Lecture 19: Stress and Strain Fields of Dislocations

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
Okay, so welcome back. We have now looked at the basics of dislocation. Now it is time
to delve into the stress and strain field, which is what will give us an understanding
of how dislocations interact and how their interplay results in the overall behavior
of a material, particularly metals and alloys. So, from this point of view, let us start
with understanding what is called as Volterra construction. This is very useful from the
point of view of understanding the stress and strain field, which will help us get the
stress field around a screw dislocation. We will not be deriving the same thing about
an edge dislocation because it is a little bit more cumbersome, but nevertheless, I would
suggest you to look for a similar kind of derivation for the edge dislocation.
So, in Volterra construction, what we have is that there are two types of defects described
about a crystal. One is disclination. Disclination is when there is an angular opening and it is a
very different type of defect and is also found in materials. But this is not what we
are interested in right now. What we are interested in is dislocations. Here in the
terms of Volterra construction, you would see that it results in translation. So, translation
and that too away from the core because at the very core, you would not be able to define any
translation. So, let us say for the purpose of this, we have a cylinder. So, it is a material
and we cut a cylinder out of it. So, it is a single crystal, but it is a cylinder, a hollow
cylinder. So, this is how it would look like and let us say that we cut this along one of the
sides. So, this is now that you can open it. It is now you can two different surfaces over here.
Now, the way you open it will and we are assuming that it is inside a crystal. This is just for the
purpose of construction. We have taken it separately, but it is happening inside a crystal.
Now, the way you translate or rotate, depending on that, you can get different types of dislocations
and disclinations. So, first look, let us look at dislocation, which is of our interest,
where the changes take place by translation. So, let us say we have this as the x-axis,
this as the y-axis and this as the z-axis. So, if the translation takes place along
the y-direction, then this is how it will look like. So, there is a gap or opening over here.
This represents an edge dislocation. Now, similarly, you can have the translation along
x-direction, in which case this construction would look like. So, this is moved along
x-direction, here it is moved along y-direction and this also represents an edge dislocation.
However, if this translation were to occur, so you can clearly identify it with an edge
dislocation, there is a gap over here, it is like missing plane over here. Here again,
you can see that this is displaced. So, this is like a missing plane over here.
So, both of these represent edge dislocation. But now, when we see the construction,
when the translation takes place along z-direction, it will clearly remind you of
a screw dislocation. So, you can clearly see that if you rotate around this, the layer goes back
and this is how we had defined the screw dislocation. So, over here, this represents
a screw dislocation. So, both of these are edge and this one is screw. And this is the
particular construction that we would use to derive the strain field around a screw dislocation,
which can then help us also get this stress field around the screw dislocation.
And this construction has been used by Ashby to explain the stress field around edge dislocation,
which I earlier suggested that you can look at it on your own. It is a little bit more complex
than what we will look for the screw dislocation, but not very unreachable. So, this is for the
translation. However, if the opening were made in an angular way, now, what do we mean by angular,
we will see. So, you can have. So, what do we see here is that there is an angular opening.
So, the two faces are not parallel. Unlike if you go over here, when it was open, the two faces
were parallel. In this case, the two faces are like this. And it has a very different implication
or different effect when you look in terms of the stress and strain fields.
So, in something we will not discuss, but in disclination, this results in a strain field,
which is ever increasing while the strain field around dislocation where around a dislocation,
it saturates or it is bound. So, this is one type of disclination where you have angular opening.
The other type of disclination can be like this. So, again, you see the two faces are now
twisted. So, again, there is an angular nature to this. And in the third one, we can,
the third type of disclination can be like this. So, here, the two faces are like this,
they are opening like a jaw. So, that is, these three represent the disclination
with angular openings. On the other hand, we saw that these three we have translation which
result in dislocations. So, these two are in some sense similar, they result in edge dislocation,
and this one is a little bit different, which results in screw dislocation.
So, now, we understand Volterra construction, which can be very useful to understand dislocation.
