noc19-ph02 Lecture 79-Diamagnetism in Solids

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
so far we have dealt with paramagnetic
phenomena in which the magnetic moment
that is induced in the system is
proportional to the applied field and in
the same direction in this lecture I
want to deal with diamagnetism
and diamagnetism is case where the
applied field produces a magnetic moment
in the direction opposite to the applied
field
so the Hiedi is known as diamagnetic
susceptibility and its meaning is the
same as was the meaning for paramagnetic
susceptibility where we had defined m to
be equal to Chi paramagnetic I had
written em in the earlier lecture B
divided by mu zero I'm writing for Chi P
to differentiated form the diamagnetic
susceptibility and we had calculated the
paramagnetic susceptibility in the
previous lectures in this lecture I want
to focus on diamagnetism and see how we
can calculate the susceptibility for
diamagnetic materials for this I want
you to recall that to calculate the
paramagnetic susceptibility we
calculated the
energy change of a solid when it was
fought in an external magnetic field of
course when we did that when I took a
system and put it in an external
magnetic field
the levels are split and different
levels were occupied differently and
therefore I got a temperature dependent
paramagnetic susceptibility I want to
look at this derivation of paramagnetic
susceptibility from the Hamiltonian
point of view by writing Hamiltonian
explicitly and recall that the
Hamiltonian of an electron in a magnetic
field is given as 1 over 2 m p + e a
square plus V R external the potential
in which the electron is moving plus
there is spin orbit coupling and dot s
and there is a interaction of the spin
moment with the external field which I
am going to write as plus 2 mu B s dot B
this is the full Hamiltonian when we
wrote it for n when I wrote it for n
electrons in an atom
this became H equals summation I 1 over
2 m p i+ e a
square plus V external RI summed over I
plus some constant and then I write the
spin-orbit coupling as coupling between
the total orbital angular momentum
capital L and total spin capital s plus
2 mu B capital S dot B in writing all
this Hamiltonian my a is the vector
potential for magnetic field that I have
applied B and mu B is the Bohr Magneton
this is the Hamiltonian now I'll show
you how from this we actually got the
paramagnetic term and how I get from
this the diamagnetic term also so the
Hamiltonian again when I write is going
to be 1 over 2 m summation when I expand
the terms P I square plus 1 over 2 m P I
dot a plus a dot P I this is also summed
over and there is an e so that II will
give me an e right here on top plus 1
over 2 m e square a square summed over I
plus summation v RI plus the spin-orbit
term l dot s
to MU B s dot B now I take B field in
the Z direction and in that case you can
easily show that the vector potential I
can write in the form a equals minus B Y
by 2 in the X Direction plus BX by 2 in
the Y direction there are other ways you
can write it because a cannot be defined
uniquely but I choose this particular
way of writing it and in that case you
see that P I dot a is going to be H
cross over I del I for the is electron
dot a which will be Y I in the X
direction with a minus sign plus X I in
the Y direction and I get B by 2 outside
and this is zero this term becomes zero
then a dot P I is going to be equal to
minus B by 2y d by DX plus B by 2 X D by
dy and I have H cross over I outside
this is from the definition of momentum
operator which I can write as minus B by
2 X D by dy minus y D by DX
there should be plus and H cross over I
so let's collect these terms together
then I write the Hamiltonian again so if
I write the Hamiltonian again I have
summation i p i square over 2m plus I'll
take this V external RI term with it
plus I over 2m and now you see that del
dot a term got 0 and I have times B by 2
X D by dy minus y D by DX and there's a
term H cross over I here plus c l dot s
term plus
to MU B s dot B now slight correction
here when I took P dot a equal to zero
in my previous calculation what I should
be doing is when I do this P in the
operator form I have to write P dot a
acting on whatever function f so this
will give me P dot a f plus another a
dot P F so what I had done there was
taken this term to be 0 and I have
another a dot P term here so I should be
multiplying this whole thing by 2 so
that the Hamiltonian now can be written
as the first term I'm going to write H 0
or H atomic without any spin-orbit
coupling then I have the spin-orbit
coupling term see l dot s then I have
plus e over 2m b LZ
because the operator out here let me
show that in green this operator
corresponds to LZ
along with H cross so that H cross I'm
going to write as I have been doing here
and as that will be only the
differential operator and plus two mu B
s dot B and the final term that we had
earlier was plus one over two M
summation e square a square so I should
add this term here also I had this term
here also I had plus one over two M
summation e square a square so this is a
