Lecture 9

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 1, 2023
Welcome to this session. So, in this session, we will continue our discussion on risk structure
of interest rate and subsequently if time permits, we will start discussing the term
structure of interest rates.
So, coming to the risk structure of interest rates, in the previous lecture, we have discussed
how default risk is measured by different rating agencies and based on that, we have
seen that debt instruments within better rating, high rating will have to pay low interest
rate as compared to debt instruments which has bad rating or low rating, also we called
as junk bonds or low investment grade bonds and they have to pay a high interest rate
in the market when they borrow from the market, right.
So subsequently, we also discussed, little bit started discussing what is Benchmark bonds,
so we have seen that Benchmark bonds are considered as those bonds which have low default risk,
those who get high ratings. So, in the globally, US treasury bills are considered as the Benchmark
bonds. So, we have also seen there that the yield on other bonds are measured in terms
of or expressed in terms of spread over treasuries and for example, the bond yield, we measure
that bond yield is US treasury yield plus that the Benchmark bond plus the default risk
premium.
So, from this, we can derive two major insights. Insight number one is higher default risk,
higher will be the yield, right. So, that means, higher will be the default risk premium
that they have to pay. So similarly, when treasury yields move, when the treasury yields
move that the Benchmark bond or other yields move with them, so that means, assuming that
the default risk premium is constant across, constant for other debt instruments, bonds.
So, when the treasury yield, for example, when it increase, so that means, you can see
the bond yield for the overall bond yield for other bonds also increase. Similarly,
when the treasury yield declines, so do with the bond yield as well because we assume there
that the default risk premium is constant in our discussion.
So, if bond ratings properly reflect the probability of default, then the lower the rating of the
issuer, the higher the default risk premium and hence high interest rate. So, what we
can, we have seen here is that default risk, the probability that the issuer of the bond
is unable or unwilling to make interest payments or pay off the face value. So, we already
seen that US treasury bonds are the, are considered as default free bonds. So, risk
premium also we have discussed, that means, the spread between interest rates on bonds
with the default risk and the interest rates on treasury bonds, treasury bills. So, that
also considered as risk spread as well. So, that the risk premium or another term measuring
for risk premium is risk spread. So, look at this, the international comparison of 10 year
government bond yield that you can see here, you can see that at the bottom, you can see the
Switzerland that is almost out negative, that means, if you want to buy a Switzerland, a government
bond, Switzerland government bond, instead of you get the rate of interest, you have to pay
because that is considered the safe investments. So, similarly, you can see that when you move
along, you can see Denmark and Netherlands Sweden, that means, the risk premium, the default risk
increases. So, you can see that, for example, the country Argentina or Turkey here and Venezuela,
you can see here that the default risk increases. So, translating this into risk spread which we
discussed a comparison with the US treasury bill, you can see that Switzerland, their default risk
premium is negative in fact, that is minus 2.96 percentage. So, that means, as compared to the US
treasury bill, the default risk is very, very low, that means, this much premium is negative,
that means, minus 2.96 percentage. So, this is considered very safe investment portfolio.
So, you can see for here is like that Japan, Denmark and moving like that. So, countries like
Croatia, you can see that the risk premium is negative in fact. So, comparing with the other
countries, see United States, we already taken that is the Denmark. So, obviously, the spread
is zero. So, moving to other countries, Italy, Morocco, Poland and keep on moving, you can see
that the risk premium increases. For example, the risk premium from this data, this for India,
this one is 5.18 percentage. So, we also have the rating here, we are given for example,
the S&P ratings, we have given it here like that for the United States is double A plus.
So, you can see further that the risk spread in Turkey is 16.36 and Venezuela is this one
is 43.11 percentage. So, that means, these are the countries with a high risk premium or risk
spread. So, what we have compared the one aspect of the risk structure of interest rates, that one
is the default risk. Let us now discuss the remaining two, one is the liquidity aspects,
the third one is tax consideration, income tax considerations. So, coming to the liquidity
aspects, liquidity that we have defined in one of the previous session is that,
that is the relative ease with which an asset can be converted into cash very easily, that means,
without loss of time and value. So, that actually include the loss of value that include the cost
of selling a bond. Suppose, the brokerage is very high for example, even whether you are looking at
the fixed cost and the variable cost involved in cost selling the bond, if it is very high,
you know that the liquidity is very low. So, that means, liquidity of the bond is
very low and the cost of selling of a bond is very high. Similarly, the number of buyers and
sellers in a bond market, that means, if the market consists of large number of buyers and
sellers, that means, is a well developed market, a large market. So, that means,
you will be getting, there will be, suppose if you want to sell your bonds, that means,
there is large number of buyers in the market. So, that means, you can easily sell your bond
when you want, that means, the market is well developed. So, that means, it is also very liquid.
