Lecture 8

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 1, 2023
Welcome to this session. The objective of this session is to examine the sources and
causes of fluctuations in interest rates relative to one another thus across different types
of death instruments. Look at this figure, you can see here that on the y-axis we mention
we denote annual yield that means the rate of interest and on the x-axis this is the
time period. So some of the key facts you can see here that what we denote here is the
yield to maturity that the rate of interest on different types of death instruments. So
you can see here that corporate bonds that is corporate AAA bonds, corporate BAA bonds,
US government long term bonds, state and local government bonds, municipal bonds etc.
So some of the difference that you can see here is that so you can see that look at for example
government bond and corporate bond and you can see that the corporate bond for example looking
at this figure you can see that corporate bond the rate of interest is greater than the government
bond that is one. And within corporate you can see that the corporate AA bonds rate of interest is
less than corporate BAA bonds. And similarly look at the short term and long term that actually we
have seen in the previous diagram the difference between US government long term bonds and short
term bonds at that time we have seen that short term interest rate is even for the
government within government short term interest rate is less than long term interest rate.
And some of other things that you might have observed that the rate of interest across the
globe that means among between countries for example when you compare rate of interest
between India and US you can see that the rate of interest is very low in India in US in the US
for example for the government bonds it is much lower in the US as compared to India.
And similarly when you compare for example Afghanistan you know that the rate of interest
in Afghanistan even issued by the Afghanistan government is greater than the rate of interest
of India. So that means you see that there are differences in the rate of interest for
different instruments debt instruments. So what are the reason for that what explains
the reason for this differences and over time you can see that it fluctuates right.
For example you can see here is that the corporate BAA bonds how much it was for
example in 1920 it was nearly 8 percentage but when it comes to say for example 2010
you can see that is going to be nearly 6 percentage. So what we explain what makes
what are the factors that explain this kind of fluctuation. So that is the main focus of
this session and subsequent few sessions. So in order to understand the factors that
explain that in the explain the differences in the rate of interest for different types
of debt instrument there are mainly two major approaches to this.
One is called risk structure of interest rate and the second one is called term structure
of interest rates. Let us now focus on the first one in detail the risk structure of
interest rate and thereafter we will move to the term structure of interest rate.
So about the risk structure of interest rate let us start with a very basic question why
bonds are risky. Normally bonds are considered as relatively safe investment as compared to
secure that stocks but however bonds are still risky because of some factors that we let us
discuss here. One is interest rate risk the interest rate risk is that interest rate may
rise between the time a bond is purchased and time it is sold reducing the bond price.
Suppose the bond price in the future the rate of interest in the future increase suppose the rate
of interest increase in the future once someone suppose they hear someone bought a bond today
and then you see after one year when the rate of interest increase then obviously you know
that the bond price will decline when he sell it in the market then the he will incur a capital
loss that is one risk this is happening due to the interest rate risk the fluctuation
uncertainty in the interest rate. And second one is called inflation risk that means inflation
may turn out to be higher than expected then reducing the real return on holding the bond
that is the second risk called inflation risk. And the third one is the default risk this is
the key issue an important risk associated with bonds this is the default risk.
Default risk means issuer may not make the promise payment on time it may be because
the moreover the who issued the bond and the supplier of bonds got into financial trouble
maybe became bankrupt or that is one or maybe deliberately he or she does not want to pay
back or maybe some kind of cheating they want to fraud they want to get into. So the anyway
the main point here is that default risk is the one of the important aspects that makes
factor that makes bonds more risky. So our discussion today is going to be more on this
default risk in order to measure the default risk so that the probability that the issuer
of the bond supplier of the bond will pay back the borrowed amount and the associated
interest payments. So in order to measure that normally this has been done by rating
mainly done by the rating agencies. Rating agencies they assess the financial strength
of firms and other governments and thus help investors identify the company's level of risk
and their ability to repay debts. There are mainly three broad group of ratings by rating
agencies that is relevant to our context one is called bond ratings and the other one is
second one is commercial paper ratings and the third one is sovereign ratings is called
as rating the governments. You know that in every country there are registered credit
rating agencies. In India there are several rating agencies these are the top credit rating
agencies registered under SEBI security and exchange board of India. These agencies they
rate they assess the risk default risk of the firms by they will assess the credit risk or
they will give a rating of each of their debt instruments which are the bond they are issuing
in the market. First it will undergo a credit rating assessment and accordingly they will
get a score rate rating they will be getting. And I would suggest you visit their website
to get more idea what is meant by ratings and how do they do and what kind of methodology
they use. And overall there is a similarity about the methodology they use however still
when you go to their website you can see there are lots of differences as well.
