In 2021, Naomi Smart qualified as a teacher from the Royal Academy of Dance. ‘Never thought dance teaching was an option for me but here I am – Deaf people can do anything.’ What are the particular challenges around ballet and dance teaching for a Deaf teacher? How did Naomi create a way of teaching that works for her and her students, and what advice would she have for teachers trying to make their classes as inclusive and welcoming as possible?
Naomi Smart is an RAD teacher based in London. She is also a writer and Deaf awareness activist, and is researching a PhD about community dance at Kings College London.
Find out more about the work of the RAD on our website.
Follow the RAD on social media and join the conversation with host David Jays:
Instagram @royalacademyofdance Facebook @RoyalAcademyofDance David Jays @mrdavidjays
Sign up to our mailing list to keep in touch!
RAD is an independent educational charity and does not receive regular government funding. Every penny we make goes back into the work we do. You can support us by either naming a seat as part of our Name A Seat Campaign or making a donation.
[Music]
here's something which I'm ashamed to
say I had never properly thought about
before today what might the obstacles be
to a deaf person who wanted to teach
ballet well it's an art form which puts
music front and center and teaching is
about knowing what's happening in the
room focusing on individual students
while also being aware of the whole
class maybe those things aren't simple
if you can't take hearing for granted
I'm David Jays and this is why dance
matters the Royal Academy of Dance
podcast today we're at the Rad's home in
London to meet naami Smart in
20201 naami qualified as an rad dance
teacher something that she never thought
was an option for her as a de person Nai
is also a writer and activist especially
on De and access issues and she's deep
into researching a PhD in community
dance when you meet her none of this
comes as a surprise she is so energetic
thoughtful self-possessed as she says
deaf people can do anything why wouldn't
she be a teacher I can't wait to learn
more about naam's journey through dance
and how she created a way of teaching
that works for her and her students what
advice would she have for other deaf
people thinking about a similar path or
for all teachers trying to make their
classes as inclusive and welcoming as
possible and why does dance matter to
namami Mami welcome to why dance matters
welcome to the rad it's wonderful to
have you here thank you so much for
having me yeah it's really exciting
really looking forward to this
conversation I hope you say that at the
end so most tweets as we know are
terrible and reflections of an awful
broken world but lovely tweet I saw from
November
2021 past my ballet teacher training
never thought dance teaching was an
option for me but here I am deaf people
can do anything and that was of course
you the moment when you'd become an rad
ballet teacher was it something that you
really hadn't thought was on the agenda
I really never had so my Deus had always
been sort of present in my dancing right
from sort of a young age I'd always been
aware that it was something that
presented some challenges for me as you
would expect the idea that I couldn't
necessarily hear things and parts of
music that I just wouldn't be able to to
pick out but also so in terms of the
sort of learning setting I was quite
conscious of my deafness and how that
might affect me if I did do something
like teacher training and yeah it was
actually a friend that suggested to me
that I take it up and and have a go I
already taught bits of modern so I was
already sort of teaching a bit and yeah
then a friend said to me I think you
could probably do your ballet teacher
training if you wanted to and I thought
why not well why not indeed that's
really exciting just to scroll back a
tiny bit you're I think since have been
uh death on your right side yeah exactly
right so I guess from pretty much your
earliest years you've been thinking
about how to navigate the world how to
find a comfortable path through things
is that second nature really yeah I
think it it permeates sort of every
aspect of my life there's sort of no
real element of my life where it's not
present so yeah it's something that I
I've really learned to navigate through
and live with and and find my own way of
doing things that works for me and has
dance always been part of that Journey
as well so I didn't start dancing until
um a bit later than some people I
started when I was about 10 so yeah a
bit later than some of the traditional
kind of you know two-year-olds and
things like that and I think dance for
me it's always been I don't want to say
an issue that's a bit of a a bold word
but it's always been present for me my
deafness so there's things that I've
sort of done to navigate that like I
always make sure I stand at the front of
the class for example so if I'm way at
the back I won't hear anything I always
have to let teachers know that I'm deaf
so that I can't hear Corrections when
they're being sort of shouted in the
middle of an exercise things like that
so there are ways that I've sort of
navigated it but it's certainly present
