Lecture 40: Strain Hardening: Single Xtal and Poly Crystal Deformation, Tylor Hardening

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 1, 2023
Welcome back students. So, Professor Dhanshu Sekar Singh has discussed many of the strengthening
mechanisms. Now, today I will be discussing about yet another strengthening mechanism,
which is again possible because of interaction of dislocations. This time it is interaction
of dislocation with dislocations. So, the mechanism that leads to this, that comes out
of this is called strain hardening. And it is one of the primary methods by way because
of which is employed on metals and alloys to improve their strength. So, for example,
you may have heard that rolled steels. So, why are the steels rolled? Because it induces
a strain in the material and these strain causes dislocations generate dislocation generation
and then the dislocations interact with each other and because of that the strength increases.
So, what happens in between that is what we will understand over here. So, to begin with,
we will look at single crystal deformation. So, how does a single crystal deformation
look like? Now, you remember that we had a single crystal and where we looked at the
critical result shear stress. So, once you are pulling it, then once the critical result
shear stress for the plane, one of the plane reaches, then dislocation starts to move in
that particular plane. But then eventually other, there are other dislocation slip planes
over there and eventually when you keep increasing the load, then the stress for other, the stress
would reach the critical result shear stress for others slip systems and therefore they
will also start to come into picture. So, that is why you will always have multiple
slip system in a material. Even though for a single crystal system as you would see it
to begin with, we will always have one particular slip system and then eventually others kick
in. So, we know that in a material, there will be multiple slip system, even in a single
crystal. So, I mean, any material system, it is dependent on material system, not on
the whether it is single crystalline or polycrystalline. So, they will always have multiple slip system.
Now as you increase the tensile load, so for the sake of completion, let me just redraw
what we had used earlier, which was, so this is, let us say this is a single crystal and
there is one slip system which is like this, which would be the first one to, so we know,
let us say we know beforehand that this would be the first one to reach the critical result
shear stress. So, there will be several of these in parallel and you are applying the
load like this. Because of this, the crystal would, so I am drawing in a little exaggeration,
but this is what happens. So, there is kind of a rotation because there are parallel slip
systems and the slip is taking place on all of these individually and because you are
applying a load, so this will kind of bend and it will also cause other slip systems
to get activated.
So, first thing is as the tensile load is increased, result shear stress on one plane
is reached, one plane or system I should say, sorry, it reaches critical value. So, this
one will start to, the dislocations would start to move on this and this would be the
primary slip plane. Now, as you keep increasing the stress, what would eventually happen is
that one because of the rotation and also because you are increasing the load, other
slip systems would also reach the critical value. So, critical result shear stress for
other systems is also reached. So, let us say those systems were somewhere like this,
maybe third one was little more oriented away. So, it is, the closer it is to 45 degrees,
as you would be able to see from the equation, they will be the first ones to, first one
to get activated and then other ones which are further away from 45 degrees, they will
get activated and so the slip system, so the dislocations in other planes also start to
move and you can realize that when, if only one pair or one set of planes were activated
and dislocations are moving only on them, then all the dislocations were moving parallel
to each other. They were just moving out and they were escaping from here, which actually
led to this rotation. However, once you have other planes, then dislocations would start
to intersect and interact with each other and that would lead to lot more complex phenomena.
And overall, if you look at the result shear stress versus result shear strain plot for
a single crystal, this is how it would look like. So, now let me draw. So, this is the
x and y-axis and now I will, on the x-axis you have gamma and on the x, y-axis you have
resolved shear stress tau. The plot would look, looks like something like this and we
will explain the various features of this. So, overall what you would see is that there
are 3 different zones and these would be represented as a stage or phase 1, stage 1
and somewhere over here, if you remove the transition, so this is second stage, let me
write the second stage, the stage 1 and I have left this region because this is more
like a transition region and this is the third stage and you can actually see some distinct
features in all these 3 stages. So, now let us, we will move on to discuss
what are these distinct features that we see in each of these stages. So, first thing is
that 3 stages and remember this is single crystal. So, in stage 1, what we see is that
as you increase the strain, the stress increases, but very soon it reaches a saturation value
and remains constant after that, which is expected because what is happening here is
that there is only one parallel set of planes where dislocations are moving and they are
not increased, the density is not increasing, they are, their number remains constant and
they are just escaping from the surface. So, there is no strain hardening taking place.