Hamiltonian let me write it again in the
next page H is equal to H 0 which is
atomic Hamiltonian without the LS
coupling plus there is this C l dot s
coupling and then I have plus e H cross
over 2 m since I'm summing over all I it
becomes the capital L dot B I should
actually write this as B dot L because L
is operating on something on the right
and what I have done here let me explain
is that I have written B LZ is equal to
B dot L because B is in the Z direction
and then I have plus 2 mu B s dot B and
the final term plus e square over 2 m a
square summed over and it is summed over
all the electrons formula write Z out
here Z is the number
of electrons in the system so you've
gotten all the terms in the Hamiltonian
right so I can again write this as equal
to H zero atomic plus C l dot s plus es
cross by 2m is mu B so I can write this
as mu B B dot L plus 2 s plus Z e square
over 2m a square now I can write as 1
over 4 X square plus y square B Square
these are all the terms in the
Hamiltonian let's look at each term now
so finally I have reduced the
Hamiltonian to the form H 0 plus C l dot
s plus mu B B dot L plus 2 s plus Z e
square over 2m X square plus y square B
Square in calculating the paramagnetic
susceptibility what we had done was we
had taken l dot s term to be the largest
among these three terms so that it
dominates and because of this the system
follows l dot s or Russell Saunders
coupling and gives Jace tapes and then
those J states split these J states
split because of mu B B dot L plus 2 s
term which is smaller than l dot s so it
comes the next and give paramagnetism so
this is systematically how we're doing
it we're taking h0 largest term and c l
dot s gives you j states and then those
j states are sep split and populated at
a given temperature in a different way
according to Boltzmann probability law
and gives paramagnetism and the last
term gives daya magnetism let us see how
if I develop a magnetic moment which is
in the direction opposite to the applied
field then it will give me a positive
energy contribution raise the energy of
the system so para magnet lowers the
energy of the system and this raises the
energy of the system and the change in
the energy
is going to be equal to 1/2 m dot B
which is 1/2 Hiedi over mu 0 B square so
if I calculate the energy up to order B
square from this term that we just
saying I can calculate KY D so let's see
what this is the last term that we saw
in the Hamiltonian is Z e square over 2m
X square plus y square B Square and it's
expectation value will be equal to a
change in the energy
which I can write and there's a one over
for also I missed so which I can write
as Z is a constant number E square is a
constant number divided by 8 m
expectation value of x square plus y
square of the system times B square that
will be the change in energy and this
should be equal to 1/2 Chi diamagnetic
over mu zero times B Square and this
immediately gives me if I cancel B
square this gives me PI D is equal to Z
e square over 4 mu 0 expectation M
expectation value of x square plus y
square so I can write the diamagnetic
susceptibility Chi D is equal to Z e
square over 4 M mu 0 X square plus y
square expectation value which I can
write as 2/3 of X square plus y square
plus Z square expectation value because
I'm taking only two terms for a
spherical system times Z e square mu 0
over 4 M which then I can write as Z e
square mu 0 / 6 M expectation value of R
square in a system so this is the
diamagnetic
susceptibility
for one atom which is given as pi d
equals mu zero let me bring in front Z e
square over six m the expectation value
of R square
let us now get a feel for the numbers
recall that in the previous lecture I
had calculated CAI paramagnetic to be of
the order of 10 raise to minus 7 at room
temperature now let's see what Hiedi is
so Kai D is equal to MU 0z e square over
6 M r-square
mu 0 is 4 pi times 10 raised to minus 7
so let's say we are taking a system of
50 electrons a square is 2.5 6 times 10
raised to minus 38 R square I'll take
off the order of 1 angstrom square so
that's 10 raised to minus 20 divided by
6 times M is of the order of 10 raised
to minus 30 kilogram so that's now
cancel terms 6 + 4 PI I can just write
this as 2 so this becomes about 2 times
50 is 100 times 10 raise to minus 7 is
10 raise to minus 5 times 10 raised to
minus 58 and divided by 10 raised to
minus 30 which comes out to be of the
order of 10 raise to minus 33 per atom
so
for a solid Hiedi for a solid will be
equal to 10 raise to minus 33 times n
Avogadro per mole and that number Chi D
will be equal to 10 raise to minus 33
times 10 raised to 23 of the order of 10
raise to minus 10 10 10 raise to minus 9
per mole and you can see that this is
much much much much less than CAI
paramagnetic so diamagnetic effects are
very small as we have shown just now
compared to paramagnetic effect so to
conclude this lecture taking changes in
the energy up to order B square in first
order we have calculated
diamagnetic susceptibility of a solid
and we found that Chi D is roughly Chi B
over a thousand
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
