Lecture 7

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Dec 1, 2023
Welcome to this session.
The objective of this session is to continue our discussion on the market for money and
then subsequently discuss the factors that affect the fluctuations in rate of interest.
In the last session while discussing the market for money, we discussed transaction and precautionary
demand for money and there using the demand and supply of money, we saw that how rate
of interest are determined in the money markets.
So at that time, we left little bit to discuss another aspect of demand for money that is
speculative demand for money.
So in the first part of this session, we will complete this part of this discussion that
is the speculative demand for money.
The idea of the concept of speculative demand for money was introduced by John Maynard Keynes.
So his definition he defined speculative demand for money is the money held in anticipation
of a fall in bond prices.
This is what Keynesian speculative demand for money and Keynes in some of his writings
we can see that the speculative motive he introduced the concept called speculative
motive that is the object of securing profit from knowing better than the market what the
future will bring forth from the existence of uncertainty as to the future of rate of
interest.
So according to Keynes, the individual who believes that future rates of interest will
be above the rates assumed by the market has a reason for keeping liquid cash that means
demanding cash demanding money, whilst the individual who differs from the market in
other direction will have a motive for borrowing money for short periods in order to purchase
debt of long term.
So about as we already seen in the previous session in our model that there are two assets
only two assets one is money and other one is bonds.
So about the relative desirability of both money and bonds about return on money we know
that money does not pay any rate of interest so that means 0 and about bond, bond actually
pay interest earnings bonds pay interest earnings and in addition there is capital
gain either capital gain or capital loss.
So capital gain happens you know that when the rate of interest declines later on in
the future and then actually then the bond price will increase so as a result there will
be capital gain in addition to the interest earnings.
So in contrast if the rate of interest increase in the future and there is going to be decline
in the bond price and as a result there is going to be capital loss.
So about the bond we know that there is interest earnings and the interest itself interest
rate is also uncertain and plus there is about the return expected return it includes interest
earnings and the either capital loss or capital gain and this actually subject to fluctuation
in rate of interest.
So an individual would make a choice between holding money which does not pay interest
and bonds the choice between money and bonds you know that bonds which provide provides
an uncertain return on the basis of maximizing return to his portfolio.
And the question here is since bonds pay interest money does not then why an individual
would hold any money above that is needed for the transaction and precautionary motives.
So prior to the concept of speculative motive was introduced there was mainly two motives
were discussed that is the fact is the motive behind demanding money that is transaction
and precautionary motive.
Then the question is then why an individual would hold any money above that is needed
for transaction and precautionary motive.
And the answer given by Keynes was that because of uncertainty about the future interest rates
that is one and second one the relationship between changes in interest rate and the price
of bonds we know that there is an inverse relationship.
So because of the uncertainty about the future interest rates and the inverse relationship
between interest rate and price of bonds lead to that would lead to the demand for that
actually one of the major cause for speculative demand for money.
That is demanding money above that is above that is needed for the transaction and precautionary
motive.
How Keynes introduced this idea you see according to Keynes investors have a relatively fixed
conception of the normal interest rate in an economy.
So suppose whether the interest rate is 5 interest rate in an economy is 5 whether is
normal interest rate or above the normal rate or below the rate actually people have a fixed
conception about the normal interest rate based on the previous data the historical
data.
So when the actual interest rate is above the normal rate you see when the actual interest
rate is above the normal interest rate investors expect that interest rate would fall in the
future.
In contrast when the interest rate is below the normal rate investors expect the interest
rate to rise in the future.
So this is the two trend that we can see here given this assumption about how expectations
about interest rates are formed we can develop a relationship between the level of the speculative
demand for money and the interest rate.
According to Keynes the he actually gave built his speculative demand for money mainly on
the notion of expectation on interest rate and there will be bulls in the market in the
bond market bulls means who want to buy and hold bonds.
So since individuals tend to differ in their views on the future rate of interest some
would expect an increase in bond price that means decrease in the rate of interest and
obviously you know that when someone expecting that the there is an increase in bond price
that means decrease in rate of interest obviously they will be willing to choosing willing to
buy more bonds and they can be labeled as bulls in the bond market.
