Lecture 32: Monetary Policy II

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
[Music]
[Music]
welcome back so we were talking about
the the monetary policy design and
implementation and what are the
rules through which the monetary policy
should be functioning and we focus more
or less on the discretion and rules ah
under discretion we mentioned that you
have when you have a shortened decisions
and short term decisions when
they are undertaken and this
lead or impact the long term decision
then there it matters a lot
right and then we focus on the monetary
rules under that we mentioned about the
constant money growth rate
given by milton friedman and then we
focus on
the approaches that we have
non-activists and activists and we we
understood that
if you are going by either the money
constant money growth rate or the taylor
rule then you are going to
solve the problem of what we were
talking about the time inconsistency
problem so here here we will have the
same reference for this session so here
we will have the michigan book 2012
macroeconomics policy and practice and
here we have the
bank for international settlement
unconventional monetary policy tools and
then here we have the unconventional
monetary policy in times of covet 19. so
this we are talking about
right so here we focus more on here on
the description that what are
the scenarios under which under which
the discretion may be playing very
important role
now
lets talk about the new dimension which
is called role of credibility and the
nominal anchor
once i mention about so a nominal anchor
so it becomes really difficult so most
of the countries monetary policies are
decided based on either the single and
indicator approach or they go by
multiple indicator approach now in this
particular
session we'll be focusing on
how do you decide about the credibility
of the central bank what are the
approaches through which the central
banks credibilities are tested
and second is the role of nominal anchor
nominal anchor role becomes really
important that how you are going to
emphasize
so here we are talking about
so
economists have more or less agreed to
the viewpoint that there should be a
nominal anchor in the economy economy
should identify the nominal anchor that
which particular factor is more
important for the monetary policy stand
so depending upon the orientation as i
mentioned in the last session also that
based on the orientation of the
economies whether it is export oriented
domestically driven economy based on
that you can think about that which
particular indicator
can act as an nominal anchor
in most economies it has been found that
it is the inflation rate acting as a
normal anchor money supply
exchange rate so all these factors are
having a more or less
implications on the economy
if a central bank targets the inflation
rate of 4 percent it becomes a nominal
arc anchor which means that if
you have the
inflation rate acting at the nominal
anchor
then you can decide about what will be
the
the threshold of this nominal anchor
if the threshold is around four percent
five percent then it means that the
central bank central bank's monetary
policy
has to make sure that they have to
supply enough money in the economy so
that prices do not go up more than four
to five percent so whatever is the
target rate this is what we try to
understand
and
the second term that we are mentioning
which is about the credibility so if the
commitment to nominal anchor has
credibility and if it is digested by the
by the commoners it has some benefits
what are those benefits will be trying
to see from demand and supply
supply side shocks perspective
if
as i mentioned in the discretion part
even
that if the
common individuals in the economy
have
some expectations and if these
individuals digest easily that whatever
stand the central bank has taken to
control the money supply it is good
enough to control the
inflation then they will not expect
higher inflation which will further
solve the problem of higher wages prices
and further adjustment
if
the individuals are
not having any kind of ah
i would say
faith or the
or the central bank credibility is
really low they are
they are not having any faith on the
central banking structure how the
especially with regard to the monetary
policy stand then they will be forming
the expectation against the what the
monetary policy is trying to convey to
individuals then there you will have the
permanent kind of disequilibrium in the
economy and this may lead to deviation
so time inconsistency problem may arise
here
so credibility has lot of role so this
is the new term you may be encountering
so credibility matters and that's why we
find that
for the most credible scenario for the
central bank is to give positive real
interest rate for most of the
ah
most of the investors or i would say
depositors
if you are depositing your money in the
bank and if the nominal interest rate is
five percent inflation is six percent
your real interest rate is minus one
percent in that scenario you know that
you are going to get less of return on
your deposits and it is not compensating
you the rise in inflation then
this will create a very bad impression
for the central bank inflation
management which means the central bank
has not been able to convey to the
people that they will be generating
