noc18-mg23 lec 43-Fundamental Concepts of Economic Externalities:

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
hello everyone I hope you all are doing
well so in this session we will discuss
on economic externalities and as we are
slowly moving for and discussing issues
related to market structures associated
with healthcare and how our healthcare
may not be an ideal market and in which
context you know we move towards the
market imperfection and and while we
were duly doing about the transition or
movement of the you know the perfect
market or an ideal market to a market
imperfection in terms of a healthcare
system we discussed about externality in
our last class and I gave you a broad
idea about what is externality and where
you know these benefits and costs come
together but not in the best efficient
manner so when I say this efficient
manner that means externality has
something to do with efficiency or
economic efficiency
what is externality you know by its
definition so we will discuss about
economic externalities and an
externality is a cost or a benefit it
can be a cost as well as a benefit that
arises from either production or
consumption of our particular goods and
services and falls upon someone else
apart from the consumer first we have
talked about producer so producer or
consumer themselves for I will say it
consumer itself that means that when a
producer or a consumer they produce or
consume something it can be in terms of
production it can be in terms of
consumption when they produce something
there are you know certain implications
like when I produce something I have
some benefit also I have some cost and
because I am producing something it can
have a benefit upon someone else it can
also have a cost upon someone else right
this benefit and cost which is
eventually not benefit the others as
well not cause any cost to others not
incur any cost to others but it is
eventually doing so then that additional
benefit and cost upon those others are
known as externalities
yes now it can be from the production it
can be as well from the consumption say
if I consume something then because of
my consumption there can be an
implication because I'm consuming
something you someone else can be
benefited or someone else can also be
equally or more or delicious something
can also be you know incurring a cost
because of my consumption let us
understand the types of economic
externalities so the first one is a
negative externality which imposes a
cost
the next one is positive externality as
that you know the name sayest it imposes
or it should not be imposes it causes
benefit or results into benefits right
so this is the basic definition
difference positive causes benefit
negative causes cost and there then we
have total in terms of now we have just
said positive and negative this positive
and negative can arise out of the
production externality production as
well as consumption so now I am
attaching this production and
consumption with this so the four types
of economic externalities are one is
negative production externality to
maybe negative consumption externality
three positive production externality
for positive consumption externality now
as the name suggests negative
externality that means cost is higher
negative externality that means cost is
higher again but from the first point
the cost is being imposed the cost is
being imposed because of this production
in the second condition the cost is
being imposed because of anyone's
consumption
we'll take examples and then understand
it on a bit away similarly a positive
externality is which causes benefit now
this benefit can arise because of
production as well as consumption
therefore if a particular production
causes us a benefit or not to the again
and not to that particular person who is
producing that apart from him or her if
this is actually you know bringing any
benefit to others then that is a
positive production externality and if
because of somebody's consumption of
something and it brings benefit you know
its results into it benefit towards
somebody then it's a positive
consumption externality we will learn
about all of these you know taking
examples let's say one is negative
production externality
negative production externality what can
be the easiest example is and a
polluting industry it can be industry it
can be a polluting farm yes a particular
form which is causing air pollution in a
certain locality they are manufacturing
say it's a paper industry it's a cement
industry highly polluting industries so
they are manufacturing their paper or
swimming you know or say whoa if paint
industry then it causes our different
kinds of you know water pollution mainly
so in terms of your pollution let us say
so what is happening is that because of
their production they are earning their
profit they are selling their products
aren't in profit you know reinvesting
the capital or the profit and continuing
their business growth what is happening
because of their production or
production process it actually you know
degrading or deteriorating de our
condition in the nearby areas and even
if those who are staying nearby they
don't you know use the papers
manufacture in that particular industry
or they don't use the cements
manufactured in that particular industry
but they are consuming or inhaling that
your air because of that production yes
so the production and the production
itself has a cost right production
itself has a cost that is the forms cost
production cost whatever production
itself has a benefit because of that
products of the products outputs so this
is all private benefit and private cost
right now there is no social benefit as
such because they are not consuming
their products nothing good is happening
on the contrary the quality of here is
going
down because of which maybe many people
around that factory are falling sick
with acute respiratory infections
asthmatic problems bronchitis this and
that lung infection so they have to go
to a doctor or they have to you know
treat themselves so eventually what is
happening there are questions increasing
right and this cost is external cost
right so because of this polluting
industry or that particular firm there
is some external cost is being incurred
by somebody else or a group of people
and that is external cost it basically
happens when you know that there is a
unregulated market because an
unregulated market will not generally
have our you know the profit motive will
be very high and then they really will
not have our intention to to to really
bother about the causes they are you
know our costs they are bringing into
the towards the society or any negative
adversities because of their products so
and because it's unregulated they have a
market power and that leads to an
inefficiency into that market eventually
this negative externality is very very
common you know so the second one is
negative consumption externality
now what is the best example of negative
consumption externality is basically
smoking cigarette and the causes I you
know and which causes harm for doc
passive smokers right I smoke a
cigarette I pay for it
so that's my private cost I pay as I pay
for a cigarette i smoke that and that is
my benefit private benefit my own
benefit but the child who is standing
beside me yes or the people who is
standing beside me or if I smoke within
the there are this advertisement
nowadays right against this smoking
causes cancer and all this and they show
that our Father is smoking and then the
child are coughing so within the room
inside the room he is smoking and then
it has after I know being exposed for a
long long time towards this passive
smoking it has a serious negative impact
on there the other cell passive smokers
health therefore because of my
consumption or because of that person's
consumption of cigarette is causing a
health problem to those who didn't want
