Lecture 13 : Effective Stress_Effective Strain

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
good morning
students so welcome back
and today we will be discussing about a
relatively
simpler or smaller topic
we will be talking about what is
effective stress and what is effective
strain so far what we have seen is that
uniaxial stress condition
is easy to define in terms of when the
yielding occurs
and when it comes to multi-axial stress
condition
then we have
a little bit more complexity in defining
when the ending occurs okay so we saw
that it has to be defined in terms of
shear stress and that there were two
different models or criterions that we
called that we used one was the one
message criterion and the other was the
tresca criterion now how do we
use
this equation to define a unique value
or a unique parameter
why we want a unique parameter so that
we can say okay then when this unique
parameter reaches the critical value
then the yielding occurs and then we can
call this unique value as the effective
stress similarly
when the effective strain
when the unique
whatever equation we derive if we are
able to get a unique value for that
overall strain state and define it as a
effective strain and when this effective
strain reaches a critical value
we can say okay this particular amount
of strain causes yielding or this
particular strain is
what is uh implemented or has been
imposed on the material
so we want to have
a concept or a parameter which can be
used to define the overall state of
stress and that is what we are going to
call as effective stress and effective
strain so let's begin okay so first of
all
one question
that
may have been coming to you again and
again and although i have briefly
touched upon that topic but that may
have still been coming to you and the
question is
why does
shear stress only cause the
plastic deformation and not
the normal stress
and the answer is simple because
deformation occurs by movement of
dislocations and not by
complete tearing of atomic bonds so for
example here look at an example
and let's say you initially you had a
long bar like this
so let me
draw it like this initially probably it
this bar was like this and when you
applied a stress like this
then
there was slip occurring on different
planes and this is how the deformation
occurred
so
don't assume or this idea that the bonds
are getting broken
between layers complete the detachment
of bonds is taking place is not correct
what is actually happening
is that some kind of defect which we
will explain later on in couple of
lectures is called as dislocation
they get generated on the planes and
their movement causes the movement of
one plane with respect to the other
plane so here you can see this is one
plane and there's another plane so this
one moves in this direction with respect
to this one and therefore this has
caused a little bit of deformation
similarly this has moved with respect to
this in this direction and so on and all
of these will have this locations moving
and it's not that the overall plane
the bonds between the atoms in the two
planes got sheared at one moment if it
were to be there then it would have
required a much larger stress and
therefore the stress that we actually
require is much lower than theoretical
stress which also we will look at when
we introduce the concept of dislocations
and it is also the reason that last
class we saw that
in the
yield locus
some stresses higher than yield strength
or the yield stress of the material can
also be present and still in the
multi-state
axial stress
state and still yielding will not occur
that is still possible because what we
are talking about uniaxial uh not
uniaxial but normal tensile condition
but
when the shear stress at a particular
plane exceeds a critical value there has
to be shearing and there will be slip
and there will be deformation which
again we will understand later when we
get to the concept of dislocations so
for now it is sufficient to understand
that deformation occurs by movement of
dislocations and not by complete tearing
of atomic bonds and hence
normal
stresses are not as important
but
shear stresses
are critical
okay so
that
is the first part now moving on to
explaining the effective stress
now you remember when we were talking
about this one this particular criterion
which is the tresca criterion
so we said that when sigma 1 minus sigma
3 which is also a shear stress reaches a
critical value c that is when yielding
occurs and we showed that this is what
is equal to
y
so now
if we define this term
as
effective stress
okay so when you keep increasing the
effective stress
until the value it reaches a value y so
it will have
a very similar
stress strain plot like this
and
at this point
you can define that this is y so at this
point your sigma bar is equal to y which
means sigma 1 minus sigma 3 has reached
a critical value
y
now the other criterion we had was the
one message criterion
so this was given by this and we said
that when this reaches a critical value
this is
where
the yielding will occur
so now let's say if so this is in square
format now let's say if i had defined
this
as
or the square root of this as the and
sorry uh before
i go to there so in this condition we
know that
this c is equal to 2 y square
okay now if i define this or square root
of this as effective stress
meaning sigma bar is equal to
this
so this is also equal to this
or this will be equal to root 2 y
meaning if i had to draw the stress
strain curve and
we have not yet defined the effective
strain so on but on the x axis we assume
that it is a sorry effective strain we
have not yet defined it but let's say on
the x axis you have effective strain
so if we were to plot it
you know plot the one message then we
would see that
for the same material it would come out
like this i will write one message
elsewhere so that
it does not guess get hot watch
so in this particular case
this is where the yielding is occurring
and
so in this particular case this is the
point uh sorry this is not y this would
be root 2y
because we have said that when the sigma
bar reaches root 2y this is this
particular value that is when yielding
will occur
and this is your sigma bar which is