But overall idea is that they are going to measure the financial soundness of the firm,
the financial health of their firm and the instrument the bond they are issuing for which
purpose for which project the feasibility the economic feasibility of that project and then
accordingly they will be getting a score rating. So for example Chrysler you can see here that
what they do that you can see that they do the rating for bank loan and they also rate long
term debt instruments such as bonds, non convertible debentures and preference shares.
And they also do the rating for short term debt instruments such as commercial papers
and short term NCDs. They also rate fixed deposits as well. So you can read it from
their website that actually the methodology and rating framework adopted by this agency
for evaluating the credit risk of various instruments issued by Indian corporate is
largely similar. However they also say that based on the context they will slightly change
the methodology the criteria used for the rating of each of their credit instruments.
And you can also go through another credit rating agencies for example India rating and research,
you will get more idea about what is meant by what are the methodology they use,
what kind of rating they do etc. So internationally there are 3 major
agencies international credit rating agencies Moody's, Standard and Poor and Fitch.
And these agencies mostly they do sovereign rating, they rate the government. Before going
to that I would suggest visit their website to get the criteria they use. So just visit
that Fitch rating scope and where you can browse for the criteria what they use.
So from there itself you can see that the rating definition, rating products,
rating process, ABC of credit ratings everything they give there. So they rate by institutions,
by sectors, they rate corporate covered bonds all these. They also rate sovereign that means
sovereign means this means governments, they rate national governments, they rate India,
they rate Afghanistan, they rate US as well. You can also visit the another rating agency
standards and poor S&P for short where again you can see that what are the ratings they do,
the proposed criteria including new and materially changed criteria.
So you can see that corporates, financial institution, insurance and they rate actually
infrastructure and governments and structured finance. These are all the sectors they do the
ratings. And again you can see here that the Moody's again you please go through their website.
And for example you can see and just say that the global long term rating you can see that
they are been using some terminology notations that the AAA, AAA, BAA etc. So let us discuss
these in appropriate context. Anyway I would suggest you please go through this website
thoroughly and get to know more about these ratings ideas.
So for example the Moody's global long term rating scale where you can see that they give
AAA, AAA means the obligation, the debt obligation rated AAA are yet to be the highest quality
subject to the lowest level of credit risk. The default risk is very, very low. This is
called prime quality, prime quality debt instruments. Then for the next category this
is another rank just below this is called that rating is called AA that you can say
that they are judged to be high quality and however subject to very low credit risk but
obviously less than AAA. And AA this is also judged to be upper medium grade and subject
to low risk. And these are called highly investment grade debt instruments or bonds.
Then comes below that you can see that BAA you can say the medium grade and subject to
moderate credit risk and may possess certain speculative characteristics. Then comes BA and
B. So for example here you can see that B they are actually denoted as high credit risk. And
they also give further they give the ratings much if the credit risk is very high,
the credit risk is very high they see that based on their applying their criteria if they find
out that default risk is very high then they will be giving CA and further they will give the C,
CA, AAA, CA and C. So C means actually these are all called mainly junk bonds that means
the credit risk is very high that the default risk is very high. Similarly they also do the
global short term rating scale. This is mainly for the short term what they do for the criteria
terminology they use is notation they use is P1 that is prime 1 reflect superior ability to repay
short term obligations. Then P2 and then P3 and finally they give the ratings of NP that means
not prime they do not fall within any of the prime rating categories. That means they say
that the default risk is very high. This also we can relate it with the long term with a we can
find some comparisons. So you can see that the AAA this one is almost similar to prime 1 the
long term the relationship between long term and short term. And here A3 till BA it can be
almost similar to prime 2 or this much this one is equal to denoting prime 3.
