To access the translated content: 1. The translated content of this course is available in regional languages. For details please visit https://nptel.ac.in/translation The video course content can be accessed in the form of regional language text transcripts, books which can be accessed under downloads of each course, subtitles in the video and Video Text Track below the video. Your feedback is highly appreciated. Kindly fill this form https://forms.gle/XFZhSnHsCLML2LXA6 2. Regional language subtitles available for this course To watch the subtitles in regional languages: 1. Click on the lecture under Course Details. 2. Play the video. 3. Now click on the Settings icon and a list of features will display 4. From that select the option Subtitles/CC. 5. Now select the Language from the available languages to read the subtitle in the regional language.
Welcome back to the lecture which we are discussing about extrusion and liquid phase processing.
In the previous lecture, we were more focused towards extrusion process.
In this lecture, we will be focused towards liquid based processes.
So, we will start looking into bioextrusion and other processes here.
Bioextrusion process, this is an extrusion based technology has a large variety of material
that can be processed.
If a material can be presented in a liquid form that can quickly solidify, then it is
suitable for this process.
As mentioned earlier, the creation of this liquid can be either through thermal processing
of material to create a melt or by using some form of chemical process where the material
is in a gel form that can dry out or chemically harden quickly.
These techniques are useful for bioextrusion.
So, the analogy for this is if you keep the fevicol exposed to the free atmosphere, it
reacts and it solidifies.
So, that is what it is.
Or by using some form of chemical process where the material is in a gel form, semi-solid
form, that can dry out or chemically harden quickly.
For example, the glue whatever we use for sticking the tire puncture, fevicol, all these
things undergo this process.
So, these techniques are useful for bioextrusion.
Bioextrusion is the process of creating biocompatible.
Very interesting.
So, if you see our body, if you see our skin, tissue, they are all made out of polymers.
Body is made out of polymers.
Of course, the skeleton is there, but the covering layer will be polymers.
These polymers, today people have understood the chemistry and then they have started mimicking
it.
So, they call it as bio mimicking.
In bio mimicking, what happens?
Understand the chemistry, redevelop the material to artificially to match the natural one.
So, this material is fabricated, that is in a gel form and it is extruded.
And when you say it is in a gel form, if you go back and think in the extrusion process,
we had a wire, the diameter of the wire, the nozzle diameter always had a restriction
on it.
So, if we can reduce the nozzle diameter and control the flow of the material, then you
can get very high resolutions or the features whatever you make will be very close to reality.
So, that is why they use liquid as a starting material or a gel as a starting material.
So, bio extrusion is a process of creating biocompatible and or biodegradable components.
Why do we call it as biodegradable?
Suppose you integrate it into your body and it is there for some time and then it should
be biodegradable.
For example, today they have staplers.
So, these staplers for example, if you have a surgery in your skin, it is cut and earlier
we do sutures, stitches.
And initially these stitches, the threads were not biodegradable.
Then came biodegradable sutures, that means to say threads.
Now what is happening?
We have biocompatible or biodegradable staplers.
So, they just pull out the skin and stapler it and leave it there.
So, over a period of time, the stapler also dissolves, the skin also joins and you do
not see any scar mark there.
So, biodegradable components are that, that are used to generate framework commonly referred
to as scaffold, that play host to animal cells for the formation of tissues.
So, either you can make, you can make a scaffold or you can make a compound like this and where
in which you can put it inside an ambience and in that ambience you will allow the bacteria
to grow or whatever cells to grow.
Then these cells are taken out and then it is integrated into the body.
So, or the cells form the tissues.
Such scaffolds should be porous.
So, we do not need, we do not need completely dense, dense material, we need porous so that
through this porous material, the flow can happen, the cell can grow and it can get attached
to the body.
With micropores that allow cell adhesion, see if you have a flat body, cell to sit on
top of it is very difficult.
But if you have undulated surface, the cells can sit and get locked very fast.
So, this is what we are talking about the pores.
If you see that, this can, I have just put on the surface, you can have across the surface,
if you want to do, you can do.
Bioextrusion machine use a conventional FDM like process with setting for a proprietary
material.
This is a challenge where many labs, many labs and industries are working.
It is completely, it is completely proprietary.
You can use light to solidify.
You can allow free atmosphere to solidify.
You can allow oxidation to happen.
So, many materials are getting integrated based on the biocompatible polymer.
Polycaprola acetone, PCL is a material which is generally used.
Most tissue engineering is still however in the research form.
So, many aspects of this process includes material choice.
Depending upon the customer requirement, the material choice, the material adding and deleting
can be done.
