noc18-mm20 Lecture 40-Summary of Course

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
okay so welcome again to this new
lecture lecture number 40 or phase
equilibria course so we are right at the
end of the course so in this lecture we
will not introduce any new topic we will
just try to have a review of various
topics that we have discussed in this
lecture so what I'm going to do is that
we are just going to start with so this
basically we started why did we need to
learn this course we needed to learn
this course because as every material
has certain phases and these that
stability of these what is the type of
phase that is present at a given
condition of temperature and other
thermodynamic variables
what kind of will determine what kind of
properties the material will have so
that is why knowledge of why do certain
phases occur under at a certain
condition certain combination of
thermodynamic variables and what kind of
variation do you have as a function of
for example change in temperature or
composition as far as metallurgical
systems are concerned or even pressure
and what are the various things that you
can determine from these phase diagrams
to assist you with processing and
product development so what we did was
we started with elements of basic
thermodynamics so the first topic that
we did was essential thermodynamics
so there's essential thermodynamics in
world knowledge of concepts of for
example what is the phase what is the
component okay so we define that phase
is nothing but entity with different
physical properties it means it may not
necessarily have different composition
but it will have different physical
characteristics it will have different
properties the system is basically an
alloy or a compound
whereas components are the one which
make up the system so a phase you may
have two phases of the same component
for example pure iron will make a delta
phase and a gamma phase but Delta and
gamma phases have different crystal
structures and they have different
physical properties but they're all
they're both made of pure ions pure iron
is the component pure pure component
similarly if you look at water in case
of h2o h2o although it is made up of H
and O atoms we take h2o as a component
because h2o is not available as a freak
H and O are not available as free
components they are available as h2o
molecules so each molecule is a
component so it changes its phase from
solid to liquid to vapour upon
application of temperature so these are
three essential elements one is system
second is phase and third is component
so we discussed these things and then we
discussed what do we mean by phase
stability and by phase stability we
meant in terms of thermodynamic terms
phase stability means what is how can we
predict which phase so when we talk
about water for example h2o why is that
at 20 degree centigrade liquid phase is
stable but not the solid phase or the
vapor phase and that is determined by
the thermodynamic considerations so that
is why we needed to understand and
correlate it to thermodynamic
parameters okay so we defined various
terms such as enthalpy free energy G so
H was enthalpy free energy Gibbs free
energy is G and then internal energy is
U and entropy is s and so on and so
forth these are the various terms which
determine the thermodynamic stability
then we looked at what is the definition
of equilibrium what is equilibrium
equilibrium basically means a stable
state and no change happens so basically
in thermodynamic terms it means that at
equilibrium that change in free energy
is equal to zero and this free energy is
related to basically H minus TS enthalpy
and entropy in this fashions in most
metallurgical systems we talked about
the Gibbs free energy there's another
free energy which is called as Helmholtz
free energy but in our context we
generally talk about the Gibbs free
energy which is G is equal to H minus TS
which is enthalpy minus product of
temperature and entropy and it is the
combination of enthalpy and entropy and
temperature which determine the phase
stability of one phase with respect to
another so and then we looked at the
simple phase diagrams so some so we
looked at the single component system
so single component system for example
you can have your iron you can have pure
h2o you can have pure tin and so on and
so forth
or you can have carbon so single
component system since they have so they
have only one component the the phase
stability depends upon two parameters so
single component and phase stability is
determined by phase stability is
determined by temperature and pressure
these are the two thermodynamic
variables which determine the phase
stability so when we did that the first
thing also any earlier we looked at the
variation of these thermodynamic
properties
terminating properties with say
temperature okay so we saw that you know
how that how the free energy how so if
you look at the variation for instance
of free energy versus temperature so you
are enthalpy varies like this this is
enthalpy and your free energy varies
like this this is G and the difference
between these two is basically TS term
okay so this is zero this is temperature
and so that this is how the free energy
varies and if you look at this slope del