enough money or enough they will be
giving you enough interest earning so
that you your payoff is always positive
whatever is the inflation rate so you
will see that most of the central banks
whenever they see a rise in inflation
they also go for increasing the interest
rate because if real interest rate is
not positive if you are not getting good
good returns from your
your bank saving account or from savings
from post office or different sources
you will be moving to riskier investment
and riskier investments are not advising
for every individual so maybe when you
are young you may be invested you may be
attracted to invest in stocks or some
other but if you are older so maybe the
pensioners those who are they may not
like to taste the
[Music]
it is the saltiness of the stock market
and they may not be saving that much
amount or may not be allocating that
much amount what we see these days about
mutual fund and our different types of
equity management funds they may be
interested more in this
risk free kind of saving
if the risk free kind of saving is
having not enough return if it is not
compensating for rise and inflation then
this
will have a
lot of implications on the credibility
of the
the
the central bank and in even in the
recent scenario when we see about the
central bank even in india when we are
going to almost touch the inflation rate
of 6 percent or so
the banks are offering you 4 percent so
your real interest rate is actually
negative and this is one of the also
reasons that why we see we are seeing a
sudden surge in the stock market that
whatever happens in the economy even if
your economic outlook is not that great
you are moving towards the
the
ah
even your economic outlook is not good
your stock market is going up that
doesn't show any kind of a good
fundamental
underlying fundamental that your economy
is not in a good shape it is still
recovering but the stock market is
reacting in a different way right so
that also shows that the individuals are
feeling that they are not compensated in
the risk-free market so they are moving
their money towards the risk investment
so you will see that lot of ipos and you
have a lot of listings going on the
stock exchange because
here the low interest rate environment
also gives the opportunity to replace
the finances so there we talk about the
top and q ratios that if in case of low
interest rate environment replacement
cost of capital becomes really important
so maybe companies want to go for a
certain kind of replacement technology
automation or some kind of expansion it
is easier to do that in the low interest
environment because you can borrow from
the bank and whatever amount that you
are not able to borrow you can
borrow through the equity market
so credibility has wide implications and
and it has wide implications because it
mentions about the
the
the role of nominal anchor in the
economy if you are talking about a
nominal anchor then so here it it
mentions about the credibility in that
dimension
now here also we mentioned that one of
the reasons why nominal anchor is
selected because it also deals or it
also solves the
time inconsistency problem and it also
puts a check on the discretionary policy
that if you are having a particular
target
and if you are targeting your economy
that if you are targeting that variable
nominal anchor variable
then you may not face the discretionary
scenarios
because if you are efficient enough to
control your inflation with the given
target then you may not require the
discretionary so this will also solve
the time inconsistence problem there
will be a
synchronization between the short run
objectives and
long term
objectives
second is about the
there is also a check on the central
bank right so here you have public
scrutiny and and criticism that
everyone knows that central bank has to
abide by certain nominal anchor targets
and if the central bank is not going to
meet then there will be public scrutiny
there will be opinion there will be a
lot of newspaper writings digital media
reactions and as a result your
discretionary stand may be thwarted a
credible commitment to a nominal anchor
will help to anchor inflation
expectation as i told that if you have
the
people have a faith on the credibility
of the
the nominal anchor and even the central
bank then the central bank decisions are
also well appreciated
they are
taken in a right mood if the individuals
are taking their the central bank
decisions in a right mode then this is
going to also create a optimistic
scenario in the economy so as we have
discussed about the coordination failure
models under the uh under the canadian
setup
that how strategy complementarities play
important role so if you have a nominal
anchor playing a very significant role
then what typically happens is that you
have in the economy
one sector dependent upon another so if
you have optimistic scenario prevailing
in the economy you will have higher
linkages across different segments and
this will create ultimately the good
scenario for higher output so those
things are leading so which means that
you will have a smaller fluctuation so
software company they know that since
there is a good demand of hardware
products so it is better that my product
will also be sold and demanded in the
market so they will be also hiring more