Today, the technology of the process engineering has gone to such an extent, they decide what
to add, what not to add.
They can functionalize, they can coat, whatever they want, they can do.
Next is structural strength of the scaffold.
Then coating and biocompatibility can be done.
Effectiveness with various clinical scenarios.
So, these are some of the aspects which are done.
See, what happens in engineering products.
Engineering products, you just make a product, do a mechanical test and you certify it, it
is okay.
But whereas, when you want to integrate this product, whatever is getting developed through
rapid prototyping as a replacement for the existing technology, so then what we will
do is, we will have to do that trial on animal, then see that, see the performance, then put
it on man, wait for 10 years or 8 years, whatever it is.
And then we say, okay, now it is worthwhile trying in the human body.
So, it takes a long time.
So, that is what we are talking about, effectiveness with various clinical scenario.
Clinical scenario, if you make a bioproduct or if you make a biomechanic product and if
you integrate it outside the body, it is easy to get clinical clearance.
If it is inside, it needs a stringent testing, okay.
So, these are some of the investigation, even now people are executing it.
The challenge here is not the machine, the challenge here is the proprietary material.
Many systems are in fact developed in-house to match the specific interest of the researcher.
So, when bioextrusion comes into fullest extent, we will talk more of rapid manufacturing only.
The prototyping is gone.
The product what gets developed from this process, bioextrusion process, let it be FDM
or any other route, whatever gets, it is directly called as rapid manufacturing.
Why?
Because you have made the live product which gets into the real-time application directly.
So, here bioextrusion, people are now talking about only polymers, slowly slowly people
have started going towards ceramics, that is hydroxyapatite they have started talking.
And then they are also now talking about can we directly put metals and can we extrude
metals.
This is another thing which people are talking about.
So, here these are some of the challenges.
And when we talk about the product, the product feature size, feature size, not the product
size, the feature size is very important.
Next one is the roughness on the surface.
The roughness on the surface can be selectively made for a cell to adhere, a cell not to adhere.
So, you can selectively roughen the surface or make a porous structure in the surface
such that the cell goes, sticks there and starts growing there.
So, bioextrusion is one of the major process which leads towards rapid manufacturing.
Gel formation.
One common method of creating scaffold, the output product, is to use hydrogels.
This is a material, hydrogels.
These are polymers that are water insoluble, but can be dispersed in water, water insoluble,
but dispersed in water.
You see that?
You can cook the material to your requirements.
Of course, there is a huge intellectual challenge there, but people are slowly, slowly getting
out of that.
Simulations have come up in a big way, molecular dynamic simulations which we talk about, it
has come up in a very large way.
So, that can give you lot of understanding of the formation of polymers.
Hydrogels can therefore be extruded in a jelly form.
Such a media can be very biocompatible and conducive to cell growth with low toxicity
level.
Hydrogels can be based on naturally occurring polymers or synthetic polymers.
The natural polymers are perhaps more biocompatible, whereas the synthetic ones are stronger.
So, you see, natural polymer and synthetic polymer, natural is soft and biodegradable
easily.
Synthetic are strong and it is many a times you add elements to it which is non-biodegradable.
Many a times, some of the elements, not all the elements.
Synthetic hydrogel are rarely used in tissue engineering, however, because of the use of
the toxicity reagents.
Overall, the use of hydrogel results in weak scaffolds that may be useful to soft tissues.
Melt extrusion is a process which is done.
This system is an extrusion based screw feeding technology that is designed specifically for
biopolymer.
Melt extrusion, if you understand the process of injection molding, melt extrusion you can
understand.
Lower temperature polymers can be extruded using a compressed gas feed instead of screw
extrusion.
So, screw extrusion, see what is happening is, the challenge in all these injection molding
machines is you have a large charge, you need a large charge.
That means to say, the raw material minimum required will be in few 10 kilos.
So, if you want to make small components, then we have to make a small hopper and we
also try to avoid the screw.
So, there we use a compressed gas feed which results in a much simpler mechanism.
Much of a system use non-reactive stainless steel and machine itself has a small built
envelope and software specifically aiming to, aiming at the scaffold fabrication.
The melt chamber which we saw in FDM is sealed apart from the nozzle with a compressed air
feed to assess the screw extrusion process.
Whatever screw did earlier, now that screw is replaced by the air.
The system uses one extrusion head at a time.
So, that means to say, you can have multiple extrusions.
So, multiple extrusions is, you can have multiple materials coming out from different nozzles.
Depending upon your requirement, depending upon your color, you can blend it, you can
get.