G by Del T and most of these happens at
constant pressure this is equal to minus
s so basically change in the entropy is
always positive
as a result del G by Del T is negative
and that determines that stability of
the system the free energy going towards
negative so if you look so if you look
at the phase diagram for example for
pure iron
okay so pure iron has temperature versus
pressure phase diagram so it undergoes
it shows various phases okay so at high
temperature you have liquid phase at
this temperature you have Delta and then
you have gamma then you have alpha then
you have epsilon so these various phases
of iron are present at different
combinations of temperature and pressure
and there are fields in which single
phases are stable and these are called
as single phase field so phase fields so
this is temperature versus pressure
phase diagram of a single element
similar phase diagram you will see for
for basically water as well
h2o system and moving on further we we
looked at the effect of we look before
we went to phase diagrams further we
looked at the thermodynamics of binary
solutions
and this is essential because no element
is pure most most and most materials are
impure in nature as a result we started
with solution Thurman a mix and we
looked at first binary solutions and
binary solutions are basically a be kind
of solutions and these solutions can be
you know the ideal solutions so one
could be the ideal solution and then you
have regular solution and then you can
have non-ideal solutions okay
so depending upon the level of ideality
you can move away so essentially in the
in the in the solid solution you mix a
and B and you hope that it will give
rise to a B and this is determined by
the liking of a with respect to B so you
will form so when you have a and B
present there is a property of forming a
a bonds there is a propensity to form BB
bonds and there is a likelihood of a B
bonds depending upon the propensity of a
material to possess a B bonds the
material will have corresponding changes
in the free energy so this change in the
free energy upon mixing two elements is
called as Delta G mixing and this is
nothing but Delta H mixing minus T Delta
s mixing so if your Delta H mix is
higher if the enthalpy of mixing is
higher then the mixing is not preferred
the miscibility of two elements is not
preferred but if the mixing is lower
Delta H mix is lower then the mixing of
two elements is preferred which means a
B bonds are more preferable as compared
to a and BB bonds so it is the relative
change of Delta H mix and delta T Delta
s mix that is going to determine whether
a solution will be stable or not so we
did complete analysis of it so for
instance the Delta H mix if you it it
also is affected by temperature because
there is a temperature term as well T so
if you look at the variation for
instance the Delta G mix
goes like this so this is Delta G mix
this is for example P or a and B and
from the rule of mixtures this is Delta
G mix so this Delta G mix that is
reduction in the free energy is what
makes the solution is stable so as you
increase the temperature as you increase
the temperature this will further go
down to so this will go down to so I'm
keeping this as a constant point but
even this point will shift downwards so
with increasing temperature that mixing
is preferred and the free energy of
mixing is even lower and then we
introduce a term in the moment you mix
things into one other one another they
tend to change at they change they tend
to change the the you can say the
chemical activity of each element so a
becomes more active when you put B it
may become less active when you put B
and so on and so forth so this is
defined by another term called as
chemical potential so we determined
another term chemical potential which is
mu I which is nothing but change in the
free energy upon addition of a component
I at constant temperature pressure and
n1 n2 and so on and so forth so change
in the incremental change in the free
energy upon making incremental change in
the composition leads to a property
called as chemical potential so chemical
potential is is basically representative
of how the free energy will change when
the composition of a system is changed
and this composition change is very
incremental it's not very large so then
we went through the whole analysis and
we saw that depending upon the nature of
mixing between two alloys you can have
so your Delta H mix could be like this
your minus T Delta s mix could be like
this so this is Delta H mix and then
Delta G could be like this this is Delta
G mix a this is B so this is when Omega
is less than zero and temperature is
high and what is Omega Omega is
essentially a measure of Delta H mix
because Delta H mix is equal to Omega XA
xB so if this term is is negative which
means there is a preference for mixing
and when it's positive there is less
preference for mixing so when Delta
Omega is less than zero that is Delta H
mix is negative that is the behavior so
your free energy of mixing is very
negative and the alloy formation is
preferred however when Delta when this
is when Omega is greater than zero and
temperature is low then situation may
change so your Delta H mix is like this
minus T Delta s mix is like this and
