Pam Tanowitz is now an in-demand choreographer – but her career has followed a unique trajectory. For years, she and her company had an under-the-radar following in New York, but only recently did she win wider attention. A work set to TS Eliot’s 4 Quartets led to international tours and commissions for the Royal Ballet and New York City Ballet. Before that happened she worked and worked: at dance, but also unglamorous admin jobs. When we met at the Barbican for the London premiere of her Song of Songs, she talked about giving hope to all the late bloomers.
Pam Tanowitz has delineated her own dance language through decades of research and creation. Now, the world’s most respected companies – Martha Graham Dance Company, Royal Ballet, New York City Ballet and more – are integrating her poetic universe into their repertories. In 2000 she founded Pam Tanowitz Dance to explore dance-making with a consistent community of dancers. She has been commissioned by Fisher Center at Bard, Joyce Theater, Jacob’s Pillow and others. Four Quartets (2018) was called ‘the greatest creation of dance theater so far this century’ by the New York Times.
Find out more about the work of the RAD on our website.
Follow the RAD on social media and join the conversation with host David Jays:
RAD is an independent educational charity and does not receive regular government funding. Every penny we make goes back into the work we do. You can support us by either naming a seat as part of our Name A Seat Campaign or making a donation.
[Music]
my favorite thing in any London theater
is the way the doors close at the
barbacon bear with me there's a door at
the end of almost every Row in the
theater and when a show is about to
start they all close at the exact same
moment it magically heightens your
expectation I saw it just last night I
was here to watch a new dance work by
New York's star choreographer Pam
tanowitz a fascinating piece to music by
David Lang set the Bible's most Amorous
poem The Song of Songs From the Jewish
Old Testament the words are Lush the
music shimmers and the dance is
unexpected challenging High High charged
but not giving up its secrets I'm David
Jays and this is why dance matters the
Royal Academy of Dance podcast I'm back
in the barbacan theater our producer
Sarah is thrilled because the acoustic
is peachy and I'm thrilled to speak to
Pam because most dance careers don't go
the way hers has done Pam and her
company had an under the radar following
in New York for a decade or so but only
recently did she win wider attention
with a piece set to TS Elliot's four
quartets that led to International tours
and commissions for Prestige outfits
like the Royal Ballet and New York City
Ballet they're bringing her work to
London in March 2024 in between Pam
worked at dance but also regular jobs
Administration serving coffee she didn't
swerve she knew what she wanted to
create I'm looking forward to speaking
to her about how you keep going about
challenging audiences about what makes
dance Jewish and the doors might not all
close at once but let's imagine they
do
[Music]
now Pam welcome to my
matters and it's very lovely to be
sitting in the barban theater beautiful
theater where last night I saw your
gorgeous song of songs and I've heard
that you're not a huge fan of seeing
your own work performed it's true it's
true I mean how was it then last night
cuz you you know lovely reception
sparkly shoes it was all I put on the
sparkly shoes but I mean I see my work
in dress rehearsal and I watch it from
the audience in all the tech rehearsals
but when it's the actual performance
it's hard for me to sit in the audience
with other people it's just really
really stressful so I I'm usually
backstage once in a while when I'm in a
place where I don't know anyone I'll try
to stand in the back and watch but it's
still hard cuz I I don't like seeing
people I know but even strangers stress
me out so I don't know I don't know what
to say but I love sitting in the barbin
is gorgeous this theater is incredible
and is that because you're worried about
it not being absolutely perfect in every
detail is it not even as logical it's
not yeah it's not logical my dancers are
amazing it's that you know what when
it's the performance it's not mine
anymore and so it's this whole other
thing that's part of it and I think when
I'm backstage it's almost like I want to
be there for something something goes
wrong even though obviously I would
never do anything I wouldn't like run on
stage to try to fix something or grab
the Betsy the stage managers like mik
and start trying to fix stuff that I
don't know how to fix but I feel like if
I'm close to the show I could do
something if something bad happens
that's one and two is I don't like
watching people watch my dance because
if I'm in the audience that's what I
will do instead of watching my piece
it's very distracting it's hard for me
to block everything out so those are the
reasons they're filled with anxiety
maybe one day I'll grow out of them all
I don't know we'll see maybe you need a
kind of base level of anxiety to yes