labor and more level to produce software
because hardware market is doing good so
you have a strategy complementarity is
playing very important role here
and as we had also gone from multiple
equipment so if you have a more
optimistic scenario
less of pessimistic scenario then this
optimistic scenario will override in the
same way that we often mentioned with
the case of substitution and income
effects that we always examine
so let's understand here we have the
credibility and aggregate demand shocks
so here we are saying that at point 1
which is this yp so this is the output
and this is the inflation
right
if you have a positive aggregate demand
shock so this might be because the forms
are interested so you have a good
investment scenarios good consumption
scenario so maybe y is equal to c plus i
plus g plus n minus x that you always
mention so you think about that way that
either there is increase in i because of
the low interest environment so your
aggregate demand shift rightward so
positive shock demand shock shifts the
aggregate demand curve rightward
right and here we have then the economy
moves to point two but the ideal
scenario is that at here 0.2 we are
seeing that you have inflation increase
right once you have inflation increase
so i am talking about the positive
aggregate demand this side you have
inflation rate and this side you have a
aggregate output what we are seeing that
at point two here your aggregate output
has gone up but at the same time because
there is aggregate demand increase at
the same time the economy is also facing
the higher inflation
if the economy is facing higher
inflation then what typically happens is
that here you have a yp and pi t and
here you have a 0.2 which is leading to
here you have a y 2 and pi 2 right
so here we have moving the economy
to a
to if the individuals have enough
credibility with the
policy stand of the central bank
then
they will not be forming expectation of
higher inflation in future so economy
may turn back
towards the
the
equilibrium point which is one
but if the individuals are having a
limited i would say so if the
individuals are having limited ah
with regard to credibility if
individuals are having limited
faith on the central bank decision then
this will move further up
your aggregate supply moves leftward
right and this will create a scenario
with
at most high inflation and your
reduction in your output so instead of
thinking about pi 2 and y 2 which is
just because of the rightward shift of
the aggregate demand and that could be
because you have positive idea demand
shocks in the economy
instead of economy moving towards one
the economy has moved further because of
the less credibility individuals are
thinking about
a more of
more inflation in the in the future
because they have less credible ah
less credibility on the central bank
decisions
as a result the individuals may be
opting for more leisure they may not
like to work for more and then the
then the then the forms are also having
a very adverse scenario so that may
create a
shrinkage of your total output right at
point t at point three so three at point
three it is not
not good so if the central bank takes a
credible decision
here itself by
by increasing the rate of interest if
the central bank is taking the decision
by increasing the rate of interest then
this may create
adjustment in the output and the
inflation both and the economy may move
to
0.1 but if the credibility is low then
in that case economy may move to a
higher rate of inflation path
and this will further
shift of the aggregate supply will
further lead to decrease in output so
this is what we say about the positive
agreed demand shock that there you have
the
the
the role of the
credibility that how credible is the
source of information
second is about the negative aggregate
demand shocks once we have the negative
aggregate demand stocks may be negative
agreement demands of the shock that you
have inflation low consumption low and
all those scenarios so what we are
seeing that we are at equilibrium at pi
t and y p so this is what we have the
output the
long run aggregate supply is fixed here
right we are here we are talking about
short run so the analysis that we have
done here it is for the short run not
for the long run so long run agree
supply is here
the short run adjustment that we are
seeing with the positive demand shock
here we are talking about negative
demand shocks so here we have the long
run aggregate supply which is fixed
right here we have the aggregate demand
so because of this
less or negative aggregate demand shocks
the output has moved down so the
aggregate demand has shifted leftward
and this leftward shift in aggregate
demand here we are having the output
which is nothing but pi 2 and y 2 right
if the central bank takes the decision
here that there should be in lower rate
of interest and this will further
increase the money supply and investment
outlook will be better then the economy
may come back here people will not have
expectation the pessimistic expectation
here that the that the prices are not
going to be
that higher right so they may not be
reacting in that way
if the individuals are having the
positive
uh credibility or they have higher
credibility on the central bank from two
the economy may move to one but if they