and was ballet the first classes was
that that traditional route or did that
come later yeah it was ballet um I sort
of started everything at once I sort of
took the plunge so I did ballet modern
tap Jazz all of that at once and
actually for a long time I don't think I
quite liked ballet as much as I do now I
think took me a bit longer to sort of
learn some of the technique fundamentals
in ballet that I just found when I was
younger really quite difficult to get my
head around but once I sort of
understood that I was really flying with
it I loved it absolutely could not get
me out of the ballet class I guess it is
quite a familiar story that idea that
you have to get past the early technique
before it can become really properly fun
yeah absolutely and I was very fortunate
that I was sort of chucked into a class
with some really brilliant dancers and
some of the people around me have been
dancing for years at that point they
were doing all sorts of like
extracurricular ballet as well really
fabulous dancers still really brilliant
dancers now but myself at the time
having absolutely no experience hearing
all these French words not knowing what
was going on I was just sort of doing a
lot of visually copying and I think yeah
the deafness comes into play there as
well I'm I'm hearing all these words
that I don't know and also that I
sometimes can't hear a lot of visual
learning happened in those sort of early
years and were your teachers from the
beginning able to make it an inclusive
setting for you I've had a bit of a
mixed bag at the beginning so I think as
a child I don't think I totally
understood what would help me the most
so I wasn't as easily able to advocate
for myself in these classes I had some
teachers who were really great and very
conscious of it and sort of took that
into their own hands would go away and
come back and think about what can I do
to make this better for Naomi and others
who sort of maybe just treated me the
same as every other member of the class
and that is fine in itself but I think I
I did need some extra thinking behind it
and all my teachers since and now even
have been really fantastic and it's a
big ask for a 10-year-old to have to
suggest the conditions that are going to
make things easier for them what would
you suggest now to a teacher who hasn't
perhaps thought about making their
classes more accessible more inclusive
what should their first steps be I would
say particularly for for every deaf
person it's going to be very individual
so one thing that's really helpful is to
have a conversation with a de student
and just say what works for you what
doesn't what would you like me to do is
this helpful is that helpful giving
options things like that but real sort
of base level things I would say an
awareness that death students are not
going to be able to hear Corrections
that are shouted out as music's playing
that's one that I know I do it myself
I'm a dance teacher as well so I do it
myself when people are dancing and I
sort of shout you know Point your toes
stretch your knees things like that but
as a student I know that I don't hear
those so it's about maybe making time
afterwards to go and speak to your de
students and say okay really good these
are some things that I would pick out
and just yeah making time and space for
those conversations with students that
are de and is there a different
relationship ship with music are there
particular kinds of music that will be
much easier to key into than others yeah
absolutely so from quite early on I
learned that I really rely on counts I'm
always that person that's at the front
of the class oh what's the count for
this what count do we do this you know
other people I think are a bit more able
to say oh you can hear it in the music
or I can feel it that doesn't work for
me very well and I also can't hear
particular instruments very well so just
as an example something that's like a
flute that's a bit more high pitch I
really struggle to pick that out so if
I'm dancing along to an instrument line
that I can't hear that sometimes causes
problems for me and I really have to
make sure I know the counts it's
something that's really quite important
to me I actually choreographed a piece
that was based around that experience
and it was just set to the beat of a
metronome to kind of illustrate that
point that I really am relying on the
pulse and the counts and in my head I'm
just one two three four constantly and
did you enjoy performing was that always
part of the pleasure of it yes always
I've absolutely loved performing I've
always felt very at home on the stage so
even before I was dancing I was doing
quite a lot of drama that's always been
a real second home for me and really
comforting for me actually which sounds
a bit strange I know a lot of people
feel quite nervous in that environment
but I've always found that really
comforting and really just a lovely
place to be I guess it's also a position
in which you can take charge of your own
environment you're there on the stage
it's up to you in a way there is a
comfort in that isn't there yeah
absolutely and teaching it sounds was
also quite early in the mix of things
you were interested in and engaged in
yeah so I again it's a bit of a tale of
