noc19-mg27 Lecture 17 - Leading the Sales Force

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
So, this is our second session, fourth week on management of field sales.
We are discussing the different aspects relating to the sales force organization, sales force
management and behavioral issues, organization issues, performance issues, compensation issues.
These are the kinds of topics we are handling this week.
Incidentally, for most of the discussions this week, I am using this particular book
available from McGraw Hill as Indian publication.
It's called Management of a Sales Force by Rosen Spiro and Greg Rich and William Stanton.
Most of the key aspects you will be able to see in the PowerPoints that will be available
to you.
For detailed study, I would recommend that you refer to this book.
You can also refer to the Manning's book, the main textbook that I had suggested right
in the beginning and it is also mentioned in your course announcement on the web.
Spiro's book is also mentioned there.
Now we are discussing, we call this whole course and as well this management of field
sales, right.
But some specialists, some academicians and practitioners, they argue that when it comes
to sales force, because we are mainly dealing with expert personnel who are necessarily
little different from many other employees, the word management is better replaced by
leading or coaching and we will see why these leading or coaching are better words than
management when it comes to the sales force.
Basically the idea here is that the leadership is a process of inspiring, influencing and
guiding employees to participate in a common effort as opposed to management which is planning,
implementing and controlling the selling function.
So by the very definition you see management is a bit impersonal process.
Management is more focused on tasks whereas leadership is still interested in tasks and
accomplishment of objectives.
But it looks at achieving those objectives through people and therefore behavioral, organizational
behavioral aspects, psychological aspects, inspiring processes, confidence building processes
are better approaches than mechanistic process oriented, task oriented management processes.
So you can argue that one can mean the other but generally therefore if you just say leader
or a coach you can actually get a better, I personally quite like this approach of coach
because that's exactly the role that today's sales managers perform.
Just like in a football team the goal will be scored by the people on the field whether
defense or offense and in combination but the coach is outside the field but the coach's
contribution is significant because the coach enthuses the team if they are down, the coach
works with them in setting the strategy, the coach makes them aware of the opponent team's
strengths and weaknesses.
So the coach has a very valuable role played in the beginning of the game, in the middle
of the game, at the end of the game and the coach in spite of being outside the field
plays a huge binding, inspiring, confidence building, enthusing role and that's the kind
of role today the sales managers are often asked to play.
Look at this two by two matrix.
We have this structural on the x-axis structure, low structure versus high structure and consideration
on the y-axis.
So this high structure, high consideration here leader strives to achieve a productive
balance between getting the job done and maintaining a cohesive friendly work group.
So you see human considerations or people considerations are balanced here by task considerations.
So this is the high structure, high consideration.
This is the necessary approach to most of the high tech, high velocity sales organizations
of many industries today.
It is very seldom today to find an organization where low structure, low consideration will
work where actually you just kind of let the system flow.
I mean some very low performing organizations may have degenerated into this kind of a structure
but this is just the exact opposite of where you want to be today in this high structure,
high consideration.
There can be still organizations where this low like a club, a club may be you know in
this kind of a situation where there is a low structure but high consideration.
So you want the club to perform different activities but you can't have a very you
know directive role there.
So the coach is a good example there and then of course there are high structure, low consideration.
This is also something that is not very where the primary attention is getting the job done.
Personal concerns are strictly secondary.
This kind of organization may be very good for a fire brigade or in the army or in the
police but not maybe that efficient in a sales structure.
But remember that these are very general classifications.
There could be somebody in a particular organization where the organization was in a huge decline
and he or she comes in as a rejuvenator salesperson but the person may initially be very rule
oriented to bring the organization back on track and therefore the high structure, high
task orientation may be required there.
But generally therefore we will like to be in this blue segment.
Most organizations achieve try to be there.
Very few organizations today will be this low structure, low consideration situation.