given by this equation
so what we see is that the plot
if we were to compare it with the
uniaxial tensile stress strain for the
tresca one it looks very much like the
uniaxial stress strain because here also
yielding occurs at y and in the uniaxial
condition also it happens at y
but when we go to one message then the
yielding here occurs as root 2 y while
in the
uniaxial stress strain condition the
yielding occurs as to y
and therefore there is a little bit of
offset so why not why not define
our effective stress a little bit uh
with a factor okay so
instead of this being the effective
stress why not define
effective stress as
and
now if we put the values over here which
is this under root item
has
this is the whole thing is c
so this is 1 by 2 c and c is equal to 2
y square so overall this
if you put in the values in terms of y
it comes out to y
and now this equation or this plot also
translates to same as on the left
and here also if you keep increasing the
effective stress now with this new
definition not the older definition so
this one was with the older
definition and this is new definition
so with the new definition we see that
the stress strain curve or the effective
stress strain curve for tresca and one
message matches not only that if you
look at only for the stress part right
now if you look at the stress part then
they also match with the uniaxial stress
strain condition
and therefore this meaning this
definition of effective stress looks
much more meaningful and that is how
effective stress for one message is
described and the reason of putting this
factor one by two is only this that you
can have a
good correlation with the uniaxial
stress strain condition
so this stress strain curve condition
the stress strain effective stress
strain curve
would be similar to the true stress
strain curve
okay so
but we have only talked about stress
part so far
okay now that is your equation so this
is what
would what is
meaningful if we use define
tresca effective stress as sigma bar
equal to sigma 1 minus sigma 3 and 1
misses effective stress as 1 by 2
factor and the whole term that we had
earlier okay so
that
is the effective stress now let's move
on to effective
strain now effective strain can be
defined as a parameter which is a
function of the applied stress
sorry uh of the
okay let me
rephrase that effective strain is not
something that can be defined in the
same way as the effective stress
effective strain
is
path dependent that is one problem
second is
that you cannot have a independent
definition of effective strain because
in the end the total work done must be
same and therefore the equation from
where we will get the value for
effective strain is the total work done
which is over here
so it needs to be defined in such a way
such that the incremental
work done per unit volume
is consistent
consistent meaning
if you take the
individual uh
direction principle stress principle
strain principle stress principle strain
in the three direction and that total
stress total uh strain in the
incremental format
then
these two should match so the
relation for effective strain must come
from this and this is the same equation
written when you have
the more general format for
the
the stresses so here it was in principle
stresses here it is written in general
format
and
in both the cases the total work done
assuming a incremental word incremental
strain should come to come out to be
consistent with each other and
this is where this is this is the
relation from where we will have to
define or derive
okay so
that is the equation that is used for
deriving the d epsilon bar however we
will not go through the
derivation and
you can look at chapter six
in again hospital and cattle
which deals with
effective stress and effective strain
and there you would be able to look at
the more detailed derivation
but for now it is sufficient to
understand that
the one misses
effective strain
is given by this relation
and similarly if you look at the tresca
effective strain this is what the
equation comes out to
so you remember we were looking at the
maximum shear strain so the effective
strain sorry that we were looking at
maximum
shear stress
in the case of trescas
criterion and therefore the effective
strain
incremental effective strain
for the tresca criterion turns out to be
d epsilon i max so whichever principal
strains is the maximum you take the
magnitude of that and you take the
and that becomes your effective strain
for the tresca criterion that is what we
will derive when we use this
constraint the equation given over here
on the other hand for one message we
will get this kind of relation so this
is again given in terms of principal
strains d epsilon 1 square plus d
epsilon 2 square plus d epsilon 3 square
times 2 by 3 so there is a factor 2 y 3
and this is
the
effective strain for the von mises
criterion and now one more thing that i
have already mentioned to you is that
strains are path dependent
okay so that is why all these equations
have been written in incremental form
because at the small incremental stage
this relation holds but when the
deformation becomes very large then
this relation will not hold because at
each stage the amount of deformation
occurring in different principle strains
would be different
however
if we assume
proportional strains
what does proportional strain mean what
it means is that b epsilon 1
is to d epsilon 2
is to d epsilon 3 remains constant
so you are deforming in a way
that at each stage the ratio of d
epsilon 1 to d epsilon 2 to the epsilon
3 remains
constant
then
you can
extend
this relation to this one and then this
becomes your effective strain relation
so here the d epsilon is now replaced
with the
strains so epsilon bar is equal to 2 by
3 epsilon 1 square plus epsilon 2 square
plus epsilon 3 square
and for the case of tresca this epsilon
bar translates to
epsilon i max
so this is these are the two definitions
of effective stress
and
effective strain for one von mises and
for the tresca so this is the original
equation and assuming that
we are
keeping d epsilon 1 to the epsilon 2 to
the epsilon 3 constant we get this
here too if we this is the
accurate relation but if we assume that
