noc19-cy16 Lecture 02-Solid State Thermodynamics

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Dec 3, 2023
Now, I will go to lecture 2 of week 1 of this course. So, in the first lecture of week 1,
we learnt about the solid state of matter and we looked at different solid state materials.
We looked at some elementary properties and some bonding, some characteristics of bonding
in solids. In this lecture, that is the second lecture, I am going to talk about the thermodynamics
of solids. So, this is week 1, lecture 2, we are going to discuss solid state thermodynamics.
So, some very basic thermodynamics of solids can be understood by looking at enthalpy and
entropy. We mentioned that solids are stabilized by interactions and have low enthalpy. On
the other hand, they are destabilized because of low entropy. So, what do we mean by this?
So, if you take any solid material, then the constituent particles, let us say, if they
were atoms, then these atoms would be arranged in a regular order and the distance between
the atoms would be very small compared to in a liquid. So, if you look at a typical
solid, you have various particles and they are arranged in some order. I am just taking
a hypothetical example of a solid, where everything is arranged like this and this distance is
very small. So, this distance in solid is much smaller than in a liquid. So, compared
to a liquid, you will have particles that are quite far apart typically and they would
not be arranged. They would not be ordered in any fashion. They would just exist far
away from each other.
So now, what happens is that since the particles are very close to each other, there is an
interaction between these particles. So, there is a strong attractive interaction. So, there
is a strong attractive interaction between the particles. I am emphasizing the attractive
part because of this attraction, the enthalpy, the energy of the solid is lower. So, the
enthalpy of the solid is lower and this is what I mean by solids are stabilized and have
low enthalpy. However, because the particles are very close to each other, they do not
have so much freedom to move around and therefore, they have low entropy.
So, a low entropy state is actually less stable. So, the solid is stabilized by enthalpy,
but destabilized by entropy, whereas a liquid has lower entropy or higher entropy and it
also has high H enthalpy. So, the enthalpy is higher. So, it is less stable, but the
entropy is higher. So, entropically the liquid is more stable.
So now, what happens at the solid liquid phase transition at some temperature and pressure?
What happens is that the free energy of the solid and the liquid are identical at the
phase transition. So, at the phase transition, that would be the melting point of the solid.
So, what happens is that the free energy is a combination of enthalpy and entropy
and there is a factor of temperature that appears. So, the enthalpy minus T times entropy
of the solid. So, S refers to the solid and L refers to the liquid. So, the enthalpy of
the solid minus T times entropy of the solid should be equal to the enthalpy of the liquid
minus T times enthalpy of the liquid. This is at the phase transition and I emphasize
this part that this is only true at the phase transition.
If you go below the phase transition, then the free energy of the solid becomes lower.
So, the solid becomes more stable. If you go above the melting temperature, above the
phase transition, then the liquid has a lower free energy. But at the phase transition,
the solid and liquid have the same free energy and what we said is that the solid has a lower
enthalpy, but it also has a lower entropy. So, the factor that you subtract from the
enthalpy is also lower whereas, a liquid has a higher enthalpy, but it also has a higher
entropy. So, the factor that you subtract the entropy is actually higher. So, that is why at
higher temperatures, the entropy term becomes more important and the liquid becomes more stable at
higher temperature. A point to make is that the interaction potential in solids and liquids is
the same. So, what you mean is that even in a liquid, the particles are interacting with each
other and if you get two liquid particles very close to each other, let us say you get them
distanced apart, the interaction energy will still be the same. The interaction is the same
whether you have solids, liquids or gases. It is only that since the particles are far away,
the interaction is weaker, but the potential of interaction is the same in all the states.
Just to clarify that, we will discuss a little bit more in detail about the interaction potential.
So, here let us look at we are trying to see what is the interaction between particles and let us
take a very classical picture where the particles are just particles that obey laws of classical
mechanics. The total energy is the sum of a kinetic energy and a potential energy. Now,
what I am showing here is that in classical mechanics, the energy is a function of the
positions. So, r 1, r 2 up to r n represents the positions of all the particles and p 1,
p 2 represents the momentum or if you can think of it as the velocity of the particles.
