noc18-ce39-Lec 05-Economic Decision Making - I

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
namaskar and welcome to this course once
again this course on accounting and
finance for civil engineers and we are
offering it together at IIT Kanpur and
IIT Delhi in this lecture we'll start
our discussion on economic decision
making and the last class we discussed
the concept of time value of money and
various interest formula relating to the
different idealized cash flow diagrams
now these cash flow diagrams basically
represent whatever goes out from the
system and whatever comes in so what we
had talked about in the last class was
to figure out what are the ways or what
are the different options that we have
if we want to find out what is the
present value of all this investment
which is happening let us say at equal
installments what will happen for
example in case we want a certain amount
of money after a certain amount of time
and we know the rate of interest what
should be our initial deposit that we
want to keep or if we don't want to keep
a lump-sum deposit what should be the
equalized installments of deposits that
we want to keep so that they will grow
into this fund at the end of this time
period with their a certain rate of
interest so B's formula we had discussed
in the last class and now in this class
we will get started with some of the
methods that are used for economic
decision making in construction projects
beginning with the evaluation of
available options now before we do that
we would like to introduce to you the
concept of interest tables these tables
are available to find different interest
factors at varying interest rates and
time periods and they basically serve as
ready reckoners let's for example
consider the business of single payment
compound amount factor this p CAF what
we talked about
we said that given P given the rate of
interest and the time period what will
be F and what we had given was a formula
like this which is basically nothing but
the compound interest formula that we
usually see so instead of that we could
use a table like this which is given for
an interest rate of 5% and it says that
if the time changes the way it is shown
here how will a single rupee or a unit
value how it will change so at the end
of one year it will obviously become one
point zero five at the second year it
will become one point one zero two and
so on depending on the compounding that
we are doing so this is how this table
or this part of this table which is the
compound interest factors so this part
of this table can be used for this
formulation that is given here compound
amount factor find F given P similarly
the same table also helps you determine
the single payment present worth factor
which basically what we talked about was
like this that given this F what is its
present worth and the formula we had
given was something like this and we go
back to the same table if the rate of
interest is 5% what would be the present
value of a unit at the end of n years at
a certain rate of interest so now in
this case this table is for 5% so we
know that the rate of interest is 5% so
we can see that if we have the present
worth of 0.9 five-to-four
it will have a value of 1 at the end of
one year similarly an amount of point
9:07 is what will grow to a unit value
at the end of two years and so on so
obviously if we keep changing this
interest rate these numbers will change
and these are available to us in
different textbooks we also have a
similar column in that table for the
equal payment sinking fund deposit
factor which means that if we want a
certain
F at the end of n years for a given rate
of interest R or I then what should be
this equalized saving of a and the
formula we had given was something like
this and here is the third column which
talks about the sinking front factor
find a given F and then we see that
obviously if it is the first year itself
then the whole thing has to be there one
and if it is two years this value you
can see is slightly less than 0.5 this
value is more less than 0.33 and so on
and so forth so similarly we can go on
and talk about the equal payment capital
recovery factor which is something like
this that given P what should be the a
and so on so I'm not getting into the
details of this discussion and not only
this factor but so many other
informations or factors are available to
you for ready reckoners which you can
directly refer to but we have to be
careful that we look at the right table
we look at the right factor and the
right interest rate so obviously that is
the caution that we must exercise and
once we do that these tables help us
determine the different factors that we
talked about in the last class now what
we will do today is actually an
application of these factors and these
principles in economic decision-making
by way of choosing the right option or
trying to make a recommendation for a
certain option given different options
let's try to do that we've been
emphasizing in this course that
construction managers are often called
upon to compare alternatives and choose
one of them obviously when you have to
compare alternatives you have also to
formulate the alternatives you would
recall that in one of the discussions we
said that we need to generate options
and then evaluate them so there are
models which we need to understand when
we say that okay given a certain set of
information how do we model that
information in a manner that we can
apply the kind of knowledge that we have
so consider two options of equipments
let us say a and B
a has a high initial cost and low
maintenance cost whereas B has a low
initial cost and a high maintenance cost
now how do we compare these two what you
will see in today's lecture is that we