From this, we will use this particular structure, and we will show the strain field around screw
dislocation. Okay, so, but before that, let us see why there should be a field or a strain field
or stress field around a dislocation. So, let us say you have an edge dislocation. So, here, I am
trying to draw an edge dislocation. And here is your edge dislocation. Let me draw it with a
different color, coming back to this color. So, clearly, you can see that there is an extra half
plane on the top or you can say a missing half plane on the bottom, which clearly means that
there is a little bit extra space over here on the bottom side, while on the top side, you have a
little tighter packing. And because of this, there should be compression over here,
and there should be tension in this, sorry, this is, yeah, this is right, because this will be
stretched in some sense. And therefore, there will be tensile forces. And if you were to later on,
well, when we look at the equations, when you draw it, you would see that the stress fields
would look like this. So, here you will have positive and here negative assuming this is
compression. So, negative is representing compression and positive is representing tension.
And these lines represent contours. So, similar stresses. So, these are much higher stresses,
but in opposite sense. So, this is how the strain fields and the stress fields look like for edge
dislocation. And similarly, for screw dislocations, which we will see in the next slide.
So, let us say we have used the construction, Volterra construction. Let me just pull these
figures a little bit. So, you can see that this is translated along z direction. So,
this is your z direction, draw it with a different color. So, this is part of the crystal,
which is rotated, which is translated by along z direction. And this amount will always be fixed,
which will be equal to Burgers vector, because that is how one dislocation is defined, where the
shift, if you remember from the Burgers circuit, it will be shifted by one unit,
which is what we define as the Burgers vector. So, this is equal to 1b. And let us again say
along this cut, we have the x axis and perpendicular to this, we have the y axis.
And let us say we are looking at some point xi, yi, which is at an angle theta from the x axis.
Now, if I were to unroll it, open this because it is cut and so if I opened it, how would it look
like? If it were completely no translation had taken place, then this should have looked like
this. But now we know that their translation has taken place. So, the actual line would look like
this. And we know how much it is moved down, this amount is equal to b.
And this point is somewhere over here. So, if this radius is, it is a very thin cylinder,
we will assume a constant radius, this radius is r and theta is in radians. Therefore, this is
theta r length and this total length is 2 pi r. So, now I will have to jump a little bit,
because I wrote this equation over here. Now, if we, you can go back to our slides and look at
how the strains are defined with respect to displacement. So, first, let us look at what
are the values of the displacement. So, we will see that along the x axis, there is zero
displacement, along the y axis, there is zero displacement. But along the z axis, when we are
talking about this particular point, along this particular line, there is a displacement and how
do we calculate that this is equal to theta into r by 2 pi r times b. So, basically, it is to be
proportionate, the distance of 2 pi r, the total displacement is b and at theta r, it should be
theta r by 2 pi r times b. So, we know the displacement at this point, which is now equal
to b theta by 2 pi or we can say that since it is theta, we can write it as b by 2 pi tan inverse
y i by x i. So, you can go back here and see this is theta, which is tan theta is equal to y i by
x i. Therefore, theta is equal to tan inverse y i by x i. Now, we know that E x x, if you go back
and look at the equation with respect to displacement, you would find that E x x, E y y,
E z z, E x y, E y x, all of these will turn out to be 0. However, what will not turn out to be 0
are E x z equal to E z x, which is equal to 1 by 2 del u z by del x plus del u x by del z.
Over here again, since del u x is 0, therefore, this quantity goes away, what we are left with
is only this quantity, which is equal to, so we have to differentiate this u z with respect to x
and what you will get is 1 by 2 times 2 pi b by 2 pi 1 over 1 plus y i square x i square
times y i by x i square. And this will turn out to be and this is minus sign over here,
I missed that. Therefore, it will turn out to be minus b by 4 pi y by x i square plus y i square
or in general, you can write minus b by 4 pi sin theta by r. But this is not the only
component which is not 0, we also have E y z equal to E z y equal to 1 by 2 del u z by del
y plus del y del u y by del z. So, again, del u y component is 0, but del u z component is not 0
and therefore, we differentiate the same equation with respect to y and what you will get in this
case by after all the simplification is b by 4 pi cos theta by r. Now, if the strains are very small,
we know that these engineering strains can be considered equal to true strains and therefore,
what we will have is epsilon x z equal to epsilon z x equal to E x z equal to E z x.