do not have credible information then
the individuals may then the economy may
move to 0.3 which is a much higher
inflation rate and
having the
the
output further lower
so in case of negative aggregate demand
shocks what we can see is that there is
a lot of role of
expectations playing and also there is a
role of credibility so
negative aggregate demand shocks are
more crucial for the
monetary policy management because here
we are seeing that the aggregate output
is decreasing in each case and it is
decreasing much higher in the third case
where it is pi 3 and y 3 but here we are
seeing that here we are having the
long run aggregate supply fixed here at
least in case of positive demand shocks
it is easier for the central bank to
react and what we see is that we are
having the increase in output in both
cases though the third case it is not
increasing that much but here we are
seeing that in both cases here you have
a decrease in output and this creates
the
scenarios for the central bank how
credibility matters a lot especially
when you have a downturn in the economy
when you see negative shocks at that
time the stand of the
monetary policy play very important role
and you have to always think about how
we can
bring new additions into the this
particular type of models
second is about the aggregate supply
shocks so suppose if you have aggregate
supply shocks so here we are talking
about credibility and agree so if you
have aggregate supply shocks
arising in the economy so this could be
for
two to three regions
one is that
either the
crude oil prices have gone up so this is
also creating a extra pressure on the
on the price increase and further
inflation so here we mention about
with so economy is at this point the the
aggregate supply moves upward right
because of this so here we have the
the leftward shift of the aggregate
supply so at long run aggregate supply
we here we have the y p and here we have
priority
here we are seeing that because of the
policy stand monetary policy stand here
this is leading to increase in inflation
rate your output is getting smaller
which means that with high credibility
the short term aggregate supply curve
shift to as2 right with low credibility
the shorter aggregate supply curve shift
even further to as3 so if it is moving
further which means that if individuals
are not having enough faith on the
central bank decisions and if they are
not convinced enough
then your economy may permanently move
from two to three in the short run and
it will be very difficult to have the
scenario or reaching towards the
yp
the ultimate
equilibrium is yp and pi1 but because of
the supply shock and because of the low
credibility of the central bank the
economy may not be able to move from
three to one
two to one it is possible and why it is
not because
individuals are forming the expectation
based on low credibility if they feel
that the central bank
bank decisions are
not that credible then they will be
forming the expectation and these
expectations will further react to the
inflation wage and then then you have
the whole lot of disequilibrium
scenarios prevailing in the economy so
this is what we always try to mention
if you have a low credible information
then ah if you have a credible
information then what happens that this
equilibrium that we have disequilibrium
this may move to point one right which
is much easier but the moment has moved
to point three then it is very difficult
to revert back and the economy must
point with a larger decline in output
and a rise in inflation so this is what
we have the
credibility and aggregate supply shocks
in the economy that we always mention
now here we have the
monetary policy credibility aggregate
supply shocks then you will find that in
most of the cases during 2007-8
as compared to the
so this is the period we have about 1970
till 2010
what we are saying is that with regard
to inflation and unemployment so a
mentions about inflation
and b mentioned by unemployment you will
find that post 1995 the central bank i
would say credibility with regard to
managing inflation has been a good so
there has been improvement here also we
can see that even post uh 2007 oil shock
the economies have almost tried to
manage this so this is what we try and
mention about that inflation rate
it has not gone up but here if you see
during this part 1979 shock and
1973 oil shock the inflationary
scenarios were not having that much
credible
and after that
the central banks have worked on
credibility and because of that they are
in a much i would say a safer zone
such type of
disequilibrium that we saw because of
the 2007 wild shock we have not seen
that much so this these are showing the
reactions of the central bank with
regard to the monetary policy
so here what we saw from the demand side
and supply side so monetary policy
credibility is capable in stabilizing
inflation economic activities when faced
with positive negative demand shock in
the short run so this is what we have
mentioned here right this talks about
short run adjustment this is the long
run
right and here the money monetary policy
credibility can produce better outcomes
for
both inflation and output in the short
run when faced with the negative supply
shock this i am talking about here that
how we are seeing the adjustment here