will actually be using the idealized
cash flow diagram over and over again
except that that cash flow diagram will
be an idealized cash flow diagram to the
extent that it carries the information
given in the text so for example for
this particular problem what we are
really saying is that we have option a
where the initial investment is high but
the subsequent maintenance cost is low
compared to that the option B has a
lower initial investment but a higher
periodic maintenance as far as the
operation period is concerned so
depending on these values here we need
to make a decision and obviously if it
is as simple as this then we know that
we can apply some of the methods or some
of the formula that we have been exposed
to to make a judgement now some of the
commonly used methods for this purpose
are given here what we talk about is the
out-of-pocket commitment the average
annual rate of return the payback period
discounted payback period present worth
comparison internal rate of return
method future worth comparisons
equivalent annual charge benefit cost
ratio and the incremental rate of return
method so this is a long list of methods
that are available to us to be able to
compare options and each of them has
certain special features and we can use
a method which is easy but we should
understand its limitations sometimes we
want to do a rigorous analysis and
therefore we need to choose a method
appropriately so as far as these methods
are concerned these first three that is
out-of-pocket commitment the average
annual rate of return and the payback
period the
I do not consider the time value of
money and are useful when the lives of
alternatives are short so obviously when
we have been talking about the time
value of money concept it stands to
reason that okay in cases where the
whole time span in which we are making a
decision is small then we can ignore the
effect of time value of money what if
that span is longer then we must
consider the time value of money and
that is where we have to understand
whether we should use one of these
methods or not the others here use the
concept of time value of money so what
we will do today is get started with
some of the methods go to some point and
then try to take a break and come back
and visit them if required once again so
coming to the first of those methods the
out-of-pocket commitment which does not
consider the concept of time value of
money out of pocket commitment is the
total expense required for an
alternative so in a manner of speaking
it is an extremely simplified model
perhaps simplistic as we shall see in a
example so precast concrete factory has
to produce let's say one lakh or one
hundred thousand railway sleepers per
year a choice has to be made between
steel formwork and wooden form work
whose details I'll shortly give you in a
table make a recommendation on which of
the formwork systems should be used on
the principle of out of pocket
commitment so what is the information
that's available to us useful life as
far as steel formwork is concerned let's
say is given to me one year in the case
of wooden formwork it is one month the
cost of preparing one set of this
formwork is let's say four hundred
thousand and fifty thousand and the
labor cost for assembling a single
sleeper formwork is ten and nine now how
do we calculate the out-of-pocket
expense for these two cases it's
relatively simple as far as the steel
formwork is concerned we talk in terms
of 1 lakh sleepers per year so we are
talking of an annual out-of-pocket
expenditure or come
meant as one lakh into ten-plus 400,000
which is basically one lakh into
ten-plus 400,000 once you prepare a set
of formwork then you can use it for one
year and all that you really need is the
labor component so if you do that your
out-of-pocket expenditure is simply one
hundred thousand into ten plus four
hundred thousand which is 14 lakhs or
1.4 million rupees if you do the same
thing with wooden formwork your
out-of-pocket commitment is 100 thousand
sleepers into nine plus fifty thousand
into twelve this fifty thousand twelve
is coming from the fact that for wooden
formwork given that the life of that
formwork is only one month in one year
you will require 12 of those form works
and therefore your out-of-pocket
commitment is fifteen lakhs or 1.5
million so now if we compare these two
obviously an out-of-pocket expenditure
or out-of-pocket commitment for steel
formwork is slightly lower than that of
wooden formwork and therefore the use of
steel formwork can be recommended so we
can see that this a very simple method
perhaps a high school kind of method
where you don't really need a lot of
expertise as far as finance is concerned
but what you need to know is the
technology that if you make a formwork
then what does it mean to talk in terms
of the life of formwork what does it
mean that even if you have the formwork
that is certain labor component in for
manufacture of those sleepers so once
you know these kind of things you can
easily calculate the out-of-pocket
commitment now let us try to talk about
the average annual rate of return that
is the a a our our method now
alternatives in this case are evaluated
on the basis of the average rate of
return which is expressed in terms of
percentage of the original capital so
here - let's try to look at a
illustrative example a contractor has
two brands of excavators let's say a and
B to choose from
suppose both the brands are available
for a downpayment of 4 lakhs that is
400,000 and both brands have a useful
period of four years so obviously you
can see that we have simplified the
situation that is we have said that both
these brands have the same initial cost
and they have the same service life
further it is known that brand a is