So, these are the liquidity considerations. So, in any, suppose, when it looks, look at
the sovereign rate of bonds and when the country's bond market is well developed,
then you know that the liquidity of these bonds are also very high.
So, same about each and every country, if their bond market is well developed, so,
that means, the companies, the corporations, firms which borrow from the market, they can
very easily sell, that means, if the cost of selling of the bond is very low and there are
large number of buyers and sellers in the market, that means, the liquidity is very high. When the
liquidity is very high, then you can see that the interest rate that they have to give in order to
supply their bonds is very low, low as compared to less liquid bond market, that means, these are
the condition to ensure that the market, the bonds are very liquid. So, just to summarize in a state,
in a stating, that means, higher the liquidity of the bond, lower the rate of interest that
they have to pay. So, the third aspect is the income tax considerations, that means,
the interest payments on the interest, the income tax that the borrow, that the demand is,
the holders of the bonds that they have to meet. So, you can see that, you can see that the interest
payments on municipal bonds in the US are exempt from federal income taxes. So, that means, whoever
is holding the municipal bonds, they do not need to pay the income tax on the interest received,
interest income that they are getting. Look at for example, comparing a bond that actually,
suppose for example, this is taxable. Consider a 1 year 100 face value taxable bond with a coupon
rate of 6 percentage with a 30 percentage tax rate. So, here look at for the after tax bond
yield. So, bond yield means, what the investors are looking, what the holders of bonds are looking,
the after tax bond yield, that the actual bond yields. So, what is the actual bond yield,
that the after tax bond yield is the taxable bond yield times 1 minus tax rate. So, considering a
1 year 100 face value taxable bond with a coupon rate of 6 percentage. So, that means, you can see
that this is a promise to pay 106 in 1 year by the supplier of this bond. So, if the bond is
selling at par, at a price of 100 for example, suppose the selling price of the bond is equal
to the face value of the bond suppose, then the yield to maturity is 6 percentage.
That means, the interest rate is 6 percentage. So, from the point of view of the government issuer,
the bond holder resumes dollar 6 in taxable income at maturity. So, if the tax rate is 30
percentage, you can see that the tax on that income is dollar 1.8. So, that 100 tax, 100 dollar bond
yields dollar 104.20 after the tax. So, this is the actual received rate. That means, in other words,
at a 30 percentage tax rate, a 6 percentage taxable bonds yield equivalent of 4.2. So,
that means, this one translate it into only 4.2 percentage. So, the promised interest rate is 6
percentage that is the yield to maturity when we calculate here, but actually the actual yield that
is the after tax bond yield is 4.2 percentage. So, what is the implication of this one? Because,
as we mentioned here, the holders of the bond, the investors are actually looking for the actual
yield to maturity not the this coupon, this yield to maturity which we saw here. Actually,
they will be looking at this one. So, that means, it has implication in the bond market.
Suppose, government announce a increase in tax for a particular bond, for example,
municipal bond or if there is a tax cut for example, for instance. So, look at this,
what if government makes one of the bond is tax free. So, in this diagram, what you can see that,
you can see here that the panel A, it shows market for municipal bonds and panel B shows
the market for treasury bonds. Suppose, the initial equilibrium position is here and you
can see that the P star and this is the demand and supply in the case of municipal bonds and
the initial equilibrium condition in the market for treasury bonds is at this point.
Now, look at the change, the government announce. Suppose, there is a tax free status when the
municipal bonds get the tax free status, you can see that the demand for municipal bond shift to
the right. So, there will be more demand for municipal bonds and as you have already studied,
that means, and when there is an increase in the demand for a particular bond, its price increases.
So, price increases. Obviously, you also know that the real, because of the demand and supply
condition, you can also see that actually its interest rate actually start declining. Because,
the it is already government is giving tax free. So, that will be reflected in the demand condition,
there is an increase in demand, the price increases and the interest rate on municipal
bonds start declining. So, this will also make impact, because the tax cut for the municipal
bond is going to make an impact on the market for treasury bonds as well. You know that now,
people will be demanding more municipal bonds. So, that means, the demand for treasury bonds
start declining. It start declining like this. So, you can see that when the demand for treasury
bonds decline, then obviously, you know that the price also start declining. So,
when the price start declining means, rate of interest increases. So, the rate of interest
increases, because the price of this bonds start declining. You know the reason, you have already
seen that there is shift, there is actually more people started demanding, the quantity demanded
in the municipal bond market increases and whereas, demand for treasury bonds decline.