with regard to output so your y-axis is
aggregate output
sorry your y-axis is aggregate inflation
rate and here you have x-axis your
aggregate output
there are different approaches of
dealing with credibility so how central
banks go for
dealing with
certain types of credibility scenarios
so here it is the the nominal anchor
so here we have the approach one
inflation targeting so here we have the
first we are talking about keeping
inflation under control
so here
what should be the approach of dealing
with so the first approach which the the
economist always mention
is about the inflation targeting
in case an inflation targeting how they
do it so in case of india if you go on
the reserve bank of india website there
you have monetary policy report
what does this report say about the
monetary policy report mentions about
how
what will be the direction of the
inflation in future so they will be
having some short run or some kind of
medium and long term targets of the
nominal anchor right so in most
countries you have the inflation
they go for public announcement of
medium term numerical targets for
inflation they will be coming up with
some reports they will be highlighting
implicitly
the stand of the monetary policy in
future so if you read between the lines
of those reports then you will be then
you will be able to understand inflation
targeting should be part of the
intuitional commitment as long as
long-range strategy to ensure price
stability so this is what they have done
that they have come they have set up the
committee
for example in india we have the
monetary policy commission committee
they target the inflation target and
this is for next five years and which
means that the country will be
targeting that kind of inflation
for
the next five years and based on that
they will be having learnings and those
learnings will be further accommodated
for next five years and then they will
see that whether we should go for higher
nominal target or we should go for
nominal
lower nominal target
then here you have multiple indicator
approach so unlike you are just
targeting the inflation that's not the
right way there are different variables
playing important roles so maybe your
economy is also facing pressure on
exchange rate because if your economy is
having the
oil import from outside then this oil
import may have passed through to your
exchange rate and this exchange rate
pass through
may further
have the implications on the money
market financial market so in order to
understand the
exact role of monetary policy it is
always good to follow the multiple
indicator approach so in most of the
countries they have gone for multiple
indicator approach
then here you have the transparency in
monetary policy through proper
communication with general public and
and financial markets so these days with
the help of certain machine learning
tools and you have different types of
document trading mechanisms through
which we can read the
the tone or the
the communication skills of the central
bank so how the central bank is
communicating so people walk in these
areas and they try to find out so
central bank will always come up with a
small write-up some notes through which
they try to convey to the
to the commoners that this is how the
central bank is going to function so
maybe the auctioning of different repo
auctions may also give you the signal
increase accountability of the central
bank for attaining is inflation
objective so if the inflation objectives
are
if you have accountability higher then
this also creates a good scenario for
higher credibility so maybe
if the central bank is more credible so
we are finding that in most of these
countries inflation targeting countries
are new zealand australia canada norway
sweden switzerland united kingdom brazil
india chile then you have a czech
republic hungary israel mexico peru all
these countries are having the inflation
targeting mechanism inflation targeting
mechanism works as a nominal anchor and
then further it creates scenario
favorable as i shown as i have shown
here that from 2 to coming back to 1 and
from 2 to going back to 1 this is
directly linked with the credibility so
this is how it matters here that
inflation targeting becomes really
crucial to understand that how certain
mechanisms are
really crucial to
to to form the expectations to control
the expectations so most of the central
bank they also conduct the household
survey they try to find out that how
individuals are trying to
uh trying to procure the information to
form the expectation about futures so if
they are forming expectation about
future based on just past then how the
central bank should be taking whether it
is a rational expectation whether it is
adopting expectations so what we can so
let me summarize what we have done today
so in in the beginning we talked about
the the different roles of the
credibility and nominal anchor and then
we we are now working on different
approaches through which the central
bank should be
dealing with the higher inflation or
the better price stability scenario so
in the next session we'll be talking
more about this and will be taking ahead
and will be also looking at india
situation where we stand so i am
stopping now and thank you thank you so
much for your attention
[Music]
[Music]
[Music]
you