estimated to give a return of INR 50000
for the first year hundred fifty
thousand for the second year and two
hundred thousand for the third and
fourth here whereas brand B is expected
to give a return of a hundred thousand
for all the four years so in order to
compare obviously the question is which
brand should be chosen using the AER our
method so we go back to our good old
friend the cash flow diagram and for
brand a this is the initial investment
and we are talking in terms of lakhs and
what the return we are getting is 0.5 1
point 5 2 & 2 that was the information
given in the text similarly for brand B
the initial investment is 4 lakhs and we
are getting 1 lakh uniformly for the
next four years which is the service
life of this equipment now the average
annual rate of return for brand a is
calculated as the sum of all these
numbers that is 0.5 that's 50 thousand
one hundred fifty thousand two hundred
and two hundred thousand each and we get
a total of six hundred thousand and
since we are talking of the average
annual we divide this by 4 we get the
return as a hundred and fifty thousand
so this one hundred and fifty thousand
expressed in percentage of the original
invested capital basically becomes 150
divided by 400 which is this value and
we get an A a RR of 37.5% as far as
brand is concerned similarly if we do
this calculation for brand B we will
find that the a RR is only 25 percent
obviously given that the a RR of a is
higher we could simply recommend a as
option to be chosen please remember that
we are not considering here the time
value of money so what we have done
really is just added up these numbers
here added up these numbers here and try
to compare them moving forward what is a
payback period that was the third of the
methods that we talked about and it is a
period at which the investor gets the
investment back it does not consider the
time value of money and obviously out of
the various options available a project
or an investment with a shorter payback
period would be preferred so now let's
take an example and see how this works
we go back to the more or less the same
problem that is excavators a and B
having a for lack of initial investment
four years of service life and the same
data that we had a fifty thousand one
hundred fifty thousand two hundred and
two hundred thousand and the same values
for B now if we apply the payback period
method what is a better method now if
you apply the payback period method
which is a better buy should we go for
brand a or should we go for brand B so
in this case again the cash flow
diagrams will be the same except that
the payback period for brand a is three
years and the payback period for brand B
is four years now how do we get these
three years we had an investment of four
lakhs and what we want to see is at what
stage will the four lakhs be recovered
so in this case we find that it is 0.5
plus 1.5 plus two gives you four and
therefore in three years you have
recovered your investment and that's
what we say that in the case of brand a
the payback period is three years
whereas in the case of brand B the
payback period is four years because
only at the end of four years you have a
recovery of four lakhs which you
invested in the beginning so here too
since the payback period of is lower
than that of me they should be chosen so
that's a straightforward example that we
did let's try to do a slightly more
involved example in the case of the
payback period so let's consider
investments or two alternatives a and B
for a company the initial investment for
both cases let's say is fifty thousand
and an option a it is estimated to give
ten thousand in the first year twenty
thousand in the second year in fifteen
thousand for the next four years and in
option B gives us ten thousand for all
the six years now if this is the data
available the question is which is a
better alternative using the payback
period approach so we go back to our
cash flow diagram for the two cases we
invest fifty thousand here in both cases
and try to see what our receipts are and
this information is available to us and
by way of or text and we can check this
out and now how do we calculate the
payback period in these two cases
because in the previous case we had a
situation where we could simply add up
something here and it came to a same
number as the investment but in this
case it doesn't happen because we have
50 thousand here and if we go on adding
we will get 10 and 20 is 30 up to this
point it is 45 but at this point it
becomes 60 so what we really need to do
is to find out some kind of an
interpolation between these two numbers
that is we can almost intuitively see
from this data that the payback period
for project a would be somewhere between
three and four years and if we do that
calculation will find that with linear
interpolation it is three years and four
months
similarly for the payback period in case
of project B given those numbers the way
they are the option B has the payback
period of five years obviously since the
project a has a lower payback period
that is the preferred recommendation
that we can make let's try to once again
recapitulate and try to take a closer
look at the payback period method now
all costs and revenues on the investment
prior to the payback period are included
without considering the difference in
their timing
when we try to add these numbers so we
can see that if this is where the
payback period is then all this numbers
regardless of where they appear whether
they appear in years one two and three
or maybe there is just a single large
recovery here at year three that really
will not be counted that does not affect
our results so all the investment prior
to the payback period are included
without considering the difference in