impel you I think so I think so I think
the day that I'm not nervous is the day
I probably should stop like I care so
much about it and and I think that that
you have a point like I think the part
of the anxiety is the driving force for
it as well well is there an intensely
pleasurable stage of the process though
where is there a happy Pam stage oh yeah
I mean in the studio making when I'm
making I'm happy in the studio is where
I'm the least unhappy and I love being
in process trying to solve problems and
figure out what you know I could spend
30 minutes on where to place a hand how
a dancer is executing all the different
ways we can do it that to me is
interesting as you say incredible
dancers are you still tinkering does a
piece reach a final fixed form or is no
I for the benefit of the tape Pam is
screwing up her face yeah no yeah I mean
no because okay so for instance this
piece you saw last night Song of Songs
We premiered it in
2022 and that moment I knew it was a
draft and I think this piece has sort of
a longt history of like working on it
then it was the pandemic you know so it
was postponed for two or 3 years it was
supposed to be in
2020 so it finally premiered in
2022 so I worked with each of the
dancers individually either on Zoom or
by themselves and rehearsal outside in
New York so that's where I'm sure you
noticed that there's a lot of very
individualized vocabulary for each
dancer and that's how that came to be I
don't always work that way
so that was also very interesting as a
director where I had all these dancers
with all their movement and then I had
to figure out in the studio what does
this all mean together now so that was
sort of a different way of working for
me which I really liked but I knew when
I put it together that it was a first
draft and third fourth and the ending
are totally different than a year ago
for this show yeah we worked really hard
this summer I stayed put I didn't travel
I didn't do anything we were hers three
days days a week for the whole summer I
didn't have a full cast ever um cuz
everyone had their plans so another
layer to that is when I finally got
everybody together I needed to see what
I made cuz I would have like five
dancers and six dancers and four dancers
but I would still keep going I love that
because then when I get everyone
together I'm like wow what did I just do
I love you know so it's I love being
surprised so just to your question is
anything ever fixed no it's boring why
would I do that I'm in a different place
in my life the dancers are in a
different place we're living in a
different world it has to breathe same
with having the live music it's like
living breathing musicians and singers
with living breathing dancers making
this thing and none of it is improvised
but it's different all the time and even
before the show we were like what's
going to happen you know even though
they all had their steps and they knew
where they were supposed to be there's
still an element of mystery and you
describing the way it was made makes
perfect sense as well because for most
of the piece there are seven dancers
which is such an interesting number cuz
there's no way you can divide that up
into neat groups always yes that's also
on purpose like I didn't want it to have
enough men for women and it's yeah too
easy I like an odd number I like to push
myself and figure out how to solve this
what am I
[Music]
doing part of the preparation for this
piece for Song of Songs was looking at
Jewish dance which is it's such an
interesting thing because I think we
know what Jewish writing is especially
like American mid-century we know Philip
broth we know Arthur Miller we know
intellectual inappropriately horny men
we know all about that yes and we know
about Jewish filmmakers Jewish dance
what is the jewishness in Jewish it's so
open because there's also there's Jewish
American choreographers like David
Gordon and anakala I mean you know
there's the 50s choreographers the
Judson choreographers and how their
jewishness plays in or doesn't play into
their work then there's Israeli folk
dance and there's all of using that
material and so to me the research that
I did wasn't necessarily about one kind
or person it was more like look at all
this stuff and what does it have to do
with me I don't know if it has anything
to do with me except that I am Jewish
and I'm making
dances and before I started this
research it was during the pandemic I
applied to the the library for this
fellowship and I got it so I was the
newk public library the Performing Arts
Library they're amazing I love them
Linda Murray and um I don't know if you
know her but she's incredible and so
during the pandemic I actually had
digital access to videos I wanted I mean
it was incredible but a lot of the the
journey was wondering what it had to do
with what I do already and had a process
that information so for example I did
look at a lot of like folk dance steps
and I tried to learn stuff off video and
things like that and to take actual
steps that belong to a specific culture
and they use it in a social and
political way and to sort of pull it out