Similarly, epsilon y z equal to epsilon z y equal to E y z equal to E z y. And overall,
the strain tensor would look like for a screw dislocation. So, you will have this one 0,
this one 0, here you will have epsilon x z, here you will have epsilon y z, here you will
have epsilon z x, epsilon z y, 0, 0 and 0. So, this translates to this strain tensor
for screw dislocation. Now, we also know that sigma i j is equal to 2 g, where g is the shear
modulus times epsilon i j and therefore, what we get is that sigma x x is equal to sigma y y
is equal to sigma z z is equal to sigma x y, the components which were this whose corresponding
strains were 0, their corresponding stresses would also be 0. And the corresponding stresses for the
non-zero strains come out to y z equal to sigma z y equal to now you will have 2 into g multiplied
with all this. So, it comes out to 2 g v by 2 pi cos theta by r. So, very simple. Similarly,
sigma x z is equal to sigma z x equal to g v by 2 pi and there is a minus sign sin theta by r.
So, overall what we get is a stress tensor which has components similar to the strain components
5 zero elements and 4 non-zero elements sigma x z, sigma y z, sigma z x,
sigma z y and 0 defines the stress tensor around screw dislocation. So,
this I have also given here in terms of I have already typed it so that there is no mistake
or any mistake does not creep into it. So, you can clearly see this is the strain tensor,
this is the stress tensor, these are the quantities and these are the quantities
for the stress tensor, these are the non-zero stress tensor quantity and the values are over
here for the epsilon and the sigma. So, this is also epsilon. So, I did
allow one mistake here. So, this is the strains and this is the stress.
So, one thing I am yet to come at is now that these are the non-zero components what we see here
is that epsilon y z or z y is equal to b by 4 pi times cos theta by r. Now,
there is a cos theta term which means that the value changes with theta and that is it is not
radially symmetric. A dislocation line is a line. So, should not you are particularly in the case
of a screw dislocation it is a line if you look at it for the purpose of ultra construction we
may say that there is a cut at one point, but in real we do not say that this is where the cut is,
this is a dislocation line and it is same all across and the construction is same all across.
So, there is no starting point and in that sense there should have been a radial symmetry. So,
where are we what are we missing here? Similarly, we can look at the stresses,
we look at it and we see that it is a function of cos theta and therefore, it is not radially
symmetry. In fact, this is how the relation when you plot this epsilon y z. So, this is
epsilon x z or sigma x z and this is epsilon y z or sigma y z. This is how it looks like.
You can clearly see this is not symmetric and the clue or the key answer lies in the fact that this
is a cylindrical quantity, but we have been using Cartesian coordinate x y z which is
more suitable for a rectangular kind of object. Therefore, what we need is to translate
everything into cylindrical coordinates and which is what is done over here. So,
when you translate it to cylindrical coordinate we have only these two quantities as non-zero
e theta z is equal to e z theta which is equal to b by 4 pi r and similarly,
sigma theta z and sigma z theta and you can clearly see now it has radial symmetry.
So, our assertion or our understanding is right there should be radial symmetry, but for that
we need appropriate coordinates and that appropriate coordinate is the cylindrical
coordinate. So, in here now you can see this is what we have here is epsilon theta z or sigma
theta z and we do really get a radial symmetry for this. So, this is the overall stress field
and strain field for screw dislocation. Now, we will look at the stress and strain field
around edge dislocation. So, for edge dislocation you would see that the components which are
non-zero are very different from the components which were non-zero in the screw dislocations.
So, here are the again as I mentioned earlier we are not going to go through the derivation
and those interested can look for a paper by HLB which will describe this derivation.
So, here are the non-zero components sigma xx is given by this relation,
sigma yy is given by this relation, sigma xy is given by this relation and sigma
zz is basically given by the x and y combination of x and y with a factor of mu and therefore,
it turns out to be this and when you look at the stress tensor these are the 5 quantities which
are non-zero and what you notice is that it is actually inverse absolutely inverse of the
stress tensor that you obtain for screw dislocation and same can be said about the
strain tensor. So, if we look at the strain tensor if we had to write down the strain tensor for
the edge dislocation it will be very similar to this. So, these are the non-zero components
for the strain. Now, if you want if you wanted to plot how the sigma xx varies along x and y axis
and here this does not have a cylindrical symmetry. So, we need not worry about cylindrical
coordinates and in that case if you want to if you wanted to draw the variation of stress strain.