So, what you can see here that, we have seen that actually the demand for municipal bond shift to
the right and the demand for treasury bonds shift to the left. So, as a result, what you can see
that the interest rate for municipal bonds started start decreasing whereas, interest rate for
treasury bonds started increase, starts increasing. So, as a result, there will be finally, the market
move into a new equilibrium, where the new interest rate will be established, set up in
the market separately for municipal bonds and for treasury bonds, where the income tax announcement,
the tax cuts, the tax free status make changes in the prices and interest rate in both markets,
the market for municipal bonds and market for treasury bonds.
Suppose, let us look at the effects of Obama tax increase on bond interest rate in 2013. So,
the Congress approved legislation favoured by Obama administration to increase income tax on
high income tax payers from 35 percentage to 39 percentage. So, what are the likely impact? You
know that when government is going to increase income tax rate on high income tax payers.
So, what are the likely impact? Based on our previous discussion, what we can see that,
consistent with supply and demand analysis, the increase in income tax rates for wealthy people
help to lower the interest rates on municipal bonds relative to the interest rate on treasury
bonds. Because, the reason is that when income tax is increased, there will be increase in the
demand for municipal bonds because people will be investing their income on municipal bonds,
demand will be increasing and as a result, the interest rate for municipal bonds will be
declining as compared to the treasury bonds. So, coming to India, there are some government
bonds. Some bonds at the government level are tax free bonds. I would suggest you visit this
website to get more information. For example, bonds issued by rural electrification corporations
in India and the National Highways Authority of India, both are tax free bonds in India.
Let us now move to our next topic that is the term structure of interest rate. So,
whatever we have discussed so far was the risk structure of interest rate. Now,
let us move to the term structure of interest rates. So, the objective here is to list and
explain the theories of why interest rates vary across maturities. Maturities means term. So,
in order to set the stage, let us see what is the main issue here. So, bonds with identical risk,
liquidity and tax characteristics may have different interest rates. For example, why?
So, the question with identical risk, liquidity and tax characteristics. Let us for example,
look at US government bonds between short term and the long term. The difference between short
term and long term, you can see the common thing is there. They have identical risk,
liquidity and tax concentration because both are issued by the US government treasury. So,
you can see that both are having identical risk, liquidity and tax characteristics.
But you can see that in general, the long term bonds are having high interest rate as compared
to short term treasury bills. So, the only difference there is only the term that the
maturity period, short term and long term, all other things are common. So, then our question
is the why the only the time remaining to maturity is different, then why such a difference in
interest rate. So, in order to explain this, let us introduce the concept called yield curve.
So, you can better understand using the term, the concept called yield curve. Actually,
the term structure interest rate, which that means between short term and long term,
it implies yield curve. So, what is yield curve? Yield curve is a plot of the yield on bonds,
yield means the interest rates with a differing term to maturity, but the same risk,
liquidity and tax concentration. So, from this figure, you can see that here we are
plotting two yield curve. For example, the yield curve 1, this yield curve that is plotted on 2016.
So, for instance, on 14th December 2016, we plot, suppose on that particular day,
what are the market rate of interest for different debt instrument issued by the US government. That
means, the difference here is only the time period, the term, all other things are same,
same risk, liquidity and tax concentration, all are same issued by the federal government.
One is for example, one debt instrument is for 1 month, another is for 3 months, 6 months,
1 year like that, 2 year, 3 year like that, 10 year, 20 years, 30 years. So, this is one yield
curve. So, that means, this one we measure, we plot this yield curve based on the market rate
of interest for the bonds issued for different terms or different maturities.
So, what you can see from here that, there is difference in interest rate for different
maturities. So, here for example, 1 month, the rate of interest is for example, 0.5 percentage
and for example, at the same time, you can see that a bond for 30 year term,
30 year maturity period, the interest rate is you can see 3.14 percentage. So, look at for
example, short term bond, you can see that the rate of interest is 0.5. At the same time,
long term bond, you can see that the rate of interest is 3.14 percentage from this yield
curve. So, similarly, exactly after 1 year, when we measure again the economic condition,
socio-economic and political conditions are different after 1 year, you can see that on
that day, when we measure a plot and yield curve, what is the interest rate.
You can see that if the interest rate for a 1 month treasury bill is for example,
you can see some more, it will be coming somewhere 1.4. So, after 1 year, you can see that in year
2017, you can see that ST, this is traded at 1.4 and at the same time, the long term bonds,
this one is traded at 2.71. So, here actually what we have shown here, we have shown two
different yield curve. So, our focus for the moment is just to interpret one particular yield
curve and to see why there is differences in interest rate over time for different
maturities. Just for example, why this is only 0.5, whereas this one is 3.14.