uh proportionates that are strains the
incremental strains are proportionate
okay so yes this is the term i missed
here if we assume
incremental strains are proportional
this is a better phrasing
that the proportional strains the
incremental strains are proportional
which means d epsilon 1 is 2 d epsilon 2
is to d epsilon 3 a remains constant
then this is what we get
okay so
now
uh let's look at a uniaxial stress
condition what will happen in the case
of uniaxial stress condition we have
already seen for the
sorry we have already seen for the
stress part now let's look at the strain
part what will happen to the uniaxial
strain
if we are looking at uniaxial stress
strain
curve
uniaxial tensile
condition
so here we remember that
the primary strain is happening in
longer direction in which you are
pulling the dog bone or your sample and
two lateral strains are taking place in
perpendicular directions
so
one thing
we have to first
keep in mind is that since it is plastic
deformation so d epsilon 1 plus d
epsilon 2 plus d epsilon 3 is equal to 0
but at the same time d epsilon 2 and
epsilon 3 are
same
and therefore if you put it here what
you will get is that it is
half of
b
d epsilon 1
and now if you put this relation
into
our relation for the
effective strain
then we have
two by three
and when you put it here so
the epsilon 1 square instead of the
epsilon 2 we'll put b epsilon 1 square
by 4 so this is also d epsilon 1 square
by 4 so these two become d epsilon
square by 2 and therefore the whole
thing is 3 by 2 d epsilon 1 square and
this 2 by 3 gets cancelled out and what
we are left with is d epsilon 1
so d epsilon bar
is equal to d epsilon one
for one misses
and if you were using the tresca
condition then also we know that d
epsilon bar
is equal to d epsilon
i
max
which would have been d epsilon 1
so even in the tresca condition we get
so this is giving us a very very
interesting
insight
about
stress strain
let's say we have
the stress strain curve
drawn like this
for a uniaxial tensile condition
now
how would the effective stress strain
look like
so the way we have defined
this also becomes the effective stress
and this also becomes the effective
strain because we have already seen the
epsilon bar is equal to d epsilon one
and sigma bar is equal to
so in the effective stress only one
stress is acting
which is the sigma 1
and
it is equal to y at the point of
yielding
by our definition
and therefore this whole curve
is
now also representing the effective
stress strain curve so
what we understand here is that
uni
axial
stress strain
curve
represents
effective
stress
effective
strain
plot
also
that is a very very
powerful and
insightful statement let's see how
so you have done a simple uniaxial
stress strain test and you have plotted
it like this
now if you do some other
multi-axial deformation
and you plot or you are able to obtain
the effective stress
and effective strain for this how would
it look like according to this yes this
is how it should look like
you do forging you do rolling you do any
other deformation
and
the effective stress and effective
strain plot that you would obtain from
there would look like like this or in
other words you can if you have obtained
the uniaxial stress strain plot you are
in other words also in possession of the
effective stress strain plot for all
other conditions
so that is the
usefulness or utility of
this particular statement
so now we have the stress strain color
for all different
multi-axial loading condition
that is what we have now okay so
now that we have understood the
effective stress strain properly
let's look at one example
the example is a circle of 0.25 inch
diameter
so
this is the diameter given to you
was printed on a thin sheet of metal
prior to stamping operation so this thin
sheet was stamped out
by operation and this is the diameter
0.25 inch after the stamping is
completed the circle has changed into an
ellipse okay so
before this is before stamping and after
stamping this is how the
circle looks like
now the major axis
is
0.325 inch
and the minor axis
is 0.275
inch
okay so both the axis have got elongated
a little bit only different amounts
determine the effective strain in the
region of the ellipse assume
proportionality of strains during
deformation
so here you are already given that you
can assume proportionality of strains so
instead of calculating the incremental
effective strain we can directly
calculate the total effective strain
so let's first calculate epsilon 1
which will be equal to ln
[Music]
0.325 by 0.25
and this turns out to be 0.262
epsilon2
we have ln
0.275
by 0.25
and this is 0.095
so we know the
true strain in this direction we know
the true strain in that direction and
therefore epsilon 3 which should be
equal to
minus of epsilon 1
plus epsilon 2 because it is a plastic
strain
is
equal to minus 0.357
and now that we have epsilon 1 2 3 we
can very easily calculate the total
effective strain which is equal to 2 by
3
epsilon 1 square
plus epsilon 2 square
plus epsilon 3 square
and you can calculate that this will
come out to be 0.370
okay so
what we see is that
the effective strain is equal to 0.370
and
we are assuming that once when this
original
diameter circle
of the thin sheet was getting deformed
then it was getting deformed
proportionately it's not that it was
deformed completely in one direction and
then the other direction then then then
this relation does not hold it means
that at every stage the amount of
deformation happening on this axis was
proportional to the axis the strain
happening on this axis so that is one
condition that has been assumed so as
long as during your deformation process
this particular condition is maintained
you can
use this relation and calculate the
effective strain
okay so this was a small topic and i
hope i have
conveyed to you
the concepts of effective stress
effective strain and also the importance
of the way we have defined it because
then we are able to utilize the true
stress through strain curve from the
uniaxial tensile condition as
effective stress effective strain plot
okay so with that we will close this
session thank you
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
you