So, if there are n particles in the system, then the total energy is a function of
coordinates, all the positions of all the particles and all the momenta of all the particles.
When you separate the total energy into a kinetic part and a potential part,
the kinetic energy function that is T depends only on the momenta of the particles.
It depends only on the momenta. So, the kinetic energy is half m v square. So,
you can write this as p square by 2 m for each particle. So, the total kinetic energy of
the entire system of particles, entire collection of n particles, the total kinetic energy is just
sum of individual kinetic energies of each of the particles. However, the total potential energy
that depends on the coordinates of each of the particles and this potential energy typically
comes because the particles interact with each other or there might be an external field.
So, now let us look at this potential energy in a little bit more detail. So, what we will
write is that this total potential energy that is the energy due to the positions of the particles
can be written as a sum of different terms. The first term has this is called a single
particle potential and this is just a one particle potential and what it means is that
this term this is a single particle potential. So, this is a single particle term what it means
is that this is a term in the potential energy that depends only on the coordinates of one
particle. So, i goes from 1 to n. So, this will have this is a sum from i going from 1 to n. So,
it will have a term that looks like potential energy of the first particle plus potential
energy of the second particle and so on. Now, such a term only comes into play when you have
the system in an external field. So, if there is an external magnetic field or an electric field
that affects each particle individually, then you would have this kind of term.
The second term is V 2 that depends on coordinates of 2 particles i and j and i should not be equal
to j and this is called a pair potential. So, this is called a 2 particle or a 2 particle term
and this comes because 2 particles a pair of particles interact with each other. So,
particle i and j they are interacting with each other and what is the energy due to their
interaction is what is governed by this pair potential. You could also have higher particle
terms this got erased a little. So, this should be V of r i r j r k. So, it should depend on these
3 coordinates. Now, this is a 3 particle term and what it means is that it is a term in the
potential energy that depends on coordinates of 3 particles at a time and you have to take all
sets of 3 particle groups. Now, usually we are interested in cases where there is no external
field. So, this term goes to 0 and we ignore the higher order interaction. So, we say that
the particles interact only through pairs and if you make that assumption, then the total potential
energy is written as just a sum of the pair particle terms only of V 2 and further if you
assume that all the particles interact with a central potential. That means that the potential
energy due to interactions of particles at i and j just depends on the absolute value of the
distance. So, this is the distance between particles. So, therefore, it is like saying
that if you have this is the distance. So, it is like saying that if you have 1 particle at i
and you have other particle at j, then the potential energy due to interaction between
these 2 just depends on this distance between the 2 particles. So, this V 2
becomes a function of just 1 scalar distance and typically you call this the pair potential
V of r that tells you what is the nature of interactions in the system that tells you like
how this interaction will change as you change the distance between the particles.
So, the pair potential is what tells you what the interaction between the particles are
and what I want to emphasize is that this pair potential is what describes various systems. So,
suppose you have an ideal gas, then the pair potential is 0. That means you take 2 particles
and you keep separating them and you know you get them closer and closer to each other and they will
never interact and the potential energy will never increase. So, ideal gas has V of r equal to 0 and
as a consequence, it can never be liquefied or solidified. It is always a gas. You always have
PV equal to nRT and that never changes. So, PV equal to nRT is always valid at whatever
temperature you go. So, for an ideal gas, if you just look at the form of the ideal gas,
it just says PV equal to nRT independent of temperature. There is nothing that causes a
phase transition from gas to liquid or solid and this can be understood as a consequence of the
fact that the particles in an ideal gas do not interact with each other at all.
Now, suppose you had charged or dipolar particles, they would have coulombic or
dipolar interaction. So, if you had particles in your system having, let us say, some particle
has charge q 1 and another particle has charge q 2 and if they are separated by a distance r,
then the potential energy due to this interaction looks like 1 over 4 pi epsilon q 1 q 2 by r.
So, the pair potential is a coulombic pair potential. This is coulombic.
So, what you have to do is, if you go back to the pair potential, if you go back to the
description, you have to sum over all pairs of particles. So, there is a sum over all pairs.
It is written as i less than j, just to make sure that you do not over count the pairs.