of that and use it just physically is
what I was interested in doing and then
have that material talk to other
material like real dance steps quote
unquote or modern dance steps or baletic
you know and have them in dialogue with
each other and sort of absorb those
ideas and steps into my lexicon is what
ended up happening and there are those
moments there are chains there are rings
there are all those kind of formations
it's like being at a bmitzvah but
without an exuberant Auntie kind of
bearing down on you yes I mean I love
the horror even before this dance though
I always put grap Vine in my dance say
always I had it in Goldberg I had it in
for quartet maybe it's just a great
traveling step it's very useful so I
mean I love a good hor always so and
this piece is dedicated to your father
herb what was he like oh he was a
complicated man very complicated and
hard to know when I started out as
making dances I felt like I had to prove
myself and I think part of my energy
trying to go forward and like and my
ambition of trying to get my work out
there was in response to trying to prove
myself and my family like that I could
do it but and a certain point I had to
let that go I didn't need to use that
anymore and then right before my dad
died he looked at me and he said well I
guess you really are a late bloomer you
know like 50 years old getting a good
New York Times review or whatever not
that a review makes you successful or
not but just that he said that I don't
know if it's in the program but
sometimes I wrate it's dedicated to my
dad and all the late
bloomers that's very lovely love I don't
know if you are a late bloomer Pam I
think it's the world is the Late Bloomer
we're just catching up maybe but also
like I am 53 when I moved to New York in
my early 20s I was you know no
Instagram no computers I don't even
think I email people you know we used to
throw rocks at people's windows to get
say hey you want to come down for a
drink or whatever but what that does
gives us time because I made I just kept
making work I didn't make a dance and
post it on Instagram the next day you
know the Gen X life you know is totally
different I remember after my first show
I did at cbgb's Gallery which was the
art gallery next to
cbgbs they treated us like a band and we
went in and we got like a split of the
cover and the New York Times came as my
first New York Times review that Jack
Anderson reviewed he was in cbgb's
gallery reviewing my show no lighting
nothing and then we waited that night at
the news stand on 8th Street to get the
newspaper to read it not you don't just
turn your phone on you had to like wait
till midnight till they throw the paper
on the street and then you like
frantically look in it and so I think
that was a blessing for me cuz it gave
me time to work on my work yeah not have
the pressure of anybody looking or
trying to do something or be someone I
wasn't and it took me a long time
because I wasn't a star dancer from a
like that path of being in a dance
company and then being a star of that
company and then making your own company
and that's great that's a different path
that that people go so I think a lot of
times people want to know like who where
did she come from like they don't
understand where I came from you know
when had
making entered the picture was that
pretty much from the the beginning of
dancing it was in college my junior year
at Ohio State University we had to go
through a it was a very traditional it
was not a conservatory but you had to
take improvisation one improvisation 2
choreography and music one like it was
very rigorous and like had a lot of
rules so when I finally got to make my
own piece it was amazing and so it was
like my junior year year and that's when
I realized that was more interesting
like being outside and looking and
seeing and solving and trying to figure
out how to make this thing that I didn't
really know that much about yeah so it
was the problem solving aspect really
got you hooked from the beginning
absolutely yeah it's interest because
there's a really lovely little film I
saw I think when you were working with
the Royal Ballet last year uh and you're
rehearsing with the dancers and you say
something like there's a little too much
drama seeping into your
face which
is was it like Anna Rose or something or
will was it one of the thetive royal
ballet dancers but I mean I you've seen
just from this little bit of
conversation that we're having someone
who is very very easy access to their
own emotion it's you don't feel kind of
closed off but you don't want that in
yeah no I don't think interesting for my
work it doesn't mean I don't think it's
interesting when I go see the ballet and
that's what I try to say when I'm
working with ballet dancers it's it's
that it's not that I like that's bad
it's just not what I want for my work
and as a performer it's interesting for
them to figure out how to perform
different kinds of dances because just
more Tools in their toolbox it makes
them a better performer so they don't
just go into these like they're not
thinking and they're just doing what