there are Delta G mixes like this so
this is Delta H mix minus T Delta s mix
and Delta G mix and they could be
scenario where Delta H mix is positive
so this in this case Delta Omega is not
very large Delta H mix is almost flat or
sort of becoming to be positive you can
have scenario when Omega is greater than
zero and you have high temperature so
this is sorry less than zero low
temperature and now you have Delta H mix
being positive which means Delta
eh mix goes like this the D Delta s mix
still goes like this so this is Delta H
mix this is minus T Delta s mix and
Delta G is something like this okay
so you still have some preference for
making a solid solution they can be
instances where Delta H mix is extremely
positive and the temperatures are also
low so this could be Delta H mix and
your T Delta s mix is not massively low
and Delta G could show a behavior like
this this Delta G mix so even in this
situation where Delta G Delta H mix is
aggressively positive that is and at low
temperature where mixing is not
preferred even then it is Delta G mixing
is lower for the terminals which means
impure solid is preferred over the pure
solid even if the mixing is not
preferred so this this still is a very
important conclusion that even a slight
addition of impurity tends to lower the
free energy of pure material as a result
otherwise pure material and as a result
in pure solid is thermodynamically
stable as compared to the pure solid and
this is why and this happens because
this minus T Delta makes contribution
prevails at at lower impurity levels as
compared to that at the higher end
impurity levels so this basically tells
you that pure materials have higher free
energy than impure so slight amount of
one's so slight amount of impurity is
thermodynamically step as long as
temperature is greater than zero Kelvin
it it tends to make an impure phase
so and then we defined another term
called as a activity activity similar to
chemical potential it basically one it
basically tells you that how active how
active a element is so basically
activity is related to so you can say
that activity is nothing but mu a is
equal to GA plus RT Ln a a and mu B is
related to G B plus RT Ln a B so higher
the activity of element in ideal
material alloy higher the chemical
potential also is so then we did the
some more thermodynamic analysis we went
to real solutions we looked at why real
solutions can have different phases they
are not exactly miscible so miscibility
doesn't take place all the time they may
have miscibility only at the terminals
as a result they end up forming two
phases or different phases inter
metallic compounds ordered phases and so
on and so forth so we did lot of
analysis of this and finally we stumbled
to what we call as free energy
composition diagrams
because these free energy compositions
free energy composition diagrams lay the
foundation of phase diagrams and this is
they are important because in the end
what you have worried about is a clip
and the coexistence of so as long as you
have one phase it's alright but it's not
always like that you when you come from
for example from liquid solid state that
is a region in which liquid and solid
coexist so what is that which makes two
phase equilibria possible and knowledge
of that comes from free energy
composition diagram so for a two phase
equilibrium to occur
you have so for example I have two
phases liquid plus let us say this is
liquid this is solid so I can see that
for certain compositions liquid free
energy is lower for certain one for
certain places this is G and this is xB
and for certain composition solid free
energy is lower so for example if I take
this composition of the alloy I what is
so I can see that for this composition
here liquid free energy is higher here
solid affinity is lower okay so the
question is what will happen at this
point so the way you do is that it is
that you you determine you draw a common
tangent to to curve so this is G 1 this
is G 2 first phase and second phase so
for this composition what we will have
is a two two phase mixture let say this
is alpha and beta so between this you
will have alpha and beta alpha of this
composition beat of this composition and
what is the line tells us this tells us
so if you go to this is mu a this is mu
B so basically if the slope of this
slope of this line is nothing but the
chemical potential so what this tells me
is that for two phase equilibrium to
occur
the chemical potential of elements in
two phases must be the the same what it
means is that chemical potential of a so
basically what it means is that chemical
potential of a in alpha is equal to
chemical potential of B a in beta and it
means chemical potential of B in alpha
is equal to chemical potential of B in
beta if it was liquid solid then again
it would be the same chemical potential
of a in liquid is same as chemical
potential of a in solid and chemical
potential of B in liquid is same as
chemical potential of B in solid so this
is what we have here as far as two phase
equilibrium is concerned which is done
by drawing the common tangent so this is
how you do a phase diagram determination
so for example if you have you you can
draw energy composition curves for
liquid reason your GL will be lower than
GS for solid region in an isomorphous