So, xx basically the normal stresses are acting along x and if we draw it like this where let
us say the edge dislocation is somewhere like this we know that in this particular case on the
we have already looked at it in just one glance that there should be compressive stresses over
here. So, we will put it as a minus sign and there should be tensile stresses which we will
put as positive sign and if you plotted the contours it would look something like this.
However, the fact is that all the plane on above this middle line or this line dividing the extra
or from where the extra half plane arises would have compressive strains and compressive stresses
and everything below this will have tensile stresses. If you look at the tensile if you
look at the sigma yy which is like this it is a little bit more complicated than this
and it will look like. So, this is sigma xx this is sigma yy this is roughly how
the major component would look like but this is not all there is more to it.
So, it would have if you draw 45 degree line. So, along this 45 degree line you would see that
there are some smaller loops and when we are drawing the lines you remember that it is a
contour line meaning those of constant stresses. Now here you would happen to have if this is so
this would be compressive. So, basically in this direction you will have compressive
and this one will also be compressive and this one will also be compressive
while this one will be tensile while this one will be tensile and this one will be tensile.
The third stress that we have is the sigma xy. So, for the sake of completion let us also look
at this one it will it happens to be similar to the yy only that it is rotated by 90 degrees
and remember that this is shear stress not the normal stresses like sigma xx and sigma yy.
So, these are called dumbbell type of structure or feature. So, it has a dumbbell kind of
distribution and here again we will have smaller dumbbells. So, whatever is the
stress direction over here you would see shear stress direction in this particular case.
So, this will be clockwise. So, this one let us say this one represents the clockwise shear.
So, this one will be the anticlockwise and if this is clockwise this one is also clockwise
and this one is also clockwise and this is anticlockwise then this is also
anticlockwise and anticlockwise and this is these equations are very easy to plot in MATLAB
and it is shown over here. So, this is the MATLAB plot which is shown. So, this you can
clearly see this is the compressive stresses which are reddish and the bluish one are the tensile.
So, if you go closer and closer to the dislocation there are lines that side looking dark otherwise
it would have become redder and redder and similarly over here you have the reddish one
which is compressive and the blue ones are the tensile. So, these three lobes are tensile
similarly here everything on the down bottom plane is tensile and here the shear stresses
the negative ones are shown by blue. So, these three lobes are blue and the positive ones are
shown by green lobes which are over here and since you have sigma xx sigma yy. So, this is
sigma xx this is sigma yy and this is sigma zz therefore you can also plot the hydrostatic stress
which would look like this. So, again this is where your dislocation is and overall you see
that there is a compressive hydrostatic stress on the upper side and tensile hydrostatic stress
on the bottom side. So, that is the nature of things. So, now we have
sigma xx sigma yy and this was xy sorry about this error this is shear stress sigma xy
and we see that overall we have three different zones which can be divided or obtained by making
45 degree lines like we drew over here or basically 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 different zones.
So, these different 8 different zones can be shown to have different stresses acting on them.
So, now we know that everything on the positive side in the x direction it will be compressive.
So, we can draw it like this and everything on below this line. So, here is your edge dislocation
and we have drawn 8 different zones where each of these zones are 45 degrees apart and you would
see that in one particular zone you will have one constant stress state although the magnitude may
vary but the signs would not vary. So, this is all compressive and over here we have all tensile.
Now looking at the sigma yy the normal stresses we know that these two have the compressive
and this one these two also happen to be compressive while these two are tensile
and so are these two. So, we can accordingly draw like that and then these are tensile.
So, if these are tensile and so are these two. So, these are the 8 different zones and now we
have identified the normal stresses on all of them. Now we can also identify the shear stresses
onto them. So, we said that this one is these two are the clockwise. So, let us put it like this
clockwise on the x direction and so that would mean anti-clockwise in the y surface. So, these
two have to be opposite so as to balance otherwise you can imagine that the object would start
rotating which we know is not supposed to happen therefore these two must be equal and opposite in
sense and whatever we have over here would be the same over here. So, this and this would be same
and it will be the very opposite in these two and in these two. So, this is how the stress state
around edge dislocation looks like because we have the sigma xx sigma yy and the sigma xy.
So, overall the stress state around the edge dislocation would look something like this
and that so now we have with that now we have the stress state around edge dislocation as well as
the stress state around screw dislocation. So, we will conclude the stress state over here and we
will come back and use this stress relations to calculate the energy of the dislocations. Thank you.