That means they expect that bond price is going to increase that means rate of interest
is going to decrease which translated into increase in bond price which would give them
capital gain that means they can make more profit more return from this movement.
So they are called bulls and how about a bears actually who want to sell bonds and hold money.
So what bears think then while others would expect a decrease in bond prices that is increase
in rate of interest.
So when they expect that there is an increase the rate of interest is going to increase
in the future that means bond price is going to decrease and they expect there is going
to be a capital loss if they buy if they keep bonds and they are called as labeled as bear
choosing to reduce their bond holdings and instead they will be holding more money.
Any increase in bond price will exceed the expectation of some bulls that is convince
them that bond price have gone up too far and convert them into fears.
But they think that the rate of interest has declined beyond a level that means decline
further and further gone up too far that means in translating this into that in the bond
prices already gone up too far and they think that the rate of interest is going to increase
because the normal rate of interest is for example 5 percentage but when they see that
rate of interest has declined to 4 percentage, 3 percentage, 2 percentage and when they think
that rate of interest has declined to the bottom really at the bottom and when they
think that so because of that you know that bond price has gone up too far then as a result
what they think that the rate of interest is going to increase in the future and because
of that some bulls they will become bears expecting that bond price is going to decline
in the future.
A preponderance of bulls in the bond market that is higher demand for bonds pushes up
the prices of the bonds and pushes down the rate of interest.
This movement converts an increasing number of bulls who want to buy and hold bonds into
bears until an equilibrium price of bond is reached where the demand for bonds just equals
their supply.
So therefore the demand for speculative money balances by bears increases as the prices
of bonds rise or conversely as the interest rate falls so that aggregate speculative demand
for money is inversely related to the rate of interest.
So this point mainly here due to the changes in future rate of interest which can leads
to capital loss or capital gain that means expected future rate of interest this also
leads to change that the building up of expected capital loss and gain.
Keynes assumed that different individuals had different views of what was a normal rate
of interest because he is talking about macroeconomy there are different people with different
views of when it comes to normal interest rate.
So as I mentioned just before actually the perception about normal rate of interest it
was based upon each and every individual's perception of what is normal.
Maybe they may build this one based on the adaptive expectation based on the historical
data that means okay for the last one year this is the rate of interest for this economy
and this is normal and the current rate of interest may be normal or above the normal
or below the normal this is just a perception.
So as the interest rate fell beginning for example at a very high rate where there was
very little speculative demand the rate would move successively below the critical rates
of different investors.
So the lower the interest rate the more investors would find that given their view of the normal
interest rate money was the preferred asset.
At a very low interest rate that is the key point here at a very low interest rate almost
all investors would come to expect almost all investors most of the investors would
come to expect the interest rate to rise substantially in the future.
Because already at the current rate of interest is much much below the normal rate of interest
and they expect that future rate of interest is going to rise substantially and money would
be almost universally preferred as an asset.
Because when they see that future rate of interest is going to increase that means they
think that bond price is going to decline and they would incur a capital loss.
This can be explained using a diagram so where we can we are making the assumption that in
this economy there are only two assets one is the total wealth the total wealth is distributed
between demand for money and bonds.
These are the two assets so where we see that MY is the individual's total money holdings
and BI is bond holdings where WHI is wealth.
Then we categorize group total money holdings into transactions.
Transaction means transaction and precautionary we can add.
So normally we bring put both the transaction and precautionary motive precautionary demand
for money as one just transaction demand for money.
In the transaction is actually more certain precautionary is little bit uncertain.
So that is the main difference otherwise we just put both of the mass transaction demand
for money and MY raise to 2 is called the speculative demand for money.
So we categorize group the total demand for money into transaction and speculative demand
for money and now let us use first start with an individual's speculative demand for money.
So in this diagram the first part in panel 1 we denote rate of interest on the y axis
and the speculative demand for money on the x axis.
So what you can see here that assume this one RI raise to n this one is called the normal
interest rate and this is only a perception we are just taking case of an individual a
hypothetical an individual.
Then his perception is that the normal interest rate is this much maybe we can give one numerical
value for example if you want 5 percentage.
Let us now see what would happen when the rate of interest declines.