With a corrosal feeder, so that extruder can be swapped at any time during the process.
This is particularly useful since most tissue engineering research focuses on building scaffold
with different regions made from different materials.
This is what I was talking to you about in bio-extrusion, we do selective material feed.
Build parameters can be set for a variety of materials with control over the chamber
temperature, feed rates, plotting speed to provide user with a versatile platform for
tissue engineering research.
This we have already discussed, the chamber temperature, so that the gluing can happen
properly, feed rate and then plotting speed.
It should be noted that the tissue engineering is an extremely complex research area and
the construction of physical scaffold is just a starting point.
This approach may result in scaffolds that are compared with hydrogen based scaffolds,
but they may fail in terms of biocompatibility and biotoxicity.
So when you replace it, we have this problem.
To overcome some of these shortcomings, significant amount of post processing is required.
So what we do is, we talk about coating the scaffold whatever is manufactured.
So this is one of the bio-plotter which is used.
So you can see here, these are the place where you keep the cartridge material, okay.
And this is the table which is used.
The machine looks to be a desktop machine.
So here are the cartridges which we keep for multiple materials.
Selectively you want to do, you can use it.
Scaffold architecture.
So scaffold architecture is another big challenge.
When we talk about rapid manufacturing using these processes in biology, scaffold architecture
is a big challenge.
One of the major limitation with extrusion based system for conventional manufacturing
application relates to the diameter of the nozzle.
So scaffold, because the nozzle diameter, nozzle dia is directly proportional to the
road which is made, okay.
So now since it is viscoelastic, then it is directly proportional to width of the road,
okay.
For tissue engineering, however, this is not such a limitation.
Scaffold are generally built up so that the roads are separated by a set distance so that
the scaffold can have a specific porosity.
So that is what is the challenge.
Here architecture is you decide and design your pores, design of pores for cell to grow.
That is a challenge.
In fact, the aim is to produce scaffold that are strong as possible but with a much porosity
as possible.
The greater the porosity, the more space there is for cell to grow.
Scaffold with greater than 66% porosity are common today.
You look at the weight, already it is polymer based and then you will have, you make it
with 66 porosity, it will be very light.
But now the challenge is how do you strengthen a 66% porous material.
Therefore, it may be better to have a thicker nozzle to build a stronger scaffold.
So designing of the pore, this leads to nozzle design.
Nozzle design leads to road, road width.
The spacing between the studs can be used to determine the scaffold porosity.
The most effective geometry of scaffold has yet to be determined.
For many studies, scaffold with a simple 0 and 90 orthogonal crossover pattern may be
sufficient.
So what they say is, they say you will first layer put like this, next layer you will put
like this and the third layer maybe you will put like this, okay.
So if you see that, first layer, second layer, third layer.
So what have you done?
You have changed the orientation such that you strengthen the material.
The more complex pattern may have varying crossover patterns.
Why?
It can have 0 degrees, it can have 90 degrees, it can have 30 degrees, it can have 60 degrees,
it can have 45 degrees, it can have a combination 0 slash 90 slash 60 slash 30 slash 45 and
then you can do it like 5 times.
So this pattern will be repeated.
So about the axis, you will repeat it.
So why do we do this?
Because we try to distribute the strength.
Example of typical figures are given in the next figure.
So you can see, these are the scaffold architectures.
So this is what it is.
You can see 0 degrees, maybe 45 degrees.
This is maybe minus 45 degrees you can have.
So different scaffolds, each scaffold has different strength.
Build time varies and you can also, the density of the material varies, of the product varies.
So you have all these important points.
And then when you also try to do, when you have these structures, the heat shrinkage
is controlled.
Heat shrinkage is controlled.
So these are very important factors when we start working on this porous structures
and when we want to make scaffolds for real time application.
So this leads directly towards rapid manufacturing.
So what you print gets integrated into your body.
And still it is in the research stage.
There are few labs abroad, they have started making testings and then they have started
implementing in the body, but still a long way to go.
Much of the study involves finding out how cell proliferates in these different scaffold
architecture and are usually carried out using bioreactors for in vitro experiments.
As such, samples are usually quite small and often cut from a large scaffold structure.
It is anticipated that it will become commonplace for experiments to be carried out using samples
that are as large and complex in shape as the bones.
They are trying to replace the bones.
If you see bones, bones are not dense.
Bones are, they are dense, outside it is dense, inner it is hollow.
So we are trying to mimic that.
They are designed to replace and they are implanted in the animal or the human subjects.
Many more fundamental questions must be answered, however, before this becomes into common.