to consume didn't want to inhale the
smoke but are you know incurring a cost
health cost eventually it can be
anything it can be will your this this
externality can will you
be you know accommodated into
environmental and energy economics
National Natural Resource Economics and
all anyways so this negative consumption
externality there therefore is the cost
caused to somebody else because of
somebody you know the consumers own
private consumption so it is like
smoking a cigarette causes respiratory
infection to the passive smokers and
this polluting industry of form which
pollutes here
causing a lung infection among the
closer by residents
yeah so these are the you know the most
prominent examples maybe in terms of
negative production exist externality
and negative consumption externality
when we move towards the positive
production externality and positive
consumption externality first let us
take the positive production externality
so in positive externality it causes
benefit right positive production
externality means the benefit is being
cost out of production of something the
externality means the benefit for
somebody else now let us say there is a
hospital coming up in our locality and
because of that hospital the you know
the city Civic body door well they have
rule or regulation that in front of the
hospital the RO do you know it should be
a boat way lane and then the road oh no
Bray it will be something around 40 feet
or something like that minimum 40 feet
something like that so if it is like
that then the hospital has to you know
or either they may be realistic the
hospital has to take the initiative
because it's a private hospital and they
can only get the sanction from the
government if they expands the road on
their own cost in front of them at least
you know hundred metres both the sides
so the upcoming hospital private
hospital
expand the roads in front of it but
those who are using those roads or those
who stay closer by a take that road
towards their office or you know back or
towards the children's school or back
they don't probably visit that
particular Hospital many of them can go
to a clinic many of them have other
alternative options but then they are
taking the road if they are using the
road and they are being benefited
because of that expansion of the road
right so the hospital expanded the road
expanded the road for its own you know
functioning for its own production
production of healthcare services and
and it it incurred its own private cost
right that is its infrastructural cost
to start their business eventually what
happens is this expansion of roads
causes benefit roads in front of it and
that benefits the usual commuters or
maybe those who are staying nearby right
maybe they are just they are not taking
the vehicle they are just walking down
the street they have not paid a single
penny but because there is no traffic
congestion and at the same time they are
also enjoying the hospital at least the
security of having the hospital that is
the satisfaction side right utility side
so then you know they have a benefit of
course and that is that positive
production externality what can be the
positive consumption externality is say
there is a high prevalence of a
particular flu yea orsa swine flu or
something which was very prevalent in
Bangalore sometimes back you know maybe
last year well and this is infectious
contagious this swine flu so and many of
the people they were taking this swine
flu vaccinations voluntarily
no if I take that vaccination I paid for
that yeah some eight hundred rupees or
something I paid for that I paid for the
doctor and all and then I got the flu I
did you know completely preventive
measure I even don't know that whether I
would have even affected by this one for
you or not it's just a preventive
measure right maybe I got exposed to a
swine flu person and then the swine flu
vaccine enters my body and then because
I have that flu I have that vaccination
the flu this never becomes the flu never
becomes positive right and that
eventually saves the health for those
who are coming in touch to me or those
who are staying around me maybe they
have not taken the flu right so I have
consumed the flu and because of that I
am trans I am stopping the transmission
of the problem at least through me
therefore it has a positive consumption
externality so the example is taking a
swine flu vaccine
and eventually as a preventive cause so
if I am NOT falling sick with swine flu
that is my private benefit whereas a
preventive cause which eventually stops
transmission of the virus through me
to those to the others who may not who
haven't taken
the Vexin right so this is my positive
consumption externality now generally
you know whenever we talk about these
positive externality negative
externality we say that one in one case
the cost is more in other case the
benefit is more you know the window it's
it's positive externality then we talk
about the benefit when it's negative
externality we talk about the cost but
every single thing has its own private
cost its own private benefit maybe it
can have both this way and all social
cost and social benefit so what happens
that when we estimate this you know the
cost and benefit it's not basically a
cost-benefit analysis but of course he
is when we estimate the cost and benefit
we will break it in two component yeah
so as we have said that it has always a
private cost and private benefit apart
from that it has another component that
is that externality right we call that
external cost or external benefit right
so a private cost
our toes
which is incurred for a production or
consumption of any goods and services to
the producer or consumer of course
respectively themselves are know himself
yes so the private cost is this cost
which is incurred for a production or
consumption of any particular goods and
services to the producer or consumer
himself now similarly private benefit is
those or those benefit which is incurred
or you know which is enjoyed ya integral
instead of incurred yeah while we are
talking about benefit which is enjoyed
for a production and consumption of a
particular good by D over here in case
of you know to D it should be by the
producer or consumer or themselves this
is about private cost and private
benefit what about social cost and
social benefit
social cost is simply the total cost
which includes private cost and external
cost similarly social benefit is the one
which includes total benefit you know
which which is total benefit includes
the private benefit and external benefit
now what is external cost and external
benefit it's very simple external cost
and external benefit are the cost and
the benefit
you know upon the others apart from the
producer of consumer yes
so together we estimate the social cost
so the social cost can be a summation of
private cost plus external cost
similarly social benefit is private
benefit plus external benefit and the
challenge to estimate this external
benefit and external cost is the
information asymmetry because often
people don't know that whether a
particular industry they are polluting
my environment or not or even if they
are polluting my environment how badly
it is affecting me yes so and therefore
you know the attaching the cost to this
is very very difficult yeah because of
this unawareness eventually energy onion
regulated market you know because the
government doesn't really come forward
or hasn't yet come forward to take a
decision or to work upon those polluting
or socially undesirable or inefficient
producer or consumer then certainly you
know it is difficult again to measure by
a single individual that okay I think
that they are doing something wrong but
I can't really do anything all right so
so the estimate of this external cost
and external benefit has often been
challenging and does the estimation of
perfect estimation of social cost and
benefit thank you
[Music]
[Music]