So this is the initial normal rate of interest as per this individual's perception and then
the suppose then rate of interest become keep on declining.
So see for example 4.5 then become 4 percentage then again it will decline further we will
denote it soon.
Let us see that what would happen if the rate of interest become 4.5 and you know that when
the rate of interest become 4.5 normally a kind of perception started building that means
rate of interest is below the normal rate of interest maybe in the future it can bounce
back it can increase.
The moment we see that rate of interest is going to increase in the future the investors
fears that when the rate of interest increase their bond price will decline and they will
incur a capital loss.
But here you know that bond also give a return that the coupon that the interest income it
will be already the income they will be giving the agreed income they will be giving the
coupon income they will be giving.
So from the return from bond you know that two components are there one is from in the
form of yield to maturity that one is the interest income and second one is either capital
gain or capital loss.
So from this point that for example rate of interest is 5 percentage when we see that
rate of interest has become 4.5 and this individual anticipate that rate of interest will bounce
back to 5 percentage then he is going to make some capital loss.
But then he may not he still continue to demand bond because there is return from the
coupon from the bond.
Suppose here that this rate of interest decline further to here that means 4 percentage.
Suppose this is a perpetual bond the return the interest income is for example 50 dollar
per 1000 bond.
Suppose you see that when the rate of interest become this much suppose and if the rate of
interest fall from 5 percentage to 4 percentage and you know that when they see that the rate
of interest is going to bounce back to 5 then obviously they are going to make a capital
loss.
Suppose the capital loss is 50 and from this calculate that this 50 then they will be indifferent
because you see they are going to make a capital loss of 50 but anyway they are going to get
50 as a coupon coupon income from this holding this bond.
So and because of that they will be little bit pessimistic about the scenario but they
will still hold the demand for bond will continue because they anticipate that anyway they may
make a capital loss of this much that 50 but it will be compensated with 50 of coupon payment.
But then we say that this rate this 4 percentage let us call this one as the critical rate
we denote it with a critical rate.
And below this what if the rate of interest become 3.5 percentage and you know that 3.5
percentage when it bounce back to again 5 obviously the capital loss won't be 50 it
will be for example let us make it 75 is the capital loss.
So in this case you know that the this bond is going to give only the return the coupon
of only 50 then you can see that the expected losses the expected capital losses because
the rate of interest is below this critical rate below this critical rate.
They see that this expected losses would outweigh the interest earning on the bonds and then
this would cause the investors to hold more money hold more money instead you know why
because below the critical when the rate of interest go goes below the critical rate
of interest if they demand money we demand bond the then the expected capital loss would
outweigh the interest earning and they will make a loss right.
Suppose it is 1000 bond if they make a capital loss of 75 and but the interest income will
be coupon payment only will be 50 that means they are going to make the net capital loss
of 25 right.
So because of that what they will do that when the rate of interest go below the critical
minimum critical rate of interest they would they would prefer to hold more money instead
of bond and this money demand is called as speculative demand for money right.
So you can see that until this one that this point from rate of interest movement from
normal interest rate to critical rate of interest you can see that the total this speculative
demand for money speculative demand for money is going to be 0 when the rate of interest
is normal or till it goes down till the critical rate speculative demand for money is going
to be 0.
So there you can see that the total wealth minus transaction demand for money this is
going to be full of bonds only bonds that the wealth minus transaction demand for money
this distance is going to be full of bond holding that means the total asset total wealth
what is left after transaction demand all will be in the portfolio allocation is going
to be bond when the rate of interest is above the normal rate of interest or below the normal
rate of interest but till the critical rate of interest.
But the moment when the rate of interest fall below the critical rate this point then
instead of bond because people anticipate that they are going to make capital loss they
are going to demand money and this money demand that means wealth minus transaction demand
for money this one is going to be speculative demand for money which we can denote as MY2.
So this demand for money here is going to be speculative demand for money according
to Keynes analysis.
This one when we translate it into aggregate macroeconomic level what you can see that
when the rate of interest for example this is below the critical rate for the economy
for most of the people when this point is below that critical rate then you can see
that any decline in rate of interest when the rate of interest keep on declining people
think that money is the most preferred asset.