The contour crafting, in normal rapid manufacturing, layers are considered as 2D shapes, extruded
linearly in the third dimension.
Thicker layers result in lower part precision, particularly where there are slopes or curves
in a vertical direction.
So what they are trying to say is, if there is a slope change like this, if you want to
make multiple layers, you will make layers like this.
So you look at it.
So this is what they talk about is the error.
The thicker layer results in a lower part dimension because there is a huge error resulting
where the slopes or curves are in vertical direction.
A major innovative twist on the extrusion based approach can be found in the contour
crafting technology developed by Professor B. Piotrowski and his team in University of
Southern California.
The contour crafting, taking the principle mentioned above, the exterior surface is most
critical in terms of meeting precision requirements.
This research team has developed a method to smoothen the surface with the scraping
tool.
So what we can do is, suppose you have a pattern like this.
So what you do is, you try to smoothen it by giving a, by using a tool.
Why?
Because it is a polymer material.
If I can play with the temperature, the material, the product or the scaffold, whatever is made
is not rigid or solid.
So I just use a blade or a hot wire and then sweep it around, try to smoothen the surface.
So that is what is talked about the scraping tool.
This is similar to use of artesian shape clay pottery and the concrete using trowels.
By contouring the layer as they are being deposited using the scrapping tool to interpolate
between these layers, very thick layers can be made that still replicates the intended
geometry well.
Using this technique is conceptually possible to fabricate extremely large bodies very quickly
compared with the other additive processes.
Since the exterior precision is no longer determined solely by the layer thickness,
the scraper tool need not be straight edged and can in turn be somewhat reconfigurable
by positioning different parts of the tool in different regions or by multiple passes.
Basically you are trying to smoothen the surface.
So this is what is contour crafting.
And today what people talk about, they also talk about something called as 3D concrete
rapid tooling.
So almost the same technique is used in contour crafting.
So you get the required output in the required state.
There are other systems like non-planar systems.
There have been a few attempts to develop RM technology that does not use stratified
planar layers.
The most notable project are shaped deposition manufacturing, which is otherwise called as
SDM, or ballistic particle manufacturing, which is called as BPM, or curved laminate
object manufacturing, curved lomb.
The curved lomb process is particularly aimed at using different, using fiber reinforced
composite material sandwiched together for the purpose of making tough shelled components
like nose cone for aircrafts using carbon fibers and armor clothes using Kevlar.
So what is sandwich?
This is, you have a top layer, you have a bottom layer, whatever you want, and in between
you do filling of some other layer.
So this and this will try to take care of the tensile, maybe compression, or it can
go vice versa.
And the shear is taken care by the core.
So this is used for making Kevlar in the nose cone.
So what is nose cone?
Nose cone is when you have a flight.
This is the front part and then you have a flight.
So this is the nose cone.
To work properly, the layer of the material must confirm to the shape of the part being
designed.
If edges of the laminates are exposed, then they can easily come loose by applying shear
force.
So FDM of ceramics are also tried today.
Another possible application of FDM is to, or extrusion process is to develop ceramic
parts fabrication process.
In particular, FDM can be used to extrude ceramic pastes that can be quickly solidified.
Ceramic paste is nothing but cement.
Cement is a ceramic paste.
The resulting part can be fired using a high temperature furnace to fuse and densify the
ceramic material.
Resulting part can have very good properties with geometric complexity characteristics
of RM process.
Other RM processes have also been used for creating ceramic composites.
But most of the work in FDM came out from Rutgers University in USA.
The next process, which is liquid based process, the process most commonly named as stereolithography.
This is widely considered as a founding process within the field of rapid prototyping, with
the first patent granted to Chunck Hull in 1986, leading to the first commercial machine
from 3D systems in 1987.
A schematic diagram of how the stereolithography process works using a UV laser to initiate
a curing reaction in a photo curable resin was discussed earlier, we will also see now.
Using a CAD file to drive the laser, a selected portion of the surface of a vat of resin is
cured and solidified on a platform.
The platform is then lowered, typically by 100 microns and a fresh layer of the resin
is deposited over a previous layer.
The laser then scans a new layer that bonds to the previous layer.
So this is what it is.
We saw more in details when we were discussing about the photopolymerization.
So here is a lens, this is a table and here is a supporting structure.
So you see that this is a supporting structure, this is the part.
So maybe if you are trying to make a shoe, a lady shoe, so here you need supporting.
So that is what is the supporting layer used.
Jetting system is another system.
Supporting material is simultaneously jetted through a secondary series of jet and cured
to a gel state with a UV lamp, so that it may be removed by water jet or similarly after
building.