they've always been doing there's no
consciousness and so in order to be
present you have to be thinking and then
you have to say to yourself you know I
don't just have to project this thing
because they've been doing that since
they were in baby ballet and so it's
ingrained in them so what I'm asking
them to do is change that a little and I
think that's the hard part it's not that
they can't do it it's that that when
they're click into their performance
mode something else happens that they're
used to because it's what they always do
there is that dance a smile for the
happy steps and the sort of the tragic
look for serious or and also but on such
as ballet in modern dancers's the modern
dance corner like what I always want to
know like what is in that corner the
stare into the midle distance yeah like
what is that
corner does that is that part of I mean
obviously there are dancers you've
worked with for quite a while now so
they understand you they understand the
process and they understand what you're
interested in but at first is that
sometimes kind of quite hard to to to
explain that you're interested in
something else about them absolutely and
it's actually really good for me to work
with different dancers because when my
dancers like you said they know what I'm
after so there's a part of like a verbal
articulation that is easy for me and
then when I go into ballet or other
working with new dancers or like even
when I go into juliard you know making a
piece on them next year the students it
makes me work work harder because I have
to explain what I want and that's good
for me because then I get to reassess
what do I want you know even though you
know and I I get to do that work too
that I expect dancers do for me what
what is it that that tends to ignite
your interest in a new piece what is it
that Sparks it because you the things
you've used as scores The Goldberg
Variations and David Lang's Beautiful
Song of Songs numbers and TS Elliott for
the four quartets I they're very very
various yes and I think a lot of ways a
lot of different ways actually like so
all the pieces that you just listed
Goldberg four quartets well those two
for instance were sort of dares in a way
so it's not like I woke up on morning
and was like I'm going to choreograph to
Goldberg Variations it was actually
quite the opposite Simona and also
Simona came up came to me usually a
choreographer goes after a a musician
and says can we work together she came
to me and said I want to collaborate I
don't know what that means how do I
collaborate with choreog because she's
not a composer she's a musician so but
her
interpretation was intrical to how I
made the work the way she played it had
freedom and openness there was space for
dance but she came to me and I said
absolutely not I'm not doing that and
then I woke up the next day and I was
like I'm going to do it because
everything up until then I used very
experimental scratchy VI
like I love and like really crazy
sometimes I go really crazy in the
audience is like not into it at all but
I love it so for me Goldberg was a risk
for me Goldberg was experimental because
I had never done anything like that so
so that was a dare and also I was scared
because you know the Jerry Robbins
version It's iconic and there's so much
stuff and everybody knows the Goldberg
Variations like it's in movies it's
playing when you go shopping you know
it's everywhere so that was that and
then four quartets was sort of the same
I was talking to Gideon Lester the
artistic director of Fisher Center in
2015 and I had used one
line from East Coker
in one of my titles and he asked me
about it he was like what's going on
with this title wherein there is no
ecstasy was the line and I said well
it's TS Elliott and I had like put TS
Elliott next to something like a JD
Salander thing and he was interested in
that and why and I said how much I loved
four quartets and I was carrying it
around for 20 years and then he looked
at me he said well the anniversary of
for quartets is in
2018 do you want to make a dance and I
was like sure but I never thought it
would happen I thought like cuz I didn't
know Gideon that well at the time and
he's like a mover and a Shaker and he
gets stuff dumb but I didn't know that
then and so I thought it would just go
away thought you were safe yeah but it
happened and so those two pieces really
like came from other people and then had
conversations with me so that's
interesting and then there's other times
where I like seek out certain kinds of
music I'm very interested in I did a
piece to Nan Caro string quartets that
are gorgeous that was very intentional
and he's very famous for player piano
pieces do you know conol and n Caro and
so he has these string quartets so it's
really just depends there's no formula
on how I come up with dances another
time I'll just start with no music and
in the studio with like movement ideas
if I'm inspired by a movie or a piece of
art you know it
[Music]
depends if I could just drag you back a
little bit to the yes I don't want to
call them the Lost Years the late