Again you have most of the pasting here the linkage between a long term and US
municipal short term debt and demand obligation ratings. So this also just for your understanding.
So you know that there are different rating agencies so what are the because these are
the different rating agencies may be rating same government may be rating same bonds they
will be rating same debt instrument they will be rating. So they are comparable you can see
that when it comes to the maximum prime maximum safety all of them give the same notation that
AAA. Then comes slightly difference that AA1 by Moody's, AA plus by S&P that AA plus M by
Fitch that means these are high grade quality. So similarly when you go further you can see
that may be this one this is called speculative that the BA2, BB and BB this is speculative bond
that is called young bonds. So just about you can say these are non investment grade bonds.
So the point here is that actually so when the ratings are very high then these are called
prime maximum safety that means the risk is very low. Then when they get lower ratings
that means that actually a certificate that the probability of their default risk increases when
the rating is low default risk is will increase. Then we will see that when lower the ratings when
the default risk is very high when the rating is very low for example young then they find
it difficult to get the demand for their bonds will be this kind of debt instruments will be
less that means they have to pay high rate of interest. So that means the rate of interest
for a prime maximum safety kind of bonds or debt instruments is going to be low and for when they
the rating increase then the rate of interest increases. So from this what you can see that
I have shown here that the ratings when they get a high ratings this is called
prime maximum safety or high quality debt instruments. However sometime some of the
angels may be the we say that the high quality bonds those who are getting double A, double A1,
double A2 or considers high quality that they are considers the high quality bonds.
Sometime they may fall maybe they may the high quality their high ratings the high
quality bonds their quality their ratings declines in the future because their risk
the default risk increases and they can be become the kind of fallen angel. Fallen angel
is a bond that has been reduced to young status because issuer has fallen into a
financial trouble. Maybe at the time of getting the ratings they may be either in all these
category but later on you can see that they may some of them will become fallen angel.
This exactly happened during 2007-08 financial crisis many top rated companies who got the
top ratings for their debt instruments they become fallen angel during the 2007-08 financial crisis.
So what happened that these bonds pay higher returns than investment quality
bonds and why they are more riskier. This is just to give you some idea about the
different types of gradings for example an investment grade who are all getting
investment grade and the description is description and for example the examples
of issuers with bonds outstanding in 2012. For example these companies Microsoft and
the country sovereign Canada so they got that triple A and similarly this company
the corporate and the government were getting double A like that.
So look at for example highly speculative so you can see here for example Greece countries
like Pakistan, Cuba, Venezuela they are actually having low ratings. This is just
for your information so you could please go through this description to get a better
understanding of this credit rating description. This also shows for the commercial rating
commercial paper ratings the companies like Coca-Cola, General Electric and
Procter and Gamble they get the P1 that the prime grade. And in addition to as I mentioned
that in addition to the ratings of the corporates they also rate the government.
So this is called sovereign ratings that means rating the governments by rating
agencies. So to get more idea please visit some of this website the countryeconomy.com
the ratings rating for different countries and you can also there are lots of information in
the websites you can see that even Wikipedia you can get the list of countries by credit
ratings. So for example for instance I can say that we can see that nearly 10, 11 countries
at present they are having the AAA ratings having that prime ratings and many other
countries they are they are having even junk status grading as well.
So look at this I just copied from countryeconomy.com website so this is a screenshot where
you can see that US for example is having AAA ratings by Modi but prime quality rating by
Modi's S&P and Fitch but only AA plus rating by S&P but Modi's and Fitch they have given AAA
ratings. So from this you can see that different countries the ratings differ you can see for
example yeah when going through that you can get a see that even there is rating difference
between agencies but slight differences and overall you can see that there is a high
correlation between the ratings and many countries you can see here that they are
having low ratings. For example however you can see Australia for example you can see that they
are having same rating by all the three agencies AAA, AAA and AAA.
So what are the factors that determines the sovereign ratings? The sovereign rating
criteria incorporate the factors that affect a sovereign government's willingness and ability
to service its financial obligation to non-official creditors on time and in full. The
criteria vary across rating agencies but however overall there is some commonalities.