their timing similarly all economic
consequences beyond the payback period
are completely ignored that is a very
major limitation because sometimes
especially if the time period that we
are talking about is long then we may
not be able to ignore that altogether so
these are the kind of things that we
must keep in mind when we are applying
one method or the other results obtained
using the payback method may not select
the correct alternative every time this
is particularly true in situations where
the salvage values are predominantly
high salvage value if you'll recall is
the value of an equipment at the end of
its service life because we are not
considering anything beyond the payback
period then the whole idea of salvage
value and so on is not even coming into
the picture so if that salvage value is
high or the time of consideration is
high then the payback period method may
not be the best alternative but the
question is if the payback period
calculations are approximate and may
even lead to the selection of a wrong
alternative then what is the use of this
method it's not that it's completely
useless if we can't take a close look
once again the payback period indicates
how long it takes for the investment to
be recovered from its benefits
it is a back-of-the-envelope simple
calculation a rapid return of invested
capital means that it can be reused
sooner for other purposes and thus the
payback period indicates the speed of
the return of an investment which may be
quite important for a company that is
running short on working capital
how would as the payback period may not
provide an overall economically
efficient solution it should not be
considered as a suitable replacement for
accurate economic analysis and that is
really true
for a lot of things that we do in
different walks of life whatever is very
simple has obvious limitations and we
must try to be rigorous if it is
required for the back of the envelope
simple first-level iterations first
level calculations simple assumptions
help so that's what the payback period
is all about and if we need to do more
rigorous analysis we should not shy away
from that now let's try to understand
the importance of time value of money in
evaluating options all these three
options that we've talked about so far
did not consider the time value of money
first of all let's talk about the
discounted payback period now similar to
the payback period this period which is
the discounted payback period is the
same as the payback period except that
it considers the time value of money
also that is the payback period method
incorporating the time value of money
concept is basically the discounted
payback period so let's try to take a
look at an illustrative example a
businessman invests one hundred and
twenty thousand and earns a return from
this investment the cash flow diagrams
for this investment are given the table
which I am going to share with you
shortly
determine the discounted payback period
for an interest rate of 10% so suppose
this was the data that is given there is
an investment of one hundred and twenty
thousand and these are the returns at
different points in time we converted to
a cash flow diagram that one hundred and
twenty thousand is invested and fifty
one forty seven twenty five forty three
point nine forty six or recovered at
year one two three four and five now
what we need to do is to actually bring
all these values to the present worth
and how do we do that we have used the
single payment
present worth factor and that's what we
will use to reduce all these values to
the present worth now how do we go about
doing it this is the table that we have
so this is the cash flow that is given
to us this is the discount factor of SP
pwf from the tables that we showed and
for one year it is 0.9 second year it's
0.8 to 630 or is 0.75 one and so on
so if these are the values which are
absolute and given here these values
turn out to be these values once we take
this factor into account so these values
of 50 147 25 40 3.9 and 46 they get
discounted to these values and these are
the present worth of these future
returns so if we do that and try to
determine the cumulative values then
what we need to do is to say that okay
we invested this much having recovered
this much this is what is still balanced
and so on and so forth and if we do that
the discounted payback period is the
time at which the sign of the cumulative
discounted cash flow changes which is
somewhere in between these two that is
between three and four years let's say
three and a half so we can do a linear
interpolation and try to find out a more
accurate number now as a food for
thought for you please try to evaluate
the payback period do not consider the
time value of money and try to do the
payback period and see what is the
difference and try to reconcile that in
your mind as to how the difference is
arising and how will you interpret it
continuing with our discussion of the
present value there is the concept of
net present value that is NPV which is
the sum of all cash flows discounted to
the present using the concept of time
value of money and that's what we
actually more or less used in the
previous example as well what it really
means is that we calculate the present
value of all these CFTs
at different points in time and try to
find out whether or not the NPV is
greater than 0 or less than 0 what we
are effectively doing is that the NPV is
the sum of all the CF T's to the present
value so if we have 1 CF T here there
could be another one here there's
another one here another one here all
these brought here and added up this is
what is giving you the NPV and how we
can do that is by using the single
payment present worth factor so in a
nutshell if the NPV is greater than zero