blooming years I mean you were raising
your daughter you were making a living
it would have been really easy for
making dance to be just left to one side
as the one thing that would be too too
much of a burden on top of everything
else what is my life that was the
question yeah so that was that was never
an option no no no I was married at the
time my husband at the time really was
able to take care of while I my daughter
Gemma while I was rehearsing and then I
would work I always had a day job and
then I would rehearse at night so and I
had this great job at City Center where
I was the studio manager so I'd rent out
the studios and then at 6:00 I would go
down and I would have my dancers meet me
and I would rehearse I would have free
Studio space and we would rehearse 6 to9
probably three or four times a week on
the weekends and I would usually do one
show a year
in New York so I never even
traveled for work till I was 48
something like that so that's what my
path was very slow and steady you know
and is that and did you think this is
just what it's going to carry on being
I'll just carry on making the pieces I
want to make that may or may not get
seen in a very wide way and that would
have been enough yeah cuz my my gigs in
New York got better and better like I
went from self-producing to the Joyce
Theater and some other good theaters but
yeah I mean I honestly never
imagined that I would get to travel and
do so much work I'm so lucky that I have
so many opportunities I teach but I
never imagined that I wouldn't have a
day job like an everyday job like a 9to
five job I thought I would have that my
whole life so I'm very lucky that I was
able to do it and you know sometimes
when I get overwhelmed I think well I'm
lucky I have all these opportunities and
and one day they're going to stop
calling so might as well just do
everything now and then when they stop
calling I can go get a job on with we
are the lucky ones because we are
getting to see your work and that you
know that's especially with dance if you
made a film it could go out there if
you'd written a play it could be
published with dance you kind of need to
be in the room don't you yeah I mean and
actually that's why dance
matters because because of that because
that's the thing about dance it's
different it's not a manuscript you can
hold or CD or a painting on a wall and
dances are really hard to make I say
this to my choreography students I try
to make them understand how hard making
a dance is because there's so many
elements and it's Visual and Performing
it's everything and there's so many
logistical issues that come about you
know like I was describing at the
beginning like you know you need the
dancers in the room sometimes I'm
jealous of painters or writers because
they get to do things by themselves and
get stuff done by themselves but then
I'm also not jealous then when I have
people with me it's amazing but when
they can't come in a rehearsal then
you're like oh was there something
easier maybe that's not the right word
about going kind of going under the
radar cuz now there are more eyes not
just audience eyes but there are you
know organizational eyes AB the first 25
years of my career nobody KN really knew
who I was and it was frustrating and
upsetting sometimes but it was a gift as
well because of that too so yes
absolutely there was some relief in that
as well as we've been talking about you
know and love your dance history and we
talk a lot about the founding fathers of
dance whether it's the classics or
George balena Jerome Robbins M
Cunningham how important is the
tradition of founding mothers in dance
oh absolutely well also it's interesting
because here the founding people are
different so when I come to London like
I'm not brushed up in that you could
Ashton and your McMill and all that well
I love Ashton because ABT does Ashton so
I get to see McMillan when I come visit
I mean I love Ashton so much but as far
as modern dance here who are the
founding people here in
London yeah no that's true it's the sort
of the rbe yes and that's a different
tradition Al together different it's
different we have the founding mothers
well we have like Martha obviously we
have Martha Graham and in Martha
Graham's company we had Paul Taylor and
M Cunningham and so they you left their
mommy and started their new company and
they were bad and they did all these
other things that she didn't do that
they wanted to do so yeah there's a lot
there there's a lot there but it's all
important to me and I think when I first
moved to New York like I've talked about
before and there was no internet and no
Instagram blah blah blah you had to walk
to the library of Performing Arts and
you had to fill out a form and show your
library card and pick out videos and you
got to watch things and I did that all
the time I was upset I watched Mark Mars
and twilight Tharp and Paul Taylor and
at my job at City Center at that time
they had an amazing dance program it's
very different now they have a good
program now but they had a series
Cunningham Taylor
ABT Ally and Ali still comes but they
