. But the thing is that, do we really have such
readings, prescribed readings, where we have the genesis or the understanding of the caste
system from that viewpoint. And can we see that, the genesis of the caste system by Ambedkar
can be seen as a prominent literature in understanding the caste system. And if that is so, then
I think, we can have a new way for understanding the linkage between the two issues.
And apart from that, another significant thing that one has to really point out is that,
when we try to have certain amount of learning, we also have to have many unlearning also.
So, the Dalit perspective is not the question of a new form of socialization or learning,
rather it is also the process of unlearning and also trying to put the things in not only
democratic way, sometimes it has to be presented in a more revolutionary and undemocratic way.
And that is how, we try to see the whole debate. I think, the Dalit perspective in the contemporary
India happens to be very lively, especially we try to see that, the Dalit leaders for
the contemporary Indian society, which tries to present the iconic figures of the Dalit
in a very meaningful way, either it is the statue of Ambedkar or an attack on Ambedkar
statue that makes a meaningful act. And how the people are being charged and are
being put together to fight for their cause and that speaks about the sort of mobilization,
which have been there with regard to the people belonging to the category of Dalit. So, we
can see that, the Dalit perspective is not simply a sort of a discourse, rather it has
to be seen as a slogan for revolution to some extent. But, the only precaution that we have
to take of course, is that, it has to be done in a meaningful and amicable way, it
should not undermine the presence of the others, the others which are basically the empowered
or the elitist. But, it has to show their presence vice versa in a sense that, it should
be a balancing picture or it can have certain amount of hegemonization, no issue in that.
But, more important in that sense of course is, but it should not be at the cost of the
bloodshed and the other issues. I think these are certain things, which one has to be sensibly
look into, when we try to speak about the Dalit perspective. And since it is an academic
debate, where we are trying to project the Dalit perspective in a specific fashion, which
tries to speak about the understanding of society in a specific framework, where the
role of the lower caste, either it is the question of jajmani system or it is the question
of the new occupations, which are coming up as such or it is the question of fighting
against the untouchability or it is the question of having the iconic figurization of the Dalits
in the public sphere. I think these are the issues pertaining to
the debates on the Dalit perspective. And it has to be reworked, we can have many other
names apart from Ambedkar and Gilomved, which can be part of that, like in the contemporary
years, we have a prominent contribution by professor Gopalguru. And Gopalguru's contribution
has to be seen in a very different framework, especially the crack mirror of course, trying
to project the things in a very new way. Similarly, you have Kanchayalai's important
contribution that, why I am not in Hindu or we have many other contributions, revolutionary
contributions, which have been made by Kanchayalai, which speaks about the versions of the Dalit
in a specific way. Similarly, we also have Anant Telemdey's contribution, which of
course, appears to be quite significant, when we try to speak about the Dalit perspective.
We also try to see that, this Dalit perspective has been charged and also democratically mobilized
by using the various means, especially the use of the ICT. Now, we find many important
contributions which are there, which are going to be part and parcel of the Indian society,
like we have the counter currents, which of course, is a prominent website, where we try
to see that Dalit perspectives are going to be an important issue.
So, we try to see that, the contributions which are coming up, the sort of connections
which are coming up or to reinvent the Indian society are to be seen in such a fashion that,
it is not going to be something, which is going to fight against our own people. Rather,
it has to have a new way of looking to the society or sort of a self-respect, which Ambedkar
has rightly said that, it is basically in a democratic way, a self-respect for the presence
of others and the change of the mindset. If we are doing that, I think, we are trying
to give due justice to the Dalit perspective and this is how, we have to really indulge
and also imbibe and also focus upon and practice the Dalit perspective in the contemporary
India. So, with these words, I think, we can have
many more discussions, we can have many more names in the contemporary India, which are
coming up like, we have Vivek Kumar's contribution significantly working on Ambedkar and also
trying to have the understanding of Ambedkar beyond a limit in that sense. Especially,
he is trying to speak about the Rohing revolutions, also trying to speak about the Dalit vision
in a new way, trying to uncover different shades of Ambedkar. I think, this is the way
in which we can have the new learning. It is not simply the hegemony of certain specific
concepts, which are to be kept in mind while dealing with sociology. We have to have many
new comments and concepts, which can not only overpower, but which can give the new meanings
to the existing scenario of the Indian society. So, with these words, I will say thanks and
definitely we will have some more learnings in the new course of time with more deliberations.