oldest time but I started assisting one
of my teachers when I was about 17
probably and I really enjoyed it I mean
I was not really doing much at that age
I was sort of just present in the room
but then as I sort of went to University
I thought this could be something I
could do some assisting you know pick up
some extra money initially was the idea
and I just absolutely fell in in love
with teaching I really love it what's
the joy of that for you I really love
watching students progress I love when
they come in and they say you know I
can't do this and this is really
difficult and I say you know you will be
able to that's why we come to class we
practice and then just a few weeks later
they'll have it and they'll really get
something in a way that they haven't
before and just that absolute joy in
their face and the sparkling their eyes
when they're like oh my goodness I can
do this now this is amazing it's just
magical to watch and to see that happen
in front of your eyes as well is quite
exciting is it amazing it's absolutely
amazing it's the best feeling ever to
know that a student suddenly clicked
something and it's done they've got it
in their head it's amazing has dance
done that for you do you think in terms
of developing and growing and changing
the way in which you take up space in
the world I think it's definitely been a
really good sort of means of getting
messages across for me for example
things like choreographing pieces to do
with my deafness it's been a way way for
me to sort of navigate that and to share
that with the world in a way that isn't
just sort of you know me writing some
tweets or me you know doing some digital
advocacy or anything like that it's a
different angle that brings together
some real passions of mine in a way that
I think is really a beautiful
[Music]
process
[Music]
and when you were training to become a
ballet teacher here at the rad was that
experience what you expected were there
conversations to be had to make sure
that you were going to get the most out
of that experience I was in a position
then as an adult to then sort of have
conversations with teachers and to say
you know I am deaf and this is what that
looks like in an education setting I'd
already been to University at that point
and done my undergrad so I was already
sort of a aware of what that would look
like in that kind of higher education
setting and again the rad are really
brilliant with my deafness and have
really been great at listening and
taking on board things and understanding
what that looked like for me as an
individual and what did that training
give you in terms of becoming the best
teacher you could be because you'd
clearly done quite a lot already how did
that shape you one thing that I think
was really good is that it just sort of
really smoothed all the edges so
anything that I was a bit sort of oh I'm
not totally sure about that so so things
like I did a great module that was all
about sort of lifespan development and
the way that children develop as they
age and that was really fascinating for
me that was probably the most
interesting module I did for me just to
know at this age they start playing
together or this age they start to be
able to share and it really informed my
own dance practice and the sort of
methods that I could bring into the
classroom at different levels and what I
could expect from different age groups
developmentally and what age groups do
you teach is it the whole Waterfront the
the whole range so right from really
tiny tiny twoyear olds right through to
sort of 17 18 and we don't pick
favorites but what is your favorite age
to teach you know that's such a
difficult question and I get ask that so
often and it changes so frequently I
will go through a process where I think
oh I really love teaching my baby
ballerinas and they're fantastic and
they're my favorites and then just the
next month I'll be thinking oh but I'm
really enjoying teaching these like
really old intermediate girls they're
really great because I'm having
conversations that are really technical
with them and their understanding so it
flip flops from month to month but I
absolutely love all of them I don't
think I could pick one
[Music]
favorite one of the lovely things about
teaching if you're doing it for a while
especially in the same place is that you
get to develop a relationship with your
students that isn't just about them in
class you watch them grow from maybe 5
to 15 or whatever it is and that must be
a huge pleasure it is it makes me feel
very old though I must say sometimes
I'll I'll bump into an ex- student on
the street and they'll say oh I'm at
University now and I'll say really are
you sure I can't be that old surely but
it is really lovely to watch children
develop and and grow into dances that
have got so much ability and potential
it's really great to watch and then to
sort of reflect back and think oh yes I
remember when you first came into the
room and you were shy and you didn't
know what to do and you didn't know what
first position was and now look at you
and do you talk about deafness with your
students as well it's it's something
they're engaged in and know about I do
and it's actually got sort of dual