would have five dance companies all the
time and so I got to sit in the theater
and watch them rehearse so I watched
like years and years years of Paul
Taylor sitting there smoking watching
his dances I mean unbelievable like he
didn't know I was there I got to watch
ABT rehearsing Mark Mars pieces and I
just got such a great lesson history
lessons like in real life so I was I was
really lucky and then New York City
Ballet I used to pour coffee in the
patrons Lounge so I used to watch them I
would sneak in not have to buy a ticket
watch all Balanchine all Jerry Robbins I
was very resourceful but modern dance
choreographers are Scrappy in the best
sense and resourceful like I could put
on a show by myself and I knew how to do
it and now of course with the dancers
you've got as well each of them is a
living walking repository of everything
that they've done I mean people like
M who danced with Mart Morris for 20
years well that's the thing is like when
I work with dancers I'm also I'm
collaborating with them I'm
collaborating with their history and her
20 years of working with Mark and
Melissa at you know was in Cunningham
for years 15 years um you know they all
have amazing and different histories I'm
working with all their teachers I didn't
teach them how to dance and I would
never take credit for it they work so
hard it's so extremely difficult to be a
freelance dancer in New York City you
know they all dance for multiple
choreographers they have to pay their
bills they have to keep their body in
shape it's
[Music]
hard so late bloomer um we I will stop
saying that at it's gone from being
Charming to to kind of rude now no it's
not rude it's not rude I cuz I always
it'll always be positive to me so
perfect well this is a good blooming
moment because you've been at the Royal
Ballet here quite a lot your own
company's works are touring uh piece for
New York City Ballet is going to be
visiting London next year I this is this
is not bad tell us a bit about that sure
I mean that was a piece it's called
Gustav L gr it's named after the
Caroline Shaw score it's for four people
it was created for a special occasion at
the Kennedy Center it originally had two
dancers from Miami City Ballet and two
from dancer of Harlem and I was really
lucky Virginia Johnson and Lordz chose
me to create this piece it was perform
once so I made a ballet version of that
piece and I made a modern dance version
for my company that was performed I
think during the pandemic on live stream
anyway so there's two versions of that
piece and then New York City Ballet
loved it and they licensed it for me and
so now sometimes it's done with all New
York City Ballet and sometimes it's done
with two Dance Theater of Harlem dancers
and two New York City Bley dancers which
they do sometimes which is great cuz
that's what it originally was but it's
in flat shoes it's not in point shoes
which I think is interesting and there's
a moving piano it's only 10 minutes and
it's interesting cuz a lot of people
like it but I never meant it to go like
have a life like this it's one of my
dances that it's like a little more
accessible quote unquote so that's fine
that's in March and I hope that I can
come I'm hoping I can be here and then
I'm coming back to Royal next year as
well oh you I'm expanding dis the
dispatch duet that I did at the opera
house with that duet I'm making it into
a full ballet so I'll be here for that
and is you saying before there's
something pleasurable about working with
the new company a new set of dancers who
have their own very particular training
and their own particular expectations
love it I love it all you know it's all
it's all like oh okay it just changes
the dynamic it gets me on my toes and
it's all interesting to me the future
sounds really lovely I like this idea of
the future this is good but now we we
stop the present moment has to come to
an end but there is one last question
which is as you know Pam tanowitz why
does dance matter to you well I sort of
started saying it before but I really
think it is about how it's so different
from all other art forms that there is
no product that you can hold in your
hand and to be able to create something
that's happening at the moment and then
just is gone very ephemeral like to be
able to create that and have opportunity
ities to make experiences like that for
audiences for me I think is why it
matters and then
also the process that goes along with
it giving hope to all the late bloomers
that was such a lovely conversation at
least it was for me I really hope you
enjoyed it too you'll find links to
Pam's Works in our show notes including
the New York City Ballet season at slas
Wells in March along with links to
everything rad please do subscribe like
or review the podcast so that more
people can find why dance matters Our
Guest today was Pam tanowitz why dance
matters is made by the rad team of NE
Cary furnace Kesha Dodd and Katie Hagen
and our artwork is by beex glendening
and I'm really pleased to have given our
producer Sarah miles the perfect
acoustic she deserves I'm David Jays
take care and see you
[Music]
soon