Some organizations may be operating quite fine with low structure and high consideration
because for example if it is a an organization like a consultant organization or a professional
advisor or a law firm they will have sales function but that sales function will be kind
of quite embedded in the deliverers and therefore there the sales leader will be actually replaced
by a role which will promote group harmony and social need satisfaction.
So some organizations may still be there in certain types of selling situation which
is say high end service sale like in a hospital, healthcare organization, in a legal service
organization there the sales organization may have this kind of low structure, high
consideration but aim in most cases will be today towards this high structure, high
consideration.
And how do you look at the structural emphasis of organization is look at how they plan,
what kind of regularity is followed, what emphasis is paid on planning, how expectations
are communicated, decisions are made and followed and performances how regularly they are appraised
and feedbacks given. This will show us the structural end of the leadership.
Consideration end of the leadership we will see how regular and effective are at a personal
level communication, how well the sales persons are treated as individuals, what kind of respect
they get within the organization and how the reward system operates. So many times particularly
if you read that it's a thin book but very nice book it's called the one minute manager
and the sales person or something like that they are actually very nicely this concept
of situational leadership is explained. So which means it says that sales leadership
will often depend on the nature of your followership that means what kind of people you are leading,
what kind of sales persons you are leading will determine what kind of leadership style
and role you should perform. So if you are leading a group of high level and highly committed
experts then this low structure high consideration may be a functional approach. On the other
hand if you are trying to rejuvenate a sagging organization, a failing organization or if
you are actually in an emergency type of situation where you are actually trying to book a very
large order which is currently poised precariously then you may actually be looking at a high
structure low consideration. So the point here is situational leadership
means you look at the situation and use the best style and good sales leaders, good sales
coaches have the flexibility to change from one mode to the other mode depending on the
team they are leading. But some of the things that a coach will always do is a lot of documentation
as you know you might have seen in movies and all how football coaches in America they
do all this game plan you know they make a game book where you say okay this is how
different people will play if this is the kind of attack then this is the way we respond.
All that kind of documents will have to be translated in your context in your industry's
context and the documentation will help in bringing the sales person and the leader on
the same page. So, synchronization of objectives and understanding the nitty-gritties of operational
processes will be better done if this four-step process of documentation, agreement, exploring
alternatives and solutions and commitment if these four steps are followed to start
with. I am now going to spend a few minutes on discussing that how you recruit sales people,
what kind of processes are followed in recruiting as well as in training. So,
salesperson recruitment is a very involved task because as we were discussing a salesperson
has a complex role the person has to be a self-starter if the person will be most of
the time operating out there in the field on his or her own and therefore we need to
be a good self-monitoring person, self-motivated person. On the other hand, the person will
be facing a lot of rejection, objection and therefore should have the psychological stamina
to deal with continuous negative feedback or subtle attacks and so you when you recruit
a salesperson you look at these abilities if not available today how the potential developing
opportunities that will be presented by the candidate. So, you look at that and so obviously
in sales force recruitment personal interaction or personal interview as well as group discussions
are an observation of group dynamics, an observation of individuals in a group situation, individuals
in a stressful situation are all very important. So, of course, these are some general remarks
to be exact you have to also assess depending on the so we were discussing about HP a little
while back when we were discussing sales organization structure. So, there obviously you will have
to take people recruit such sales people who have the ability already built in as a necessary
technical background to be very good in understanding the intricacies of a complex product. So,
those are things that you have to add to the personality factors, the group interaction
factors, the calm and cool factors, the ability to handle rejection factor all that you have
to also add the technical caliber and such capabilities. So, determining the job requirements
the job profile must be very clearly articulated and which part of the job profile needs what
kind of expertise that if it is charted and presented to the potential candidates will
be very good. So, like for example, it should be right there upfront that with how intense
will be the travel requirement of the job so that there are no dissatisfactions at the
later stage. Some of the typical questions faced by sales persons during the interview
I have listed here I have participated in hundreds of interview situation with sales
people. So, this is for you to this is a quick recap of things you should know well if you
are getting into a sales interview like for example, can you describe the sales process?