So where you can see that the aggregate speculative demand for money schedule as the interest
rate becomes lower and lower it falls below the critical rate for more individuals and
the speculative demand for money rises.
This is the concept of speculative demand for money in a macroeconomic context at an
aggregate level.
So what is the point here is that to summarize this one what we can see here is that suppose
that an investor believes interest rates will fall then bonds then how the higher aspect
of return and thus would demand bonds no speculative demand for money only transaction money demand
when investor believe that interest rate will fall in the future.
So obviously he is make capital loss here no speculative demand for money in this case
but in contrast this scenario if the interest rates are expected to rise then it is possible
that expected capital loss on bonds will outweigh interest earning and then expected return
on bonds would be negative in such a case and money would be the preferred asset.
So to study the main definition to summarize this one money held in anticipation of a fall
in bond prices that means a rise in rate of interest is Keynesians Keynes speculative
demand for money.
And this concept was introduced by Keynes in the context of depression great depression
when the economy is undergoing a recessionary stage or a depressionary stage then normally
the demand for the rate of interest go below the normal rate because overall the economic
activity is very low that means economy is undergoing through a recessionary phase and
as a result the supply of bonds will be very less and people demand for bonds also will
be relatively less.
So as a result overall during recessionary time the rate of interest will be very low.
So at that time what is going to happen that Keynes said that Keynes argument was that
when the rate of interest is very low which is much much below the normal rate and also
below the critical rate people always anticipate people will be anticipating that the rate
of interest will increase in the future and they will make a capital loss.
Then at that time suppose monetary policy the central bank of a country for example
when they try to when they inject more money in the economy with the anticipation that
the rate of interest can be reduced so that investment can be rejuvenated.
But what is going to happen here is that is a kind of liquidity trap will happen that means
even when the central bank or the monetary authority inject more money in the economy
it would not be invested in the bond market it will be just held as cash just held as money
that means just in the held as liquidity liquid asset that is money then at that time the
monetary policy is going to be very ineffective.
So here it is created trap liquidity trap that means a situation at a very low interest
rate where the speculative demand for money schedule becomes nearly horizontal.
So what we can see here is that look at this, this is the money demand suppose that there
is speculative demand for money then what happen that after certain point of time when
the rate of interest become really low.
Suppose R0 at this point very low and after that the perception is so strong among the
general public among the investors that the rate of interest is really low it can bounce
back to it will increase at any time.
So at that time suppose the money initial money supply suppose this one is MS0 this
is the initial money supply.
Suppose then what is going to happen if even if they increase money supply money supply
is not going to reduce rate of interest because the additional money supply coming to the
economy that the money supply money injected in the economy will be just held in the form
of money by the people just they keep it as just in the form of money it won't be invested
in the bond market.
We know that what we have studied in the previous session that means in the normal scenario
if there is an increase in money supply keeping the demand for money same constant if there
is an increase in money supply we have seen that people will be content with more money
supply more money then they will be demanding more bonds then the bond price will increase
and then the rate of interest will decline that means when the rate of interest decline
in the economy the investment will there will be more investment in factories and machines
that means more productive investment in production.
So that will rejuvenate the economy that will increase the economic activity then the GDP
will start increasing right that is the whole idea but when the economy is in a liquidity
trap during recession Keynes argument is that even if we increase money suppose we increase
from here to MS1 to MS0 then rate of interest will be still at the critical the very low
that the R0 and even if we increase further also it is not going to make any impact even
if we reduce the money supply even from MS2 to MS0 then also is not going to increase
the rate of interest as well right that means this point this area that means the demand
curve the speculative demand with the money demand the entire money demand you can see
that it is going to be horizontal that means perfectly interest elastic a horizontal line
that means any increase in money supply is not going to make any changes in the interest
rate here.
That means any additional money supply it will be fully absorbed by the households as
money liquid asset that is money asset it would not be invested in any bonds.
In the next session this session we completed our discussion on the demand for money mostly
our discussion here was confined to the speculative demand for money where we related it with
the bond market and the rate of interest and in the next session we will discuss the changes
the differences in interest rate for different debt instrument and subsequently we will
also discuss what are the factors that explain these differences the factors explaining determining
the differences and fluctuations in the rate of interest.
Thank you.