So, V between 1 and 2 is same as interaction between 2 and 1. So, it should not be over
counted. So, we put a condition that i should be less than j in the second sum. The j goes
over all the particles. So, if V of r has this form, then you can write the pair potential.
You can write the total interaction as sum of all these pairs. You could have other cases
where you do not have charged particles that are dipolar. You could have particles that have both
charges and dipoles. So, you could have many different interactions.
If you have completely non polar neutral particles, then you can also have what are
known as induced dipolar interactions. I want to emphasize this induced dipolar interactions.
So, suppose you have something like argon gas and inert gas. So, inert gas, there is not really
much polarization that happens. You still have interaction. You can still liquefy all these
inert gases. Let me write it right here. So, if you take, I will just write it here. So,
the V of r in this case, if you have neutral non polar particles, then what would happen is that
there would be an attractive interaction that goes like, I will just say 1 over r to the 6th.
So, the way the attractive interaction goes as 1 over r to the 6th. So,
this is and then you have a repulse. Typically, you will have some short range repulsion. So,
this is 1 over r to the 6th. So, this represents the attraction due to the induced dipolar
interactions. Now, if you get the particles very close, there will be some repulsion and
a very common form of this repulsion. This is not the only form by any means. So, this is referred
to as the Lennard Jones potential. So, this is what happens when you have neutral particles and
you have induced dipolar interactions and this is typically what happens in inert gases.
Now, of course, if you take atoms of metal, then the interactions are much more complicated.
If you take molecules, you will get even more complicated interactions
and typically these interactions, if they form a bond, then you will have an interaction due
to the bonding, which will be either a Morse potential or a harmonic oscillator potential.
But in any case, the point is that if you take particles in any solid, then they can have very
complicated interactions. If you actually want to go ahead and take any 2 particles
and calculate the interaction between them, then if you want to do it correctly, you have to do a
quantum mechanical calculation. But nevertheless, we say that at the end of this calculation,
you get some pair potential of interaction. Now, what is important is that if your system
just had particles, let us take a gas and let us take a gas that is not ideal.
Now, since the gas is not ideal, then we say that the gas particles interact with each other
and if they interact with each other, if there is some attractive interaction,
then that could lead to phase transition. That means if there is some attractive interaction,
then by cooling down the gas, you could get into a liquid state. If there was no interaction,
you could never liquefy or solidify it. That is what we said. For an ideal gas,
there is no interaction. So, you can never liquefy or solidify it.
But if there is some attractive interaction, then you can actually cool the gas and at some point,
the particles will try to come close to each other. Now, what should be kept in mind is that
the interactions are same in all the phases. So, whether you have a solid, liquid or the gas,
the interaction potential V of r will be the same. It just depends on what the constituents are and
what atoms or molecules are there in that system. Therefore, when we say that a solid
has low enthalpy, what we mean is that these particles are at such a distance from each other
that there is a strong attractive interaction. So, the distance between these particles are
such that there is a strong attractive interaction in a solid. When you heat it,
then the entropy term becomes more important. Therefore, even though there is a tendency to
be close to each other because at high temperatures, the entropy term becomes
important. So, the liquid state becomes more stable.
So, what I want to emphasize through this discussion is that solid,
liquid and gas have the same pair potential. If you take, for example, iron and you heat
it, the interaction, the pair potential between any two atoms and iron will be the same.
You heat it above the melting temperature, it will become a liquid. Even liquid iron will
have the same pair potential, but because the temperature is so high,
entropic effects become more important. Next, I will talk briefly about the phase
diagrams. What should be kept in mind is that your melting temperature depends on the pressure.
That means, if you take ice and at normal atmospheric pressure, ice melts at 0 degree
centigrade, but if you increase the pressure, then ice will melt at much higher temperature.
Now, this dependence of this behavior of the system on pressure and temperature is encapsulated
in the pressure temperature phase diagram. You have all seen this in your thermodynamics course.
So, I will just briefly mention some key characteristics. If you look at a typical
phase diagram of any simple material, I will show you the PT phase diagram.
Let me show the pressure on this axis and the temperature on this axis.