So it can also, you can also use reaction based.
For example, you can use some solvents which can dissolve the material.
As with the other processes, at time the process was initially aimed at the rapid prototyping
or rapid tooling market.
But the emergence of RM application has resulted in an interest in using technologies for using
in the end products.
So this is done by the jetting system.
This product and this product are done by jetting system.
It is really a complex product.
It is an engine valve.
If you want to make it in a single product by metals, it is, you can do it by casting.
But designing a mold for it is also a challenge.
Injection molding also can be tried.
But before doing it, rapid prototyping is used for making such complex shapes.
So you can see here there is a pipe which flows and then here and here.
High viscosity jetting process.
The principle involves continuous the same in layer pattern according to a very thin
slice of object to be printed.
This uses a mechanism based on displaying a small droplet of printable material to a
desired location on the substrate, okay.
You have a substrate, so you put droplets.
So these droplets come out of the jet.
The fundamental unit consists of a single jet which is controlled by air jet pressure.
The distance from the substrate and the length of the jet pulse is very, very important.
An experimental program on single jet is being carried out and the results are showing the
different shapes and size of deposition can be achieved.
Still this is in the nascent stage.
This concept will be scaled to a block of multiple jet control in parallel to deposit
of layers of a desired pattern.
If you are looking for an analogy, this process you should look at ink jet printing.
It is almost like that.
So you have a cartridge through, there is a liquid, then through this liquid is allowed
to open and then you try to create multiple outputs.
The high viscosity jetting principle.
What is the challenge?
It is the high viscosity.
The viscosity is a challenge wherein which you have to apply compressed air and this
fellow compressed air, through the tubing it comes, the compressed air pipe it comes
and then you see an air jet pulse is given.
So micro holes to support the plates.
So you see the, there are, these are the holes through which the jet falls down and then
this gets deposited.
So this is like your filter.
So the compressed air comes here and then you have the liquid also through this and
air jet is pulsed here.
So there are lot of holes.
Through these holes, the material falls on top of the substrate and you get deposited.
So what is the big advantage?
The advantage is layer thickness can be controlled.
It is a slow process.
Layer thickness can be controlled.
So high, higher resolutions can be done.
Higher resolutions is done or is made.
The strength is weak.
Strength of the component is weak and it is still in research.
These are the points you should understand.
MAPL process, MAPL-DW, Matrix Assisted Pulsed Laser Evaporation, direct write, was invented
by researchers at the Naval Research Laboratory, Washington.
It uses a high repetition rate, 355 nanometer UV laser beam, which is focused on a transparent
material or ribbon that has 1 to 10 millimeter thick layer of build material on the underside.
As the laser energy is directed to the ribbon, the build material transfers to the receiving
substrate.
This is the analogy of a typewriter ribbon.
Look at it here.
You will have, you will have a ribbon which keeps going, okay.
This ribbon will have material, ribbon.
You will have, this ribbon is the material, final material, what is to be deposited.
It is there.
So now what you do is you use a laser to write and when the laser writes or when it cures,
this material gets deposited on top of a substrate.
So this is a very, very interesting process and people are working on it, but still it
has not come to the market in regular use.
So the analogy is like a typewriter, in typewriter what we have is we have a spool, a ribbon
is passed through, then you have a type or a hammering of a single letter.
So this is an alphabet.
So when you do, what you do is you press the alphabet, the alphabet goes and hits at the
ribbon.
So you have a paper here.
In this paper, the impression is created.
So you can continuously keep doing it.
You can, so what is the, what is the limitation?
The spacing cannot be controlled.
The spacing is fixed, the spacing between letters.
For example, the spacing between these two letters are fixed.
Same way in typewriter.
If you want to go lesser than that, it is not possible.
So here also it is the, in typewriter that is a limitation, but however in laser what
happens, you can reduce or increase the distance, the pitch between the two letters by increasing
and decreasing the feed control, feed rate control.
When you start doing a feed rate control over this, you can start controlling the spool
and then you get this process.
So this is a MAPL process.
MAPL process is also used for bioprinting today.
To recapitulate whatever we have seen in this lecture, so we have seen what are the
basic principles used in extrusion based processes.
What do you understand by plotting and path control?
Explain about the different materials available for extrusion.
Explain about the major limitations of FDM.
What do we mean by the term bio-extrusion and why is extrusion based additive manufacturing
process more suitable for medical scaffold architecture compared with SLS scaffold made
from a similar material.
So these are the series which we saw today.
And I thank you for being with me in this lecture.