What are your greatest strengths and weaknesses? What sales books have you read lately? What
was the most boring job you ever had and how did you handle it? What is the biggest contribution
you made to your last employer or just sell me this pen or this book or this computer
or this lamp? Consider I am a buyer and you tell me how you will sell it. So, you may
be actually in this kind of an impromptu situation and be prepared for some nice start of presentation.
Usually you will not have to make a five minutes presentation. You just start and the
interviewer may shift to the next question just making some quick assessment that how
you handle the first level of interaction and of course, the typical question like why
should we hire you? You should have some good responses to all these kind of I would say
that this one to seven in combination will be present in almost 80 percent of the sales
interview situations. So, it will be good to prepare for these and after you have taken
a good salesperson remember that the training and development post recruitment is a very
very important step. If this is not done well then a good salesperson may actually
go astray because the person may not be well synchronized with the organization's culture,
organization's objectives all those can be communicated well through the initial post
recruitment training and development. That's why often that type of training and development
is called induction. That means how you take from somebody from outside and make it part
of your team has to be a process which is sensitive to not only the technical side but
also the human side, the organizational culture, psychology, behavior side that what are the
different do's and don'ts in this organization those should go hand in hand with this is
the nature of the product or these are the highlights of the product and such issues.
My last four slides are dedicated to motivating the sales force. Motivations are of two types
obviously internal motivations and external motivations. Internal motivations come from
the personality of the person, how that person deals with a somewhat hostile environment,
how that person deals with operating alone, how that person deals with what makes the
person glad, what makes the person sad. These are internal motivational factors and external
of course you can always use monetary incentives, prestige incentives, task completion joys
and I'm going to present to you some interesting facts coming out of different research. Incidentally
compensation plans, these are the typical five types of compensations given to salespeople.
You get commission that means you know more you sell more money you get. So, it totally
dependent on your month to month, week to week performance. Then you can have commission
with some kind of guaranteed part or some kind of an advance drawdown facility. It can
have a fixed part, commission part and a bonus part. Fixed salary plus bonus can be
another alternative to that. So, fixed salary plus bonus, bonus if you exceed your quota,
your goal sales goal or it can be some small part will be fixed then there will be a large
part which will be related to commission on sales up to the objective point and then
there can be a larger percentage in bonus if you exceed the goal. So, right from straight
commission which is one end to straight salary which is the other end there can be these
different combinations. Now, the compensation can be compensation plan can be linked to
motivational factors and thereby you can actually create subsidiary objectives or you can perform
strategic objective of the organization. For example, a specific product movement the more
sales for a specific product very important when it is a new product introduction. So,
a higher level of incentive provided for higher level of sales of a new product is required
because a new product needs a lot more intense sales effort, some innovation, some more training
understanding expertise development on behalf of the salesperson. So, it is good that if
you give some higher level of compensation for a specific product movement or establish
new accounts this is another case where higher level of compensation can be thought of and
then of course, percentage sales increase or general increase in sales activity these
are important inputs into the compensation structure.
The sales force productivity therefore, should be measured in terms of quantitative criteria
like sales volume in rupees, sales volume compared to previous year sales, sales volume
by product, sales volume by new accounts percentage, net profit per account, number of customer
calls per sale all that should be there and also there should be qualitative criteria
because sometimes there may be a star performer in terms of the results, but that person can
be a toxic person with respect to the sales team environment within the organization that
person may be very abrasive, that person may be very depressing encounter for the other
members of the team. So, therefore, you should look at attitude, product knowledge, communication
skill, goodwill generated, initiative, team collaboration all these are as qualitative
criteria that should be rewarded or challenged. So, compensation strategy should be performance
related as well as structural issues related which means should be based on quantitative
criteria as well as qualitative criteria. So, that is where we end today's session
and we will discuss more about compensation and some of these other aspects that we have
brought up in today's session in the subsequent discussions.
Thank you.