So, this is when slip system with lowest CRSS gets activated and what we observe is that
there is saturation, which is almost no strain hardening because all the dislocations are
eventually escaping away. So, here basically only one set or one parallel set of planes
have got activated. Now, in the second stage, what we will observe
is that more than one slip system gets activated, which means that there are more and more dislocation
interaction taking place and you remember the forces that we talked about when there
are more dislocations, so there is force from one dislocation to another dislocation
and when there are more than, when there are several, so there are forces acting on each
of them. And therefore, if you are applying a stress for a dislocation to move, basically
what you are trying is to overcome all these internal stresses. So, a larger amount of
internal, larger stress is required to overcome these internal stresses and hence we see a
very sharp rise in shear stresses. Strain, almost linear strain hardening is observed
and the main mechanism of strengthening is pile-up, which was discussed like by Professor
Sudhanshu Singh with respect to grain boundaries, but here also once there is intersection of
dislocations and then there are some immobile regions and the dislocations cannot pass through
that and therefore, they kept piling up over there and therefore, there are several such
you can say knots or locks where the dislocations cannot pass through and they keep piling up
over there and which eventually means that much higher stress is required for dislocations
to keep moving. And it is at this stage that dislocation
tangles, meaning now that you can see they are intersecting like each other, something
like this and some of it will form a loop, other will remain there and therefore, the
dislocations do not remain independent of each other, they begin to get tangled with
each other. So, that kind of tangling of dislocation starts to take place which results, also result
in dislocation cell structure. So, at this stage, you would also expect to see some amount
of cell structure getting formed. And these are very well documented if people have done
careful experiments with single crystal and they did find these different stages and whatever
important key points that we are writing down here, they have already observed in majority
of the systems.
Then the third stage, so just let us come back and take a look here. So, this is a stage
one where almost no strain hardening is taking place. When we say strain hardening, meaning
the stress required with increasing strain is not increasing. So, stress is almost constant.
While in second stage, we see almost linearly increasing. And in the third stage, what we
see is that thus stress, strain hardening is decreasing, there is a decreasing tendency
for a strain hardening. So, initially, there is a large rise of dissolved shear stress
with amount with small amount of strain increase and later on that rise becomes smaller and
smaller and smaller. So, the strain hardening becomes, strain hardening rate becomes lower,
becomes smaller and smaller with increasing strain.
So, one of the chief characteristics of this stage 3 that it is characterized by decreasing
rate of strain hardening. Now, why is this decreasing rate of strain hardening taking
place? So, it is taking place because some amount of dynamical recovery is also taking
place along with deformation, which releases part of the strain. And regarding dislocation,
cross slip starts to take place, which also releases some of the stress, which would have
been caused because of the pileup. So, the stresses are so high that so cross slip requires
a little higher stress, because it is on a different plane, which is not the lowest stress
plane. So, because of the increased stress, cross slip is now more convenient and therefore
cross slip becomes more common. And when it takes place, then it releases the stress created
because of pileup.
Another point that has been observed or another observed phenomena that has been observed
is that behavior in this stage is temperature dependent, meaning if you go to higher temperature,
then strain hardening rate is lower. If you are at lower temperature, then strain hardening
rate is higher. So, this suggests that it is temperature dependent and what phenomena
dislocation phenomena is temperature dependent, it is the climb. So, it clearly indicates
that climb is also active in this stage.
And we saw that in the previous stage, dislocation tangles were beginning. Here, it is confirmed
that this dislocation tangle or entanglement becomes even more pronounced and intersection
of dislocations is the chief strain hardening mechanism. So, this is how the dislocations
qualitatively, this is how the dislocations lead to strengthening in the single crystal.
So, you can clearly see that as the strain is increasing overall the strength, the result
shear stress required for deformation is increasing meaning strength of the material is increasing.
So, that is for single crystal. Now, let us also briefly take a look at how this thing
will happen in a polycrystalline material. So, we already know that if you were to look
at the polycrystalline material, then over here, what we see is only the second and the
third stage. So, there is somewhat second or linear point and then there is that ever
decreasing strain hardening rate. So, in brief, what we can say is that there is only
stage 2 and stage 3 deformation taking place in polycrystalline materials.
So, why is there no stage 1 over here and it should not be surprising and it is not
very difficult to answer. It is because we will not have only one set of plane at any
time. So, only one set planes cannot deform. Let us understand this why it happens. So,
in a polycrystalline material, let us say I draw it schematically like this. So,
you have grains which are contiguous and the material is contiguous and there is
one grain and very next to it there is another grain and so on.
So, therefore, the material looks something like this. Now, let us say if only one set of
planes were deforming in 2 neighboring grains. So, we will pick 2 grains from here. Let us draw
it separately. Let us say the 2 grains look like something like this and this is the interface or
the boundary and this is another grain. So, let us say that one set of plane which can deform
is such that the formation is taking place along these lines in this one and along these lines
in this one. So, now what will happen? If we allow this kind of deformation,
what will happen is that there will be steps getting formed over here,
but these set of planes cannot fill this gap. Therefore, eventually what we will see
is that and this one will have this will remain plane because no deformation takes place over
here and what it eventually tells you is that there would be gaps created between the grains.