So one you can see that I am just giving five key areas to determine a sovereign ratings one
is called the institutional assessment. Institutional assessment means the
institutional and economic profile of the country and institutional and economic assessment. So
the overall institutional the how strong the institution socio-economic and legal
institutions of the country and how strong the economic institution the economic scenario of
the country that is one of the criteria. Then the external assessment will be there
then the fiscal assessment whether the similarly the monetary assessment.
About the fiscal assessment what is the fiscal position of the country that the whether the
country is having fiscal deficit or fiscal balance or fiscal surplus or even if fiscal
deficit how what is the scenario current scenario whether it is really very high
fiscal deficit whether it is increasing over time or it is declining over time whether
government is making deliberate effort to reduce the fiscal deficit systematically.
So this is called the flexibility and performance profile this also will be
included or considered in this rating criteria. So that means these are the key factors then
they develop an indicative level then based on these each agencies because each of these
rating agencies they will be using their own framework not necessarily exactly the one
mentioned here but overall these are the factors they take into account.
The even the monetary assessment how the monetary policy the monetary institution
how independent is the central bank and how robust are there with their economic policy
making the interference in the economy how all these factors they take into account.
I just posted here some of the credit rating for India for the last couple of years and you
can see that our ratings is called for example features given triple B minus that is in June
10, 2022. Obviously this is not a good sign not as a high ratings that means they rated
somewhere below the medium investment quality. Moody's like that and you can see the DBRS they
are given this one these are all they are given during this time period and here also you can
also see that they also give an outlook or watches for the agencies.
For example positive somewhere here but here we had positive in 2015 what is positive means
that a rating may be raised in the future that means if they have we had BAA 3 then
in the future if we continue our economies performing the way it has been doing then
in the future is going to be increased. The rating will be raised from BAA to the next
level. Then negative means a rating may be lowered that means here in this time economy
is going to trumped up situation according to this rating agencies so they may lower downgrade
our ratings. Stable means rating is not likely to change in the future so that currently for
example Fitch in June 2022 they have their outlook about India is stable.
So what are the reasons and consequence of poor sovereign ratings? So the one of the
reason I mentioned that the fiscal deficit is one of the criteria for sovereign rating. So
high fiscal deficit will lead to low sovereign ratings which would lead to high rate of interest.
We are getting low ratings when our sovereign ratings declines it also means that low sovereign
ratings means the country has to pay high rate of interest when they borrow by issuing.
Suppose the government issue bonds whenever government is issuing bonds they have to pay
high rate of interest when we are getting low sovereign ratings. Because low ratings
means high risk, high risk means the rate of interest also has to be high.
So which would lead to high rate of interest and then not only that many foreign governments
would not allow their companies especially pension funds and insurance companies they
would not be allowed to invest in those countries with a low sovereign ratings.
And it has implication for economic growth as well because when the sovereign rating
is very low the foreign direct investment will come down because they see that the country
has high risk sovereign high risk is there default risk is very high. So other factors
so the political and economic the stable credit worthiness this whole will be this actually a
factor as I mentioned poor political and economic if there is instability in political context and
economic system economic institutions are weak then it will adversely affect the ratings of
the country. So we want to see that the impact of rating on yields this is the main point here
we need to summarize the discussion. That means when higher the ratings we can see
that the rate of interest will be low they have to pay low rate of interest they can borrow they
can supply bonds and they can borrow at a low rate of interest. When the rating is very high
the those bonds which is having high rating they are having low default risk and they will be
considered as benchmark bonds. So in the global scenario the US treasury bills are considered as
the benchmark bonds. So they are the benchmark bonds and their yields on other bonds and are
measured in terms of the spread over the treasuries. So a bond yield for example the bond
yield in India it will be measured or expressed in this way for example US treasury yield that
is the benchmark bond plus suppose the bond yield for example in India for example 8 percentage.
Suppose the US treasury yield is 2 percentage 2 percentage and remaining 6 is the risk premium
default risk premium that is called 6 percentage. So this is the way we express the bond yield US
treasury yield and plus default risk premium. So this 6 percentage is the default risk premium
that means when our ratings improve when it is become equal to for example the benchmark bond
this will become 0. In the next session we will continue this discussion. Thank you.