then the project creates value to the
investor and if it is less than zero
it's a loss making venture and usually
alternatives are assessed based on their
NPV let's try to consider an
illustrative example as to how we
compute the NPV s here is a situation
where cash flow projections for a
proposal are shown in this table
calculate the NPV of the cash flow at an
interest rate of fifteen percent
throughout suggest whether or not the
project is worth executing so what's
given here is the cash outflow initially
is 200 and then these are the recoveries
that you may make so it's 35 for seven
years and then 37 in the eighth year so
if we convert this into a cash flow
diagram this is what it will look like
in thousands of Indian rupees and now
the question is how to determine the NPV
and try to see whether it is positive or
negative so we calculate the NPV
considering an interest rate of 15% this
is the cash flow diagram and we know how
this discount factors which is SP p WF
that a single payment present worth
factor comes in and we know that these
numbers we can get from the tables and
these values get discounted to smaller
values then what is projected here
because that's what they're present
worth is considering the rate of
interest of 15% so now if this is what
we get in terms of the present value
what we need to find out is that what
happens if we add up the present values
that is we do an algebraic
some of these values and then we try to
find out the NPV so basically if we look
at the positive values that's starting
from here to this point we get the
number as 156 thousand three ninety and
if we try to find out the net present
worth that is minus two hundred plus 150
six point three nine gives you a minus
forty three point six one and that means
that this is obviously less than zero
and therefore the project is not worth
executing from a purely commercial point
of view now let's try to talk in terms
of comparison of alternatives and trying
to find out which alternative is better
now in this case there are situations
where there are equal lives there are
unequal lives and there are infinite
life that is the project goes on or the
benefits continue to accrue for a long
period of time now in those cases there
are different methods that are available
for our analysis and let's try to
understand first the situation four
equal lives as an illustrative example
let's try to see that if a contractor
has been awarded a job and he requires
to do a procurement of an equipment two
brands of equipment a and B are
available brand a requires an investment
of seven lakhs and brand B requires an
investment of four lakhs and the annual
maintenance cost of these equipments are
given in the table which I'm going to
share with you and which brand should be
chosen if the interest rate is 8% so now
if this information that gives you the
maintenance cost detail ear wise is
known to you the question is how do we
make a decision as to which brand of
equipment to be bought in this case
since we are talking of equal lives
let's say in both cases the service life
of the equipment is three years now if
we can see that brand a has maintenance
cost of three lakhs every year whereas
brand B has a maintenance cost of five
lakhs we convert this information to our
good old cash flow diagrams for the two
brands of equipment in brand a we have
an initial cost of seven lakhs
is only 4 lakhs here but here we have 3
lakhs as a recurring expenditure for the
3 years and the recurring expenditure
here in case of brand B is 5 lakhs so
this issue is to compare these two
brands now for this we could use the
equal payment present fourth factor and
this is the formula that we had talked
about and if we do that then the NPV for
equipment a is negative all the time it
is several lakhs which is coming from
here and it is this notation this is the
notation which talks about what is the
present worth of an a which is occurring
at an equal level for 3 years given the
interest rate it 8 percent so if you
look up that table you will find that
that factor is 2 point 5 9 and if we
multiply this 2 point 5 9 by the 3 lakhs
which is the number here we'd get the
NPV to be 14 point 7 7 minus similarly
if we do this calculation for the brand
be the number turns out to be minus
sixteen point nine five so because the
NPV of is higher brand is preferred the
question that I would like to ask you is
how do you look at this number of two
point five nine this number of two point
five nine you can see is slightly lower
than 1 1 1 which is 3 and that's what
you need to clearly understand and
reconcile in your mind that yes this
number should be less than 3 so these
kind of simple cross checks help you
avoid a gross mistake when we are trying
to look at those tables and do the
calculations so this is how we compare
alternatives with equal lives now let's
try to wind up for the day what we set
out to do was to study the different
methods that are available for economic
decision making considering the time
value of money and this was a list that
I
given to you and what we have done today
is a complete discussion of these three
methods which do not consider the time
value of money and this method is half
done in fact one-third done because
we've only done type 1 what we need to
do is the type 2 and type 3 that is
unequal lives and a long life and of
course then we have these other methods
which are listed here which we will
return and do in a subsequent class so
with this we come to an end of the
discussion today and here is the list of
books or references which you may find
useful to get some more information and
detailed description of the kind of
material that we have covered today I
look forward to seeing you again thank
you
[Music]
[Music]