If only one set of planes were deforming in a polycrystalline materials. So, clearly this is
not possible. You need minimum some number of planes systems to be deforming simultaneously
to be able to accommodate or to ensure that there is contiguity of material. Otherwise,
there will be voids created at very small strains itself. Now, looking at this itself,
you would be able to say that there should be minimum of two independent slip system
in a 2D material system. So, if theoretically there were 2D material system, there must be
at least two directions. So, if there one set is like this and if you had a corresponding
set another one like this, then it would have been able to take care of all the
gaps at the interface and there would have been no problem of contiguity.
Similarly, if you people have shown that if you are since we are have materials in 3D.
So, in for 3D materials, you need minimum five independent slip systems. So, overall,
what we see is that when you are deforming a polycrystalline material, it shows only
the stage 2 and 3 and it is obvious that it cannot show stage 1 which is dominated when you
have only one set of planes deforming in the single crystal. So, this polycrystal is similar
to the single crystal with only stage 2 and stage 3. Then we also looked at why stage 1 kind of
scenario cannot exist, because it will lead to contiguity of materials, there will be gaps
created. And since we know that it does not happen, there must be contiguity and therefore,
there must be at least two independent slip system in a 2D material system
and at least five independent slip system in a 3D material system.
So, now that qualitatively explains the role of dislocation in the deformation of single
crystal and polycrystalline material. Now, let us get a little bit of into quantitative values
to understand how the dislocation causes strength, increase in the strength.
So, for that, now we will go back to our equation for interaction of dislocations and you would see
that from there we would be able to derive what is called as Taylor hardening. So, if you remember,
we had dislocations, one like this and let us say another one is somewhere on another plane.
So, we said that this is a distance y and some distance x, what are the forces acting on this.
Now, from that forces, we will be able to understand how much force you would need to
apply externally. So, whatever force is there, you would need to apply externally opposite of
that to be able to overcome that forces, if you want to move the dislocation in the other way or
in the direction of the applied stress. So, for this kind of scenario, we looked at and we saw
that the stresses look like and over here, we saw that this is equal, this is the distance in along
x direction. So, for the x distance, we know this is 1y, somewhere over here, we have 2y and so on.
And here we have minus 1y, minus 2y and so on. Now, this is how the forces are acting on this,
the other dislocation, let us say this is a fixed dislocation for some reason, just for
the purpose of understanding the amount of force required for movement of dislocation. So, let us
say this is the fixed dislocation and this is free to move, then this is the force acting on it.
Now, if we want to move this dislocation in some or we want to stop this dislocation from movement,
or we want to move it in any other direction, then clearly whatever force is acting on it,
we must apply more than that. And if you want to be able to completely move it as per the applied
stress or as per your desire to say, then you must apply a minimum of this much stress, either this
much or this much in the other 2 directions. And just to make things clear that this value
is actually equal to this value in positive sense and this one is equal to negative sense.
The earlier time, the last time I drew this, if you go back, you would see that there is a little
bit of discrepancy, this one is lower than this, but that was a schematic and because
I could not draw it as accurately as it is supposed to be. So, just keep in mind that
the value of this force and this force is same in the positive direction and this force and this
force is also same in magnitude, but just in opposite direction. And this is your tau, this is
the x and where does this maxima or minima occur? And if you would be, if you look at the equation
carefully, you would be able to find out that this minima or maxima occurs at 0.414 y.
Or equal to minus 0.414 y. So, if we look at the force equation that we looked at earlier,
f equal to tau into b is equal to g d x, x square minus y square times b by 2 pi 1 minus nu.
Now, if I want a critical tau, which is this one, then I need to calculate it at x equal to
0.414 y or the minus of this minus 0.414 y and it is not very difficult to show that it will come out
to g b by 2 pi 1 minus nu y and the rest of the factor would come out to approximately 1 by 4.
So, this is g b by 8 pi 1 minus nu and if we call this distance y as h because y is
represent some many at places something different. So, the tau critical can be written as
g b by 8 pi 1 minus nu h. Now, this, what does this stress signify? This stress signifies that
you need to apply at least this much stress, shear stress to move this dislocation
in either direction. If you are able to apply this much shear stress, then this dislocation
can be moved in any direction, a little bit higher than this because this is the maximum stress
that is acting on it because of the presence of another dislocation.
So, if there is another dislocation and you still want to be able to move this dislocation,
you need to apply at least this much of shear stress. So, that is what this equation tells us.
Now, let us move on. We can have, this is just, there may not be just one dislocation. In a
material, there will be lot more dislocations. So, what do we do or how do we calculate that?