So, this is the main focus of our discussion here and what explains the differences in interest
rates for bonds with different terms to maturity, but the same risk, liquidity and tax concentration.
So, understanding the term structure is very important because term structure integrates
the market's anticipation of future events by offering a complete schedule of interest rates
across time. So, in this, you looking at this yield curve also, you can see that suppose this
one, this yield curve, this is plotted on, this is the transaction happening on 14th December 2016.
So, at that time, the investors, that is the demand is of bonds and as well as the suppliers
of bonds on the given economic condition as well as the future economic conditions,
they make, that is the agreed rate of interest, the market rate of interest for different
maturities, different maturities like this. So, this actually not only includes the rate
of interest for here, for example, short term, that is for just for the one month. At the same
time, you can also see that this is 3.14, that is the forecast, the anticipation they are making
for the next 30 years. So, actually this term structure, it integrates market's anticipation
of future events by offering a complete schedule of interest rates across time,
that is the present conditions as well as the future conditions of the economy.
This will be reflected in the yield curve. Accordingly, the yield curve, which we already
measured, defined a plot of the yield on the bonds with the different terms to maturity. We
can see that there are mainly 3 types of, it can be more than that, but actually assuming 3 broad
categories of yield curve, one is called upward sloping, that means in the case of upward sloping,
you can see that long term rates are above the short term interest rate. So, in this case,
you can see that a yield curve, it will be looking like this. This is a time, that the maturity,
maturity you can see here. So, this is the maturity, this is the rate of interest, yield to
maturity, yield. So, this is upward sloping. Then another one is called that the flat,
that means short term and long term rates are same, short term and long term rates are same.
Then the third category is inverted yield curve, that means the long term rates are below the short
term rates, that means long run interest rates are below the short term interest rate. So,
here actually we are making a comparison between short term, short run, medium run and long term,
that means different maturities or different terms. So, in the long run, what makes the,
what is the difference between short term, short run and long term? So, in the long term,
you can see that there are interest rate risk, that means interest rate may increase or decrease
in the future, right? There is uncertainty with regard to interest rate. So, we cannot,
it is very difficult to forecast what is going to happen in the, after 5 years, 10 years,
20 years and 30 years. So, many things, maybe you, we have already seen that in the long run,
there may be some other kinds of risk may come up, that is associated with the political and
economic conditions. So, there is, so we can see that there are, there is interest rate risk in the
long term, uncertainty with regard to interest rate, that is one. And second one is inflation
risk, inflation risk that may be, inflation may increase, there may be an increase in inflation
in the future. So, that means if there is an increase in inflation in the future, you can
see that actually the investors, they are looking for real return, real return, the demand is,
the holders of bonds, they are looking for real yield or actual yield adjusted for inflation.
So, if they expect there is going to be increase in inflation in the future, you can see that they
want high interest rate in the future for the long term, that means if there is inflation risk. And
similarly, another aspects that makes long run different from the short run is that liquidity
concerns. So, in the long run, you can see that the liquidity of long term bonds will be relatively
less as compared to short run because the maturity period, for example, 10 years, 20 years and 30
years is, that means it is a very long period. So, at that, because of the maturity period of
those bonds with the long term, you can see that because of the high maturity period, the liquidity,
that means the liquidity of those bonds will be less because you know that the issuer of the bond,
they will redeem or repay the bond amount, the issued amount only after the expiry date,
maturity period, that means in the case of long term, because of that, this is highly probable
that the liquidity of long term bonds will be less as compared to short term bonds.
So, what we are going to do here is that, when we develop a term structure of interest rates,
we set some conditions here, that means a theory of the term structure of interest rate must explain
the following facts, that means interest rates on bonds of different maturities move together
over time because we have seen in one of the previous session, that means different types
of bonds, different bonds that move together, maturity, they move together, so that means
interest rates on, interest rates move together, so that interest rates on bonds of different
maturities move together over time and second one is, when short term interest rates are low,
yield curves are more likely to have an upward slope, that is one, when short term rates are
high, yield curves are more likely to slope downward and be inverted and third and finally,
yield curves almost always slope upward, that means in normal condition, normal general,
normal economic condition, yield curves almost always slope upward, that is long term yields
are tend to be higher than the short term yield. So, when we develop some theories,
a theory, it should explain all these factors, then we can say that there is a robust theory
of term structure of interest rates. Let us conclude this session and in the next session,
we will discuss various theories associated with term structure of interest rates. Thank you.