Now, as you increase the pressure, then the phase that you will get is the solid phase
and as you increase the temperature, you will get the gas phase. So, the typical phase diagram
will look something like this, where you have a gas phase here. You have a solid phase here
and in between, you have the liquid phase. So, this is what the pressure versus temperature
phase diagram will look like for a typical material that has only three phases- a solid,
a liquid or a gas. Now, if your solid is a crystalline solid, then you could have multiple
phases on the solid. So, the solid itself could have many different phases. These different
phases are typically referred to as polymorphs. So, in this case, you have a gas. Now, what you
have is you have your liquid here and your solid. You can have different phases of the solid. So,
you could have solid in the first phase and solid in the second phase and these are called
polymorphs. So, S 1 and S 2 are referred to as polymorphs of the solid.
So, you could have different polymorphs in the solid and these would correspond to different
phases of the solid. So, your phase diagram could get much more complicated and this is quite common
in lot of materials. Typically, these polymorphs are seen at very high pressures and often the
phase diagram is actually shown the other way. It is shown in terms of temperature and pressure.
So, for solids, usually when you go to very high pressures, then you will see lot of these
polymorphs. So, often this phase diagram for solid temperature and pressure and typically,
you need to go to very high pressure to see different phases in solids.
Let us take an example. First, we will go to the ion phase diagram. So, if you just look at pure
ion, then the phase diagram, I will just sketch it. So, this is an approximate sketch. So,
this is the pressure in units of kilo bar. So, 1 bar, remember 1 bar atmospheric pressure is about
1 bar. So, this is in many kilo bars. So, it is really thousands of bars. So, it is very high
pressure. So, if you go to very high pressures and let us say, you look at temperature in degree
centigrade and let me take a gradation, where I have 400, 800. So, I go from 0 to about.
So, obviously, if you go too much, this is 0 degree centigrade. So, if you go to lower
temperatures, then you will just have the same solid phase. Similarly, if you go to lower
pressures, if you go to very low pressures, then you will just have the usual solid phases.
But if you take iron and you look at the various phases as a function of pressure,
when you increase the pressure to very high values, then you will see some interesting
behavior. So, I will just show it schematically. It is approximately drawn. So, you will see
things like this. This is the usual phase of iron that is a BCC phase. It is called the alpha phase.
But if you go to very high temperatures, if you go beyond about 900 degree centigrade,
then you get what is called a gamma phase of iron, which is an FCC phase.
So, it is the same iron solid. All these are phases of solid iron. So, this is a phase diagram
of this is also solid. Gamma FCC is also solid. If you go beyond about 1500 degree centigrade,
then iron will melt and you will get liquid phase. If you go to very high pressures greater
than 100 kilo bar, you will get an epsilon phase, which is actually HCP iron hexagonal
close packed iron. This is a body centered cubic. This is face centered cubic and hexagonal close
packed. So, you can see that if you go back to our phase diagram, you just had a solid liquid gas.
So, we are just looking at this solid and liquid region and we see that we are just looking at
this solid liquid behavior at very high pressures and already we see lot more complications.
Now, if you see this phase diagram, there is one other phase that has been observed
experimentally. That is right around here. There is this delta phase, which is another BCC phase
of iron, high temperature BCC phase of iron. So, you can see we are just taking pure iron metal
and we are getting all these phases. Most of this is only in the solid region.
Now, what happens if you take iron carbon phase diagram? This is typically very important for
steel. So, here if there is more than one atom and iron and carbon, this is the phase diagram
of iron and carbon. Now, what happens is in addition to pressure and temperature,
you also have the percentage of carbon. So, let us say you have an additional variable,
which is the composition or the weight percent of carbon. So, in this case, what happens is that
as you change the composition of carbon and you change the temperature, you get several different
phases. So, at low temperature, you have this ferrite, a mixture of alpha ferrite and cementite.
As you go to higher temperatures, then you get alpha phase and alpha plus gamma,
austenite steel and so on. Melting is again much higher. Melting is only at this very high
temperature. As you increase the percentage of carbon, the melting temperature decreases.
So, you can see already that the phase diagram becomes very complicated when you have
different crystal polymers. So, I will conclude this lecture here and
this will be the end of lecture 2 of this course. Thank you.