Not very difficult. So, let us say we have, so here we will make some assumption that the
dislocations are slightly arranged. So, it is something like this and let us say the distance
from here to here is h. Similarly, the distance from here to here is h. So, if I were to
find the dislocation density, so let us say I take this area. So, this is 2h by 2h or 2h square
and number of dislocations that we have over here is 1 single dislocation and 1 by 4 into 4.
So, there is total of 2 dislocation in this area of 2h whole square. So, if I were to calculate
the dislocation density rho dislocation, then it will come out to 2 by 2h square which is
1 over 2h square. And now if I want, I can also write h in terms of the dislocation density.
So, it is like this. And now I can insert this h because this is h, I will not be able to calculate
for individual dislocation. But yes, as a dislocation, if we know in general the dislocation
density of the material at a given state, it can also be calculated by various means.
So, I would know rho. So, I can use this to insert or approximately calculate the value of h
and therefore, tau c would become gb, which was already given as gb by 1 minus nu h.
Now, instead of tau c, I will now call it tau naught, which is the stress. It represents the
stress required for the material to deform. So, for a given dislocation density, what is the stress
that is required to deform the material and this would be given by gb by 8 pi 1 minus nu.
And instead of h, I will write 1 by 2 root 2 1 by rho. And this can be approximated as alpha gb
root rho, which is or the Taylor hardening relation. So, let me just write down what it
is saying. It is giving the shear strength of material as a function of dislocation density.
And what it is saying is that as you keep increasing dislocation density,
shear strength of the material keeps increasing. So, this is exactly what we mean by strain
hardening. When you have more the strain, more the dislocations, more is the strength of the
material. And if you look at a single crystal, sorry, polycrystalline material.
So, we know the stress strain diagram looks like this. If you compare the original yield
strength versus this point, and let us say you deform it up to this point and then release the
stress. Then it will come back and when you if you do the tensile test again, this will become
the new yield strength of the material. So, why has the yield strength increased? Because
as the strain increases, dislocation density increased. So, the strain is increasing which
leads to dislocation density increment and therefore, strength, the yield strength of
the material increased. And people have also plotted normalized shear strength of the material
against the dislocation density. And what they observed is something like this. So,
if you look at y-axis B root rho. So, this is the dislocation density
and the normalized shear strength of the material, people have obtained a
straight line relation. So, it clearly conforms the Taylor hardening relation.
So, this is this clearly establishes the strain hardening. Now, we will go through some example
to be able to appreciate this even better. So, here the first example is that you are given
that 2 positive dislocations are located in 2 parallel glide planes which are 10 nanometer apart.
At what value of separation in x direction, so in this direction, they experience maximum and
minimum force. So, there is force between the 2 the dislocations are there will be some interaction
and because of that they will either attract or repel each other. So, the question is at what
value of x they will experience maximum and minimum force. And if you go back to the
notes, you would see that the maximum force occurs at x equal to 0.414 y, but y is 10 nanometer which
means 4.14 nanometer and minimum occurs at x equal to minus 0.414 y, which is minus 0.414
nanometer. So, maximum and minimum are here just the signs that whether they are positive or
negative, but magnitude wise, the forces would remain same. And in fact, both of them would
happen to be attracting. So, both of them will try to attract it and eventually form a array like
this. This is what we saw when we looked at the interaction of dislocations with similar sign when
they are in different planes. So, this is example 1. Now, let us look at still another example.
So, here you are given that in a material 100 dislocations were observed in TM in an area of
10,000 b square. So, what is the shear stress required to move dislocation through this
material? So, TM is basically assuming that it is showing the representative dislocation density.
So, let us look at what would be the representative dislocation density value.
It is equal to number of dislocation which is 100 by 10,000 b square which is equal to
1 over 100 b. Now, let us look at the relation for shear strength, we know it is equal to
gb by 8 pi 1 minus nu root 2 into root instead of root rho, we can write it as
implies root rho is equal to 1 over root and under root 100 is 10 and this is again b square.
So, under root b square becomes b. So, 2 into 1 over 10 b and therefore,
the b gets cancelled over here and what we 8 into 10 becomes 80. So, this becomes g root 2
by 80 pi 1 minus nu. So, this gives you the shear stress required to move dislocation and
if you had higher dislocation density you would see that the shear stress required is also higher.
So, this clearly establishes strain hardening. So, over here we have show assume that strain,
increasing strain causes increase in dislocation density and that part is still to be shown or
understood and that we will look at in the next lecture. But assuming that increasing the strain
increases the dislocation density we have clearly seen qualitatively and quantitatively that the
strength of the material should increase. So, with that we will come to end of this lecture
and next time we will look at how movement of dislocation with
strain causes increase in the dislocation density. Thank you.