phase diagram for a solid region GL so
this is a B so for solid region GL will
be less higher than GS for two-phase
region your GL and GS will have behavior
like this so that you have a two phase
region alpha plus beta and this is you
just correct this
so you'll have we draw the common
tangent so this is GL let's say this is
GS this is liquid this is liquid plus
solid and this is solid either the
common tangent and this is the
composition of liquid in so this is CL
this is CS so if you're on oil
composition is X naught then composition
of liquid in equilibrium with
compositions is C naught in equilibrium
with solid and solid composition in CS
so liquid of compression CL is in
equilibrium with the solid of
composition C s so this is how you
determine phase diagram and then we move
down to various kinds of phase diagrams
based on the free energy composition
curves which is also determined by free
energy of mixing so higher affinity of
mixing tend to give rise to isomorphous
kind of phase diagrams sorry
lower lower Delta H mix tend to give
rise to isomorphic kind of phase phase
diagram because that is where they are
miscible into each other so you have
isomorphous phase diagrams something
like these so you have temperature you
have composition and this is liquid
liquid plus solid solid so for example
copper nickel system has this phase
diagram then we have eutectic phase
diagram eutectic phase diagrams are the
ones where Delta H mix tend to be
slightly higher as compared to
isomorphous and they tend to make so you
have some solid solubility on the
terminal ends but in between they tend
to phase separate and if the melting
point difference is not huge and you
tend to make phase diagram like this
then we have peritectic phase diagram in
case of peritectic phase diagram Delta H
mix tend to be high and also as a result
also the melting point difference is
very high and hence what you have is a
situation like this so for example you
can have this kind of behavior and so on
and so forth so you can have peritectic
reaction so you can have liquid plus
alpha giving rise to you know so this is
beta say alpha sorry alpha this is beta
this is alpha plus beta and this vary in
liquid plus beta and peritectic
reactions are generally accompanied by
other reactions as well so you have
isomorphous eutectic peritectic and then
you can have a eutectoid in solid state
and then you can have peritectoid which
is similar to peritectic but in the
solid state so this is liquid going to
alpha plus beta at this point here
liquid results are going to beta at this
point and then here alpha going to beta
plus gamma solid state reaction and here
alpha plus beta giving rise to gamma in
the solid state so these are solid state
reaction so they occur in the lower part
of the phase diagram eutectic peritectic
are the liquid phase reactions which are
running at all and then we looked at
various kinds of phase diagrams the
microstructure evolution but two
important things that we discussed what
I line rule and lever rule tie line rule
allows us to determine the composition
of phases in equilibrium
whereas lever rule allows us to
determine the proportions okay so we did
a few exercises on them as well and
these can also be related to the
microstructure evolution that takes
place so microstructure evolution for
example in this case would be you will
have a hundred percent liquid you will
have liquid / solid so this will be
hundred percent liquid here you will
have some solid and then you will end up
having one hundred percent solid
similarly you will have microstructure
evolution in eutectic and other alloys
and then finally we did the whole lore
of analysis on phase diagrams we looked
at a variety of phase diagrams we also
looked at how to determine the phase
diagrams and so on and so forth and then
finally we looked at ternary phase
diagrams
and their characteristics which we
discussed in a few lectures followed by
applications of phase diagram so this is
what we have done in this course we have
looked started from basic thermodynamics
build up the background and
thermodynamics looked at how the
variation of free energy and Talpa
entropy takes place for various systems
looked at at regular and non-regular
solutions and then we looked at solution
thermodynamics variation again of
thermodynamic entities as a function of
composition and temperature and they
allows us they allow us to determine the
construct the phase diagrams that we see
in reality and these phase diagrams are
very useful from the perspective of
determination of microstructure
determination of solidification
temperatures segregation and so zone
refining design of alloys and so on and
so forth so hopefully you have enjoyed
this course I have tried to give you a
reasonably good overview of things the
books that I recommend have been shown
in the beginning of the course and also
in the intermittently please go through
the books and the exercises I am sure
you will benefit there will be some
assignments that you will have to carry
out which will help you to go through
the course thank you very much and if
you have any questions please write to
me my email is Ashish
g at iit k dot AC dot in this is my
email id please write on it thank you
very much
[Music]
[Music]