benefits for me so on the one hand it
actually really works behaviorally
because I sort of tell them I can't hear
when everyone's talking at once
everything gets muddled so actually my
students are really good at making sure
they lift their hands talk one at a time
so actually has been very helpful in
that regard because I don't get the sort
of Babble over each other most of the
time but they've been really
understanding as well so when I start
teaching a class I kind of sit them down
and I'll say I'm deaf that's what this
looks like I won't always hear what you
say I'm not ignoring you um just wave
your hand at me things like that and I
feel it's important to sort of open
space for questions and answers so if I
start teaching a a group for the first
time I'll leave a good 10 minutes for
has anyone got any questions is anyone
confused about anything and those can be
sort of any questions around deafness it
doesn't just need to be about dance but
I think that really Fosters a good
relationship between me and my students
where they understand what I need but
also what I would expect of them and
what are the questions that most often
come up sometimes I get quite cheeky
questions like oh were you you hear if
I'm whispering about you things like
that H I think I'll be able to tell
though you know um but I do get some
really quite thoughtful questions as
well so I have students ask me what does
that look like when you're performing on
stage really quite considerate questions
which I think is really really great to
see from my
[Music]
students
[Music]
I may me you are
multifaceted you are doing a PhD you're
an activist you're a writer especially
on disability and de issues is there for
you a thread that goes through all of
those things and dance and dance
teaching as well yeah as I've sort of
grown older and become more comfortable
with my sort of de identity that is
something that's really shown up
everywhere I think for a long time I was
doing sort of several different things
wearing different hats and thought that
they were very separate but I've come to
learn that two things that kind of flow
through everything I do are my deafness
and my love of dance my PhD is looking
at dance groups voluntary dance groups
so even there the dance is dance is
showing up and what is it about that
that's interesting you so I'm really
fascinated by Community Dance that's
something I think is really important
and I've got so much time for Community
Dance I think it's fascinating so what I
look at is voluntary groups where
there's no sort of set hierarchy so
whereas in a professional company we
might see you know ranks principal
soloists things like that or other
companies we might have pay grades that
differentiate people for example we
don't have that in voluntary spaces it's
a very open sort of democratic space and
I'm really interested in looking at how
people work together in that setting to
produce uce a finished product it's
really I well I find it really
fascinating anyway and are you still
dancing as well I am I dance with an
amateur Ballet company called Chelsea
ballet which is really great and what
are you doing at the moment at the
moment the next show so we have a show
every wintertime at the moment we're
working on several pieces that are
choreographed by several members within
the company which is fantastic I've been
lucky enough to choreograph one myself
this year that that's what we're working
on at the moment and anyone listening to
this especially someone who is deaf or
has a disability and might be wondering
about taking that private passion like
dance and extending it into a career
sharing it with with more of a public
what would you say to them I would say
absolutely do it I think it's very easy
to sort of hang back on the wh ifs and
say oh you know what if this doesn't
work or that doesn't work I would say
for me personally at least one thing
that's really helped me in this career
is being loud about about my deafness
and making sure that people know about
it and it hasn't caused any problems for
me yet which is
[Music]
fantastic and Amy here is the
fundamental question the final one which
has to be asked why does dance matter to
you what a big question I think dance
matters to me because of the community
that it Fosters I think for me dance is
about coming together with a shared
interest a shared passion no matter what
your sort of background what your
situation coming together and having
that shared love for something that can
be a real leveler across a group I think
that's why dance matters for
me smart by name smart by Nature naami
was a great guest in our show notes
you'll find links to her work and to the
rad and it's faculty of education and
you'll also be able to access a
transcript of our conversation I really
hope you found that conversation as
enlightening as I did please do like or
subscribe to the podcast it does help
other people who might enjoy why dance
matters to find us our guest today was
naami smart why dance matters is made by
the rad team of Neeve Cary furnace Kesha
Dodd and Katie Hagen our artwork is by
beex glendining and our producer Sarah
miles is also a very smart cookie I'm
David Jays take care and see you
[Music]
soon